Pesachim 8a-b - Losing The Needle - Gemarah Pesachim #41

the yeshiva dotnet 10 lines from the bottom suctioned of hazama Dolloff the gomorrah has been focused in the last section on the expression of the Mishnah call McCoy who Shane Magnuson boy Komets Ansari dica every place where one does not bring in comets does not need predict as comets why the mission to use the word call mock i'ma not ma coin and for this the Gemara explained that there are various places which we would have excluded from this a lock and we would have said they do need because comets for example the holes in the walls of our home where you could put comets in and there in rooms where you do bring in homage such as the holes are higher or lower and similar situations wine cellars and oil cellars where you may think that you do need because comets stables barns of cattle or chicken coops or storage places of straw or different items in the house that have roofs and you could they have they have tops a GOG atop and you could put comments in there and you may be using the furniture for comets and the room for comets but nonetheless because these particular places are either a place where you will not bring in comets individually into this item because it's not comfortable or you have animals who may eat it etc so therefore the mission is call maka other words we expand the Mach time as as much as you have to the point is if it's a place where comets doesn't belong and you don't bring comments there we rely on that and we say you don't need to the customers now the camera continues the next Stickle america's de the priestess I think bei dogyum bei dogyum is you have a storage place of I guess Bay dogyum is a place where you keep fish and that's where you get your fish for the meal in sort of petechiae so you don't need thickest comments they're frag the Gemara waha tanya the bryce is situation but the you do need sort of wisdom would be contradicting the price of the time oh yeah so acting more like cash it's really not a contradiction Harbor traveler V Harbor zoo tree when the Prince de said that you don't need thickest comments in a bait dog and he was talking about Ravelry that really means a big one a large one it's basically a place where you have a storage place where you have large fish so therefore this Amish the person who's preparing the meal can estimate before the meal the quantity of fish that is required for the meal and take it out before the meal and therefore it will usually will not happen that the middle of the meal he says there's not enough fish and he's gonna go get more like we said before by the oil hub is URI the Bryce is talking about place with his small fish as Rashi says huh bibliography ain't sort of dickin the second of the white wines sure yesh lemkova aim is main circle our model of events are sued because you can estimate I'm it means you can estimate Kivar means is a fixed number you know how much you're going to need and usually he won't have to get in the middle of the meal to bring more zoo tree means small fish England club volume it there's no clear estimation of how much you're going to need ya like herring would be an example our herring yeah our wearing would be an example we need more herring but sorry slime with the lobby so middle of the meal you may stand up and bring more you're giving big big pieces of fish you know how much you're bringing you're not gonna need more but if it's small fish right maybe if not a few people if somebody's a little more hungry you need more fish to the sandwich the middle of the meal is going to want to get more and he may walk into the storage place of the fish with his and leave his bread there and therefore that's why the Bryce's says you would need Nikolas Commons so in other words they weren't really arguing they were just describing the situations that were coming to them people were asking questions to have to do because come and see if Nichols comments here and they were describing the halacha based on the reality that was being presented to them and therefore you don't can't make contradictions because here it says here it says there because you just have to know the circumstances Amira Abbar of Hoonah amber the son of Ravana sir may milky obey Kira a storage place for salt and a storage place for wax that's used for candles it's articulate it needs be Dickon why here we can understand why she says bein milky is based on Ella Bache earrings shriver place where you keep wax started legal official imitation I'll sue the lovely MELAS my neighbor's this is very calm in the middle of the meal that the waiter gets up to bring more candles because the candles went out so he needs more wax or we need salt and therefore the middle of the meal he may leave bread there by mistake inadvertently chef Ameera Papa with papas Beit CV a storage place for wood for lumber CV is lumber obey Tom Murray and a storage place for tomorrow in which our dates sardars particular gonna need snicker because here again you will enter in the middle of the meal and the reason is you need more lumber maybe for the fire or you need more dates for the meal again it's not something that like desserts you know impersonal once more dessert is not enough dates it's not like the big fish that it's it's basically a course come Tom it's week I'm talk on our Shabbos meal everyone gets a plate with fish yes it's possible that one person is going to be starving and you're gonna want to get another big piece of fish but it's not common but if it's dates or it's a small piece of fish these types of snacks or its wine or beer and bubble these types of things we're in the middle of the meal is often a shortage and it was common for the shamash to go and then get more like wood or dates or wax or salt here you have to do thickest humus but the principle remains always the same you have to look at a room and say is it likely that there may be comets it likely doesn't mean I'm 90% sure there's comets I may be 10% maybe only a 10% chance but there is a chance that there is comets a chance we mean under natural circumstances that could be comments anywhere but I don't have to expect it but if it's a place that is had that the person will enter through it will it go in during the year enter into that place with comets in his hand and that is a likelihood it's a possibility so that's a place that needs thickest comets even though it's of course only a soffit because he may not find any summons there it's not like your kitchen where you're probably going to find comments Tong we had a Bryce Amos I've annoyed Silverhawks initially the Federals dog can live the company Asik honor the price it