Pesachim 120b-2 - The Chidush of the Avnei Nazer in Karban Pesach

the yeshiva dotnet daf cough cough I'm a days we are up to one two three four five six seven eight nine ten eleven eleven lines from the top her pacifier cat-sized Mikami aasaiya diam majuli okay let's remember what did the mission to say the Mishnah was divided into two sections the first section was about people who fall asleep which we discussed yesterday people who fall asleep in a group if some of them are still awake or none of them are awake and the story of abaya watching robber fall asleep and their conversation subsequently after that the mission is said are different in that pacer after hotsauce matam is ayodhya that the carbon pacer once midnight hits contaminates the hands and the mission continued piggle and no sir also contaminate the hands what does this mean what this means is as we explained in the Mishnah that the hakama made a special Khazaria that when you have a carbon and you leave it over after the prescribed time when you're allowed to eat it which is called noiser and you have to burn it so if i touch it at that point it's Mikami maya diam even though it's not Tommy it's not Tommy food it's regular food it's holy food that was left over but it's going to be me Tommy Maya died him and now my hands have a status of tumor it's called a chenille automa which is a second level of tumor and as a result of that if I will now torture uma drummer food the tremor will become puzzle the calm will not allow to be eat it let's say a coin has bread which comes from Truman I touched that bread now after I touched an oyster so my hands now transferred the tumor to the the tumor to the trauma if the Truman touches a carbon now the carbon is possible to eat it has to be burnt so this is a very serious Gazzara the Gemara is gonna discuss the reason for this is ater why they were so serious about this thank you so much but that's the point no sir Mehta me and I'm and pickle is my Tamiya damn pickle is another form of a carbon which becomes disqualified to eat not because it was left over but because of the macho voice of the kyon while he did the Veda when he slaughtered it or he received the blood or he sprinkled the blood or he led the blood from the cheetah to the MS baya cheetah Cabala Lucas Rica and he had a merkava that disqualifies the carbon and it's called tingle that meat will also contaminate dance what's the finish of this mission er that by Pesach it happens after cuts ice the moment midnight hits the night of pace of the night of the say there afterwards if I touch the curb basic on the table and I touch it it's Mikami I say a dime it's Mohammed the hands that's what the mission is said and the Gemara is now going to elaborate on this Halak in the Mishnah dr. Gomorrah pays a Catholic such as me Tomas iodine holy everybody has it you see of Kaufman base Alma what do we see from here we see from here I give all that you finish about carbon paisa and what's this hidden my saw is heavily no sir from here we see that our Mishnah holds that from cuts ice Pesach midnight the carbon paste becomes nicer in other words from that moment it's considered leftover meat that you're now letting eat anymore yeah and it has the status of noise sir that's a Kaval decay finish that since you're now let heat it anymore after car toys what's nicer nice - means it's left over after the time prescribed to eat so that means we learn from here that the time till which you can eat the carbon base of his midnight which doesn't exist by any other carbon every other carbon is either that day and the night afterwards or sometimes that day the night afterwards and the next day we say every morning there's carbon is that you can eat yo in Valhalla this carbon is you can eat snail member Lila echoed in the morning before before I be a small Lima but the finish by Pesach is that once you know let me eat it any more minute later and since you know that eat it minute area anymore so therefore it has a status of noiser because it has a status of noise sir it's Mikami it contaminates your hands not the rest of the body just your hands because Thomas a dime is a tumor Madeira bond on a terminal area will always spread to the whole body but a to Madeira Bonin could be sometimes only on the hands not on the rest of the body and the hands become a shame ela Toma so Alma we see from it that make up so he's heavily nicer that the pace that becomes nicer at cut size that you now let eat it any more minute right and therefore it's muhammediye damn that's what we learned from this mission because if not it wouldn't be the time of the a dime because the only thing that's retama the a dime is nicer and piggle it's not pickle so certainly noise Freddie did your mother Montana who is the town of The Tortoise the Tanner says this in our Mishnah but this is a big problem and the reason it's a big problem you know what are they more commercial no Byron because the posit is now guys I'm gonna analyze sukham will be much easier if we have that if we have the circum will be easier to understand you have a commercial ready okay anybody else has a hamish if you have a so much Trent Apaches boy they'll become much clearer when we have the circum in front of us okay there's moisture base yet okay please turn please turn to page 182 in these blue so mushroom the art scroll blue so mushroom its page 182 its parshas boy pay reviewed base Exodus chapter 12 okay page 182 right column on the top you see pager conveys podcast I'm gonna read faster you just get that point he's talking about the carbon pacer Vash Lewis a bus of a