Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
This Torah class is brought [music] to
you by tora anytime.com.
Thank you so much Bronson.
Um the only Milo that he could really
say is that Ray Bronstein uh allows
himself to to be considered he allows me
to consider him my my friend. So that's
my uh biggest mile talks about that you
should be uh you should be you should
have to talk about the having a good
friend to give advice. He could steer
you in the right direction. He could be
in
I have all of the mileas of and I I
appreciate that very much and I'm very
honored to have the opportunity to share
with you a few words before
going on brings
18 hakamos.
that various would make before they
would start learning in yan.
Just as an aside, not relevant to
today's shir. It's interesting. Why
couldn't they just start off? It says in
the third p of the migill. It says in
pariml whether they need a hakama or
whether they have to go to uh go to mish
go to go straight to the migill. What do
you need a pesak for the migillah? Do we
find elsewhere? Then when kazan want to
teach about something they need to start
off else somewhere else just go straight
into the migilla.
what's what's guru what's lacking in the
migill itself that we need to uh begin
with the pes from some somewhere else
so maybe it's an interesting idea
we know kadua there's a famous kasha on
the garland hamara licorice migill so
everybody asks that mikra migill is not
built to migill is also part of the
toyra it's also one of the falit's farm
so there's a very the novel chuva the
frame
where he wants to say that the gar
debates whether migill is
and there's an opinion it's not
so wants to be that even according to
the migill
it's only
in the to read it on but it's not
that you're the mitzvah of by learning
about uh the that's the B of even though
the is not to me on the B of the B of
seems to say that if you sit down and
you learn Miguel you're not the mitzvah
of Tal that's certainly the way the ABS
grips it
asks so it comes out that everything you
darill is not actually limit
so could it be that all of the pages of
the migill are not on the madrega
So maybe that's why there were
from a different angle. In other words,
whatever we're going to say now helps
you understand
full-fledged
maybe. In any event, the Gumar brings
one of the
were offered by and he
laid on the
says how make a name for himself mikra
everybody knows there's a question oh
where's name in the migilla okay it's
it's the it's great you could give every
terrorist in the world where the's name
is in the migilla why it's not there
explicitly but at the end of the day
theam's name is not in the migilla
so why Would the safer with which
created a name for himself be the one
safer that his name doesn't appear?
Okay, you could give every terrace in
the world why the's name is not migill.
But how could we
with a book? You could come up with any
other of the 23
with which could have made a name for
himself. The last one you would go to
would be Miguel.
The learns that that's gaug
but it's hard to know what the gar's
answer is. What does it mean?
I always like to look at a memor and the
garra brings the balmish.
I always try to understand why was the
one who said this? Why was the one who
said this? If you look at the end of the
So the first question that Rizal deals
with or Pano deals with is what kind of
name exactly is Sheilas? It's an
interesting name. Sheilas like a
Hungarian name. Well, you know like what
what were his parents thinking when they
when they called him a Sheilas? What
kind of name is Sheilas?
Mamisha. We don't find such a name. You
know, they once came to Yakob Kameeski.
They said, you know, the there we have a
name, an old name, a European name, and
it's a little bit of a funny name, but
the the grandmother wants it, the
great-grandfather wants it. So, Yakov
would say, you know, you have to make
the grandparents happy when you give a
name. Even more important, the parents
have to be happy, but the most important
thing is the kid has to live with the
name. you know, you can't sh the kid
because uh so I mean Sheila, what what's
what's the Indian of Sheila?
I want to begin today with a cash of the
Briskarov. This is one of my favorite
questions on Miguela and Desmaya. I
think we're going to try to offer
perhaps a new insight into answering
this question. The briskarov deals with
the third to last.
You would expect the migill sort of a
climax. It's leading up or we're
perceiving we're understanding the hand
of
even though albeit in a hidden way but
nevertheless it's it becomes very clear
that the is behind the scenes and the
migill ends
the
taxes the people
taxes the people. Wow. What a what a
beautiful inspiring ending to the Porm
story that taxes the people. Who cares?
