Pesachim 9b - Gemarah Pesachim #46

the yeshiva dotnet Testament base 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 right 1 2 3 4 5 Testament base 11 lines from the bottom the line starts over nimza Hollow a car arrived snake Sabourin the Gemara brought the first case was that there were nine piles of matzah and one pile of comets and a mouse came and you saw the mouse take one of the pieces from one of the piles one of the lavas and the problem is you don't know if it took matzah or a tuck comets because you did not notice that and then it went in to your house which you already checked for Pittacus comets so now you have a mouse with a piece of lava or pita in your house you don't know if it's matzah or if it's comets of course if it's Mars you don't have to do a second Dicker's comets if it's comments you have to do a second because comets as the gamora said earlier enough Testament olive that the Mishnah that says you're not afraid that a weasel or a rat took comets from one house to another houses only if you did not see you don't stomp create a concern that maybe this comets in my house because a rat brought comets and the mouse and then Eiland over so if you'll never have to you'll never be able to stop doing because comets because there's always how much somewhere on the continent where the rat could get comets from and therefore were not afraid of that but that's only because you didn't see a rat coming with how much to your house but when you saw a rat or a weasel or any other rodent our mouse coming with comets to your house then it's a whole different situation then we said ain't Suffolk might see me they bother even if it would be a small piece of bread and you can eat it but you're not sure it's valid a that has come it's a certain has come it's it's a Suffolk maybe she took it out maybe she ate it maybe she ran back out to the street maybe she went into the sewer system I don't know but I don't know so I have to do but it cos comments that was clear here you saw you saw a mouse come into your house but you don't know what it is maybe bread which is comments and maybe bread which is nuts so the question is what to do and this is where the Gemara taught us a gavel the king of all the Kushida SH and that is that you are Magoo you've to do another bittakers comments you are ma who you have to do another bittakers comments in contrast if in contrast to the second situation if what if the mouse did not take the piece from nine piles of matzah or one pile of commas but rather one of the pieces separated from all the piles into an isolated place and we don't know from where and the mouse comes and takes that piece and brings it into your house and then you say that you don't have to do bedico so much why don't you have duplicates comments because statistically there's nine piles of mats on one pile of comments you can assume 90% or 95% or 99% that this was matzah and if you know the COS comments you follow the majority go according to the right what's the smarter than in the first case you don't say this so this is what we learned that length and we explained it at length and let's summarized in a coda but the ha common learned from a passage a mass exodus service from the positive of our arrival overcome like cumin learnt a special halacha the arrival overcome all of that there is a special halacha called Cole kavacha Maxo our master dummy which means that when something is in its place Kivar means it's in its place the word cavora means established but here it means when something is in its place then it's never seen as a minority ever that seeing as a self-contained item and it's not considered a minority even if it is in terms of the fact that there are others that are a majority it's not considered a minority it's considered commits all matter as in though it would be 50/50 even though it's not 5050 the example is nine stores nine are kosher one is truth the trayvis store is not considered a minority because the trade for meat is in its place which is a non conscious what happens now if somebody buys meat in one of the stores and the person is not sure what store they went into whether it was a kosher store not a kosher store so the Suffolk was born in the mahkum hoc huius in the place of the meat Kolka var connects all markets Adame whenever something is in its place it's not considered a minority but 5050 so now when you have a Suffolk it's considered a Suffolk not of 90/10 but a 50/50 because it's considered a Suffolk of 5050 so I can't eat this meat because it's cavora because as in its place you went into a store there's a block there's nine culture stores one thrift store person goes into a store buys a piece of meat he doesn't know which store was he didn't realize he didn't remember whatever it is now he comes home he wants to eat to meet his wife says which store did he get it from to the finished so you would say statistically got it to my culture store there's non-conscious stores we say no it's considered or suffered just fake it their eyes it's 5050 why is it 5050 it's not 5050 legally it's not not 5050 but legally we considered how logically we considered 5050 why because since the Suffolk was created we're where was the suffix triggered whether the Suffolk begin Suffolk began in this store in this store the meat is in its place yeah so it's not considered bottle it's not considered a minority legate the other stores it's considered one store in other words on this story there's only one question either it's a caution a store not a caution a storm that's one question 50% it's caution 50% it's not either it's a karcher not kasha it's one question on this storm when you're in the store that's the question when you're in the store you don't look at this store in red in in in as part of the pool as part of the whole mahalo as part of all the stores you look at the store alone because it's Kovu what's established so you have one question is this store car sure not gosh if you know it's car sure great if you know it's not car shows great now you don't know so this is a Suffolk that's called NOLA the mahkum acquiesce it was created in the place of curious so therefore this type of Suffolk is considered Suffolk a schakal 50/50 now when you come home and you don't know you say it's 50% cultures people said today if you now let hit thank you very nice of homra what happens if you find a piece of meat on the road in front of the stores it's kosher why now you pick up the piece of meat now you have to look at all the ten stores because it came from one of them it didn't come from one store came from all of them very interesting I'm lucky a typhus now you have to look at all the stores together who now you make one mishmash now if I can make one show and one Charlotte majority of the John discussion it's a ton when each store is in its own place it's a Kovu that spread Kahua so that ends its own identity just like if it's not bottle and as its own it that doesn't get affected by the defender there's about a thousand cars misters I don't care doesn't affect me I am Who I am because I am Who I am so if I you know who I am I don't get bottled but there's so many stores that are cautious or what but I'm trace huh right but the Suffolk was born in the store in the second case the Suffolk was born not in the store when the guy came out of this toy properly new Explorer was not everybody's ass la maza like me the guy knew he just dropped it he's a second that push la maza he knows what story just drops things there's always a slow Mazal in the story because it's a subconscious kasha when I meet when I find it in the streets now something is not on want it's a Suffolk on a piece of meat that came from one of the ten which I don't know from which one so what do I say follow the majority my comments we say the same thing if the ask Burt took it from the muck of my careers from the pile then the Suffolk was bored in the place of Kivar its place place doesn't mean that it was always there from Shay she's in Mauritius place just means this is now its place cavour doesn't mean the Mito so it's not conversation assimilations used to be a nun Bahama right for what Kovu means it's just its place a place where it is the place where it was and it had an identity in other words it's it Hannah it had a place with its identity and it was a clear I didn't he's a pile of moths the pile of Commerce the afterburn now takes it I don't know which pilot oook it from each pile is completely self-contained each pose a question your comets are you're not coming if I would know it smarter combi doesn't get bottle and the others it is what it is right it has its own type if it has its own loo hosted as it's all Mitzi's now you don't know what I am okay so I'm either this or I'm this it's never defined visa via other stores other piles but mailer it's 5050 comments or matzo now you come into my house 50% matzah legally I have to look at it the 50% covers even though it's not you it's not 50% legally that's I'm looking at how logically and bemay laughter do predict a summons my Shane Kane if a sport took it from a separate piece that left the piles already now I have to ask this piece came from where I look at it as one big shawl and it came from one of the ten nine of them were mad sir one was comments I say it's right what would that could happen if you had ten piles nine formats and one from comments yeah and they got mixed up together what would be that locker then you're good say that did then it's not Kabul anymore that cavora the mats and the Comets used to be separate but now the Kapila they're mixed in if they're mixed then it's not caval it's not in its place with this identity decrees let's say an hour before somebody came and made one big pile nine matter one comets if somebody came and mixed them together because they want to sweep it up what would be that now earth mouse comes now this Suffolk didn't happen in Makkah McVie is now that something happened where in an absolute Shaolin where the comets was already bottle the comets was nullified it was a minority it was mixed it wasn't its own store wasn't its own pile right somebody takes the ten stores it makes one store you break down all the walls and now everything gets mixed up now you have a problem of bitl now it's not met its al Madison now you're back to Midland that's where the Suffolk happened you understand that's the difference of Kovu and not Koval cavora means it's in a place which the identity is distinct and clear parish means it's separated it's not in that place now I have to look at everything yes no good Schuyler yes yeah good Schuyler you're asking because comments is there a bottom if thickest comments is there a bond on so even if it's a Suffolk mean even if it's 50/50 faker there a bottle of Cola Mela by me it's a Suffolk Terry riser so 50/50 you have to say it straight but you're saying even if it's 50% comments it's only 50% and it's a sulfur kind of Indira Baumann so maybe you should go look cooler because that's dialogue let's make it there a bottom when you have a but a rabbinic thing what's that waka you always follow leniency for example Broca's right suffered Broca's if you're not sure if you made a broken obligation is there a bar none then you don't say make another broker unless you're sure whenever there's a leak whenever it comes to a suffering their abundant we always do the lenient that's called faker there isayama trick so buy meat I understand you're asking buy because comets let's say it's Cavour and let's say it's max our merits are granted so it's 50% comets but those are 50% max on this just because you're Kapoor it doesn't mean there's no max it is also matzah just because it's 90% mad so you don't want to call it 90 call it 50 but it's 50% so you're asking a good shylu why does the Gemara say you have to do another padukas comments it's an excellent question it's a Suffolk about yah but if you say that you did Bittle and thickest comments is there a bond on so then you're not gonna be overrun by era that's the Shiloh ah okay this is a good child hold on to it for one moment it's a good shine right right you know I need comets that's very nice the question is on particular if you say the question was empathic yeah well even given the horizon let's say this was on one file out of 10 it still doesn't work so it's spitzer because you might eat potentially decent right even in this fingers 1rh dance floor it's not medicine that say it's not 50 50 50 for sure that's the homerun without loyalty but even one out of 10 without a lot of pee yeah for eating for sure if you say the question is I'm eating then it's not a question you know let it eat the suffer comments cuz that's a Suffolk very nice that's a something there hi sir it's like tray for meat you know what he'd say for me to fit so Suffolk right bit to Lisbon Roy may not tire but if it's not believe it's max aah max does not drive that's the finish of Kovu Kovu for standard this was the first case now the Gemara goes through a second case yeah but not if you got it in the store if you got it in the store then you can but what I'm saying by monster play by Horwitz it give one's a piece of Louisville which looks like a matzo outside of the pen stores were 10 work 9 was baking matzah said one was making comments Gomer but it looks the same you know I'd love to you today would write because it's a