Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
This Torah class is brought [music] to
you by tora anytime.com.
>> Okay. Good evening.
Tonight with Hashem's help, the plan is
we can only try we're going to try to do
um and a half. And this week we'll try
to do a blot and a half. So that next
week we only have an it just uh I think
it might take the edge off. Next week
might be tough. Okay. So here we go.
Um
we're trying to we're addressing the
Shila of Ravashi. Raashi had a question.
Raashi says we know that another who
took upon himself
does not bring a carbon. However, does
he
shave his hair on the seventh day?
That's the sh is there.
We know there's hakas of vatime rois
only someone who became tame brings the
carbon zeros. What about somebody who
became tame? What about someone who took
upon himself the zeros in the basar he
doesn't bring the carbon does he shave
his hair? So the garra tried to bring a
raya from a bry that made a kav
regarding a mitsra.
The garra wanted to know we know that
only tum does not count towards days of
nazeros. What about saras? So the
gamarra wanted to make the lush of the
bry was
um
this is five
son who took upon himself in a cemetery
His hair is primed to be cut for the
Nazeros. And yet
his days of do not count.
His hair is not going to be cut
because of his nazerus.
Meaning we will cut his hair for his
saras. But it's not his nazerus that
demands a haircut. So therefore, this
guy is more further removed from the
whole subject matter of nazerus
altogether cuz there's nothing about his
nazerus which would require his hair to
be cut. Certainly that time should not
count. the Gomorrah. Now, we're harping
on the lion that the Nazir uh his hair
is roy.
What it means is once he becomes tahar
his here is roy and prime to be cut but
not that we would cut his hair when the
here is
says
it's very logical that we're talking
about
why is it logical says
because if you're going to think we're
talking about cutting his hair
If you're going to say what we mean is
that if a
we
where we cut his hair
that the days don't count. Certainly
where we're not cutting his hair from
the days should not count. But the says
his days of of his days of also require
us to cut his hair. Meaning, we're not
going to cut his hair for um
in other words, let's say you have a
nazer who's a
we're going to we're not cutting his
hair for we are going to cut his hair
for
but both a nerv and a
are cutting their hair for tum. So in
that sense they're identical. The gumar
says if we're to it's we're talking
about
because if we're talking about nazer
then
saras and nerma are identical they're
both having their haircut for a process
for a state of tumah and in that case
why is the garra differentiating
in other words what are we saying alo
kosha
How can you say that is not both of
these situations are to have their hair
cut for various tum so it must be no
we're not talking about cutting the hair
of a nazer what we mean is
says no really we're talking
but the differentiation between a nazer
cutting your hair and mats is that a
nuzzer is cutting his hair for for
and is not cutting his hair for neros.
Look in
um
during the days of don't you need to cut
your hair
at the end of your period of being a
confined
is called.
There is no cutting your hair of
because the second cutting
that you cut after you
after you
uh
count the days
is shaving through from
because even in the time of your
counting
So there is no period by of
says
really I'll tell you that a
who accepted the basic shapes his hair
and you're going to say well in that
case then a is equal
And it's not that
the emphasis is shaving
in the cemetery.
His hair is for shaving.
But during the
days of
you don't need to shave because of
and that has no connection to at all
of meaning the still stands because it's
true that is going to cut his hair for
for but not for so therefore the listen
carefully what the kav is kav
is if
who he has connection to Nazeros cuz
he's going to shave his hair for the
Nazeros procedure and yet if he becomes
tummy the days don't count certainly
who's not going to cut his hair for
anything to do with Nazeros the days
should not count okay vom
we're still trying to determine whether
a Nazir be shaves his hair upon the
conclusion of the nazir tash coming
here.
This is really the and the we mentioned
yesterday that when Raashi had the shah
he was not aware of this.
We're talking about
who became
who became that's what we're talking
about.
He has to remove his hair
and bring two birds. But the words
indicates only who became the
exempts who accepted the nazir in the
cemetery.
He doesn't have to remove his hair. He
probably doesn't have to bring carbon.
So here we have explicitly the says that
a ner does not shave his hair. Now had
we not had this I would have thought he
does
really it should have uh you could
really have learned that to say that
does cut his hair.
