Pesachim 11a-11b - Two Views How We Respond When In Panic - Gemarah Pesachim #51

the yeshiva dotnet so we are up to da few Dolloff Ahmad olive close to the bottom of the page three lines from the bottom yet Aleph a Morales brief summation of this suger the Gomorrah has been analyzing the consistency of the views of review Hooda and the consistency of the views of the hakama regarding one question and one question only and that is when I'm doing a permissible act and while I'm doing the permissible act inadvertently I may come to do a forbidden act which I am likely to do because it may instinctively follow the permissible act for example in our Mishnah but because comets Erev Pesach in the afternoon and when I'm holding the Comets I may inadvertently put it in my mouth to eat it because I'm hungry which would be forbidden because comets is permissible eating is forbidden so the question is if the hakama felt the need to mated make a decree and prohibit the permissible act why because it may directly mean you by mistake into the forbidden AK and those are the views of review hood and the Cohanim who argue about this in the Mishnah a Buda says they do make this later and therefore there's nobody curse comets after the sixth hour error face-up when comets would be forbidden to eat minute area with the Kalam argue there is because comets in the afternoon and it continues throughout Pesach and that's what our mission had taught us the way the Gemara understood the Mishnah and the suger is trying to examine the views of rubidium in all of shafts in all of mission areas to be able to see the consistencies or the inconsistencies and since many inconsistencies showed up so therefore the Gomorrah felt compelled to be able to make us say there and show that there is a logical rhythm in the view of review hooda and there's a logical pattern in the view of the haha right I'm I'm giving you this I'm giving this and action to you because it's important with any shoe gear not just to focus on the details a question-and-answer question and answer question I answer proof my rejection another proof another question but always to be able to see the the big picture to be able to understand like what we're not just trying to quote every mission we know about your view hood then bring it into the Shaolin and just make a confusing show and as confusing as possible but there is a there's always a rhythm there is a rhyme here because the function of the Gemara is to make us say there in the views to be able to see whose view was what what was the Mahalo what was the logic to be able to understand it to be able to deduce one perspective from another perspective to be able to create patterns and what we like hauling today algorithms so what was the conclusion of this conversation that the common just like Rob you Hoda are concerned with this issue they are not lacks they don't say don't worry about it everybody is worried that if a person is doing something that may bring him by mistake to something forbidden it's something that you have to avoid that they all agree with yet the Cohanim are more stringent than review hood in the sense that they don't distinguish between something that you usually detached from and something that you're not usually attached from in other words as long as the object or the activity that you're doing is similar enough to an object or an activity that's permissible and again the object with activity you're doing is similar enough to the object or activity that is forbidden and you can exchange one with the other meaning from one you could come to do the other that have come and made this Zarin that's why practically they did not allow you to harvest the new crop before the carbon i'ma why because what I'm harvesting it what is going to happen I may come to eat it not because I want to my mistake because it looks like the other grain it looks like the grain in my house that's from last year's there's no difference it's not like this looks there's a sign here now today in it then therefore I'm gonna come to eat it they said don't harvest it that's number one they also did not allow me to put oil in an eggshell and have a drip into the lamp on Friday night and the reason is because as I'm eating and there's oil on my plate it looks just like that oil and inadvertently I may come to take that oil from my own use when I'm now allowed oh because it's hastening the muhabba extinguishing the flame or because it's moksa they also did not allow me to tie my barrel which I want to lower down into the well to fill up with water with a rope of Weaver's a Weaver's rope why even though it's not going to be an enduring not because it's easily exchangeable with an ordinary rope and therefore I may by mistake say oh I can use a Weaver's rope oh there's another rope I'll put that rope and that would be of course forbidden they did not mind if I connect two ends through a bow why because a bow is not the same activity like a classic knot and therefore even though the object is the same object I'm dealing with a rope or the same rub but the type of activity that is permissible is very different than the type of activity that is forbidden it's not like it's not like it's not like the oil where I'm eating oil and I may eat the oil because I'm involved with the oil and I may just eat it here you're saying the person may come to do something else different something different because you made a bow they're not they're not concerned about that and therefore everything is consistent in their situation and their views besides comments comments they say I'm not worried the person is gonna eat it for a specific reason since the whole objective of what you're doing is McArthur a loveless surfy trying to burn it we're not afraid that when you're doing because comets that itself is going to bring you to eat it because your whole objective is to get rid of the Comets so we're not suspicious even by mistake you're gonna contain it Reb you hooda on the other hand he makes a gazelle not to deal with an object or an activity that is permissible but may bring you to make a mistake and do a prohibition only if it's something that you used to doing the whole year but if you detach