Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
the Rambam says that the
Tuva is somebody who comes to the same
place and circumstances as he did the
Avera and he doesn't do it
so as Hattori Mosca yong about fifty
years ago I was here for met game I
don't know if it's my worst Avera
certainty laughs my biggest yes Shea
Stadium don't don't say because I guess
your age if you say Shea Stadium but I
don't know if there was my worst life
area but Bertha shame the Mitzvah of
today is a is a great Mitzvah so I guess
we'll use it as a bit of a Khepera
I want to try to define one of the
problems when we talk about things that
is such a consensus on is that we sort
of I don't know if the word is obfuscate
but we sort of tend to have a vagueness
thank you very much we we tend to be
vague and then a lot of unclear grey
areas open up so anytime you deal like
with motherhood and apple pie and flag
because everybody is so pro you have a
hard time getting a sharp definition all
right sister all is one of those topics
and kiddush Hashem is one of those
topics we all know the importance of
kiddush Hashem we all have an intuitive
sense it's nice to make a good
impression you want people to think that
you're wonderful and Judaism is
wonderful Shem is wonderful but can we
get a more specific understanding that
will help us really define some of those
areas that it's not clear what it's
about let me pose I will make a because
broccoli I've ever trained to catch and
I found that speakers were trains to
catch are very popular I've I've even
had a few people buy me ticket sometimes
the middle of the speech for the next
train so it's it's M I I try to stick to
then the kuda the point I'll stop the
Rambam says he speaks a lot about our
locus of kiddush Hashem the famous
kiddush Hashem is when a person
is threatened with death if he doesn't
commit one of the great sins or a lesser
sin in public different categories and
all of those we are however enjoined to
give our lives rather than to allow
sauce Rivera and that's the kiddush
Hashem
the Rambam says there's another example
of kiddush Hashem and he says color
porush moverá Oh awesome Mitzvah if a
person it's M if a person does not do in
Aveiro or he does something proper
lomi played over Bolam not because of
any incentive low parkersville o year of
lockers covered neither fear nor
enticement nor covered elimedia bura
bura who only because of hashem like
Josefa Sadiq that is I raised him a
caduceus ahem okay first of all um
between Yosef and pootie far nobody knew
what happened and the press got it wrong
M you know so what does it mean a
kiddush Hashem who was the kiddush
Hashem more than that I'm troubled by
where is the overlapping definition of
kiddush Hashem jumping in a fire or the
assisting from doing a nivara
for no reason the world accept the same
sham I am like Mike spoke the same from
I am I mean to both wonderful things
they're both they're both very very high
moments but is there a common
denominator other just a vague
generality of being a wonderfully noble
act is there something we can define
what kiddush Hashem is that's something
that really I find difficult I think
it's important we do it we also when we
say we want to make a kiddush Hashem for
almost all olam it's kind of fake it's
like we want to put on a little show a
little dance a show so that they think
we're wonderful and good and nice and
fine those that's the issue I want to
deal with and one maybe one more point
on the Rambam
the Rambam is talking here Butler shame
shame I am 100% lachemann lachemann
Rambam says is a unique motive that very
few people ever reach the Rambam in
quite a few places points this as being
a incredible incredible act of a pure
mitzvah it's a great mad Rhaegar but
what does it have to do with public
presentation and if I have a little bit
so change of mind what are we talking
about so I want to describe the point
and then we'll see it in a year shall me
um
let's think about the word he'll wash em
and kiddush Hashem what a spill mean
what is kiddush mean so let's describe
it as follows for people who believe
that the world is material everybody
believes the world's material we also
understand the world's material physics
knows what it's talking about chemistry
knows what's talking about biology knows
we're talking about the world is a
physical world and the reality around us
responds and conforms to physical laws
and activities and I can take the
greatest saint and I could I you know I
I could take him apart biologically and
he's and he is like anybody else but the
question is anything living anything
active has an engine that drives it what
drives it and the answer of the secular
world is it drives itself for itself
cells are entities that do things to
survive or else they would not have
survived it's not because it's
pre-programmed it's not because there's
anything about a grand plan it's because
it survives what motivates a person so a
the bigger part of evolution
of evolutionary biology today is spent
on trying to describe human behavior in
terms evolution and via soda a Soto's
the fundamental axiom is people act in
ways that will make them survive more
themselves their species in other words
the engine that drives the world is a
material engine that's what a material
world is we have a very different
concept of a world there is a world as
physical as described by science and we
have no doubt about it but that is a
shell and filling that shell is another
engine that's driving it altruism can be
described as materially driven and there
are a hundred to one explanations every
few weeks there's a new book explaining
it's better for yourself it's sort of if
everybody helps everybody else I'll need
something ask insurance company it's
better for the species it's it's a
vestige of some of some past time when
it was better those are all material
