Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Okay, good evening dear friends. We are
continuing in
is making a nether
to prohibit something that is currently
in yourus for a time that it's no longer
in your field is in your however
once comes it is
once comes it's no longer in your
possession. Could you make a ne to
answer your fruit on someone? Well, once
Shmita comes, you shouldn't be able to.
It's not yours anymore. But if you make
that NDA before while it is in your
domain, can it continue till uh at a
time later? Um could it continue for
when it's no longer in your domain?
Okay. So, let's see the Mishna.
one who was also to get han from his
friend and before in other words his
friend made an to before came
he can't go down into his friend's
field.
So
if somebody made a nether answering his
friend before and he said you can't get
h from me so you're now to go down to my
field and
he can't eat the trees that are hanging
over the field even though that's not
technically it's no longer in your field
but it's extending out of the field. The
is you cannot get derived benefit.
Now presumably
when it says if the nether was made
before
it means even during the year
but if the nether was made during
he can't enter the guy's field because
even though the fruit doesn't belong to
me but my field belongs to me and it
sounds like I you still can't eat my
fruit
you could eat from the plantings, the
trees that extend outside.
So this is all if somebody asserted
Hana. So if you assert Hana, so then you
can't come into my field. You're getting
Hana from being in my field and you
can't eat even the fruit that is hanging
out. However, if the nether was made
during, you can't go into my field.
However, you could eat the noto.
But what if we didn't what if the nether
wasn't where the nether is?
Let's say he made a nether on food
before
then the person could enter go down into
the field.
However, you're because I'm only
answering food. So if I made a before
then the person who is could go into the
field because that's not but he can eat
from the fruit presumably that means
that
um he can't even eat the fruit during
and if he made
Not only are you allowed to go down into
the field, but you're allowed to eat it.
But if you assert before, you can't go
in. You can't eat the If you answer
during also, you can't go in, but you
could eat from the
but it sounds like you're now to eat
from the what's in the field itself.
You can't eat from the fruit of the
field, but you can eat from the fruit
extending out of the field. Let's see
the says the
you can't go into the field of the
person who made the
cannot even
doesn't have rights of passage. Like we
learned earlier,
you can't eat from the extending trees.
from the fruits that extend on the road
close to the field.
And in
you cannot go into the field.
What does this mean?
It means if the nether was made during,
you're now to go into the field. So in
the first case, if you made hana before
shmita, you can't go in the field and
you can't eat the nois. If you made the
the during shmita, you can't go into the
field. That's strange. Why can't you go
into the field? We'll have to see.
So now the is going to bring
versus
and
they both say
if somebody says these possessions are
user to you
if they said it before then
you can't go down into his
And
he can't eat
from
the fruit.
He can't eat from the trees that are
hanging over
even though came. So if you made the
before, if you said these are to you
before, you can't go down into his field
and you can't eat from the hang whatever
uh branches are hanging
even though came
but if you made the nether during
you can't go down into his field
you could eat from
So ra and say as follows. If then if the
formula if the nether was formulated as
follows. I say these are to you. If I
say it before
then I can't go down into the field and
I can't eat the fruit during
even though during shmita the mad
doesn't own it. He assured it before it
remains assur and therefore you can't go
down into his field and you can't eat
the fruits. But if he made the nether
during shmita you can't go down into his
field because the field belongs to him.
But you can't. But you can eat from the
branches that are hanging over because
it's not his toer.
They both say
I'm sorry. They say
if the person says my possessions are
also to you
if the nether is made before
you can't eat from his field
but once comes not if you made the
during once comes
you're allowed to eat the hanging
fruits. So let's just identify the
between versus
ram say if you made the nether before
the nether continues to the noto even
during shmita
says no if you made the nether before
it's also to go into the field it's also
to eat the butmita comes you can't go
into the field but you could eat the so
what is this is they seem to be arguing
on if you ask her something at a time
that you own it will it continue even
for a that you don't own it says.
Let us say that this is what they argue
about.
They both hold
that a person could answer something in
your that's in your domain even for a
time that it will leave your domain.
That's
says
this logical
memor
is there anyone who holds
that a person cannot answer something
that's in his domain when it goes out of
his domain if so
they should have had a
where you said
these
and certainly will you say my
possessions.
What does this mean?
The case that they argue on is where
they say
We're rammo say.
So let's see what this question is. If
so
then
should have argued in a case where it
was
and certainly
it would apply if he said my isn't that
though what they argue about. Isn't that
the case?
Let's go back at the lion the lion of
oh
here. So that's why we need to use the
sca here. That's the confusing thing. If
you look carefully, even though
the changes it to
and
they say
they're arguing in a case where the guy
says my but if this was
they should have argued whereas
and certainly by
So let's see if we could crack this.
Let's see if we could figure this out.
Let's look in the run.
Even though came
the
he even though it's all Paris of Hefkar
nevertheless
since at the time he made the nether
it belonged to him
it's the even during According
to Raven, the mission would be saying
two different
according to Raven. The way to read the
Mishna is that if you make the nether
before the nether and then it applies
even
even whenus comes.
And then the safer comes to teach
that if you made the nether
it's true the nether is not for the
fruits.