Lila has arts liege yamato summer area music look right now remember the COS i'll have this text to deal with that's what they're dealing with this is the source so just remember that eat this meatball allah azza wajal allah huzzah on this night on this night now was mean on this night which night so for that turn back one page look at possitive of valhalla Hamlisch marries a durbar uh sorry I'm afraid it says their fish of the ways that called Kalidasa so been are buying you had to take this sheep or the lamb the sheep or the goat on the tenth day of the month watch it till the fourteenth day of the month checked it on the fourteenth of the month put its blood on the door on the top of the door and the two temples and two sides for us Lewis Abbas about Lila as I was balajl Isaiah if you slaughtered on the 14th of they it would mean that night and this night meaning the night of tests of of the night after your dollar the night of Pesach eat the meatball islets liege omatsu summer aramaic slow roasted and fire together with mopsa sand morrow you should eat it I'll tell him I don't know bottom of a shoe bomb I am Kim Silesia chakra Bell Cuba there's no cooking it has to be roasted on fire the whole thing the head with the with the knees with the intestines persecute but I say see Rumi Meno add Baker don't leave over from it until the morning van noise in the Meno add boiled cabbage to sorry for anything that's left over from it till the morning you shall burn in fire and then he goes across a total oh I say let me tell you how to eat it you have to eat it when you're ready to leave must make some Kagura in your shoes on your feet your stick in your hands back ultimate submissive pose and eat it with haste passer hula Shem you'd bays variety Barrett's mitzrayim ballet la raza I'm gonna pass Egypt on this night the same night vkc called query Barrett's Masai madam edema I'm gonna smite every first born male in Egypt whether it's humans or animals the gods of mitzrayim I'm going to destroy and the dam will be on the homes I'm going to pass over your homes right and Posse Kedavra oh yeah yeah my Zelda summons a karmic Sun goes to my straggler some there is sacrum this day should be remembered it should be the holiday this is the text that describes the mitzvah of carbon pace of the first time around how to slaughter it how to prepare it when to eat it how to eat it clearly there's a prescribed time here eat it on this night lo se serum Noi biker don't leave it over till the morning and if you leave it till the morning then you burning in fire comes our Mishnah and introduces a new thing midnight at midnight it's nicer how did that happen that's why he says Montana who is the Tanner that invented or deduced this type of idea that my hot sauce it becomes nicer in the PAS circuit clearly says in your voice a serum ameno ad Baker the Hanoi sir and welcome is destroy fool boy care is not a choice Boyka always means morning now cup so it's not midnight Montana who is the Tanner who says this oh uh uh interesting question what do we see from here from this mission er that all night after that says you now let it eat it minute IRA because you're calling it no sir if you would tell me that the rabbi's don't let you eat it after cut sighs I have no problem but you're not saying that in the Mishnah you're saying that's Mikami the Italian doesn't mean you're now on eat it it means that it becomes nicer in other words let's understand what this means the how come and made a famous Gazzara on all car bonus that the time limit is the day you bring it and the night afterwards they made a famous tikona we have it in the first mission of shots my sector broca's you remember the story there the Trojan of RAM Gamliel came from a party from a wedding they told their father we didn't read Korea schmatta night what should we do it was already late at night or before morning what did he say he said if it's not dawn break yet your maklouf to do Karishma but i'm Gamliel says in the mission Krrish Maz are kathoys till midnight and this was after midnight so what animal you'll say I'm Leo said that everything that the Mitzvah still don't break the hakam him said do it by midnight because they were afraid that if you let a person do it till dawn break he may miss the time you know it's 9 o'clock in the evening you're exhausted you'll take a nap and then you'll miss the time so they said do it till cup-size you didn't but you still have to do creation I'm an operator and then he continues column s : Ascot mitzvahs on actually a llama the chakra in que la marmora Hamid Karzai's logic Ottoman Ave all the carbon is that you're allowed to eat the day you bring it and the night after really you could eat it a whole night till the morning the condom made a limit don't eat it after midnight why because they were afraid they wanted to they wanted the person they created a fence they created a you know to protect you from a hazard that's only an instrument there are born on la jolla cardamon Avera they were afraid that let's say even if you don't if you know even if you don't sleep through let's say our sasha car is 358 ok mister yeah and today we have clocks it's easier right you're eating your carbon it's 3:30 in the morning because you still have 25 minutes right and what if you eat at one minute late it's nice it's a it's a chorus so it made sense for the coming to push it back a few hours so even if you make a mistake and you eat at 12:10 instead of 12 o'clock you weren't over done it is Sakura so it makes a lot of sense because if they let you eat until the last minute people make mistakes