Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Okay friends, thanks for joining. We're
continuing down.
were discussing
and rebi regarding
that became tame.
when could he start counting his uh
rebi says he has to wait until the
eighth day because it says
once he gets kapar on the eth day
no the
says that he can already start counting
the tahara not when you bring the carbon
but rather even earlier once you get um
once he cuts his hair
fine so the Gomar wanted to know okay
gets it from the uh puk of
the extra word by says he could start
counting on the seventh day already.
What does Rebi do for
also it says
so shouldn't that teach me you could
start counting ready on the seventh day
would say no
the is coming to tell me the following
it's to tell me that you could already
start on the eighth day even if you
didn't bring the carbon
you You could bring it on. You could
already start on the eighth day. It's
dependent on the day, not on the carbon.
Okay? It's dependent on the day. Not on
the carbanis.
Don't I know what's going on the eighth
day? No.
The simple reading of the
until you get with the carbon
that it says in the
before it says.
Now the
comes to teacher
day
even though he does not bring his
carbon.
Okay.
Now, so we just said teaches me that you
could start the Nazir Satara already at
the beginning of the day.
What does the beginning of the day mean?
So,
we just had
The Mishna said,
"Who's the Tana?"
Why? Because we need to find the
scenario
where your tum
was
when you're a
and yet you didn't enter the realm of
bringing carbon. So how is that?
How is that possible? It's only possible
in the world of where the you became
tahar on the seventh day. It's depending
on your
on the tiglas. Once you shave your hair,
you're a tahar. But you didn't enter the
realm of carbon. So you only have to
ring one carbon. But according to rebi,
it's not dependent on you don't become
another until the eighth day and at that
point you're ready.
So
established that.
So now
says
what forced
to establish the Mishna like
well we assumed what what forced him was
we're looking for a scenario where you
could start your nazer the Tahara but
you're you didn't enter the realm where
you could bring the carbon
why can't
we say it's rebi
Nitma.
Why can't we say he became T? But he
became the night of the eighth.
He became on the night of the eighth.
And in the world of rebi meaning we're
assuming now that in the world of rebi
teaches that you could already start
counting the ner the night of the
eighth. We think it means the the the
date on the calendar which already
begins the night before. So if it's the
date on the calendar well ultimately
we're going to say no it's the next day.
But if it's the date on the calendar so
then is exactly like
namely I could start my now at night but
I can't bring the karma till the morning
what forced him to establish the mission
like
why don't we establish it for example he
became
he became fit to counter to the night of
the eth
but it's Not yet time to bring the
carbon. It's verbi and it's rebi. Why
can't it be? Why do you have to say
Since we include according to
Even though he didn't bring his carbon,
you can't bring the carbon. Why?
Um
we learned that from
the fact that we didn't establish like
that.
Shall we say the night is not missing in
time?
It's not that you can't bring it at
night, but it's like you already entered
the sha that is of the carbonus. In
other words, what we're asking is why do
you have to say and establish the Michel
Huda? Why can't it be
where he became tame and the night
and you're fit to start counting the
now but you can't bring the carbon until
the morning
the fact he doesn't say
The night is not lacking in time. What
does that mean? That even though
technically you can't bring the carbon
until the morning,
but that's only because there's a D, you
can't bring carbonus at night, but
fundamentally it's like you've already
entered the realm where the carbon is
supposed to be brought. Therefore, if
you became tame now, you're going to
have to bring another carbon. Meaning,
maybe it must be the fact he didn't want
to establish it like rebi because we're
assuming now that the
nazer tahara really could start being
counted now and you don't bring the
carbon till the morning. So, why can't
it be rebi?
Oh, you know why? Because it's like the
obligation of the carbon already hit.
And the Gumar is going to say, "No,
maybe
it's it's like the carbon didn't hit.
The carbon didn't hit. However,
you can't start counting the Nazer yet.
The Nazer can't start yet." Why not?
