Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

MB DH Siman 108 Seif 9 If You Indicated that You said a Makeup Tefilla Before the Obligatory Tefilla

90 views
Rabbi Daniel Glatstein Official avatar
Rabbi Daniel Glatstein Official

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

okay good morning friends we're continuing we're up to let's read again says you made a mistake and the first one is because first you in the and the second is a makeup the same thing would be if you didn't now on that that if you made a mistake and you didn't have twice the Miss says even though you're coming to make up a weekday since it's shabus you di in a shabus to make up for the if you made a mistake D the second one of a you're exempt if you first daved the week day and then shabus you're not according to everyone why because it's clear you however the said if you're making an early shabas but youus with M or but you didn't D in Mar and you didn't D in so you're supposed to twice so both should be forab and the first one really should be for Mar and the second one but if even if you made it a week day it could be your say why because it's still day IAB okay I was ma shabas but it's still the day and the fact that Ma shabas is that that it's still so even though it's clear I'm ding the first nevertheless maybe it's not a I'm ding even though once I'm I'm really supposed to twice if you did this that was what we learned on Friday now the r says let's see the raama for a minute let's say you didn't so you missed that should not have a y but now I have to D in twice I'm going to dve in um two we already had by the way if in the first one I didn't say then I'm not going to say Al in the second one because I wasn't okay if you did not mention in the first one and you mention it in the second one I have to go back again you know why cuz I'm showing that the first one is the makeup and the second one is the and you're not all to do that I didn't mention either or I mentioned in the first this is from the besides what it says that you that's all from the okay I miss by the way if you didn't D in or you're going to dve in two Mar with this is not like the why I have to say in the second one I'm not making up a now the D brings the would agree if I'm ding Friday night to make up a Friday afternoon I would say both of shabas cuz that's a zilzil to chabas one who did not now of course you you should say Y in both let's say in the second one I didn't say y now I'm making up a mar and a mar I don't have to say Al I mean I have to say it but I wouldn't have to go back if I missed it I don't have to go back and again why since if I was ding itself and I forgot I wouldn't have to go back the makeup is not going to be more than if I would have next let's say I made a mistake and didn't and it's a two I'm going to twice in the first one if I miss it ain't a big deal because it's and now I forgot in my makeup for I would have thought well I'm daving it as a Marv and Marv I don't need to say I said I would have thought no I would have thought I'm making up a and has to have so if I forget y now in the second maybe you'd have to go back no why because it can't be more than so the makeup is also it's not what's now for the pr adds let's say was one day then would I be saying in my second Mar let's think about that is one day I missed by my mar I didn't say so in the makeup I wouldn't say either I'm only saying y because I said it in the first F so since in the first F if I didn't say I don't have to go back I don't have to do it in the second f what's the scenario I miss on now it'ses in the first one if I mentioned if I did not mention y in the first and I mentioned it in the second so what I'm indicating is that first I'm ding tum and then I'm ding I have to go back and Dav right remember the case he ones twice he DAV someone who did not Daves he DAV um two ones and really he should say in both but if he didn't say it in the first and he said in the second he's indicating that t comes first and he's not in this case by not mentioning in the first he's revealing that his is that it's a makeup for the Tash that he missed it's a makeup his his kavana is that it should be a makeup for the of which was weekday we already explained in the beginning of the Simmon the that if you advance the before the obligatory you're not you won't be just like in in the next where we're going to see that if you missed and you're going to dive in two Mar if you were not MD on the first and you're MD on the second one then you're not in the first one because you're showing your ding the first then you have to go back and D in that what does that mean that the you did the second time where you mentioned in the second this scenario is where the makeup is coming for a which is not fores since you did not mention in the first one you're [Music] revealing you're ding in the first to make up for a weekday but what ifes was both days for let's say the day you missed and the that night so I missed on the first dayes and now I'm ding Mar on the second day and in the first I forgot y am I indicating that the first is a no it could have been the first was I just blew it so then I don't have to go back and Dav because the first F where I forgot y that could have been for and there's no proof I'm ding the first one as a just because I didn't say but I need to say because both were so the first one was I just happened not to say and the second one was that if I didn't mention but if my cavana was the first one should be for my I just happen to forget then it works if I had explicit that the first one should be the second for makeup yat then I would be the second one I forgot it in the first and I said it in the second one ah you mean one second it's that's why he said it's no it's no it's talking about where it's talking about where the day before was oh in the RAS case I'm sorry where the guy it was he didn't mention in the first and he and he mentioned in the second one and he was that the first one is oh because it'ses even though by the way he wasn't mes so maybe he shouldn't be saying it right I think we had before that you don't say it what um c mean we had in so if it's still we had before that if let's say you forgot what you missed then uh you cannot make it up so a guy who came the case was someone who came to show and he didn't even though he didn't do the right thing it's not going to be called hazed and therefore he could make it up and if it'ses he should say even in the second one however if he forgot in the first one he shouldn't do it in the second one because he wasn't Mel he he didn't make it but you're saying that's only because it's still day but in this case it's night you would say it by the way the D says that in this scenario in this scenario he's allowed to say in the second one but he's not look back in the so if it's at night and you're making up uh a non and now it ises but in my I forgot to say I can say y in the second one okay so I would be allowed to I would not have to that's theard so you're right even though we learned earlier that you don't that's when it's still day but if it's night you are allowed to okay thank you very much have a great day we'll see everybody tomorrow in by the way this evening we're beginning so once you're already learning Mish you might want to give a try to Gar we're going to be starting 915 uh happen to be tonight we're going to be doing the full blot because I have to get ahead a little bit and 10 minutes before that there's going to be a brief intro to so 9:05 intro 915 sh okay making up and the first one I did was and I'm not no no I only have to the you're going to be in the second one and then after that you do the no the first one you said it doesn't do doesn't work for anything have I did the the second one is the right and then I have to make up the T right everyone have a good day