Pesachim 121b - The Pidyon Haben Question - Arvei Pesachim

the yeshiva dotnet yet to bring the carbon Shaggy get out a few conditions first of all it had to be weekdays right it also had to be it to be pure Bottari and you had to have you had to have a small carbon pay stuff that wouldn't be enough to feed the people so the cogito wasn't always brought if you don't have it you don't have it you don't it's not vital for the Seder if you have a few people even the carbon pay so it could be anything it could be a sheep it could be a goat it could be a cow if you have a small little family doing a carbon pace if they'll have enough to eat obese they'll be satiated if you having a seder of 60 people and everybody's gonna get a cause ice from the carbon pay so if you broke a Giga that's why you'll see that if it's mature Shabbos when you do the Seder mr. Sharples like this year right we say at the end with noise cause um I mean has the vacuum woman up Sock'em rubber mats are sharp as many change for nice wholesome right Menachem amina's welcome because they say that it's matauri Shabbos they weren't mark of the keg Egon Shabbos so does ever yeah there was lawmen that they used to bring for Yom Tov that would be brought later so therefore they same in up soccer - mahkumat - vacuum in absorption because they weren't matter of the Haghighi and ate it before the peso so yeah it was the pen and then you of course gonna make a brach on it the question here in the mission is if you are eating both so there's two brothers to make the question is can you make one Baraka and exempt the other one you make two brothers but if you made only on Pesach rubbish mole says you Yates it for the server cannabic if it says no you're not yeah because on a regular say there you eat the service before the pace of a no call from Minas welcome I mean up soccer either Haghighi by dinner and then you need the Pesach at the end of the at the end of the say they're like by the afikoman but in a time when it was Shabbos so you weren't allowed to be mocked over carbon on Shabbos besides the carbon paste of the carbon-based if you could do on Shabbos usually an individual carbon you now that I bring marker on Shabbos cause it's a melaka Shack thing as a melaka right and burning the meat everything it's a melaka so pub communal sacrifices you could do on Shabbos like the carbon Thamud the carbon pacer who's also a special dispensation you like to do it on Shabbos but the carbon car gig I can do on Shabbos so if Arif pace across campus I'm not eating Manaslu cameraman ups awesome oh because it includes all sacrifices you know the way mid REM knit Dava is hagigah was just different car bonus shall make a Giga yeah yeah yeah yeah so the Gomorrah taught us what was the conclusion of this Gomorrah here on that cough cough I love a man Aleph there will be small holds that if I make a brush on the Pesach I exempt any other broker if I did of course I can eat the Kylie go first I make a brach on it that's not a problem but if I made a brush on Pesach I put there I exempted hagigah but not the other way around your backk if it says not everyone has a separate broker and even he made a brach on the pace at first you can be pointer the karmic lag it has a separate broth and the Gemara associated and try to explain the logic behind this argument what would be the logic stomm like what there has to be some theme behind it so the comer tried to connect it to another argument between a brief smaller ABI Akiva and say that it's possible they were smarter about Kiva argue about the second item and hence we can understand the argument of the first item in our Mishnah and that is what there are two types of carbon is darker bonus we had to sprinkle the blood with a Kaylee and this car bonus we had to pour the blood with a Kaylee not to confuse with the carbon Karthus we had to place it with your finger on them is back on the corners but here we're talking about the car bonus we always used a vessel which was most car bonus so carbon Arella and a carbon Slama and a car a shaman a carpenter you took the Kayle and you sprinkled the blood right on two corners of it two corners like we always say how I look Irish kadosh with us I might soften the keyboard amma MacLeish ours but soften the Dhamma tone stay Matano strain Arba because he wanted to get it on the two corners the one hitting let's say every if the two corners that's why Sabbath right you do two angles in one corner and then two angles on another corner so you got it on all four walls all four sides of them is bare that's called Sabbath that's most carbon estoy law and the ashram and the slum and the prey and slum includes a lot of car bonus that our slum Eames that old their slums likely to have the toy day and you have the L DiNozzo like you have a lot of that oh come on is the hottest is an exception and you have also the oiler the ashram the preparing there's long with attorney says clearly to sprinkle the only two exceptions are what my Simba Haim and pastes second over the traitor doesn't even say to sprinkle the blood but we learned from another plastic that all the carbon owners have to be poured the dams vishakha you shuffle miss bahasa Malacca and from here we learned that the carbon pesach is Don bish Vica we take the vessel and we bring it to the wall and we actually pour it on the actual wall and it trickles down to the ledge to the side of the miss Becca and we're good and you only do it once I told you this one opinion of the I said Lily who says that the carbon base of you also sprinkle but even he agrees that it's only one Matano you don't do two sides maybe the word is not sprinkle do they use the word sprinkle foreca I keep on using the word sprinkle ah what are they use as Rica throwing okay throwing the blood throwing I guess throw yeah and poor is I'm Amish I'm very precise I go close to the wall and I almost control the direction yeah the same Kayle the same Kayle but either I stand from a distance because I'm not I'm not right there at port you don't you don't throw it if you're right there I go away from a distance and I go like that that's Rica I throw it I says I'm Amish come close to the wall some even say the coin stands on the ledge on the east side because the east side went out like a foot and a half or two feet so he stands on the ledge that's not clear some say yes some say not but he's right there and he pours it on the wall no kata so you take the finger and you put it on the corner it's a dip it's a dip toi vilette's boy padam Yom Kippur you have a combination you Kippur you go to the Holy of Holies your finger you you throw the blood ACK Aslam I love a shovel Amata yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah on the corners yeah the only carbon that's not with a Kayle is carbon cantos of carbon Coty's yeah yeah because because because on a deeper level it says cause chuhwa you have to go out of a Kayle you have to go out of your Calum that's what Chavez you understand okay Lee is a container it's a limiting container like we're learning in Lakota Terry the mind may of motivo and Bullock what are we learning that the whole purpose of life is to do trova because in a some of the way it's before this world it's in Calum and when you come into this world you go out of the Calum because that's what real truth is truth always comes from a certain frustration a certain tension and that causes you to transcend your vessels we all have vessels that we live in containers which are important but Chavez that is the going out of the Kaylee you shatter the vessel that's the power of it there's something in infinite about it it's the cry it's the yearning it's about transformation so the carbon Cantus fascinatingly the blood is not from a Kaylee it's the only thing that goes out of the Kaylee all the other components remain in a Kaylee and there's a lot of so many hollow cos will you put the blood how you put the blood like it's it's it's pretty interesting yeah yeah yeah damn who are nefesh the blood is the soul and and by true ver it goes out of a Caylee because that's what truth is you go out of your Calum that's why you have to do Chula if you were comfortable in your kale you would never do truven truven means I'm uncomfortable in my Kaylee my structure is frustrating me and I go beyond it and in many ways that's the purpose of life to become a ball sugar to go out of the Kayla a very interesting thing with car bonuses also you speak about throwing the blood where do you throw the blood the miss base was a tall structure on the upper half or the lower half and there were different cabanas some companies had to throw the blood what's called beyond the Jota Sakura beyond the red string right yet newer than the upper half and if you did it on the lower half wasn't good or the other way around so it's it's like it's it's it's extremely interesting all these things yeah no no you didn't need yeah the Cayenne shafted somebody took a Kayleigh and place it by the animal to receive the blood that's called Kabbalah then there was something called halacha you take the cable you bring it to the altar and then there was dis Rica yeah yeah and with the carbon paisa wasn't Sarika with shisha the campus was a whole system because there was so many people it had to be done very fast so they had from the schita till the Miss baya they had a row of kyon M right who would pass the vessel to each other like I would get it from the guy who received it I would give it to you you would give it to him him him mmm he was by the MS baya he poured it and then he sent the Kaylee back with another row as it was happening so was like this this ah conveyor belt literally literally because remember you can have thousands and thousands and thousands all in the afternoon every Jew brought a carbon based on men women was yeah yeah silver I don't remember there was a reason I don't remember there's a reason for yeah they didn't want to cheat congeal the blood should congeal eeeh of course it's very meticulous it's very precise exactly how it happened there's intricacies of Walker's here you can assume one of two things either nothing makes sense or everything makes sense these types of things either nothing makes sense or everything makes sense yeah we'll have the Einstein once said either nothing is a miracle or everything is a miracle you have to choose which philosophy in life yes so the Sarika was the ultimate that's what macabre the carbon Pinkel yeah so piggo can happen either through a mosquito or halakhah or kabbalah or Iloka or is reka one of those four at any stage because those are the four avoiders that really make the carbon happen yeah yeah after that yet after that you can go home and then call me read the newspaper just take off your big day kohonen go home and read the newspaper right it's not that yeah in other words when I'm involved in the avoider my mental state becomes very very critical which is unique in Judaism because usually the mental state you asked before but my shava right we learnt that the Mushaf azureus of tsadikim are more serious than our voidness of our Mars we see it in piggle that your mental state actually completely disqualifies a carbon and according to some reason you don't even have to verbalize it even if it didn't come into dev or its mama sure thought it's a crazy thing I just had a thought I might control a fourth came into me I don't want to eat it today I want to eat it tomorrow I want to sprinkle the blood tomorrow I want to burn it tomorrow but chorus chorus chorus really what am i eating I wanna mean poison I'm not even poison yeah you eating poison why because somebody's thoughts a guy at a thought a guy at a thought and the meat became poison chorus chorus means it's poison for the soul cuts off the soul it's a fascinating Aloha yeah obviously a car bonus is different okay now so so what was the conclusion what did the gonna try to say that according to be small Sarika by Klaus Rika meaning schrieffer is all-inclusive so if any carbon is brought through shreeka it's good it's not the way to do it but if I take a Khadija and instead of throwing the blood I pour the blood I'm good but not the other way around if I throw the blood of the pay sucks it's not good sort of small sister now I understand if you make a brush on Pesach it includes a Ginga because the shaggy ger in some sense is part of the country pacer part of the laws that govern the carbon Pacers but not the other way around if I make the brush I give you I'm not the answer for the Pacer no be a keeper holds no Zook is not Prakash Rica and Trish is not with Klaus Rica