Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

Mishna Berura Daf Hashavua Siman 66 Seif 4 Can You Get an Aliya In Middle of Shema

40 views
Rabbi Daniel Glatstein Official avatar
Rabbi Daniel Glatstein Official

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

okay good morning everyone we're learning that was reading and they call him up for so what is this what does this guy do there are those who say that he interrupts some say he does not interrupt is like the opinion that he does not interrupt any here any he aspiring okay says what would you say he's middle of should he interrupt for his Al or not or he's middle or whe whether he's in middle of the the same applies that between he should not go up even if they call him up even if they call him up for an alyah he should not go up why but onab where you're allowed to be then it would be permitted for him to go up um all the more for sure doesn't goes without saying the guys the midd no continue make believe you didn't hear them okay some say you're mck why because of honor to people the and their meaning if you're allowed to be certainly should be able to according to this even if they call to be you so why is the talking about they call the the reason why picked a case of is for the that you're not in other words there two one opinion is one opinion is the opinion that you're it's because we make if you're certainly then would come out even if you're why do we talk about a case of a because of the case of because of the what's the reason for the the their is why since you're not being how is it to the the reason why I'm not being m is because I'm being the but he's a aren't we worried that people are going to question his lineage if he doesn't go since the reason he's not going up because he's middle of sh nobody's going to say oh maybe his his father has some kind of uh uh question about his lineage people see where he's up to everyone's going to know that this is the reason and even could take his place if there is no other H let us begin the next M briefly that you're not says even though is like the second by the way is the the first is the so even though the says that you're not right which right is like the first even if they called it and he's in middle of what about if they call the guy up for M he could take the alah and if the reads he could read the and if he needs to bench go he shouldn't bench go by the way I got a very interesting sh I don't know the answer to on just on topic of go do you remember last week in par we spoke out from the that didn't when he came down from cuz if you're if you went somewhere because commanded you to do it and you're doing a Mitzvah you don't bench when you survive didn't bench after so sh is a soldier who's fighting in Gaza if you're going to say it's a because the r says even if you're not even if you don't say uh just simply the rambam holds that protecting Jews from so it's a mitzvah for him to go he survived the war does he Beno when he comes back according to the good sh right fine I don't know the answer even if they called him as and he's in middle of and even though there 50 other next to him even though we could get another were because of what if what about to go up for the brings in the name if there other he should go out if he's the only he and he should try at least to finish the very least theki says no even if there are hundred other him you go up in middle of okay unless you're in the don't change this this is you know people get very uh sensitive about this minog the minog is you do go up so you're middle of ma whatever it is you came late you were on a flight you came late you're middle like it could happen I think uh when we when we landed in Panama we came the flight was late we came into a big sh there was one minion we were behind because we arrived late luckily they they they didn't give us an Aliyah but if they would have then then you would have to go up you don't go up yeah but the min is that you do go up so don't get the wrong impression many people say breaks breaks it's only if there is a in the that is brought in the and the is the other way but if the is like not like that then you can follow but not St your grandmother a guy once told me his Min to talk by daving because his father spoke by daving and the answer is theim are going to take this guy and their Minh is going to be they're going to be no to put him in the same place upstairs where his father is I'm sure he did Other M and he'll get out but that the bring is you know the road to a hot place is lined with many many beautiful minhag so you have to know what is a minhag a minog is something that you're no based on a of just because your father did something that doesn't necessarily have any bearing on the way you should do it okay that's our uh in line of uh it's in all seriousness but also at least if you smiled you'll be even though it doesn't start yet but he ends off he says which is have a great we'll hold it over here and we'll pick it on Monday yeah no on the topic of I didn't get a chance to listen to sh would that mean that any for any you should have been person flies to he's flying for many reasons I mean all well actually going to is maybe is a you know or is it only when you get NAA but they risk their life yeah he he says it applies to say they didn't have to bench goal cuz they had to give up their life I don't know I don't know if we we we I I just brought that more as I don't know if it's think look into it I never heard in the records of the SCH over there they they don't have a record that he gave after after the that he made we don't have any any record that yeah