teaches us we do not obligate a person doing Dickus comets to take his hand and put it into holes and cracks to do boudicca's cometh because of danger that's the price now it's very cryptic my second what type of second are we talking about what is the danger he named a place OCONUS occur off perhaps you too much scorpions if it's an insect that's not dangerous I don't care so they'll be an insect over there but perhaps we're afraid that in these cracks and holes there were scorpions and the person could get bitten cos mashaallah so therefore the hazael sir relax don't put in your hand into those places but NASA Connor if that's what it means then we have a bigger problem establish a establish how is he using it for comets why is he putting his hand to put things there if the scorpions hanging out there in other words if it's good enough for him to store comments there or to deposit comments there or to high comers there whatever he wants to put there any items so why is it not suddenly becomes dangerous the night of Nikolas comets the night before the kiss comets and a whole year it's a good place to use but suddenly the night of dick is coming star scorpion is what they knew to arrive from Nicholas comments he missed a machete astonish how did you use it initially how did you use it I see you're going to say you didn't use it because there's no scorpions there well if didn't use it then it's a mahkum shame I listen become fit so you don't need thickest comets so don't tell me you don't implicate his comments with NASA kana you don't have do Dicker's comments there because there's no common thing because you don't use it if you don't use it so there's a long how much they because you don't put anything there answers the Gemara electric I'll explain to you what the pricing means the pricing means didn't offer basically the structure say the wall fell it crumbled in other words initially the wall was there and there was a hole or a crack and you used to use it and there was no fear of scorpions because they usually don't hang around in a place that is populated and civilized and therefore you put comments there the problem is this wall crumbled so it became basically a heap of rubble and now it attracts scorpions or snakes or other insects that's where they hang out you know rats mice etc these are there these are the fun places to hang out these are their sand boxes so now I'm afraid because it's a place of rubble and dirt and and gravel so it attractive scorpions and there is comets there then maybe comets there so I tell you you don't have to do particular there why I'm in a huh Sakana so what do you do you just look if there's comets on the top of course take it away do Boudicca but to stick your hands into every crack and hole in the rubble there's no need for it with NASA con either cos I'll wanted because comets but the same has all set in this case we're going to rely on bittle because we do not want to endanger a person says the Gemara one second this doesn't make sense enough owl if we're talking about a case where the house fell or the wall fell or whatever crumbled then lama liebe dich then it's not an issue of a scorpion then you don't need thicker why after now we have a mission em sock and we're gonna learn it later that vomit out how much enough love my polis if you have comets even if you know that this comments there and I'm a pilot how did you say I'm a pilot sir a heap of stones a ruin collapsed and covers the Comets so now I'm doing nika's comets the night of pay suckin in my basement right a wall collapsed and covers the comments hi ray who can move or how logically you can treat the Comets as in though it was already destroyed as though it was burnt as though it was eliminated you do not have to go and take shovels and dig up the rubble and find the Comets even if you know the dis comets in order to do beer companies I thought the difference was is it the case with yeah it was accessible this I think we understand before that's a concept them where it's collapsed and it's inaccessible okay good that's who the governor wants to analyze you know if you telling me that it was enough foul the word my polis is actually associated with the word right mop all no foul it fell and it collapsed yeah and that's what you're telling me and that's where you don't think about the comments cuz there may be scorpions I'm asking you forget the scorpions whenever there's comments that is under a map Oilers under a pile of rubble debris gravel earth filth the Cohanim said you do not have to do dhikr you could treat it as though there's beer it's true that how come him said you have to do bit though you should do bittle still right and the reason you should do bit tool is as we're gonna see later is because if the middle of pace are for whatever reason some of the comments gets exposed right somebody comes and cleans up a little bit over the rubble or something happens or or an animal comes around and exposes a little bit of the comments and it's in your domain you're gonna be over on bali a row of value mud see if you don't destroy it right now so if you did bitl you're good but you don't have to do beer comments so forget about scorpions even if we know there's no scorpions answers the Gemara answer no let's take a look in a she didn't offer enough Allah Binion ain't much - I said live de cos gala of on him we don't obligate him to search through the pile gal is a mound or heap a pile of stones Evelyn Marisol I am here Myra sign doesn't mean my reciting as we usually save my rasayan only what your eye sees in other words the comments that you see you have to get rid of I have a lawyer - Missy under ebay naen there's no obligation that's what the price is meant to put your hands in between the cracks and look and find why because of scorpions or a similar danger of some dangerous insects that may be roaming around your gravel your dirt well miss helix show you our coastal kindness damage McCoy in the beginning when the wall was intact you used it they used it was a hole and you used it but that's enough for their ships a connoisseur of him said I cannot see ash voiceover Galan scorpions are attracted to garbage dumps and - and - heaps of rubble ash Boyce's ash for garbage and gallon are are heaps mountains of of rock and rubble and dirt etc so therefore you'd have to do bodega ah it's a my pointless answers the Gomorrah host and the mission is talking about chain a colossal copy Sakura that the door cannot search for the Comets the Gomorrah explains over there the mission explains over they do Sherman I'm Leo said when is come it's called manure if I'm a pilot fell on it only if this if the