Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Heat. Heat.
[Music]
All right, we got a nice cover here.
Check it out.
Hey, how are you? Hey, Celeste. Nice
seeing you. One for me right now.
Yeah. Oh, you start. You want me to
start?
All right. Great. So, we're going to
start in a minute. Would you like a
source sheet? Yeah. Doroth. Yeah.
There's some good stuff here.
All right. Uh, I want to welcome
everyone and uh it's a great pleasure to
be here this evening with you. Yashiko
for uh for being here and making the
time to learn. This class is a class
in prayer. And what we're going to be
looking at this evening is uh
the of
creatur. And uh there's a lot to say
about creat. And I'll begin this way
actually. And uh that is with a Mishna
that we find in Perkyos. Perkyo says
that um that one should be careful in
the reading of the Schma and in which is
an interesting thing to find in Perkyos
because Perkavo doesn't generally have
that kind of uh those kind of
directives. It's more about ethical
teachings and uh about Musar but for
some reason Pierote comes along and says
that when it comes to the Schma when it
comes to that one should be careful when
they read it. And um from aic point of
view when we read the we're supposed to
have kavana and the rabbis say kazal say
that when it comes to other parts of
ideally you should have kavana but if
you don't it's okay but when it comes to
the schma they're not so uh they're not
so lenient. They say that you need to
have kavana when you read the schma and
there are opinions that say that you do
not fulfill your obligation. If you say
the schma and you don't have in mind
what you are saying that you have not
fulfilled your obligation. The truth is
you'd have to go back and you would have
to say it again. And then there's a
whole question of what is it that you
need to be thinking about when you say
the what does it mean when I say you
should have kavana when you read the
schma? Does it mean that you just are
aware that you're saying the Schma, that
you're fulfilling an obligation, or does
it mean that you need to understand what
you're saying to think about the words
that you're saying that they're
meaningful? So, I think we would all
agree that the ideal is that when we say
the words of the Schma that we actually
have in mind what we're saying is here,
O Israel, Hashem, the Lord is our God.
Hashem, the Lord is one. and to be
thinking about that. Now the question
is, well, what does that mean? Here, O
Israel, the Lord is our God, the Lord is
one. Okay, now I know kind of the
translation, but what's really the
meaning behind those words? So, what
we're going to look at tonight is uh
we'll see three or
four. I'm not sure if we're going to get
to five. we'll say three or four ideas
from one of the greats of the last
hundred years and that's
revitakoenuk who is the first chief
rabbi here in yushalime here in Israel
before it was the state of Israel he
dies in 1935 and we have a lot of
beautiful teachings from Ravkuk on the
sitter and we also because he wrote a
commentary on the agadada on the
non-hikic sections of garraote we also
have a lot of his teachings and in braot
the beginning of brahood we have a lot
about kayachba so we have a lot of
beautiful insights from ravkuk
okay so I want to begin here I want to
begin with uh with a statement that's
made in the gamarra about the importance
of reading the schma and the statement
that's made in the gamarra the gamarra
says that it's more important to say the
schma than learning of Torah and if
you're learning of Torah you have to
stop the learning of Torah and you have
to recite the schma now often Torah
trumps any other
mitzvah. We say that Torah is greater
than any other mitzvah. And yet says the
following and we'll this is the page one
source number
one. Greater is the reading of the
recitation of
the in its proper
time. greater is reading the Schma than
learning Torah. So how do we understand
that and sort of in this the uh
prioritizing and the balance of mitzvot?
What is it about the schma that is more
important than talora? So this is the
way that RV cook interprets it. And
again, I always when I when I study RV
cook and we learn RV cook together, I
always like to see the language of RVuk
to appreciate his writings and not just
to take my word for it, but for all of
us to study it together and to
appreciate what RVuk says. So this is
what he writes and this is his analysis
of the difference between Talma Torah
and Creatma. What's the difference
between Torah study and uh and
recitation of the Schma? And why is it
that the recitation of the Schma is is
more significant is more important than
the study of Torah? Here let's look at
the words
of when it comes to the study of
Torah. When we study Torah, that is the
placebo that every single person
individually is that he acquires.