so therefore the Broca's can't exempt each other I did want to clarify one thing I'm asked yesterday the question that is a contradiction in Iran bomb the de Rambam apparently contradicts himself very heavily because in Hill crassula hammock adduction which are the laws that deal with carbon is have become disqualified in Payard Bay's he says then even car bonus that you have to throw the blood if you pour the blood it's good which is like rubbish ma zouri Quebec Lao Vika right and yet the Rambam and hostess cumbersome at Sebastian's that the brach of paisa does not exempt the broken car Giga and you have to make two separate rockets which means now he's signing with Rabi Akiva the Gamora clearly puts the two together in the Rambam in his own home office chooses one and then chooses the opposite view and he'll cause Potomac - and he follows him Ishmael when it comes to Shri Sansa Rica and hookers comments amok so he says two separate ruckus and one does not exempt the other mob said cause the Gomorrah the Gomorrah says one depends on the other right look at the Gomorrah the debris debris smalls recover Klaus Rika became a large stroke of a classic of ERISA so the or understood that admonish one depends on the other if you hold this you hold this if you don't hold this you don't hold this and yet the Rambam apparently obviously he learned the Gemara so this is this is as I told you the lack of Mishnah the left commissioner asks this question and he says the zuikou sure kazakh this is a powerful question that's our opinion that's how the letter Mishnah the commissioner responds to the square which is one of the one of the commentators on the Rambam so that slack right that slack is that CL NF Australia which was authored by Arabi Haskell and L denied the B Hooda and I'm Misaka Sock'em he says that tourists this long toys service he brings an interpretation of one of the Ballia toys was known as a Brian Cohen and rapine Cohen which toy service brings as an interpretation here in this Gomorrah that slaughters probably the ROM mom agrees with this interpretation because that would make the Rambam that would allow us to understand how the Rambam thought of it and that is basically that the Rambam holds an explanation that's boarding you shall me and the gyro shall me insult him that's what I see as being from crime client do you solemnly holds that the reason why pacer patters hagigah the bracha the reason for every Schmoll is and actually he said it yesterday one thing he's here today said it yesterday because it's called a current offal in Baracus we have a concept called a current offal a primary food and a subservient food let's give a simple example it's fair it's pretty extreme actually I want to drink a little bit of schnapps in the morning for whatever reason let's say for good reasons my doctor told me it's important for my heart the problem is is xa9 cerca you know what's XA 9 sakura is 96% alcohol and 4% non alcohol you ever drank such this really okay so in know not advisable uh-oh so I wanted yeah I want it I love it I enjoy it but I know how sharp it is I don't want it to burn up the kishkas so right after that there's a happy so Karla a piece of bread I eat the bread why am i eating the bread only to serve as a cover up as a as a cushion for the mask so that look is you don't make a brush on the bread you know it could work on the bread call Shruti care right Mubarak Allah ikura Poitras a tough now you have to make sure it's powerful if I'm eating the bread cause I also like a little bit to eat bread then of course I have to wash I make emergency but if I'm really eating it which is why you have to be careful with IKAR and TOEFL you know because or a piece of cake people sometimes they take a snap right and then they eat a piece of cake just to sweeten it so if I don't want the cake I just want a cushion for the mask I'm not supposed to make a brush on the cake why because the cake is not considered cake it's considered an extension of the Mashka it's powerful it's subservient so you make a brush on the air and you put it on the TOEFL that's the holocene oh [Music] yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah so therefore so this is all your Sami says this is the reason of her but this is the reason of rubbish small that the hagigah is TOEFL to the pacer why is it tougher to the Pacer because it's not an essential obligation the whole reason it's broad is that you should eat the carbon paste when you're satiated so what's the whole point of the Haghighi just to serve as a as a catalyst that your carbon basic should be eaten when you say she ate it and that's why you only bring the Kaguya when it's a weekday when you're pure and when you have a few people when when you don't have enough of the carbon paste so now there's not any central obligation to bring this on Giga it's a hot corner it's a preparation for the carbon pacer and therefore according to this every small says you make a brach on the eco you point to the trailer so that's why the Pacer is part of the hug Union okay coach good one one good one before we get there good question so that slash says the Rambam probably follows this reasoning and that's why the random doesn't have a problem with saying that the pace truck is not quite to the huggy who's he agrees with a be a Kiva and still saying that what's recover Klaus with her cuz he doesn't believe he follows do you assure me that the two arguments are not connected the two arguments are not connected the reason of Rabbi Shmuel is not Costa Rica McLouth visa the reasonably small is because the ek is pointed at awful that's the reason of every Schmo if you attack a whole that's because Rica but sorry sir then he couldn't write what he writes but he owes the reason everybody small is because it's a current tougher like the US Army that's the answer that Isis brings to a crime Korean and therefore it's not a contradiction you can holds recover Klaus with her and you could still hold that the pay sucks is not pointed as ever that's what it's Locke says in the rumble right the you guys are tough for you saying okay okay okay right right right right the question now is what would Rebecca vis say what would your back either say why would he disagree why would he say you make on the Pesach and it's not point to the car Giga so you might answer like Rebbe Yaakov just said the din of a current tough will is only right if you're eating first dicker what if you eat first a TOEFL what if I eat the bread before the schnapps I can't say I'm not making a brush on the breath who's later I'm gonna drink schnapps doesn't work that way if you eat the TOEFL after the a care yeah or another example you take bread and you put hummus on it you take Amazonas bread or my might see when you put commas on it so if you're making I might see making I might see but let's say you take a cracker you put hummus on it you don't make her brother Chacal on the homeless why cuz the homeless is subservient to the cracker yeah what if I'm eating hummus before the cracker yeah I don't say I don't make shikaku I'm you're eating bread before the schnapps you have to make a brother why because he now letting eat before you make a brother since the shaggy go was eaten went before the carbon pesach so therefore rebecca says the Pacer can be point in the car who's the basical is gonna be later but then the question is the opposite what would every small halt we're gonna be small then why would he yell that there was the pace of this point did that huh giggle when you eating that I'll give you first meaning the kangy go first so let's say it's tough we'll be eating the tough will first have to make a brush on it right so then the shila's why would you back here with disagree so you say well cuba this agrees because they ate the Haghighi first so why would they be small disagree but the truth is that there is a difference between burkas Hannon and Britta some mitzvos abraca that you're making on food because of Hanaa here it's not a British on Menon right we're talking here British on mitzvos we're not making a brother shikaka me abit Vario burger Priya eights when doing abraca she coulda Sean no boom it's noise of its Yvonne oh la lah pestle there are more when we say that you have to make a brach on the TOEFL if you're eating it before the IKAR the point is if i'm eating bread and then drinking schnapps you can't say that my bracha in 10 minutes over schnapps should work for the bread you now let me eat without a broker you eating bread now you didn't make a brook later you're gonna make a broker so that works by british and then and it's very true cuz you know that i have AA from oil um hase without a broker so therefore I have to make a brush of first I got it but by British Assam mitzvos you can't say this I'm now going to eat bread without a broker I am gonna make a block on schnapps that's gonna be later but now you have to make a brook on bread I it's awful tough walk but you're eating it powerful so you have make a broth but the business of mr. she can't say oh I'm now going to do it without a broker what do we now let her do it God told you to do a mitzvah you have to do it you're not making a Brock in order to allow you to do the mitzvot you have to do the Mitzvah you're making a broker to prepare that to poppy to prepare you for the Mitzvah the Khammam said you should make a broccoli before you do the Mitzvah but it's not like you now let it do it without a broccoli you have to do it the trader said you do it I want you should make a broccoli before the broccoli should be before so maybe you could say that here even if you do the TOEFL before you don't have to make a brush on it why because when is the shaggy complete it only when you eat the paste us because the whole purpose of cutting edges for the Pacer so therefore the broccoli dur perhaps works even for earlier so the affordable small would hold and even if you eat this I get before the Pacer you don't have to make a brush on the car giga if you want to make a brock on the pace perhaps because it's different because it's a mitzvah it's not a regular not a regular case of a british a nanana almost why don't we make a Shahi or no buy beer comets we do beer comets it's a mitzvah comes once a year we say close the shutter y'all know what if young TIF is gonna be is gonna work for the beer comets also right in other words because I'm doing beer comets for young TIF so there's a Theon or a beer comets is exempt by the chef Fiona that I make kiddush I it's 24 hours later it's fine so the same thing you would say here then it'd be small hold that even though you make the brush on Pesach later it would already work for the Sabbath because as Elvis's our TOEFL and the mitzvah of the cog is finished with the Pacer it's completed through the pace of who the whole purpose of it is the preparation and yet Rebecca VAT disagrees but Cuba still disagree Zimmer Cuba's says that even in this case you never allow to make a brach on the hog eager for the pace for the pace takanakuy ginga no difference whether you eat to pay some first eat the peso second it doesn't it doesn't it doesn't become Tuffle and another interesting thing is that even if small halts that it's not like you have to be packed you have to pack to the high giga if you made on the pace stuff you don't have to make on the car gig but if you want to make on the car giga like a pillar it doesn't I hate my and TOEFL you're not supposed to make on the TOEFL you're only supposed to make on the acre here the Bhishma also says you can make on the Haghighi he just says if you made on the pace if you don't make another one on the hagigah right or if you made on the pace of before you ate the car Ginga you don't make another one on the car gig in New York but even heels on the cap he'll have to make to Broca's so it's not a regular case of a Korean tough one one explanation is that occur and TOEFL usually is dependent on the person's mind where I am from me it's occur from me it scuffle from me this is the primary for me this is a subservient if I want something only as a TOEFL it really becomes Tuffle because it's all about my perspective because it's just what I think for you this bread is is the primary food for me it's not it's meaningless I just want to eat it I want to drink the schnapps mitzvos you could say are different because mitzvos it's not about me I'm a hoof to do it right so how do you know what's an EK what's a TOEFL and you know what's in it what's a Tuffle if the tiger makes a tough hole it becomes tougher but it's not a tough hole but at some in other words the keg is Tuffle