good it's so good even if it's one over the ten well it's how does it prepare to meet and know you could then little bear I've yeah but bottle Burroughs via me not right here yeah well you say it's not comments this is before pate and pacer comment is not bottle even the Marshall before pacer comets is bottle on pacer comments is not bottle even the Marshall that's why we bake our Marxist before they used to make maps as on Pesach and everything today we do everything before Pesach course before Pesach comets could get bottle after Pesach how much doesn't get but it doesn't have the regular how lockers orbital we're talking you right then it's a different issue right we're talking here before because don't by the time of Dicker's comets good point on pacer comets will not be bottle so if you're saying if you find the mouse coming from taking this one piece and you're not sure then you can't eat it right before pay sectors bit good heart a good harder next case let's see next case the Gemara is now going to just explain the structure daft estimate based started as suger it's gonna continue diffuse till your DOM is base almost on the next mission and not mama SH and it's basically nine cases and the annoying case is evolved the nine cases evolved okay so we had the first case was a case of cavora now comes case number two what's case number two Sinead seaboard in two pieces two piles Eckert remarks of official comments one is matzah Juanes comments well the phenomena bottom and in front of these two piles is two houses exit bought the record said mother one day ready did they kiss how much one didn't do boudicca's comments yeah so it's ten o'clock at night the night aware of pacer I finished Vickers comments in my house I'm done I'm sitting on the stoop and drinking a cup of water a cup of coffee I'm good you just came home you rushed my shotgun and you about to do but it consumes it's a beautiful scenario in front of our house there's two parcels master comforts of course they look at the same uh they wouldn't look at the same you wouldn't have an issue with any of these they look at the same okay for us to snack bottom now with this perfect scenario two miles two mice appeared effort shock all massive effort uncle Cummins one of course went to one pile and took mats one went to another pounder comets next each of the mice now having its breakfast and launch of course goes in it's time to go to sleep so each of them runs in to one of the two houses so there's two pause matzah comets there's two mice one went to one part woman to another pile one house was but that one house was not mother and each Mouse went in to another house great but lawyer diamond here's the problem the lawyer didn't inhale availa mihaela high off we just don't know which one went into this and we sure went into this in other words we lost track till now we're good this matter this comets there's two mice one one Mouse is addicted to matzah one Mouse is interested in comets were good there's two houses I have to do I don't have to do particular you have to do Boudicca and now they might run into the houses and hit is a confusion who was I said to get which mouse and of course we understand the issue if I got the mouse with the comments I have to do a new padukas comments for you it's no difference because you anyway doing meticulous comments again not again you didn't do it yet so for you it's no difference anyway checking for the bread in your house you'll check also for the bread that the mouse brought in but for me it makes a big difference when I finish my dick so here the hyena it's an issue of 50/50 right statistically what are the chances that this comments in my house no no we do know we do not hear the suffered didn't happen over there the Suffolk didn't happen in the pile everything was clear we live momma's together as the mouse the mice ran in we got confused we didn't see they go to the hallway the hallway splits into two doors we lost it over there in the house we lost count so in the makamaka vu there was no Suffolk the Suffolk happened in the house oh but it's like hi to max out max so you would think based on the previous Gemara what would be that luck huh gotta do another thing has come it's right that's where our logic would go we just learned that was the case before call kavacha my cell Meza but here it's really 5050 well it's not nine and one you'd have nine piles and one five it's out not only attend mice nine with map so one with commas you have two nice one with mats along with comatose that can 50/50 you know you know called cavour for 50/50 yeah be a real 50/50 not only a legal one yeah come to the Gemara and says hi new state corpus this is like the case of state coach snake stake approach think it was means two boxes that's how the camera is doing all these helices it says our case it compares it to a precedent that we have in matthias of riser and then it applies effective accumbens that's the first case we did high notation hannelius I know safer and now we do i understate covers the tiny we have a bryce here again it says the Tanami we don't have a mission like this so that's why the mysterious estas changes it from the turn on which means a mission it to the tiny which is a Bryce stay Cooper's if you have two boxes basically these two boxes were usually wicker boxes and Akash al hool initial trauma one of these containers was filled with Holland which means regular mundane fruits or produce and what was filled with trauma which is sacred produce now let's remember here okay let's remember what is true MA me not Toyota when a Jew has a farm in edge you all will feel the farmer garden on Orchard I have two separate room I mean separation very holy trauma I have two separate tithe to proximately 2% to the client I can give it to any client I want and the Cayenne eats it this food becomes holy what do we mean holy another Jew is nominated the client canina his wife can eat it his children can eat it his servants can eat it but are you sure all our ladies now let it eat Roma it's our Cilla's our and it's a very serious penalty miss simulation I mean Allah determine why it's holy food at sacred food once I segregated once I separated and I say this is I raised it Roma even before I give it to the kind then I give it to the car and only the coin Canadian grant that's the locker with true what's the din when trauma falls in to regular fruits let's say I have an apple of trauma that belongs to the client and now this Apple somebody didn't realize my child takes the Apple and mixes it with a box of 500 apples so the din is that's for uma to become kosher to everybody you need a ratio of 1 to 100 which means if there were a hundred apples minimum and one through my apple fell in its cold bottle if there were 99 apples none of them could be eaten by me they all could be eaten only by a kaya I could sell them to a Cayenne of course but that means I'm gonna have to sell them for a much cheaper price because the demand for these apples is not great because only a few people can buy it so I could sell them to the coin because I would didn't have to give the call you know 199 apples at the give him one Apple I could sell them 98 apples but he's not gonna pay a lot of money I'm just giving an example it's valid true miss 2% I'm just now saying if the Truman didn't fall into a hundred that's no bit the bit to love Truman is a ratio of 100 to one or more of course if you have 300 apples great thousand apples wonderful but the minimum is one 200 that's the din of Bethel I mean hot area also be rife with work by the way Madeira Bannen they made a hundred to one and there's a reason why they're abundant made the bittle of rumors so much more than usual meaning not only sixty like we have by trayvis but a hundred they learned an ad from the pursuit come how it should be done what happened here you have two boxes Holden and Roma the lift names Mesa in in front of these two boxes yes nay seen a saw as a certain measurement the certain volume measurement between there's an argument and the that's exactly what it is but it's basically you ever art scored is he say in the probably between two and three gallons between two and three gallons so it's a nice amount and you have to saw meaning two vessels that container saw exit who'll American children one a schooling then one has to have enough flow a looter Calum the Paris from this vessel fell into this box the pages of this vessel fell into this box that we know but we don't know which one fell into which so it's mahmoud similar to the situation that we have here with the comments so again yet two containers Hulan and truman you had two containers Hulan into roma both of them got empty down in these two boxes which would have been wonderful if we would know what fell into what but we don't what's our problem our problem is like this if the colon fell into the colon great the trimmer fell into the trimmer great if the hole and fell into the trimmer nope the problem is the trimmer fell into the Hulland because the trimmer fell into the hole and now what do we do if there was a hundred to one I don't have a problem in other words if the box is that it's fell into had a ratio of a hundred to one to the boxes that fell into it to one box that fell into it I'm fine why because even if it's drum it got muddled but it didn't have that because it didn't have that so now I'm stuck so we average a vowel decay finish muttering you're allowed I eat the Paris of Hulan I they may be mixed with drummer how could you shun me oma because I say I say hula not a cool enough low thermal attest romanov I say the Kulin attracted to Holton and the trimmer attracted the true man the Kulin felon takunda trimmer found it Trump what's the basis for this just like the trimmer fell into dramatically dramatic olan subside the laws of attraction the trimmer felt the true man fell it with me somebody poured them both in and then I realized yeah they thought of somebody was trying to clean up they thought it's one big apples apples let's make one pile of I didn't realize if anything ever sits attract here it's not shiny I'm it cuz I said what's the havona here the Avani here obviously is let's see Rashi steak up is doubles only friend London which Michener's make up is to tell in only Cola we attributed to leniency but the finance nation shall pay us enough Llewellyn take a loo I saw a little halo a Cooper's via dual on who shot not for Brazil back at Mizzou we know that one fell into this someone fell into this it's not like we think maybe both fell into one the Aeneid ooh our age observe a episode a limit order pages so Cooper's our Hulan with tartan Lazar curricula there permissible to these stall as initially a fellow aim but Cooper Goodell hours or so bad for the mayor even though the box does not have a ratio of a hundred to one in order to be Movado why how ice means to elevate the some meaning to be move at all to true Shaunda a rim cooling with a full enough flow alma to linen the cooler had to bat the visib is it's 50/50 we attributed to a wing in see we say you're right it could have been this way how logically were assuming a lenient pass a lenient what method were assuming that the lenient the more lenient thing happens I forgot the Carrera if I could say opposite you're right you could say opposite but the how comes that despite the fact you could say opposite shiny I'm ER legally this is what we're assuming Hawking I mean the color to linen here too family no we say our combination is the same they both the climax on the bottom the summits went into your house you got a dupe knickers comments and the matzah went into my house I don't gonna do think of comments that's what we say fascinating how long the Kumar's gonna analyze this yes we don't know yes yes yeah we take on that they worked in parallel symmetry yeah yeah yeah yeah we're assuming the halacha even though we know it could have happened otherwise legally we're assuming the more lenient scenario what would be the more lenient scenario of course that the Kulin is not mixed with drew man we can eat it right even though we know it's 50/50 what's the reason for this salsa this is what happens when you have a physicist and a mathematician in the chair so even though it's a 50/50 we saved a little local sucked the Gemara one second aim with them linen jean de mer I could understand this Shani I am and I say meaning even though it could have happened otherwise but this is what I say and we understand why they say Shani I am it's very important words they're not saying this is what happens we don't know what happened they're saying Shani oh ma we're saying this happen in other words it's only a halakha that this happened when it comes la loca we're assuming that this happened Shani I mean it's a hidden bar near him it's not there they're pink they're giving on a vous about what happens when he holding a via he without giving a V is here it's a I understand that when with true Madeira born on because this blazer was written after the Corbin by Saunders and shroom there was rabbinic but Mele even if you got it wrong what's the worst thing it's gonna happen you're gonna be eating true but that's not biblical because they're Rambam holes and this is very important Rashi says true Madeira Barnabas man has set the Rambam says in whole system is that the moment most Jews were not living