So basically the way raw reads the
Mishna is that the ra is talking about
if you made the nether before it would
continue even formita and they both hold
that it's everything
before
but when comes it's to have the
so
Hold
in.
So let's see if we can figure out this
round.
This would seem to be the explanation of
this garam
should please give us to understand
this. The hasht the thinks now
they're both trying to explain the
Mishna
explain the like we explained namely
that the race shows you made the nether
before and it continues
even when comes
learned The Mishna is talking about one
case. Case number one is when you made
the nad before and
has not come yet. So then the is your
user and the fruits and your user to go
on the land.
Meaning ra and say that the ra is
talking about where you made the nether
before and it continues even during
shmita. But according to
no the ra is talking about he made the
nether before and shmita didn't come and
the cifa is talking about where then
shmita came so you can't go into the
field but you could eat the fruits
it's it's one case it's talking about
you made the nether before
you can't go down
that it's true you can't go down into
the field
and the reason you can't go down is
because he made the nether before and
the land is known as rashus
to the precious time
why are the fruits
even though he made at the time that it
was in his
you can't answer something in your
for a time it goes out of your so
therefore once comes the fruits are when
it's true nothing is being taught in the
meaning bishl according to raven the r
is teaching
Because we're saying that the nether is
even when comes but according to
the is not talking about where comes the
is talking about where comes. So what's
the
um so according to
to teach even though he made him take a
nether before even though he made the
nether before.
So that's
against raven ramo say the nether isal
for the fruits and for going down would
be true even if comes the is talking
about where you made the nether during
so it's not for the fruits
and the ra and the are both teaching me
in
the is going on In the case of the the
is talking about you made the nether
before and didn't come and therefore the
nether is and that's not aesh at all.
The kadesh is it's a setup for the safa
that if you made the nether before and
then comes then it's not going to be for
the fruit because you can't answer
something
when it's in your for a time that it's
no longer in your so the gum now has two
questions. Question number one ones
is is there anyone who says that a
person cannot answer something in his
rush for when it goes out of his in
other words according to
the nether that you made to asser
the fruits before
is not effective when shmita comes and
you could
the person who's now to get Hana is
eaten.
So if that's the case,
if what
are saying is you cannot asser something
that's in your for a time that it's not
in your
and that's why when shmita comes it's
not user then why do they dava talk
about a case where
it's his possessions
they should even say if the person who
made the nether says these possessions
are user to you certainly if they're his
possessions. So what's this all about?
What's the nuda of why say the nether is
off? Is it because well the guy said my
possessions. So when schmita comes
they're not his possessions anymore.
Is it because it's not his possessions
or even if they let's say the guy didn't
say my possessions. Let's say he said
these possessions are user to you. Then
when shmita comes it should be kam
because he doesn't have uh he doesn't
have rishus over it anymore.
Let's see the run on the three lines on
the bottom.
If
that a person cannot answer something
for a time that it's not his domain,
they should have explicitly argued.
Even if he said explicitly these
Let's see Rashi. Maybe Rashi will
explain a little bit more.
Why do they only argue and say
they should say even if the guy says
these
let say the
A person cannot asser something that's
in his domain for a time that's not in
his domain
because then certainly if the guy says
my possessions because if he says my
possessions
then it's for sure not his possession
anymore
when comes
why do they limit their
why do they limit themselves to talk
about where the guy says my possessions
because if he says my possessions
there's a very strong argument that
could be made that when Shmita comes
they're not his possessions anymore.
They should have widened the situation
that they're talking about to even if
the guy says these possessions and the
point is it's not going to be effective
later because it's not in his domain
anymore. But the fact that they limit
they say my possession that implies it's
only because he says mine and it's not
his anymore.
Furthermore, the gar asks,
furthermore,
we learned in the
Mishna seems to say explicitly that you
could answer something in your domain
for later because the case of the ra
which says that a person made a
implies even when for when comes
The Mishna says explicitly that a person
can asser something in his domain for
when it goes out of his domain. We
learned in
somebody says to his son,
I ask her what you get hana from me.
I say whatever you get hah from me is
asser mace
if the father dies the son could inherit
because that's not called getting from
him
let's see the
he's not getting from the father
he's getting enough from the
to him so ma the father dies
the son will inherit.
But let's say he says in my lifetime and
in my death
I don't want you to get enough from me
while I'm alive and when I'm dead
if he dies he can't he doesn't um so
clearly you could answer something when
it's in for a time that it's not in your
says
It doesn't mean he's not going to it
doesn't stop the process of
the possessions will belong to the son.
We're gonna explain in our peric coming
up the
says he inherits
to say the dinner is like other
but it doesn't mean you don't inherit
you do inherit you just can't get can't
get
but so the bottom line is you do inherit
But you can't get but what do we see?
So you can't say the is can you asser
something for a time when it's not in
your because we have an explicit Mishna
that a father could say you're not
getting h from me in my lifetime and
when I die and that would not allow the
son to get hah from what he inherits
even though the lion is he doesn't
inherit explains no he does it just he
can't get hah and that shows everybody
agrees you can answer something
now when it's in your is for a time that
it's no longer in your is
have Have a beautiful night. Thank you
for joining.