Pesachim 15a: Why Reb Meir Holds You Can Contaminate Terumah Chametz Erev Pesach

the yeshiva dotnet you download I'm at base seven lines from the bottom we go back now to the next line at the next section of the Mishnah let's recall the Mishnah quoted the testimony of Rebecca Nina that the kyon name would be meta may they would take beat that was Ashley she and throw it into the fire with meat that was an Ave that was that was a that was a Buster chanute mabye ova - ma basta that became Tom made by Ava - mer and therefore this meter was Ashley she would become a Shanee through the contact why cuz it was about to be burnt her back Eva said they took oil that was parcel and they put it into a nail that was an avid Houma and the oil went up from Silesia tuition because it was being burnt what does the next line of the mission to say right after that a mihrab mayor and Mayor says me divyam love magna from their words we learned she saw refunds rheumatoid a meta may have a pestle that I'm paste a share of pace I hear a lot of bird rumor that's comets what's pure together with Truman that's comic that's impure I'm ready I see a nahin I made there Bayesian says that's not true you cannot learn it from their words wrong I disagree with you whether it may tell us that from Rabkin in it from their words we learn a finish it's Erev Pesach and I have a lot of bread in my house and it's all comets and it's all Truman because I'm a Korean and I didn't finish it before Pesach the problem is one foul is coming and another Salah is tired I won't be able to eat the tire one because it's time to burn the comets it's 11 o'clock in the morning I don't have time I don't have anybody to eat the challah what am I supposed to do I have to burn the hummus so do I have to make two separate fires no Ramaiya said put them together in the same fire even though they're touching each other and the true Metoyer is now coming in contact with the truman timaya and it's becoming Tom a it's fine that's what we learned from the previous testimonies and a BOAC said wrong na I made wrong what would be the problem the problem is you now let it be me Tommy trauma right the Torah says you have to guard your trauma mich Maris promise' you have to protect it from what from impurity and here you are actively literally bringing these two pieces together and it's not like you're gonna be over on comments you can make a separate fire and burn the other trimmer there you could make two separate fires yeah you may be lacking wood that may be a problem you may not have the money for it you may have a challenge but maybe at least like a pillow you should tell the person to do that your may says no me the vram love mod no I don't care if you get that Truman Tommy why cuz it's about to be burnt I the trader says you now let it be me Tom a trimmer your now that'll be me Tommy trimmer but it made is telling us that what then here there's an exception yeah perfect so that was talking about not Arif paces that was talking about on a regular day we took something that was puzzle that was parcel and we made it Tommy right we elevated a Toma Sohrab mayor says from this I learn from this I learn a new lesson and that is that you could take drummer that's call her and make it Tommy on Erev Pesach in the process of burning it that's exactly what he's saying he's deriving from this he's so that's gonna be the discussion now sir a mayor says that we learn it from the testimony's eruption in Derby Akiva is that really logical how did your mayor say that why did the BOC disagree what was going on it that's the discussion right now in the Gemara we finished with the first two pieces of container but given we now go to the third to the third step what would be red mayor's reason let's understand why would you allow to be me Tommy Truman you're not allowed to be Mitama Truman the answer is because you're gonna burn it so if you're gonna burn it anyway so you're allowed to be Mitama the trauma but let's analyze that what would be what would be the logic of that perhaps you could say like you said yesterday or two days ago it's about to be burnt if it's about to be burnt it's like you're being the time is something that doesn't exist or even though now it does exist but in 10 minutes it won't exist so it's like you treated already as it was burnt right and there's no chance of spreading to more anything because it's about to be burnt which you're always concerned about so it's almost like treating it as though it doesn't exist anymore so you say the Mitzvah doesn't apply your to garden because there's nothing to guard it's gonna be burnt in a few minutes and you're ready treating it like that now or you could say on a more practical level you could say the reason you're now let it be my time at Roma why would they try to say and I want to be my time at Roma is it just not to bring Thoma into the world is that the reason right or the reason is maybe just very practical and that is the turo wants you to eat it there's a mitzvah to eat it and if you're Mitama yet you're basically ruining the chances to do the Mitzvah of eating yeah in other words you should guard it in order to be able to eat it right right not on pace I'm saying but Slough but Slough the whole year oh yeah according to this yeah according to this if it's comets an era of pacer you're anyway not gonna be able to eat it like you said so the whole point of not being metonymy it is that you should have a mitzvah to eat it you're anyway don't have a mitzvah thene if you have a mitzvah to burn it because it's Pesach cash should be sooo so therefore you'll say who cares if it becomes tum a what's the problem of it's becoming Tommy you won't be able to eat it well you're burning it anyway so who cares if you say the issue is you now let it make it Tom a so you know how to make a domain right so who cares when you just now let a make a tummy but if the Easter is just you're now gonna make your tummy so you should be able to eat it here your anyway not eating it so he cares if you make your tummy that would that would be very logical right now the question is so if the myths if the only reason you're not gonna make it Tommy is because you're not gonna be able to eat it what if it's Tommy already are you a lot of at Toma if it's not being burnt with the planning area keepers say regular tremor just make it more Tommy you might say they won't why because the more Tommy it becomes yeah it could spread the trauma to other things and it will disqualify them from eating it so I can understand though you shouldn't make it more Tommy on a regular day even though you can't it already now because you can't eat this now but if it becomes more tummy right it could make other Truman more tummy and spread it more cause Shane Ashley she etc right if it's a shame E it's lower if it's a reshoring it could spread the tumor more so that would make sense but if you're burning it you're not spreading the tumor and you can't eat it anyway that's why would make sense where I never came and said who kids making tummy though purposes