explanations because the world is
solidly material through through we have
a different picture of the world inside
a shell of a very physical shell there's
an engine that is of a different nature
and that's what we mean divine it's like
the mind is to the brain we don't we
believe in Neurology down to the last T
except that's the beginning there's
there's a content biology is a perfect
description human being the shell not
the content and the content is what we
call the neshamah
the reason why I reach out and help
somebody
is because my body is a glove to some
sort of soul which is not physical it's
not only not physical it has none of the
motivations drives or anything that's in
common with physical reality
I have kedusha that's something it's a
type of instinct that is not from
material of material for material it's
of spiritual for spiritual and it uses
and controls my body to a certain degree
for that purpose those are the two
distinct worldviews of momentum and
anima meaning if I if I hollow out the
person and I say the shell without the
content that's called pillo the word
halau means avoid a modern avid halal
space a hollow in the in himesh means a
corpse a body that's soulless it's an
empty it's there's a void inside it it
it's it all it is is just the body
pillow Hashem means that I present the
world as being void of anything more
than material kiddush Hashem the word
Ducie is designation designation means I
take a cup of water if somebody were to
be mocked ich it to the base are mikdash
this cup of water will be the same cup
of water it would be the same chemical
composition in the same plastic but it
would have a soul to it a designation it
is it is designated for something else
this is no longer water its water that's
there as a vehicle for something else
so we have two worldviews and they they
come they are at the core and at the
essence the distinction between Emunah
in its totality and kefir in its
totality one sees the world as a mahkum
hollow empty a void we can only look and
explain it on its physical and material
being that's all explanations and or we
have a sense that everything has in
itself a soul and that's called Kadosh
it means a designation outside of its
material self for some other purpose
this is realized and manifested in two
ways I can talk and preach all day long
about wonderful things until the guy
stops me over there but okay
many good people in the world are
idealistic and they wanna they wanna
utopia of sorts and they preach to
utopia but people who are more shall we
say realistic and say ok that's a dream
it's not a reality if you're an
evolutionist who believes in the
material world then the Utopia preaching
is a dream that's not connected to
reality it's not real you want to change
the world that's what you want to do you
can't change things everything has an
inertia to itself when a person acts in
a way that the that that what is driving
the person well why is he doing what
he's doing and my only answer can be
that there's another set of instincts
that I can't divine from the physical
world because I must be a shelf or
something else that is when people say
no there must be something else inside a
person
there are two instances where that can
be realized one I will do many things
like a pyramid I'll work hard to make a
lot of money I'll make a lot of money to
enjoy myself I'll sacrifice I'll suffer
hardships to cross a border to go to a
country at great economic opportunities
everything that I do can somehow be
subscribed to a material well-being even
if it in the short run it it's not
pleasant but what about if somebody
gives his life I'm giving my life for
what in the physical world and yes I
know the Taira that for the species it's
better I want to tell you with my entire
it's a horror I don't care much about
the species I'd be very honest and I
don't think anyone who really cares much
about the species let the species take
care of itself and I want to take care
of myself when a person stands up and
offers his life then people say there
must be something bigger than what we
call life then the vital signs on a
hospital sheet and that's kiddush Hashem
when I imbue I bring down into the world
an undeniable message that there's more
to the world and a human being than
physical self fulfilling drives that's
one second case when I do something that
the only motive that can be subscribed
it to it is something else yes I can do
I can be altruistic I can do it you know
I do a guy a favor you never know when
it'll come back again it's still nice
it's all a good thing but at the end of
the day it is not if showing that the
world has more than something physical I
can do it for covet I can be honored
institution it's nice its pleasant and
if it's worth the money you put in but
still it's something that that is ok you
know it's it's it's um but when I find a
person when yo savate sadiq does it
it's not a question of who observed the
Ansem act itself the very act of doing
something the only thing that controlled
your savate Sadiq is it's it's a
restraint that comes not from this world
every fiber of his body of his drives is
urging him to do it and he says no yes
Allah Kim something I can't do that is
bringing a locust into the Brya so we
have two areas where we are the ones
that bring a Kurdish burrow into the
Bria when we do mrs. nefesh and we do
things with a certain purity of motive I
want to quote a it's it's a Madras and
it's something that is also your Xiaomi
and both of them the Asami's gear sir
fills in some pieces they complement
each other it's the same story with a
bit of a compliment so my suburb Sherman
shotta do you saw me brings that rep
Zimmermann shutter who was one of the
very early canoas one of the zoo goes
worked very hard at flax working flax
flax seem to have been a very difficult
