Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

Mishna Berura Daf Hashavua Siman 59 Seif 2-3 Saying the Kedusha of Yotzer Ohr Without a Minyin

58 views
Rabbi Daniel Glatstein Official avatar
Rabbi Daniel Glatstein Official

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

progress okay good morning everyone we're continuing in we're learning Sim midle of basically the m is talking about a guy who during Shak he started saying the of and we learned that you need two you need to make sure of two things number one you need need to make sure the main body of the is and that you conclude with if you ruin either of the two if if either the main body is or the conclusion is then you're not so we're up to where the said the same thing would be if you didn't say only if you finished say if let's say you said the whole the only thing is you made a mistake in the conclusion because you did not make a in the on the light that begins to illuminate on this day [Music] okay you remembered and you said you remembered and you said you're you're in other words you said the main body correctly you said you also the only thing is you ended off you fixed it by saying other words like this let's say the guy he said the the whole correctly and the only thing is he's spacing out and and he ended off and he looked around the sh and one guy was shcking tobacco one guy was on his phone another guy was uh counting theak on the pushka another guy was I don't know what looking at the par sheet that they gave out from from 10 years ago and then a minute later he woke up and said hey he's not he got he start from the beginning that's it he has to start from the beginning he would not be y what if like this the guy ended off incorrectly and he started middle of he said hey I said what does he do now then should not interrupt he should just end off in order of the and then he should say before wow so he's basically going to first say and then he's going to say now I would ask the following question on that so basically you could say the out of order right so you'll end up saying I have a RAB and then you my question is like this shouldn't begin with a well you say well it's it's supposed to yeah but that's only if you say y first but here you're you messed up your y so y doesn't count so now you're allowed to do that basically first say and then then aren't you ruining the because it's not starting with unless it's not by the way the brings Ki said that even if let's say you said and you're still you're done saysi that's called like the Mish says that someone forgot that once you start the word it's considered a new uh you start a new thing let's say a guy did not say the before for whatever reason you could say it after or if you didn't say for whatever reason for you could say it uh before if you didn't say it before you could say it after daving that's wherein okay the ends off if you end it off basically like this if a guy concluded correctly he started correctly even though in the inter he started saying so the very kindly gives us a uh synopsis of this C says here's the executive summary there are two things that are number number one the opening of the or the middle the beginning and the middle by the way says what if a person skipped the K of he says your it's a it's not the the is to thank hem for the light and B the second thing we need is you should know the same thing would be by so you want to make sure you start correctly the middle you say and you end correctly um and the says if you finish since you start with if you're like this even if a guy said you might say okay he's now we don't say he's but rather it is um it is okay ready for let's begin some say some say the K of an individual could say it because it's just a story what's the story you're saying a story of what the say some say that an individual skips it and it could only be said some say that a y skips it and it's only said you should for it that if you're ding you have to be concerned maybe you shouldn't be saying it therefore if you're not ding with a minion you should be L otherwise it's a sh if you're allowed to say it okay so we have the opinion of the in the name of the raban SAS and the rash and the rambam they say you're allow to say theim the it's only but some say um now the the first is the CH the second is that you have to skip it who is that that's the ra himself the and others the therefore says you should be and say it has spread like the first that when you answer this K you answer it out loud says so what should you say should you skip the whole P you say according to the second you just say the word if you came late and there's a minion in the sh you're just not daving with them everyone agrees you could say the the is we are make regarding this and you could say the the says no that if you're doubting by yourself you cannot say it yeah but the r says the get to say it the correct thing to do is if you're ding you should lay the so we're not going to move from the we're going to say it but because in deference to the who says the is not like the the is like the the to say okay you know let's let's finish off when you answer K you say it this K you should be sitting down so if you find yourself you're a guy you like to Pace some people they like to Pace pal have a seat you should be sitting for KRA now let's say you're middle ofra and you hear aor saying Kad of you're not allowed to answer you do not answer middle of to this K that's what the writes now it's very interesting that um the Mish says it's correct that if you're ding to Sayes you don't have to use the regular trap if you have a niggan that you learn with you're allowed to say it in that nigan cuz the I inan is that kadus you can only say with a minion so you want to be you want to show you're not saying kadha you're learning so you could say it in your learning uh nigan question guy's in the middle of su he's not worried he he feels he'll be able to start with theore but he wants to know should he skip to be able to say this Kad with theki says no no it's not a reason to skip okay out loud you say when you're saying the you say quietly the says there's no even to say it have a great day have a good day why should you look at sitting I'll cabala the brings theaba okay