Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Shmita | Part 15 - Treating indoor plants
42 views
This class is covering the topic of how to treating indoor plants during the Shmita The course is ONLY available on at https://atzmut.com/shmita
Categories:Torah
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
[Music]
so yesterday we started learning about
the laws
of
plants that you have inside the house
i want to just quickly uh recap what we
talked about yesterday and then to
continue
so
there are two major things that we need
to focus on when i have a plant inside
the house
if it's in the house or under a roof
then that's considered part of my house
and the rules to the plant will apply
according to the fact that it's in the
house
once that i took it out of the house and
it's in the porch
or in a
terrace or backyard
once it's under the sky already that's
it it loses its status
from being a home plant a urban plants
and then the the the rules are going to
be completely different
and if we make it today we're going to
learn what happens when you take a plant
in and out
or out and in and what's going to be the
rule for that
but as long as the plant is in the house
then the rules apply according to its
when it's in the house once it's outside
it changes its status and the rules are
completely different we concluded
yesterday that once it's outside you
treat it like any other plant that is
connected to the ground doesn't matter
if the pot has a hole it doesn't have a
hole once it's out that's it it's out
and it has the rules of outside like a
plant that is connected to the ground
doesn't matter if you put it on a stool
if you put it hanging up it doesn't
matter what way you put the plant
outside as long as it's exposed
completely underneath the sky that's it
it loses its status
once it's in the house then we have two
options
one of them is when the pot has a hole
and the other one is when the pot
doesn't have a hole
the one that has a hole called nakuv the
one that doesn't have a hole called
lonakov we concluded yesterday and
explained that even if the hole is a
millimeter
that's still considered that it has a
hole and it will have the status of
nakul
today we're going to explain a little
bit more in depth that once it has some
type of a separation
between the plant
that's in most cases will have the
status of lanakul of without a hole and
therefore the plant inside the house is
considered that it's not connected to
the ground and therefore you can treat
it like any other plant any other year
because it's like it's not connected to
the ground
so really the the main definition that
we need to understand inside the house
is nakuv velonakov naku means it's
punctured it has a hole lanaku doesn't
have a hole and the size of it can go as
little as a millimeter that will be
considered nakul that's the first thing
that we need to remember
now
when we have a plan that the status of
it is a nonaku doesn't have a hole
it doesn't necessarily mean that it does
does or doesn't have a hole because
let's say it does have a hole and again
i gave you the example last time with
the plant over there it does have a hole
so hypothetically one might say this is
lanaku this is nakuv it's punctuated it
has a hole then it means the status is
different so we said
a planted that doesn't uh that's
considered
if
it has some type of a separation this is
called
between the soil and the plant because
it has to have soil and a plant
right because any plant will have the
actual plant and its roots inside soil
and then it will have the pots
if there's a separation between the the
soil and the plants to the ground this
is considered
a separation and then the status of it
with the hole will be considered like it
doesn't have a hole
so i just wanted to elaborate on that
because it seems like yesterday wasn't
so clear now
if this is the case now imagine i have a
plan we're talking about plants inside
the house we already concluded if it's
in the outside the house it's in the
porch it's on the terrace it's on the
veranda under the sky there's nothing to
talk about here
it's pretty simple once it's in the
house
then we have one option
if it has
a
does have a hole doesn't have a hole
doesn't matter but its status
is as if it doesn't have a hole lonakum
you can treat it like any other year
so right now your job inside the house
is to figure out if it has a hole or
doesn't have a hole now it's important
to have the basic uh
uh you know it very well because when
we're going to start learning when you
start growing herbs in the house
mint nana
basil whatever it is you can grow
certain things in the house but all the
rules will apply with a little bit of
difference same thing with same thing
with hydrophonic and many others so you
got to get the basic rules set
out of the house out of the picture in
the house with or without the hole but
has a status of without a hole i'm just
going to say the word glonachov then you
treat it like any other year so now it's
what's up to you is to figure out how do
you determine the status
so it says it follows yesh has
to
master this section
i need to know how do i determine the
status of it not if it has a hole or
doesn't have a hole because 99.9 of the
pots will have holes in order for the
water to come out but that's not what we
go by we go by the status of it
and yesterday i explained to you if it's
on a
on a shelf if it's on a stand if it's
hanging
and with different conditions if the
leaves fall down and they fall on the
ground they don't fall on the ground
they touch the ground i don't want to
repeat everything i just want to repeat
what was not so
clear
now we have two options in the plants in
the house
one of them
the first group and it doesn't matter it
can be a tree it can be a bush and it