throughout the year then we're not afraid that's why he is afraid with Lucas comments why because people eat comments all year since people he commits all year instinctively they may come to eat it again but he doesn't mind if you harvest the new crop before the carbon Armour why because people are detached from it the whole year and therefore that is what is going to prevent them from eating it in the case of Shabbos he doesn't mind if I fill up the XL with oil because here again people are very aware of the stringencies of Shabbos and they're very cautious about what they do on Shabbos and what they don't do on Shabbos that's why he doesn't care if I use a Weaver's rope to make my knot on Shabbos because again because of the day of Shabbos I am extremely cautious however he doesn't allow me to make a bow not because I'm going to mistake it with a knot but because by him the bow itself is considered a knot in this whole conversation there's not one more last piece three lines from the bottom your dollar former Aleph the hall hated the bundle mean a like Gossard of you who though a buyer gave us that premise that comets and colors are different comets like the lehman a car there's Billy mean a god there's people are detached from they're separated from it all year much from the Year Commons they're not separated from the incumbents all year my comments he makes a decree by father she doesn't make a decree is that true the Haleiwa the ball with the mother manila goes interviewed is it true that every situation where people are detached rabbuna does not make as a de on a permissible activity which may bring you to a forbidden activity VII tania we learn to price the bracelet tells us fascinating case harsh Akiyama you have are may male cattle firstborn male cattle sokka's a dumb he becomes congested with blood now let's understand the case the background behind this Allah when a Jews when a Jews animals give birth to a part and we're talking about sheep or or cows right when a cow gives birth to a baby to a baby first male born a calf or the sheep gives birth to acquire a first male born so there is a unique Allah and that Allah he is that this baby this male firstborn is a part and therefore it's holy the owner must give it away to the car yet the Cayenne offers it in the base I make this as a carbon which belongs to the Cayenne a part like every carbon a part of it gets burnt on the altar and then the Cayenne takes it home and he can eat it we say it every morning up hurry right before high do a card waha massive a passer caught some Colin right street awesome Islamic Ummah Zahra Hikari Nicole McCoy youngnam the boy is eaten by the KNN my silica law governor Holland McCauley McCall Markel stem of a lilac cut and the Korean belongs to him and he could feed it to ever he wants as long as a person is kosher need a carbon you have to be pure granted but this is the property of the card it becomes a carbon that may some exertion then the part the kaiyan enjoys it with his wife with his children with his family etc this is only if the prior is unblemished what happens if the prior is blemished a moon enters into the cart you can't bring it as a carbon because it has a blemish what's the halacha now the client treats it like a regular animal that he owns it still belongs to him he shouts it and he sheets it like weed our animals it's called Hollen it's not a carbon it's not holy can eat it wherever he wants in whatever state he wants it's a regular regular meat am I allowed to make a blemish in my in a loud boom la year boy has all teach us that it's biblically forbidden to cause directly a blemish in your cart even directly or indirectly not only obscured any bahama of Shem any carbon you're now allowed to intentionally make a move if I move happened you can't be at Marcus but you now let intentionally make it a more here's the problem know as a mom the Cayenne gets it and he treats it like a regular animal this becomes very relevant today because the world the word the halacha sub hurry still apply today belongs talkin so if it has a mom it's fine if it doesn't have a mom you got a serious issue you have to let it run around till it gets a mom because if it doesn't have a woman Sequoyah goes to the bay somebody would offer bay so make it belongs to the client because it's book it becomes cottage my aim of the moment it's born there's a collage kedusha right the other cut Jim you sanctify once you consecrated you now letter make a boom here here God sanctifies it the moment the desire is born it Scottish may a love there's a hollows kedusha there's still a mitzvah that the person should say I raise a car but it's it's holy whether you acknowledge it or not right exactly you keep it usually for 30 days just to nurture it a little bit and then you give it away to the client and the coin brought it to the Masonic dish as a carpenter was his this was the dinner part it only applies to accent either cause and to cheap the first male born of these animals not female male born by a childhood assistant your pointer yeah you don't give it to a client to share right but by us when we have a par we also give it to the coin but we have a way of getting it back by giving him mummy but by the animal not the question yes yes the reason is because for a child it's important to remain with parents the animal could deal with you or the clay if you have a carbon and the carbon has a mum now now you have to pay the money to the heck - and you redeem the carpet because it has a moment but I'm now letting make a momen ish alee yes yes yes so here's the problem I have a coin shock aside um it becomes congested with blood and what happens is I feel I know that this animal may die as a result so what do I want to do I want to let the blood once called ha Casas Tom you want to let the blood you want want to reduce the pressure so you poke you poke the animal you want to puncture a vein in order to allow the blood to come out this is called bloodletting in English a casus tom in order to save the animal the challenge here is this could cause a blemish it may not cause a blemish the types of blemishes that are forbidden to cause our permanent blemishes not temporary blemishes a temporary