in Eric's Easter all there's no obligation of trimmer which means he holds that even during the base second base HaMikdash trimmer was rabbinic from when the ten tribes were exiled a hundred and fifty years before kerbin by his recent rumor became a rabbinic obligation even those who differ with their and mum still hold after urban Bayou Chene II when there's nobody so McNish true miss Ventura Bona this Brice was written by the tan I am sometime after the burn so they're saying today if it happens people still were giving trauma to Clennon was to leading Truman today that's gone because you have to eat shroom Avatara but then they still had the para don't man they could cleanse themselves from Tomas mace so Cornyn was to leading Truman everything worked after the second Corbin yeah so therefore bhisma Hazare when it's their abundant what's the worst thing that can happen you got it wrong you got it wrong what are you eating are you struggling I'm eating shrimp in okay but you're not violating a biblical obligation when I tell you this is not true you're not obligated to give to them it's just regular apples the rapid my mail it's a Suffolk and then their opponent if it didn't the red bananas look cooler what's a cooler my shame cane if you say so that's what the sunny I'm a flag the Gemara but Bonet calm it's very nice to me I'm written and here it's about comets it's about comets it's Adam very nice nobody says comets today he's home it upon saga the Gemara to particular summers day nice there are bother me they mean there I shall beat Obama soggy way it's the second time big Aman is repeating it it's because come as day nice if the kiss comes only after about a minute right so you could do Bittle in other words not to be every time by you know you could do Bittle so in mainly in my house I do bit off so it's not a question if I'm gonna be able to buy let's say the mouse came in with some it's the mouse what's the worst thing that's gonna happen the worst thing that's gonna happen is that there's comets in my house pacer which is an issue they're a bummer because my nighter I do bittle if I do bittle there's no by your own by a moat so even if this comets in the house LMI it's a suffered during your Bonham I may have to I may have there's a reprimand said it's fine you don't have to since Suffolk in a field there are bonham 50/50 you don't have to be Mahler you don't have to do a second because comets but if I talk a woman do bitl if I let's say this story happens Arif Pacers in the afternoon when you can't do Bittle anymore and then the mouse comes into my house ah then I have a problem why do I have a problem because I can do Biddle anymore then I would have to do Boudicca but since we're talking about a case there was bittle so now the question is I have to do dhikr so if I know there's comets doesn't help that I did because the ha ha mom said you have to do dhikr but since it's a Suffolk there are born on Shanley I'm here I say you can assume that the Comets went into their bias a no bother and you do they care enough to the tick excellent question so you should have said this by the first case too because comets is their opponent that's what I asked that's why I waited for this Gamora after you read this Gamora the first case becomes problematic the first case you told me called caval come back tell Maxo and if we have to do another bleakest comets - what a few three live a few lines later they come on a contradicts itself says no because come in sit up on it really just reminded yourself an optical covers in a bunny you forgot that four lines ago stickers come instead I'm gonna it's a very very strange very hard thing to understand in the Gemara the question is really are nashi goes take a look in the Gemara itself take a look in the Gemara itself what is the first case look like taste should see Buddha show matzah right there cultural Commons was the aspergers Shaka the lawyer didn't eat matzah chuckle how much chuckle yeah the camera doesn't say the width Iike you realize think I didn't say they were thicker the emerges said I don't know if this asked but the Comets I don't know if the odds but took matzah that's what the camera shows take a look the second case okay the second case sinead supernatural tomorrow tell me with flames they both have excellent Bo Duke that's it sir ain't I bought that one Mr Gove illidan a lie of a liar here we introduce the concept of dick the first case not Rashi though says both cases are talking about the same thing if you take a look in Russia in Russia which rashly the rashi right for us Africa Shaco rash he said Venetian Aslam eyes with an animal a I didn't become a truck of the human the cozinha shrieking our new live Dyke rashly is the one who says the first case is talking about the boudicca's comments I might actually don't need to be D care so rashly clearly says both cases are talking about dicka dicka Mar in the first case doesn't mention the word thicker they went says we don't know if it's coming so matzah so let's see let's see know if you're not right so so then you have to do particular the question is the question is right okay okay good good harder good order so they have a problem with the second case if you same because they realize they were probably the second case so let's take a look in toy service high note a Chicano yes high note a Chicano yes you see the second and last ice is enough testament phase annotation colleges suck toy service the first case we compared it to the story of nine stores the theme are superior is Lingam thicker according to Rashi you says that were talking man thicker line a hearin Leary remaining its cook says this doesn't make sense there are age he might see lie invitation sundar Yadav a kadai right sir Vaseline and homra raucous naked in a button okay de minimis sambal what are you comparing it to nine stores by the nine stores the question of meat which is an ism annotator of course it's a sir here it's a question of dhikr which is within a bun as the Gemara itself is going to say melius la merde the idk going shall a bit one way of saying this according to Rashi is the first case there was no bitl the second case there was bitten in the first case he didn't do bit since he didn't do bit to lure maybe he can't do bittle anymore cuz it happened to late-era fazer than they have to know no he didn't do bit though so now it's a question by a robbery might seem in a fight which rash in the first mission why do you have to be both the comments could I live forever by you know by you mutts cuz if there's no Bittle but thicker than is a few of men how tired attack there was no bit yes dupa dick been male it's a Suffolk they're nice if you don't do dhikr you can it might be over and I should be stolen by your buddy what's you have to do that's one way of learning I the second case the Gemara sassani i'ma she has the same the second case for some reason the Gemara was talking about the do was brittle and therefore it's there ever taka in the second case of the woman be bitl you would say the same thing you have to do be thicker again because it's 50/50 that's one way of learning it which of course is a little difficult because even though it works but it's a little difficult why the Gemara is changing gears because of course I'll tell you why the problem the problem is because then the second case should have been the first case in a case where you did brittle you understand the second case like a mother should have repeated the first case and just said and in a case where you did brittle then you don't have to do thicker because really if what you're telling me just in a different scenario okay so you could find answers but that's one way of looking at it factoids is what I shall have another problem capitation some new year's lucky Huskers headed by nine stores there's no Huskies heta meaning it's not like there was an assumption of Hector novel hockey here lucuma Huskers model The Hobbit bothered my teenie lava he cheated the Bible dick excited is a difference because by the meat the tray for storage doesn't have a Hess cassette its truth the question is which two I got it from here this house if I go to the sometimes you have a soft weak you say let's go back to the status quo what do we know for sure we know for sure that it was bothered because if you don't know for sure them for sure you have to do predict if you didn't do particularly we'll see if do particular difference there's a mouse or not so look right here there's another reason to be make or besides the first issue that this is very nice and because there are bond on the second thing you know here you have a Huskers bundle that the house is already in a state of cleanliness now you wanna be okay the Kazakh based on a suffered cuz I hear something Kazakh means if we go like five hours if we go one hour ago we were good right now you want to change the status quo like like we say I might seem a very Oliveira in other words this is my this is by me now you want to say it's yours okay bring proof this house is a coastal a pacer house now you want to say it's not pre proof that's another strong vara to differ to make a difference between the bittakers comments and colonies so Tyler says venir led renewed a lily the Linga Navy Akbar Allah bias the nymph sir kibou e ashore ela ela ela now in our culture this is gonna be hard to understand but in those days it's not hard to understand the issue is the mouse brought in the food into the home and it's here the mouse leaves it the mouse traps enough in the dining room and the question is the Kindle accented hungry somebody's hungry a my daddy eat it or not I'm pace up that's the question that's a whole different question now you can't tell me the house is but ask us boudic what does the house being but haskers public have to do with this piece if i mlady now you can't tell me did i born on it's not that i bonnet eating comets is very nice so toy service learns that the question is a completely different question it's not a question on bedico it's a question on archila it's a whole different question so it's a suffolk they're nice 50 50 50 % coverage 50% maksakov oh come on so master you know what eat it are you telling me ask us bother cool does that have to do with the Sheila because my house is crushing the pace are they from Allah to eat something that's just over comics in the house nothing to do two separate losses is a dinner to have to be buddy to clear house a mile I to eat a piece that's a suffix or commas of course if this happened before the time the analogy comment is not a question it's talking about the time that you are now any comments and now it's an issue in aeterna so striking a racial home what but may let toy says this is it differently the first case thing about the second case in tomorrow the first case in tomorrow was about eating the second case Ingemar now it's very case mark the second case Ingemar is about dicker it's not about eating we don't have a Suffolk if I'm allowed to eat it or not then you attack and now let her eat it you're right when the now that's what we brought meat in the first case cause we're talking about eating just like the meat that's perfect the second case we're talking about you came into the house and the question is if I have to do another beaker when I already did thicker this is only a Jeroboam so here I say Chandi I were just like rumor is they're abandoning a evening math like the meat so dick is the reports of perfect symmetry two separate cases and that's why in the second case it's a different case than one thicker this is the of Tice's wrath she doesn't learn like this or as she says the first question was thicker I was a Suffolk there are born on so toys excuse it was no bittle I think Amara says there was but in the second case so here we're gonna say give all the convert ah excellent no because the Suffolk happened when the mouse took it out from the pile from then yes that's the cavora yes yes yes yes yes yes no no Spartacus a big thing has cos mother goes a big thing because it basically you go back to certainty again I'm gonna give an example from a different situation you come and you say that this safer belongs to you right now cloudless I might see my Kaveri Oliver ayah you have to bring the proof I don't have to bring the proof why because it's in my domain I'm wearing this jacket you say that I took it from you okay bring proof you understand that's called Kazakh Kazakh means we let things go by the status quo of what is maintained right now as an obvious certainty this for true of course of natural noting that we don't know anything this was short true but this is what we're assuming now you're trying to shake it up you want to shake up the status quo you bring proof I don't have to bring proof my house is Kaushal up a sign I did a batik everybody knows I know now you're telling me no no no it's not bring proof could you bring proof 50% it's a Suffolk so there's another reason that if it's a VAT dye the VAT dye changes the Kazakh your house is not crucial of places this bread in your house RP it used to be not anymore but it's a Suffolk that's the idea you are the burden of proof is on you not on me not on my house is a good house you want to say it's not a good house that's that that's thus far of Cheska septic it's it's two separating anima depends well we see here that so