they make mistakes either they rely to eat it later and then they missed the time or they were eating it but they made a mistake in the time and they either too late so they made at econo to eat it only till cuts ice right right right under few days if people make mistakes by now or people make mistakes by two hours but that's exactly the point so they made a blanket rule till cuts ice and you're good that way you'll never get into problems because you won't need it after 12:00 midnight and even if you make a mistake by a few minutes you're still not gonna be over on a circus but this doesn't make it nicer this doesn't make the food nicer that you have to burn that's not the passat and therefore it's not gonna be in the time of your hands until the morning but our Mishna says that paste assessment Tommy the hands biceps ice that mission doesn't seem to stop eating the pace of my cut size it says it's about time of your hands in other words our mission holds that the Pacer has a status of noiser packet size it's called no sir in other words it's not like other car bonus oh if that's the case it's Montana where did you get such an idea who's the talent that says this when the posture clearly says that it becomes nicer in the morning why say sue me man Oh a biker that's the question the Gemara raises on our Mishnah I just want to add one detail Highsmith's writes here in the ptosis on my rubber that the Cohanim didn't even prohibit you to eat after cuts ice that's not even what happened it's not like they came and they told Jews you now that eat after cuts ice they they caution people to eat before Hut sighs that's the thing it's not like they regularly we understand there have made a prohibition to eat after cuts ice in other words if you miss cuts always tough luck why to protect you from chorus toys fist learns they didn't even make a prohibition they just it was more like a instruction eat it before cut signs and if not that needed after it's an instruction it's not a prohibition yeah eatin even more than a suggestion a commandment but if you don't do the commandments you could still eat it afterwards the toys on my rather yeah yeah yeah he hold it is not is routine after cut sighs there's a mitzvah to eat it before but if not okay according to this for sure you can't say that back such choice it becomes nicer and it's become ADEA Diane you know even according to the first interpretation it's only an issue they're abundant it doesn't make it nicer according to taste interpretation you're allowed to eat it afterwards how can you call it my sir and that's gonna be my family and I'm when you're allowed to eat it as a carbon so even if you say even if you say that there has come I'm a stirred it still doesn't make sense that it's noise it's not nicer to be me Tommy you're dying noise sure means that it's left over after the prescribed biblic time for reading certainly if you say it's not even a mr. t they just wanted to eat earlier but you could eat it afterwards how could you call it nice you can't you lie to eat it come and wanted you should eat it earlier the fact that we copay some nicer back at size means that you push it now that he eat it after cut size not only rabbinic li but also biblically he says Montana who is the time Amory abusive al ahzab in Isaiah the time is RIBA lhasa binisaya the time yet we learned to bryce a blossoming as i teaches us a fascinating thing and I want you now to good to go look at those to pursue can we read and see something interesting pass a tres for us Lewis Abbas about Lila Haase okay anything miss anything weird anything extra in this pasa pasa tres if you would write the plastic was there a word that you could do without very good we don't need the word house there it's a slaughter it on the 14th at night eat the meat of course this night which night shouldn't be too big shot if I tell you I want you Sunday afternoon to bring a carbon at night eat it of course it's Sunday night it's not the next week Sunday night unless you want to distort it but that's the literal meaning but Lila has that means this night it doesn't by the way explain it this night which is this night maybe this night is in February oh no it means the night of pacer the vocalist of us about Lila but says how's that the bilasa been Azaria picked up on this and he said there's a reason for this and the reason is you have to go to prosecute base Posse good basis variety merits Mitzrayim by Lila hacer could have also said for vitamins messiaen by Lila will took mother same night night of pacer I passed through Egypt at night you understand there's nothing about Lila's air we have two hours ears that are extra they blossom and Isaiah says that's exactly the point the Tyra wants to compare the mitzvah of eating the meat of the carbon base off - what happened Marcus Paris when I passed through at night to smite every Blair when did Marcus papyrus happen so we have a pasta kleider we have a pasta later whether the tragedy happened if you ooh pasta cough tests page 184 on the bottom positive test page of a positive test batches boy by Ibaka see how Lila Vashem he cook okra Barrett's Mitzrayim it didn't happen in the beginning of the night it happened back at CI Lila midnight so when a Shem says variety maitre signed by Lila's there it's not a blanket statement this night it means when midnight so when it says for us Lewis our boss about Lila Isaiah not a blanket statement at night it means midnight that's what a blossom in our sorry let's see inside almond ability really seriously blossoming eyes are you the tiny we have a price the price it