blemish that will be healed that's fine because it's not disqualifying it from being a carbon but a permanent blemish that's forbidden so what's the question here Oh cuz I doubt this animal this prior became congested with blood I feel amazed even though it may die we're not sure but it may die ain't my kissing Lloyd I'm you're still not allow to puncture a vein too to allow bloodletting because you want to reduce the pressure so even though you would think it's not a permanent blemish i'm puncturing the vein it's gonna heal it's gonna heal I'm Kate I'm doing it for the sake of the animal I'm now allowed to dvw hood review this is a Peter of you how come in my room no yak is of course you could do the bloodletting you could puncture or pill virtually at them Ivo just be careful not to puncture anything that well create a permanent blemish let's see Rashi okay so trashy ploy I still have told my mom I feel all eager I'm even indirectly can the Tangier Mumbai year boy it says in the puzzle among should not be in a namely Elish Lee I told my mum and I actually agree my Tama Glen McCall moment my sexist Bates a machism down I feel of a mark of shame is my mum behind over home welcome Shibuya main is like there's no men who excel if you're not going to cut a part of a bone or a bone I Pergamus fossa or blemish it slip as New York's ear the cold over shame if I silicon Musa and anything that will not be repaired have a mum that's the moment that is prevent prohibited a doc but another blemish which is temporary like puncturing the rate whatever mum because Gaza reviewed at to Makkah boy said way more and yet review who the said you're never allowed to do the bloodletting when it comes to a car why because he's afraid that once you allow the person to do a permissible act right inadvertently he may come to create a blemish in the animal in order to let the blunt and this would be prohibited biblically the Eiffel goth decoction Huckle Dale in my head and even though carbon noise is something that people are detached from all year meaning there's always a sensitivity 365 days a year then if there's a carbon it has to be treated differently so there's a concept of but let's not like this animal is free for all to do whatever they want all year it Scotch him and you know it Scotch him nonetheless revealed is still afraid and he makes disk zeta so even though you could let the blood through puncturing a part of the body which will not leave a permanent blood review hood is afraid that this may cause you to cut the animal in a place that will cause a permanent blemish even though everybody is bad L mean I caught him and actually says my conception abuser but terrorists claim you have this much likeness if you're allowed to be an outloud ooh de beauté it says you're now allowed that I come in which included Shimon say you are allowed so here we have a whole new contradiction you're telling me he then abused this consistent wherever is bundling a he's consistent and he allows it that's why Kaddish works Shabbos works puppets doesn't work but Kardasian Shabbos works here we see no review that has a different Mahalo clearly made this cuisine he's afraid if you allow the permissible the person easily could come to do the forbidden because he's holding a knife whatever he's holding and this letting of the blood could cause something that's biblically prohibited even though he's gonna we're telling him to do it in a permissible way so I'm gonna get my good question Hussam over there there's something else going on and this is a concept that halakhah called Adam Bowl alma mine I people get overwhelmed when they see loss happening in front of their eyes other Bowl on a minor we have this concept when it comes to a sick person of this concept when there's a fire in a shtetl Hussam hear me the matter shot the bowl on my my nine since a person is terrified ball means you're terrified you're overly cautious you're overwhelmed because of loss of money he's watching a play he's a Cayenne it's his animal it's a precious animal it's congested with blood what's going to happen if I don't do anything it's gonna die what happens if it dies if it dies it's worthless it's like a carbon that dies if you have a consecrated animal that dies you now let it eat it it's a novela on the other hand it's a carbon now what is you have to bury it so therefore there is a state of panic ball is like a state of somewhat of hysteria yeah bahala like you're terrified you're overwhelmed so what's gonna happen a surely if you're gonna allow him to do the letting of the blood but Malcolm Shane I send my in a place that's not going to cause a moon or Scylla method welcome choice in my mom because he's in a state of panic and dread and historia stereo and confusion he doesn't have the the the presence of mind the mental serenity to be able to be conscientious here to be heard they're scared when I'm preparing hard is when underpinning the new crop there's no hysteria there's no dread when I'm trying to tie the rope in order to get my my my barrel down nothing is happening there's no major laws I just need to get that rope to work cuz I want some water I need some water but here there's a certain uniqueness the person is in a crisis mode and how do I know how long this animal is gonna live for is it gonna live for ten minutes is it gonna live for an hour is it gonna live for a day so W this says therefore I just tell the person you know what don't do anything if he knows the halacha says don't do anything you won't do anything if you won't do anything the animal there won't be a moment there won't be a moment if the animal dies the animal dies that's gonna be heard assess interesting read up on on what are the rabbi say about this they're the ones who say you do make a savior but hear not they used a very logic in the opposite way what do they say they say culture K certainly you're creating a bigger problem you hooda you're trying to save a month you're creating the monster closer to the English artists like clout if you don't give him any outlet also a moment he'll just do everything if you tell him everything is forbidden yeah he says lisanna this is not for me I'm gonna save my animal it's too much