What is it that we're doing when we
study Torah? We are we are improving our
ourselves. We're improving who we are as
people. That's part of what it means to
study Torah. And we're doing that right
now. We're sitting and we're studying
together. And with the study that we're
doing, we're we're learning. We're
improving who we are. Hopefully, we're
going to when the next time that we
recite the Schma this evening as part of
Marv or Malamita that we're going to say
it with with greater cavana, with
greater intent. So, here we are. We're
studying and we're improving. But RV
cook says when we study often what we're
doing is really studying for ourselves,
right? We've all we've come tonight
because we want to learn something. We
want to gain something, want to benefit
from learning.
That's But there's something even
greater and that is what the Torah when
tamorra is something that the Jewish
people join in together in study.
And when we study to study Torah
together in a unified way. Now when we
think about
creatma prayer or is it to some degree a
kind of study of Torah or recitation of
Torah? Creatma is not prayer even though
it's in the prayer book. It's in the
sitter and we think about as part of
prayer but we're not praying right.
We're not supplicating. We're not asking
anything of God. What we're doing is
that we are taking sections from the
Torah. We're taking passages of the
Torah and we're reading them. We're
studying them to some degree. So what's
the difference between regular study
Torah and the Schma? When we recite the
Schma, when we recite the Schma, we're
actually all coming together and we're
studying Torah together. Ravkuk says
there's nothing as elevating and there's
nothing that's more significant than
when cloud Israel together studies
together and that's what kachma is and
in that sense katchma is greater than
study study is individualized right
study is every person and even as we're
coming together as a class all of us are
are studying and the benefit that we're
all going to gain from that study on an
individual basis but katchma is
everybody that same text everybody
together and actually the cookook points
out that the gamarra says which means
when you say thema at its time meaning
there's one moment that the entire
Jewish people all come together and they
have that one text in front of them and
they're all reciting that text they're
all studying that text they're all
thinking about that text and how
powerful that is and it's more powerful
than study of Torah why because study of
Torah is individualized what is the
schma thema also a kind of study. It's a
it's it's taking a passage in the Torah
and and reading it and understanding it
and and making it meaningful, but we're
doing it as a we're doing it as a and
reading on
now the entire nation
together that we're all uplifted
together to the very the very essence to
the very root of life.
at one moment. And again, it's a very
beautiful idea. I don't we generally
don't think about the Schma that way
because we're just kind of again, I
think we think about it that we're just
saying the Schma. But when we're saying
the Schma in the morning, all of Amisel
is doing that. The entire Jewish people
are all gathering together around that
text around that around that passage
from the Torah and we're all reading it
together. Surviv Cook says there's
nothing like when nothing like the power
of Israel of the Jewish people all
coming together um around the study of
Torah. It's like the uh when they had
the SMA shots when they do that every
seven years and they have the highlights
from that from uh Metife Stadium in New
Jersey where they have 90,000 people
100,000 people in the stadium, right?
That's Tmura. They're studying Torah and
what an awesome event that is. They
Madison Square Garden in Manhattan,
right? There was a big nickame the other
day. They said it was the highest price
ticket for a basketball game ever in uh
it's basically $1,000 for the the
cheapest seat in the house. this uh this
past I think it was on Saturday in New
York. There's nothing like everyone
getting together but getting together
and that's where Cook says getting
together for the study of Torah. That's
the Schma. The Schma is the Jewish
people all gathering around that text
together all reciting it together and
studying Torah
together. What that does, it strengthens
the bond of the Jewish
people and that's greater than
individualized study. So, it's an
interesting way of thinking about the
Schma. The Schma is the Jewish people
gathering together and reading that text
together um declaring their faith in
Hashem together. And that's the power of
the Schma. Now, the first time that the
Schma was ever
recited, the first time the Schma was
ever recited, when was that? So, the
Gumarra says the first time it was ever
recited was when Yakov was passing away,
when he was on his deathbed and he had
all of his children come around his bed
and he turned to his children and said
to his children, "Are all of you
believers? Do each of you believe in
Hashem?" Now, by the way, I want to read
that to you. This is
And it
says the famous he tells us about the
first re this is source number
two and he called all of his children
and he said come
together and I want to tell you about
the
future. He wanted to tell them about
future days about a messianic
day and somehow the the the very
presence of God leaves him and he feels
that something might be wrong that the
fact that he's not able to share with
his children. He kind of like loses a
little bit of this nava of this
prophetic vision. He feels maybe maybe
something's off. So he what does he do?