says but also the but the POSIX it was impossible I Lazare Balazs have been us are you a man a mark on it says malala's vanilla Holland it says a few pursue come late of a variety retro scramble I Lhasa Maha Island just like the second m'lila are kathoys it means toolkit soy's Hashem smite Hashem killed the Egyptians went pocket CLI let midnight Afghan the first ball I Lhasa to eat the car basic is a choice Marquez queries happened to cut so it's not after cuts ice after Khalsa was over but kept CI Lila that's when it happened I could wear didn't happen 1:00 in the morning 2:00 in the morning 3:00 in the morning it stopped by her choice no moisture said Kaka toys so they shouldn't air they should have but it was real hot shams concise yeah by Heba Katya Lila Moisture set cups ice yet ok to the best of our ability of course to the best of our ability if you have atomic clocks yeah but the point is Marcos Belarus didn't happen after cuts ice yeah that the carbon Pacers can't be eaten after cuts ice yeah yeah buzzer right of course of course well if you have a doubt stop a minute early right you gotta make sure that it's yet yeah yeah you're right no no no no chorus yeah yeah yeah right yeah you can always do each other exactly exactly exactly yeah yeah oh good question good question good question he's saying this is intellectually dishonest Marcus Reuters didn't happen after cup size but also didn't happen before concise it happened exercise so if you really want to make a crush you should say we all have to eat the carbon pacer exercise and you know how long we have a nanosecond which is of course impossible you can't eat the casillas in a nanosecond or even in 20 seconds so you're not comparing so yeah anyway you're anyway not comparing it to Marcus Belarus others Marcus lawyer is by Wayas there you're right it happened at midnight I agree but how not later but not before we don't say that by the carbon peso we save the moment night falls you can eat you can eat for six hours if nightfall is at 6:00 you can eat 7 8 9 10 11 till 12:00 that's not Marcus papyrus in other words you're choosing and picking that what you want you're saying it can't be after cut size because Marcus Reuters didn't happen after cut size by Laila's that means deadline is cut size but then go the other way it also didn't happen before cup size right but that you can't say cause it's not gonna make sense to tell people that the Turner is telling you that we have to eat the carbon basis at midnight and we have approximately one second for it because that's an impractical Mitzvah so who you talking to you talking to angels or people you can't say that God is telling people to do something that they can't do right so you're picking and choosing what you want so once you're picking and choosing then do it after cut sighs very good question you're asking very good question you know I understand it below subpoenas are you can say you have to eat it at cuts ice because how long do I have I have to give people some time and you got to give me a few minutes to eat it right I understand that but then you'd rush is already disqualified a good to Shila you understand a sailor it's a pretty good question huh he's saying he's saying you're picking and choosing you're being intellectually I mean he said it nicely but right exactly you know I'm we're not God exactly Oh or Hashem could do Marcus notice like this yeah okay so however he did it but but was bad sighs right yes we can't replicate that experience so we have to somehow expand the time which I understand but then it's like you really you know so it's not a real Baal Isla hoste it's not like Marcus papyrus right so the blossom is are you saying that since it says variety merits miss Ryan but Lila Hosea what does m'lila as I mean it means I cut saris but it doesn't mean a whole night I'm not gonna pass through Egypt all night I'm not two in the morning I'm not passing anymore one in the morning I'm not passing I'm passing till hoist so when it says varrock labelled Eliza it doesn't mean a whole night even though it says don't leave over till the morning which we have to understand we'll soon see what that means but when it says eated by Lila Z this is a limit in the light Lhasa and that is the same limit of macro squares haircut sighs so he's asking mushroom cloud rashon so the B oil is asking I'll give all the cash isla it answers why not later but we're here we're doing it before let's put it zwei why can't rabbul izza but maybe the blue managed to say something else it's like markers plane is one thing Mac is ready to start cuts ice so we should start eating the carbon-based Hut sighs maybe had better like he's picking and choosing what he likes he's saying not after cuz market phrase wasn't after so maybe not before what well was not before what am I supposed to eat it so you have to pick one so why do you pick this way why don't you pick that way just for convenience it's better to have dinner at 6:00 that have dinner at 12 so maybe there Elizabeth I should have said the trader wants you should start eating the current basis biceps eyes it would have been a very interesting Mitzvah or one Mitzvah that we have taken suppose we would have cut and paste and perhaps ice oh and there's even a miler because there was a serum and Awadh Boyka would work very well you started midnight you continued throughout the night till the morning what's not what he says right but whitelighter starts at nightfall but it continues after sub-sites so you are cutting the Lila you are cutting the Lila because Lila continues throughout the night but you're