then you should be able to eat it but your anyway not eating it and you're not spreading the tumor that other things you can't eat it's going into the fight so who cares who cares so Eric basics is the same thing even though it's hard but you can't eat it you can't eat it if you can't eat it right just like Tommy you can't eat it so I don't care if you make it more Tommy what's gonna happen you'll make it more Tommy and what's gonna happen it's being burnt it's not like as a result of making it tumblr you gonna lose the myths of eating if it's Tommy already and he can't even spread it because it's being burnt so here too since it's Erev Pesach right so you're not gonna be able to eat it anyway so therefore who cares if you make it Tommy what's the big deal yeah you're gonna be over by your own bar you might say you know I'm gonna have you can't say that the midst of guarding trim ah you can't be everybody rubble you might say it's trimmer everything is awesome bono it's trouble its comet's comets dasa Bono yeah you might even want to say perhaps even if there's a mitzvah at smus there you now let it be Mitama drama outside of the of the issue of a filler but you might say what I said the first fara since it's about to be burnt so Kahlo I'm at Lister of kisara of dummy it's like it's gone so even if there's such a mitzvah one way you could say is the whole reason you're now allowed to make it Tommy is in order that you should be able to eat it in this case you anyway can't eat it's for this base so make it Tommy or even if you want to say that the Mitzvah of not making it Tommy is essential you know let it bring tumor into trauma cause it's a holy thing but perhaps if it's about to be burnt so that Mitzvah doesn't apply because it's not considered a hayfitz that's cost of that significant because it's a out it's about to be gone so this would be the logic of Reb mayor that would make sense why you would think that you could be Mitama drama at this point of the game why it's something that you can't eat anyway it's something that's about to be burned there's different considerations to layers that we could explain why you should allow to eat why should allow to make true Murtagh how your tummy in the fire ed of Pesach if it wasn't Pesach he would never say this because why would you make a tummy it's part of the consumer first of all why are you burning first why are you burning it sale why are you making the tummy both things you know Oh fine yeah it would be similar if you anyway can't eat it if you anyway can't eat it so then maybe you could be Atma Tommy but then I could say but but then maybe the rabbi's would be cautious you know why because if it's not burnt if it's around then the tumor can spread to other trauma like if torrid trauma touches this it could become Tamil but if it's being burned then there's no shot at all so yeah they'll be much more lenient so even if you say that if it becomes unedible make it Tommy because who cares those Ines oh but I could still see a tremendous caution because it could still pass on the Tama so even though I'm not worried about this piece but I'm worried about other pieces but if it's being disposed of then it should be fine exactly exactly exactly says the Gemara me devrait in the man me devrait in the man whose words whose words are the foundation of remains teachings eel a medieval cannon is gonna clean him if you say it's from the canina me dummy how could you compare it awesome Tommy Vee Tommy Hawk Atari Tommy Oh they the two pieces were Tommy already he just bumped up the Tama here the trauma is tired that's what you asked her prove and you can't compare it there it was Tommy he bumps up the Tama a little bit and it's about to be burnt got it here it's also about to be burned but he's doing something much more right he's making it Tommy liPuma it's tired of it Tommy so could you really learn this header from repenting is gonna Cayenne him it's not fear it's not fear I will say you're not ruining the Mitzvah of eating it anyway who cares cause it's Erev Pesach right and you have to burn it so who cares who cares okay fine it's a Sephora it's a smarter but you can't maybe you're right but maybe you're wrong maybe there is a problem in in in in taking trimmer that's taller and mamas making it Tommy you're right you can't eat it you true you're right you're gonna burn it you write this for is to say that I don't care but maybe I do care maybe your now let abeam atomic traumatic IRA even if it's just gonna be around for a few minutes and even if you anyway are not going to be eating this piece maybe so you can't run it from canina replica Nina I know he was Mikami it but let's face it was Tommy already it was Tommy there was a lower level of Tommy but it was Tommy so you can't compare it you can't compare it the point is there's no proof there's no proof you understand you may be this 50% there's a smaller but there's no proof she says ok let's try the other one Elementary about given perhaps you've learnt it from Eric Cuba's words Rebecca said that you take oil that's not Tommy that's pasal its pasal and you bump it up to become a recent by putting it in a name a kid Tommy me dummy again awesome puzzle the Tommy Hawk atharva Tommy over there it was puzzle already it wasn't called Tommy but it was possible it was disqualified you now wanna eat it it was not edible anymore the name was Tommy so you bumped it from puzzle to Tommy but here it was tire and Tommy rib mayor says you take true me that is edible that is tire that potentially you could eat it if it was another time even though now it's era of Pacer you're gonna have to get rid of it he's saying llamada no he's saying I Walker how could you can't learn this wannabe Akiva you can't learn this wannabe at Kiva maybe I'm now let it do it you're saying but who cares are you burning it and you can't eat it and this but it was not possum it was true Matt I mean it was completely terminator maybe there's an e surf to take trauma to her and be it not me that's it she said but why why and you're burning it fine I got it you can't through from the other cases where it was a ready tummy LMI you made it more tummy you understand there was a heft to the test it was coming it was not Mishra it was not guarded anymore you you you you wanted to protect we didn't protected its tummy tough luck possum but here it's not here it's really a good piece of trauma true your now how to eat it that's true it's gonna be Pesach you're gonna have to burn it but to take the trim itself and be it my Tommy maybe you're not loud like uni it's a big finish make another fire and burn it burn it don't be it Mikami if it wasn't peso for sure you we're not gonna say you're allowed alright cuz it's anyway what it's anyway nothing that's good threw me because it's Pesach and it's gonna be us or to eat in a few minutes so you have to burn it okay so burn it but don't who says you're allowed to make it on me so you say but who he is if it becomes Tommy it's not Anibal and it's being burnt okay I understand but it's a big image