He says, "God forbid three lines down in
source number
two, maybe one of my literally one from
my bed is absul meaning one of my
children maybe they're not a
believer. Maybe like Ishmael or my
father that had an asov." So here we go.
Amu loanav. So all the children turn to
their father and they say Israel listen
Israel Hashem is our God. When is the
very first time that the sha was recited
by the children of Yakov the tribes Ruv
Shimon Ley Yehuda bin Yammen that all of
them are standing around the bed of
Yakov and they call out Shma Israel. And
what is that a reference to when they
say listen Israel in that context? Who's
Israel?
That's That's right. Aba. They're
referring to their father. Listen,
Israel is again we are believers. So, by
the way, what do you see in this story
in this episode? What is the schma
about? The Schma is about the people,
all the children coming together and
declaring their faith in Hashem. That's
Cookook says the power of the Schma.
Learning is very beautiful, but learning
tends to be an individualized that we do
it. we sit down even with the kabooa
even in the class it's limited but what
is the schma what's so unique about the
schma is that all of Israel is doing it
together and the very first time that
the schma was being recited was recited
was when Israel represented by theatim
the children of of of Israel of Jacob
that they all declared their faith in
Hashem so that's what
happened and they
said just as you father have a belief in
one
God. We also are believers in one
God. At that moment, Jacob then
said, by the way, that verse doesn't
appear anywhere in Tanakh. What we say
right after
the Where does it come from? It comes
from this episode. But it comes from
Yakov who said those words after he
heard his children all declare their
belief in God. He said blessed is the
name of God. His melik his maluto his
kingdom should last forever and ever. So
that is lesson number one about the
Schma. What is the Schma? The experience
of the Schma is the Jewish people coming
together. By the way, one interpretation
the Schma
is this interpretation that the children
are saying to Israel. But interesting
when we say the what does it mean
Israel? In other words, when we say
Israel, we come to shul this evening,
tomorrow morning, shabas. We're saying
what what's listen Israel? What what are
we saying when we say that? Talking to
ourselves. We're talking to Well, I
would say we're talking, we're not so
much talking to ourselves because we
don't say schma, we're Israel. We're
okay. We're part of that, but we're
saying we want Israel. I want my fellow
Jew. I want everyone here in the room. I
want everyone here in this community. I
want everyone here in this city in this
to hear that I am believer in God. We
are talking. We're we're making this
declaration. Interesting. It's not even
to God per se. It's a declaration that
we're making a statement that we're
making to one another. We don't say
hashem listen God that I believe in you.
We say schma Israel listen my fellow
Israelite. Listen my fellow Jew I am a
believer. So we see as Rav Cook
highlights that the Schma is about
togetherness, right? It's about Israel.
It's a moment that we take these
sections from the Torah, these passages
of the Torah, and with that we're
declaring our belief in Hashem. So that
is that's lesson uh lesson number about
the Schma.
Okay, let's look at a second lesson from
Ravk about the
Schma. And I'll ask everyone to turn the
page to the top of page two. This is
number second lesson where we're going
to see and then we'll we'll we'll do one
more. We'll do three ideas from Rivkuk.
So this is another Garra that talks
about the reading of the Tanya Sunkus
Omar. This is one of the Amarim of the
Garra by the name of Sunkos. He says the
following.