dog can't search for it meaning that the heap is tall at least minimum threat for ham which would be approximately between nine and twelve inches so that even a dork will usually not go and search for it because it's enough of a mathletes enough of a hot seat sir for the smell of the Comets to reach the dog and entice the dog to go look for the food Harvick shocked L of your helicopter Sakharov here when we say that the Bryce is talking about that the wolf fell it doesn't is a huge heap of rubble and the comet is buried threatt fuck'em under the rubble then you say you don't have to do but they can be its like manure but here it's much more accessible as you said your vehicle it's not under 312 now 9 inches or 12 inches of rubble there is some rubble the wall fell so you would have to do boudicca's comets because it's right here the dog is gonna find it and that's why there's a much bigger shash that it's going to be exposed because it's pretty in the open it may be one tear under two trucks a month or two and a ton there may be a few inches but not many inches and therefore you would have to do dhikr but if there is any danger of scorpions or similar hazardous insects that have come and said don't do particular for that reason that's why the price is says that when there's a hole you don't have to stick your hand into it because of the sacona because we're talking about in the case where number one you use the hole we asked if it's a hole and there's a sarcoma there why did you use it the answer is you used it when it was attacked then the wall fell so it's not intact now the Comets may be in the hole over there but it's not deep threatt welcomed under the rubble it's not so you could do but they can be or it's much more accessible and the dog is going to reach it and that's why we do say you have to do beer right however in this case you don't have to because of the particular hazardous concerns in terms of the scorpions which may bite the person who's doing but they can therefore they said we do not obligate you to do particular comments in this particular situation so this means that we never have to do Dickus comets when the Comets falls under the rubble whenever the Comets may be mixed in into a pile of rubble gravel filth dirt and it's buried under it you never have to do big if the rubble is three tall and the Comets is under it or maybe under it which means between nine and twelve inches then you for sure don't have to do beer because we said hi ray who can move or we treat it as though it's gone it was exterminated it was destroyed but now we learned that even if the pile of rubble is smaller right it's not three tall nonetheless you don't have to do particular summits why because of a concern that there may be some undesirable insect there and therefore you do not have to do the kiss command so that's a give all the inhibitors that we got from this price that is a whole new concept besides the issue of my point list is the issue of Sakana and therefore you don't have to do but there's comments even if it's a small pile of rubble as long as there is even a chance that it may be attracting a scorpion or a snake or similar things that are hazardous of course if you know that this that chance doesn't exist so then this wouldn't apply so now even they open the whole I'm sorry what know if it's in the open then we're not worried about a scorpion just take it yes I know no it's not much sticking your hands into a place where you don't see the scorpion if this hum it's right here what's the problem today I mean in the open it's dirty if there's a Sakana if it's in the open it's not a problem just take it away when the scorpion is not there but if I have to stick my hands in two holes and cracks right so I can't see were there so you would say okay bring an attractor bring in bring in a cleaning group let them take shuffles clear it all up and the Scorpions will go away or at least you'll see them we don't say that we don't say just take a look in toy service it's an interesting toy store is the last Toys R Us customer out harvick shock L of your college campus aha earth we're talking about that the dog can search for it because it's not so deep and therefore the smell the aroma is very appealing to the door well the train ain't it parted I look nice Arcana and that's why the source of the exemption is danger nothing else for hard the marsh Maga Vemma Polar's the mikela vehicle a hopless a nakum evolve it's a little over they will admit them a place at Cana sacrif if so Toys R Us has a question the mission is said that homage to novel of my polis is kim ofwar and appearing a lil explained when if it's three but based on this browser the Mishnah should have not left us in the dark and should have said actually not even if it's less than three to Arkham you don't have to do beer comets for a different reason because you're telling me the reason is cuz it's tweet and therefore nobody is gonna bother to find the whole reason of Nicolas comments is why you may come to eat it you're not gonna come to eat it chummy over La Salette right it is something you have absolutely no access to it to all we still do bittle just in case in case in case it gets exposed to basic fine we're not warming but here which less than three two awesome we're saying you still don't have to do but it can be or why because secona so the mission er shouldn't have made a blanket statement that if it's three two you know have to do boudicca's comments something very strange it's a very confusing i love in the mission and you're telling me that the price is introducing all moral officer that's the question of priceless from the mission it seems like that if they're my pilus if the heap would be less than three twelve him it wouldn't be mejor and you would have to do but it his comments omae says the ree shiny hassan is different very interesting / EK comments over the mission is talking about you know that there's comets you know for sure that you had a whole whole basket of bread here you know for sure so therefore he who are the vada you can comment it's for show comments so therefore you could say he tree hookah common-law Hasker pollen but moreover Hasina eval haka shana how much you do a low heat treat kugel meaning the mission is talking about in a place where you know for sure the dis comments so therefore they're going to tell you that if there's no three to him you should hire help clean up the heap and get rid of the comments because you know for sure that this comets and it's very shallow it's not deep i there's a Sakana okay so clean it up so you could see and then you could take the comments away and you're not