to take tar and say I'm making it Tommy I'm making your tummy when I was not Tommy before the object was now Tommy even though you have an issue to eat it yeah yeah maybe you're breaking that Mitzvah maybe you're breaking that Mitzvah yeah maybe breaking that much yeah yeah they had the idea of selling to a non Jew but it was not commercial meaning you could do it privately if you had a neighbor a friend you wanted to sell it's fine the way we do it today wasn't necessary then the way selling comments started as people owned Inns and motels with a tremendous amount of liquor so at a big problem but then you had a couple of pieces of bread you were lucky you know what I mean you didn't have frozen pizza in the basement for a Chevy Barajas you know so so so it was a whole different matter so that's that that's what we're left with now here's an interesting Aria you can add and that is when do we burn comets toasters make at this point Bennett area after burn comets the beginning of the seventh hour let's call that 12 o'clock the rabbi's did it an hour earlier right you have to burn it already 11 o'clock and you have to stop eating it an hour before 10 o'clock so you're burning it in the beginning of the sixth hour now I'm at the beginning of the seventh hour now I mean eternity you can eat hummus til 12 you can eat 11:59 oh so the rabbi said you now let me eat much earlier so when you're burning this trimethyl higher actually men hotter it's edible so that really makes the problem much more serious and that's why you can't learn it's written in Arabic every but he was talking about oil that may not tell you your nominee eats but this is common that biblically is edible so it's much worse it's not just it's tar and who let you be it make it Tommy it's not like a bear keema it's worse at least if it was 12 o'clock it's forbidden to eat it's not edible so then you kataka say you're not doing anything you're not ruining it's because you can't eat it anyway you have to burn it but 11 o'clock you're actually allowed to eat it minute later so from the traders perspective you're taking good to Roma just like after pace us you now let her do it 11 a confusion are you taking good Roma and you're destroying it and making the tummy for no reason you want to burn it burn it but burn it in a regular fire you can't make it tummy she's a murder bi Kiba said you're allowed Oh Ricky was talking about something that's possum in our area I mean I tell you it's not edible here I mean I trade it is edible because it's only 11 o'clock so you could say this smarter but it's about to be burnt right but if you say the reason that you're now allowed oh that you're a lot of make could come me is because you're not ruining the Mitzvah of eating it because you now let me tit anyway in this case been a 30 or a lotta eat it so that's why it's very different here be Akiva that's the problem so the gomorrah says naima we have to say perhaps cassava at mayor mayor holds mass Nissenbaum Fatuma dairy riser or Vlada to madeira Bonhomme de madera cetera Mallya Ramaiya probably had to learn if Canada was talking about a unique case one piece of meat was Tommy from an alpha 2 ma there's an hour to murder guys let's say a dead mouse fell on it so the food the buses are we sure the other piece of meat that became Tommy became Tommy through a Vlad how to Madeira Bona which means it touched a Shanee that was only rabbinic so it's Ashley she only Madeira banana not minatoya an example would be you had liquid that was Tom a right this we shine the liquid went into a Kayleigh the Kaylee's are shaming only rabbinical ëcoz biblically a Cayley can't be ashamed and you put a carbon into that Cayley this carbon mean I thought it is perfectly pure only Madeira born on its tummy that's what he says Vlad how to Madeira Burnham it got Tommy from a Vlad automa from a Shamy of the rabona in other words uh the Bossa became much Li Shimin a Bonham yeah yeah so became coming from a Shayna dear abundant and it became Ashley she summoned area I Satara mahalia may not later it's completely tired so what did the cunningness say you're a lot of burn it let's think about this I mean how Taylor it's pure it's pure right and yet you're allowed to burn it why you can't eat it why can't you eat it only with your opponent you can't eat it minute either you can either buster but nonetheless since it has a tumor there abundant that's Ashley she you could burn it with her Lucian minute Aria Irish under erisa busted at touched enough are you being my Sethe on the tumor what are you being myself on the tumor it was Ashley Shay making it a shame he because they're coming hunting with addition nonetheless rep canina allowed this to happen that's perhaps how it mayor understood the give mark the Mishnah oh my me defray and what does he mean with Avraham made every rep Shannon is gonna corner from the words of Rebecca Nina that what that you're allowed to burn meat that's Tommy Madeira bond on with bosses that's Tommy minute order I have now an example for what we need I have trauma the true my story not only is it rheumatoid the Truman may not tired it doesn't have to be burnt yet and it could be eaten just like the boss sir that was Ashley she only Madeira Bonin nonetheless even though Ashley she only made their opponent you're allowed to bump it up and make it more Tommy yeah you're gonna make it a shame II by touching or not Ida and out of mind why why the answer is because it's unedible Madeira Bonin right and it's about to be burnt say here to I would say the same thing oh so are you bumping it up me did I born on are you bumping it up minute Ida right so that depends on what we learned before if I shall me Tommy I shall or ain't I shall meet a miracle right if you say that ain't a comet a miracle by hole in and even buy from which were many shittest there is a there that I shall meet a miracle by Truman Katya right but mostly this is a notional Metamucil by : and even by Truman it perhaps by cutting the even kocham not we learned three as before but this is true MA so if ain't no tomotommy uh-huh so then when the true mer to hurry touches determine timaya it's only a durable indica Toma right it's only there abundantly Couture and if janina's ghana korean and we learned could be talking about also anal meet a miracle sonia durable indica toma so that would make more sense that the rabbis who made the to madeira bonham allowed the tumor to be bumped up to another term of the Urbana and the Comets which is not edible but there are Bonin they allowed you to be matinee with Truman Mayer Madeira bono that's how a she learns it that would be that mayor's Mahalo that would be the maize mala Rebbe IEC would disagree because if you say a nice calm itami icicle so then Oracle touches article it's not me Tommy it right Rab Yossi would disagree WC would say that Ashley she and trimmer is tak apostle it's not Tommy but it's not just an e sir it's absolute a tumor so you can't compare it in other words comets it may not be edible Madeira Bonham but it's still pure so maybe WIC says