saying that you can't eat it a whole night Lila is only till midnight so we have to understand what's the mechanism of rabbul izza banaz is thought there right so I'm gonna tell you on inside by the Avenue nazar the Avenue nazar you know the Avenue nazar was his name was rabbi of ROM Bornstein of ROM Borenstein he was a son-in-law of the kotsky Rebbe Rabbi Menachem Mendel Morgenstern he was there ever and rabbi of soccer chav soccer trevor was a very well known city in Poland still in all a city in Poland so big community in Poland and he wrote a saver called Charles to traverse Avenue a geoserver a saving called egg later on malakas of Shabbos he was one of the great Gangnam of the generation and Paul and he was well known his son was the shameless small group small of soccer cover of small Borenstein was the son of the Avenue nazar and the Avenue nazar from soccer Tov he was he was student as I said a student and a son low of the cuts Karev and he was known as a great gun he has a set called salsa troopers Avenue nazar I think in Simmons shouldn't pay or shinpei olive over there the Avenue nazar gives the following insight okay and he asks the question he asks this question which this question we learned a while ago and of Zion the Gomorrah discusses there the question when do you say al when do you sail it we put on tefillin we say Lohani at fillin when it comes to Hanukkah we say la Harlequin air Konica yeah when it comes to how much we say al beer comets when it comes to matzah we say Allah Heelys matzah the question is what's the lure what's the owl so it's a complicated discussion in the Gemara and they were showing him and of Zion him soccer we learnt it with all that of they were showing him one consensus is that Liz when it's for the future ow is for the past oh so not only for the future for the past something that happened Alma tell us you're dying on the telus lulav because we make the bracha after we pick up the will of her any right Alma till lisatime after we wash our hands that's one discussion another discussion is another explanation is live is when you're doing it yourself al is when you could do it through Ashley uh admits were that you have to do yourself you say live because you have a mitzvah to do it al is there's a mitzvah about it so there is showing them say Allah he love smart so you can do through Ashley Ahuh I can make Ashley f to eat matzah I have to eat matzah myself some rishonim vodka have a lotion lehel matzah but we say our Hillis matzah so it's something that I'm doing in the future I'm not doing it in the past I'm eating Macs and now i shouldn't've in Silvano lasso matzah lerka matzah to eat matzah we don't say that we say our hellos matzo toff DNA's question and a lot of people struggle with this a lot of them a fortune why do we say he brings from one of the the cup Jakob says because the puss success vocalist of muscle m'lila zat's Liege amatus Owl Miriam your clue so it says owl who Marxist owlman's is what's the connection of matzo so Miriam a clue or our mats or Aramaic lortell Achilles Muslims ow our there's different types of mitzvos and you have to always know how a mitzvah works the question is is the Mitzvah the Pula or the Mitzvah is the niffle the Mitzvah is the act or the mitzvah is the result of the act and it's a very different definition for example when I put on tefillin what is the Mitzvah is the Mitzvah to put on tefillin is the Mitzvah to be until into weird Philip do i fulfill the mitzvot by putting on that's villain or no putting on the tool is a preparation to have that villain on me the rocket sovereign abusive angle both maintain that Phil and shall yadda mitzvos to put on tefillin Phil and shall rise the mitzvah is to have that villain because by Phil and Saadat says the Rambam and Phil and says like this lick shirts villain our yard Leo still enough Irish tie that's filling on your hand have that villain on your head it's a different Mitzvah by so Roy putting it on and tying it as a preparation for the Mitzvah the Mitzvah is when it's on me by shall Yad the Mitzvah is actually putting it on Lamai enough come in a big mouth come in if I put on Phil in the middle of the night at night is not the time of tefillin but I leave on that's Phil enduring the day that I fulfill the Mitzvah of tefillin if the Mitzvah is to put on the Phil and I did not I put it on the middle of the night if the mixture is to have that's filling on me I don't care if I put it on the middle of the night I had its fill in the Gemara says if you put on till the middle of the night in the morning you have to be a marsh mace you have to like like touch it and redo it like you know shake it a little bit like retie it so the record traverses that's only two Phillips oh yeah de not feeling so right because Phil and Suraj having it on you is the Mitzvah what did they random come up with this kiddush he looked in the hole says sorry tom is a leader huh maja you that they tougher is bein a NASA but Phil and so you add the myths is the Pula the Act but Phil in charge the act is not the Mitzvah the result of the act a caller gets dressed for her wedding the objective is not to put on the gown the objective is to wear the gown you can't we're a gown without putting it on but the objective is not to put it on that putting it on as a preparation what about a mitzvah Slav de bris what's the myths of a bris is the Mitzvah the act of circumcision or is the midst of it to be circumcised it's a very different Mitzvah if it's the act of circumcision so the mitts happens when you do it if the Mitzvah is to be mall it happens as a