can be a plant and it can be flowers it
doesn't matter what it is and of course
it's not going to really work what i'm
saying now with flowers because the
first group is if the the
the stem or the
the
the stock you know if it looks like wood
or it's hard
this is one group
now if it looks like wood because you
can have a bush inside your house
you can have a little tree in the house
what it
doesn't uh
it doesn't matter it doesn't have to be
in the ground
i have a hadasim how do you say hadas in
english
[Music]
myrtle
yes so i have a bush of a hadas of the
myrtle and the stem it's not really a
stem it's more it looks like a trunk it
looks like wood
so this is a bush it's this big but if
it's inside the house there's no problem
for it to be in the house
so group number one
if the trunk sorry the trunk the stem
the the the stock it looks like wood or
it's hard
then uh it depends on the type of the
pot you have
if it's something hard like wood
metal
steel glass
a
very strong plastic
then
this will be considered lona cove it
will be considered like it doesn't have
a hole even if you have a hole
why because the we need an option for
the not for the water to come out for
the roots to come out water is not that
doesn't bother me the water if it comes
out what concerns me is if the roots are
going out
so if i have
and this will be the more extreme group
that can be a tree a bush whatever it is
and the trunk the stem the stock looks
like wood is wood or hard like wood
and the pot is very very
strong steel wood glass and so etc the
status of it is on a cove like as if it
doesn't have a hole why because these
roots cannot come out
now if i have a bush flowers whatever it
is and the stem but the stalk is very
soft then doesn't matter what it's in it
will be considered lanakult
now what do i mean something else it can
be in a bag it can be in hay straw
very soft plastic whatever it is
then doesn't matter
what it's in they will have the status
of lorna cove
without a hole which means from what we
take from that that most of the plants
in the house
we'll have the status of lona cove
now if you remember i added on that
what happened said
that that's what we go by that if you
what we're talking here we're talking
about a house for 400 years ago when the
floor is the floor is uh
the earth then you have a problem
because the roots can touch the earth
and that's it it will get connected
but today when we have tiles and we have
cement
you're not connected to the ground
whether you want it or not that's your
hat
so all the everything in your house is
not connected to the ground so he gives
a more of a homura by saying hey it has
to have tiles and a cement floor and
more than and by the way in israel all
this all the floors are cement they
don't build like in america or in europe
when they the the construction is from
wood
all the houses in israel are cement
you're not going to find any house in
israel that the floor is not cement
a they're building it for wars for bomb
bombing earthquakes and so forth but
that's the style of construction and
shmitan laws apply in israel so it
doesn't matter outside of israel in
america some of the houses are built
that the floor is wood
here we're looking at israel
so
the rabbi says if the floor is cement
and it's supported by pillars
then you have no problem to start with
now even if your house is attached to
the ground
but most of the houses in order to
support the building or the house it has
pillars drilled into the ground and
that's your pillows that are connected
that are elevating you from the ground
so anyways you are not going to have a
status of lanaku so you technically have
nothing to worry about when do we have
what to worry about is when the leaves
fall down
right if you have a plant the leaves
starting to fall down and then they
start touching the ground so again
where will this supply believe it or not
there are some houses that they have
like a little uh a
plant area that's in the house's sand
if it falls on a tile then of course
it's not touching the ground you're not
gonna have a problem but how is it about
if you have like a porch or something
and you closed it
and it's connected to the ground or it's
kind of ground that is like i'm not
talking right now that you have a very
big
pot
because if you remember yesterday i told
you for big pots if they're drilled into
the ground or if you can't move them
that's considered luna cove
but
like i gave you example yesterday in my
porch it looks like a big garden it's
not it's it's a cement floor on pillars
and it's just big
i mean it's built in so there is soil
there but it's not connected to the
ground now what will be the status of
that and it's on pillars and cement so
what if there's a lot of soil and
there's a roof
that's it status is very simple lona
cove even if it's a lot and and and you
treat it like any other year now
uh a pot that doesn't have a hole
here is a very important rule a pot a
plant that doesn't have a hole
or the status of doesn't have a hole
it's not enough that the base and the
pot
and of course the soil and the plant
itself is separated from the ground it's
also important that the leaves not
falling on the ground remember we talked
about it yesterday
which means the the leaves whatever it
is cannot fall on the ground
the fats
and what if happens if the plant starts
falling down the leaves um
and it starts touching the ground
it will have the status of a plant that
is growing from the ground
but again like i told you yesterday
we're learning now the rules
all the rules that's if it's touching
sand the actual
ground
if he falls on a tile and the the floor
is cement especially if you're on
pillars and if you on the second third
fourth floor then you have no problem
but it's important that you know the
rules