One who extends the word when you
say if you extend that
word that person will be too long days
and a long life that's what he says now
the question is why is that by the way
I'll just point out that the does say
the Rambam brings it in the Mishna Torah
it's in the also that you're supposed to
be that when you say that word that
you're supposed to extend it you extend
the a bit and you extend the data a
little bit that and you probably have
heard it could be that's your as well
that when you
say so that's an extension of that some
do it even a little bit more than that
but extend it a little bit so that's
what the gamarra says you should extend
it and the reward for extending it says
the gamarra is that you're going to have
a long life now the question is what
does that mean like of all things you
could say you get rewarded there's going
to bear like what does that mean in
particular that you're going to have
long days and long years that you're
going to be you're going to be uh
gifted. You're going to have the reward
of long life. So this is what this is
the way the RV cook understands the uh
the the gumar this passage in the gumar
and let's read the words of
cook and what is and what is the this
reward what is it referring
to the benefit of extending the
word it's in order
to embed to uh to root within the soul
of a person that a person should
understand that because if you
understand that God is
one that God oversees the world in his
oneness everything that God created in
this world created with a with a purpose
and with with an elevated purpose if God
by the way we talk about God being one
and here cook is already giving
interpretation it's not Not only that
there's this one God in heaven somewhere
but the one God means that there's a
oneness there's a unity in this world
that everything in this world has been
created as part of a grand plan of God
now if everything is part of that
oneness of God of this plan of God it
also means that we are part of that plan
as well that we're not here by
coincidence we're not here by chance
that God has placed us here in this
earth on this earth at this time to be a
player to be to take part and that we
have a particular mission to fulfill is
part of our time here in this in this
world. We weren't created 100 years
earlier. We weren't created 100 years
from now. Our nishama was placed in us
and we are brought here in this world
for a particular purpose. So we think
about God being one. It's not only that
God is one, that there's one God in
heaven. It means there's a oneness.
There's a unity and that we are part of
that great unity. We're part of that
plan of God.
that we have to recognize that we have a
great mission to fulfill every single
person and
therefore therefore you're going to have
length of days and
years so that you can you can accomplish
great
things for this holy purpose that you
have in this world. So this is the way
the Ravuk understands the idea of when
you say the word and you extend that
word. Extending it means that you now
take a moment to think about what that
is all about. Is not just that God is
one. It's sort of like a simplistic way
of thinking about it that there's one
God in heaven. It's it's more than that.
Much more than it's very profound that
there's a oneness to everything in this
universe. We're part of that oneness.
We're part of that great plan of
God.
And here's another sheet if you like.
And um and
therefore why is it that the reward is
that we have length of days a long life.
What it means is when you recognize that
you have a particular role to play now
your days and your years are very very
significant and you take them seriously
and it maybe means that God will even
give you a longer life that there's a
lot there's a lot for you to accomplish
if you recognize that there's a lot that
you need to accomplish here. So
God so God says to that person who
recognizes that uh that that role that
that they're going to play that that
person needs to be here in order to to
fulfill all that uh all that he or she
is here to fulfill in this
world he said that before Rashy Kipper
in the month before before the yadin he
says you should start doing a lot of for
other people you should add a lot of a
lot of acts of kindness sort of get
involved in people's lives and do more
for people. So why is that? So he said
because when Rashana comes and the
Yomadin and God is kind of making a
judgment, should I give him another year
on this earth? So he'll say God is going
to look down and say, "Well, he's
involved in this person's life and he's
doing so much for this one and he's
involved in this. How can I take him
from the world now? He I need him there,
right? He's doing so much. she's
fulfilling you know so so uh so many
important functions and his he's taking
his role in this world very very
seriously. So I think that's sort of
cook has in mind as well. So that's what
it
means when we say we should have in mind
and here's a kavana that we can have
when we say the again not only that god
is one but there's a oneness of the
universe. I'm part of that oneness. I'm
part of this great plan that god has.
I've been placed on this earth at this
time to fulfill a particular mission
that I have. And when I think about
that, that's part of what it means to
say that God is one. That I'm part of
that unity. And and uh and the reward
will be that you will have long days and
long life. Why? Because you need because
you now need those those days and life
and long life in order to fulfill your
mission here on this earth. Okay, that
is lesson number two. and a cavana a
very beautiful kavana that we can have.
Now we go to one more idea from Ravkuk
um and this is if you want to look at it
page two and it's source number three.
Now one of the things that we know about
katchma which is a really fascinating
thing which we don't generally have when
it comes to a mitzvah is that we do it
two
times. There are two different times
that we do it. We do it at night and we
do it in the morning. That's a little
bit out of the ordinary like there's
usually you have a mitzvah and a mitzvah
to fulfill and you do it one time and
that's and you're done. You put on fill
in you keep the day of Shabbat. You take
a lava and an estrog whatever maybe you
sadded you do it once and you're done.