Because it's not dependent on the
calendar date. It's dependent on the
morning. You can't start in a zerahara
until it's
it's roy to bring the carbon. Meaning
we're assuming now you could start the
zerahara. In that case um this
why is it not covered by the carbon? It
must be because it's like this man of
the carbon already came. No. to which
the garra says
one is dependent on the other.
If you're going to say the night is
lacking in time. So it's like
you could say really is
and it's like the time of the carbon did
not come yet.
and carbon and when are you fit for a
carbon saf
so in that case so then why can't it be
that he became tame at at night
before
you can't start counting the
of yet
and if you're going to say the night is
man. And in that case, it's like,
you already could bring the carbon.
And if you're so if you're going to say
Laya is not
and in that case
you could already bring the carbon at
night. So if you could already bring the
carbon at night. So then the nazir is at
night and you also need to bring another
carbon because it's
so in other words in the beginning we
thought that what that
starts at night
and if that's the case why couldn't you
become tame at night? It must be because
it's like the carbon already came. So no
says no it's not it's not the case.
Maybe I'll tell you
man and the carbon did not come yet. The
of carbon did not come yet. But if the
of didn't come if you became also the
nazir didn't come
and if you're going to say
then
it was night.
So rebi can't fit in.
Let's see.
It can't go like why
amus my carbon if you're going to say
man. So it's like you're in the carbon
already in the nighttime.
If you're gonna say
so you already in the carbon I'm sorry
you're not in the carbon until the
morning. So my carbon
so then the nazir is also not till the
morning
why the
when it's to bring the carbon that's
when the
And then if you became at night
then you didn't even uh it's not even a
separate tum and if you're going to say
is not
and it's so ifa is not
if you're going to say is not musarman
So it's like the carbon came.
So then the is
and then your carbon
because the it's already
of the carbon. So now you're going to
have to bring another carbon. So it
can't be and that's why it had to be.
Okay. So this is the first half of
we'll try tomorrow to do uh
and okay friends
everyone have a great night thanks for
joining call
>> recording stopped
>> okay Good evening everyone.
We're on
B.
We are at an amazing
nugara.
Goofa.
Goofa. Now
this is also interesting. What do you
mean goofa? Gua usually means we said
earlier.
However,
in this case, it doesn't mean that
which is a pela.
What does it mean?
It means we're going to go back to
something we spoke about before, but
we're not actually quoting a that we
mentioned earlier. Okay, go.
If you became on the seventh day
and then you became on the seventh day
again,
you only bring one carbon. So if you
became tame on the seventh day and then
meaning you became tame and then seven
days later you became tame again
and then you became tame again. Seven
days later,
you only bring one carbon.
If you became on the eighth day
and then he became tummy on the eighth
day, maybe carbon,
you bring a carbon for each tum.
Okay? So, if he became tummy on the
eighth day and then he became tummy on
the eighth day again, you bring a carbon
for each tuma separately. Okay? So far
so good.
And what do you do?
You begin and you start counting right
away after you
go through the process of purifying
yourself with the haz then you start
counting right away. Now this implies
now who is this who is this opinion?
This is the opinion of Rabbi Lazar.
Now wait a second. There's the opinion
Rabbi Lazar. But we learned that Rebel
Lazar holds that when you become Tame on
day one, it's not soer.
Rabbi Lesar is of the opinion that you
have it's only so if you have a minimum
of two days only if you become T on the
second day. So what exactly does it mean
that your
wait a second if you became on the
so then what your maybe carbon
you start counting right away.
So then um
there should be no carbon to in this
case
the is according to the carbon to is
only brought if the toma happens on day
two
and here
is saying you're maybe carbon why would
you be carbon
you only may carbon according to if
there are minimum of two days that it's
so So it must be when our blesser says
that your
masad means on the seventh day.
What does that mean?
That means he became T on the eighth day
and he became T on the eighth day.