for me so what is he gonna do he's gonna go make a move because once you free him prohibit everything so now there's really no difference if you don't make him over you don't make it you do a mom he's not such a timeless welcome to know this isn't airborne on and this is the ricer so once it happens you'll do anything to get the bone you want to cut the lip cut the lip for the same reason he's overwhelmed you're gonna say top off limits I can't deal with that I'm losing my animal so I'm gonna do and since you forget prohibited everything so you pushed me to the wall you pushed me to the wall to do Annie sir once I'm doing Anissa who cares I'm doing an is I'm doing a Nessa very interesting marked in other words if you prohibit everything you sometimes making it worse you're trying to help because you don't want the person to make them and if you prohibit everything you're almost you're forcing rebellion there's a halakha by war right that you're not gonna surround the city from all four sides because you create desperation and the the need to fight back if you create one side open this was how Jews fought their Wars they had to leave one side open you have to be able to let people what's called come down from the tree you have to let them you have to give them a way out if I if I corner you from all sides it seems like a victory but really it's worse sometimes because now you're forced to fight back you know I corner you you have to rebel there's no choice if I could give you a way to escape there's a way you know you got a look it's called bloodletting and you gotta let the blood go out you gotta let them escape so it's very interesting rubee hood this says No so I was thinking what's this Sparta I'm not sure but it could be the Gomorrah says I'm a second's bumper , that whenever it says in shafts my sub accosted I thought a story about a hashset it's referring to review Hooda it's referring to debut of them in other word then it says Hassan in shots a committee of you heard a very low order Buda BAM Baba so when it says costed what's costs it costs it means a very pious person so could be W Hooda felt if the how am I gonna say your now let it touch this animal a Jew will say okay the terror doesn't want me to touch the animal tell me just a animal the hakama maybe we're looking from a different perspective and like out of desperation people are gonna say I'm sorry but I gotta do what I gotta do and then the smarter becomes the opposite if you don't give him any outlet he'll just do everything he'll do everything you know I sometimes see it in the culture there's some cultures where people don't the difference between our ice Adira bonnell a minik a homra a hitter right or mishegoss an idiosyncrasy a certain family minute which may be nice and when they break that minik they think okay now I can eat pork I should hear Liam Caracalla Shabbos cuz once I broke that minute right of wearing a certain type of shirt so I'm not Jewish anymore and if a person would no no no would understand this priorities don't make everything on the same level when you make everything prohibited then if I rebelled then everything becomes permissible because there's no differentiation anymore so therefore the huh come and say let him let blood is there a shot she's gonna make a mistake yes there is so why don't we make a sale like we made by huh - I'll tell you why cuz my gosh all I'm telling him is to harvest in a few days not a big deal but here were you telling him is your animal may die people are gonna rappel once they rebel they'll do everything better to let it make a temporary blemish even though he may make a mistake then putting him in a situation where he's like forced almost to make this the permanent blemish and it's more likely that the mistake will happen you're right if it's an engine of ball Alma minor if it's a place of panic and hysteria where I'm where I'm almost forced to rebel because it's too much to bear they will not make this Xavier that's their point W who they will make it W that will make it so I was just thinking it could because if you hook them because of his I'm not sure but if you did the Kimora says he was a hostage so maybe interview Hooda just felt this way it was like a little bit of a higher in my draga a little bit of a higher level because I'm it review they could understand this logic is very simple logic and we also understand of your this logic really logic is because people are in a state of panic they won't be McAllen they may cut the lip you know you just want to do anything when you want to save a life the most important thing writer doctorate emergency is the use of hadass right don't do crazy things because there's a crisis but here have a crisis my animal is dying it's a big nice animal I'm not that big but it's obscure and and in the state of panic I'm just like just get this blood out you gotta cut the lip cut the lip but I don't I don't know where the vein is I can't puncture of em but I can cut the lip just get the blood out so that should be whoo this time maybe this time is that it's a state of hysteria you can't trust differentiations and therefore answer everything if you prohibit everything you're good to go so fine we settle the issue there's still a consistency and if you hood that maintains his view and that could come and maintain their view this is a unique situation because of Adam ball al Mamoon a Rashi Alma my night koreans air ball our partial ammos Kolchak a hollow ball who English artist labor market Shana I said my mom / Alvarez / eisah he's gonna transgress wish of a nism a makka moo moo shall I be mekomo the sovereign Shalva very beautiful words the moment you prohibit everything in his mind everything is identical that's on the same playing field and therefore is gonna do everything drag to your mother or me I mean on the kymaro will not let go and this teaches us about the integrity the intellectual integrity it seems like it's settled the camera is gonna show it's not settled me I'm lean on the W who the other vol our mom I know really you just introduce the concept then Abby hood this says when people are overwhelmed because of loss of money the rules of the game change now we're gonna make a