If a nazer who became
he has to remove his hair and bring the
carbonis meaning a regular nazer who
became tame he has to cut his hair off
and bring the carbon. So then
someone who violated his nazer from the
very onset
isn't that all the more so
that he should require to remove his
hair
and bring the carbon. Meaning if someone
who had the tahara and only violated it
by becoming tame, he goes through the
whole procedure of
cutting his hair and bringing the
carban. only who has accepted the
only
and then became
he's required to remove his and bring
the birds
and to exempt
that
The noir bev
does not not only does he not bring
carbon but he does not cut off his hair.
So here we have it. We have the answer
toasha
wanted to know
does he cut his hair? And the answer is
no. Why? Because there's a bry that says
it's a drussa
thirdis
he's not now it means he started to
count his impurity
then he became
like it says the first days will fall
away the lifter
except in the in the cemetery that he
doesn't have to cut his hair or bring
birds
may
he's also excluded from bringing the
carbon
that it says in that
and that's what it means what it says in
In the Mishna by Nazeroi
maybe carbon tum. He does not bring a
carbon to
because the
now I would have made a
not I would have made a
who becomes has to go through all the
procedure
His
forced him into the procedure
certainly where he was from the
beginning
he's even more
maybe the what is this go change
It's the P is extra. It could have said
why does it say
it's coming to say that? No.
He only cuts his hair if he became tame.
Okay. So now uh we've we've been push
good everyone. How's everybody doing?
Good. [snorts] Great.
Mana. Okay. Verana.
Who's the Tana on the following tanic
statement?
Shazar.
There's no difference between someone
who is tame and accepted upon himself.
Nazir
to and a nazir who became
a nazer who accepted.
He could start counting his nazerus
on clean days on day seven. But
he has to bring his carbon on day eight.
He doesn't bring a carbon to so
therefore his nazer could start counting
on day seven. But
where he has to bring in a zeros on day
eight. So his day seven doesn't count.
Who holds that way?
So based on what we were learning so
far, everybody learns that way. Nobody
disagreed. Everybody held that a nazar
does not bring carbon tum. So you could
start counting your nazeros on day
seven.
said it's
why
says the
is not until the eighth day because on
the eth day he brings his carbon the
tamer
starts on the seventh day. So why would
the say that it starts being counted on
the eighth day? We're going to see only
Rebi holds Nazer is only on day eight
but ra
already begins on day seven.
Why? Because according to us carefully
because according to Rauda
then a zeros is not dependent on the
carbon. It's dependent on the shaving of
the hair. So even though the carbon is
brought on day eight, the shaving of the
hair is brought is done on day seven. So
already on day seven you could start
my
he will sanctify his head on that day
on the day he brings his carbon
says no he starts counting on the day of
his shaving. being
says the holy
that's what it says in the
he'll sanctify his day his head on that
day
we learn
it's the eth
And this is
so the we just quoted goes like rebi
that the reason why the yeahara starts
on day eight is because you have to
first bring your carbon
But no, it doesn't go by that. It goes
by the shaving on the head.
But that which we learned in the Mishna,
listen very carefully.
Nazir
who became with many
will only bring one carbon.
A nazir who be took upon himself many
who became tummy with many tom only
brings
one carbon.
Now why would that be?
Why would he only bring one carbon?
Let's say a guy became a nauseir
and then became tame and then went
through the purification and then
brought a carbon and then became tame
again.
So he has to bring another carbon. Why
would somebody who
contracted many tummas only bring one
carbon? Unless you say he became tame
and then he became tame again and then
he became tame again. Well then it's
obvious he only brings one carbon. So
who is this going like? Montana
says
the newer
is
starts on the seventh day.
How could it? It starts on the seventh
day
and the situation of becoming tame twice
only bringing one carbon
he became tame on the seventh day.
And then he became tame another time on
the seventh day.
So again according to
you know how you could become tummy
twice
and only bring one carbon
it's going according to
where he says the nazerus of Tahara
starts counting being counted again on
the seventh day. And how do you have
such a case? Let's say the guy became
tummy on the seventh day and then
after becoming
let's just read the words.
Nitma Bishvi. He became Tummy on the
seventh day
and then he became tummy again on the
seventh day.
Now what does that mean? Does it he
became tame seven days later or he's
becoming tw tummy twice on the seventh
day? I think it means he's becoming tame
twice on the seventh day. Now why would
he only bring one carbon? Because
technically speaking, let's say he
became
he became tame
and according to Yehuda
Nazir,
he brings the he shaves his hair on the
seventh day and he brings a carbon on
the eighth day and day seven already
starts counting towards his nazer.
the tahara
because he's shaving his hair on that
day. So if on that day
he became tame.