You would think isn't that enough by the
way just so one time why do you have to
do it two times and what does that
really represent these two the two times
that we do creatma the night and the
morning. So there are probably many many
answers many ways of looking at it but
RV cook offers the following
interpretation and here RV cook thinks
about the schma sort of in a in a
national and a global way which I'll
you'll you'll see in a moment. So this
is again let's go
to let's go to the source and read a few
words from RVuk a few lines from RV
cook. This is source number three on
page two and there's an alf if you want
to follow along in the language of a
cookook actually it's not often cook's
language is very challenging here it's
very straightforward this is one of the
early things that he wrote by the way
they say when he come when he came to
Israel he like he like went into a
different sphere like his writing
becomes very mystical very poetic he's a
young man he's living in Lithuania he's
like writing in a way that we can
understand Rivk Cook so in The olive
right after the bold it says the that's
here we
go. We have the creation of the night
and we have of the
morning. There are two types of calling
out or recitation of the
bashem is two times a day. We have the
night schma. We have the morning schma.
They represent two different ways in
which we call out our faith in God.
Interesting. Two. It's not the same. You
probably thought it was the same the
night one. I just got to do it right. I
got to do it at night. Got to do it in
the morning. Cook says you should think
about them differently and they are
different from one another. Number
one. What isma? One type of creatur. And
this the garamar says is the famous line
about keshma then and this is a kavana
by the way that we all need to have.
It's not only enough just to believe
like to express declare our belief in
god but that
we're by the way some point out that
shin read the other way
is mal shay. You got it. But reading the
other direction that's the mal shaman.
So that's what we're supposed to be
thinking about when we read the schma.
Accepting upon ourselves the yoke of
heaven. Meaning not only that I believe
in God, but to believe in God means that
I have to devote myself to his will. I
have to surrender to his will. I have to
keep mitzvot every mitzvah as as best as
I possibly can. That's what we're
supposed to have in mind. That's a
kabana that we're supposed to have in
mind. So that's one kind of kavana says
that we
are for ourselves for us personally and
as a as a
people and this is the other kind of
schma that we the other message of the
when we accept upon ourselves the
mitzvot kash
He says something fascinating here and
that is one kind of schma is that we
accept upon ourselves and as a Jewish
people we're accepting upon ourselves
mitzvot but there's another creatur
there's another calling of God's name of
recitation of God's of belief in God and
that is that we want to bring this
message to all mankind. We're not
satisfied just having God and the ethics
and morality and mitzvot for us. We want
everyone to know about it. A Jew wants
to change the world. Wants the world to
be a better place. Wants a world to be a
place that's infused with the light of
God and the light of Torah. So the schma
of the night, he says, is a more insular
kind of schma. That's the schma that's
more Jewish people oriented. But as the
sun comes up in the morning, what does
that sha represent? It's a call to
everyone. And Rafuk says that sun coming
up in the morning, he says that darkness
is like the galut. The long galut we've
been in is like the dark night. It's
been a it's been a dark night in many
ways for the Jewish people. But as we're
coming back to the land of Israel, we
can now, excuse me, we can now begin to
think about how to bring that light to
all mankind. Now, by the way, this
sounds like a bit of a radical idea.
I mean, it sounds a little bit
surprising, right? Is that really what
did you ever hear that? Did any rabbi
ever tell you that when you say the
schma, you should have in mind that
there's a message here of bringing God
to the entire world. That sounds like
that's like a ruk something kind of
radical. But here we are. I want you
Yeah, I'll take your question or comment
in a moment. There's one comment that
Rashi makes on the Schma. If you go to
the Torah and you look at the line of
the Shma, if you look at the line of the
Schma, so Rashi has one comment on the
Schma. Now, by the way, if Rashi gives
an interpretation to the Schma, would
you say would you agree that that's
something that we should have in mind
when we say the Schma? It's not a not a
Zohar. It's not like a midrash
somewhere. Rashy's interpretation of the
Schma. So, here we go. Look at what this
is Rashi's interpretation of the Schma.