you can't compare it so there's two ways of looking at it Reb mayor says that we could learn from all this that it becomes mutter to bump it up a level Truman the same thing on Erev Pesach Rubio he says perhaps not so this is one way of learning how we understand the mayor's to the mayor's perspective okay then the Gemara goes into a whole other different explanation jewish lakeisha's explanation how to understand a mayor in a completely different way because this is difficult to interpret it somewhat this is difficult that it was all talking about it there a bond on that's how you have to say it so the Gemara is gonna give them a federal rich Lockridge which is gonna be a different perspective okay so that mayor remain ought us in the Mishnah his words were material ahmad no and aphid a little mouth from their words we learned they allowed aberrant rumor to hurry with trim it's may on Arif pacer when you're burning the comets even though you're throwing it into the same fire pit or the same bonfire or the same fire and the tummy is gonna become cuz gonna come in contact with the Titans going to purify it you're allowed oh right he said material Ahmad no we learned it from their words so the Gemara want to know which words can we learn it from a pnina maybe because if Kadena says that you're allowed to bump up meat that was Ashley she to meat that was arisia and burn it together so maybe here too since over there with trauma what's the have on at rumor that was Ashley she you're allowed to bump it up to our wishin and you may explain why because you anyway can't eat it anymore you anyway can't do the Mitzvah anymore it's Ashley she so I don't care if you're mice if Tomer right I don't care if you might if DOMA so maybe that's where the mayor learnt it from but the Gemara challenged that because over there it was Tommy already so you can't compare it to our case no I'm saying maybe the shot was that Joss like you're allowed to bump up meat that was Ashley she to meat that was addition why because let's put it this way because yeah you're burning it anyway but let's add something you're burning it anyway that's true and because you can't do the mitzvot anyway with it why can't you do the mitzvot because it's time a what are you gonna do with meat that stop me you have to burn it and then you might say the reason you now let it be at Mitama is because there's a mitzvah to do with it anyway can do the Mitzvah so I don't care if it gets stung you're adding also something else it's about to be burnt that's another high sulfur there's two details here number one I can do the Mitzvah anymore even if I don't burn it and I'm burning it which is why I have to burn it cuz I can do the myths so therefore you might say who cares if you bump it up caninus us so the mayor says the same thing you can't do the mitzvot here what are you gonna do here it's comments what are you supposed to do with the Comets you can't eat it it's air of pace if you have to burn it right the mitzvot can't you can't eat this room at some point you're gonna have to bring him if you can eat it great but if you can't eat it you can't eat it it's time to burn so therefore you say you're allowed to be at Mitama that's the Vaart because he can't do the mitzvot anyway Marcel doesn't make sense you can't learn it from honey because I'm cannon was talking about Sun L was tell me already this was tired you can't scratch it so far it's a good swara but you can't learn it from canina okay Nina says if it's taught me already I don't care if you bump up the Toma I'm not gonna get meticulous about that but to make it tombe from new maybe you're now louder maybe an hour louder so the Gemara said okay let's compare to your back Eva forever Kimmy maybe we could learn it repair Cuba so do you take trimmer that's Ashley she which is not coming it's puzzle it's possible it's not Tommy he won't transfer the tumbler it's possible which means you can't eat it so that would be very similar to comets I replace right it's not Tommy but you can't eat it you can't eat it and here he says you can bump it up to a higher level of Toma see here tow you take the trimmer which you can't eat because it's air of pacer and you make your tummy the noises you still can't compare it because we're about given it's puzzle it's it's Ashley she it's puzzle it's not called Tommy but it's called puzzle here it's not puzzle it's regular true matira huh yeah huh yeah even even if you're gonna say that at the beginning of the sixth hour right so you can't eat it it's the beginning this is though you can't eat it me there are bonham but Minotaur you could eat it the trauma that's Ashley she mean a trainer you can't eat so you can't Kabir Ruby I keep it to this case right mail if it was the beginning of the seventh hour maybe you can argue that mean Authority also can't eat it but this is not the beginning of the seventh I was beginning of the sixth hour so me there a bond on you canteen admit that seder you could eat it so you can't learn from the be Aquila that you're allowed to be Mitama is such strong I'm sorry maybe you're right but maybe you're not right you're right I can't eat him at the rabona I'm gonna burn it but I am I allowed to be at me Tommy from rebbi akiva I can't learn it from B Akiva it's too of a far stretch forever kibbutz pusle this is not puzzle this is edible Truman I have a problem it's the pair of paces and Rabbinical II I have to I have to burn it I can't eat it anymore but biblically I can eat it for another hour so who says you're allowed to be in the tummy you say but you can't do anything with it biblically I could do allow with it I can eat it so you say yeah but Rabbinical you stock okay so burn it but don't be at Mitama he can't learn it for every Akiva that's the point in other words the Borden or the burden of proof is on a mayor you want to be master something you have to bring proof and if I can find a problem in that right this is an important principle to understanding tomorrow when you're proving something from somebody to say a kiddush your proof has to be airtight it can be 99% right ask me 100 percent because if I could puncture that proof then the burden is on you not on me you're telling me I'm allowed to be become a true mother of pacer the burden of proof is on your mayor not on me are you proving it to rebbi akiva I'm telling you maybe you're right but maybe you're wrong you can't make that finish you can't sit about Kiva agrees with you maybe River Kiva would say if it was puzzle and unedible biblically right the Mitzvah can't be done now you could bump up the Toma here you're taking tar its target I can now wanna eat it you now let it eat it but first of all you now let it eat it only rabbinic li biblically you're allowed to so it's not like the trauma right and also it's even if even on another level you can even say here it's not like the room itself as possible it's just your now let's eat it it's a different idea on avid Kanani who belongs to a cohen is allowed to eat it but he's not a teen comet either I never eat kanani's