So what would happen if he became tame
on that day? On the seventh day
he had already became tame once. Now he
became tame twice again
on the seventh day.
So the is you know he didn't yet enter
the category of having to bring a carbon
for his because the carbon is not until
the eighth day
since the hour did not emerge that he
has to bring a carbon because that does
not happen till the eighth day
he's only one carbon. So the the case of
becoming t twice in the world and only
bringing um one carbon that exists in
the world of rais
on day seven you could already start
counting the new term. So let's say he
became
tame on day seven.
So if he became dame on day seven, he
really has to bring he has to count
seven clean days and then bring a
carbon. So he counts seven clean days
and then on day seven he shaves his
hair. But if he became tame again
technically speaking he did not yet
enter the category of bringing the
carbon because the carbon is not brought
to the eighth day. So therefore his tuma
is still going to be covered by the
carbon brought on the next day. But
according to why can't it be rebi?
Because if he became tummy on the
seventh day and then he became tummy
again seven days later
then
it's all one tum. So it's it's pur he
brings one carbon because it's not a
nazerus he never entered the realm of
nazerus to tahara inhudaf he became t on
the seventh day so then seven days later
he starts again but he didn't yet enter
the realm of bringing the carbon so if
he became t on the seventh day he only
brings one carbon but he became tahar
and even though he becomes tame So he
only brings one carbon. But in the realm
in the world of Rebi,
he obviously only brings one carbon
because he never became tame twice
says Tyus.
It's on the seventh day.
What is this going on?
Where are these words going on?
When says
that on the seventh day,
he starts counting the newer on the
seventh day.
You know how you have find too many?
He became tummy on the seventh day
after he sprinkled.
The seventh day will count toward the 30
days.
If he became the seventh day,
it's already considered like a newish.
It's not like somebody who after
becoming became tummy then on the sixth
day because that's one long tum
wasn't yet
why could you p yourself with one carbon
he became on the seventh day
he never emerged for an hour
to a day that it was right to bring the
carbon which is the eighth day. If he
would have seen the second time on the
eighth day, then since he could have
already brought a carbon for the first
TA, he would have to bring another
carbon for the second to see the second
time on the eighth day. Therefore, he
could bring one carbon. But according to
Rebi,
if he saw on the seventh day, of course,
he only brings one carbon. It's one
longer.
He's not even fit to start a newish.
It's like becoming on the sixth day.
Why would you call many?
And if he became on the eighth day, of
course, he would bring another carbon.
since he emerged at a time that the
carbonus could have been brought.
It's like someone who became after the
carbon were brought
he definitely would have to bring
another carbon.
uh let's try to uncover what is the
rationale of rebi why does rebi hold
what does rebi hold
that the
a t that became a nazir The seventh day
is
and
why? Because he has to bring the carbon
on the eighth day.
Why does say it doesn't count?
Huda says
the seventh day does count.
You will atone for him because he sinned
against
alive.
Then it says he'll sanctify his head.
What does that teach me?
So again it says you will atone for him
for having sinned against for having
becoming tame. And then it says
then he starts the nazerus again.
Only when in other words only once
you've gotten kapora could you start
counting again. But if you haven't yet
started getting kapora through the
carbon so then you don't start counting
again. You don't start counting again
until there's kapor. It's only
then
says no.
Then it should say he sanctifies his
head.
But it says he sanctifies his head on
that day.
Why does it have to say on that day?
Obviously on that day what does it mean
he starts counting
uh on that day he from the time he
brings his carbon what does it mean
if it's not needed for the day
says that once he is
once he gets
teaches you can already start counting
on the seventh day.
Why the seventh day? Because he's
already pure on the seventh day from
shaving his hair. Let's see.
Then obviously it's all one.
Okay, we did that.
The somebody who became.
So why does it have to say
that
it's obviously talking about the eighth
day the we're talking about the
I'm sorry
it's an extra
to that it's going on the seventh day.
Okay. So that is
alf.
So um we'll start. We'll just go till
the
two dots
or not to the two dots but where it says
gfa.
So we could find that.
Yeah.
Okay. I'm just going to cut it here and
uh this it will be easier.
>> Recording stop.
You've just experienced another Torah
class brought to you by tora
anytime.com.