gonna get bitten don't put your hand in a hole but are we're talking about here you're not sure that this comments remember it's talking about a hole and we said you don't have to put your hand into the hole you're not sure that there was comments there it may have been used for comments throughout the year and then the wall fell since you're not even sure that this comments over there so the comment did not make you do this now there's an irregular situation even if you're not sure that there's come that's would be the kiss commences look I'm obligated you to go search for comets in every place with is a possibility for comments in a place of danger they're not Mojave that you should rent workers and clean it out in this case they were lenient and they relied on little that's the distinction he makes so this is talking about in a case where you don't know that there was how much and then you don't have to do it if you know for sure that this comments get rid of it unless it's tweet for him high and then you don't have to you can just do bit okay so as a result the conclusion is that the price that told us if there's a hole you have to put your hole your hand into holes and cracks to do particular comets because of danger and we explain what we're talking about when I talk about a regular wall which is intact because then if there's a real danger you wouldn't have put in comments then if you did put on comments there so then why can you do particular comments and if you didn't put in how much there because it's always danger the you know fluke dick has comments at all but what did we establish share a principle and that is a Jew is going to duplicate summits and his hand or body may be bitten and therefore we say no particulars comments for you the main thing is to keep you safe frack the Gemara a general principle of our marvelous Arabella's and taught us loose a mitzvah a nun is like some insisting quest not a joke somebody is going to observe a mitzvah he should not be afraid of being harmed he's going to predict his comments he should say I'm not worried for scorpions the scorpions knows because how much they stay away yeah the famous story slew came it's raining as I can Amira Bashi quite a fascinating answer NEBOSH she answers and says you're right scheme' toward lima hot I'm afraid that this person be occurs how much is gonna lose a needle he lost the needle a needle is not easy to find right we have the expression go find the needle in a in a haystack if it's a big thing I'm not worried he may have lost a needle Vasily universe' and where did he lose his needle for more places didn't lose his needle way somewhere in the bedroom he lost his needle by this heap of rubble this heap of rubble where the hummuses might be buried this is where he lost his needle no once you're doing because comments let's kill two birds with one stone but already schlepping down and move looking and searching for comments but I see the universe' as I'm doing ridiculous comments I'm going to be my eye and I go to search for the needle because I want the needle so therefore I'm doing because comets not only for the humus but also because market one second I'm searching for the needle so therefore dive actually says this is not called slush a mitzvah you're right if it was only because comets the price that would have not told us be afraid of scorpions and don't do boudicca's comets but I'm afraid in some situations there may be a needle he's also searching for or something similar that's small and hard to find and therefore it's not slim it's many more and therefore the cause I'll say nobody should do it even if you don't have a needle just stay away from this because we're afraid of that one drew who may have an eel flag tomorrow you're making a face so this takes away the whole thing and giving a guy a dollar when he goes to good question good question saying people go on a trip they're going on vacation and you give them a dollar or ten dollars as Ashley Smithson at the gifts talker he's not Ashley H mitzvah he's going on vacation in the process he's gonna put ten dollars at the bush gun right it's country think you play this game are that's the how do I know it's a good question because then one's gonna ask it am I gonna not gonna talk about the vacation and Miami at that point I didn't yet go to Miami's before they discovered before they discovered Miami maybe Athens maybe Greece and say that's his question what's with that unless you go in specially for Dhaka but you're not you lying in a business trip you're going whatever you're going for which is nice but it's marked it's not a mitzvah fregley Gomorrah very good question let's see Rashi shemitah' with lomasa kind of looking we're not talking about you lose Anita let you lose out you lost the needle earlier already before Vickers comments but in other words if you lose in the middle of the bedico at the end of the video you're doing because coming from Nicholson but he lost it earlier for RC Ashton Luna Buster so now you already killed two birds with one stone you gonna look for it the kingdom is Cavanaugh LaMarca and since your intention of Dicker's comets is also for the needle laugh / mitzvah Vanessa we're afraid that he's not Ashley Schmitz when is going to be armed why we're not scaring no he means if it's at the end of the Dicker's comets you had a needle in your pocket and it fell fine but your dick his comments was good in other words that the particular comets is already the hope that this comet is also part of thickest of the blick of the needle I think that's what he means you know what I'm saying you're right if the needle fell in and be the beginning of the concomitant he says let me do it for both it would be the same minyan flag the guimard okay hi Gavin a LOF Mitzvah I don't understand let's say I'm searching for a needle it's not a mitzvah this is your question it's not a mitzvah why is it not a mitzvah he wouldn't need I mean we negate after exactly why would it negate them it's something of summons so you'll say well maybe cuz you have another hedge but another incentive so here's a question I'm giving stocking people do it all the time I'm not giving stalker only because I want to feed the poor person I'm giving stalker because of other reasons as we're going to see does that take away from the stock flag big amount of a tiny we went to Bryce how I'm it if somebody says sell Azul it's duck giving away this Sullivan succubus sure sure yes here Bernie I want my child to live oh I share you Ben Olam haba I want to be a been a Lamar I want to merit the life of a Lamar but that's why I'm giving this elephant's knocking Rashi the last