McCoy even all the mitzvos of a woman he does he does yeah yeah just like women an avid Kanani is a lot of each Rama if he belongs to a coin that's a kiddush right then Everdeen is allowed to eat rumor in other words even though he's a semi drew a red ooh moisture robbed a new eats from yeah it's McCoy of Mr benét um I am an avid Konami who yesterday was a Gentile and he's not even a full drew is a lot of a trauma because he's the evident because he's the extension of a kyon can occur in feature matters animals every every can't eat Romo cuz an avid is not the property of the kyon unless he's a Korean if it never did me the Cayenne Iike me through my cousin to hate but the finishes are ever the canine eASIC Manny's a Gentile he comes in you own him and basically what happens is you has to go through circumcision and he's only McCoy human mitzvos Shana's man Grammys macomb interests of women so it's like a semi Jewish status right he can marry a shift klutz are much more lean in Jewish status when he gets emancipated he becomes a full Jew he's allowed to eat rumor because he belongs to the client Kenyan caspo he's like an extension of God can you feature material Bahama s' it's an interesting question so practically carshena trauma which as you ask that Kushina trauma are parts of truman that are not edible to people you can feed to your behaviors there are many employs convey your a lot of feeds from it to your animals but practically it's not done because there's a man which I think in ton of the belly oh that speaks out against it how logically there are many parts can will hold you can feed it to your animals which is a evolved occasion ish then how logically you could take trauma which is holy holy because it's a Kyon's animal so it's part of the coin just like the Evatt but luckily they don't they did not do it because i think there's a famous manage that speaks out not to not to give trauma to an animal unless it's a part of truman that you can't eat it's called carshena trauma like seeds that animals eat that you can give you can give to the animals of a cardigan to give to the animal the animal of a coil so so the evidence can eat Roma right that's the broker that we learned to market our eloheynu melech ha'olam so the bottom line is remain has a burden of proof that you're allowed to be me Tommy trauma and it can't be to be small in a can't be I'm can be Ripken in it can be Reebok Eva so the Gomorrah finally says you have to say remain on the stood up canina that it got Tommy with onto Madeira Bonin meaning - Lea she was not a dairy rice initially she was in Urbana the me touched a Kaylie there was a Shayna cuz the Kaylie touched Maskin and that meat became Ashley she so it's only Tommy made their abundance I mean I thought it's actually taller so when you're bumping it up you're bumping it up from something that's mean there are born on to something that was Tom a minute IRA another term of their eyes or their up on them but even minute IRA that's what's happening that's what he has to say which is theirs to say it in the Mishnah that it was of la da da Madeira Bonham but if it was a darrell bond on then things could make much more sense why because then it's like the comments the comments the beginning of the sixth hour you now let it eat Madeira Bona just like the meat of the carbanion alle to eat Madeira Bona I mean I Terry there was also edible and yet you're making it tummy you're making it Tommy but me now trader was edible sort some Amish like the Comets on the sixth hour I'm still a lottery to Truman and yet I'm making it Tommy just like the carbon midnight there I'm not tired I'm allowed to eat it so it's not Tommy I mean there a botanist on me and yet he allows me to bump up the Toma Madeira born on to a much higher level right the same the same thing here I mean there are born on I'm now letting eat it minute I'm allowed to eat it so even though it's not Tommy that Truman is not telling me the trauma I saw her write the Truman is not Tommy but in the sense that I'm not letting it it's the same thing I can't eat it anymore there's nothing I can do with it so since there's nothing I can do with it so he says just like the person in it says that since this boss you can't eat it Madeira bond on and the if I don't care if you met Tommy it even though you're bumping up the tumor here too I can't eat it Madeira bond on and they if I don't care if your meta meds Raschi even adds that if you say a nice calm a Tommy also made ERISA so actually becomes Tommy only Madeira Bonham right if you say ain't no soma Tommy I shall be cotton which the Gemara brought different as if Elizabeth a miracle so then if cannon is only talking about there are born on becomes Tommy only Madeira mana and the trauma also becomes Tommy on the Madeira burner so you now let it eat it me there and you Mikami admit their opponent because when the ISIL touches ISIL it only gets coming with your opponent the question is how that works with true myths ain't no limit a miracle so there was a sorry sure sure material container right yeah so according to this what does Ramaiya mean me divyam he means from the commoners gonna call him right me devrait infrared cannon is gonna clean mind me divyam the remain vivid up come in let's see Rashi the troop the type of test of off the true matauri rubbish a show us Daniel our who dish lishi the true matura in six hours the beginning of six hours is like the meat of the sleaze she did tie-dye rice limit on Madeira burner it was only Tommy matera Bonham vahana me Shia made a rice I feel a similar sentiment in a moment just like the Comets for another hour it's mutter because you laddie tit so the trimmer Tahiry 11 o'clock in the morning IRA of basic is just like the meat of the swishy the meat of the Schliemann our player you can eat the true Metoyer 11 o'clock you can eat they're both you can eat and whether the feminists say you're allowed to do with that boss our bump it up throw it in the fire why because my dear abondon you can't eat it I know mine attorney can with their a ball rabbi say you can't eat it so once I can't eat it so there's nothing I can do I can't do them it's wet anyway I don't kiss you mad Tommy are you mean to Tommy it I know but there's nothing to guard because I can't eat it same with the comments you say how you being a myth Tommy is what I'm canteen and it's 11 o'clock when I tried it I bother my canteen it will be meme atomic trimmer I'm being Mitama trimmer that I can't eat I can do the Mitzvah sorry when I tell you you couldn't I know but I have to follow the robot right right right in order to burn it it has to be coming because I'm now let it be my I made something because the terrorists us I could do a myth so assets the trader says you have to guard trimmer you have to protect your money yeah mich marries true Musa so that means as the cause I'll explain you have to guard it from tumour so this explanation is why why there's a reason for it the reason is not to lose the myths for the datura gave a mitzvah to eat it there's a mitzvah to each