in the sense that you don't always bring it you're not always macro vet but they're back if it can hold when you are Mac rivet because it's a mitzvah so you can't call it a TOEFL because this is what Hashem wants this is what a sham wants and the Mitzvah gives it an ultimate shivers and ultimate prominence it doesn't really become Tuffle it's a mitzvah you have to do it it erupts in Hashem can you say that one Rutzen is Tuffle to the other Upson there may be different conditions when to do it how to do it but it's not that it's essentially subservient then it loses its significance it has an objective divine value that's why even according to their be small only but the you could Pat about like a pillar you make to Broca's and accordion but giving you but cloud can't patter it okay so that's the way of explaining the Rambam ah no no no I was one of the ballet artists ya later he's just saying that his view the Rambam would have this yeah yeah you could see the last lines of toys vs. LEDs one two three it's like six lines from the bottom you see bit of cayenne Cayenne Pitta sh sh attempts align my lid available Schmalz Ricky but claustrophobic Laos Rica car key gears abyss fauna Mia Shane him in the old sparkly McCulloch are Banas bazooka bush with her which means you could do all carbon is both the anal ahok bit o British soccer my eager lifter it's a tough old Vilayet uh Felicity care the crime coin at a different gear say he said that the small actually holds everything works not like we learned here his gear says Schmidt works for 3 cos Rico works for Swiss I so why can't a cog eager be pointed a peso kinda passive phase it's cuz base of his eager and it's played to the TOEFL and not the tough of the acre okay that's the that was his gaze of hungry next attack it says in you rashon me accorded is the barley and you shall me with fit and the Rambam could have believed like this and he had a different gears in argue more and therefore the Rambam has his own way of learning and that's what we explained a Kirito for every small and rebbi akiva yeah yeah the lubavitcher rebbe as a hundred i'm Sock'em and he shows that throughout the whole sauce you'll be smaller but kiva have many arguments that are similar to this pattern where to be small looks at every Mitzvah from the perspective it's from the perspective of the human being and her back even looks it from the perspective of hashem so it's very interesting and a lot of for example every small hole did retire collection Bonet other terror speaks in the language of manner but if it says Lloyd did retire callosum they other for example if there's a redundancy in a pasta commish mall says oh that's how people speak they repeat themselves twice they repeat themselves twice so God knows that tuna but if it says absolutely not Turner does not speak in the language of man yeah the kymaro says in the beginning of sight uh that there's a thought a thought it's it's rejected that's fascinating that a small hole that all the mitzvahs are voluntary whenever it says in title you should do something it's just to suggest if you want you could do it sighted of gimel it'd be small holes that every Mitzvah is voluntary because the Gemara brings three mitzvot establish wall says are voluntary but Cuba's an obligation law Utama does a coin have to become tummy for a sister for a brother for a father for a mother if small says voluntary vacuous obligation so the commercials may be to be swallowed that all the mitzvahs are are voluntary what's the difference a voluntary obligation in terms of a person when you do something voluntarily if more involved because it's your choice right an obligation means basically you subservient to God so it current Tuffle to Rabbi Shmuel looks at it from the human experience when the human experience Haghighi is Tuffle to Pesach because it's subservient its whole purpose a spacer but from the divine perspective the meddra says out to Yosh of a circle mitzvah shall terror don't decide which Mitzvah is more important which which is less important if it's God's will it has ultimate objective value the Tuffle is just because I Shem wants it should be like this but it's not the Exim puffle it's not about your perception it's about that they want so this is a McCleod kiss between be smarter but keep it throughout the whole shots why huh Ginga would not be a tough full acquainted about keeping why occurred nebbish Marla would be a tough full about an you fine huh because nor the crime Cain had different gears and the bhava Lee oh no you won't say that because he he reviewed his safe for a few times so he went back he would have changed that he can't contradict himself like this the Rambam had a bird's-eye view of halacha so sound like when he wrote else's comments ahmad say he forgot he can't he can't work like that we have today Google but they had Google here better than Google no this rocky be says this free will and Pirkei avos how called soft voice ferociousness Sunnah but the question is forever keyword Yiddish guide ultimately whenever it is a choice he will always look at it from the godly perspective and it be small more from the human perspective okay let's see the next piece or to put it this way you this card is a relation between our chemin de jeu in every relationship right whenever you look at of marriage at a family you could see the imprint of the husband you could see the imprint of the wife so when Judaism you could see the imprint of the divine and the imprint of humanity that's the beauty of it the question is in those cases that are not clear which one do you accentuate which one do you choose which one is the focus which one is the primary component a lavell ooh a Louisville darillium cream of course there's always a truth to this and a truth to this it's not so the Gemara now continues with the final story of moussaka Sock'em DAF cooker follow the midbass the big question of course is how this comes in right here we had a mission about making a brach on Pesach a Giga but the Gemara now tells a story similar equal opinion have been reps in law he came to opinion huh Ben see this works with our first chair in the morning car - Lee called her every first male born has to be redeemed from the Cayenne and we small case employee came to us ceremony of pedina Ben listen what happened Bomi nay they asked for him a question what's the question it's obvious that our pinion our Ben Ishak additional my choice of its Yvonne opinion a ban a via Ben maverick it's obvious that under pity now Ben the broker I shake additional limits raven-symoné opinion I've been who makes the broker the father of the son not a question that's obvious that this is what the town is similar at the pity and I bet it's obvious that when it comes to pit in a band the broker I shocked the deshaun of my choice I would say one opinion a band is made by the father why is it obvious because he has the Mitzvah he has the Mitzvah I'm a father I have a son after redeem him from the coin so I make a broker rapid you know like it's true you make a broth granted the question is Bordeaux sure he honor the c'mon of the journalism on Isaiah Korean maverick I have you been Navarre what about the blessing of chef Leon blessing of Saffiano is made not by every Mitzvah when I put on tefillin I don't make sure he uh no Saffiano is done on a mitzvah that happens miss man was man right the night of him Kippur you make a chef he uh no you blow chauffeur you make a chef he on the first night of Hanukkah you make a Saffiano so there's a Saffiano by pity in a ban but who makes the Brock Korean maverick yeah via been Mubarak the Cayenne who's receiving the money or the father what's the question Korean moverá become mati Holly other maybe the Korean makes the broker cuz the benefit the enjoyment comes to his hand the coin is receiving five silver slowed him from the father that's a great Hana that's a great financial have no benefit there's are not and it's an also with a mitzvah it's a mitzvah it's hot nuts tongue it's not rusty giving him five slowing right I'm just adding that cuz it's not every time that a person gets money that you make a Saffiano but the point is it's Han na that's coming with a mitzvah for the father with whom it's of the Kai and also the client is part of the Mitzvah and it's fact it's one of the Martinez Cohen opinion about oh yeah via Ben maverick or maybe the father of the child should make the broker to carve it Mitzvah he's doing the mid-south pinion event that's his Mitzvah boy half a be all day your boy he did not know the answer he did not have in his hand the response she's had a pig in a band and they don't know who makes sure he uh no they know who makes the first broker they don't know make sure he uh no soy obey madrasah sesamoid goes to the base meddra SH and he asks the question um rule a they tell him a veha Ben maverick I am the father of the son of the child makes both blessings are pedina been and shishio know and the gomorrah says vehilce sir that's talk about loca the lock is de la vie I've been divorced I am that the father of the child makes both blessings the blessing of our pigeon our manager here and others what they told reps employee and the bass madness is kabaah halacha that's the story so the rash mom says rips employee claw masoom the ID must need submission a mini broca's how does this come in here who's Tom uppity in a band huh we're talking my making a brush on the carpet ASA he says because we spoke about two types of brushes but Adam I thought to myself that all he said was they couldn't paste as was ever shall he go by in my path we're talking about two brothers made by one person connected with one action that is dependent on another action like a pacer and a Kaguya the hugging comes with the Pesach so we want to know if you make one Brock or you make two brothers or could you make one Brock all you have to make two so mission hockey not cut na mila hi move the W bend over her style so that's how the Gemara came into this story that the father of the son has to make both Broca's he doesn't only make one brother he makes both brothers just like rebbi akiva holds they have to make both brothers on the pace of kin as ever hey there's also to Broca's pedina Ben and Chevy oh no do you make one bracha they make two brothers here you don't pat through one brother the clan will make it or I have to make both brothers as a father that's how the rash bomb sees the connection now if you look at this story if you look at this story there's a few very interesting intriguing things about the story number one the connection of the rash bomb is a little bit of a difficult connection it's like the cause we're talking about a Brock of pace seconds ever there's an exam time exam so therefore the gomora reminded itself by a pity now Ben is a question of who makes the second bracha it seems like a very difficult connection it becomes even more strange I'll tell you why the riff and the rush rabbits are called Farsi and a rush what they do is they're always in the back of the Gemara they don't quote the whole gamar they take out all the hollows of the Gemara because they're like the beginning of racial Canora they're not that they're not talking about at the beginning the first halacha connection right but what they did was something very very special took out the whole office of every miss after and they put it where it belongs in other word sometimes you have a halakhah right and Maseca Shabbos that belongs to another miss Esther so they'll take it out from there and put it in that mess after the Rif and the rush you would think this how locker they would take out from here and put it in a sec stop iris which deals with the whole office of pity and I've been picking Claire but they keep it a Miss act of soccer that means they felt that it's actually connected to Pesach now that sloth asks a very interesting question and that slack asks the following question a fascinating question and it teaches you how to read a story in Gomorrah simile is that a pig in a bend the brach are pinned in a ban what do they say we know what to do we have a question about saffiano he says if it's pretty why they telling it then they should just say what do we do with saffiano why they giving an introduction imagine I come to a pig in a band yeah and you have a question yeah are you gonna come to me and say rabbi it's push it that on the coffee we make Shaco my question is how much money I give the Cayenne if it's partial it's partial why they giving this introduction seater what you want to show off your now is even more than that if they're