gazelle that we usually would not make because of Cox and eliminate but we'll still make eggs and er it's just the case I'll show you to be who did it has a different view but not we have a mission of a circus basic of gimble maybe hood I'm aw this says ain McCord in Bahama be empty you're now a lot of comb McCarten is you take a metal comb and you comb out of Bahama young teeth to get rid of the mud or the filth or the dirt or the gravel that has attached to its body you know sometimes it goes into a ditch or it goes into mod or or they roll they lay they sleep they lay down so you take this comb right and you want to comb it out so you want to do it on your turf review this is your now a lot of wine if they show up because it's very likely that you're going to create a wound in the animal and when somebody wounds an animal and blood comes out it's prohibited on young Thomas and almalik on yom tov so even though there is cement or or concrete or mud or whatever that cleped suet became attached to its hide and it's a cause of aggravation but nonetheless because by taking this iron comb and combing it you may create a puncture and a wound that blood is gonna come out which is forbidden on Yom TIFF so therefore it either says you now that I do I want my carts ofin but you could use a wooden comb the Cardon is a metal comb and micarta fin is a wooden comb because it will not make that ones even though you're doing exactly the same thing but since you're using a different instrument for each so the metal is forbidden and the wooden is permissible how my mind let me say not we disagree a McArdle half a McCart Sofia do not use any calm not the metal and not the wood Tanya so the price explains the Mishnah azo Carruth vaso kerchief what do we mean by the word McCarran in the word mccard sniffing key rude is katana and voice and kabura key rude is an iron calm so therefore the teeth are very are very thin and armoire armoire armoire sharp and small which can easily cause a puncture cute soft is good eylem it's done with a wooden comb and therefore the edges are much more huh thicker and therefore vain toys and kabura it's not going to cause a wound and therefore w Hooda says one you can't use and the other you could use what's the question out so that she says McCadden astral it McCarthy fan could depression a McLeish in of gaseous the teeth meaning that what are they called the spike star the teeth of the comb it's much more thick of a noise a kabura the hive of all the time al Malaki Danny Mia's what do we see from here a llama carrots ofin the Buda says you could use a wooden comb Alma like Gaza and meet Alicia Adam Bowl he surely shoots off of it kid or with we shot it Matt delicious of a moment Sara what do we see from here when the teeth the mud is on the animal it's making it weak it's causing an aggravation that's damage for your animal you're having a loss of money this is your animal or Dumbo llama my night Roberta should say if you allow the wooden call you're gonna use the metal come and because you're a little panicky because you're afraid for your animal so therefore you're not so relaxed you're not so serene so it's easier to make a mistake just like he said before when it comes to bloodletting but here we seem out that way Ruby hood this is person has the state of mind this is forbidden and this is permissible and therefore you could allow them to use or wouldn't come even though you don't allow them to use and iron now I know your answer is good let's see the Gemara awesome over there the east java claim is over there means the earlier case the car if you leave it alone without reading it without blood letting it may die you're dealing with a fatal potential fatality even if it's not a hundred percent but it's a potential fatality I'm leaning there we say other than ball out my minor we say a person is overwhelmed because of his money and if you're gonna allow him to puncture the vein of an animal where doesn't make a permanent blemish he may puncture a part of the animal where does make a permanent blemish awfully you shall be clay if you're gonna tell them to leave the animal and not read it sorry balm oh it's aggravation but it's not a potential fatality lyonie no we don't say other than below my my noise we don't say that a person becomes overwhelmed because of his money and therefore we can rely on them that is going to act responsibly with serenity and presence of mind and be able to remember that you use or wouldn't come you don't use a metal come he's not gonna get lost in the rush and in in in the impulsiveness of the moment he's going to become impetuous Pawhuska maíam he's gonna become an Petro and just oh there's a comb give me any comb just give me a call we got to do it when it comes to bloodletting give me a knife slice everything we just gotta get the blood here review the makes a distinction so karashi okay not rash something tomorrow will be hood one last question have you heard my so therefore what's the conclusion the Buda is being consistent he's not being inconsistent other than ball oh my my not great and that's why I'm afraid by the part over here I'm not afraid to be this is I don't make a scene I don't make a sale I let him comb with a wooden comb there's no need to say that he's gonna use a metal cop doesn't matter one second a comb is not something that's forbidden all year a comb is Lakota permissible so ever you damash Nagas become as the gods are Oh Monica because of the legacy why by comets the mute is afraid you let him do particular comments you may come to eat the comments why buy combs doesn't he make the same thing forget about other bolo mimouna we establish their W hood that believes that when people are not detached from something right they may use it a comb is not something you detached from it's not like a metal comb is something prohibited by Kadosh it's not something prohibited you can use a metal comb you use it all week if you use it all week and now it's jumped if and you want to use it yeah you may come to make a mistake so why buy comments you making Zeta and my kids off which is basically combing it with wood you don't make the sale now you might answer that he already said that when it