Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Shmita | Part 18 - Treating indoor plants
33 views
This class is covering the topic of how to treating indoor plants during the Shmita The course is ONLY available on at https://atzmut.com/shmita
Categories:Torah
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
[Music]
so i just want to
recap real quick what we learned
yesterday
uh because it it seems like many didn't
really understand the simple explanation
that we did
with the plants
when depending on the
on the
status of the floor so since we're going
to finish today the section
of
indoor plants and i'm just going to very
quickly recap what we spoke yesterday in
very simple words
and it shouldn't be confusing
there are two
ways
or two statuses
of how i consider the floor
i told you the lenient opinion that what
we go by is that once there's tiles on
the floor
tiles cement whatever it is this is
considered a hatchita
a separation from the earth
therefore the
the status of all indoor plants
will be considered like a tzitzsche
nonaku like as if it doesn't have a hole
and the laws of shemitah doesn't apply
inside the house
this is option number one just remember
that when there's tiles on the floor
then no shmita in the house just to keep
it simple
and then there's a more strict opinion
that says no
even when there is tiles
we don't consider that as a khatitsa now
all the laws that we learned in regards
to nakuva nonakov with the whole without
will apply at this point so if you hold
by the floor
that the floor is a khatitsa you don't
doesn't matter not everything that we
learned in the last few glasses doesn't
matter i mean we learned it for the sake
of learning but the status of all your
plants are attitude
like as if it doesn't have a hole
meaning it doesn't have connection to
the ground no laws of shmita apply on
the plant and that's it end of story
now the next option is if i don't hold
by that the floor is a hatita if i hold
by that the floor is not a separation
everything that we learned in the last
five classes will apply now you have to
first determine if the part is
doesn't have a hole if it doesn't have a
hole then we're going back to option
number one laws of shmita don't apply if
it does have a hole then it has to have
a plate or it has to be on a stool or it
has to be on a shelf and so forth and
then i'm allowed to
treat it
like as if there's no schmitta in the
house
so first you have to determine how do i
accept the floor
the floor is
now we have another
concept whether there's a roof or
there's not a roof
here the rules are simple if the plant
is outside under the sky no question
it's like an outdoor plant laws of
shmita apply and the story
and that will be that even if i have a
window and on the window there's a
window seal and on the windowsill i put
a plant and that's directly under the
sky doesn't matter it's under the sky
it's like an outdoor plant all the rules
of shmita apply
so that's the next thing you need to
take into consideration if there's a
roof or if there's not a roof if there's
a roof and it's not underneath the sky
that's it then the plant is an indoor
plant if it's outside outdoor plants
now come a more
a complex
option is that it's under a roof
outside
but there's no ground that's where you
have to start applying all the rules
that we learned now how would be an
option that it's outside with the roof
with no ground that you have a backyard
and there's a grass a lawn or plants and
you have a uh some type of a roof an
awning a a permanent structure
uh
here is very common in israel they call
it a pergola they take a
wood structure they cover it and it's
permanent
and underneath is a exposed earth
then everything that we said yesterday
then it applies because it's under a
roof which means it's a it's a
uh indoor plant but
it's outside
so but it's not under the sky but then i
have the exposed ground
so all the rules that we learned by the
way is when the ground when the earth is
exposed why because if the plant
doesn't have a hole and i put it on the
earth then the roots can't touch the
earth
if it has a hole nakum then eventually
the roots will come out of the hole and
go into the ground and start sucking
water out of the ground that's what i
need to prevent
so if the pot is completely sealed then
i have no problem if the pot has a hole
which is 99 of the pots most spots have
holes then i need a separation
so if it's outside and it's under a roof
and the floor is exposed meaning the
earth is exposed everything that we said
yesterday will apply because it's a
tsitch in a cube
and it's touching the earth which means
that it can nourish
a
liquid from the earth
so you have to always define what what
status my plant has
yesterday we had two options
how do i treat a plant
that is considered a indoor plant
doesn't matter right now in the
cuvolnikov
because if i go by the opinion this is
what you have to this is the rule you
need to remember if i hold by that the
floor is a chatzita
all the plants have the status of
lanakurv
right lona cove no hole why because the
roots will never hit the the the soil
the earth
so rule number one if the floor
i hold by that it's a hattita
a separation all my plants are at siche
and on a cove as long as there's a roof