result of this circumcision but that's not the Mitzvah the Mitzvah is to be Maho the Gomora says in Shabbos that Dovid was in the base americas he was in a bathing house and he felt very bad and he says I'm naked from mitzvahs and then he realized that he has a bris Miller and he was happy what was he happy about that he once did a myth so when he was 8 years old he also put on tefillin in the morning he also ate matzah paisa the shop is that filling in the morning he doesn't have now in the base Americans the mitzvah of brisée has now in the base of matters because the mid sir is not to do the bris the mitzvahs to be to have the grist that's forever as long as you have it in other words permits for 24 hours a day that you fulfill it's always a question about how you understand the Mitzvah the act or the the result the Pula or the niffle you're with me says the avenue nazar that's the kshitij of the blossom in Azaria all the cohorts it blows I'm gonna say he knows the problem we can't be Marquez papyrus I'm not God I don't know how to eat in us in a split second I don't know how to do that so why are you telling me about Lyle Isaiah ah the mitzvahs not to eat it of course the mitzvah state that's a preparation the Mitzvah is that by cut size the matter that the Pesach was either second I eat it seven o'clock bite that's oyster pox is eaten and it happens that moment the Mitzvah fascinating words when I'm eating it I'm preparing for the Mitzvah nine ten eleven when does the Mitzvah happen the Mitzvah happens the moment cuts ice comes and there's the patient says that explains very nicely why this are common was so concerned that people shouldn't eat after the carbon-based ah who cares we learned before a mouth Tyrion after a pesos after claiming no dessert the question is why so where's Bom says cuz we're afraid that if you can let people eat after the carbon pay so what's gonna happen is they're gonna have their whole meal after the carbon pay second they need the carbon Basin when they're hungry so that's why you know let have any dessert he says it's much deeper than that because you want one hot soy scums ah the method when one caps ice comes when cuts ice comes the pacer should still be there in other words if you ate a whole meal afterwards so whatever cuts ice happens okay you ate the carbon base you wander by cuts ice I can't eat the carbon-based ikkaku they're gonna take me more than a second but the time of the Pacer should linger in my mouth so even though I didn't eat it now but by now it's eaten and not only eaten it still felt like midnight how is it felt by midnight because I didn't replace it with any other food ain't my fury I couldn't pass a coffee claim if that's the case he says you can't say I could his son of a waste of it's Yvonne o-laca matzah he commanded us to eat the matzah because actually the Mitzvah is happening in a very funny way retro actively I should've shown residence Yvonne Oh Alice Alice matzah actually when the Mitzvah is happening I ate her I ate it already when the mitzvah happens at midnight I ate it already so you don't say he commanded me to eat matzah which sounds like the commandment is happening right now eat matzah and you're done he commanded me Allah Phyllis matzah it's actually a mitzvah that's gonna happen in stages just like be your comments beer how much is it al beer comment you don't say live via comments on the eating of matzah yeah yeah exactly yeah yeah yeah it's the result yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah so the mitzvah taka happens in a split second right they wanted the taste should be there yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah retroactive yeah yeah yeah that by hot sauce it was eaten I don't know I wouldn't use the word brainer but by hot sauce it's eaten you did the Mitzvah of course I have to eat it eating is a myth so what do we mean eating like putting on film is a mitzvah right yeah yeah yeah you do your thing and then it happens it takes roots it takes root like you planted a seed right and then it takes root yeah artists that's the answer to this question by cuts ice like this it happens like this you don't have to know god god no god no yeah you've just been done before you just be done before yeah yeah and from this Davin a nazar says a big tradition Aloha he says what happens if you have a seder park assure me of thirty eight o'clock and everybody learned in school something to say by the seder yeah you know those Dharam and we're gonna learn soon that many hold that the say my luck with carbon basis is Daffy claimant now if a claimant is in lieu of the pace of her blossoming as ayah says no pacer half the cut size Northy Coleman half that size now we're suing him see Rebecca keifa argue stabilizer he says you could eat the Pacer half the cup size you could eat African man after cuts ice it's not a problem okay but they're below subpoenas arias has no pace 1/2 the cut size and that's the whole idea of not eating that for coming after cut size based on this Gomorrah but Lila Haase so the native says I'm gonna tell you a big finish he says if I'm right I'm gonna tell you're a let's say you have a long Seder and you see it's getting let's say cut slices 12 o'clock and it's a quarter to 12 and you're still holding Manish Tama or you're still holding rock so whatever this say there is not even beginning you before the meal which happens sometimes along say there it's a quarter to twelve and we're starting to wash from might see matzo you need might seem at some marker it's all scenarios a meal takes 20 minutes a half an hour by the time we