comes to Shabbos right come to the Shabbos the diliman a you remember that right but this is not Shabbos this is Yom Tov this is Yom Tov Shabbos you could say people are very conscious of Shabbos that's right immunise said you could put the oil in the egg and you can use the weavers rope but it's in our Chaves this is young teeth young Tim is not a mistress killer young term is McLaren is Sakura huh Malaka of young Tiff's is a laugh so therefore Delta doesn't have that some rough Shabbos also Yom Tov we're a lot of cook you up there is a is a lighter situation but mailer the mailer you can't say that it's what's up hombre de Chavez blue minute cause it's not Chavez it's an Indian of young teeth so maybe the Gemara has this question and you ever seen exactly a lot of shocked and animal you want to cook the animal so therefore so the fight it's just like comets and nonetheless he doesn't make the Zeta and for the Gemara one place the call me today sing on Shabbos calm you may also use kala Similac still is or if you find a good purpose you can use it but the question is we set home reduce Shabbos people are very very careful not to do an Easter right so I'm saying it's not Shabbos it's Yom Tov that's it this is your time just by warning that that's why the good Maury doesn't have that and emerges a close your buddy said to Chavez is different I'm explaining why the Gomorrah can't answer that so the Gomorrah says lesson by lesson miss love key to acute appointments love bread that's forbidden on Pesach is exchangeable with bread that it's permitted on pace because I told you moths and comets were identical but mainly if you allow person to be by the comments in the time of Easter you're going to you may made my mistake eat comets why is it gonna eat hummus because it looks just like matzah and it's inadvertent and even though he's doing him dick his comets right but he may forget and exchange it it's not like he looks at it and it's like this big inflated piece of yeast that will remind them there's nothing to remind him it looks just like matzah so it looks just like matter again my mistake it's not willingly my mistake he doesn't think if he would think he knows he's doing thickest comets but since he doesn't think so he made my shengcún here it's cured by yourself you don't exchange easily by mistake I wouldn't come with a metal cup so even though I allow you to use I wouldn't come I'm not afraid then as a result you're gonna go to your closet and get a metal come again we said the person is in a mental space of serenity because there's no Isis the behavior has side the name is not about to die so the view this says just like we learned before by their abana that a bow and a knot you're not gonna exchange why cause it's two separate activities there it's the same objective it's not even the same object it's two separate objects with their up on an argue as we're actually says Lloyd Mitch live with abundance of remix left and then abundant say this Mitchell off because it's sending in over calm and therefore it is exchangeable Abuna says not and therefore he still remains consistent that he doesn't always have to make hugs area he makes Xavier only when there's a shock that it's exchangeable and that's clear just like there's a common the question is here they argue if it's exchangeable or it's not exchangeable it's kabura you make a kabura a wound so blood comes out as an know if it's your here then there's an issue of pulling out here that's a separate it's double shana miss Gavin you just trying to get the mud out you're trying to eased aggravation since there's a dovish animus Calvin yeah if it's inevitable then if it's a gracious you have to be careful say both you now let it both not the metal and not them yeah everybody says no matter and and and it's likely to make you could make a rule to the metal not for sure but you may make a won't or not like every come if if if you if you're using a comb and it's not certain that here is going to come out right okay and it's it's it's not certain that here is gonna come out that's why they make these Shabbos brushes so then this ah so then the stack of people who don't do it but its little does it is this room to permit it there's room to permanent padding of the animal has to do with touching something that smokes is not a problem moving something that smoke it's as a problem so moving an animal maybe most touching looks is not a problem you let it touch the car on Shabbos you let it touch an elephant on Shabbos if it moves moving MOOCs as a problem Ballack I am a moccasin the question of pets in a house is as a contemporary discussion with some allow it some don't I want you the last thing to take a look do you have Gillian house shots on the right side on the top Gillian our shops and small words Gillian our shots on the right let me take a look at Amara so on the left left bottom left bottom and Mike Hamoui is just different Gillian our shots these are the short comments of rebbi akiva ager on Gomorrah but kee Vega has his short comments and some of them all of them are very powerful I just want to read with you to convince ager and Gillian are shots cuz this question is one that teaches us how to think trouble you for that massage the human like yesterday the the red one over there on the bottom that red one yeah take a look Julian ashes oh my snog a beaker itself why by cutes off review that doesn't make eggs era comics he does make a sailor okay so you started to ask but sister guy in the Gemara wants to know comets versus kids nickers come it's not combing with a wooden comb yes even though both can easily bring to a prohibited act which is a mistake so the one who says it's different yeah but that's the question that reviewed is being inconsistent that's the question caution Lee says Rebecca Vegas ecofarm and you see Gillian ashes partially I don't understand listen to this question cavaldi can costly hockey door who rocky rabona hinder which means using a metal comb on yontiff is prohibited but it's rabbinical e prohibited why now ain't I miss Calvin I'm not trying to make a wound and get our blood the law you have a persecution and it's also not inevitable you can't say it's a hundred percent