Must mean that you start counting the T
already on the seventh day. So this way
you have a minimum of seven. Uh this way
you have a minimum of two days. Now wait
a second. You start counting the the
days of Tahara on day seven. Rebi does
not hold. You start counting Tara on day
seven. Rebi holds you start counting
Tara on day eight. So this Razer must be
consistent with uh Rabio Yehuda.
Now I feel very close to Yehuda because
I woke up very very early this morning,
much earlier than I wanted to. and Rabio
I said okay I'm gonna think about rebi
and raihuda
and rahuda did me a very big favor
because that was the last thing that was
in my mind he put me back to sleep so I
feel very comfortable with
raiohuda holds that the tahara already
starts to be counted on day seven as
soon as as soon as you go through the
procedure of
um of sprinkling and cutting the hair.
You don't have to wait for the carbon
tum. So the way you read this isma if
you became tummy on the eighth day and
then you became again on the eighth day.
the eighth day
and he brings a carbon for each
separately
and
and he starts counting his
on day seven.
Now what would the logic of rebel be?
Let's see.
Even though he holds that the nazir
starts on day seven
since he became before the eighth day
which is a time that is to bring his
carbon
he's with one carbon for many
but when he became on the eth day
so it already came the sha to bring his
carbonos, he has to bring a carbon for
each and everyone. In other words, if
you become tame on the seventh day and
then you became tame again on the
seventh day,
you only bring one carbon because you
became tame before the carbon. But if
you were nitma,
you bring a carbon for each one.
Okay. Now,
the next chis, we're not supposed to do
the beginning, but we're going to do it
anyway. We're going to be very
rebellious.
The simple reading of the words indicate
that you start counting the on the eth
day.
It's impossible to say this. Why?
Because if the nazir of does not begin
until the eighth day,
then if you would become on the eighth
day, it would not be at all. If you
start the on the eighth day, then if you
became on the eth day, you would not it
would not be at all.
you would not be at all.
Rather
means on the seventh day.
That's when the
from when they sprinkled the blood and
he immersed
This way when he becomes
it demolishes two days.
Okay, that is the opinion of rebelar
basically subscribing to
back to the carbon.
He brings one carbon for everything.
If he became tame before he brought his
carbon katas. Now a nazir
who became tame brings three carbon kas
asham the of the are of the opinion that
if you became tame no matter how many
times before you bring the carbonas
he brings
one carbon for everything until he
brings his katas heavy katas. If he
brought he became
then he brought
maybe he has to bring a carbon for each
if let's say he brought the but he
didn't bring the asham
he starts counting
the son says Oh,
just like the prevents him. If you
didn't bring the you don't start
counting the zerus again. So too you
have to bring the asham as well. Now the
question is going to be why doesn't
anybody talk about the three carbonates
need to be brought
and well they only talk about the and
the in other words according to
the it's all dependent on the accord to
it's also dependent on the
says
the rabbis
Then does not
until he brings his
heavy
he counts his
reason is learned out close by. We'll
we'll explain what the drasha that they
get it from. But
says
until he brings his
the reason is mentioned nearby.
Okay.
says the bisher.
I understand
again
is
that
if you become on the eighth day and then
on the eighth day. So already came the
sharbon
you bring a carbon for each one.
If you became on the seventh day then
one carbon pers everything.
He will sanctify his hair on that day.
What does it mean on that day? That
means
he starts counting the zerah on the
eighth day.
Uh
carbon even though he did not bring
carbon actually on that day it doesn't
mean the eth day. It means that the
seventh day even though we just had
before even though he doesn't bring out
his carbon meant the eighth day here it
means the seventh day. Looks
extra.
It includes the seventh day.
Then on the seventh day, the nazir
is
like we explained earlier
Now
um
so according to the Pik says
it's mutar
to be
the seventh day
the language
Even though he didn't bring his
carbonas, what it means is as
it doesn't just mean he didn't actually
bring his carbon, he didn't even reach
the day that it's to bring his
not like we said earlier
that according to Rebi
indicates that even though he didn't
actually bring his carbonas as long as
he reached the eighth Yay.