no shmita laws apply i can move the
plants that's what we talked about
yesterday move it from here to here from
here to here up down hang it move it
because
it's not connection to the ground if i
hold by that the floor is not a hazita
now a whole new
ballgame now i have to define if the
part is open or not open
yesterday what we learned which is
really simple
is if i hold by that the ground is a
hatita
by default all the plants are considered
without a hole then i can move it
wherever i want as much as i want right
once i hold by that the floor is not a
hatsuta then i can move what we learned
yesterday i'm just repeating i can move
the plant from here to here i can move
it from one place to the other that
would be considered a nakuv which means
i am in danger
as long as it's for the sake of cleaning
organizing design and not for the
benefit of the plant move the plant
wherever you want
once i'm moving the plant for the
benefit of the plant like close to a
window as i said to get sun that you're
not allowed
so really what we learned yesterday is
simple just you have to
make a clear definition
and the definition will depend
how do i hold by as the floor if the
floor is a hatsitsa
all my plants are khatic
move it do whatever you want with it
because the laws of shemitah don't apply
if the floor is a hati is not a hatita
then i have to make sure that it's
separated from the ground by a stool by
a ladder by a shelf by a plate then i
can't put it on the floor because it's
going to be very close to the ground and
yesterday what we learned that if i have
came to the conclusion
that the floor is not a chatzita or the
earth is exposed and my plant is nakuv
it has a hole
can i move it from one place to another
yes that's what we learned yesterday as
long as that i don't put it on the floor
so i can move it from the table to the
chair from the chair to the stool but i
can't put it on the floor but how when
am i allowed to put it on the floor if
i'm just doing it
very short just to clean
so really yesterday what we learned
sounds a little bit tricky it's not you
you just need to make in order for us to
conclude this section we're just going
to learn a few more laws and then we can
include indoor plants so just that you
leave with practical
er er
not advice but practical
first you must define
what you hold by and again i'll repeat
myself if the floor is a hat
that's it all the plants are considered
non-aku you treat the plant like as if
it's there's no shemitah unless it's
outside under the sky if the floor is
not a khasita
then i have to all the laws that we
learned in the last few classes that's
considered that she naked and then just
be careful with it how you move it and
where you put it but in our generation
like i told you most hold by the floor
zakatita that's it you have nothing to
worry about
yesterday the day before we learned if
you take the plant out
from the house to the garden that's it
it lost its status
so if you take to consideration that if
you took your plant out
and doesn't matter in the kuvo shenonoku
you took it out to the garden for
whatever reason and it's under the sky
it lost its status now all the laws of
shmita apply on it even if you bring it
back into the house
and vice versa
if the plant was outside and there was a
storm and you wanted to protect it and
you brought it into the house but
originally it had the status of a czech
under the sky that's it it will stay at
seats china under the sky even if you
bring it into the house because you want
to protect it from the snow or the sea
or the hail or the the
the weather
so
this is the rules that you need to
constantly remember if it's under the
sky not under the sky if the floor is a
khatizah not a floor
and again like i told you most hold by
that the floor is a hat
and the only time
that the floor that will be under a roof
that would be considered exposed to soil
is two options option number one what
kind said yesterday that somehow the
tile was removed and the the brick the
the
concrete was exposed which i don't think
that's happening so easy unless
some earthquake i don't know what
explosion or you're drilling then you're
exposing the earth but that's not so
common the only common way is if you
have a backyard you have some type of a
roof that is permanent or it doesn't
have to be permanent like with concrete
but even if it's a
like fabric but it's
sturdy and then you have ground
underneath it then
you will have an exposed ground under
the roof the laws of shemitah might not
apply to it but you have to be careful
because it's exposed ground
then it depends if it's nakuv or nonakov
that's really what you need to follow
now we'll just learn a few more things
to conclude the section and with that
we're done with the plans then we'll go
and continue in other more uh
more sections
so yesterday we spoke about how can i
move the plant in the house i want to
clean i want to remodel i want to design
i want to move the couch over there i
want to move the plant over there so
that's what we talked about when it's in
my house now how is about that i now
live in my home and i move
i move to a different home
can i move the plants from home a to
home b
i mean after all they're going to be now
under the sky
for five minutes ten minutes two hours
