Alaska Adventure: Seward - When Did Fish Become Permitted For Consumption?

this Tower class is brought to you by torahanytime.com okay back at it with the fish I want to say over what uh we have a very customer rub on the trip and I want to say what a pleasure it's been to have a rather doing whatever Ikea on the trip together with me uh he shares so many beautiful derby toyra and it really has been a big idea for me to be together with him and his Husband Robinson and uh I learned a lot from them first of all the egos that they have over here in this mishwaka you have the bells let's see if I get it right your bills [Music] clingberg M2 no routine clean version which I'm a very big admirer of a safer the rabbit is from the major server the Samsung phone Hirsch yeah how am I doing so far yes yeah not bad and that's that's only mixer so the rock shared with me a beautiful idea from the manager another reason why we eat fish on Shottas and that's because tells us there are three items that were in this operations we know dog him Hashem isabes so it's a triple brother that's another beautiful reason we have fish on Shabbos I also want to mentioned says that the reason we have fish on Shabbos is that we know that gehenam is not showing on Shabbos so you take your hot shower you come out of the gehennam and you're good to go is not sure that on Shabbos the same way the age of the marble was not surely laid on the Duggan we know in the marble the dog and we're saved so to indicate that the fires of gehenam are not operable on Chavez so we have okay now here's your trivia question to win a free copy of the mystery on the Majesty Shabbos I already give you a big hint we say sir and the final pasok we say twice why do we repeat the last person another time why do we repeat anybody know I never knew this my whole life I didn't know this until I saw there's a news safer there's miroskyevsky writes told him based on the magala mukas it was just the yard side of the Galaxy by the way my Robinson is director tells us that there there are every Thriller you say takes an hour and a half which means four and a half hours a day the gehennam is not operable so how many hours a week does not operate well you have 24 hours on Shabbos and then you have four and a half hours a day so throughout the course of the week gehennum only operates 117 hours [Music] there are 112 words in the ocean say again to get to 117 words can I get 170 7 towers that Gahanna operates during the week because what Shabbos is over then it's you know back to that place so to protect from that we we say so and we we say the final plus with five words I want to talk more about the fish you know there's an interesting thing there's an interesting there's an interesting uh idea that until after the marble other mauritian was not allowed to eat meat was not allowed to eat meat mankind was not allowed any meat Adam was not permitted to meet other was only permitted to eat um So Adam was allowed to eat salad and leaves and greens tough existence there you know in Ghanaian but Adam was not permitted to eat meat not until after the Mabel so my bound is troubled okay what happened after the marble though that all of a sudden Adam was a lot of disease says rabban since the animals were only saved in the Merit of of Nayak since the animals were only spirit the animals would have all perished in the marble the the animals that were saved in the Teva were only beshdayak so since they were saved in his house it's only right he should be allowed to eat them by the way there are dark adds not only were they saved in his Merit but he was also matria he also went through the trouble of taking care of the animals so as a reward for caring for the animals now man is allowed to eat for the animals but not the fish the fish survives the mammal so what why is the fish the only reason he's allowed to eat the meat is because he saved them but he didn't save the fish so if he didn't save the fish then why is he allowed to eat the fish so says there this is what they say in sausage was not allowed to eat the fish it was prohibitive for him to eat the fish so when did it become Mr for him to eat the fish at Cabo satara when was the Torah given on Shabbos says nothing is that the reason we eat fished on Shabbos is because fish only became mutter to eat on Shabbos okay but this is a major question because Gamora and Sanhedrin seems to say explicitly that okay maybe you'll give a different answer maybe you'll say that Adam harishime himself was allowed to eat fish from the beginning of creation so maybe the fish didn't become mutter by the Teva maybe the fish were always mother but the grandson hedgens says very clearly that Adam was not allowed to eat the fish so now the question is so when did the fish become mother says that the fish became permitted after the marble I the ramban says the only reason why my wife was allowed to eat the fish is because he cared for the fish maybe it's because he he cared for the animals but was not caring for the fish the fish survived says well we know there's a well-known principle shall I take the NASA voracious Hashem doesn't want to make jealousy if he's eating if other reason was eating moose if Nayak is eating moose and he's eating caribou and he's eating steak then the fish are going to be like you know boasting huh you can't eat meat so in order to keep a certain level of equality Hashem allowed to eat fish as well others say there's a commentary on the ramban the late Sean he says that it wasn't pushed for the fish to survive the only reason the fish survive how did the fish survived the whole Atlantic Ocean was like a burning fire the lips says well the fish escaped they went to a comfortable climate yeah how are the fish able to escape they're only able to escape so even the fishes survival was in the Merit of Nayana so that's another approach that why the fish became permitted others suggest that in fact adavari shine was allowed to eat fish from the very beginning this seems to be the opinion of the even Ezra that other Maurice shine was allowed was indeed allowed to eat fish from the start so next time you have fish if you like one of the earlier sure that we spoke about when uh when you see you see azayas you remember the Sherman because Asim when you see a Kissa Iran when you see a taina when you see a date you remember that the world is a world of Torah every finger represents another halacha you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com