Thomas is saying that the Kazakh should be stronger that's what he's asking yeah that's why he says it's about akela but I want to introduce another perspective that answers this question and this is an extraordinary insight that was given by the Magid Mishnah the name of the raw in Rambam take a look Rambam we have copies here pulses comets or matzo peyrac Bay's hello who you'd favorite basil off-field dr. amber Heaney our t-shirts abuddin show mats and you'll see it's almost a quote from our game art you left nine piles of mats of official comments oh boy a suburban no till a mouse came and took it for Loredana we don't know in comments in Matsumoto did he take comet so did he take matzah vanilla slab is Bo Duke and he went into a checked house sorry Liv de aqui have to be boy dick shikaka hua connects our merits a new who does the Rambam learn like we now share the toy service yet like Rashi sorry sleeve like thickness Levias buttock in other words he learns that you have to do Boudicca like Rashi so take a look in the magnet mission on the right okay it's a little small but I'll read it he near t-shirt Sabourin so matzah okay now before the market wish to take a look at the arrived it on the left side in middle we see on the left side of the Rama mass others arrive it and small words he near Tisch Kosovar Ivan South Lima Avraham Ilsa I do not agree with this a Lola Ingham Bittle millennium Dickens making their abomino drive it is basically giving us here clear perspective that would tie Swiss Express sorry this is true about bittle you have to do another little that yeah why Suffolk minute are done you gotta do another bit full but bit thicker you know have to do dhikr why it's a something to Roboto it's Madonna again problem the toys was introduced into Russia now let's see the Magid Mishnah after he quotes the Rambo ah right so you do a little if you can't do a new bit full cuz its air of pacer after this man you can't do bitte laughter and of paster around eleven o'clock after the beginning of the sixth hour you can do bit also then do another dick but this is if it happened before just do another pickle and then you're good you never do bitty enough to dick first case them are eating not thicker white ice was the first case the question is eating not if you don't do another thicker and the second case is talking about the dick and that's where you don't to do another position but Rashi clearly says you have to do another bedico the ramen clearly says you've do another dick and we're back to our big questions faker there are born on look cool though what happened to that it's a summon the Gemara itself says this how can they argue with the Gemara the Gemara to then second case tells you straighter than a bottle look cool and they're saying no yep something very something very strange very strange unless they say there was no middle that's what it says if there was no bitl you're right so that's a way of answering it but it's do maybe another way of answering it even if it was before the sixth hour but you didn't do bittle for whatever reason you're right you're right if it's after the sixth hour you could only do particular you can't do Bittle anymore yeah we're assuming that this happened during the time of Dicker's comets meaning either in the night or in the morning but you're right if it happens a middle of pace sucks the laws change right it's always before bittle could only happen until the beginning of the sixth hour the beginning of the seventh album and are tired in the beginning of the sixth hour Madeira Bannen once the Commons does not belong to you let's remember there's no bitter right that's we learnt in that love little can only happen when the comets issues let's see the maggot Mishnah he quotes the round mummy quotes the Gemara I'm not gonna go through the whole thing cause we just learned the Gemara the - rashes are you see the back of it - rashes oh who shot him a first mark I ruin him Kadosh Robbie know like the Rumba Rashi holds like the Rumba gum it's really the Rambam holds like rushing rush he was before the ramen but the driver is just trying to bring out that they match he's not talking historically gamma debris ago in America from the enosis seems that way but paying customer fader to buy lockers Horowitz cook eben Gaius the cassava horrors all there are are a be no Erin lav says one of the great we showing him says the mug admission shahe tom the reason is the ARF Algarve this fake Adira bonne année even though it's a Suffolk Terrebonne on keyword ship because comets he lost saw Alice avec since boudicca's comets he loss of colossal means it's very beginning it's very foundation it's very Genesis is created for a doubt because of a doubt me rubus faker Yosemite are a curse of the brain therefore their attitude to this Suffolk is different than any other Suffolk there are born on the haymaker and this is the truth this is the way to learn the Gemara what is the magnet mission telling us because comets is a different creature completely every other mix within a bond on every Ultimates with the Rabanne oh is that the rabona there are bond and made you should do a mitzvah let's take this true McKay's trauma cases may not turn it off to do trauma right with the Rabbani have to do trauma now it's a question it's a Suffolk so we could go lenient in other words it's a Suffolk is this true more natural McCann I eat it I can't eat it do have to sell it to a coin I'm not sure if I'm sure then I can't eat it but if I'm not sure we go the coat since it's only an issue there are born on or suffering on why don't we go look you want to say because comets is the same thing you're not sure if this comets or that comets right so therefore say it's only the moment there's no comets excuse a moi what is the biggest comments the whole thing is comments in the case were you not sure that those comments what do you think is comets if you have comments on your kitchen counter you don't need a few because comets the night before baseline then you have to get rid of it you don't need to bother to tell what's biggest comets but what booty cos thickest comets means I gotta go under the bed who puts helmets under the bed why do you say snake in there I'm gonna look over I come with a candle I'm like is that comets under the bed 50% year 50% not we know the truth 95% know 5% yes vacant urbana look all and what happens there's nobody curse comments you've done in a minute yeah the stems give out why did they convert from admission every the whole thing cos coverage is one big Suffolk you should snap before you begin go with the candle is there comments in that drawer in the bathroom now maybe fake is in a bottle Nicole don't do it what's the answer that's the Mitchell the mid-surface that even though it's a Suffolk I want you to be my I think that's the Mitzvah that's one because comments vincas comments he lost solace offing the holy site the biggest comments is that is a Suffolk and I'm not sure came to bounine and said since you're not sure we're telling you go searched and searched and searched and searched go to every hole and go to every crack I who put comments there I don't know but if it's a Suffolk you got a search so now you're telling me that has the words exactly in a copy in the mail are you telling me Sneha did a bundle of Cola really if you would apply the dinner to thickest comments you know how you got to do that no Jew should ever do particular comments you should go with your candle take a look in senton this is a Suffolk Don Suffolk Don so I'm down already my biggest covers is now the piece of hummus that's father you don't even think is coming that's been a tighter so the whole you signed them thickest comments is then it's a Suffolk you're not sure and that's the missile the midst is even though it's a Suffolk the Mitzvah is to deal with fakers Nazis the Mitzvah thus is because comments so now you're telling me because it's a Suffolk if this comets in the house or not don't do big s make it political really the whole biggest audience is this story I'm not sure of this comments maybe there is maybe it is not dope dick now a mouse came in Kolkata metal master so you're telling me but I'm not sure maybe it's not so maybe it's common to sacred an album that is the mitts love the thickest commerce that's together you're not sure you do it that's the bag admission is fine Samira oh now that from her stay in the second case subjugation baklava heard that the whole idea of sacred that I bother doesn't work because commas because that's the gather of the Mitzvah the definition is that even though it's a Suffolk you still do bigger scum it's that is what bleeker's Commons is so if I say the second case you might have a Suffolk fifty-fifty so you should say so you should say that what cuz you don't know shiny ointment you don't know why you did bittle I don't care if you did bit that's the whole party the more it is you did and it's at this faker than opponent I don't care just fake it did help on that's the myths malli commits of Lady Chanukah candles are eating too or giving true more shaking the lulav that's holding him of at night the whole dinner used in of sulfur so if I say the second case locator should also be okay so here it gets a little more darker stick it gets a little more darker stick how you have to understand this fakers think and okay we'll explore tomorrow but if you can come up with the difference okay so let's summarize the Gemara goes through here a series of nine hollow cos nine scenarios of doubts and with the question of how a person should respond to these doubts in terms of Pittacus comments the first question that we addressed to us there are 10 piles 9 piles of mats are one pile of comets you saw a mouse take a piece of pita or laugher from one of the piles obviously the mats and the Comets look identical if not you wouldn't have an issue and as we explained that in the olden days and still today in Yemen they make matzo like PITA so therefore you wouldn't always know the difference between moths and comets it's not obvious like it is by us where the matzo is so thin and burnt and tough it's a whole different creature then you wouldn't have an issue with a mouse but in the mats of old and in the matter that still exists in some communities the Yemenite community you could get mixed up between the two cuz they look identical and as a result of that you know that the mouse took one of the pieces but you're not sure if she took comets or if it took comets or matzo and the question is the way Rashi understands it do you have to do another because comets caused the mouse now runs into your house your house was already checked the question is if there's comets in your house now if this comments in your house you have to do another because comets are not so what's the finish the finish is that you don't you have to do another bittakers comments why even though the majority of the piles are matzah so you should follow the road you should follow the majority because statistically probably comets so we learnt the great dish that the camera teaches us that called Kovu our chimera AMEX adam that since you saw the mouse take the Comets from the piles themselves one of the piles and over there each one is in its place the Mart's is in its place and the summits is in its place identify your boat this is mad citizens comments it's not like they were mixed up they weren't mixed up they're separate and ten separate files so it's in its place identifiable the halacha bukavu a is that legally we treat it not as a minority but as equal to any other pile in other words which read it as 50/50 we treat it completely a self-contained and therefore it's not a question of majority versus minority it's a question of 50/50 so male its 50% that I've come it's a mouse 50% I don't have comments in my house so therefore you have to do another bedico on the other hand if a piece fell out of one of those ten and ended up in isolation and the mouse took that one and brought it into my house here I wouldn't have to do another video why it's a fascinating I look I wouldn't have do another video why because here when the one was the doubt created the doubt was created when the mouse took that isolated piece that isolated pieces not kibou it's not in its place it was separated and I don't know from where was separated because I don't know from where was separated I go according to the majority right statistic statistically it comes from the max of piles because nine are comets are Max and one is comet so it may later on to another of Dicker's colors that was the first case of the Gemara what was the second case of the Gemara i have in front of me two piles mats and comets i have two houses one did thick and one didn't do particular and the mouse comes and takes one piece and then another mouse comes and takes another piece and they run in to both homes so now one house got the match the one house got the common ground I don't know which one the mouse took matzah and one Mouse took summits that's good everything is nice I would have stopped right there problem is when the mice ran into the home I got confused I don't know which one with the matzah ran into which house so now it's 50% at my house which did bodega has matzo which is good but 50% it has come so what's the halacha now the Gemara says hey the locker the Gemara brought