Roma and if I make it call me or I let it get Tommy I am destroying that Mitzvah but here I'm not it's a replacer I can't just like with the sweetie I can't that's the comparison that's what Rashi is saying that's the comparison and now she continues the Kievan - winner have come in intimate a min and to Madeira ba number two Midori rice the meta male Madeira Bona no philosophical and system Canada says you're allowed you could take the two Madeira bond and Ashley she and be it me Tom a with the first meet which was a Rishon because it touched an ass it was Tommy died Raisa and now this tomb is gonna travel to the meat and the meat is gonna become a research because the bus are the meat is gonna become a Shanee I'm sorry because the bus are touched the person who touched the mace so the buster is arisia right and when I'm gonna this bus is gonna touch this bus it's gonna be elevated to a Shanee right the Mitama limit your opponent ISIL as ISIL could at least rabbinical II food can impurifier a bond on meta mean and na meat rheumatoid that cinema the Obama be tumour the trauma to Mia died right sir I could take true metal IRA that is a sir to eat only with the Rabanne on and be it me Tommy by contacting it with tumor of the drummer that's Tommy middle ear I see cuz I can't eat it anymore and raschi adds one more detail the llama Tommy yellow element there a bundle day in ISIL me Tommy a kilometer up honor and remember he allows this Raschi yes because the tumor is only with a rabona cuz food that touches other food minute area is not coming so it's only a rabbinic tumor so you're actually saying like this if it would be Tommy me not tire you would have a problem because the titer doesn't believe you now let it so from the Titus perspective you taking food that you're allowed to eat and you're making a tummy for no reason but since the rabbi's say you know let me eat it so the same rabbi say it's Tommy but they also say you know I need so it works thusly she becomes Tom a from the Reese show but it's only rabbinic Lea so it's good because for the rabbi's you know how to eat it and the same is true with the drummer when the trimmer touches the other trimmer ain't nice call me Tommy I saw some mail that's gonna be telling me their abundance of nail it's fine that's how she understands the Gemara so this is the this is the vertebra Mayer this is divert of red layer this is a finish of Rashi now she adds adds the skiddish and yet rabiot she disagrees with her mayor Rubio she said your now let her do this he reads your be akiva he reads the become in his gonna cry on him and he still says you now let her do it what's your abusive the ocean like boy hit coffee like coffee I made the wrong you can't learn it from her be a keyring of canina the BOC still disagrees he doesn't agree with her mayor he says in the missionary mayor is wrong right he says in the mission and those are his words I'm ready I see a nahi Amida it's not true I'm gonna be smaller from the container about mercury you can't learn it no he disagrees to be old you now louder burn it together but the reason he disagrees is because he says there's no proof there's no proof what doesn't he like about it mayor he believes that pasal and us are two separate things not eating comets Erev Pesach is not the same thing like rumor that's possum because even though it's parcel and it's not Tommy but it's a form of Toma it's already Tommy it's a weak tumor it can travel but it's already told me it's contaminated food it's contaminated the complex is not contaminated the comets I'm now let it eat it's a very interesting insight I'm now gonna eat it but the common good comets its Tyra puzzle it's not coming but it's possible its disqualified there's like an infection in it so to speak there's an infection in it yeah you're right in both cases I can't eat it but it's different here I can't eat it because I'm not going to eat hummus now but the true man its own is good from a kosher trimmer after pay sex would be beautiful trimmer before basically beautiful trimmer here the trim itself she says there's still no proof maybe that you're allowed to bring up to trauma because it's already tummy you understand but here it's not tummy at all just I can't eat it so maybe there's a stringency so you say but if you can't eat it who kids if you make it tumblr you can't even anyway no maybe there's an easier to make it tummy even if you can't eat it unless tell me already if it's tummy already I say ok Tommy already bump it up right and maybe you can add the fact that it's being burnt anyway you know maybe in a good day I want it but here it's not good being burnt anyway but it's not taught me who says I'm a but you see we can't eat it anyway ok but don't bring proof or a B Akiva tribulations I disagree with you is Sir impossible is not the same thing it remains I'm Mallory eat it fossil means it's possible it stomach he has to make a separate fire you have to make a separate fire no the BOC hold that the issue to be Atma Tommy is independent of the fact that you can't do the mitzvah with it even though you can't do the mitzvah with it you still can't be at metonic at least but there are bottom maybe maybe y'all's been attorney couldn't have these weighed upon you can't just say I could be at me Tommy but there's nothing to do with it stop fine so London do with it I'm sorry don't do it burn it right yeah you're gonna burn it you're not to burn it because it's its promise you're not gonna say that then mitzvah to eat rumors die sir is Sir comments that not seen how that he'd come at some place I write that not so you have to burn it I get it but it doesn't give you room to be at the table and don't work for any Akiva IRA back if it did do it fine but I be a Kiva had an extra level that you don't have it's called puzzle that's too much because that's where the BAC completely disagrees with them and therefore he says he now ladder beam at time of the tremor because it's a gather of it sir it's not a gather of pasal Malacca is like Ruby I see yeah that we'll see now another interesting thing I just want to be mayor is the mayor says medieval eh-hem Lamade no right MIDI free ham Lamar Lamar says mind me divyam develop randomness ganic IANA is it both together or is it just one says middle a ham so does he need your be a kiva also only repla known as gamma Carina right look Heidi he learnt it from cumin is gonna come up in is gonna call him said that what that boss sir that's Ashley she Madeira born on you could bump up to a Shanee by touching right the bus ershon it ma but Hatami right that's what he said that was a very Conan's Vaart the boss's little bit vodka coma is Ashley she and your myself to Malta Massa so what do we need to be a Kiva he says Madeira ham ah we need those soft of Rebecca ver but why do we need to I suffer about giver right so Louie De Luca Ida the fort is that according to the pnina you're right you could bump it up and it's only inedible are you sayin animal or unedible inedible Madeira bond on your right but its tummy Madeira Bona so