And again what we should have in mind
when we say this rashi hashem eloku this
is from this is where it appears in the
Torah
eload
hashem God who is our god now the elote
and he is not known to the nations of
the
world in the future he will be one god
For then I shall change I shall change
the nations to speak a clear language a
prophecy all will call out in one name
in the name of God. And here's a puk
that we all know from the end
ofu according to rashi when we
say what is it that we're supposed to
have in mind this is rashi Israel here.
Oh Israel, right? I'm speaking to the
community, those around me, to the
Jewish people. I believe in God
Israel, the Lord is my
God. The Lord is my God. It's our God,
the God of the Jewish people. But we're
not satisfied with that. We want
everyone to know the oneness of God.
That's what it means, Hashem. That there
should be one God for all mankind, for
all of humanity, that everyone across
the board, every every human soul across
the universe will know the oneness of
God. That's what Rashi says. That's how
Rashi interprets the Pukma
Israel. So again, and that's what Rufuk
says. Rufuk says that there's two parts
of the Schma, and we can think about
them as the Nichma. The nichma kind of
emphasizes or it symbolizes the idea of
of a more insular Jewish people. A
Jewish people, yes, that we need to have
faith, that we need to have that
commitment to Hashem. But as the sun
rises in the morning, that second schma,
what does it represent? It represents
that we have a message to share with the
entire world and we want the entire
world to believe in Hashem as well. So
that's quite a kavana and again this is
that's Rash's interpretation and I would
suggest to all of us and to myself as
well that when we say the schma there
are many things that we can think about
we can fulfill the mitzvah in many ways
but this certainly is one interpretation
it's Rash's interpretation that tonight
when we say the shma tomorrow morning
when we say thema and we think about
what is it that we're saying I believe
I'm calling out to Israel Israel I want
every Jew to know that the Lord is my
God but I want this God to be a God that
everyone knows. I want a world of that
everyone will know the ethics of the
Torah, the goodness of God, that
everyone will be a believer in Hashem.
That's the messianic vision. So, this is
the Schma contains that great messianic
vision of the Jewish people which
hopefully and Rafkuk believe that we're
getting closer to that. And he said,
'You know what? For a long time, we've
been not we have not been able to really
teach that part of Judaism. And we've
sort of downplayed that part of Judaism
because we just we weren't able to
really to to talk about teaching others.
We've just been trying to survive. We're
just trying to hold on to faith. We're
running from country to country. We've
been persecuted and all the violence and
we're just trying to hold on to Judaism.
But as we're coming back to the land of
Israel, we can begin to share that
message with others. And maybe that's
maybe that's beginning to unfold that we
have uh that the whole world is looking
to us. Everyone is everyone is is
analyzing what's happening in Israel. I
mean it's it's gone on for a long time
but it's an opportunity and maybe maybe
the time is ripe for us to begin to
share that message to uh to the entire
world. Did you want to make a a comment
or Yeah, please. I wrote it. What? I
wrote it. You wrote it? Yeah. Can I
read? Yeah, please. Please.
Before the rabbi said
people supposed to be a light for the
Gentiles, a light for the nations,
right? For all the Gentiles. Correct.
H I think his
wrote his rabbi of Germany.
Rabbi who? Rabbi H. Oh, Rabbi Hirs.
Yeah, Rabbi Hirs.
Samsonville.
Yeah.
Holic the meaning
of he said that coming through
Adam that means that a Jew has first to
be an Adam. Good. And then a Jew.