an example from stay Cooper's you have two boxes of Hollen and Truman and yeah two boxes of Holden and Truman they each fall into one of the boxes we don't know which one to which Shandy I may we say that the hoenn found to hold the Truman found a tumor and he stroked and eat the whole and box even though there may be Truman at 50% same is here we say that the Comets went into the Bayou Chene I bought doc and if I don't do another thickest comas I I could say the opposite you could say the other way around as well actually says you could but the hazael were lenient and said since you could say not you don't do another thicker scholars ask the Gemara why would you do this by true meds because to remove his mana says deira Bonham so speaker there are bondin the cooler so there's my says that's true I predict his comments in Dickens but there are born on this mean I try to you did Biddle so therefore I mean I tell you you won't be overrun by your or even if this comets in the house if minute ID would be over just wake him in the IRA dice you would have to go home and do another pick but since minatoya it's not an issue only Madeira bono so there are bondin decided to be lenient and say since it's possible that there was no comets in your house and your house was checked already so you don't have to do another particular comets you could leave it as is the other person of course has to do because common sense duplicates comments anyway because he he never did the COS comments before right so toys versus the big question that Lacroix did this doesn't make sense these two Gamora screws in the first case you tell me that if it's 50/50 you have to do another bittakers comments and it's second case you tell me that if it's fifty fifty dollars to do one other Pittacus comments so toaster said that the first case is not to my because commas just talking about eating right that was toast versus ants or the first case is talking about that there was no Bittle so it's a Suffolk when I tried but then the mag admission er answered in Iran mom that what's the voor de Voort is the thickest come which is a different type of Suffolk why is it a different type of Suffolk because the hope because comets was instituted because of a Suffolk whenever you check comments it's because there's a Suffolk and nonetheless they said you have to be by the comments even though there's a Suffolk that's the finish of the mag admission in other words whenever I do particular comments I come into a room right am I sure there's comments there under the bed I don't know the soma nice fakers it's not one suffered number one was the Comets ever brought in here number one Suffolk number two even who was brought in here maybe was brought out suffer Columbia 3 maybe it became moldy and decadent and rotten even a dog can't eat it so no he's know is nonetheless you say after duplicitous comets is fake adorable cooler so Suffolk the Urbana the answer is that is Nicholas comets the gather of Dickus comets is that my admission deported in Los Alamos Suffolk it was instituted because of a software that's together of Dicker's comments in other words a definition of Dicker's comets is that when you have a Suffolk you do it that's the he'll yep that's the here Madeira Bona if in other words if you'll save a kid or a bundle Nicola by bedico's hum is there gonna be predict as comets anymore other the name of the Rabanne on abundance said you should do something now is a Suffolk that I do it or didn't I do it did I do this mitsuo didn't I do it see say you know what you don't have to redo it why don't you have to redo it because it's a suffering that I Bonham I maybe you didn't do it that's what a suffering their abundant is somebody their abundant mean there's are something did you do it or didn't you do it so you go the color here you're gonna say it's a Suffolk is it's a Suffolk of this common sir there's no comments right so you'll say enough to do padukas comments no the tikona is that's the tacoma that / taco that's the market Michener's give out the kitchen dish that even though it's a Suffolk in the first case is let's do particular comments cuz you're saying be not sure of this comment so matzo that's what hope the customer says you're not sure you have to be bite the big problem is then the second case why does the Gemara change that was the big the great struggle we stayed with her in the second case then doesn't make sense because if you that is saying their ridiculous comments it's a different type of creature it's a different type of something which was amazing to cavort of the Magadh Mishnah but then what happens that the second case the gomorrah says you could ignore it and make believe you didn't have the comments because it's 50/50 and you say that what there you don't have to be both the comments again this is the question we remained with choiceless asked a question about kazakh devold a good question how could you compare predictors comments to the nine stores by the nine stores I understand that one store is traif because one store is trave so you say it's cavorts camacho matza but in our case of the house toys reset there's a Hesse curse but look by the stories there's no Hess kiss Hector in other words one story is really trace there's no question about here there's a Hesse cos bondic which means this house was brother Caretti so if you go back to the kazakh kazakh means if you go back to the status quo where was the house right before the suffolk what type of house was it the answer is doesn't need Pickers comments I already did the customers so maybe that's another tremendous incentive to assess as to question first of all the consumers as there are Bonham and the stories are stylized some meters device and this is the rap on question number one question number two of it a there's no has cassette or the husband's mother which is why Isis changes the commander and said it's not talking about dick is still not eating but brashley clearly says it's about thicker the ramen clearly says it's about thicker so you have to say there was no bitl but the ramen doesn't make that distinction even if there was Bittle you have to do another body count so that's where the mug admission it came up with his words ashamed a rod of iron out lady would shame earlier we showing him that thicker scum which is a different type of creature okay so this question is very clearly code a very very powerful and important question let's keep it on hold for a few moments you could say it was that in the first case we have one subject and because the reason of my Commission's on the shops then we understand that we do in this particular and we require second in the second case where we have a case of Suffolk and poly because one guy already did dick another one for shooting duty and now has something happened and now what we do because this topic is already less the Suffolk because there is a Suffolk for one guy but for the second guy there is for sure body that he needs to do no matter what so because we're talking about case of two people and not one so that Nikora would do it because there is a Suffolk and mother this is it's not just wrong shopping on its own because you compare to the vada it's relevant help me with you sang for you it's worse okay I got it but Surrey still no no you're wrong the dick was made for Suffolk I'll tell you what if you have helmets on your counter you don't need to have common to say they're gonna do dhikr you gotta get rid of it that's not dicka dicka the finish of dick is that any room in the house where there's a possibility that hummert's went in there middle of the year you have to do big ah there's so many doubts maybe there's no comets there maybe even if this how much there was taken out maybe even if the comet wasn't taken out yeah it went there last aniket became rotten the answer is you're right of course you're right that's why there's a question in Sheol Senora what happens if you buy decay house you don't find any comments is it a brothel of at all and the answer is no because the Mitzvah is not to find them it's mr. search what are searching by definition mean searching means that it's not conspicuous now a lot of knickers come with is not that when this hummus in my refrigerator I have to get rid of it you don't need the Cohanim for that let's say there was no key of Dicker's comforts me that I had them there about only their ice you understand it's how much of my refrigerator you don't need to rub on own of course you have to get rid of it it says touch be so sorry but thanks up well your habla I'm upset the question is if there's comets in a room but that may not be comets in the room do I have to go search for it trader says you shouldn't see combat you shouldn't have comets but what if I have no reason to suspect his comets maybe yeah maybe not came the commandment said that's what because comets is I want you to search in places even though it's very likely that there's not comets as long as it's a possibility that there's comets if for sure there's no comets a place you're not being accommodate economically of course there's no reason to suspect we don't spec's Tom freaky things that are not natural but if it's a bedroom of a child even though it's not the kitchen and mommy said a hundred times no cookies in the bedroom but since you know your babies and they don't listen to mommy always so therefore Eutychus comments there etc that's the Vaart let's see the next case okay case number three case number three cebu rehearsal hamed's all the fun of Schnee bottom Dukan person has one pile of comets and in front of the piled are two houses and they were both checked so let's understand in the first case what happened there was one house and the algebra came into their house we're not sure with comets or matzo from the pile already we're not sure second case there were two houses and two mice and each one took a piece of matzah comets which we know which piece it was but it got confused in terms of the houses which when they went into now this case number three similar official comments you have one pile of conflicts that's not a question all the fun of snare bottom Dukan and in front of it you have two houses that were both checked for us as a vehicle and a mouse came and took the Comets from the pile and went into one of the houses below adenine ela hi alia oh but I don't know which house the mouse went into it's not a question if it's not so hummus it's vada comments there was one parle comments it's clear these comments and the mouse took it that's clear we saw it and we saw the mouse go into our house that's also clear the problem is the mouse went into the house and it didn't remain in the dining room so everybody could see the mouse with the commas then you have to do boudicca's comments in this house unless you have the mousey get rid of the mouse when the Komets but I'm talking about you know which house it went into you don't know which house it went into it ran in right it went through the door under the door there's a little hallway say when boo one of the houses now needs another particulars comforts so here come on you saw how fast mice rot even Google can't figure it out always no no you saw it going to the house you saw it go into the entrance of this let's say let's say this one door let's say there's one door between two apartments right and it let's say there's a front door there's a hallway yeah yeah yes yes joint door a similarly a similar phenomenon right so you don't know exactly you know if you didn't see it going to a house you don't say you went into a house could have got to the could have gone to the Garter could have gone on the ground could have gone to some hiding place we said the Mishnah ain't hurtin we don't have stomachs ash that a rat when at the house with comments cuz then nobody cuz comments should never work because there's always rats and mice and weasels especially in those days right so it's always a so to speak let's say right or he was reading the book or he was texting now now here we come to step 3 this is different in the previous case why is it different than the previous case well HIDA isn't this much the previous case the previous case exactly the same thing you don't know if it's this house you don't if it's this house why is the camera making a whole new situation no I know factually this story was different but in Tison in sale in the Mahalo it's the same story in the first case in the first case in each in both cases it's 50% that I have comets both cases in other words in the in the previous case it's 50% to have comets it's also 50% I don't have because it could be the mouse of my house is holding the matzah was holding the map so right that's so it's 50% in this case also it's 50% to have comments cuz it could be the mouse one into the other house the only difference is and case the mouse for sure went into my house but maybe with matter and in the second case the house makes a difference we know for sure we have to do in this wish house most likely both oh so this is very important that the Gomorrah adds now the third case because it's not just the story changes it's the mahalik of the story changes in the previous case you could say that the Comets went into a house that was in Bothell we're not sure but 50% chance that the Comets went in to the right house cleaning the house that's anyway