get to have a curve is gonna be 1:30 in the morning what do you do what do you do you say you have to have a short say then he says no I'll tell you what to do this is what you do this is what happen amazes us he says right now wash and eat eat your matzah and your afikoman they Philip Asaph eat it okay eat it eat your matzah zatia their syllabus as a fake Lima but with a condition if the lockers are calabaza Ben Azaria this is your f reclaim line if their lockers like rebbi akiva it's just a piece of matzah reading a piece of matzah now what happens he says your blossom in Azaria only has a problem he says if you eat after your afikoman till cuts ice after cups ice you're done I don't care so he says eat a piece of matzah make a condition if you're blossoming Azaria is right this is my alpha claimant don't need any food after this tool cup size afterwards you're free to do whatever you want move on with you Seder if the lock is looking to be a key there then you can eat that for coming at 3:00 in the morning so you'll lead to our free climbing at 3:00 in the morning the second time and that's how you do it so it works according to both opinions so if it's a quarter to twelve and you're holding by Schultz and iris yeah let's say we just brought out the fish just stop the fish for a moment eat the afikomen no feed the fish no no fish afterwards no no wait till cups ice after subsides go back to eat the fish the monofin if they look alike others have been Azaria you rate your AFRICOM and your pace they feel the pace up by cuts ice it was done you had to taste in your mouth after subsides I don't care what you do have a whole meal I don't care continue the fish continue this soup continue this chicken two o'clock in the morning eat your Africa lemon a quart your beer kiva and then you won't need anything afterwards because if there look like it wasn't Ben Azaria you had a freak lineman already before cup size and after that you didn't need anything till concise after Curtis you can eat whatever you want cuz then mitzvahs done and if you order hear me Akiva so you did a free climb on later in the night in the regular time right before benching you didn't need afterwards that says I walk no cuz aim according to him the whole reason aim of Tanaka pesos afikoman is only till cup size because the Mitzvah is that by cut size your pace that should be eaten so we want the taste to linger till cup size but that's it after cut so he says I don't care if you eat other things you're done it's like the next day what do I care the whole reason you now letter have anything in your mouth after cut slices only after the pesos is only so that the taste of the carbon pacer should be present in your mouth by a choice because that's what Marquez Clare has happened that's when the Mitzvah takes root afterwards I don't care so that's his solution to a seder that goes very long eat like two Africans whenever faces your eating - Arthur Clements yeah that's a separate discussion that's not the good Mary's not discussing how to determine cut size he's not that he's not getting into that whatever the cut size issue so according to this we understand that a bilasa binisaya believes that you now letteth the carbon paste after cuts Iseman hot area it's biblical because he learns it from Xavier Java but Lila Houser means not just like Marcus Brutus so therefore we understand that according to blossom and as I after subsides it's nicer it's left over and therefore it's my time of the end I'm not like other carbons with there's a decree of the rabbi's not to eat after cut size because they wanted to create a buffer zone and protect people from us in that's not what he's saying then it wouldn't be nicer but by pasting this Xavier but while I was there it makes it nicer and therefore it has a gather of moisture that's mohamed iodine from cut soy soon afterwards okay yeah yeah yeah yeah you're right you're right yeah but it's but we have that also with we have that also with we have a similar soiree with beer comets beer comets the myths of beer comets it's explained social corner of caravan sim and I think tough mem hey when I do the beer comets is not a Mitzvah yet I'm just find looking for comets when the Turner says ask me I'm Irish and I should be so so the trader says now I want you to be Mars miss comets yeah I want your comments to be mush bus so now retro actively the beer comets that I did the dick and the beer comments become a mitzvah the burning of the comets in the morning if a person burns comets eight o'clock in the morning is it a mitzvah or not a mitzvah yeah it's not a myth so I don't have to burn home it's eight o'clock in the morning but when hot soy comes and there's a midsummer of Tosh missile it should be merged with by now the Mitzvah is that by midday Arif pays us the comet should be gone how did it get gone because I was masked person in the morning so retro actively becomes a mitzvah and that in essence that's why we say al beer come it's not levar comments because here too it happens the shot of our I'm not doing them it's right now later it's gonna be something that retro actively takes root and even not sold not so dramatic I put on tefillin sure Irish I didn't do the Mitzvah yet I'm we read it that's the Mitzvah when I put it on I'm preparing for the Mitzvah the Mitzvah happens right after I put it on as a result of me putting it off that's one way of understanding understanding the Gemara cause if not it's very hard to understand what the bilasa bin Azaria was was was was thinking like it's very nice to pick and choose but it doesn't make sense unless he