Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00

Shmita in the kitchen | Part 2 - Leave it as is

13 views
Rabbi Alon Anava avatar
Rabbi Alon Anava

Transcript

Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.

[Music] we're going to continue learning with the laws of shemitah today we're going to start learning a little bit how do you eat the fruit and vegetables of shemitah because there are in this section in this part there are three sections and it's not that any fruit of jewish you just put in your mouth and you eat there's ways of eating it and without too much explanations let's explain first of all how do you eat the fruit and the vegetables of shmita and the title is eating the fruit or the vegetables whether raw or cooked and it says as follows the way to eat the fruits and vegetables of sweet is only to eat it in the way that it has to be eaten and he will explain call me every every specie every type according to how it has to be eaten what does it mean according to how it has to be eaten if something will be eaten the way to eat it is raw for example orange avocado radish and so forth then you can cook it you have to eat it how it how it's eaten raw davao del college something that is way to be eaten cooked for example a potato you don't need raw potatoes then you cook it then you have to cook it same thing with he says bhutnim peanuts and so forth and when it comes to pickled food or fermented food that's how you have to eat it bro saying in other words the way you eat it usually that's how you have to eat the fruit of sweets about when some things you eat either pickled or either raw like a carrot then if you can eat it in both ways then it's fine to eat it in both ways [Music] what's going to happen if i made a mistake and i ate something uh i cooked something that is usually eaten raw okay then i transgressed the the the provision of then the the dish is not prohibited to eat like when you buy mistake cook on shabbat and you can eat it the wholes manchester and as long as it's edible a dino so if i made a mistake by mistake and i ate something raw when it has to be cooked or something cooked when it has to be eaten raw then then i can i will stop of course but nevertheless the food can be eaten and it has to do with it on it next there are three ways how we uh so to say cook things one of them is baking it's called afiya the other one is celia called grilling and the third one is called cooking all these three they're all considered as one way of eating saying in other words kolshodar if i'm allowed to cook it then i can grill it if i can grill it then i can bake it which means it's all considering the same thing it's not that one boy say oh i can bake but i can't grill cooking grilling and baking are all considered the same uv meat but the condition is is that i don't spoil the food which means if you remember in last class we spoke and said that if i'm now cooking in oil that is from chevits in order to better another dish but i'm spoiling the oil i'm not allowed to do that here he says the same thing as long as i don't spoil the food then i can cook bake or fry or or grill it doesn't matter next davao dal cola if something you eat it normally raw what would you eat normally raw a cucumber right nothing wrong with eating a cucumber but i'm not allowed to pickle it so if i'm usually eating a cucumber raw i don't cook it i don't bake it right usually you eat cucumbers raw so here it says if the way to eat it is wrong then i can't pickle it so i can make pickles on sweets but if this is not the only way my one might say what are you talking about i cook cucumbers all the time okay if you cook cucumbers then fine but if you it's not a way you're eating cucumbers i don't know people cook cucumbers but nevertheless we're the vouchers we share so but if the way to eat it is by pickling it or fermenting it then i can't cook it okay and the thing is the the rabalyashiv adds on that legume when you're going more streaked then it says kavushka vushal pickled is like cooked and if i want to go lenient then they don't say pickled is like cooked saying in other words if the way is to eat it raw then you can pickle it if the only way of eating it is pickled then you can't cook it okay pretty simple next year no sorry sorry i skipped one by mistake now we're talking about first allah we said if the way to eat the cucumber is to eat it raw then i can't pickle it but what if somebody will come and say i don't know what you're talking about i always cook my cucumbers then he will come and say ah i'm always cooking my cucumbers must be then i can pickle it so now he says no no no wait a minute if you're coming up with some new version then it has to be a substantial amount of people who do it it's not only you invented it okay if there's a group but a big group that eats a certain fruit or vegetable in a certain way that many others don't eat but there's still a group that eat it then that is considered let's consider how you're eating it okay a group of people it's a minority and you can't call it a way of eating how many people will come and tell you oh yeah i grill my cucumbers all the time i don't know many people who grill cucumbers maybe you grill zucchini or maybe you grill a tomato i never heard of somebody grilling a cucumber so maybe one person who says uh no objection i grill cucumbers okay but you're a minority you have to have a substantial amount of people say yeah yeah we all do that ah if there's a substantial amount of people who do this weird way of cooking then i can come and say okay there's a lot of people who do that then fine but find that amount of people come and tell you oh yeah i