This is the this is the climax. This is
the pinnacle the height of the hash of
the story that taxes the people
especially in light of the facts
points out
points out that the next is
if you want to know all of the
historical background and the palace
intrigue and you want to know all the
backstory you got the wrong book. This
is the wrong book. It's not mentioned
here. It's not here. It's not included
here. None of the history is here.
There's not one detail recorded in the
McGill that's written to give you a
better understanding of the times to
help you uh recognize what the palace
was like, what the politics was like. If
you want to know that
that's the end of the migill says the
migill is telling you that if you think
there's even one word written here to
help you understand what was like in
Persia back in the day what was the
palace like what was
relationship with his officers wrong
book look in the chronicles of Persia
media every detail written in the migill
was written for one purpose and one
person purpose only
for as
the reading of the migill is the halal.
So that magnifies the question. Why
would the migillah end? The climax of
the migillah is taxes the people. That's
the brisk
risk gives a answer because you would
have thought that at the end of the
story seems to be such a he seems to be
so so fickle and switching back and
forth. You would you would expect his
malas to fall apart and the migillas
his mus became even stronger. But I
think there's still room to ask, is that
really the climax of the Porum story? Is
it really that important to know about
the strength of the mouth of why does
the story end that way?
I want to talk about three words in that
to me are the three most important words
on the whole story.
So the Pik says that Hmon just consulted
with his wife. His wife said, "Go to the
king right away in the morning." And
Hmon runs to the king and the king
and the says
Hmon was coming. Where was he coming
to the outer courtyard of the king
to say to the king
on the tree
on the tree that he prepared for him
says three words I think these are the
three most important words son of God.
That's all you need to know about this
story.
He wasn't preparing it for Morai. He was
preparing it for himself. He thought he
was preparing it for Morai.
In reality, he was preparing this tree
for himself. Mash says the word is
extra. could have said
obviously it's for him him being Morai
why does the why does the say the word
so it doesn't mean him it means him he
was preparing the tree for himself
and with David in the puram he has a
whole
on this particular line of the garra
where he brings many many examples in
the migillo where this is a very
dominant theme in the migilla and I
would like to be Magdal just a little
bit
points out
that this
is in the of the we say on we say
what's the difference between these two
says
is Hmon had a plan. His plan was to
annihilate
was made for it. He nullified it. Hmon
tried to kill us. Wiped him off. He he
had him hang.
You know in English is it was Hmon
hanged. Was Ham hung?
You know this
[clears throat]
kyra you know. What about was Ham Hang
or was Ham Hung? The par there's a big
big difference between Hammon and the
Ben Hammon. One of them was one and the
other was another.
Hammon was hanged and the Ben Hammon
were hung. Why? Because you hang a gabra
and you and a is hung. A picture is
hung. So the bon were dead. Ma they're
like a picture. So they were hung. Hmon
was hanged. No extra charge for that.
Okay. So that's Hmon was hanged. So
that's
[snorts]
what's
says
from and he says you pick the plan, you
pick the weapon, you pick the scheme,
you pick the machination that you're
going to use against my people and I
will co-opt and hijack and take that
plan and use that against you. You know,
everybody says, okay, you know, we have
to have this president of the United
States. We have to have this governor in
office because this one's good for this
one is good for this one's good for and
says you think I need the the president
or the person who you think is good for
me to carry out what I want no you pick
the guy who's going to be the biggest
Russia the biggest the biggest
anti-semit and I will use him to carry
out what I want people get all very
scared you know we have to have our man
in office
is bigger than that can handle the other
guy in office that's count
doesn't have to work with
could easily doc
so there are a few very very uh amazing
examples in miguela for instance you
know the the pik says h has this great
uh plan he's going to make they're going
to send out uh word
They're going to send out the the
runners to all the communities of the
king. And what's it going to say?
That's what it's going to say. But then
the next continues,
but what's the
gonna say? What's it going to say on the
wall? What's going to be
doesn't say what's going to happen. All
it says on the posters is beware of this
day.
