Mishna Berura Daf Hashavua Siman 32 Seif 18 A Reish Made As A Daled Must Be Completely Scraped

this store class is brought to you by torahanytime.com we're continuing in Mission we're learning Simon base we're middle of Sith this is on page mem Zion daf mem Zion you made that little bump on the right the top right hand side foreign it's not enough just to erase the leg oh yeah or the roof via commemoration then write it like a race whether the roof or the legs was made in a state of disqualification of the grosham you need to race both of them so let's see what this means or above that you may like a race and all the similars to any similar scenario where you made it in one writing so it seems like a rage that you make like a dalid because I would have thought it's two parts first you make the top and then you make first you make the roof and then you make the leg apparently it's one motion even though in this case you made like a dollar so it's extending more to the top right so how would that be one motion going down let's see come in Dallas let's say the roof of a strip a Final Cut that the roof let's say you made it's a long Huff the long cuff has a very long leg the leg is much longer than the roof but let's say you made the roof very wide until it looks like a doll at a race are not careful about this okay so here are the uh the Macabre is saying that the race that was made like a dalid you should be macmur it's not enough just to scrape the leg or the roof alone because both the roof and the leg were made of soul so it's not so clear what the issue here is in other words let's say why isn't it enough just to scrape the why isn't it enough just to scrape the roof the leg was made okay there's nothing wrong with the way you made the leg in the beginning said that if you have an open mem that it got sealed up that's not going to help to scrape it because that's so you have to basically uh scrape the whole the whole nose and then it's gonna be like uh uh and then you could write what you uh scraped off so the question is why is this um why why do you have to scrape the entire letter the leg was made um in a state of cashless so it seems like the mission Brewer said in subcutane Zion um institutan I involve excuse me it's all one motion it's all since it's all one motion since the Rage or the dalid is one letter it's not made of two parts so therefore the whole thing is considered puzzle let's see the beer halacha maybe this will give us a clear Insight because I would have assumed again that you see a race I understand is one motion really right it's but a dalid I would have thought it's you're making a horizontal of so to speak and then you're making a line down I wouldn't have thought it's but it seems like the dalid is also one motion I think I think we're learning it correctly in other words the issue over here is any time a letter is consists of one part it's not going to help to scrape off part of it that you ruined it's one entity so you have to scrape the whole thing I think this will be clear and very lucky erase let's see you made a very wide roof foreign but you made the you made the top the roof very wide so it just looks like a bigger race cars amonging around the yamsha Regal so now elongate the leg actually that it should be double like the roof but if there's nowhere to go you can't make the legs so long it's going to go into the next line or in the another word you have to erase the whole roof why you can't just erase the extra part of the roof David guerreras just erasing the extra width of the roof it's not gonna help it basically you made the roof too long so yeah I want to erase part of it but when you raise part of it then you're forming the letter through by removing something in the middle of the letter is appearing last foreign 's name um I'll have to erase that I'll erase the roof just be careful not to erase the leg so um in the dershow explains that even Ella even though the valley is hashem's name it's like secondary to it and you can't erase it so you can't erase the leg now I don't understand I thought the mission Brewer said that when it's written because you can't you have to erase everything oh that's discussion now that's a we're learning it right in other words so the question should should be very clear to us the mission of Bruce holds that the reason if you make a race like a dollar you have to erase the whole thing because any time a letter is made of one part if if any part of it is ruined you must erase the entire thing so again what threw me off is I would have thought a race is consisting of two parts certainly a dalid but clearly Mr Brewer is telling us a race and a dollar is one kasiva and therefore he's bothered if you if you make the ender half with a too long of a roof to watch too wide of a roof then why does it help just to erase the roof you should have to erase the entire leg as well that is and therefore the whole thing has to be erased um he says even though taka there's a big Kasha you should have to erase the whole thing just like a dollar in a race but since there's a sheet of the prihadash by dalid and race that you don't have to raise the whole thing so even though by Donald and Rich we pass again you do have to but by hashem's name you could be late Mako and rely on the prihadash namely again the prehadash is conscious by inend you only have to arrange the roof and hear the saying you have to erase the whole letter bottom line is and we're going to hold it over here the bottom line is that the cloud from the from the beginning of this page is that any letter that consists of one writing If part of it was ruined then when you erased you have to be Megara the whole thing because the soul extends to every script of a letter okay let's hold it over here I guess we'll do the rest of the page tomorrow okay you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com