grill cherries all the time i don't know we will grill cherries and if you already find a group of people who tell you yeah we grill cherries all the time then it has to be all the time it's not like once a year it has to be something that is done like coming some with some cuisine from uzbekistan and they do they i don't know they grill the cherries i'm saying i'm making up something that it has to be something that is unheard of okay so if you you know like i said boil cucumbers who eats boiled cucumbers so one person will say listen with with potatoes i will fry them okay so you make french fries another person says i boil i grill them i make a baked potato another person will say oh no i make mashed potatoes so these are all accepted objective acceptable by people but to come and say i uh do something i boil cucumbers ah that's your own distortion you can't that's not a way of eating it and so the rules if you're coming with some weird and new cuisine it has to be at least a nice amount of people who do it and it has to be something constant not like once every seven years we have this dish then then you're allowed to change the form of it all this we're talking about is changing the form like i told you if to eat the cucumber raw you can pickle it and we're and so forth vegetarians you have a nice amount of people who say listen i eat the vegetables in a certain way and vegetarian or what's the other name vegan and someone said listen i don't i eat it like how i eat it yeah but you have thousands of people doing it so that's not considered here he says something interesting he says ah the vegetarians the vegans they're the exception here is because they're eating it for healthy eating and that's considered medicine and not considered a natural way of eating therefore that's acceptable acceptable and they can do it so the rule is that you can't eat or prepare a certain food if it's not acceptable by most people if you have your own invention then i'm sorry to tell you that is not sufficient to change now the way of eating it and like i said we have cooking grilling baking and so forth it has to match and if it's something that it doesn't and you don't do it regularly then you can't do it like i told you i give you keep giving you the example of the cucumbers people don't boil cucumbers you eat the cucumbers raw therefore if you if most people eat the cucumbers raw must be therefore we learn you can pick all the cucumbers where are you going to get your pickles then you have to do it from last year and put it in jars and you'll have pickles from last year next i explained already a couple classes that the problem with we have in our generation generation with wine is if the wine is used for any type of idolatry or what's called naisek then you can't uh make you douche on the wine can drink the wine but can make it and i said that in our generation most of the wine is not kosher to be very careful with the wine you buy now yay the translation of nesser is libation or libation that is used for some idolatry now what do they do in our generation with wine not in our generation all generations if i want to make sure let's say i want to move now the wine from one place to another if i make my own wine and i hide it in the cellar and nobody touches it a non-jew doesn't do any uh idolatry on it then it's fine i drink it it's called yarin lomi bouchard not cooked but let's say i want to move it from country to country or how do i eat what do i do then i cook it it's called me bushel now when the yarn is in order to prevent it to become yanesa why because the taste is now spoiled it's not the same taste but i'm allowed to pasteurize wine or grape juice and to put it in closed bottles so very important if you make your own wine and you make we ein of chevy eat which is allowed and i can't cook it and if you find cooked yarn of chevit then you know it's not kosher don't don't drink it because you know how to do that next mutaglasimiyano meets the pusim i'm allowed to take a a wine or a juice and to put it in a cake or any type of dish to add a flavor yes now comes a big question i'm not allowed to cancel or override the flavor right that's the rule of of the shmitah i can't spoil the taste so now comes the big question do i put a large amount of the juice of the wine so the flavor will be noticeable or is it sufficient to put enough and this comes already says ish ladoon means now let's open it up and let's start debating here but in general i'm allowed to take some wine and to put in the dish that i want to give it some flavor or he says orange juice to put in a cake or whatever you want it doesn't have to be limited to these though next number seven tavlinim now tavlin there's many ways of translating it one of it is flavoring seasoning condiments this is doubly name anything that i add some of the spices all the flavoring i can eat it by itself i don't need to to add it what is what is a what would be considered seasoning that i'm allowed to eat by itself onion most people don't eat an onion some people will eat the onion i don't know so many people will do it but i've seen people done it and some people eat it raw but most people put an onion to give flavor so it says even if the onion you can eat it by itself but usually i would put it to add flavor i'm allowed to put it in a dish in order to give it flavor even if later on i take the onion out and throw it now where do you see that i don't know the word the names in english but some people put dill or or let's say parsley in a soup or they put a leek in a soup to give a taste and then they take the leek on the parsley and throw it out right so one might say i'm not allowed