Rashi on the page okay I governor the miss Calvin la Mitzvah uhlet's Oracle when your objective is the Mitzvah your own needs my needle laughs we a mitzvah bit Mia the bracelet tells me if I'm giving us elephants Tucker because I want a llama bow or for my child sauce I raised it sadly Gummer this is this person is called a saga camera complete Tzadik which is a very strange expression and he said Santa come this is like the ultimate sound the complete wholesome sonic rashi now she was perturbed by this expression that is it sounded gum you become a sad the gum by giving oneself I did it started going bad of herself in this act is called it sounded Gummer meaning you don't say that this act was a schwa calm Isis it's not really righteous coz he had other agendas and this may say he's at sad the government of rosaries at something , but low Yemeni you don't say shallow leash Marisa interesting you don't say this is called a mitzvah not leash ma he's not doing it for the ministry couldn't care less about the Mitzvah y ella kia mitzvahs burnish it's evolved asses talkin beautiful rash this jew is observing the midst of his creator who told him to give stocking or miss Calvin I fly mouse up smile he's also having qivana for personal benefit she is cabal Olam haba through the duck he wants to marry de l'homme haba the next world oh she if you burn off or his children should live as children should be healthy the Mitzvah that he did Rashi says it's called leash ma as he said in the previous Rashi we don't say that it's lund its lastly as mitzvah we don't say he's not called Ashley as mitzvah because he has other intentions we don't say it's called sir Loyola schmuck we don't say that even though he's saying it I'm not doing it because God told me to give succor to feed his purse I'm doing it for my own benefit still not called still not culturally lachemann in other words Rashi is saying the fact that you have a mic Shover of personal benefit doesn't take away the fact that is also an element lachemann why cuz Rashi says if he's a Jew he's being Makai in the Mitzvah of his creator chance of all Isis this additional myself but it's an additional layer it doesn't take away the truth that deep inside he wants to do God's will and that doesn't take away LMI for character I want also I want to gain from it in other words my my nefesh a Bahamas is also happy new is vas if you want to use that terminology my animal soul is also happy my divine soul is happy because it's doing a mitzvah my animals are publish book it's always loose nor no good question good question good question he's learning because it's quiche mock coz he likes it's quiche Mac tomorrow's markets good intellect there that's gonna smell it's a good harder good on arrays it's sad the Comets interesting words sadly Gummer in other words don't say the dismissal is absurd and half-baked no it's a complete missile some it's foolish now she says it's a myths foolish MA low yammering and shall only smoke we don't say it's shillelagh strong even though he's saying this is my thought I'm doing it cuz I once I push a want reward huh no he's doing it for some it's doing it for scar in other words there's an additional layer you want to do what a Shem wants additionally yeah you saying you know what I also would like my children to were to be blessed okay good question one minute one minute so so in other words he wants to wash em once plus he wants another thing also and not only that it seems from rashing even this mush of itself is a good match over in many ways you could taste even a positive thing that this Jew believes the power of a mitzvah he believes the power of a mitzvah it's not like this much Chavez now but it's an additional layer the mush of itself however you want to find it it's a divine act ruts in Hashem so yeah however you want to talk but he sees the value the infinite powerful value of a mitzvah that's what I meant though I need Sedaka's benefit so let's take a look in toys first you ask you a good question the Mitzvah that's true you saw me when it says Mitzvahed mean soccer and you saw me when it says mitts with me stockin take a look into Isis for habit UNAM we have a mission in pre-clovis peyrac I love mr. Gillmore al to you cover the resumption asar have some national kebab brass don't be like servants and serve the master in order to get a price process a prize the word prize in English comes from the Greek word press which in Hebrew also means Prusa like a piece you know you got a piece of the part fructose first you see it says in the Mishnah that it's not a good thing how do you cover them how can the bride's The Saturdays it's odd the gum or is there an argument no no no usually we don't try to make arguments so the Mishnah pre-k office is trying to discourage this attitude and the bracelet says sad the cover which means it's not just okay but it's perfect it's like go ahead do it with the qivana that you want your children to be healthy how is it sad the comer actually says perfect but the mission and prickly others said no no it's not we're not gonna say don't do it but it's not perfect it's not I'll do you covered that's the SH I love toasters so ty service says don't compare two separate things I Manaslu cobbler price means that this is like a condition this is the only reason I want it and if class official and the person learns that he's not gonna get scar he's like this is the stupidest thing I ever did in my life that's what the mr. Spock mom I know because I Gavin in a case Streamlight overly sat I wish so much Zappa if the good that he's waiting for does not come tell you Oh miss Harriet a lot stalkerish awesome then he says that Stucker was futile he regrets it in other words there was only one one agenda and that is my benefit that's what the mission is discouraging it shouldn't be our Manasa the condition is like I tell you I'm doing this for you wani reason because there's a condition it's a condition without that condition without that I take it all back I managers in other words there's nothing else besides my benefit Ivo me Shane otário mr. khayrat but somebody who wants it but the kalila it's not gonna happen and he's not going to regret the whole thing in other words he cares for it that's the point at least subconsciously or in a deep place he cares for the Mitzvah then I raise it sadly can go more but hey Marsh Ramirez my secretary Shoshana Duff that would prepare your comment of a bastard affiant so it's not that he's doing it almond nuts in other words it's all almond ass that's the only condition and it's not and if not I'm not interested in doing it's the other way around I want to do the Mitzvah