needs prediction and the matza went into my house which already had a bodega so you could say that it was my sorry so you could say it works out well right I did a dicker and I got the matzo you didn't do ab dicker and you got the comment I can also say the other way but at least it's equal both fakers are called school than its equal so that works so what happens now I could keep each house in its kazakh in other words the same assumption that this house had before the mouse it can have now to the classic of this house is that it was Bo dog maybe it's not me right maybe it's not but I'm not sure I know for sure was bought up that's 100% I didn't think of it it's a good thing as Commerce was coaching so for sure the status quo is this houses mother now you want to change that you want to change my Kazakh by saying no this comments you don't know okay so shake it it is just making dinner bombers a secretary it's a suffocated in Dearborn right Nicola I go with the 50% that its culture and if I don't change my kazakh that's in the previous case in this case both houses were bothered so you can't say leave each house in its Kazakh it's not going to work one house is Kazakh was destroyed because it's not 50 percent so hundred percent that has come it's in one house not fifty percent it's a hundred percent the problem is I don't know which house so it's a completely different type of creature for sure Komets went into one of the houses in other words one house for sure needs a particular a new dick in the previous case that's not true that's for sure that one house needs a new Boudicca you didn't do it but it's you anyway need to do it in other words you were any way doing particular so it's not a new thing me I did a particular yet and we're not sure I need a new particular 50% sure but will fifty percent an action in this case we don't know which but one house for sure the status quo was destroyed and the new outlook was created problems I don't know which one you're right you're right so this I'm just explaining this this is what they round the Quran says why the Gemara is an evolution here why the Gemara brings a new case in other words you say it's the same case like before it's just a different story what he has stamina much it with every type of scenario so he says no it's not and that's where the camera is gonna bring a new source to deal with this suffolk the previous source with true man who is not gonna suffice there because again in the previous source i could say the Hulan I knew this boxes : that's the Kazakh right it was a father he was sure now you want to change it and say there's true mayor it's only a sufferer so you keep it home that works for the second case for the third case you need a new Vaart because something really changed in others we know for sure one of the houses needs about the COS comments the question is which one exactly in the previous case the house that have dickermax and therefore the house doesn't need the customers exactly you can't say kazakh anymore Jessica's body doesn't work you say it has a Hesse curse but look of course it it had asked us bothered doesn't have a cask us but look anymore if I do particular scum it's in my house and then somebody brings in shallot in my house you say eskas but what Catskills mother you need a new dick you're right do you see a mouse going to the house with comes Alaska's public anymore here I saw it I just don't know which one it's a whole different part so what do we say now something tomorrow hi new Nashville and this is the case of two paths that now we learned omission of a sexist iris Barry okay snakes will endure were two paths at Khatami the f guitar one is impure and one is pure meaning there's a path that horizontally there is a grave there's somebody buried in that path throughout the entire width so if I walk through that path my body became an oil my body hovered over the mace and automatically I became Tommy no question but there's another path which is tired in other words there's no corpse over there know what happens now what happens is there were two paths exit Tommy Vesey attire the problem is we don't know which one is what we know there's two paths we know one is Tommy wanna start we don't know which one of the two paths is the Tom Hollis basket man I walk through one of these paths for us at iris and then I come home and I deal I make I touched iris tyrus means let's say so you shall I am and I'm meeting my carbon and I touch my carbon fruit or i mcai and I cut my trimmer food now I may have just walked over a corpse and became Tommy for at least seven days until I don't get the sprinkling of the red water and actions of the Parliament go to the mikveh or whatever the tumor is and the problem is the tyrus become Tommy well Park Ave Roy for Hollis push a knee his friend went on the second path Vasa Terrace and then he went and touched pure sacred food one of them certainly became Tommy and one of them certainly was machame the toy food but we don't know who this is the case the Gemara is comparing it to what's the halacha Eudora me review this says thank you fascinating evening shall lose above Nats movies ever from a outs my if they come to a column and they asked the question independently to hide it everyone gets a verdict are the rough tells you Taher your food is tired everybody can eat it I'm a higher the rough tells you your food is time I it seems like a joke the answer is it's a Suffolk it's a Suffolk as we'll see in raschi Suffolk tomorrow sir album this time yes name a bass ox but if they both came to the Holcomb to the stage simultaneously what should he tell them he has to tell them to me Botha Tommy why simply because he can't say to both of them Todd both Atari can't it's not true it's a lie so it's a very funny thing you come the next guy comes ten minutes later both come out with a sack time your bad Mazel you walked together you said we have this issue sorry both are Tommy you're bi CI mera BAC says no sorry make a coup Bangkok to me in both cases it's time right right exactly right the Buddha says because it's not individual it's not so it's not together it's individually both get-ups Akhtar unless they came together on my rover right yes oh no no no that's irrelevant when they went yes yes yes yes he means they came to ask together now that they went on the paths together it's two separate paths yes yes the asking was together yes yes yes yes yeah two roads diverged two roads diverged yeah one took one and the other took the other one so wanna stomp on my rubber Elvis says let me explain the Mishnah retain manipulation and some say Riviera and sentence but by soccer is the vehicle to me in fact if they came simultaneously everybody holds this sardine the verdict would be Tommy nobody who do would agree as he says and a BAC would agree as he says but Zack has said the vehicle to Hydra if they actually come one after the other everybody would hold tight in other words even abuse Lenexa cool the real argument driver says or tubulin on his alibi volley charlotte love Alka vada if one of them comes to ask a question for himself but also for his friend in other words he comes in and he says this is the story and we want to know I'm asking for both of us what is the halacha about the holy pure food that we both touched yeah the boys see Madame la lobos's Reb you see compares this case to a case where they both came and asked the question simultaneously because just like in that case he can't say both foods are pure here he also can't say both foods up here cuz it's not true whenever you who did of you did the first opinion Madame Lee Leila sarcasm he comprised this case to the case where they come one after the other why since there's only one person questioning not two people so therefore he could tell him your food is tired and as Rashi says he'll be able to understand that the same answer applies to his friend that's the case we're now finished with the case of snakes villain this is where the Gemara brought in order to prove the answer to our situation with the two houses let's see Rashi Rashi second - see you tomorrow the lawyer didn't Eli of Eli oh he must Safina medical traveler do both need Icahn Highness Nashville may hug the trunk emission elements in all emissions the mission of our two paths will give us an answer after Tommy cave remote Oh Bailey Rock boy there's a caver a corpse a burial plot of a corpse LaRocca in the width it's very important to say it's with y Kuzma Malia's school i it fills the entire width of the path if the cable was in the length then we're not sure one person is Tommy maybe both are not Tommy so it's a whole different situation but here it's mammalian school a meaning the ain't everybody shallow yo there's nobody to pass who could not who can avoid hovering over the corpse that's what an oil means you become a tent either you're in the tent with the corpse who you become the tent over the corpse no difference in both cases you come so hullick was the pirate mummys for us a terrace nogepa terrace africa you touch pure foolish mahalos Bechet me I didn't enjoy visuals olives olives ah - the mother mentum we know for sure that the two friends took different paths and not the same cuz if that is a doubt maybe we did the same path then we both may not be Tommy right so then there's no dinner if we come together you can't say Taher you could say thar because we both may not be coming we know for sure the vaad I couldn't hatch to by the elemental even is shallow collected Lusaka mistake epiphany absolute are vain bezel itami why could the crime alone be Suffolk to IBO sort of a quick talk about the Ganesha sugamice at the site there neither that when it comes to Suffolk come in a public domain even though it's a question of Toyota you going to the base emitters you can eat carbona see it's big questions serious question Suffolk time you should say orchids make a comment it's a unique situation that the question of doubt or certainty should be based on where it happened usually that's never the case no difference we're the question is is it likely or not likely here it's unique if it's a questioner shows our album it's Thomas the question is it's a tire but the question interest I offer the stomach well soon see we learn it out for myself from Seiter from the sugi of Seiter but in the Shuster album it's time the male snake eater so therefore you can't say this person is Tommy I he may be but it was a Suffolk Tom abuser albums of malice faker Taher and he can go back and say that all this food remains pure mean bah bah bah saunas hiya Luber here ah a Casillas non-alignment man entirely but if they come together since in one directive you have to say Tyra Tommy EF chillon all MLM Toyota madam Sharia exit vada Tommy you push it can't you can't verbally say you're both tired even though individually you could say it so yes so even though the patroon of russia's album is not lost but he cannot say to both of them Taher to the food is tired because that's not true because one of them became Tommy reveai see I'm a big castle been cashed a million chorus so Rob explained but Zack I said the vehicle toy in an avocation collected I'm Allah Fernando Collor my Sicily Mitchell Khomeini I will Ain initial allow out to me mater hail life even if I share what happened to my friend if I'm only asking for myself everybody holds you could say toward a low bulk of a ray mater hail Schnee new what if he asks for both WOC madami lula Bostock us the FOP change name the phone etiquette service after Iran are hustling a and its main after my Toyota not them Friday in at the limit I do not replace it compares it to them coming together w-who the madam in-law was asked as a high event console alas there's only one man questioning receiving will you tell them tired after you talk why shy race a fake beer who because it's a Suffolk beer what planet sir Suffolk beer it's a Suffolk if he ever came into the path with his amazed so therefore Tory rata cuz it's a Suffolk being it's interesting rash he didn't use these words initially when Ashley decided what the sake didn't when Ashley explain what the Poseidon was he said Suffolk to Mauritius Arab mistake a tired he here he adds this move art Charlie Suffolk be who it's a Suffolk if he was loud entered into this path who may ask me over in South America my he'll understand on his own the sack for his friend a Vikash Nayar a limited Candida more but if both are asking touch today did when here actually defines what does it mean they asked together as together means what they speak simultaneously it means within a few seconds Shalom alechem a David a beer so militiamen between a few seconds from the first person the other person asked sorrow at the loss of listen a in cash so you have to answer both and then everyone will hold that you cannot say tied what's the connection to our case oh gosh Ragab a bottom nah me so now is the same visor with the house okay my house is Bo Duke your house is Bo Duke one of our houses needs a new political summit that's not a question one of our houses needs it's a Suffolk just like the two paths ceases Ebola shows Elif asked me with everything it's mine if they both come to the Sox I'm independently task Republicans Cummins I'm gonna lay the call hard we tell each individual yacht at Soros live duck you know if everybody why it's a Suffolk because the key