to do that because i'm spoiling the taste in order to give taste to another thing that's what we learned last class and then i throw it so he says no no no even though you can eat it separately but you're using it to give taste and later on the taste will be spoiled or if it's not edible you're allowed to do that ahmad khalim sharokly but other types of spices of flavoring or seasoning that usually you just use it to flavor the food but very few people will actually eat it then you're allowed to do it only if the seasoning or the condiment is later on edible that you can separately take it out and eat it if it's not edible then you can't do that next mortality tag you're allowed to uh fry in oil of chevy heat next mutaglia because a fruit some people dry grapes and it becomes a grape raisin some people dry figs and dates apple plums people dry it out and you eat it that you're allowed to do on chevit and last associated this is a loophole that some people think that they can do because there's a rule in that if there's 60 times the amount of one thing then it will cancel the minority okay it's called battle let's say i have a one piece that is not kosher if i bring 60 times the amount then it will be swallowed in it then it will cancel it if i now have a chicken soup and have a five liter pot and a little drop of milk just falls in it if there's 60 times the quantity of the soup over the drop of milk then the drop of milk but tell besim it cancels in the 60 times that's it eat the soup nothing happened here you're not allowed to do that when it comes to sweet i'm not allowed to take a little bit of fruit of shavit and then mix them in many fruit of the rochevid now why would i want to do that ali they can tip then of the sweet maybe will be void the you always hold them and i can sell them or leash or to do anything that is prohibited with first of javits that is not applicable can do that and some people do it by the by the way by default now but i'm talking about other things not the shavit when it comes to comets comets for example doesn't have the bitul and many things doesn't the the amount something is battle bomber but tell them a time 200 100 in some things it doesn't work so in chevy you're not allowed to do that i can't take a little bit of pirouette fruits of shavit and put it in a lot of pirot no chevy to mix it out why to remove the shot then you're not allowed to do and that loophole doesn't work and why would somebody want to do it either to sell the fruit and vegetables or to do with them whatever is not allowed let's say i have now cucumbers and i want to make from the cucumbers pickles and we concluded that i can't make pickles from the cucumbers because that's not the way of eating it normally the way of eating it is raw and might by the way some people might argue and say yeah but eating the cucumbers pickled is a very common thing then you said before that if i eat it either raw or pickled then it's allowed then i'm allowed to pickle them but like i told you there's different types of opinions how they hold bite but here one might say oh i have a little bit of cucumbers and i have a lot of cucumbers that are from uh i imported let me mix them and then i can do whatever i want i can cook them grill them fry them pickle them that's when you're not allowed to do that and uh just to to conclude that when it comes to the perot of cheviet then you can mix them with perot of what's called of from other years are imported and so forth you have to keep them completely separated because the perot of shavit will have the touch on them and as i'm saying here is a side note because a lot of people i mean people watch the video not everybody here can ask you a question some people say listen i know of a certain cuisine that is very uh acceptable that everybody eats it in a certain way how is that about then when it comes to certain things one has to ask their rabbi how do we go about with this food because for example the example i gave with cucumbers and pickling it a lot of people might say no i hold by that it's very common to eat the cucumbers pickled and it's acceptable to have both fermented and pickled and raw but again that can be said with the carrots and it can be said with the beets and with many things so therefore one should they consult with their rabbi or go by whatever they hold by because some people say listen in my culture every meal we eat pickled or fermented beets tall normal thing some people say what are you talking about i never heard i had pickled beets pizza i baked them i cook them so that's what i'm saying there's different types of cuisines and some people say listen this is my diet i pickle all my food that's how i eat it ah if that's your diet and there's enough people eating it then that's considered that there's a substantial amount of people that's what i'm saying i'm giving some examples could be that my examples are not applicable maybe there's some a group of people says what are you talking about we boil uh cherries all the time it's totally common in our cuisine so i'm just throwing examples but don't don't have to be so hold on the example that i gave because sometimes sometimes you can go to some culture and they have a cuisine and i never ate it like that and and then of course it's acceptable there and not acceptable here so again i'm just giving it the rules and some examples not always the examples will apply a hundred percent you have to in many cases say okay this is how i eat it then as how he says here ashley don't have to bring up the question go to the rabbi if you don't know and then decide how you're gonna be able to eat that fruit or vegetable or not [Music]