asking rip similarly the question it means they think he knows how to learn much better than them that's where they're I asked him a question if he knows how to learn much better than you so if it's partial by you it's pushed by him and it's a case of my raha la cabaña Robbie not supposed to tell our Walker front of you rather similar is gonna be your teacher and you know that he knows that alert why are you telling him things that are simple it's not even so respectful just say rips employee who makes their yellow they do a fitter why asks so the slack has a brilliant Vaart and his vote is that has to do with the bracha you see they quote the whole broker top pigeon I've been challenged as recessive oh no I'll pity in a band you don't say Liv dosa ban you say I'll pdn have been I'll pinion have been what's the difference some breakfast we learned before and outshine you se llama trite like Lahani yet villain and sometimes you say owl what's the difference between llama then ow so the slug says that's what they were saying that the broker is not lived i sub-n the brokers owl pidyon haben and it's like says as follows the reason you say ow it says in your showing them we learned before they revoir the rushes when you could do it through ash Leah when you don't have to do it yourself you can do it through Ashley if you say I'll because the midst is not on me to do it the Mitzvahs it should happen you can also do it from me pretty not been you could do through Ashley uh that's what this locks us that's what they said out pity not been if that's the case who should make sure he or no he says I'll tell you why if the father appoints Ashley uh to do it for him that's leaf can't make her shut hey uh no because the Schlick doesn't have that simcha because he's just a slid for somebody else so that means if the father has to make a Saffiano sometimes I see Fiona won't be made because he says ow ow means you could use Ashley recover users list me sometime Saffiano me so better the Korean to make it because the claim is always did it's not printed I bet without a client that was there Schuyler the owl is the introduction to their question because if you could use Ashley acts it means that the father won't always be there probably won't always be that there won't always be a chef Keanu so better give it to the Cayenne cuz he's always having the Hanaa let him do it that was the you can't happen to have a pin about without the easy Kevin feel about without the father not without the kind you need a shreya but the father Ashley even best and could be anybody Commission alia does father just needs a messenger to do it that's uh yeah yeah she could be a slayer yeah there is a hollow if the father doesn't do it it happens today a lot father doesn't do it so then when the boy grows up we have to do it Padre Tiffa de they do maryland's Padre eat if that twice that if your father didn't do it for you you have to do it the Vilma gone was a boy who used to walk around with five slam whenever he met a coin he did pinyon have been for himself no without a shame of Malthus barakatuh mark I shall transmit one opinion on bet why cuz it just in case they were the Korean how do you know he comes from Ireland maybe he's not a real guy and maybe he decided he said you know people decided their client him at some point you know sometimes it was good for shidduchim sometimes at the boat they said Oh Cohen yeah Cohen shine Cohen as it was a coin yeah so the villain oyster always redeem himself but that's only if you father didn't do it maybe he didn't have the money or maybe he didn't know or maybe he was not a very engaged Jew it's just like a bris right the father does the bris but if the father didn't do it you were ah a lot of Russian Jews and other Jews who have had bris and later in life it's not so simple but you know Ben is a little easier than a bris for obvious reasons so the so the point here is this is the first of art of the clock then this father gives a second opportunity and he says ow means that the mitzvahs not done through the father himself he needs the client to help him do the mitzvot I can do the mid so myself as a father that's why it's not lit it's al al means I need the participation of others it's not a myth spawn me to do it because I need the coin the coin for crying says I'm not interested in the mitzvah I can't do the Mitzvah huh there's a partnership in the midst that's why there's no lid this owl that's why they had a Suffolk who makes Chevy ah no since both of them are doing the Mitzvah but the coin is the only one getting the money so makes sense he should make the chassis ah no that's the two ways that slack explains the Gemara that it's the owl that makes the question if you would say lei I wouldn't have a question cuz it's all the father the father kept makers Leah and therefore he'll always make sure he all know and the father is the one who has the Mitzvah but since it says al al means a you can make Ashley R so that means sometimes if the father is not there there won't be a chef he knows some better the coin should make it because he's always there be all means that I can do it myself I need you oh so so the Colleen is also part of the Mitzvah plus he gets the money so maybe he should make sure he oh no that's the slacks explanation and the Gemara oh so based on the kid than that a question they couldn't make ignore we asked what are they saying if it's printed don't say it get to the point you don't say represent Lori it's that the air-condition should be on I mean it's it to their own the co for you makes sure Huckle okay fits punch the punch it for you it's also pushes for him you know if to teach it to him just ask me a question when you read a story Ingemar you have to be sensitive to these types of things ah yeah the father was there it's just the ass because it's possible the father won't be there so maybe maybe never have him douche fer no because that way the Sheffield is always secured because the father appoints us live he doesn't make a Saffiano because it's not his simplicity ah no is the sin of the myths for the father does yeah yeah yeah in other words as an introduction to the next piece oh good there's a problem with the slacks answer is and by the way that some surfer gives a similar answer is you see at the end that the Gomorrah keeps on going back to stymie which is superfluous we already dealt with the first Baraka he came to the base meditation have told them a via been Navarre saffiano nobody asked about patina ban we not be in a better and the healthiest savvy I been maverick sty him the camera keeps on going back to that first Baraka very good it should have said maverick Saffiano that's the question why maverick stallion we never had a problem on pinion have been the hostess Aria been maverick chef young boy comes into the race matters he asked about Sheffield it should have answered about Saffiano why they sang she I am but there's also a bigger problem with its laughs i'm not bigger another problem with its lock challenge and that is when you read the language of the Gemara you see that's not the case look at the Pieta the peshitta is i'll pigeon have been I shake it this son of a mistress of its Amano LP dionneb an avi hub and may vary according to the track what should have it said it's pretty that the RV hub and makes out pigeon have been the focus is the text of the brush and not who makes it so the grammar should have been that when it comes to pity and I ban the father makes alpide Ian have been by Chevy y'all know the question is who made Saffiano but what does the Gemara say it's pity that the browser copied in our ban the father makes in other words what's the focus the father making it not the text of the bracha that's the focus because think think in English when you make a sentence yeah where do you put the punchline what's your punchline here he it's anticlimactic that slack is saying the pity is that the brachot is outfit in a been not who makes it because who makes it that we don't need that's it exactly is that via been a via been Navarre who makes the broker not Peter avi huh been missing translation sivanna patina ban yeah yeah yeah also also a be the contrast first they say it's Peter that the father makes up it in a ban the question is Saffiano who makes it it seems like it's it's it's it's a parallel contrast it's abscissa that the pinyin I've been he makes the question is who makes SEO know that's the question according to the slack that's not the issue it's not it's not a parallel it's not a parallel question but the main thing is the no sir you see the new circuit should have said avi have been maverick I shall travel is one RPG in a band not opinion are been right Navarre opinion a beneficent that is one opinion I've been a via been maverick it seems like the Gomorrah is not talking about the text the Gemara is talking about who makes the Braga it's obvious the father makes the brush up with vigils what were they trying to say according to this fact they weren't trying to say that the father makes the brush because that they're trying to say that the text is al not Lee and that's why they have a question the biggest proof is you open up the rush the rush quotes the Gomera Liholiho what's his words I quote the Russia's words I'll pinion have been bad guy ha of Maverick he doesn't even give them no son lease he skips that hole no son he goes out pidyon haben vanayya VI been maverick in other words that they were saying as it's obvious that if the father the question is chef he on who does it not that they were focusing on the text of the Baraka I'll pig in our band vedera of Maverick when it comes to pity in a band that brother now you could say he says I'll pity and I been he puts in out pity to have been but he's opinion I've been valet of Maverick without the whole ocean of the channels I said one a pity not been the last question I'm not gonna do the answer today but the last question is according to its lock it's very very clumsy the words it could have said balm in a they said like this Kevon thou padilla not been more efficient consciousness of an RPG in a band so baroque Saffiano korean mubarak heaven what's a splitter it's simple that i'm pinion our band the brush up him and the father makes he could have just said very straight bomb in a they ask the question since since by a pagina been he makes the broker outbid in a been so the question is who makes saffiano instead of this whole cumbersome cumbersome language and text yeah going to the slocks and it's it's it's a it's a very growled the top of the slot that the owl it's the owl it's not the lid that was the question but it's it's a little difficult in the in the in the text so if you'll turn to enough cough cough Oliver Matt Bay's I want to explore with you a little deeper the story that we that we learned last time the story of rebus employee it looks like a very short and nice and Gus Macker story but when you delve into the story there's really very a lot here let's remember what the Gemara said about the story what happened the Gomora said rips employee came to opinion are Ben and the pigeon have been they asked him a question what was the question they said like this it's it's partially that for a pig in a band the brush and additional moisture with sivanna patina band the father of the son makes that's partials when it comes to pit in a band the broker I should get a shot of him a choice of it co-op he didn't have been the father makes the question is what about the broker Shafi honor who makes it the koi you know the father does the Cayenne make it because he gets the benefit he gets the money he has her norm not to on all the other so he makes the blessing chuckling oh no chef Fionna was a blessing that you make because of a simcha because you're in a state of joy so therefore the coin by pinion have been he should make the Saffiano because he gets the cash he gets the silver I should say not to cash the silver or maybe the father should make chef Theo no because he's doing the mitzvah carve admitster he's doing the Mitzvah and because he's doing the Mitzvah and it's not a regular Mitzvah it's not a mitzvah that you do every day MIT's opinion are Ben you do once a wife because their second son you can do the Mitzvah anymore this is a mitzvah you do once a lifetime and you can't even do it once a lifetime always if you have a first daughter you can dupe it in a bet right or if you're lazy I call you and you don't do pretty in a band so it's a unique mitzvah so it's unique and therefore he should do this he should make Saffiano so the gomorrha certainly have