it's a much higher level of tumor its tummy the Comets are now ready taka but it's not coming so perhaps he needed to be accurate to say that even if it's not Tommy it's only possum it's only pasal you could still you could still bring it up right it's only possible right right perhaps parcel and is sir could be much more compared to each other right because postal means you now let it eat it Tommy means not only an hour to eat it Tommy means it's giving to me to others Commons doesn't give it to mother come with his comments was much more like comments parcel means you nominate it you could still argue which is abuses argument parcel you're right you're now that eat it but it means that the FAFSA is disqualified [Music] that's my point right right exactly what now how much of a lower passer in other words what do we need your bare key before from reckoning I would just say that if it's Tom a I can make it more Tommy right even though it's only Tommy material bun and you're right it's only talking about I mean I tell you it's fine but since it's telling me there are bond on I don't care if you make it more tummy and as Raschi says you're making it more Tommy only minier Bonin because it's Alma Tommy I'll go but comets is a different game there it's not it's not Tommy it's just I can't eat it but what does it be a Kiva tell us that even something that's possible I could make Tommy what does that mean that's something that you now let's eat you'll want to be me Tommy so that teaches me that something that I now ready eat and I can't do them it's now I'm a lot of bhima Tommy that's the finisher back ever so now it works well for comments that even though it's only when there are born on so for that detail I have rep Romina and for the detail that I'm now that I eat it have Reebok Eva and from Togeth together I learned that I could be mad time of the comments you understand replica Nina I need to tell me that is there are born that even a rabbinic prohibition and when I tried I could eat it I could still make it worse Rabat cave I need you to tell me that if I can't eat it it means I'm a lot of be Atma Tommy because I said about Cuba does he takes oil that's not Tommy its fossil and he says you allowed to make it Tommy so from the two together I have my you so that's me devrait hem Messiah my MIDI frame did it may when it may a said me the very what did he mean he meant to come in yes yeah yeah yeah in other words you come in itself I would say yeah lotta Bhima Tommy the meat because it's already Tommy at least with a rabona but if there would be only on Easter right and not tumour you wouldn't be able to be Atma Tommy oh you can't eat it okay fine so don't need it but you can be damning but from where be a key right there in that words that even if it's not Tommy I could in other words the Hector is not because it's Tommy but because you can't do the mitzvot anymore because what does pasal mean pasal means you can't do them it's from so sorry it's not Tommy it's not gonna bring to me to anything it's it's possible but you can do the Mitzvah anymore it's chemin Chan if subbulu I so because I can do the Mitzvah like rebbi akiva says it's possible nonetheless I could make a tummy so a buzzer is something that's not possible but it's a sir it's similar to PO so what does Oscar mean also mean it's not Tommy but I just can't eat it like Hammad's so we're in Canada said it could be mice of tumor on car bonus that are coming Madeira born on right it's because he holds that something that's Tommy that'sthat's that's that's not good Madeira born on means it's something that's not ROI for the Mitzvah that's why you could be it Mikami he holds that something that's Tommy Madeira born on right even if it's there are born on right you could still be Atma Tommy and bump it up because it's not really for the Mitzvah for a B Akiva we learned that even if it's not Tom a it's just a sword it's not wrong for the Mitzvah if it's not right for the Mitzvah you could be atma Tommy so together we have together we have the idea right so we want to say that is Sir and pasal are the same levels so we have two details here without trip coming we wouldn't know that you could do it with rabbinic s-- in other words rebbi akiva is talking about oil that's possum in hot area so you say it's possibly not Toyotas that means it's really not deer oil for the Mitzvah it's not knowing for the midst of it's basically it's like garbage so if it's like garbage be it me Tommy I mean I don't mean it's like garbage it's not garbage it's true myrrh but it'd be me Tommy right but it's me not tired kameena says no even with me not tired it's perfect but because my dear are born on it's not right for the Mitzvah yeah so the rabbi's will allow to be allow you to be at Mitama so that's you so number one but hummina would tell me okay but that's because it's Tom a so you're making it more tummy but how do I know if it's not Tom a so this is what I learned from be Akiva that even some that's not Tom a some that's not coming it's like the Comets you could still be it matam a but that's only something that's meant a toy that's why I need to come in and the combination of both gives me the conclusion we did a hab that when I have true mer that's not edible only Madeira bummer because it's the sixth hours eleven o'clock and it's officer that I'm now that he eat it with your opponent and story I could make it Tommy I could make enough and as Rashi says you're only making the Tommy Madeira Bonham because ain't no coma Tommy aha this is one mahalik of understanding Reb mayor from here the next sugar the next piece fresh lavash has a whole different Mahalo to me says nobody understood you didn't understand read mayor you misunderstand a man he takes her mayor into a whole different angle no the bi seek he disagrees the mayor he embraces him Kununurra back ever he just disagrees with him mayor I'm sorry for mentioning it again but if you could has her over the mission and the Gemara over Shabbos or Sunday I think it would be very very helpful you'll see no I'm not in town everybody have a wonderful high dish a wonderful Shabbos that's luck and everything we started the sugar up come in on Tuesday I believe right it's on the issue but not melt it's a few days ago it's a little complicated but I gave three days of introductions so you'll get a full picture you'll look out of the sheba dotnet live over the last thirty days you'll see when it started it'll start with an introduction to torment IRA number one dissipated you see there's a rhythm right now I get a no no there's a rhythm people what I told you when it's taught to first time it's not done in a structured way it's pure chaos so the kid it's usually when they're nine years old learning machine is you know what I mean just even just saying there's only three things there's the source of Tama does the recipient of Tama there's how they come in contact is it ready you've covered the whole picture even just saying only four things could be Tommy a person utensils or clothes food and drinks that's it nothing