Do You Say Shalom Aleichem on Shabbos Chol Hamoed? - The Machlokes Satmar Rebbe & Shem M'shmuel

One time on Shabas the Sharim said that Shabas is different than a regular Shabas. Regular Shabas it needs a hisus for the Shabas. Shabaso does not need a his for the Shabas because the Yumiff itself makes room for the Shabas. You see on a regular Shabas we have to greet the Shabas. on a shabas that comes after the six working days. We have to make room for the shabas. Says that the shabas asks dra from Israel. So we need to be the shabas. No, not shabas. The y makes room for the shabas. You see on sukus the dra of Israel is in the suk makes special room for the shabas says on page sak. So let's talk about perhaps one of the ramifications of this idea. There's a question what comes first on Shabasen or Shalom. In general, you could ask, "Do you even say shalom on Shabas?" The Benes says, "In fact, you do say you say and that was also the you should say on Shabas if even if it comes out on Yamiff and certainly Shabas." However, what's interesting is the samurba was once sitting in the suka and the question came up, what comes first or and there was a certain r there and he and the said what do you mean? Of course the should come first because come every Friday night and only come on to whichba said what you think the the come are the same that come the whole year no the malim that come are special malim therefore we don't apply the rule in fact the was first to say and then based on the Sanhedrin and therefore first you invite the sadikim and then you invite the I was thinking my min is I don't say sham not on shabas that comes out on yam and not on shabas and I think based on this there's a very good reason not to because if sadikim are greater than it's not respectful to invite the after you just invited the are greater you have and you're inviting no you can't do that and I found that the bberb says then in sons the is not to say sham and I was very happy to find that in sach also where I come from they did not And the shamish writes on that the are greater than than the malim. So to invite the it wouldn't be respectful to the ushisen. How could you invite the malim when you invited the ushen? Another reason is the only reason we need malim is the malim serve as an intermediary as a middleman. But when you're in you're in the shade of himself where the suk are the two various she of we don't need any intermediaries we don't need any gobetweens we don't need malar furthermore the malim are afraid to come into the suka they're afraid to be in the presence of the holiness of Israel in together with the don't even come and therefore we the min says the da not to say shalom on Shabas but perhaps based on the Shim there'd be another reason not to say the reason to say sham is it's a form of for the shabas but as mentioned on shabas we don't need that the yumptiff itself welcomes the shabas on a regular shabas we need to welcome the shabas on shabas the yumptiff welcomes the shabas and therefore we're off the hook. And that would be another reason not to say sham on Shabas. Wishing everyone a beautiful Shabas and >> recording stopped.