sure that when I call my animal with a metal calm it's going to be punctured and blood is going to come out it could happen but it's a dovish ain't I miss Calvin and it's not secretion okay so even if the command prohibited it it's not biblically prohibited Kimmy Varla had the Babbitt's ax the armor w-who de l'homme de da versa a name is Calvin a sir the Gomora says there that dub you who de doesn't allow you to use a metal comb cuz he holds Dover shame I miss Calvin is awesome remember we learned to be a mean old of agenda miss Calvin motor review the holes you now let it take a bench in your bungalow colony and schlep it from my house to your house through the earth even though you're not interested in making the furrow in the earth all you're trying to do is bring the bench to your house and the reason is because he holds dovish ain't a Miss Cavanaugh so it's not that local by the way the luckiest over Shana miss Calvin his motor I'm allowed to schlep that bench but that's this to Lou they were talking about revealed so in other words are served by the way means when there are born on Austin's mama yeah Bobby sharp limb cane have a rocky Cindy rabona the Hobart sharpest ask my mother for midbass but ties with Deborah Maskull Mesa Casa de little be who the Dover Shayna miss Cavendish are miss havin a rabona when abused it says it's a sir it means they're abundant and when a fisherman says its motor which is that look it means motor even Rabbinical e4 cane cost of choice of you enough one with all of them in base I think us a ration shop is f go follow dollar fee to my the inkay i buzzer dr. McKee vaguer mission Murphy like gods are kids of attica door I know why he didn't prohibit using a wooden animal because you may use a uh-uh-uh-uh sorry I wouldn't come cuz you may use a metal come you know why the kid good for you the Rebbe honor what's the worst that's gonna happen he's gonna use a metal comb and that itself is only rabbinic Lee prohibited I will become it's cuz you're in on Shama Yau the Hovind eraser without the Kakashi here the Kaczmarek in Vega the whole question of the Gomorrah seems so strange the Buda says comb with a wooden and what's a wouldn't call not what's a what now with the metal come because we're metal comb you may make a wound even though it's not your intention but since you may happen right you're not allowed to do it because blood could come out and that's what prohibited even though you didn't have an intention repeat the oldest austere fine maybe the oldest awesome so he says you could use a wooden comb right i we asked you may come to use a metal comb says it became a okay you may make a mistake and use a metal console what's gonna happen you'll be over it under their opponent it's not like when you use a metal comb you're trying to let the blood left it may bring to it and even if it does bring to it it's not a biblical prohibition it's like when I'm slapping the bench even if I make a Faro really doesn't say it's a biblical prohibition it's a rabbinic prohibition because I didn't have an intention to do that and it wasn't inevitable and whenever you don't have an intention to do that and it's not inevitable even if it happens you still not biblically liable it's just a rabbinic prohibition so I understand why to view and that allows me to use a wooden comb because he says I know people could make mistakes but even if they make a mistake what it's gonna happen what's gonna happen is don't do a rabbinic rubbish and the whole purpose of a rabbinic prohibition is as a fence for a biblical prohibition so it's like we say they roll exactly I'm knitting you don't make a fence to a fence no you're now gonna let me use a wooden comb cuz if I use a wooden comb I may use a metal and if I use a metal comb what's the problem I may come to do something that's biblical but this itself is not biblical so I understand they didn't do a double fence when it comes to comma it's a whole different situation I'm afraid that a middle of Dicker's comets I find comets I'm hungry I see a nice piece of laughs or what do I do it goes into my mouth that is a biblical prohibition-era face I have the hot sauce some of that letting you do padukas comments because you may come immediately to make a mistake and do a biblical prohibition how could you even compare it to this creature of kiddin and kicks off and if aqui Vegas says that Soros even Gothel but sorry seeing other means it's a huge question and the Gemara has to say because bread you could confuse with bread but two types of combs you don't confuse with each other and let's say you could confuse the common with each other it's still of different than comments this is bringing you to know what there are bonding at best and this is bringing Utah very nice I can understand why here here you make AG Isaiah why because if you cross the fence let's talk about it physically here if you cross the fence right you get electrified class for Shalom okay here if you cross the fence what happens you bump into another fence that's it here if you cross the fence you could get hurt here if you cross the fence what happens you just bump into another fence which if you cross that you can get hurt so I do understand why I don't let people go through this fence but I let people go through that fence you understand because I need one fence so I can understand this Eero Saarinen god--all McKee Vegas says a car is a MOT sauce amazing a chemise bonus shake who came with toys vishesh on him humor Daffy lama dalai lama base i see that the toys vishesh on him he asked this question in humid ah flama Dollarama days and therefore Ibaka vaguer says ok the question was asked so what does the choice is just shun him say put your Toph is the question yeah you Toph is the question a very very powerful question more enhances rep with Wigmore actually more doesn't answer nothing more than a good answer I think moisture that's Homer the sharpest bead eliminates the Gemara centromere the Shabbos Padilha mean a that's what you mean it's not Quentin I'm Italian I'm invisible I'm Devon with olives he says la Madeleine I'm in bays but it's not printed dis you gotta figure that out and and totally showed him ads in the question he