So the girl is bothered what there are
two things. There's the message that the
are carrying and then what it says on
the signs. So the girl says yeah was a
very smart guy. He told all the
officers, he told all the governors that
on the 13th of Adar, we're going to
eradicate, we're going to annihilate the
Jewish people, but do not write it on
the signs because I don't want the
Jewish people to know about it because
then they're going to call the Agoda and
they're going to pay money to the
government and then they're going to
bribe them and they're going to get it
off like we know how to do. So what's
going to happen? So the Jews are going
to get out of it. So therefore, we don't
want anybody to know exactly what's
going on. just tell them
beware of the ides of March and uh
they'll find out when it happens.
So the says that exactly backfired on
Hmon thought she was not writing the
date to cover up so shouldn't figure out
what was happening but the truth of the
matter is
so if it if it would have been written
in the document that will be killed and
that cannot could not have been
retracted. So what happened? So tells
Esther, "Look, you just changed the
document and now uh you're not violining
what it says.
Here's the best one.
By the way, the stipler has a whole
piece on this stipler has a very
interesting uh
about uh this of he doesn't call it
But he calls it what the garra says in
the garra says about
he came from and he said one in the she
said that he prophecied about the
destruction of the says why is
prophesying about the destruction of
soar says the hashem's
is
when wants to bring destruction to the
enemy. He brings it from the enemy
itself. So who better to prophecy about
the downfall of Edim than himself who
comes from Edin. So Stifer gives the
following uh analogy. So there's a man
named Parrot and Par's astrologers tell
him parro we see in our in the stars
that the Moshian shall is going to be
born. Oh, so Par says, "I have a very
simple. We're going to drown every
single boy that's born." No problem. So
is looking down from Shay. He says,
"Pro, you're trying to bring the
downfall of the Mashian sham.
Guess who is going to raise and groom
the Mashian?" It's got to be you. You
know what we're going to do? Your
daughter is going to be bathing in the
river. She's going to see a little kid.
She's going to take the kid inside.
She's going to bring him into your
palace and you're going to pay for his
rent and board until the kid is 20 years
old. You're going to pay for his gun.
You're going to pay for his tuition.
You're going to pay for his food. You're
going to buy his clothing. There's
amazing. Evanzra says, "Why was it that
had to grow up in Par's palace? I mean,
he couldn't grow up among the
why does he have to grow up in the
palace?" says even if he would have
grown up among Israel, he wouldn't have
amounted to anything because were they
had a slave mentality. They had low
morale. He can never be a leader. The
only way Moshe became is because he grew
up among royalty. He learned leadership.
He learned how to be a man. He learned
how to be a melan.
So Mosha would come out and maybe maybe
Mosha's shirt wasn't straight or his
jacket wasn't straight and parro said,
"You're going to be a leader one day, my
son. You got to get get your act
together." Who created Misha? Parro made
my parro
created.
Why? Because parro tried to destroy the
shel. So says, "You're not going to
destroy the Mosian. you will without you
parro we would never have would never
have a that's how operates the is not
just
here's another beautiful example from
the law
so par has a problem with his wife so
here are the options you could go to a
therapist you go to a marriage counselor
who does par go to
He goes to
the man, the men who know the times.
What's that going to do for him? So the
Miguel explains
were people who knew how to make
they knew how to sort of bend the law in
a situation where the law said one thing
and they needed a little bit of a
loophole. Why did need
says the because there was a problem.
The continues.
It means as follows, says
the law in Persia was that the king is
the meal. He has unilateral control and
decision over anything in in his
kingdom. But there's one thing that did
not have control over. There's one thing
that could not decide on his own and
that is if it's to him. That was the
rule in Persia.