and another important rule at sitsnakuv
wow is about when you have a pot that
has a hole
have a fridge
when it's sitting on a stool
or stand on the table it's separated
from the ground
the nokia tits
then it's status like a pot that doesn't
have a hole so as long as you have your
parts on some type of a stool a stand
and so forth and by the way like i told
you the plate that's on the bottom to
capture the water that's considered the
hatchita a separation then the thing the
judge the rule the status of the pot not
a coup no problem
sometimes you have plants and when they
grow some plants grow straight up some
plants they start falling down and then
the leaves start touching the ground now
that they got separated from the plant
if they're separated from the plant you
just throw it to the garbage they'll dry
up but if they're still connected to the
plant and they fall on the ground and
start touching the ground
then that will have a problem status now
let me give you one example maybe we
should take pictures for the ones on the
video not on my house after and look at
the
the wall around the house facing the
street and there's pot pots uh like
flower pots there right if you look one
of them and that's connected to the
ground by the way it's because that's
all the way down to the ground
now if you look at one of them i saw the
other day that the plants that went out
there went all around down on the
on the
wall and they're on the ground already
now but if you stand really exactly
where it is and you look up you'll see
that the roof is going a little bit out
of it above it
then then it's underneath the roof
if the roof would not be there
then once and those flower pots they re
they actually touch the ground there's
no cement in the bottom they go all the
way down even though they're very very
high
but since that little whatever it's
maybe 60 centimeters uh two feet that is
uh
above it then it's underneath the roof
it means i can treat it excuse me
it has to be on top of it so let's say
this is the line of the plant has to be
on top of it listen yesterday was
raining the water came all the way into
the house
but as long as the roof is covering it
that's it
now if they wouldn't have the roof then
i wouldn't be able to treat it like a
pot from inside the house it means i
have to treat it like a
flowers or a plant in the year of
shemitah
because it's also touching the ground
that's it it's mamas no gerbakarka
but since i have the roof it changes its
status it's part of the house i can
treat it like any other year
then i'm going to have to make sure that
i'm cutting it that it's not going to
grow out of the roof line although you
go by where the roots are
but
in order to be cautious yeah i will have
to trim it all the time
that it's not going to start running out
of the of the
border of the roof a hundred percent
with no doubt
with that said that was a little recap
and preparation and an intro what we
learned yesterday now let's go to
another section
now let's make a definition and a clear
understanding
when i have a plant the plant is in a
pot has to be in a pot you can't have it
not in a pot all the soil will start
falling apart
so sometimes you buy it from the nursery
in a bag
right that's why i said before it
depends what's in the bag now if you buy
it in a bag and you bring it home
and you and the stem is hard then we
said that's like it's
like the coop sorry with the hole if
it's soft it's like it doesn't have all
but let's say right now forget about the
bag we have a plant i have soil and it's
in a pot now i need to make clear what's
the status of with the hole and without
a hole
la de ocho bubba say fakudem for the
opinions that we explained in the
previous chapter
there are some opinions that say
the floor of the house
is not considered a hazita
from the plants to the soil
we go by that it does but how is about
with the opinions it says mapitom so
what if you have a tile and 60
centimeters of cement but it's not a
hotel
to be considered without a hole then i
have to have the conditions what we
explained before
separation from the ground remember what
we said yesterday i'll repeat it has to
be on a stool it has to be separated
from the actual tile because we said one
opinion would we go by that as long as
we're on pillars and the cement the
floor is cement and i have tiles no
problem i'm above the ground but there
will be opinions says no no no no the
ground is not a hatita
the ground is not
so in order for me to have a status of
lornaku noho then i have to have the
conditions if you remember the condition
has to have the separation has to be
above if you remember yesterday they
said no
air underneath the leaves can't touch
the ground and so forth
kadeshi
nonakov in order for it to be considered
without a hole why do i care if it's
with or without a hole le tape elbo
because i don't want to have the rules
of shmita for it for the plants in the
house which means that if i want to
treat it like any other year and i go by
that the floor is not a separation then
i have to follow the rules would be
learned yesterday and what i just
repeated
how would i do that the major rule is
is that the part should not have a hole
and the part or the the pot that's
holding the pan should be
with a strong material that will
consider zakatita
metal
uh
wood
glass and so forth clay doesn't count
clay was not considered a hattita if you
remember i said yesterday that clay is
in the same status of a bag
okay
the other option is to have some type of
a separation between the plant
the pot and the ground so that can be a
plate there can be a stool can be some
type of iraq
you figure it out
figure it out i mean you decide how you
want to
elevate it
and of course
the whatever has to be whatever is going
to be the separation