says not only is it a day rice in middle of Pesach it's a chorus I understand where to be who this guy said so how come him hold that thickest comets should be even the middle of Pesach that's what I see results so it's a chorus I understand of you who doesn't want you to be over encouraged here if you call me with a metal calm at best you're doing an isn't there a bottom I mean at worst you're doing a Nissen to grab on so the back leg it doesn't say that the Tyson's you've shown them answers it he just says it says you shot him asks it he doesn't say it look there for an answer he says sorry even goggle twice because you shot a man says yes Lamar you're right it's a good answer but I didn't mean a coma Shani which means the Gemara has a different answer which is a better answer because what the camera is trying to say is that the two even in gosh me it's not the same in other words besides the fact that in Easter it's not the same yeah it physically it's not the same this is bread and bread and this is two different types of combs so you said it's a better answer you right it's a good answer but this is a better answer that's it easy more it's not using the words I would explain what the Tyson's USANA means is that even though it's of stark Apsara but this severa is still an idea in halacha which means it's a spiritual idea the Gemara is saying before we get there right don't just physically a physical reality bread life and lava is laughs whoa metal combs are wooden combs is metal and wooden right so he's saying it's a good one but I told you Mike you may get on-site ocean of answers he does I see entices you've shown them asks it oh and that's the kiddush that they are geyser that there's a common are geyser in this case huh no not a comet so we hey there goes it even would even would ya even would ya right yeah now she says that abundance of limitless they hold it at Smith cliff and obviously they hope they do that that the metal is prohibited because it couldn't let something which is after look at them sack debates of what they're smart is credit over Shana miss Carmen could be they hold its accretion to look up a diversion amiss Garvin is mutter is Oscar only for sure better be Hooda holds not maybe years old even if you don't know for sure it's too awesome but they're a bummer yeah you still mal out of Dover Shane Emma Skye I know it's something that could lead to Malacca even though it's not your intention if you'd to hold you now louder even though it's not for sure we don't hold that way Lala who we sex while you're saying Lolita dovish animus a dovish a name is common even metal yeah so the Gemara dress isn't there in Bates about from gimel misako's Bates of your mind what's the smaller of them the cashier Becky vague is Akasha Akasha other bowl on my mind Ashley there's a common if you don't let him do it he'll do everything but here it's not such a bahala if you're losing your animal too that you'll do everything you rebel if they're telling me foots are don't do it say ok I won't do it it's a different Indian the same thing we said better be hooded with our dumb ball we're gonna say by the hakama mero so yeah so that's looks like that's the kind of pluses like Ida Clark Bates are the Michener's bait sadaqa of gimel Amidala excellent question there's a whole sugar I had no life it's a good question that's a good question how do we know you're not letting Comets ever face it says touch B so you have to get rid of it good question that's the basis of the sugar it's a good question we're gonna learn later a whole suga how you know you know a lot in common surface you see the view diamond Amick adness I'ma be on the show is a kabura hominem you don't do either maybe hood ahold of or Shana miss Garvin ah sir aha so he sent it in a bun on hold is rabona near hold a crab you hooda the dover Shana miss Calvin ah sir but there's a in there rebel ah subpoenas are you who allows it because he owns a shipment over Sheamus Calvin motor so you could use even a metal cop in other words if you're allowed to use a metal conquers double Shannon miss Calvin then of course you're allowed to use a wooden comb but both their opponent have you hood in this suit gear hold that over Shaina miss Calvin is uh sir so a metal comb everyone holds is not you now louder the question is a wooden cops review this says they're not exchangeable so you could use a wooden coffin but it's not rip Shimon if it was if Shimon why do you say tube Shimon I mentioned of Shimon holds over Sheamus covered mutters but the Hakam Amir is not rip Shimon if it would beat up Shimon you write for beat up Shimon you're right right Shana miss Calvin what - yeah lotta comb the animal with a metal comb even if the one that the saucer is silver I'll be hood up she won't know even if it's exchangeable why would why would why would you you say there market but even more than it be hood the Marx would even mother Ted there guys Alexander Alexander because even then it's only dinner bottom that's what you're saying right toys first rights by the way that our comms everyone holds it saucer because it's secure a sure cuz you for sure gonna tear out here you're here toys who says our comms we for sure gonna tear out here everyone hold its officer for the secretion so then it's even it's a double Seamus Calvin you now louder he says our types of comms I guess they had comms we could take out the mod without their here probably the teeth were very distant from each other so it could it could it could it could can extract the clumps of mom get out the clumps but it wouldn't maybe it would stick into the clumps and and get it out rather than go to the skin no what I'm saying it's probably the mud is fresh maybe I don't know if it's inevitable it's a sir so if it's for sure that here is gonna come out here now Lana you're right if you're not sure then you're going so that's the mouth look you secretly say crazy by the ton of my revenue then we'll be holding that it's not and yes yes I have to be my iron and that Naqada either humming margosa if it's a time bomb okay this class is brought to you by the achieve Annette please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot a yeshiva net slash donate