The law in Persia was it's a very good
law if it's the himself the cannot make
his own decision. So he had a call
who knew maybe there's a that the says
didn't want to kill Vashi. Vashi had
good vashi was beautiful. So wanted to
keep her but he felt that if he would
keep her that there would be a great
rebellion because she stood up against
him. So was looking for
he couldn't find one the law in the land
was that he if it's him he has to ask
somebody else
so to the end of the end of the migillah
so how Hmon takes a misstep with Esther
comes back into the room he's fuming and
this guy says oh
and says hang him wait a
Isn't this
so
he should have to convene you know
supreme court of Persia and they should
decide what should happen to I mean
that's what happened in the beginning of
migill in the beginning of migill it
says
which according to the means that if
it's the king someone else has to make a
decision so how could just listen to
listen to how the learns says the yeah
that was the law in Persia
And what does
says the law in Persia is so ridiculous.
Aren't you the king of the world? Aren't
you the king over here? You can't decide
what to do with your own life. We're
changing the constitution. We're
changing the law and from now on the
king makes unilateral decisions even if
it's to himself says great idea.
Hmon thought he was going to get rid of
Vashi because the med says Hmon was
jealous of Vashi. Vashi didn't invite
Hammon's wife to some party. So Hmon
thought he's changing the law in Persia
to promote himself. No, no, no, no.
Hmon's changing the law in Persia so
that when Hmon takes the misstep and
otherwise would have had to send it to
the Senate and the House of
Representatives and it would have been a
majority but not twothirds and he would
have ended up being okay. No. So now
Hmon is dead courtesy of Hmon himself.
It's not just
this is the dominant theme in the Zer
says you know you got to go
Go first thing in the morning before the
says before anybody else has a good word
to say you have to go not like you
typically go says the typically Hmon was
so he would be the final one to go in go
first thing in the morning great ideas
so first thing in the morning the first
thing on's mind is he didn't pay back
Morai and Hmon gets to have those to
lead through the
I hope this is uh correct.
I happen to be giving a shir and safer
Ezra. Why? I don't know.
So learning say for Ezra and there's a
man by the name of Dyesh. Who dyes?
He's uh the son of a sin and
there's a man by the name of Ezra and he
says to look uh we got to go build build
a temple says no hate what do you need
as said we have no money we don't have
anything we have nothing we're poor we
can't had the same issue couldn't
rebuild the walls of so says what do you
want me to do as says maybe we're having
a charity campaign maybe you want to
contribute match donors if you Give $1,
someone else will give $10 million right
now.
You only have one more hour to do it.
And the says amazingly, say for Ezra,
I issue a decree
issues a decree to his officers. Please
cooperate with the elders of the Jews.
I want you to build the temple. So they
said where we get the money
and from the royal estate
from all of the tax money.
Do me a favor. Open up the treasury of
all the levies and taxes that have been
collected here in Persia. And I would
like you to use it to fund the building
of the Bameiktas.
And I ask you, where did get all of this
tax money from? And I would like to
think that he got it from.
That's the end of the poem there.
Taxes every last North Korean in the far
funk corners of his mouth. And now Abd
collects all of this tax money and as
one of the
sometimes puts in somebody a desire to
collect the money who is a go-to for the
sadic. So collects his taxes from all
over the world
and then he dies and it goes into and it
sits there and it sits there until Ezra
comes and says we have no money and says
TAKE ALL THE TAX MONEY.
So who is the b of the second?
Now where did get a could have gotten
all the money from the the money H paid
to kill the Jews according to the that
he didn't give it back to Hmon different
opinion so according to that comes out
built the second
the
funded the second mikdash through all
the tax money
and to me that is the perfect ending of
migra
because The story begins is having the
big suda and once is celebrating that
the said in seven years will be rebuilt
and it wasn't rebuilt and is celebrating
oh it WAS REBUILT IT WILL never be
rebuilt and is looking at he's saying
you're celebrating the second day
rebuilt not only will the second be
rebuilt not only will this not be a
celebration that it won't be rebuilt
aluda
vash is going to die. You're going to
marry Esther. You're gonna have a KID
WHO'S GOING TO FUND THE BUILDING of the
second.
What a beautiful ending to the Porum
story.