a be other he didn't know what to say he didn't know the answer so he went and he asked him to base my dress and they told them that the father makes both blessings Savia been Navarro style the blessing of pinion I've been in the blessing Saffiano the first year and the second year are matching not only that but also in the details we'll soon see [Music] he left the pig in a band it says he says austere he came shawl by Madras I asked in the base Madras he went to the yeshiva where they were learning with the great comedy curcumin were and he asked what do we do he didn't know that obviously Arabs employee is one of the great the greatest of them Miriam he's called the rebus employee that's where they asked him the question but he didn't know as the Ben URI other points out hey you see how atomic awesome functions he doesn't know yeah he himself went to the base Madras and he said I want to find out he didn't send us Leah he went himself maybe somebody was greater than him or the general consensus or you know Dybbuk evade him they can debate it maybe somebody had a tradition you know the collective always has the power or just the creativity of the collective working it through and they told them that the father makes both blessings and the Gemara concludes the story that's the end of the sternum our clue that the hwacha is a via Ben Navarro Steinmetz that Walker the father of the son makes styie meaning he makes both blessings the blessing of our pity and abandoned the blessing of saffiano right that's the Gemara so we brought the question of the slock Rebbe Haskell and out denied to be hooda the ceilin efforts na who asks AG about the Kakashi Akash is why the introduction pritter if the first broker they knew who makes it and it was obvious so I've introduced it to give a simple Marshall if you come over to me at a meal and you point to a certain food and you say rabbi Jacobsen what's the broker for this food you're not gonna start it's that I'm the caller we make a might see but I don't know what do we make on this if it's don't say it you can't say that they thought it was printed by them and not by him because if they're asking rebus employee which broker to make who should make chef he all know obviously they believe that he knows how to learn better than they do that's why they're coming to him and saying what should we do on chef he all know so if it's the first brushes per that buy them for short written by him if they know for sure he knows they're trying to come to him to ask him for saffiano certainty knows what to make for the first block in fact saying is even a type of mirror lock-up if any robbery don't start teaching your ever the obvious how losses that he certainly knows because you know them so certainly he knows them so they should have got boehmini they asked him who makes you feel no opinion I bet that's the question of the clock the answer of the slackers very original answer that the question the prettiest part of the question why is it part of the question because they quote the whole blessing on pity in a Ben Ishak edition of its race of it Savano al pity and I've been the father makes they're not just not trying to say the father makes it that splinter they're trying to bring in what he makes there's two ways of making a brothel amador al because actually the tournament's waste of its Yvonne will leave those have been or share the tournament exit with Silvano al pedina Beth just like with many brokers right when you put on tefillin she'll yard you say Lahani act philan a philan shiroishi say al mitzvahs tefillin beer comics you say I'll be your comments Lou love you say Alma Tillis lo love lightning Chanukah candles you say la had the commercial Kamaka chauffeur you say leash Maya culture fur not al schmears culture every broker has its unique genre how you say it says it's lark the text is al pedina Ben that's why they have a question because that's the budget because it's obvious that the father makes the brush and what's the brother I'll pretty in a bear not leave toys have been there for we have a question about Saffiano what's the connection so it's likes us to different ideas one idea is al we have a cloud Jairaj brings earlier on design from the river that any mixer you can do through Ashley off you say al any Mitch for they have to do yourself you sail it if you could do it through Ashley a few say al because the Mitzvah is not just on you the Mitzvah is you could do it also through somebody else and pity and I've been is one of those mitzvahs that you could do through Ashley the father can do it through Ashley and therefore you say alpide you not bend not live so therefore if you can do it through its Lea it means that sometimes the father won't be there because he could send Ashley and if he won't be there then if the chef he are no falls on him sometimes it's a Fiona won't be made because if you're doing it's very slick for somebody else you don't make a shelter y'know because chef Ianno is the joy that comes from december the midst oh you're not you're only Ashly if you're doing it for somebody else so the Brucker you make the broccoli you make but you don't make the chef Fiona because you don't have that simcha and therefore the father if the father is not there and he's the one who'll make sure he uh no so sometimes it's a no-no won't be made so therefore maybe the client should do it because the coin is always there because you can't have pity not been without a Cayenne the second soiree that slack says is that since it says al padena been our pig in our been means not lived i sub-n al so what's the owl so the slack says a second smaller and the second smaller is that the mitzvah is not just done through the father the mitzvah needs a partnership with the Calle I can do the mitts on my own if I'm a father I need the client that's why it's not a charity show impressive receive on the live noise because it's not like you just have go do it it's alpide in a band which represents there's more than one person that's necessary in order to get this done you must have the Cayenne so therefore since both of them do the mitzvah it's not just me I need you for the mitzvah as well but you also have Henault so maybe you should be the one making sure they don't know because I'm doing the midst of attack it's my midst so but I don't have an offer from it you're part of the Mitzvah and you're having I know so that's why you should make sure Fionna so this slash says that's why the Gemara that's why they said they said the cuz they wanted to put in the text of outbidding a Ben because that sets the stage for the second question of Saffiano they can't just start off who makes Saffiano the Korean or the father that's not a question of course the father mention it says Mitzvah once we said that the brush is al that means the coin is part of it that means there could be Ashley off now there's a good question who make sure you know even though the answer is talking to the father make sure he'll know the answers of the / explain that / says that they introduced the procedure in order to frame the question why would there be a logic for the client to make it right why would the be logic so kind to make it the answer is number one because since you could do it through Ashley arc so sometimes the father won't be then the father won't be there won't be a chef II don't know at all if you give the chef children to the father and the father is not there there won't be a chef you know give it to the client and there'll always be Acharya know that's the first thing or the second sweater that I explained because the coin is a partner in the Mitzvah the challenge with this flock as we said this it's a very good mark of art but there's a few problems the biggest problem is the text of the Gemara it's anticlimactic right when you read the game or the qumari says the broth copied in our band the father makes that's the highlight of cause like that's not the highlight it should have said Pritam by pleading I've been the father makes a bracha alpide you know Ben that's your point your point is not that the father makes the Barossa as we said that's the kshitij is the textile pigeon I've been so that's how the good mother should have said it number two the contrast of the two questions seems like the question is who makes it like Twitter here the father makes it here the question is who makes it you know according to that's laughs they're not parallel to each other number three he could have just said it simply not since the brokers out paid in a band so therefore we ask myself er no that's what he could have said it would have been much simpler since the broca's pig in a band keevon are picking up any self-pity in a band so the question is who make saffiano not I'm piggy in a band I shall internally learn are picking up and the father it's much more clumsy and and and very encumbering length encumbered language you can't ask the second question because you want to say the nusic of the Baraka right you want to say that the new suck of the brothers I'll patina Ben but he could have said sins by pity and I've been since my pigeon have been you make a Brock out pity in a ban or you can even say since my pigeon I've been the father makes a brush I'll put you in a band so the question is by Saffiano but do you see what's the language of the Gemara very different that by pitting a ban the broth is made by the father now the question is who should make sure Fiamma even more so as I mentioned when you look in the language of the rush who quotes this Gomorrah la ilaha the way he quotes the gamora's he says i'll pig in a band VII of Nevarez he takes away the whole text of the blessing he deletes the whole text cuz the facts are relevant here you see clearly how he's learning the Gemara I'm pigeon I've been for sure the father makes the Baraka he starts off ALP Indiana ban which he could also be including the text of the blessing I'll pigeon have been but he gets to the point opinion I've been for sure the father makes vada of Navarra now the question is who makes Jeffy all know if it's VAD day so you don't have to say it I'm saying I imagine you come over and a wedding to somebody and you say it's prettier than on the water you make schakal but he make on the rice if it's a fitness fit so don't say it especially he's Arab he knows what's there by you if it's fitted by you at the buyer so we're back to that question there's a safer called chance to traverse Hitomi shoeless Hitomi shoeless it's a very interesting safer it includes questions and answers by three people reply in Val Arjuna his son in laws name was your pillow and his son-in-law and a grandson whose name was rebel eaz it's hook freedom kind of illusion there was considered the great student to one of the greatest students of the gone and he founded a yeshiva in vulajin vulajin is a city in luther way nia and he founded the yeshiva and Velarde was also the rabbi of a lodge when he passed away his son took it over the pixel of a large and Arab it's koalas honor it's Allah that was his son he took over and when he passed away his son-in-law took over the yeshiva his name was rebellious a its hook freed this was a grandson of her crime allow Gena through his wife his wife his wife was a daughter of rebel of a large nur who was the son of a primal Arjuna he also had a son-in-law his name was a pillow and he was a bigger of so they brought they published a safer a great-grandson published a safe in Vilna called Hitomi Shoeless which means the triple triple thread shouts including mercilessness which has true verse of a primal Arjuna and his son-in-law and his grandson so I saw over there there was a Hydra nam Sock'em and he's Mikado's over there just to tell you how far how far this goes okay I hid there's give out they get finished in this story give out the resolution the story I'll quote you what he says quite fascinating but again very difficult to put it into the Gemara he says as follows the story of rips employee was a unique story what happened the father did not do a pity in our Ben he did not do a pinion I bet this story in this story yeah this safer Jota Michailidis is suggesting a finish in this story the father did not do a pity in our Beth the child passed away the baby what's the halacha the luck is that the father still has to do a pigeon I've been why because Spadina Ben is not just you should be able to take the baby home prisoner Ben is a mitzvah that you have to redeem the child conditionally called core pet the carafe come you have to redeem the trunk so the halacha is and my sector careerist is a Mishnah that if