Mishna Berura Daf Hashavua Siman 62 Seif 3-5 Your Ear Must Hear Your Mouth Saying the Words Of Shema

okay good morning everybody we're continuing Sim you need to hear with your ear what you say with your mouth if you don't hear it with your ear you're still provide that you do emit it with your lips so it needs to be audible enough to hear it that seems to be okay um it needs to be audible if it's not audible then um it sounds like you're not y question so that means you need to say it loud enough that your own ear could hear it if you say it quietly that your own ear can hear it you're not um but you do have to say it but if you think it what if you move your lips and you don't actually emit any sound does that anything is that is that hear her so we get one thumbs down let's see the M this requirement that you need to hear with your ear is a rabic requirement this is interesting the r it holds it's but it's only that's a very interesting get there no you biblically need to be able to hear it but if you don't you're still what about that you're supposed to say the says still you need to be able to hear with your ears just not loud enough that other people could hear [Music] it what if that's what we asked yeah say it's Mish no I don't I don't know if he's say I don't know if they're reading it no no no no no when says it's considered I don't think he means you're moving your lips and nothing's coming out because he brings you need to what's the difference between and not it sounds like there's a getar meaning if you just go like this you know like the way people talk by middle of daving you know they so I don't think that's called the debore I don't think that's I don't think anybody would say that zore but it sounds like there's a g there where you move your lips some hot air is coming out but it's not Mish making a sound it's not just you can't hear it it's not like it's not really making a CO that is is debor but just to move your lips I don't think they would say that that's debor um let's see the brings that if you don't hear it you're not it's because the and the Riff and the shter say it says which by the way we don't hold to that that's the Dr of the other we don't hold we okay by the way the important thing here is for that many people they dve in very quietly and their own ear cannot hear the words they're saying actually most people dve in that way and you're not you D in that way most people are saying so quietly that their own air cannot hear it now that works for me because you're not bothering me but if you want to be you know I'd rather have that guy sitting next to me by daving than the guy who you know he says it very loud that his ear could hear it and the ear of a guy in the in haras could also hear it so you know but in in terms of my comfort level I'd rather the guy who you can't hear he can't hear what he's saying the only thing is he's not so yeah for you need that your own ear should be able to hear what if because of an illness or another you read what do you mean we hold we'll see in the miss and even you should do this if it's in a place that's not completely clean you're not able to clean let's say you're in a place of so you can say the words so you should think it it can't be completely dirty you're not allowed to think about learning in a dirty spot so let's see what the what the means that if there's a or another and you read it doesn't mean completely we hold thinking is not like saying it what it means is if you can't say it you should try to think it God will give you reward but you're not really so what if like this the doctor tells someone you cannot speak for the whole day they have an issue with their throat the doctor says he can't talk today so said otherwise you're going to lose your voice so says you should think I don't you have to be no you you don't have to give up more than a fifth of your money to be your voice is an important thing so you would not have to say sh but an would be from someone else with now we had earlier that it's not P um but but let's see we had before that it's not what what probably a better option it's a better option and most most say you could use right we just had it where do we have [Applause] it where do we have it oh look in says okay fine what about this is interesting sh is better than her so there's a who says that even if you say is it's only but so therefore it's not okay v um now now like this so therefore the guy has an he can't say the words of sh he should think it when fines you have to read it again by the way this is an interesting one let's say somebody misses the you should still say the third para you have to say the third para CU very interesting somebody was Ill they woke up late say what's the point of saying sh at least the third para would still be direct so fine but right I think I think this is saying even more right because you're right in other words let's say you miss and you can't say Ms you're saying you can't say Ms you should still say the third Para he saying if this man didn't pass so then you have the okay meaning um the said if someone has an illness they should think on some level you should do it if you're in a place that's not clean let's say someone's thirsty at night it will be impossible for him to wash his hands and make a meaning this that the is saying that if the holds that if you have and you can't say you should think you should do so if you're in a place that's not clean so says the Taz let's extrapolate you're you're in bed at night you know you're in Russia it's -30° you can't go outside and wash your hands the the water is ice you know and you can't even get out of your covers and you can't even go to the bathroom so what are you supposed to but you're thirsty so you have to suffer no think the braa but the what do you mean get up and wash your hands it's not like someone who's sick or extenuating circumstan ain't done in you can't compare case where there is an and learn from a case where there was no let's say there's not enough water to wash and to drink or it's freezing why can't you wipe your hands I would say like this what if the guy has to go to the bathroom it's 4:00 a.m. he has go but he in Siberia he ain't getting out he's not going to the bathroom so what does he do is he allowed to be Mahar the I mean I mean [Music] uh if you know your hands are dirty it will still help to wipe them so the says you can't think the bra so wash your hands you know you can't wash your hands wipe them by the way this whole scenario that we're talking about that you're thinking the sh the the ra says as long as it's not matam so what what in the world is the case it's mat but not matam what's a case that it's and you can't say the but you're allowed to think it what what is the scenario if it's you're not allow to think it if it's not you're allowed to say it so the says we're talking about the of some people are clothed some people are not there you're not to speak but that's how the learns this it's a very bizarre situation I guess and what you remember you didn't say sh so why don't you just step out you know there's not enough time Turn Style Turn Style there's no there's one way okay um you should not think the the or you should just think you're obligated and you're not able to fulfill it you should be pained that you're not able to will see in your heart to give you reward for your thoughts those who drink in a bath house are not doing properly they're even her you're not an on for drinking there the writes that if someone wants to drink he should make the the or in the where nobody's there or go into the Mikvah over Thea cover your head and be M to drink in the okay let's hold it over here have a great day have a good chabas we'll pick it up Monday in oh let's just sorry when he says the word you should say it out loud so that the call hears and everyone is M together and the adds even someone who's not daving now has to answer with them like we say later and he says in order to the afterwards um the with a Biblical recitation of sh so one should try to say with the and if you're answering with the you should have in mind not to be then okay we'll hold we'll pick it up next week in Sim have a good shab yeah when you can be do recording stopped why that's