Is There Lo Tisgodidu Between Ashkenazim & Sefardim Putting On Tefillin? - Mishna Berura DH Special

this Tower class is brought to you by torahanytime.com um yesterday uh ravianki danziger asked the following question we we learned that there are two practices two ways to put on fill in two men hug him or two approaches to the method of putting on film the Rama brought a yeshmi shakasav to put on the tone until um and there that's from the agor in the name of the zyar Brahma says it is not our custom to do that we do both standing the mug in avram says that the in between a position would be to put it on sitting and the bracha standing which Lakota would then mean you make the the reverse order you stand for the bracha you then sit to put on the villain right the other way around and the Ali Arabic says who's greater than Ram shimshan mikinai that you do everything standing so the question is in one Shoal if you're an Ashkenazi could you put on your philan Ashkenazi style or if you're a smarty could you put on the villain svardi Style um we know if my shashita is you cannot have in one shul in the open some people wearing fill in some people not wearing filling now the basic rule of lysis guy to do is uh there are two reasons for lysis guy to do Rashi and Ivana they says the reason for license guide to do is it looks like they're two tairas it looks like uh God gave the Jewish people to to religions however the RAM and and according to that if it's just a matter of Min hug we don't we would not apply like this guy to do to matters of Min hug the rambam says the reason for a license guide to do is because of machlaikas so even if it's only Minogue if anything it could be it would even create greater Mac like us if it's a matter of Min hug so I want to share with you um very briefly I'll try to do it quick there's a chuva in the hashiv moisha regarding a remote do you say David by minha or do you do your own thing or vice versa okay so that's certainly a matter of Min hug and that is um an issue of whether life is going to do applies to the David so the Isha Israel he brings from the kovitz that if you usually say about the minute that says you should do like the minute presumably it's it's like this guy did in other words even matters of men hug him you should do what deceiver does he goes through the studio and he says this is a very prevalent Shiloh regarding many many issues and he says regarding Le David everyone should follow their Min hug their own personality do whatever meaning do whatever you want that's his conclusion this one of the main comments of the subject is the mug in avram in some seems to vacillate he says something which is only a matter of Minogue we don't say lysis and so something that you could say you're not having to avoid is all there's no license guide to do and he says you know what there yeah there is there is like this guy to do so the question is and he says no there is going to do does he mean there's this guy to do even on something where you're not having for a Dover yes sir or does he mean there's even hug him so that's the Shiloh the place can have when the Muggin of rum retracts and he says there is lysis talks about two cases he says by Minogue there is this guy to do and by something that you're not concerned for us sir there's no license and then he says you know what there is does he mean there is by something where you're concerned for a lover or even by Min hug is that even by Minogue there's always this guy to do but some points can explain about Ghana from that he's only Heiser by something that you're not Makai for advar is Sir but regarding Min hogum the magaram would would conclude like his original Cheetah that there's no license going to hit it by Minogue that's the shita of the Israel so the the remote wants to say it's talai on the makoicus we shine him that we mentioned earlier if the reason for lysus Gods was like Rashi that we don't want it to look like two Thai rice so then there's no license going to do by Minag but if it's because we don't want to cause macholicus then there would be like this guy to do now there are more rights later on regarding svira you should not have in one city some people doing one way and some people doing another way so that seems to blow the whole thing out of the water that there's a license guide to do even by Min hug uh one second let me just leave this that seems like there's always this guy to do even by minhog then the the remote wants to say that this that was even by Minogue that's only by a Minogue that it hasn't been definitively decided okay you could do like a you could do like B Minnie that's only something that is sort of we leave it to your discretion how you should conduct yourself however those men hug him that are already hooked ashkenazin do like this Spar them do like that it's not going to be lead to makloikis because it's long been decided that this group does this way that group does that way by the way he brings another maramakoi we know that the second night of yamtif of of sukis there's a Shiloh do you first say late shaver do you first say shakiano he said the mission Brewer says in one sukkah you can't have different people doing different things maybe because there it's not really decided it's it's not really like it's not like ashkenaz and due and spider them do be it's sort of you know it's up for grabs though um he brings that there's voice that's going to do if somebody puts on philanthalamide in a show that the milk is not to I by hilu came and hug him we don't say like this guy to do no this everyone would say Lois is going to do why because it's in other words it's very interesting legabe fill in and might be something which is awesome to put on phonology therefore says um the the the uh even who says that there's always this is going to do on fill in on holiday that's because if you're not supposed to wear it and vice versa and then he brings but ramesha we know says that if you're an and people are not careful about this if you dive in ashkenaz and as far as or people that haven't started in an ashken Ash and uh you know it comes to tahn so so the the if you're that many eyeshadows you put your head down right away people that have inspired they're starting to clap why because maybe they feel they have their dominating whatever it is but they're not they're emotion says you know how to do that you know how to do that you're not allowed to publicly show that you're doing something different than the seabor so that means that Maisha holds even by minhog that's a matter of Minh it's not a matter of that means promotion is going like some soifa that even by a matter of Minogue there's an initial voice this guy to do says the um that's because it's public but legabela David where it's minhog and nobody knows what you're doing nobody knows you're saying Lil W you're not saying La dovid maybe you're saying pitamaktarus again so remote says even Ramos would say regarding Le David you could do whatever you want not like Zaman says follow the minigun that sibar I would assume Zaman says father Dominican with Seaboard not because it's lysis because the whole Indian of the David it's not mamish uh it's not a it's not part of a mate it's a very very late edition it's in a certain way it's like saying to him at the end of davening so you so do what the sibra is doing but the conclusion of the of the ramesha halberstam is even Rabb Maisha who by matters of Minogue says there's an is an issue of life is going to do um he says so the question is what would ramasha say about an Ashkenazi putting on to fill in his way by fire them and vice versa I mean I can't imagine would say this is a good thing to do because it's a matter of Minogue which is public it's a you know you're so put on your tone outside that's what I would think that what my show would say uh you're dealing with the laces going to do over here La Mesa um ramosha Harborstone probably would say it's okay because it's a matter of Minogue it's not a matter of Issa malacha meaning it's a matter of minutes sir it's not Usher to put on Phil and standing or sitting it just it's a matter of uh whether whether you're going to follow the reasoning of the of the Zaya or are you going to say desire holds uh that you could put it on standing so I would say remote would say it's okay and ramaysha would say put on the tillen privately that's what I would think well I said uh yeah but um probably lagabe um as well right nobody important you get stoned if you do that um I'm singing But in America as well emotions they're not macbid that people put on Toko might sit behind the Maritza it's the same thing why is and um and in our show we also if someone wants to put on filling you do it before uh you do it before you do it behind the Makita but Lamesa when it comes to ashkenaza's father to fill in I don't I've never seen anywhere whatever I'm telling you now is look you know what should be in an idyllic laboratory of you know we'll make this fire than put out realistically nah it ain't gonna happen anywhere that you're gonna but I would think that if you're an Ashkenazi you have Dominos I would say uh probably if you want to follow me it'll probably make sense to put the phone on outside anyway that reason says you should put on the fill in outside of the and then walk in for the mother home anyway yeah yeah so anyway you're putting it on you're not putting it on in the shawl but to go into the shoe I mean that that's a good spot you're gonna go into a spider League shoe where they below you shouldn't put on the toilet on the shot and you're gonna put it on like an Ashkenazi now you can't do that okay everyone have a wonderful day who is this is you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com