Hashem because I know how valuable the midst of Hashem is I believe how beneficial it is for carrot it represents the faith of the person and the cleric of Tara mitzvahs the class of optimize making my channel acacia I can use that same logic so pickers comets is the same thing I'm doing I'm doing biggest comets because I want to do because comets I also want to happen to find a needle no today's it's a de comer why are we dealing in amaizing this hope Nicolas comments in saying he's not Ashley as much if you would tell me that when you have a much other for personal benefit it's not cold leash MA so then maybe never lesser such loose a mitzvah a nun is okay and only if they do it lachemann because then it's like a godly act so then do you have a special protection but if it's shillelagh Sh'ma meaning i'm doing it but for my benefit then we say you don't say a nun aside but once we established here that it's coldly small i raise its add the gum or that's right actually says it's called with smurf you would say it's called a mitzvah churlish ma then I can explain in that case it's not completely divine so to speak so therefore you don't say enemas recomment so once we establish its lush MA so that wall hi can't you put your hand into the crack despite the scorpions because look Emmet Satan is like that's the Shiloh of the Gemara was also saying that that it was it has the same wish mons but because he attached a condition to it right yeah have to look it up but I think so yeah Ashish I mean we can see every single jewel as the Edson yeah yeah yeah it's although they give to this organization you'll get given their it's not that you only giving for that Reese now again even even if you're doing the Mitzvah mama shillelagh schmutz they'll call the Mitzvah like we say alum yosik other material Mitzvah Shalom is not even really shallow leche mama mama shallow the smart person is learning Turner because he wants to be atomic Hawk them a person is learning Turner because he wants honor a person who the emergency career Abby wants to be called a Rebbe a person is learning tater you say the intellectual intellectual high etc we say motoki Lola Sh'ma polish mom it's still a mitzvah here we're talking about a type of Mitzvah that will protect you from natural damages this needs a mitzvah that so two speakers a little beyond TEVAR it's a little beyond TEVAR so you need a missile ishm are in a mitzvah lachemann to be the Karaka bellicose in the mitzvah that's the hinge that intimates this is a mitzvah Sh'ma he's doing it for a sham even though he has a goose mac because of personal benefits also so famous marshall from the baal shem tov why we eat on Shabbos why is there a mitzvah Shabbos is a spiritual day a holy day who came up with this idea that on holy days you have to eat more than other days what's the choices so he told a famous story that there was a prince who was who was sent to a far far remote village to you know to get experience of real life in the country so he should be able to be worthy of being a king and after many years he got so absorbed in the culture there that he lost his touch and he became a real peasant and the king was very aggravated because he went there for a purpose but he lost touch so the king sent him a letter and a letter he wrote you know how much he misses him and he should know who he is and you're not a peasant you're a prince a very very warm heartfelt and heartwarming letter and the child received it and it triggered all his memories and the warm relationships he started to dance the peasant said why he dancing he said I got a letter for my father's who's your father the king and he starts to strengthen what are you talking about what your fantasise go to sleep and he realized the problem she said you know what I'm going to take you out for a drink and it's all on me they said oh that's good and they all go drinking and he pays for the drinks and they're dancing and he's dancing he's dancing because of his father's letter and they're dancing because they got free drinks so you said shabbos young to the neshamah the neshamah the mayor mayor I shouted with him got soul gets a letter and it's overwhelmed from ecstasy and it starts dancing so the body and the HR what are you what are you doing don't worry we're having an unbelievable meal tonight gefilte fish masala are great so everybody's celebrating the nefesh Obamas are celebrating the kugel and then a shaman is celebrating its connection for stays so doesn't take away doesn't take away so yeah even even my all the parts of me are celebrating it for different refer for different purposes and it still called them it's foolish ma you just have to remember what's their care and what's not they can that's the distinction that Isis makes if it's a real tonigh that without it you undo it you know if Shabbos is not about cocoa there's no Shabbos or it's you know extra credit so to speak this is the question of the government's gonna tell you a fart there's a safer called a free truer soak a cynic word from him Herschel Eliska he asks ok everybody what's high raise at Santa Gummer so Rashi says doesn't mean he's Assad that gamma means this thing is the season I think when the Vilna gone it's brought that the original Gamora said sadiq gimel so the person interpreted a today's that sounded gum really it had to be a Taser Dhaka Tamura I raised its talking camera that's a type of word from the film and gone it's complete stalker not a tease it's not the Gummer where he became outside the gum were cuz he decided to give a cell effort from from her scar her a zits dhaka the word sound that comes from Woodstock that's true that's true said that justice santa casa but in the CUDA is i raised its docket gomorrah rash doesn't learn like that most of all far is known because he says i raised its at the gamba da versa but I saw a beautiful heart from from the Osprey druwa mama Jean ice vart he says I raised it sounded Gummer why when a person gifts Tucker usually the person who receives this bucket it's not so comfortable it's always more comfortable to be on the giving end than on the receiving end basically you don't have and I'm giving you the money and you you feel like a little bit of a snorer and I'm the one who's giving there's a certain sense of uncomfort which is why the Gemara Bubber bastard speaks about how to fight somebody who gives stalker with a with pleasantness you know there's people who give a lot of money but there's a certain arrogance is like let's remember who's the giver and who's the taker and it's obnoxious sometimes because not just the money it's also the attitude to smile that there are shared to