when the batik has come is deer are born on talena McCullough just like Suffolk to me Bruce Arab amidst our biggest comets is a he of their are born on we follow the lineage possibility Romney nuns fake like what you have a Suffolk and you did bitl it's only a question on their opponent fine quantum dicker I may be this comets okay it's a something we Eva basses most name system they can they both came simultaneously then you can't say you both don't need to be dick here that's not true one needs so therefore they're gonna need a dick and what if one person comes and asks for the other then it's gonna be on my clickers of you never see Rubio EC will say they both need a big interview they will say they both the only thing cuz you tell this person you don't have to do but they cannot understand on his own with his friends if one person comes to ask for both so even though one Hozuki was certainly ruined and one house for sure needs dick his comets and he can say go back to the status quo one of them can't go back to the status quo nonetheless we have AG avowed the kiddush we keep each house according to its hozuki and nobody a stupid ickis comets and this is a hitter screws even though we know for sure that one house has comets in it and there was nobody cares comets after the conference came in which you can't say about the second case the same case we don't know for sure that a checked house now has comets and was not checked you don't know that for sure 50% here we know for sure that one house after bleeker's comments got comments and nails and there was no noob Nicolas comments nonetheless we say you could go into Pesach why could you go into Pepe sir because you asked for yourself it's a Suffolk just like snakes villain we know for sure that there's a carbon that's Tom a and nonetheless we treat it as tar and it's very interesting because if you think about it we know for sure that one of these foods is stomach it's like what are you talking about how could you let it go you need it it's awesome Amish could be it could be a pseudonym of of missamma nation I am of nonetheless we say it's fine why because Taylor says Suffolk commercial said I'm thought so them if you have a Suffolk you don't have to say top I it's not a Suffolk it's a van they just don't know who you're right but for you it's a soft no no no it's Manila Luna minute island from silk'n yeah yeah yeah of course of course costumers are the engine of day license yeah it says unique usually specular I saw the Cumbre Foss was up there yeah the same Tyler says that they're exactly the same tighter that says that it's a Tommy and it's an issue comer to eat it the same Toyota says even though you could say one is for short on me and you know it for sure it's not a question nonetheless you can eat it twice which has an interesting deal if you take alcohol as Beckerman Massa taught us how did not Qatar as well I call man Adam time why do we have to make this whole complicated my see he went and touched pure food why don't you just say about him is he tired or not does he need para don't worry not does he need make her or not I mean what do you have to go to the food talk about himself same issues he says no we're shunned Allah Gavin when we talk about the people I forgot the McMinn libertas co-starred in much hidden loot Villa Vizag shalyah goosh Nahum 'but rumor the other room it may have our dough is vehicle benissa been with no goosh name bastard the mission islamic Disgaea fascinating toys who says when it comes to the person himself even though he has asked a star and you can't take away that kazakh through a suffix I'm tired we will still force the person to get to Vila and Hazor means sprinkle from the Red Hat from the ashes in the world of the part of Twitter go to the mikveh why why not for himself because if me and my friend touched rumor then the true miss for short time and if somebody eats it he's kind of miss of edition line and if we touch somebody that person is now that person is now itami from the both people and if he goes into the base some extra she sky of cars so therefore we're gonna force the person to go to the mikveh ah that's cute that's funny the first time Sudirman olive that's why the Mishnah puts it in different situations us at iris food you can't put food in the mikveh i'm gonna work so the question on the food is is it Tommy guitar on the person themself you right I'm tired and you're tired but we're gonna say go to the make of anyway but the tyrus is not gonna help you have to give up a socket in so that's why it says on Tyrus another interesting word entices the bass actors did a hackle to make him neither the Hyneman did not bother them with a rifle of a boxer he says even this is only their opponent other words mean I've tired at eyes result if they would come together you could still say you're both talking at Ithaca their abundance said don't do it because you look like a lawyer it's Mexico Chikara it's very strange it's like you're contradicting the facts so therefore don't do it but he says that goof is only add ended up on them I mean not tired even if they come together you could say you're both tired are you both not tired but you're both in reality tired because Suffolk coz Suffolk took me this time so mayor you both are fascinating right the diary looks like it's strange that so there are abundant said if they come together it's gonna be too weird too too too deceptive too strange so this is the third case we'll sue secret the Kumar's gonna get back to it yeah yeah well soon see we learn it out from the sugi of sight uh there's a different min Suffolk temperature ceramic soldiers will soon see the exact source good already in the second case we sets make because how much is us their abundance make a look : we're just the third case ago just like in the second case which 50/50 you say don't have to be by dick here it's also 50/50 I don't have to I one of the houses for sure needs but you're right but each house has a Suffolk so if I come on my own and you come on your own right or even if I ask for you according to W hood we both don't have to do dick you're right you want to know again with the mag admission are good the same question we had on the second case we have in the third case you're right you sang why you because comets why do we we let go of acres ah I'm gonna answer the question but I want to do one more case one more case next case case number four okay for the first case concluded two details Kahoot and parish the second case was the two houses matzah comets the third case was the two houses and comets in one and not in the other one there was one mouse and now comes the fourth case what's the fourth case very interesting case I saw the mouse take comments okay and slept it into the courtyard of my house the four year the huts are the courtyard Suffolk all Suffolk lay off I don't know if he decided to go into my dining room to if he decided to go into my house or not Raschi puts it take a look at nYSCI Suffolk also the globe raw akbash and not all comets because what's bothering Rashi you see a mouse with comets on forshay you don't have to start being harsh I went into your house cuz then nobody can ever do because comets that's efficient you can always think that there's a mouse the problem that's where - she says it's not some stuff we called Suffolk law we already learned in the Mishnah ain't hi Shan Shan mcgarricle de Mumbai's low bias told me hot silicon sir right cause anal another so if me a linear so Rashi says Raj but should not tell how much because he took comets in the hut via by his buttock the any day a mission a sirloin honest I don't know if he continued to go in to the house or not into that well either you or not loved Africa could be my own hot sir so I'll get sometimes you have a shot sorry but called only particular because this Ravens there all the time and so forth yeah here there's a hot so I see this bread hey I'm for sure gonna have to do dick here because the aspis here with the comments the Davos ice you know he went into the vicinity of my home now what's the question let's understand we already answered it's a Suffolk you call the cooler didn't we have the second case the third case it's all the same issue you're not sure does comets in your house maybe yeah maybe not so go look cool another why is there a new question in the Gemara if you don't know which house the mouse went in with comets even though you went into one of two houses you go back to your house oka and you don't have do a second thickest comet unless they ask together right sorry buzzer II here for sure it's good cuz we not even sure you went into the house ma does in a case where you know for sure the mouse went into a house you just not sure ma I know yours right still you don't have to do because comets why because unless you came to ask together each one is assumed to maintain its kazakh even though one for sure didn't for sure here you don't even know it into our house went into a hut sir so we kind of culture can't become assignment should be good why is the Gemara struggling with this case here again the fiduciary Ron who is the one who explains the evolution of these are walkers comes to the rescue and what does he say he dinars that the question is do we look at the hut sir and the house has one richest as one domain it's basically like one one one complex if it's considered like one rucious so then the fact that it came into the cuts there is Macaulay of all the bottom with a second Iike why because it's like you saw a mouse come into your house with comets it's not a question of 50% that's one way of looking at it yeah just like if I see the mouse on that corner of the COTS I have to check also the other side right cuz maybe he left there I don't say oh I just saw it there you have to check another the whole culture sky even bigger the whole house or houses would be higher than bodega all the houses if it's a culture that shared by many all the houses behind them thicker so this I can't learn from the previous situation and the previous situation he went into one house so we hear my Suffolk is only about that house cuz I'm not afraid he took it from one house to another house as we said before we don't consider that trash so over there you can exempt every single house because it's a Suffolk but here it's a valet on the house just not on the house on part of the house if you consider it part of the house that's how they round the fines the question so that's the Schuyler how you look in a hut sir that's the Schuyler how you look at the shot sir how do you look at it see says hi new beaker this is the case of bicker what's the case of bicker how does he translate bicker Valley this is the case of open fields who reported the SS over upon them it's dependent on the argument of the blessing upon and although this lump little is one and many are not don't put into the text will soon see why that's non the Mishna says initial abhi cover my section if somebody goes into a place of open fields during the rainy season and it's not considered Arusha sir Robin why because during the rainy season you're now at a walk through people's fields because the seeds are germinating and trying to grow and therefore it's off-limits it's not like in the summer time after growth we're very often it could become a domain for the public the point here is it was the time when there's no permission for you to trespass another way to to recycle the tumor beside the plainness we know that one field has a grave basically it's impure on my ramaa record one guy says I walk through ma Kamala's I went into this territory maybe a day McNasty voices sodium - nasty but I'm not sure if I went into that field or I didn't go into that field each field there was a place of a lot of fields but each plate field has parameters it has some boundaries and we knew that in one field there was a caver the problem is we don't know we don't have a doubt the problem is the person doesn't know which one he went it did he go through this one did he go through that one and if we doesn't know if he ever covered over that grave now usually Suffolk Toma Bruce a yahud is Tommy and this is a vicious eye your head so when he comes to the hukum the answer should be coming but he doesn't know if he came in ever so there Burleson metalia ban hamma Mitama rabbul izza says he started come say no so he SS Ramar Suffolk BL PI Suffolk market to me Tommy when we say Suffolk to Mauritius ah yeah it depends if it's a Suffolk if he but cloud entered Suffolk beer if it's a subrogee McCloud came in via from the word BAE that's lovely we came in then tired even initially offered Suffolk Margot uma if it's a Suffolk if he touched the tumor for example I know that I came into the field I don't know however if I came in contact with the tumor that's the type of tumor that's in your shoe socket that is Tommy that's what your bilasa tynus with the hannam say that he is coming that's the McCoy Goose let's explain according to the Belleza when you say Suffolk to Mauritius I offer this tummy okay there's two ways of learning I'm going to first say the first one it's only if there was one Suffolk not a sex Rekha here there's aspects faker why is the effects faker two stouts number one that I ever enter into the field I'm not sure I went through the fields but it could be I went to another field