that was his paranoia and it worked very
hard at it his students came to him and
said we I have a better business for you
much easier and he bought him a donkey
Himura so it says he bought it from a
non Jew from Ishmael iya hood and I
guess I don't know exactly what business
is going to into but whoever was it was
much easier his tongue beat him said you
won't have to work so hard my obvious
assumption is that if Jimmy MacArthur
wouldn't work so hard he wouldn't use
the other time for golfing he was a big
time of hokum he was one of the pillars
of the the sort of the forerunners the
Mishnah they begin as the Mishnah he was
a great Dyan he would use it for
something very valuable
I'm studying helping people leadership
whatever it took
so they found the diamond on Rollo
so something considered Rebbe burkas a
shemitah' share hash caja practice
miniature maíam Icarus Perot who got you
a diamond and that's it you know you
have to drive the donkey that's it you
know you said for life and again the
life is going to be used will be used
for wonderful things so if she later
said does the person know about it no
she said I did not buy diamond I bought
a donkey
so it says holla where zero Lisa smelly
he returned it at non-jew the Kuril of
Isis Mellie and that Ishmael II said
baroque a shame a location bachata
blessed be the god of shimmy bachata
have a Mayim no social buzz of Adam at a
demo no Scottish Morocco from the
faithfulness of a human being you can
extrapolate the faithfulness of God
shanem on the solemn SCARA mitzvos that
he's believed to pay for mitzvahs India
shall me it says it says a piece before
it says that when he came to him and
told him you got rich in this net he
said boy Havisham in bachata mash ma
brittle or candy you die shimon
bisciotti prefers to hear the words
blessed be the god of the Jews may a
guard call a Dane Alma more than the
Tsar of anything in this world
what happened you can talk and preach
honesty all day long and it's it's talk
and even you know and that's not that
person is a hypocrite or doesn't mean it
but can people really really be honest
when there are zero consequences and you
didn't rob anybody and so on
no that's a non material value in the
great world of evolution
every animal ate the morsel of food that
that it has and that made it survive and
those poor animals that thought of of
giving back the food didn't survive
that's not that's not a material value
it's not a material drive so when
somebody introduces that value into the
world that becomes God's presence in the
world we speak about God when somebody
speaks about a universe that is out
there if somebody comes along you with
the following hypothesis there is a
universe somewhere we can't see it feel
it touch it here at community in any way
in which angels dance all day and I
don't know you you know fill in the
blanks a I can neither deny nor firm
that and the real truth is it's a
meaningless statement once you've told
me it's not part of this world and it
can't be and it can't connect to this
world so I mean it discounts like a
parallel but Verne bit a lemn it means
nothing I come and say a Shem is
faithful and naman and this and that and
so on and so forth it has no no
relevance to us so it's like everything
else we talk about God it's like some
sort of idle philosophical speculation
but if a person brings name- into this
world if on the body of Shem eben shut
up the God of Shem eben shotta means
that Shimon bachata is the body for the
nish for the vinous into this world if a
person can be an amen' a trusted person
the way he was then ashamed Sam Munna
comes his world and from that story of
Shinobi shut up say Munna I understand
what it means when Aminata Lajos Mason
incredible so if we're to ask ourselves
in the big picture and let's talk a few
minutes about ourselves and what it
means it's not about making a good
impression it's not a PR job it's not a
Shanda and the and it's not all of
that it's certainly those things should
matter
but it's a lot deeper than that anything
that we preach and believe in yes we
have a responsibility we are a Kurdish
Morocco's represented in this world it's
not to talk about God it's not to preach
about God it's not to make impressions
it's about to bring a sense that there's
something in the core of this world in
terms of what drives it that's much
deeper most people can't connect to it
until I guess call you Cyril will open
their eyes for most people the world is
a physical loop it's sort of it's it
enforces itself reinforces itself and
just keeps on supporting itself but in a
person's in a workplace and this is the
area of where people who are out in the
world have so much more to offer than
people who are in the cloister mismanage
each person needs to be where he is
where coach mother put him when a person
sees somebody day in day out in the
workplace and the person is motivated by
other things a person turns down it's
not he's not a kind of nebbish guy and
so on he's a rough tough businessman and
he makes hard deals but every so often
he says this is wrong and I born to it I
think I says we cleared it with the law
department they said they signed on they
said this is brilliant that might make a
new law after you get through with it
but but as you've done it it's it's your
you know it's it's it's excellent and
you say I know as a businessman profit
drives me but something drives me more
than I'm a man before a businessman and
and for what I tried I'm going to desist
if a person has opportunities to wrong
things and everyone figure out
themselves in its setting and a person
says no because there's something more
to me and people notice it people
understand it if if if I act considerate
Lita's people pissed way beyond what
would not be quiet and I do it because
it's generally my
drive to be em Moroccan alcohol myself
that makes an impression people at least