respect yourself or the person it's not always easy for person who has money to show that respect you know to every guy who comes for so the professional Disqus says like this he gives the person money and the person feels uncomfortable I'm a nasty Ischia Bernie I'll - I'm doing this for myself you're doing me a favor that's the point the point is he does it in a way that the receiver feels that he's doing the giver a favor you're helping my children you're helping me in my life really you're giving and I'm taking you're giving me the opportunity to be able to accomplish so I race at Santa Gummer that's at sod the Gummer that when he gives it stalker the feeling that he gives to the other person is I'm doing this mamas for myself and young you're helping me do what I want to do and that's real stock that stacker real stock a real stock is to make the person feel the MS that as much as you're giving you're also receiving as cause I'll say more more than the only receives from the Bala bias the Bala bias receives from the money the source of the docker so that's a very deep feeling then essentially you know there's a cycle that God created happens to be them in this situation I given you take in other situations you give and I think and even in this situation itself I'm giving but really I'm taking you're giving me the opportunity to give stockin I raise it sounded Gummer that's a that's a tank I'll call partner we're back to the question why is this situation excluded of solution Mitzvah even as I can because of his needle how could the needle ruin the Mitzvah of Dicker's comets and for the Gemara and for the guimard I'll tell you the problem Vilma you're right you're right if he searches for the needle with biggest comments arrays inside the car but no problem Ashley H Mitzvah but Dilma busts are the bada costumer you in the bathroom what I'm afraid is something else not the thickest comet the thickest comets is good after he finishes the customers so the Mitzvah is over in other words you finish the kiss comments you say there's no more comets here and you're done with Nicolas comets it's time to go to sleep it's midnight Arif basic we're going to bed but now you lost the needle and maybe you lost your needle the middle of the COS comments maybe you lost you needle in the beginning of the COS comments maybe you lost you needle at the end of whiticus commas so you say let me go continue a search just for the needle this is not for comets anymore this is for the needle this is the second are we worried about not for the biggest comments for the biggest market after Dicker's comments was over that's what a she says busts are the bud a quick dombarris column it's ver or similar universe row and therefore we don't say on the same it's rainin Nisa so if you would search that place first before the house on you if you're doing it with comment I don't mind you're doing a mitzvah Hashem and you're saying I also want to I want to benefit that maybe you might even say let the midst of this come it's helped me fine help me find but now is the question if I don't find my needle I'm gonna say oh I should have never dumped it cos comments this is a stupid thing no I also want to find my needle and it's it's how the Karma but here the problem is you may do it after so therefore it's a fascinating I welcome because of this that you may lose a needle and you may look for it after the COS comments they said that nobody should do Patinkin summits nobody should do dhikr scum it's in a pile of rubble why even if you never lost a needle you don't even own a needle why cuz there may be a Jew loses a needle and this Jew is not looking for it with thickest commas that whatever he look for it after particular comments and that's why it's gonna be a danger because the the Scorpion may buy them and that's why nobody stupid thickest comments because of this Jew who may have lost the needle it can also be a danger if he searching the needle is also looking for and you're right okay that's something else but when I think we're not even we're not even we're not even considering that I want to conclude with the voice from the cops Kariba God scarab has a beautiful worth on this Gemara it's not the literal meaning of the kepada but it's a beautiful part it's printed in a saver called base coats click utam so he says like this he says like this I understand if the kymaro would have say what's the lushness of the Gemara here yeah shamit overtly maha through a she says maybe he lost a needle now she should have said shemitah' oddly alloy him maybe he lost a diamond then i understand the person was too talking yeah he's gonna go crazy and i hope his comment is think about his time and then after pickles come as he looks for his diamond not my heart my heart worth like you'll tell me the Gemara will say you may have lost a penny you may have lost a nickel she lost and like I understand a person lost a check of you know $25,000 in the rubble you're gonna go crazy yeah Lloyd my diamond not a mashups I'm Mudman I'm not laying in a needle from all situation give me something a little more a little more expensive a little more precious interesting question ah you say even a needle yeah obviously means even a needle we don't mean only a needle even a needle I understand if you lost your credit card in your license and your passport for sure but that century said this is the example he gives this is especially thickest comets is once a year you do it once a year and people there's a certain energy you know peso is coming it's not up something that happens constantly was even a shy the why we don't make her Saffiano I'm thick as comets okay we rely on the Shakya know of pacer but it's it's it's a mitzvah that comes once a year so the Gemara really thinks that the middle of the Dicker's comment that comes once a year he's thinking about his about about about the needle and then he asks another question the expression of the Gemara sloosh a mitzvah a Nana's Ike slew Seamus which means literally somebody who's Ashley R to do a mitzvah really the point is somebody who is involved in doing a mitzvah right like here because comments I'm not sending ash Leah the word shlush a mitzvah in many ways he says is strange why because what's ash Leah Leah says I send you to be my LIF to go somewhere and say be Mikado janeshia or be my first rumor whatever the SH list is I send you on a solution is to go somewhere where I am not there and therefore you could do it he says the concept of shlush this when it comes to a mitzvah is difficult to understand why Malloy call or it's quite that Hashem is everywhere lesser sorry poem in a there's no place devoid of