okay that's Suffolk or even if I did go into that field that I happen to go over that grave maybe I happened to walk in the path of the field there was no grave you don't have to say that I actually walked where the corpse was and I hovered over it so am a learnable as it says that Suffolk tomorrow should say okay this Tommy if it's what Suffolk but if it's a smacks faker it would be tiring that's the of Robbie Elias what would the haha mom hold the shaman would hold that there's no to say cursor why because the fact that there are borders between fields doesn't make it separate properties in terms of our locker in terms of tumour and therefore there's only one Suffolk did I go over the grave or not because I went into one of the fields and it's considered since it's a beaker with a lot of open fields it's not enough to differentiate and say that there's a double Suffolk markers dis markers but there's no physical physical right right right it's considered one field so Bay let's one Suffolk that that's one way of learning too much like this that's how a she no but what if it's not that's the road but here we don't say that that was by the shrill it wasn't like that it wasn't for sure yes it was in a corner in a field or in one place in a field it's not sure that if you went into the field you talked then it wouldn't be a strikes rate it's a Suffolk it's a Suffolk that's what Suffolk to militia say y'all could means it's a something maybe let's say so there's four corners you the chance you went through 104 it's okay much less it's nothing maxillary it's look no no an open a group of open fields right so I guess sometimes it means a place with this that the idea is that in a valley becoming is a valley but the idea is that over there they would usually plant a lot of fields you're right yes yes you're right yeah over there the point is the ditch that the lower the lower incline another way of learning this is choice versus way is that grab a lesser holds that smacks faker versus I often is tired because where do we learn suffolk tama birches a yard we learn it from a site what's the din of a site you tell your wife I don't want to see you privately I don't want you should be in a private room with write XYZ there's too much going on I'm suspicious say in front of two witnesses she disobeys and she goes into a private room with that purse the door is locked or closed there are witnesses who see her go in lock the door nobody knows that anything happened but they were there for whatever time and now she comes out they both come out what's the halacha the lock is there now let it be together as a husband and a wife until she goes to the base on McNish and drinks the famous sight of water and the water will determine if she admits that she had a relationship so they can get divorced and it's fine if she says no I'm fine we just we just drank a little grape juice over there and had some sushi so she drinks the water and so to speak God takes over God becomes the therapist in this marriage and he says I'll decide ok this husband obviously wouldn't trust anybody else so Hashem says she comes out of this trust her and if not she won't live that's that the idea of sight till she drinks the water yeah she's considered Tommy they can't be together it's a Suffolk tumor why is it a Suffolk DOMA because we don't know for sure we know for sure you wouldn't have to do the water right we don't know for sure so this is where we learned that Suffolk two members should say yeah it is Tommy and as the Gemara says it's a cow behind me because if the woman did it by mistake or she was coerced which she didn't want to then it wouldn't be a problem at all nonetheless it's only if she does it willingly nonetheless if it's a Suffolk you still say Tommy certainly when it comes to a dead corpse were even if you touch a corpse by mistake you still Tommy so for sure Suffolk temperatures are y'all can just tell me that's the site from a site that a Suffolk to memory so you can even though it's a Suffolk could tell me now in that case by a Suffolk by a by a site only one Suffolk what's the Suffolk if she had relations if she didn't have relations it's only one Suffolk so a mailer the Blazer says from site - you can learn that in a case of one Suffolk it's gonna be Tommy that's the vork because from site there you learn out that Suffolk to Mauritius a yahoo Tommy and over there it's only one Suffolk so therefore rabble Ezzor disagrees that many fakers purchase a Yahoo this Tommy he holds only if it's one Suffolk versus I else it is going to be coming then there's no stomach that is no Suffolk to me no citrus a asset they were secluded in a private domain only then does it apply according to this a Belleza with alcohol that only one Suffolk push yourself in the stomach usually most shits as we say that as many fakers even specs vex vex faking wishes al had always Tommy and the reasonable as would be my tire here is only could as a Suffolk beer it's a Suffolk of you but cloud came in it's a different type of Suffolk or the toys versus notable azúcar pillows that if it's one Suffolk its mutter if it's one Suffolk it's Tom Lee only suspects faker would be tired coming in here coming as coming yeah as coming in yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah so now so what's the conclusion how does this apply to us it applies to us exactly the same situation what's the situation so let's see Rashi and he clarifies it all Suffolk all Suffolk loyal where our ass Bush and not all Commons because of our buyers bothered mainly am Nick Miceli madness right beaker Highbury saw this awesome yacht curry beaker that's what he means by big care many things and my suck shaman have a bigger issue say Yahoo the term they say quite summer has either been reduced uncle Adam Lacan Islam it so just I offered because the seed started growing and they don't let anybody come in the kind with on Suffolk town we should say yeah it's faker Tommy but so deploying is Colima but as soon as I went into a field the I did not obey Ziva call south of a Southern Miss EMS women Sorrell we know where the mace is and each field has its markers the mahkumat laws the because oh I don't know if I went into this I went into the Beekman I don't know which field so red blazer says finds helmet Thomas Avila Suffolk tomorrow socket but emeliza lahar Shimla Suffolk to me LMK knishmas lazada only if you came into the field I will a me a name Halen lawyer I will hashtag with aspects faker but now it's aspects make so the Belleza says you tired because you're not sure you came into the field what are the hakama mold the FICA memo that all the fields are considered like one and therefore as R as she puts it it's not aspects faker it's only one Suffolk why because how logically when it comes to tumor they just see it as one as one domain as one domain according to this what snob of Dicker's comments or a she continues the gab a bottom I feel her bun and my ID the kid when the dick has come as the rebuttal in a little me by comets it's because comets is a fee of only there are born on so mainly even there are born on who say Tommy over here will say that you don't have to be biting the house I they say when you came in the fields even though you're not sure you went into that field so a mailer its aspects faker they say you Tommy why you tummy because they hold that it's not considered to separates fakers it's considered one suffered or you may want to learn because they hold even specks make commercials so yeah this Tommy however you want to learn their Vaart but then it could is that the common would say Tom a so if they say Tommy what should be the halacha here well no the algebra came into the cut sir should I have to be boy dick the house it shouldn't have to me by the grouse look how it I should say just like there we treat all the fields as one domain and therefore it's only one Suffolk and we say that your tummy so look slightly we should say exactly the same thing here so they says we're soil according to their but Leslie you don't need another particular why don't you need another particular cuz it would be a spec speaker even according to their are born on since it's only a few of their abundant so you go the cooler what would be the cooler the color would be that it's one Suffolk what's the Suffolk the Suffolk is if it's by you or not and you would say telling on the co2 linen is you were you rely you assume yeah Tyla yeah yeah yeah like you were tribute to linen you're Tyler you you you bring it over to the side of cooler you hang it on this side well I can hang it on this side I can hang it on this side so to speak and I hang it on the side of Cola so what do we see from here the gamora's comparing the commerce to the din of Toma if we say that cuts around the bottom is one ruse so then I have to do batik in the house also as though over the corner of the cut-set so according to their ballasts are who calls it Suffolk beer because I'm not sure he went into that field why don't why am I not sure cause I don't consider all like one field so here to every house is separate from the cut sir since I didn't see the mouse come to the house so there's no reason to consider it a house in which you saw comments was broadened so you didn't you don't need another predict the finishes that even that have come in who disagree with rebel laser here they say you could be lenient and say that the mouse didn't come into the house why because the fiber sub dick is only their opponent and therefore you could treat it as a separate entity because we're dealing with a few of their with a fee of the Urbana that's why it seems like Rashi wasn't good as be placated in a bless of her Bonham cuz she's saying it's according to both shittest it's according to both opinions and spent okay so we won't have time for the answer today so we'll do that tomorrow if you could just keep the copies please please just keep it because so we don't have to make more copies you're having a ram bomb and you have your cell phone or a hookers pesach so if you could just keep it all so yesterday we had around on the first page of the Rambam so we just keep it's basically four pages to stapled and to separate just keep it wherever you'll know where it is tomorrow cause we're gonna learn it tomorrow Ballina there everybody have a wonderful day know for sure but that's not considered a court I'd like for example like Shabbos it's not considered a court you know because I thought too is enclosed the hata has four walls culture has four walls yeah like when it comes to Shabbos minute or you could carry in a Hudson has all of them said a Duva cáceres why my mother was moussaka but men are tired of rock scissors should say Offit it's full of houses for walls without a roof it's like the lobby of an apartment building is a hot circuit the lobby of an apartment building the lobby of an apartment building is as part of the homes it's it's private that's so if you see a mouse in the lobby right do you need the ticket so the law says you don't need it yeah the he needs bicker the lobby needs bicker because there's bread over there but the houses don't need to be Ditka the lobby needs a picker the Hudson needs bicker the whole lobby whoever is my if we're partners were over here so one makes us real you make Ashley Kawai oh are you something but somebody got to do it if there's an owner if there's an owners and these if it's missing bunch of kids play there if we live together there's a lobby and kids play there with food then there could be comments they have to be I mean it's usually even if you look if it's if it's if it's owned by a Jew I mean question is Lucius is it if it's comments of a guy that it's never also Jewish would you required to view the video on bro Lobby are you using it during shuffle do you own it to you all the shares to your place you know write the commentary so does that mean because I don't think so if you don't own it probably not to use it you have a right to use it use but even still the shares themselves it's not it's not like you want a quarter if you want to share in a cooperative manner so that would be a different thing that's more powerful and that's different I think so he's asking us about whether or not impersonate his name on a deed to a place for anything like that not so here what's right a movie HUD Cyrus Brooks is on the game that they owners together that everybody has a right to use it on Shabbos to carry their to play there etc that's the if a guy tucker has right there you have to figure out how to do it it's not supported then you have to be boy because that's real ownership yeah yeah yeah that's real ownership so in the lobby you would have to be bided cuz there's a mouse there do I have to go into the house now and do a whole new dick in the building that we say no I it's possible he went into the house it's true it's true this possibly possible not people do that it's owned by a Jewish person I think they do it I'm thinking in our when we lived in an apartment building that somebody knew because comments there and it is an easy because Hamid because usually it's just an open I mean it's usually an easy please comment it's not a no okay maybe it's Malcolm Shan municipal Commons this class is brought to you by the achieve Annette please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot a yeshiva net / donate