a child passes away after 30 days even though he did not do a pinion event he should now do a pinion unban the father gives the Cayenne 5 slime to redeem his son even though the son passed away already Romana looks like that's what the Mishnah and mastectomy iris DAF mem tests so toy service asks a question over there taste was Ashley his topic I have a question does the father still make a Chevy ah no then he makes a bra Kyle piggy in a Ben is not a question but does the Olson make a Chevy on why she make a Chevy uh no cuz zoophilic I am a mitzvah it's asked us to do a mitzvah it's a big source just who's for the father to screws for the Somoza son also wants the Mitzvah that's what Tyson is yesh this topic after the p'tee really after the potato yeah yeah yeah yeah fascinating toy service Oh so inshallah troopers caught on my shoulders the grandson of Roberta Brian vulajin Pemberley as he it's a tweet says and it's Adam so him he says the question of toy service is according to the halacha the halacha is that the father has to make most blessings are pretty Nibbana shishio no so toy service asks in this case does the father make the second blessing chef Ian or not and we can understand both sides decide to make it is because he's doing a mitzvah and it's a source to do a mitzvah it's a great simcha the door mitzvah for him and for a son decide not to make it we can also understand because it's it's bittersweet it's a very tragic situation he's redeeming a child who's in the goes gone who passed away already so there's a certain grief in the mitzvot he's redeeming his son there's always a grief because he lost the some especially now he's doing the myths of pigeon I've been without a baby you know the main the main was looking at the signatures not there he's been buried already obviously he passed away so he has to do the Mitzvah but it's not planted saffiano placement says yes lists topic a Suffolk that's according to the conclusion that the father is the one who makes both brokers so the question is does the father make the second Brock says the vulajin the Russia she follows and what happens if the conclusion here in the Gemara would be that the Korean makes the broker that the Korean makes sure he honor why cuz he gets the Hana with toys for Sava Suffolk does another Suffolk the Colleen is getting the money okay we're not talking that he's enjoying the fact obviously the claim is a male let's hope that the claim is a mentos is not only a Korean but it's a different level of course ah he got the money he got no obviously there's a certain element of empathy every Jew has for another Jew but just like if a person builds a new house they make a shitty ah no a person buys new calum they make a Saffiano even if that day something transfers all them happen to somebody else that's true but life moves on right you just give it to the kyon that you give to the client yeah yeah yeah yeah because when you have a curb bahama it's basically you're not redeeming it from the kyon you give it to the client and the client does with it whatever he can do if it's a ball mum he shafts it and eats it if it's a Tom he brings into the based on my condition brings it as a carbon if it's dead right it's died but it belongs to the client he could sell it to a guy right the only pigeon buyer behaviour pettish am i right the donkey which you exchange with a sheep you exchanged with a sheep so this is unique by a child you don't give you a child away to the client yeah nobody ever said by a pigeon I've been you know what keep it I'm gonna keep the money you keep the child there's a mitzvah to be paid to the Ben so the vulajin in Russia Shiva says if the coin would be the one to make sure he honor then then he would make sure she honor even in such a case ptosis wouldn't have a Suffolk so he says that that's the story here that's what happened it wasn't a regular pity number it was a pig in a Ben we're rock monoliths long the child wasn't there so they said who should make sure theano the father should make or the Korean should make that's why there was a question usually wouldn't be a question but because this situation they asked who should make the father with a client the father cuz he's doing a mitzvah the Cohen cuz he's having her know why would that be more powerful than a mitzvah why would that be more powerful than the Mitzvah would be more powerful than Mitzvah because the father is also mourning so maybe give it to the Cayenne that's he says that's what happened at the story that's the story so the conclusion was the father huh in other words you're right so you're asking the Shila Lloyd of a large know why the slices have a Suffolk if this is trapped in the Gemara they told them that via Ben makes both right a be very good very good problem very good question wise dear Suffolk why starving or suffering and also it's so difficult to put this in the gamora's like in fact they be mcalary's at the painting that been there was no trial here I think it's an interesting in dish but like you got a hint to such a thing like he came to pity in a band a there was no boy there it's abstract hitters but that's how he wants to explain what the dilemma was the harm in is that it's a source to do a mitzvah you're right I know in other words listen man I said that I can do a mitzvah no they know that the day that I'm doing the myth so whenever the day just like a baby Hospital amou passes away right just like a bris just like a bris also they do it they do it because it's still his child it's still his child he has to redeem his child from the client yeah he didn't do it in the right time or the door a week late and he didn't do a pigeon have been whether he didn't do what he forgot there was no Cayenne he didn't have money whatever the situation was oh but that's but there is the quite next question a deeper question I ask you a question every time you get five dollars or $18 in maker Saffiano you know maker Saffiano on every hand ah I'm asked you a question in fact client him get a lot of stuff they don't make a shot Ianno why not every time do you get something somebody make brings me a cup of coffee yeah even if it's not every day every day I in this damage even if you get if somebody gives you a gift you don't make a shocker you know you buy a new house you make a shower you know that yeah that's true you buy a new house cuz that's a very big thing you're entering into a new home you don't do it every week right or Becket's Hodder's today stocking not a big deal but in the olden days you bought a new garment that was a very big thing today you know it's not I mean look again because of the affluence today but it was a big thing so people sometimes wore the same bag at the same two garments you see cause I'll speak about two garments for weekdays with rhombus for vous long it was it was not like today's you got a new beggars Posada was like a wedding gown I was like this try mala you made Asha here because I what and made pad made a patch for the wedding yeah it took the old Capote made a new patch yeah so it's not that the kyon got five slow Yin which is I don't know today $30 $40 $50 whenever the number is between 40 and 80 dollars somewhere there that you need you make a Shahi oh no it's because the Hana is coming from a mitzvah the nurse coming from the mitzvah it's not stahma ha no you gave me $20 $50 fine it could be it could be but it's not a mitzvah that's very regular it's a rear midst and there's also other kyon and remember he's not the only coin in the shtetl yeah so since it's on now that comes from a mitzvah so the Mitzvah gives shivers to the hognose not a regular 5s lawyer it's a mitzvah Ditka five slam it's like a unique five slam we have an expression that has our asura app survey or mitzvahs are actually the Easter may exhibit a car service the Mitzvah gives it a fresh service the Mitzvah gives down it's not a regular not it's a unique type of unlock it's a mitzvah Takano it's the mitzvah of the father there's a mitzvah opinion event then it comes out ah the fathers are now as the Mitzvah is saying I'm sorry what so even the Chevy y'all know over the Cayenne according to the half of the Commission it's not so much that he onofre know that he's getting money it's the Hanaa that's connected to the Mitzvah that's happening so when toys who says yes lease topic if we should make sure fee on Oh in this case so the vulajin Arusha she very basically as a free the grand center of crime says but if the chorion would make it then of course he should make a you should make aa I because ma TR nollie all day because he's still getting down ah but it's not a regular nod this is I know that's coming from the mitzvah from whose mitzvah the father's Mitzvah why is there a Suffolk yeah I'll share with you another mahalik in the Gemara if a coin has a son he does enough to do pinion could be part of it yeah could be part of it yeah yeah there was once a co-op saw him that the Lubavitch had ever made out of her bring in your elephant isn't option cough BAE's 1962 before Pesach and he asked all the questions on that slack he brought to the footnote a kind of illusion as expletive kinda vulajin explanation some sofas explanation there's another Pella here another another very interesting question and that is how it comes in here to be Sock'em how does this story come in here miss activist awesome the last mission speaks about the Brock of the pace of the Brock of the car Giga bish mall says the Brock of the pace of exempt the kagiri Makeba says it doesn't and then suddenly rips my came to patina ban what's the connection so the rash bomb says the connection is because since we're talking about earlier if one person has two mitzvahs can he make one brush or does he have to make two brokers so the question is by a pity not been does the father have to make one bra for to Broca's but seems like a little bit of a difficult difficult question since the question is if I make a Brock on Pesach on my yoga gig or I have to make a separate Brock Allegra be a keeper says it's aggressions my pity in a band do I have to make both brushes so I only make one Brock on the claim makes a second bro that's what the rush bomb says the connections because josh Brom is looking for some type of connection to the Gemara how does it come in here something has to be when I told my painting I've been we're not talking about Saffiano when I talk about the father of the car you and we're not talking about the midst of opinion about we're talking about carbon paces the brush basically a Giga we spoke about sprinkling the blood throwing the blood pouring the blood swishes Rica will come in picking up an even there are bombs answer I told you the reef in the rush they take out to every Gomorrah all the helices and they set it up biologically they take out from every miss after the how lock and they put it in the right miss after we should have this bin and the reef in the rush of miss after Pyrus but this they keeping miss octopus Arkham this means that they believe that it was connected to miss active Sock'em so here's the Charter Mahalo of the lubavitcher rebbe Chattanooga Mara which very very good schmuck of art and the shot of the Gemara he said if you read the Gemara carefully slowly you'll see exactly what happened in the story because when you think about pity in a band you could think about it in two separate ways let's understand this when you the midst of pity and I bent you can understand in two different ways pity and I been happens through a partnership through a trio there's three people involved there's the father there's the son of course if there's no Sun there's nobody to redeem and there's the coil if you're missing one you can't have a pity in a bend 30 day old boy can't do pity in a bent himself he's a baby he needs the father or somebody representing the father there's the child if there's no child there's no Mitzvah opinion I meant and there's of course the Cayenne now the Cayenne is not the one who's obligated to do a pigeon have been the coin got to show up to take the money I'm a coin I'm not obligated to redeem your child doesn't say in the trailer you're the car you have to do the Pythian no you have to you have to come take the money for the pigeon yeah I'm part of the Mitzvah but I'm not the coin is not obligated do this Mitzvah the coin is a part of the Mitzvah the coin is a tonigh in the Mitzvah the coin is a hey look in the Mitzvah who is the obligation on the father but the rebus said you could touch pretty and I've been in very different ways one way of learning piggy and I've been is it's a mitzvah on the