Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

Mishna Berura Daf Hashavua Siman 79 Seif 4-5 Does Dog Excrement Have the Status of Tzoah?

91 views
Rabbi Daniel Glatstein Official avatar
Rabbi Daniel Glatstein Official

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

okay we're continuing in you can't go into shabas without knowing about how could you possibly go into shabas without knowing these it's going to be nice weather you're going to be walking outside what else do you do when you walk outside you think and learning so the most for this coming beautiful shabas K that we haven't had in 20 seven years and we're not going to have it in quite a while have that in the 17th century we went 44 years without uh without listening to it so you need to know what to think about when you're walking in the street of a dog or a pig if they put hides in it you distance yourself like from Adam I could still smell not remember I could still smell when I was in Fez at the Tannery the odor of the Tannery is the strongest odor that is conceivable to mankind so if you put highs in it then it has but if it's and the guy St a criminal for not cleaning up after his dog and she he should be locked up still it does not have a of it's like of any other animals wild animals or Birds that's very relevant to me if I can I like to walk every day and my route is I walk up Branch Boulevard I can't give more information but I end up in a park and uh in the park there are a lot of goose and the goose they uh they they're droppings along most of the road but what if I want to learn while I'm walking it's not a problem does not have a din ofas of as long as it doesn't smell it doesn't smell there's no smell so bottom line is right this is the the question everybody wants to know the of a k if you put then it has otherwise it's like as long as it doesn't smell now it's interesting when it's on the street it doesn't smell if you once you step in it and you bring if you step in it then and you bring it into the house then other people are going to smell it so maybe that activates it let's see what the says you know that it smells you don't have to check you don't have to check now what is a says people are it bothers people now we mentioned before a tatun anybody know what a tatun is tough tough R none any Israelis someone who has a illness that they can't smell a tatran the said earlier that you have to go to someone who could smell what if you have very strong smell and you smell soya much further than most people the car Le says you have to just go from where the smell stops for you cuz for you it is not okay something that naturally smells badol it's not called if it smells bad naturally that's then it's not something that smells because it's decomposing only that smells because it's decomposing now what about sweat the B Bar says you could be make so if let's say a guyy sitting next to you he hasn't showered in in years they're people like that they're not like regular civilized people that shower once a month they don't they haven't showered in years yeah so it's not considered you next to them what about someone who has bad breath says it you don't have to distance yourself for now you may have to anyway because you know it might but Hally you don't have to however the and the um if it says no if somebody has bad breath you have to be like okay what about if you're near a butcher shop and it is the smell is like decomposed meat so in you should not make a there what about a wine seller where there's a bad smell from decomposition Simon he brings holds you can say sh there okay that's we that's a discussion V um if they have a bad odor then they're like you have to go four away from where the smell stops from behind you so that's very interesting if the dog does not smell there's no even of it could be in your would be even if the smell stopped once it once had a smell it has a the is that the M holds that ifas smells it's a problem as is our old if they smell says no you may think they smell even if they smell a little bit when they come out it's not such a strong smell it does not have a of and you don't have to you only have to distance as far as you can smell it and that's how you say it again you again you make opin don't have thata it does not have a din of even if it smells coming out the bottom line is the of a dog I don't think generally uh smells and and one does not have to worry about saying or thinking even in its presence and we'll do the of a donkey which is soft after it came back from a trip the or the of a c what's a weasel maybe is that what it is look it up and a carcus has of human feces so this this is interesting of a donkey or a cat now you you usually won't see a cat's soya lying around they're usually pretty clean about themselves but it it smells as someone is going on the road even if you see off in the Horizon if you don't smell you don't have to worry oh maybe it's not from a dog maybe it's from a donkey if it's near the city you have to you should be concerned now I want to point something out what about horse the horse smells yeah I mean uh even though the MRA did not make a separate category here I don't know maybe their horses were different our horses it's it smells so if you're you know you're behind the police you know uh horse and there they have stuff on the ground that's definitely a problem that's what I would say maybe they're concluding they smell bad if let's say you give it the smell test it doesn't smell so bad it's still do we talk about of a horse anywhere I don't see I'm not sure why did they not have horses it's been real have a wonderful chabas um and we'll see you Monday B will continue in Sim look up about horses good Chas everyone have a safe trip call Tough literally put down