kindness that Balala has a teaches us a new gather of what carry basis is it's not a regular Mitzvah not a midst of eating it in a certain time and that's the Mitzvah because the time is a very limited time the time is cut sois it sois the prasat is you have to eat it at cut sois and buy cut size it's eaten when cut size comes the myth so was he the result happened I'm now in a state where my carbon basis was eaten and that's why the how come and added and said really if so it's good to have the taste so at least it's the closest thing you can get to eat it back at size you can't eat it back out size at least you should feel it but cut size at least the residue should remain in your mouth but cut size at least the impact of the food should linger in your breath by cuts ice I can't tell you to eat it at cut size because you don't have time it's only a split second but that split second even if you didn't eat it you feel it's like you ate it then because you still feel the taste when you eat something you feel that this so it's the closest thing they can do to get you to eat it back a choice that you have the time by cuts ice so it's much like you ate it that's they made this taco Nevada after an octopus a coffee cup according to the Avenue laser there's not a question that I have is notorious item company this mission er what's that connection here with two parts of the mission there's one part they fell asleep didn't fall asleep was to get up sleeping in second part is is about the hands next up we got the connection if we understand is the issue here is when I come to cut sauce a my width for complaints have a mad without problem plates up then sleeping is very relevant if someone fell asleep he doesn't come to cut sauce with the same the same Corbin place that we started before it's exactly the same issue mm-hmm she's saying that now you can understand the connection of the two parts in the Mishnah those were just like the second part by cuts I have to have the carbon basic if I fell asleep in middle I went off in the station in which my golian right but the bilasa been isaiah wouldn't say they an hour to go to sleep before her choice well qaeda he wouldn't say that that's a big finish if I finished my say the nine o'clock I can go makes me not ready itself one is speaking maybe first be between then he is not ready that it's the same Indian it's nothing you could say this with others when you fall asleep in middle the carbon pay sucks so the second time you're eating it is not connected to the first time it's it's a new carbon pay stuff it's like in a new place like we said when you eat it after sleeping it's like eating it in a new place so you're saying the same as the Nakota that by hud sois the peso has to be a base it has to be eaten the connection I planned on teaching it but not so early I wanted a furnace finish to sukhiya but because he asked the question and it was a very good question because without it it's very hard to understand the Gemara it seems like almost this so I felt compelled to to spill the beans immediately he was thinking he was think please attend that say metric is that what you do for a profession according to this according to this when you're sleeping in Macomb the Mitzvah is this exhibit because I've always learned the emotion said yeah yeah yeah yeah a shaker which is always get alerted yeah we become alert when there's this word says anything very precisely aligned us they wouldn't accept it the holy night is precisely has Michelle as Mary Beth's boy boy Emma's are you saying sir as a pin point is pinpointed this it's a moment says narrowing it down to a moment said this cuz the night is not this it's it's it's a it's a larger expense whenever you say say you're pointing like Mario beds boy rhyme is that this is it it's a point so it's it's a point and a point that you can't divide further which means a conceptual point because say you'd know cause a Marxist a shekel precision precision you need the precision zen needs precision Kosair Ava Kaddish right this type of mode and what's the third Manoa monoid also precision yeah pleasure to have you pleasure to have you also for mate sister all to work him for my chest wrong ain't tourniquet area said yeah father that healer has a lot of Huaraz his point is not that that Hill is not a Mitzvah that Hill is the beginning of the Mitzvah the Mitzvah has stages no okay so you reacts in a question hoot kids how you eat it so that's the VAR the VAR it is it's not just it should be eaten it should be consumed the vert is the Minister has stages stage one is to eat it but it's not complete yet when cut choice comes and you ate it now you completed the Mitzvah okay so yeah so in my shoulder I should say might fill in the Mitzvah is only the result and here the Mitzvah is in a few stages the mitzvahs to eat and the result okay that's good you're right right you're saying you're saying the Mitzvah stages it's not finished with eating it that's the Vaart it's not gonna be finished with eating last oil is not gonna cover the Mitzvah there's still gonna be more that's we say Allah heal us well we have the truth as it says in the fortune that it's both the mid suicide the pool and side the result say here - you could say the Mitzvah side the pool of the healer and site and and and then the step two is the result you need both you need a midst of eating but that's not enough you need hot so should come and it should be very good order yes loksabha this class is brought to you by the achieve Annette please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot they ueshiba net / donate