Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Gems on Parshas Ki Seitzei - The Yefas Toar and Ben Sorrer U'Moreh
46 views
Subscribe and hit the bell to see new videos!!! • Visit the Rav's site: https://www.rabbidg.com • Have a Question? Contact the Rav: https://www.rabbidg.com/contact • Order Rabbi Glatstein's Books: https://www.rabbidg.com/rabbi-glatstein-books Date This Shiur Was Given: 8/27/2020 #Torahstudy #Judaism #Jewish #Torah #Spiritual #Rabbi #Chumash #Parasha #Parsha #Gemara
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
this torah class is brought to you by
torahanytime.com
welcome everyone parshas kisetse
we know we have the episode of the
fast toyar
where somebody's going to war
and
uh we know that when someone is uh
going to battle so yeah i need help here
so the the so to speak the passions are
flare uh
flaring and it's it becomes very
difficult to conquer one's desires
and the torah actually makes an
allowance that if somebody sees a fast
toy or a beautiful woman
they're permitted to take her
and hazal alcohol at loydibra hattora
ella canegadietzahara the torah only
speaks
um opposite the itsahara
what does that mean the torah
acknowledges the strength of the sahara
the power of the it's how difficult it
is to overcome and the torah makes
allowances in fact
would always open up the newsman
by quoting this hazal
and
let a person never think that their
their learning of torah or the
performance of mitzvos is beyond their
capability
because if something would be impossible
the tar would allow it
as we see from the fast taya that this
is a challenge that's too difficult to
overcome and therefore the taurus says
it's permitted so whenever something's
too difficult to overcome the torah says
go ahead gazan to hate
but everything else that tara says is
forbidden whatever other expectations
zatar has of us
we have to fulfill because uh that means
we're able to
mute everybody
because uh this is something that we're
able to
uh overcome because if we weren't able
to overcome
then
uh the tarot would
not allow it
okay or the torah would allow it now i
want to
focus for a moment on the language of
ghazal
so the question is the language of rashi
should be the language of the gemara
should be
dibra hatorah keneged yetzerhara the
torah speaks corresponding to the sahara
what's loyi dibra torah ella connected
why the double negative just say
straight up say the torah is addressing
the sahara why is it why does it say loy
dibra torah
so it's interesting and the safer
preenum economy brings down from the
kilaus maisha based on the gmar nadarim
the wife of rav
would cause him distress
he would ask for scrambled eggs she
would make him pancakes he would ask for
pancakes she would make him waffles
so she wasn't cooperating cooperating
so the tamidim says why do you show her
respect and honor
so rav says what do you mean she does
her job
isn't it enough
isn't that enough rav says that she
raises the children and she saves me
from sin
so she fulfills her two primary
objectives
she
saves me from sinning and she's magada
as habanem
so says the kihilas so let's think for a
moment
that a typical woman a woman is supposed
to
accomplish this for her husband namely
that she saves him from sin and she
raises the children
but when it comes to the ifas tayar
the fact that she
she could only fulfill one of these
objectives because she's not going to
raise the children in that she's going
to produce a ben soromaira like the
khazal say that somebody who marries you
will have a benzero maira so her only
thing she could accomplish is
save you from the eight sahara that's
arashi means
allowing you to marry her because what
the tara has in mind is what she will
accomplish for you is she will save you
from the sahara only that will be her
only accomplishment for you but in terms
of magdala says habonium that is not
applicable to yufas tayar and that is
because she will ultimately be
she will ultimately cause a ben soyra
umaira
okay
now the pasta continues vahaya
and will be if you don't want her
rashi says the pasuk is
promising you
that yes marry the fast tayar but you're
gonna ultimately hate her
so the question is and the mizrahi asks
how does rashi know and how to hazal
darshan
that the pasik is promising you that you
will ultimately hate her we're in the
past do we see any into any intimation
that you're going to ultimately hate
this woman it says and it will be if you
don't want her where do you see that the
pasik is promising that you will divorce
her
so i in the safer panini mukaram he
brings down from rav gavriel the abbasid
of nickelsburg
and
ramnasan
in the safer
lassoshem that you gave me
he brings this down from the base shmuel
on avena ezra very interesting idea
there's a funding last night i went to a
wedding
i hope everything turned out okay
because after the khubba the inspectors
came
and they made everybody leave
but
we know that there's a difference
between aksuba
and agat
in the tsuba it says
yeah it says
in a get it says
why
because the passage says
it says new by the taking her
and it says
garesh
in other words like this by marriage it
says
marriage we have the word hoidesh
but gerushin we have the word yarach
gareshem
it says the word yarayak and by
conduction it says the word
so question
over here it's talking about marriage it
says
so why does the passage say you'll stay
with her yeah
why does it say yarach over here we're
not talking about divorce we're talking
about marriage so says
gabriel avbesdan of nickelsburg the fact
that the torah uses the word yerach
which is usually used in the reference
to get to giten that's a signal word
that ultimately you're going to come to
hate the woman and you're going to come
to
garrison so last night i was speaking to
yadidi
hagon with mayor bronstein who is the
rav of the aguda
farakawe and he told me a question that
he posed to his class
and a vart that came out of it really um
spectacular
we know the
gemara tells us what is the meaning of
the episode and the parasha of bensaro
maira
it's almost an impossible scenario
because i'll say that the the
father has to have the same exact voice
as the mother the shama because
that the child did not listen to its
voice that the father and the mother
have the same voice and the kid has to
be of a certain age and the parents have
to be of a certain stature and there's
so many qualifications of van saramara
it seems impossible and the gemara says
ben sarah maria
nivra it never was
it never existed it never happened it's
a fairy tale so so why was it written
what does the gemara say allah
darshan it and receive reward
meaning
the purpose is that don't think torah is
only
to know what to do practically there's a
concept that manuscript wants you to
learn just to learn for learning's sake
not to be anything not to know
just for the sake of learning torah and
therefore it gives us an episode to
learn that never happened
so i don't understand
why
why did the gemara if the whole reason
for the episode ben sarah mira
is just to learn something that never
happened i mean we could have the tara
could have made up
any
um outlandish story to learn that never
happened right the gemara could have
told once upon a time
the media spoke the truth so tomorrow
could have asked aye it's not true they
don't say one thing that's true whatever
they say is distorted and the exact
opposite of reality so marcus said
you're right but jerusalem
you're right the media doesn't say
anything that's true they're all you
know employed by the liberal parties but
what are you what could you do
the torah could have picked
a
an infinite number of impossible
scenarios and stories that never happen
that can't happen to learn to get scar
why daft this story
so rabbi breinstein said he asked his
class
and a bakar i think he said his name was
mayor simcha sperling
said the following idea what's the story
of a ben sarah maira
that there's a kid
who
he has these bad practices he's over
indulgent in meat he's older
overindulgent in wine
he's stealing
and they take him to beds in and the
parents say
this jewish child
there's no hope for this jewish child
so the torah says learn that
but no lawyer of eloy nivra
that never existed there is no such
thing as a jewish child
that is so rotten and so bad to the core
and so off that we could bring him to a
bezel and say he's hopeless
there's no such thing
ben soro mira lahayevolai never that's
why we picked this scenario know
that this story is a fictitious story
it's a made-up story there is no such
thing in judaism
as a child who's beyond hope
that's a
a pretty remarkable
interpretation okay so those are just
three ideas and then i have a sheet
and
we'll start with that you've just
experienced another torah class brought
to you by torahanytime.com
Up next
24 recommendations shown