Uh-huh. Now that doesn't go well with
what you said. Why? because he
said that we need to come to Israel and
then be an inspiration of the
Gentiles. Now if he said that we need to
be first in Adam and then
Israel in order to be inspiration for
the gentile be among them to be
inspiration that we have to be among
them. Can I just say as you repeat? Yeah
yeah
yeah next
time quiet. So no no no. So I I if I
understood the question correctly um Sam
Silverfellow seems to suggest that we
need to be sort of amongst the among the
other nations in order to inspire them
and um so what does it mean when Raf
Cook is suggesting that only once we
come back to the land of Israel that we
can be that that great inspiration. So I
first of all I would say there there may
be different opinions and RF hers may
take that you know that side and and uh
RF cook would take the other position
but I would say this I think we we have
we we really have not been successful
and it's and as I intimated I think it's
it's almost impossible it's been
impossible for us to be successful on
that front to be the light to the world
living in the galut living in exile
where we've been persecuted. We just
it's it's it's it the um opportunities
and the ability for us to have uh to
influence and to impact others has been
limited. I mean, it's been a I would say
this also, it's been we we've been there
for 2,000 years. And I'll ask I'll ask
you, how successful have we been as a
people in spreading the message of
Judaism? Again, we're not talking about
converting others. We're talk, we're not
talking about converting others, but
sharing the wisdom
um inspiring people to Chev Noah of
living the seven Noahide laws. How
successful have we been not in a hundred
years but 2,000 years? I would say we
haven't been very successful. In other
words, if Rhers makes that argument that
we should be do that that's what it
means to be in Galut. It could be he
makes that argument and maybe we maybe a
time will come where we can be
successful. But 2,000 years have gone by
without a lot of a lot of success. I
think that I think we would kind of we
could agree to that. Yeah. Yeah. Please.
I think it depends on how you look at
it. Do you could you assume that I've
been directly successful where people
have kind of influenced the uh the
environments and at least until very
recently does uh but but she's no
influence now winning Nobel prizes and
so on numbers totally
[Music]
unfortunately Muslim basically They uh
uh took a off us. They uh their
religions are based on our
on that that's correct. But I don't
think we've been able to um to be a
light to those other religions in uh we
we haven't been successful doing that in
the exile.
Right. Correct. Yes. Please. If I could
just say that I think there's also no
real argument. there's if there's a need
for galut because of our sins, Hashem
also found that's a way for us to
influence the go whether as you said at
least individually and whether it's but
I think on a greater scale even in
societies
uh as uh Ken Spiro in word word perfect
said 2,000 years ago you know if you
held up a sign do not murder in front of
the coliseum you would be lunch so you
know on a certain scale we have Jewish
people introduced the concept of Msiah
that's why you have Christianity in
Islam we have had a major influence you
know on Shabbat whether there's some
kind of break humanity has offer
weekends so much that we have don't
downplay it at the same time that's
called plan B because it goes plan
A is in the land of Israel where we
could be a greater light that I think
that's great I think yes the way you
express is Beautiful. Yes. So that's it.
That's that's more of what we would say
is a bid, right? It's not ideal. We've
done what we what we've done what we
what we can outside of the land of
Israel. But Rafuk believed and I think
there's a lot of truth to that today,
which we almost take for granted that
the world looks to Israel and to the
Jewish people and they're judging us,
but they're also learning from us,
right? They're seeing an ethical army.
They're seeing and again, we we need to
be a great people here as well. I mean
that's the that's the great challenge
that we have the great responsibility.
Yes, we need to be the great people that
the world is going to look at and say
and say that's the kind of society we
want, right? That's the kind of kindness
that we can learn from. That's the kind
of government, right? To see how people
interact and the respect. Now, we don't
we haven't we're not always perfect on
that front and we have a long way to go,
but that's what it means to build a
great society here in Israel that the
rest of the world is going to say that
is that's the role model, right? That's
the paradigm. That's the that's the
perfect society that we want to emulate.
So that's that's sort of Cook believes
is possible and hopefully we're we're on
the road to that. Let me just uh just to
conclude. I think we're where we time
wise. Five minutes five minutes. Okay,
good. So I'll conclude with the
following which is uh just an
interesting vort that uh that kind of
highlights the idea that we just focused
on by the way again and I think there's
these are ideas that we can that we can
take with us when we say to think about
to think about this idea that Rashi
presents and that that Rafuk presents
that when we say that we that we want to
take that we that we believe in God and
we want this message to be a message for
not only for the Jewish Jewish people
for all mankind. What a beautiful idea
that is as we that's what Rashi says we
should have in mind when we say the
Schma. What a beautiful idea that is to
say as we say the Schma to think about
to think about that. So one of the other
interesting sources that we know about
the Schman, it comes from the night of
Pesak at the seder are the students that
come into the uh into that famous seder
with Rab and Rab Tar and they
say
Rabbi Shakar it's time to say the Schma.