boy Hashem gives a mitzvah on the boy you were born in Europe where you have to be redeemed a problem is you can't give a mitzvah to a 30 year old 30 day old baby you can give a mitzvah to an adult not to a baby so therefore the Torah obligates the father as the representative of his child since I'm your father I'm responsible for you huh I'm responsible for you so your responsibility is transferred as conferred upon me as your representative that's the Mitzvah in other words I'm doing the Mitzvah on my child of course it's a mitzvah on me the Toyota tells the father redeem your child but well as what as a representative of your son he can't do it himself you have to do it huh on behalf I'm working on behalf of my trial that's one way you could look at it or you could say no that's not a shot the Mitzvah is on the father the Mitzvah and the father to go redeem the child he said it's an interesting thing if you look in town with Bava lien you look in town Madeira Xiaomi they both have a halakhah with different sources what happens if I didn't redeem my son I was a bad boy I was a bad patty I did not do a pity hug then my boy grows up right and he finds out no pity no bet what happens now he has to do it he can't say it was my father's problem he has to do it but how do you know this so it's interesting that in town with Bob Lee and Tommy Jewish telling me there's two different sources for this Holika in town with ba Valley the sources and Talmud Bavli the sources it says in parsha skywrath lush Natasha's Clara they're Amish thank you very much and parsha scared of the lotion is this is a gomorian condition very cute a test evolve a pod they received their espera Adam redeem shall you redeem the boy says twice why pod they saved it twice so the Gemara says if you don't redeem you Sonny has to redeem himself pod they save desperado that's a partial carrier and you shall me the source is because it says impartial boy many of us say it every day in in a Bennett Thomasville and a rash east villain what's the lotion it says the whole coil are done before negative de every part of a person of your children you should redeem what's the hope card um deployed is a person what is not an animal since we hope hurt other than when activity means you should redeem every part of your children but then it says Adam he himself Oh starts to redeem himself two different sources why are the two different sources because there's two ways of how to learn to Mitzvah one is it's a mitzvah on the child and the father is working on behalf of the child and one is no it's like a pillow Mitzvah on the father if the father didn't do it then the child has to do it but it's a whole different idea if you say the first iPhone it's a mitzvah on the child I'm just working for you because you're a baby the terrorist says until he grows up he needs somebody represent him the moment he grows up it's his Mitzvah now he doesn't need you to represent him or you say no the mitzvahs like a pill on the father it's a mitzvah me that I'm it's for my child however there's a special Lynwood when my child grows up he now also has a mitzvah he can't say it's all my father's not all your father see father when you grow up you also have the myths now ah very good what happens when he grows up and they both want to do the myths good we'll get there in a moment very good that's that's gonna be the big laugh come in there when he's a goggle when he's a goggle for sure but this lease is not the one was believe in the mitzvah you can make anybody actually if he can make you father or some of the questions who's Muslim in the Mitzvah now the positive hope heard of them before negative de that's the source in your shall me over there the Russian is that the father is the one who has to be ponder the hope heard of them before negativity and partial credit you just says positive desperate Adam doesn't say who says you have to redeem in parishes boy it's a connection to UCSF Australian kingship Irish am killed every part alkane coke carbon i evident in purchase credits is just part of madness Kahuna it's not connected to micros Reuters it's one of madness corner one of the gifts you have to give to the Chi in him why is there this difference between widow we're to learn it why do you Rachelle me you learn it from the same parsec where you learn that the person has to redeem his son hope heart are them beaver negative EDA in other words in the original Mitzvah of Indiana Banja both obligations together I have to redeem my son and my son has to redeem himself in other words the midst is a mitzvah on the child the child can do it I do it when he's an autumn he does it himself when he's a cotton I do it on his behalf cuz he can't do it on his own in the bhava Lee the hwacha that he has to redeem himself is learning from a second passing by madness Kahuna not part of the source of pity not been with his hidden on the father because the fume of the Sun is not connected to the father it's a separate limit that even if I didn't do it when the son grows up he hasn't Mitzvah mother's really it's my obligation it's not my obligation it's not my son's obligation when he grows up it's not shot that I lost my Mitzvah I didn't lose my Mitzvah I have to do it however a son is must live in all the mitzvahs one of them is that if I didn't do it though I don't want to do it he has to do it now so now let's understand this well my enough come in who cares whose Mitzvah is very simple my boy grows up I didn't do a pigeon I've been for him I become a ball Shula I become about 200 so what you have a mix of pigeon I've been I say my boy come my 20 year old come we're doing a pigeon a man he says who's making the brokers out making the broker check in the Sun excuse me why are you making its my pigeon I'm making the broker who wins ah the boy wins how do you know how do you know depends how you learn if you learn that the Mitzvah is on the boy it's just when he's a baby I work on his behalf now he's not a baby anymore he doesn't need a representative I mean if he wants to appoint you as Ashley a fine but it's his but how do you learn it you could learn the Turner told the father because the boy can't do it so you're working on his behalf you're like the toilet puts you in like you're his upper troopers you represent him i it's my mommy you right it's my money because no no we want a bit to when he's 30 when he's 30 days how do you know maybe it's a mitzvah on the child but Exim and the father is obligated to represent the child and therefore when he grows up you don't need a representative it's your Mitzvah so you come to the Cayenne it's your Mitzvah the father's I want to do the Mitzvah it's very nice of you Tati but I'm an adult just like with everything else or or you say no all you say it's my Mitzvah there was always one which it remains my matter that was never taken away from me I have a mitzvah to redeem you if I don't want to do it the Turner says you do it if there's if the father doesn't want to go the son has to do it that's true and I made a mistake I didn't do it right yeah so you would say just like when he's a baby the father does it on his behalf so would be an interesting situation that after the Patera the father would also do it on his behalf yeah cuz that's cuz best in asaro you for cloud you straw but it's not a Mitzvah on them yeah yeah yeah yeah no well Basden always has a responsibility to try to help people do mitzvahs but it's still a mitzvah individual yeah of course we means of amou means if he's alive he has the mitzvah oh so that's the difference in Tom Madhura Xiaomi the Mitzvah that the boy can do it is a separate pasta can carry rock years after the midst of pedina Ben it's not even doesn't even mention the source of patina Ben you'd see us miss Raymond marques Paris it's a separate in a spa date if they're with the fathers not even mentioned we learned pod they live there it's a mitzvah on you that's according to the you shall me according to the bhava Li I'm sorry that's according to the URIs to the bhava Li according to the euro shall me it's right in Paris boy behold Adam Belvoir negative either in the first original Mitzvah redeem your father and if you're a person you redeem yourself the same exact verse as a connection to Marcus quite is right there you already know that the child has to redeem himself why because dear Asami old it's a mitzvah on the boy and the boy can do it the father got to do it then when the boy can do what the boy doesn't and anubhava Lee it's not that way it's a mitzvah and the father it's just now look at the story rip similarly looking in the gamar you'll see your boy comes to pity in a bed they say to him our pit in a band a shaker deshaun room it's waste of encephalopathy Nibbana via Ben maverick it's by them it was simple that when it comes to pinion our band the brother I record this shot of the trace of its Yvonne knew he commanded us who makes the grass Ivy I bent and the way he said the Gomorrah doesn't give a time limit when our via Ben makes it a Viet Minh always makes it meaning a via been before if even if the boy is forty years old he still makes the broke up again I've been why cause it's his Mitzvah he's the one who make section of the channel is receive on our page in our bed IV I been the words the father always makes the brush up written I've been always when these three days old and when he's 30 years old cuz it's a mitzvah on him nobody ever takes away that mitzvah from me true if I don't want to do it my boy has to do it we have a special limo that there's also another person it would be like a guarantor so to speak if I have a loan I have to pay you back right I may have oh so somebody right on our eighth who says okay if the guy defaults come to me but it doesn't mean I don't have to pay back my loan there is a type of guarantor we could send the person like a pillar to the guarantor but I'm talking about a lot of people do that but I'm talking about a regular loan if I don't do it my son has to do it that's true as an adult cuz he's an adult but the Mitzvahs on me so if I want to do it I make the brush and Childress is run up here don't see it's a brothel of a taller not a brothel about our avea been Navarre ah that was the sitter if that's the case now we have a question when it comes to chef Lior know since the cube is always on the father always a via been maverick always even after he's an adult the father still says I should do the Shawna Mehmet slice of its Yvonne ooh it's a mitzvah me you can't say a Brock Jim this one who I'm doing a bed of my son it's a broccoli patola you don't have such a mitzvah the fact that I'm a father and I make the broth even when you're an adult means that it's my Mitzvah so then they have a question on saffiano why if the Mitzvah was on the son not on the father then they wouldn't have a question on saffiano you know why they wouldnt have a question I don't know let's think about this I'm Ashley f for my child it's not my Mitzvah saddlemaker saffiano if I send you to do a mitzvah for me right as Ashley R you never make a chef Riano Ashley F never makes a chef you know why cuz what's a saffiano for saffiano is you doing a mitzvah that you're abla gated in once in a while it's a big simcha but if you're the SH Li if you're not obligated you're just doing it on my behalf so the broker you make but check the owner you can't make because the chef Ian who is coming from the simply you're excited to come on even a little but you're working for me it's not your bit slow so if the father was working as Ashley F for his son so then it's not his Mitzvah whose mitzvahs it it's his son's Mitzvah it's just his son can't do the Mitzvah if that's case it wouldn't be a shailu who makes saffiano of course the car you should make the brush a fee owner you know why because the kyon matthean Ollie are they the coin as an enjoyment Saffiano became on of the journalism a miser I have a no I the father is doing the pity and a ban he's doing for him for his son the Mitzvah of a song that's what they said oh since its portion that IV have been memory not like that / that it's Altadena been no ivory I been before the father always makes the brush even as an adult in other words it's his Mitzvah ah if it's his Mitzvah he's talking about getting mummy but he's doing a mitzvah so maybe now it's not so partial that the client should make it if you would say it's the songs Mitzvah so the father is really only like her the father's mr. hot in herre the father is just the guy who's who's acting on behalf he's like what's the word for it in law when you were he's like a power of