that's option number one how about if
now i don't want the plant anymore i
want to put their uh uh i don't know a
sofa and you say i'll take the plant can
i give you that plant it's going from my
home
and with my status to a different home
okay so let's see what the aloha says
a solo team in habitat seats i'm not
allowed to take out of the house a plant
a filo anonyco
even if it doesn't have a hole
and to put it outside
very simple once you have a plant even
if it doesn't have a hole i'm not
allowed to put it outside
vegas
and i'm not allowed to remove the
ceiling above the plants so let's say i
have a porch and on the porch i have
some type of a tent or some type of a
not so permanent roof
then i can't take the roof down i mean
if i take the roof down the plant
changes its status
but how is about when i'm doing it for
the sake of cleaning removing whatever i
don't do it anything for the benefit of
the plants
i don't have a benefit for the plant i
want to do it because i need to clean or
something
but it has to be obvious
that i just took the plant out because
i'm washing the floor
or the plant now i'm taking the roof off
because we're putting a new roof as long
as it's very obvious what's called the
nicara davao that it's obvious that it's
done for that
let's say i have a roof but i need to
remove it because i need to do a sukkah
ah well it's obvious that i'm why i'm
removing the roof for the sukkah then
i'm allowed to do that
so it's pretty simple you're not allowed
to take the plant out of the house
i mean nobody's forcing you to do
anything but the second you took the
plant out of the house it lost its
status on this point on it has the laws
of shemitah applied to it
and you're not allowed to remove the
roof the only time that you're allowed
to do it if it's very obvious that it's
not done for the benefit of the plant
exactly i'm going to now address also
what do you do when you want to buy a
plant
now
mutagla viratsitsnakov
so let's say i go to a store and i see a
nice plant
i pick it up i look underneath has a
hole am i allowed to buy the plant and
bring it home yes
i'm allowed to do that
but ravel yashiv he's very strict about
things like this yes mahm
a drab in our generation passed away
but he was a great posse he says yeah
you allowed to do that but you have to
wrap the entire plant with the plastic
or with nylon
ola
that i have to put something underneath
it
that it will not touch the ground at any
given moment
or you hold it
so the status of the plant will be
considered without a hole
while i'm hauling it from one place to
another so either you carry it either
you put something underneath or yeah it
says cover it with plastic put it in a
big garbage bag
and when i put it into my house
i have to continue or maintain the
status like it's
in nonakov meaning that doesn't have a
hole right away put it on a plate right
away put it
in a way that is won't change its status
if i fail to nothing happen enjoy the
plan but
all the laws of shmita apply to it
now on the same level now we're talking
about a plant how about if i want to buy
for anything any
flowers i have a porch the porch is
completely covered by a ceiling that's a
permanent ceiling you can't move this
ceiling all the flowers flower pots the
the the the places where i have for
flowers i can do whatever i want there
the laws of shmita doesn't apply in my
in my porch i can plant new ones so how
would i go now and buy new plants first
of all it has to be done in a careful
way that people from the outside won't
look and be like hey what is the
planting here in the middle of shemitah
not everybody knows all the rules and
nobody's sitting here and learning has
to be done in a way what's called
maritime but nevertheless
how is about when i want to buy plants
so it says as follows
i'm allowed to buy plants in a nursery
when am i not allowed to buy plants
shenishtal beshmita
that it was planted in the ground
or in a pot that has a hole during
shemitah
so i have to actually go to a nursery
either their
observant of the laws and they will be
able to tell me oh i have to tell them i
like these flowers
when were they planted
if they tell me it was planted during
shemitah and either directly to the
ground or in a pot that it was with a
hole sorry you can't buy it
now usually in a nursery you're not
going to have a
nice spot they have it in like these
plastic cups but that's that's has the
status of it so it's the coop because it
has holes underneath
so you have to make sure where you're
buying it from so you're allowed to buy
as long as it was not planted during
shemitah directly on the ground or in a
pot that has a hole
yes
and
now we'll have another option what if
you bought it to me as a present
i didn't buy it you came high you the
house warming gift or whatever you know
that i like flowers you bought me some
flowers to plant not only the flowers to
put in a vase i'm talking about the
flowers to to plants here is calling it
because it doesn't have to be an
electricity flowers can be any type of a
plant that is for beauty not for eating
so some will be more strict and will not
accept as a present
next
agadel bertitsch
i was about if i have a plant
and it ha it's growing in a pot that
doesn't have a hole and no
this is not
prohibited from what's called sephirin