so the whatever i use as a katita has to
have a very strong material it can be
plastic but as long as the the roots
don't go through it
so what do we use today some people put
a piece of plastic some people put a
plate and so forth
now how is about
when the floor in the house she bites
off because
now imagine i'm on the second floor and
up
you're saying
is a very high floor but let's say
second floor and up i'm totally above
the ground not like here here it looks
like we're on the ground but believe it
or not there's something underneath us
but
it's fat is not a good example because
you don't know what's underneath you you
can go now 50 meters beneath you and
you'll find things but
let me assuming in a regular town in
israel let's say some of the houses are
connected to the ground so he says some
of the houses when the house is paved
with tiles
because
when it's above the ground
must speak like
it's
a smaller it's
what's enough is to have a separation
between the floor and the plot and the
plant that's it
and that would be usually done with a
plate
must speak like
it's smaller it's bites enough to have a
separation between the plant and the
floor the enzo chlakpitel khatitsa bin
no fat seeds
pa and you don't need to have a
separation between the floor the tiles
and the leaves
remember because in the house you can
have a plant that the leaves fall on the
ground but you don't need that
because you have the separation between
the pot and where whatever base it's on
and that's it
and even if the plants you know here is
not a good example that one on the
corner you see the
the leaves kind of go up right and then
the one next to it it's not a good
example but you see the leaves are kind
of falling down so even if the leaves
are falling down and there's a
separation a big separation between the
leaves in the ground that's it the judge
the the status will be like without a
hole i have no problem
dino que no naco the status of it like
it doesn't have a hole and then you can
treat it like any other year
what you need to uh pay attention is is
that the separation is between the roots
and the soil on the ground that's what
you need to worry about
the second that you see an option that
the roots will touch the soil in the
ground
that's it it doesn't matter what you're
going to do that is considered a problem
next
now what is about well i have a plant i
figured it out that the status of it
doesn't have a hole or on the other
hand i figured out that it does have a
hole but what if the
the the status changes
somehow i had a part without a hole
somehow my cleaning lady came with the
drill and drilled a hole in it well the
status changed now oh you know now i'm
making a joke but let's say the part
failed got a crack
let's say it's a hard plastic but still
was getting a crack or something happens
at seats
sheena kev when i have a pot
when it's considered without a hole and
suddenly becomes a whole
ocean
now
yeah another one option is that i
suddenly have a hole another option is
that somehow
the branches came out or the roots came
out out of the soil and came down and
suddenly they touched the ground
no question the status changes right on
the spot now it's a part a plant that is
punctured
and that's it and there's no you can't
reverse it that's it it's changing it
changes status and that's the status it
will stay
i was about a tits nakup chinese stamina
bomb
the other way around
i have a pond that had a hole
and somehow the whole clothes
for whatever reason i don't know my
cleaning lady came with super glue and
glued it or something happened
now
now i'm joking of course but let's say i
have a pot and suddenly i change its
status by putting a hat underneath i i
have a separation and i elevated it and
it's in a stool on a on a
shelf
now what happens is now i separate it
from the ground
the normal attack attention then i
change its status
all it took is to put a plate underneath
and i change the status
but this will only be considered when i
want to treat the plants like any other
ear with putting a
fertilizer cutting the leaves and so
forth and just to give you a side note
we're talking about a house that the
floor is soil
and some people will go by the soil not
soil that will be the status
but i can tell you already that most go
by the lenient opinion we go by that the
floor cement tiles you have no problem
next
video
i'm allowed to gather the leaves gather
the
roots gather the branches whatever and
kind of fold it all up and then put
underneath
separation to change its status so i'm
allowed to initiate it by myself
something happens i forgot the plans oh
my gosh it's a day after rosh hashanah
what am i going to do i forgot it
in such a way i'm allowed to initiate
the change and to put a separation and i
changed its status
next
no no no no that you can't do you can
dig from the outside we're talking about
everything that is in the house
and we're no no this we're not gonna
have time today we'll do another class
you can't bring you can
but you but you're gonna have the same
status if i bring now a plant from
outside inside the house
because i think that the cold weather is
going to kill it or there's a saying in
the forecast is going to be hail and i
bring it into the house i just brought
it to protect it because i'm allowed to
protect my plants outside
but the status will stay the same
doesn't matter what you're going to do
to it it stay it start came from the
outside you're allowed to do that if you
know now the forecast is saying it's
going to be severe
storm you want to bring some of the pots
inside some of the plants go ahead bring
them but you can't it doesn't change its
status we're talking about inside the
house
when you
have
you change from a status of with a hole
and you want to change it to without a
hole
[Music]
you