him so that like he sends you on Ash lysias the place where he's not there and whatever you accomplishes with his help you can't move your finger without him so the concept of slea Committee says it's a strange Russian you are shreya cover mitzvahs I catch them sends you to go somewhere where he himself is not so you can do the schlissel so this expression the freshness of some modern expression so the cut score ever explained that homolytically and he said the Gemara means something else there's a famous my macaws are the measure says 3-burner shel Olam says peace who leaked judicial markings when the effortless ham capisco Cholula which means gems has opened up for me an opening the hole the size of judicial market who they shall market is the eye of the needle which is a tiny tiny tiny makes a little hole open up for me a crevice and opening who there's so much that's all I'm asking Vonnie FM capisco Cholula and i will open for you an opening as large as the doors of the Ullom which was a perception of the base I mean it actually had no doors so it was just open completely so it was a huge opening so you open up a little tiny door from me let me have them professional from the Baroque major Bush says matoi voya left a jakob michigan a sofia strong bilham said the tents of Yaakov are beautiful so rashly says why she ain't ascared Maha 1 and negative Z Nagisa their doors were not parallel to each other I didn't see what's happening in your tent when I looked out of my tent right even I put in my door the doors weren't parallel so people weren't looking and there was privacy modesty sneeze a barnacle measure Bush said the never Nevada Holly says ain't piss Kayne the doors of the Jew and God don't parallel each other we only have to open up hood there shall market the eye of a needle and he opens up capisco a shallow loom it doesn't have to match each other what I open up is not what he opens if I open up a little little hole and he opens up kappa screw shallow so he says so what's a person's job in the world the person's job in the world is peacefully judicial market to be able to open up an opening in his heart and his soul judicial market to make to make a dent to perforate to perforate is his ego is his insecurities his fears his to be able to pierce it to pierce it a little bit and that's and that's something he does and he does it in this world as Ashley Smith slit dr. Bacchi I'm afraid Shama toy avidly market I'm afraid he's gonna lose the needle lose the needle means that needle that he has to take in order to to create a who darshan market in order to create that little pestle you need a needle yeah and the point of a needle is explained also a needle has two sides one side perforates the other side has a hole through which you you bring through the string because you want to ultimately so yeah in life you have to have both you have to have the ability to be able to penetrate the hole a certain strength ultimately though you want to bring through the string you want to connect you want to create integration so I'm afraid that the person yo even like my heart his needle is going to be lost and therefore what's gonna happen - Lia MIT survey says then you could of Ashley if Mitzvah what's the / Mitzvah what his mission in this world to be pudding shall market he forfeits and he loses that opportunity to be the Schleck Mitzvah that's the form that scheme' Yogurtland Makati lost the physical needle and lost the diamond then it could is the middle of Dicker's comets are the capability of he lost the a he lost that capability that ability that consciousness the hoodie shall market that opens up for him to peace Christian Lula that's the afraid that's the fear so the Gemara says what's the problem he's doing it together with the biggest comets ah make it felony maybe it's after the biggest comments he loses that's how he touches okay continue tomorrow on Bezier she tried to finish the mark of the mission Lena de fish oh the storage of the fish I understood that it was dead cuz he says bait dog him I didn't understand that the fish were alive you mean it was a pond upon your supermarket even is they go get the fish alive it seems to me that he means a storage place huh the middle of the meal he's saying a middle of the meal they went to get living fish so if they were serving big fish then you're not gonna go get more but if you serving little fish then you may go to the pond and bring out small fish I don't know if that's what it means cuz usually I would assume in the same pond you have both no big and small so that's why I understood the Gemara meaning a storage place we have a section for bigger fish a section for small how would they store fish you're asking what's your pond on your property and it has to be indoors because we're talking about Dickus comets you're not going to search a pond right you're going to search a room where you bring in humus stray that has to be indoors where there's no fish I mean usually you didn't have a pond indoors I see it more as a place how they stored the fishing me that it didn't rot but maybe it was a colder cellar maybe they pickle did they salted that they had preservatives even then you didn't have refrigeration no no he's asking when the Gomorrah speaks about a storage place for fish it's no matter pond there was talking about like a closet well hide we're talking about a place we enough to be by dick so let's create a room when it may be humus and it says the Sharma's goes in and may put his bread there so the pond why would he put his bread in the pond and the fish would eat it up we're talking about La Jolla they're just like we do our wine and oil hunts he goes in he left in the Sun we're outdoors if it's outdoors then the birds eat it up we said before you sing a fish tank single indoor fish tank she sang you take some herring in a cop they pickle the herring and they put it they put it in a barrel higher and that room with the herring is of other fishes that's where he went in it that's my pastas that's what Italy I don't think it means duska a pond with me okay for lineage the makishima Tobin LaMarca for linear the maca pits Kalika condition marker Ashley s Mitzvahed the markets now some people will need fish and Payson eats fish on Pesach or not we're talking about if you have to be both the Commons before Pesach in a room where you store the fish why wouldn't you eat fish on fish on my Walker in a word dump all the garbage in invision old state corn we also eat comets maybe we shouldn't exist on this class is brought to you by the achieve Annette please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot they you Shiva net slash donate