else it's not like is food drinks a person we can break it down as Hollis his skulkers makes better they get scared but but it's not it's cut it's it's intricate and it's complex but it's not there's a lot of details a lot of details but it's details the problem is not that people don't know the details is that they get lost in the picture when you have the picture so far this detail I have to learn this dig left to learn but there's a picture there's a rhythm there's a system it's not chaos it's not Meshuga and everything was they were sensitive to every nuance it wasn't it's okay let's make a new trauma doesn't didn't work that way like when we looked about Moscone everything has a place Marsh comb has discarded this as I said and everything has a source if it's biblical it has a source there's no such a thing Toma because we want it to be Thomas what does the tires say Terry says this this is how it is we may add something because of a concern right like Mashka being or we shine or I shall being my Tommy I fell right I shall being met a miracle is an important idea why did the rabbi say Uncle Matt a miracle because they understood if oil is Mitama Maskin right and oil is not gonna be me Tommy oh so you're gonna let oil Tommy stick around and what if the other oil has a little masking on it your cholent has a little water on it what happens it's Tommy the whole thing is Tommy so by saying Osama Tommy oil they created a gavel the cuff ends for Toma right if you would say a local Matt a miracle so if I have a chicken that stomach I'll just leave it around because if there's a salad who cares the salad is not becoming to me but the salad is wet so all these things right so now the salad they said the salad even if it's not wet the stomach why because oil is Mitama yes so that way you're making to make sure that the salad doesn't get close to the chicken for who leave a Hooley no honey means it's contagious parcel means it's disqualified can go Vitus oh but the thing is tummy not being contagious no if it's taught me it means it goes further pasal means it doesn't offer a Schlick is not Ashley she's called possum it could go to V 2 V could go to the V could go to cot Roberta to it but to its own level it doesn't go further than a definition it goes to this own level to its own genre can go on yeah now it's interesting oil that's possible yo I'm right it's called Ashley she yeah let's called Ashley she because it's drama yeah so the truth is the truth is like this that the truth is like this if the fool yarn would touch oil not of trauma but of car bonus what would that be would you call the Tom Maher puzzle mccartey would call it Tommy cuz it could still make it could still make a Revere right the told you I made actually she and then coy - and carb honestly she's called Tommy cause it makes a reveal only in true Mirza called puzzle so in moussaka site - there's a much like us about that and Ramaiya holds that Ramaiya does hold that he holds that that together together is that for coitus it would be called a a Tom a and only for him it's called pasal that's true that sort of mayor hold sector sighted of hoof tests Oh Marilla deaf guests and remai is the one who's analyzing Herbie akiva so that's why we're talking about that it's just good to note that there's another that have come him and that's that Walker and they hold that when a two-volume touches a carbon because he's a truly I'm he will not make it Tommy he will make it puzzle in other words by at full you I'm the carbon will not travel further so both Truman and carbon will be Ashley she and it won't pass on so will actually be called apostle even for a carbon and that's the halacha so to cavaldi considers that at full yarn because of the weakness of the Toma because he's already in the mikveh he's on the way up so he will only make it Ashley she even car bonus in other words it's a real puzzle its puzzle cuz it really will not travel further not even the car bonus in other words if the trimmer ah well we call it Ashley she so if this cry this because this coin dish becomes pasal from there from the two volume and it touches another carbon a one God and if the true myrrh and therefore the trimmer touches another carbon also not in other words the stage Li she can't become Ravi so it's really pasta cream sense Reb Mayer just doesn't hold there a mayor holds that it could become a ravie that's why we're talking here oh this from May because her mayor's analyzing rebbi akiva but I'm just I'm just making that how are is just good to know just bite folio and there's a unique leniency according to the car comment because it's a different type of Toma really he's not coming he just the problem he went away the problem is that the day didn't end yet and because he was Tommy in the beginning of the day there's a residue and but it's a different type of tumor we call it a Shanee but it's not really much less than a shiny and where do we see the knife come in and we see it by liquids when a full yarn touches liquid it doesn't become a Risha usually when a shame he touches liquid it becomes a Risha if I ate um indica food I'm ashamed I touch liquid it becomes a Russia if my hands are coming cause I didn't do it until I see a diam today right or I did but I didn't protect my hands and six hours later I touched food yeah I touched mask and that masking becomes Arusha because my hand is ashamed but if at all you man I touched Moscone nothing happens unless it's true MA but even if it's Truman becomes Ashley she not a Risha trauma yeah yeah we learn it from our woman who gives birth but Hulk idolized singer yeah yeah yeah Rashi says because it's a Dyson didn't need physic Rashi says because it's a clear finger didn't need physic yeah yeah yeah in other words even though it's full your parcels trauma sexy Asarco stove and it's very nice so they didn't have to be Atma Kazakh they didn't feel that if he touches liquid they have to make it into our issue it was fine first of all it's a weak Toma so they didn't want to do it and they didn't need to do it because it was a protected halakhah and others people knew to protect themselves from volumes and they didn't want to do it because Maskin becomes a researcher but they didn't feel it's right with a Tyrolean cuz it's a weak Toma well the council at folium is a very interesting concept it's basically the concept of what's full yo him is that I'm taller I went to the mikveh but there's a residue that's left over from a previous experience and I didn't completely say goodbye to it that's a very interesting ha welcome if you think about it spiritually I'm in a pure place I'm in a pure place but there's a residue of an experience that I'm still carrying over because I didn't completely graduate from it I'm still in that environment somewhat and it affects me so usually I won't make anything tell me it's fine but true man kocham are sensitive to that they're sensitive to that this class is brought to you by the yeshiva net please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot they ueshiba net / donate