we're going to have to make a another
class separately about that although i
touched it in the beginning
is when things grow by themselves
why because last year when i planted
some of the seeds fell around
or sometimes
you know the flowers they dry
they they fall down and from that grows
new flowers
this is called sephirim
that something grew i didn't i didn't
plant it i didn't do anything it just
grew
so
in some of the cases that would be
prohibited for me
and the laws of shmita will not allow me
to do anything with that plan
when it comes to what i said now
if let's say i have a plant and it
doesn't have a hole and somehow grew
more of it then what does he say
there's no prohibition here where it's
called sufficient
and last but not least
uh that will have to elaborate uh in a
different class when it comes to
to hydroponics but here is referring to
how do you deal with the plants inside
the house that grows in water so it says
as follows that's it's
mine
how's about when i have a plant that
only has water doesn't have any soil in
it
it still has the status
like as if it has soil in it
therefore you're not allowed to take a
uh
like a jar take the
pit of an avocado what you put like
something sticks to hold it and then it
starts sprouting
exactly like a batata batata i think how
would you call it sweet potato
but there's a condition
if we follow all the rules in section
four what we learned two days ago then
you're allowed to and what are going
what are going to be these sections that
it's not touching the ground the leaves
don't fall everything that we learned in
section four so if
all the rules in section four are
applied then you can do it if not then
it will have a status like if it has
soil and then i'm not allowed to do that
and with that we're not going to touch
hydroponics today
we're going to have to dedicate a class
just for hydroponics because
technically
the hydroponics is no problem in doing
it in the house because it's water it's
above the ground doesn't touch soil and
so forth but we're talking about when we
don't apply all these rules then i
should consider it like as if it has
soil and therefore uh not allowed to do
that
with that we conclude the section of
indoor plants i'm just going to recap
very quickly that you have it uh
strong in your mind
first rule that you need to know is
what's the status of the floor if you
hold by the floor that is a khati tower
not if the floor is a katita separation
doesn't matter if you have 50
centimeters of concrete of five
centimeters of uh of a tile doesn't
matter if i hold by that the floor is
kazita
then it doesn't matter all my plants are
considered a tzitzier nonaku like it
doesn't have a hole as long as there's a
roof laws of shmita don't apply on these
plants i can do whatever i want with
them if i hold by that the floor is not
a hatchita then i have to make sure that
that seats the plant is
doesn't have a hole if it is nakub then
the all the laws apply it has to have a
plate or separation higher from the
floor and so forth if it's
doesn't have a hole that doesn't have a
hole i have no problem it's in the house
and the laws of shmitah will not apply
same thing with outdoors as long as it's
under the sky all the laws of shemitah
apply there's a roof that's covering it
and like we spoke yesterday it's hard
for me to explain it uh verbally you
have to see it but if you go to my house
if you're standing on the side and you
see the wall the wall has a lot of
plants in it if you look directly up
like that then there's 60 centimeters of
a roof coming out of it that's
considered not under the sky
so like you said yesterday the part that
broke probably from the storm i can fix
it it's under it's literally if you look
it's under the little part of the
ceiling that goes out if i wouldn't have
that then it's under the sky you can't
take care of it loads of shmita apply
and then of course when when it's
outdoors then i have to make sure that
the ground is not exposed the soil
and all the rest is pretty simple
when it comes to growing things in the
house that will dedicate zippered class
for hydroponics or growing other things
in the house because if i have just
hypothetically and real quick if i hold
by the the ground is uh
and i have a roof and all the laws what
we learned that doesn't apply the loves
of shemitah that i can grow you know
herbs
i can grow an idle thing in my house
might not grow so well but some things
you can grow in your house with no
problem usually herbs and stuff like
that you can't really grow with trees
but maybe small bushes
if it has good daylight not not direct
sun but daylight but then you're allowed
to do it because your house is uh out of
the restriction of shemitah
in another section we're going to learn
next section i think what we're going to
learn i wanted to skip and do
more about fruits and vegetables in the
house but we're going to learn how do
you deal with this when you build what's
called the hamama greenhouse
specifically
for
me am i allowed to do that it's kind of
like my house it has a roof it's an
extension of my house oh it's in my
backyard so we'll learn that too because
these are the loopholes how you can grow
things
and
and continue
enjoying your fruits and vegetables
during the shemitah
[Music]