gain a sense that you know what there is
something else to the world maybe it's
only the Jews or maybe the Jews are just
the they're just the forerunners of it
there are harbingers of that type of
thing and from us they see it the the
world devoid of akka Rivera who is
hollow and that's the Kailash M the
world that has a cottage borough who as
its corn as its drive that's kiddush
Hashem and the only ones that can make
it happen is us there's an extraordinary
story then we'll finish with that
there's extraordinary story about a
Sherman shuttle that the Gomera brings
and it fits the person and it's an
understanding why only he could have
done it tomorrow brings the sanhedrin
that similar shot that had a brother yah
am Ella they were kind of very different
the animal killed her all Hofmeister oh
she run away and not an easy was part of
those kings in a second
those Hellenized kings in the in the
second temple era really trouble and one
of the servants one of the slaves of
Yanam l killed somebody and they hold
him into the Sanhedrin to be tried and
Sherman shutteth insisted that Yana
hemella must come and be there how it
has that logic explanation why that's
not the relevant piece over here and
when he walked in he sat down and she
Musharraf told him a mode or Aguilar car
via either Baja stand up they're going
to testify against his servant and again
there was an obligation for him to act
as sort of the the trustee of some sort
and you must stand on your feet like an
accused and they will bear witness
against you
so he said and it's it says that the
King turned to the people on the right
to everybody else has said is that who
you think and they all looked down on
the ground they were scared they didn't
want to say he looked at the people to
the left of schemata and he was and they
were scared they didn't want to say and
cinema shot I told him he said Lola for
Nainoa - Oh mate I'm not demanding in my
name that you stand in front of me OLF
name Misha Olive Oyl um I made a time it
you're standing before God and that's
why you're required to stand stand up
the only person that has the right to
make that demand is a person that lives
that way if Shimon been shot at what to
have a personal agenda then his ability
to say that statement with their full
with the full passion of a person who's
conscious is clear would not exist if I
don't feel that way and I don't act that
way if my driving force is not a cottage
bar hole and is not kiddush Hashem then
I can't demand that the demand falls how
long on his ears and and I can't say it
with conviction Shimon Ben shutter whose
very self was Bri Rahman Allah K -
Amiata he could stand from the king and
say you're not standing in my presence
because my presence is the president of
the divine it's something that we all
take unfortunately many many times when
people who represent us publicly should
or our public persona are acting in ways
less than we would be proud of
we can talk write articles and do many
other things when you act a certain way
when your own presence is and again this
is a type of thing it's like voting
everyone can make the argument my vote
doesn't count
but when a hundred million people make
that argument then it doesn't count if
we make if every single person develops
this sense in himself then the public
face of our community communities would
also be different to demand a pur
integrity from the person standing in
front of me
they can't be me I can't demand
integrity other person when I'm the one
who's got an issue I've got to be able
to say that I'm just a vehicle for
allocation my shuttle
so kiddush Hashem is probably the most
appropriate it's our core mission as
call Israel as Mike said and I'm talked
about the personal level that mission is
to project honestly because that's who
we are that yes with physical cells with
physical drives and needs and so on and
even weaknesses but down deep there's a
mechanism that drives us that is not of
this world
it's from somewhere else that every
single person look and say brick ramana
lekar of this person and this person
this person could be in a small area it
could be in many areas but that is
kiddush Hashem and if we personally the
more personally we embody that we're
just a vehicle for a homeowner the
shimmer shutter then we can demand with
with with with the full confidence and
end of and and the full passion of Emmis
that from the Malacca I'm stand-in
understand are standing in front of me
somewhere along Claudius role is a group
of individuals who each and every one is
a vehicle for kiddush Hashem and those
who are present Christ role as the Clow
will certainly be that and together
we'll be mikata shim-sham I am and bring
down that same air Casa Lovell
we began today at 8:30 in the morning
with with the duffy only Shearer
followed by another Duff Yomi Shearer
and from 10 o'clock through this hour 30
different speakers teaching us Torah the
Orthodox Union touches 24,000 students
in high school every year doing the
exact same thing
teaching torah teaching yiddish guides
we do programs on 22 campuses for
students and universities and secular
universities teaching them torah and
touching torah for them we bring
disabled members of our community
hearing impaired members of our
community closer to torah and allowing
them to have their role in torah but
we're beginning to realize that our
membership the adults in the community
also need additional opportunities for
torah learning and this program today is
the first of what we intend to be an
ongoing program and making exciting and
varying dimensions that are available to
all of us throughout north america and
beyond so thank you all for
participating today we hope that you
will continue in this partnership
exploring our holy Torah in the years
ahead
thank you very much more Dobbin Meyer of
now
[Applause]