Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

Mishna Berura Daf Hashavua 111:2-3, 112 Is "Hashem Sefasai Tiftach Critical"?

144 views
Rabbi Daniel Glatstein Official avatar
Rabbi Daniel Glatstein Official

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

okay good morning everyone so um actually I got a call about this year I have a friend a classmate of mine who lives in Las Vegas who every morning he listens to the shear you know it's a three-hour difference but he's you know mamish holding with the she so uh you know the as they say Okay Simon when he begins to say alow he goes back and he says I have to say the simple of the is says says m now the what about when he says says that the sh does not have to say it's good to say it quietly this is the opinion of theim say this I believe it comes from the m the others does not have a right is not allowed to interrupt after he doin quietly he can't be M for something near for a matter it would seem that he cannot now there's an an epic mug epic beer so we have to do it that's the okay so the question is what if a person forgot is that is that a lack in the fundamental nature say I have a very good you need to say that means the tibra is not hearing it so if the tibra is not hearing it then obvious viously it's not the answer is is not relevant to the they're not themselves it's most logical that that which we say that only regarding that it should not be an interruption between G and but not like that you need to go back because of that you know what the proof is we say not because it's but nobody would say if you didn't say it's only it's not a I would humbly assert that nobody thought that the reason why you have to say Hashem is because the fact that it's that shows you have to say it maybe once we know made it not part of the they made it part of so question is once it's part of is or not okay Simon if let's say before you said you found that first you have to say why it's better to meaning okay so is more important meaning with the what if you're the paid you know you're the guy who D every day and you walk in late you know the P tend to do that you know and uh the guy's sipping his coffee and he walks in and uh they're almost up to he would be allowed to in even though he didn't in the friends remember this is all in the morning in the morning is better than but we saw yesterday from that also and then Andre and we don't do fine s why it's this week's of course is and the reason he cross is is associated with there four in and here we go he can't interrupt not in the first three and not in the last three a person cannot ask for his needs the first three not the last three you can't ask for personal you could ask for what are the first three simar to a servant who arranges his praise before for his master the middle to a servant who asks for a prize a reward payment from his master he Praises him and he leaves since the first three are from the order of Praise You should not ask for your needs for who communal why are communal needs permitted part of the praise of the master is that many need him so it's a to be needed it is a to be needed I theu on second and Sh you do make requests from RAB so says the last three are for example what maybe and also maybe because it's it's the same way we say we're asking okay we don't say those are the that are added to we don't say we don't why because for the same reason uh you're not to ask for your needs in the first three and the last three some allow it in all places we all say and says that you could he says that he has in his possession a few questions that one of the asks from the heavens through Solitude he asked the heaven said and look over there he warned greatly not to deviate from the Min hug of saving P now in a place where they say it you cannot be punish not see unlearn what yeah um we're in either one um talking about in I mean that's what this Simon is talking about I'm not sure let's see but then the Rama says that I mean say C so you're going to take theit of and stick it into the it wasn't made for the so is he talking about saying it in Yer you shouldn't say it or is he saying you shouldn't say it in because look what do you mean not to be over how would you possibly be over if you said them in they don't say it I don't know if that's the reason I think because they would have to close down if they would say it because nobody would go to theiva yeah my son came home he said he likes the um look in the in the D brings down from the T the is to say it earlier I guess here in the they're grouping together the I mean you're right that the is talking about saying it during and sort of speak grouping together both don't fast because of them until after I guess he's talking about when you say if you see the is being in the and because of that they're going to miss do not wait for them there you should wait in silence ask you a question according to does It Go by or what is what man so you're going to say and you're going to wait over there until the gets there and then you D in together with them okay so here the because and that's have a wonderful day we'll see you all next week on Monday S have a good day good chavas