Hmon thinks he's hanging. H's hanging
himself. H thinks he's leaving an
opening in the to be able to kill. No,
he's doing it to kill him and his kids
and his
h thinks he's changing the law in Persia
to be able to advance his cause. He's
changing the law in Persia so could
execute him on the spot and thinks he's
celebrating the fact that the bish will
never be rebuilt. Akash is having a suda
to rebuild. It's misha fundraiser. It's
a fundraiser not on zoom. It's live
fundraiser. No charity. A live living
donors to rebuild the second. So you
would think then that the poor story
should end that is raising money to
build the SECOND THAT'S THE CLIMAX.
YEAH, that's exactly how it ends.
Perhaps a different approach to the
question of the brisk.
Now this is an amazing
understanding of the hasha of
this is not just
you know we tend to think that what's
the great hashka the story why is hashem
the hester because each detail in it of
itself you could say is unremarkable
it's not remarkable that vashi was
killed maybe it's unremarkable that
Esther became the queen maybe it's
unremarkable that morai overheard the
plan the plot to kill but if you're
mystery all the various details. That's
something that's clearly the but we're
learning it's much more than that. It's
beyond that. It's not just a combination
of all the seemingly random things that
are theem. It's
taking every and plan and thought and
idea and saying you pick the poison and
I will poison you with it. That's the
Where is the name of the rebel?
Can we say the name of the appears in
Miguel more than in any other book in
the
where is it?
How does the Ram begin? A very
interesting beginning
which is not the first comment of the
Raman. First comment of the Rama is
says you know
says okay if you're not but at least
what do you mean
talking? So I once heard
that like they begin with so is 26
that's how Rama starts.
Okay that's Ram's beginning.
How does Rama end? famous
says
that means begins and ends with the same
the is there's
and there's a
says
the
is
says the two are
how is one
says if one lives with
if you recognize if you feel that every
detail of our life of course we know
it's Hashem but sometimes we think oh is
patching it's a setback it's it's a
hurdle
it's not a hurdle this is. I'm grooming
you for success. I'm grooming you. Oh,
what a bad last year. Wa what a what a
difficult year. Yeah. But meet they knew
it was a difficult year. But McGillis
teaches us that operates on a different
plane. Sham is not is grooming us for
something big.
That were
comes from placing before you always.
So you could place before you always. Oh
that's
and the bal say but the greatest way is
to live with is part of you. It's part
of your personality. It's not just the
fun of it's part of your essence. says,
"Look at the word and you'll see
[clears throat] it says the word is
plus the which is the reg of the that
without David Hashem's
is wobbly. You have of the three but
it's not a stable K. That's why when
Yehuda was born the says it says
the
Hashem's name was Yehuda is the
fulfillment of the Hashem
and the says
it's interesting
Hashem's name doesn't appear but neither
does the name of
no's name doesn't appear
why doesn't anybody talk about that
where is
doesn't say ben Israel ben what are we
in the miguela we are yehudim 44 times
in the cl are called's
name is so in the migilla that it's not
just
name became
my name is in you
That's where's name is. It became part
of the essence of the that through
seeing this of Hashem's
writes in the
he wrote a b he says why did
orchestrate the story of
he says that since
was so hidden and there were no open
it's not enough for theam to so to speak
be behind the scenes by stringing
together seeming coincidences
in a time of darkness
the only way for him to be meal himself
in the clearest possible
is not
that's the greatest
it's greater than
think about the numa the garuma says
let's what is
hash Listen to this.
That means this man of Esther is
but it's it's a
if the if the morning is the end of the
night then Esther should be the
beginning of the not the end of the
time of Purim is is not y it's
So how think about the analogy of the
Gor
that means is the day.
Yeah is the day. Why? Because since
is behind the scenes and the only way he
could reveal himself is
a greater reflection of Hashem's
presence even greater than pur is the
pur is not the
hashem's name appears throughout the
estster more than any other place
created a name for himself not in a
place where his name is written where
his name becomes part of
where we become
and therefore the says
because if you're
then you're elevated to
and
shall make a name for himself.
Omar Yehuda.
Who else but Raud says
name
is
Hashemi.
The of the is from
reach of the blade.
Thank you so much for the opportunity.
Wish everybody.
You've just experienced another Torah
class brought to you by tora
anytime.com.