Now one of the questions that's asked on
that I don't know if you ever thought
about that. Why do they say it's time to
say thema? Why don't they say it's time
to daven Shakaris, right? It's time
to begin davening, right? Why is Schma
in particular? So, one of the
interpretations that's given, this is a
rabbi, he lives in Israel today, Rabbi
Ruv Sasson. He actually is uh considered
to be one of the great expositor
teachers of teachings of Rafuk. And in
his hagada, he has the following
interpretation. We'll we'll conclude
with this and I'll just read a few lines
from from his hagada from Ruven
Sasson. There's really a a deeper idea
here that should be understood when the
students came in and said it's time for
the secret of the we recite in the
morning. What does it represent? It
represents the revelation of God in the
final gula. Now we talk about gula. We
have gula, the redemption from Egypt,
the salvation from Egypt. But that's not
that's just the beginning of the
process. The ultimate gula, the
goulashma is when the Jewish people come
back to the land of Israel and when the
Messiah comes and there's going to be
peace in the world
and that the entire world will know the
oneness of God. So what were the
students saying to their rabbis this
long night that they were studying the
hagada? They said it's time for creatur.
In other words there was this whole
night that we're discussing Pesak and
the story of Pesak. That's just a
prelude, right? That's just an
introduction to the ultimate gula. It's
time for the schma. What do they mean?
It's time for the schma. It's time for
us to declare two minute war. It's time
for us to declare that there is God and
a God that's going to bring for all
mankind, right? That all mankind is
going to know the oneness of God. That's
what the students were saying. Not only
yes, on a simple level, it's time to say
the Schma, but sort of the more profound
idea and what the
audit that's the beginning of the
process. What's the ultimate redemption?
What's the ultimate schma? It's a schma
that the entire world that there's going
to be a transformation. The whole world
is going to know the oneness of God. And
let me just uh we'll just read the last
words
here. Gu is uh is symbolized by the
morning is accepting the kingship of
God. When we say the morning, it's a
hint. It represents the secret of the
ultimate redemption.
Our rabbis were coming to
teach you that the story of telling the
story of leaving
Egypt and of the
night that brings a great
light. That's the beginning of the
process. The final the the the the uh
the final stage what it is that we're
praying for is the goulash ma. So this I
think is really like a it's a very very
profound idea. I think it's a new idea
that we we probably have not that we
don't think about when we're saying the
schma. I'm not saying you have to have
this in mind every time you say the
schma, but it's a it's it's something
that we could add to the repertoire of
what is it that we're thinking about as
we say the according to rashi according
to that when we say the schma we should
be thinking about accepting upon
ourselves that we're accepting upon
ourselves mitzvot belief in God but you
know what we're not satisfied that we
have it we're not satisfied that I have
it that my community has it but we want
everyone to have it we Not the whole
world. We want to the Jewish people want
to change the world. We want a world
that's going to be at peace with one
another that knows what it
means that believes in God that believes
in morality. We want that. That's the
battle. That's the battle cry. And
that's what we say every day. And that's
what is all about. So these are a few
ideas about uh about creatur. And uh if
we can take some of these ideas again
it's nice to talk about them sort of as
a you know theoretically or
hypothetically and to learn about it but
to try to bring it into our crema so
that when we recite the we have a deep
kavana that's the ideal and that's what
it says in the Mishna says that
person that you should be here that you
should be careful in the reading of the
and in one gear it says even more so
than because something that we do you
know sort of automatically we need we
pray for things requires additional
kavana when we say it. So these are some
ideas that we can bring to our schma and
uh yash to everyone. Thank you Rabbi
Poston for the opportunity to teach
continued here in Ian. Let's pray for
rabbi flags and all the we pray for the
kayim. We pray for the uh the captives
that they should come home. Those that
are kidnapped and all our should be safe
and we should be z to the gulma to say
the with that prayer of the ultimate
redemption.
[Music]
Amen. Heat. Heat.
[Music]
So much