attorney he's not the guy I mean he's the guy but it's a power of attorney that's what he is it's not his Mitzvah but if you say I ve been Navarre he's talked him out getting money he's giving money but he's doing a mitzvah he's doing his Mitzvah for are I even in 30 years he's gonna have to say the brush up he didn't I've been even if his son is an adult cause it's his Mitzvah even though there's our Walker than if he doesn't do it his son doesn't son has a Mitzvah but it doesn't take away from the father's Mitzvah so now they have a question without the peshitta they wouldn't have a question that the Quarian makes sure he on rule but because it's persisted that it's the father's Mitzvah so then he should make sure he on or maybe you say no the kyon gets the Hanwha now you can ask a question let them both saffiano let them both say Saffiano what do you care but the truth is the truth is they can't make most of you on the why because as we explained Saffiano you're not making for the Honora for just having money getting money you make you Saffiano because I know that comes from Mitzvah which mitzvah what's the Mitzvah the Mitzvah is a mitzvah of padeen have been the Mitzvah gives the Honora special prominence if the father is making chef Ianno why is he making Shahi oh no for the Mitzvah itself now you want the Korean to make sure he or no for the ha no that's Tuffle to the Mitzvah that wouldn't work the father's making Shahi oh no for the myths of itself the coin is making sure here not for her not stam he got money it's for the Honora that came with the Mitzvah it's subservient to the Mitzvah so there wouldn't be a separate Ruggiano for that the me rewrites the coin can't make sure he uh no because he's taken away from other chi annum by me getting the money you're not getting the money so she uh no for me and it's a loss for you that's who the meat he writes the rajma rights you don't have to people making sure she uh no for the same thing you have to understand why not according to this we can understand here because the Shakya know of the coin would be a subservient saffiano to the father Saffiano he's making shishio no for the Hanwha which is thoughtful to the mitzvah so it's wrong to make a Saffiano for the part that's thoughtful to the Mitzvah cuz he made sure he honor for the midst of itself so why is he making chef Leon for the ha na aana no you don't make a Saffiano unless it's a huge honour lmia making on the Hanwha because it became part of a mitzvah but i already made on the midst of itself so it's much more encompassing you don't make sure he unwound this yeah that's very good that's the vert that's the Pitta very good if the father was just the guardian then they wouldn't have a question to make sure he all know for sure the coins with make Saffiano but since avi have been Mavericks always oh now we should make sure he oh no this answers a give out the cavort that slaps explanation was beautiful why ow but according to that /script similar he went to them and what did they tell him a via Ben maverick stallion we never asked about two we asked about Saffiano it's like again you don't know what to make on rice you go to the base Madras yeah and they say oh I'm coffee Chicago and I write I never asked you why have you been the varnish time of year been maverick chef llamo the hook is salvia been the varsity on the first bracha was not on the question why are you answering the second about this first brother when we never asked about it the answer is now we understand beautifully that was their answer their answer is a via been maverick style the same reason that he's making our pity not been is the same reason he's making chef you know if they wouldn't say ivory I've been divorced I am you could say why doesn't the Korean make sure he uh no maybe the Hanoi is not enough maybe there's another reason why it doesn't make sure here you know maybe the different reasons he doesn't make chef you know maybe you know acarya doesn't make another madness corner when you give a current roommate doesn't make sure he uh know when you give a car in when a lady gives him through miss my sir the pastor's on the easter altogether but but pedina been out but that Spadina been oh she doesn't have a mitzvah but you could say the coin is a hey look of the Mitzvahed now in the mitzvah dim in the mitzvah however you title so you could see these different reasons the coin doesn't make sure he on maybe it's not enough of an AA they want to negate all of this they want to say you know why here's an extra here cuz i via been mavericks tie him in other words it's one reason for both charles like the father makes pity not been why does he make padena been why because it's his Mitzvah the main mitzvah is not that he's doing it for his son it's a mitzvah on him and that's why even when his son is obligated he still makes the broker the same reason he makes sure he uh no cause it's hizmet's and he gets to do a give all the commits were once in a lifetime she makes a chef you know i this the the coin is getting down ah okay the coin is getting that naga valdek just like just like if the son as an adult the dick son is also getting a ha but the father makes the bro why doesn't this son make the shishio no save art don't think the claim doesn't make the Saffiano very good question because it's the father's Mitzvah that's why they say sty him not a via Ben maverick Saffiano a via been divorced I am because together why he makes sure he all new is the same gether why he makes up it in a man always cuz it's his Mitzvah that's why there's the hostess a via been maverick the stallion brings out the answer why he and not the Korean make sure they all know know if it's a mitzvah on the sunny as dunno if it's a mitzvah on the father he is down not if I'll be just like the claim gets the money everybody gets benefits here the son gets a benefit and the Korean gets a benefit everybody gets a benefit but who's doing the Mitzvah who's the kiddush none of them it's waste of it see one of the father ah I guess spiritually I bizarre a bizarre II it's clear whites at the end of soccer because entire box of how does the might the sipper of ETS messiaen finish if you go to Paris boy literally perishes by how does it end your father your son is gonna ask you tomorrow why are you doing all this and you're gonna tell them Hashem killed every prayer Barrett's Masai Mara alkane and needs a vehicle a sham called bethere a thermal scan of a cop car but I have their God killed all their pride him he redeemed all our Claridon so that's what I'm doing every prayer that I have is holy and I so to speak we demon for my show this is high or low selfie because that's alteration because of NZT as messiah so turkish about that his massage tips awesome you go through a homeless sex the sock him how does the end he ends with the same it's repeating i been because what's the result of UTS what's Ryan what's the Mitzvah that was born directly out of ETS which I'm directly all the mitzvahs are connected easiest Misamis a shirley chisholm is Ryan because they're all ultimately connected to us going out of MIT sign but which Mitzvah directly commemorates what happened my atheist mister only one Mitzvah and that is pitting up core so just can't Arabic South the fee of of pedina ban is because of you TSM simen that's how it ends so in miss octopus Arkham which the main idea of miss after obstruction as easy as much time in the word Pesach is what's Pesach soccer that he jumped over the homes of the Jewish people when he killed all their elders and he redeemed the Jewish craters but a new hit sill our brightest our homes he saved that's the reason for padena been so therefore that's the end that's the masu Verve that's the that's the summation of my second absorption the myths of patina been but it's more than that it's more than that because some sofas of art and one of us are intruders he says we say but he keeps your Irish volcano by era gosh M Colbert's I'm currently Bama alkane and me surveyor Hashem capital Alchemist quorum for hob harbor naive de alkane Annie he says what's the what's the alkane Annie what's the okay Nonnie says what's an e alkane that's why we do it so he says as follows interesting worth finding our ban you can do through ash Lea like we said al you say how could you do you don't do it yourself he says but yet most fathers will not appoint Ashley oh they'll always try to do with themselves and he says depart when they had a pair of animal they used to go and check to themselves cuz she took shader bizarre a coin doesn't have to do yeah she says why did people do them okay not me I'm doing it Nicole Carter been out there since the reason is cuz Viagra gosh I'm cold car says an evil Ashley ax Hashem didn't send the Slayer he did it himself he did it himself so they fall cane on me I also want to do with myself even though God could also send to sleep but he didn't like we say in the Haggadah Annie I did it myself it's a nice mmm it's I'm Leah - Leah Clare they sort of before they bats my that's why I want to do with myself that's what he says I'll k-9 is a ver clash' but here we have then the CUDA of why the father has to make sure Fiona how would the kratom saved because I shall leapt over their homes he himself took out the Jewish people from its Ryan he acted like a father who saved his child Bini Bukhari is wrong first thing when she tells Perry's Bini Bihari is wrong the Jewish people are my prior so Hashem saved the player so therefore what's the Mitzvah is the Mitzvah on the father on the child the Mitzvah is on the father the whole Mitzvah comes from because God took care of his children he redeemed his children he liberated his children that's the connections of Sock'em so on the end of suction what's the story the story is it's a mitzvah and the father Thummim it's found the child the father did does it today like the father did it then like our Father in heaven did it then so it's printed that the father makes the broker if he makes the broker it's because it's his Mitzvah even when the boy is an adult he makes the broker therefore we have a question I don't know and therefore we say he also makes stuff we don't know cuz it says Mitzvah this is not breakfast and I mean this is breakfast a mitzvos know over there was business omits verse also professor peso has the Mitzvah the end of boy dilemma much the end of boy the last circular patches boy no no the end of parsha cts material the last piece of how Yuki Bianca is about pity in a band that's our parshas by ends the have one of the gomorrah how you learn pity not been what was the cheetah the question is how you define pity and Ibanez and amid so on the Sonora Mitsu on the Father so the Pritchett is that it's a mitzvah on the father so therefore there's a shine launched ok or no if not there wouldn't be a Cylon shall hear no and that's why they had to bring the pre and that's why they answer stymie and that's why it comes at the end of soccer your typhus huh Lloyd - you shall meet occur the Mitzvah is on the son but then the bhava we the Mitzvah is on the father its projected that it's the father and that's they have to say it since the Mitzvah is on the father the question is who makes check me out of the midst was on the Sunda wouldn't be on Shila that the coin should make sure if he on would since it's a mitzvah on the father does a shy and the answer is that the father makes why because Navarro's tie him just like he makes the first brush up it in a pan because it's his Mitzvah even if the son is an adult he still makes up agin a ban because it's his Mitzvah and therefore when the Sun is a baby he makes the shower you know cause it's his Mitzvah even though the coin gets on law but the coins are no can't be more important in his Mitzvah the coins are now is coming from his Mitzvah so his Mitzvah Trump's d'Arnaud of the client if the father is not around then we have a special limit positive that the son is mostly have to redeem himself still everyone holds the son has to redeem himself the question is whose Mitzvah is it when the son is an adult if the father wants to do it can he do it or he can't let's say the son is an adult the father's I want to do the Mitzvah I want to give the coin in the money I want him do the myths I want to make the brother can the son say sorry too late you woke up too late so we're saying that we say the Bible he says Peter that it's the father does it tomorrow we're gonna start bearish and a few dollars I'm at Olive the suger Ripken inna is gone a K&M which is the whole the main sugan shots of tumour and Tara have a wonderful day