Then
you could start counting the
nob
is including the eighth day.
Okay. So, we got from
that
the eighth day already you start
counting.
What about the rabbis again? The raan
say it's all dependent on the carbonas
on that day. meaning on the eighth day
even though he didn't bring the asham
because the
is mentioned right after the meaning as
long as he brought the it's not vital
that he brought the ashamish
what does come to teach because
according to him according to rabishal
It's not enough to bring the It's not
enough
uh
that you reached the seventh day. It's
not enough
that you brought the katas. You even had
to bring the asham. So what does teach
me
would say
even though you didn't bring the carbon
says
the
doesn't need a
again what does rabbi No, no, no. The
the rabb say even though he didn't bring
the asham, even though he didn't bring
the asham,
still
you could start counting the uh the
right.
So we need a puk to sayan
even though you didn't bring the asham.
Even though you didn't bring the asham
meaning the only carbon that is critical
is the katas. So wait a second and where
do we learn this from? Hah. Well, how do
you know the is not needed
doesn't need to be excluded?
No, you Okay, so let me read it better.
Anah doesn't need to be excluded. Why?
Because an doesn't bring kap an is just
a gift. So I don't need a to say you
know you could count your nazer even if
you didn't bring the because the doesn't
bring kap the is just
the is just a present okay
let's see twice
who
aagra
Even though every
here we learn from the
it comes to teach even though you didn't
bring
but now the has a shahon
what's the logic of the raon
Meaning why taka did raan say
you need the hu he's coming to say even
though you didn't bring the asham
I would think you need to bring the
asham what's the kasha I wouldn't think
you need to bring the asham because
actually it says before the bringing of
the ashan
so why do I need a p of
so we're going to give a different
approach
you made.
It says the heserashem is right. He will
bring a carbon asham to he will make
nazerus to hashem his days of nazerus
and he will bring a kas a year old as an
ash. What is that coming to teach?
It's saying you're going to be a nazir
and then it says after that you'll bring
in asham.
We find all in the
I would think here also the bringing of
the iser.
Therefore, it says you will be a nazer
and then you bring the asham. Meaning
the asham is not the nazir.
Even though you didn't bring iter, you
start counting the nazir. And
what does
do with this heer?
When could you start counting the zeros?
when you bring the carbon cuz according
to
um
he says just like the kata says the
asham is also
let's see tisus and then
we will start dia testim this is this
tois is the top of your
That's what the is talking about.
If so, according to why do I need
typically
if so
according to the raan why do I need
meaning if now we're saying a new theon
don't learn out from that is not they
learn it out from so why do I need
typically
had it not been for
the rabbis
had it not been for I would said it's
only
so therefore
and it's that we should be even though
you didn't bring
the asham so that's why I need both
>> rabbi don't we uh don't we hold that a
is for atonement uh we wink ourselves
like an inasht
is a type of it's mandatory it's not a
gift
twice a day.
Isn't that how we hold today?
>> Does an aa bring
>> It's not a gift. That is for atonement.
>> But it's not directly for atonement.
First of all, the the carbon tid is not
for atonement. The regular carbon t is
not for atonement. And the
in general when it's brought with the
katas it's just a way of appeasing
Hashem that the should be accepted but
it's not directly for atonement usually
although if somebody violates an they do
have to bring a for kapara but in
general it's not it's a different it's
not directly for kapara katos is
directly for kapara
>> I hear you but
the incription Before we say that the um
the in the morning we there's an
introduction we say that it will be
>> everything is shabas is but it's still
not nobody would say the purpose of
shabas is for atonement even though it
brings atonement but nobody would say
that's the objective of shabas. Okay
this is the end of
and now you have the good fortune of
doing
>> recording stop. Okay.