Pesachim 117b-118a - Arvei Pesachim

the yeshiva dotnet Co feuds ioan on would base on my rather the line starts Amish the middle of the page go to the wide lines one two three four five six six lines from the beginning of the wide lines could Zion Ahmad base you see the Gomorrah discussed the brush in the halftime uh gained of it versus the brush and Avenue Matt Smith Karen you're sure the uniqueness of Magen David why we would even define Hashem as the shield of David because of his comparison to the Ghulam our share Boris of Rama certain Yaakov which is why we say muggy end of it in the Baraka that speaks about restore Chris the restoration of mouth was the kingship of based of it on my rather yeah he asked about that the mug and oven right okay yeah it's a whole I mean there's so many theories in this it's it's a complex discussion the history of the Magen David the meaning is a genuine is it not it was a Jewish symbol in Russia they were Jewish son William am i rather robber said ash christina was surveyed the pompe DISA one time I found the elders of the city called pumpa discipline Padilla is a city in present-day Iraq in ancient Babylonia and so via the padishah are the scan him the elders of pompidou's I found them the yessiree they were sitting the Comrie and they were saying the shops on Shabbos bein boots Leutze Bambi kedusha both in Dominic slices governing and by kiddush you should say my kadesha Shabbos this is what the elders of pompe dis had told me I found them and this is what they said to me which means on Shabbos when you davon and you make the Middlebrooks Nestor Friday night Shabbos morning and Shabbos Monica how should you can conclude abraca we do via new who Valkyrie is ramakrishna barakaatuh shem makatea Shabbos when I do kiddush on a cup of wine how do I conclude the bracha Friday night once again given over heart a sonic a dr. michael amon right Travis coach Kabanov Ruxin him kitano Baruch Hashem the conditions the same text in the Dominique slicer and kiddush be a merkava on yom tov bein bits louisa baby kedusha both darling and kiddush on the wine a different conclusion barakaatuh shem Makeda sheesh Royale DA has mana which is strange I would expect makka dish yom tov meccanica Shabbos Mikado Shem Tov that's not what we say the way we finished the Brock Anyang term the middle blessing again Yom Tov at night yom tov in the morning um tiff in the afternoon from and what do we say waha CA Noah Shem Allah came to us because Maya etc reached a divan oficina catch in America right and barakatahu Shem Makeda she saw Ava's mana he sanctifies Israel and the times which the times represents the times of the calendar different dates this is Manon from the words ma that's what the elders of pompe DISA told me a regular Shabbos that's not yom tov Mikado sure Shabbos a young Tov Makeda she saw the has mana what about a young Tiffany Shabbos come together right so the rush mom says then they would say what do you say or three makka - a Shabbos the Israel vas madam in other words you join the two together I mean Allah who I know I told them I told the elders of her padishah Adorama to the contrary it's Lisa by daven Inc Bainbridge shops a baby I met over Samba suryam tiff the blessing should finish with these words Mikado she saw b'keen Ducie and kiddush on the wine the shop sir on Shabbos Mechanica Shabbos but your mate over McAllister saw has mana by kiddush on wine I agreed with the pump odyssia people on Shabbos say Mikado sure Shabbos onions of semca Chavez mana by Dominic I disagreed with them I changed ELISA for Shabbos and Yom Tov by Dominic you say Bora Hitoshi Mikado she's wrong and Yom Tov also McCarty she's wrong other ABBA that's what other rubbers you're wrong it's the opposite Shabbos injunctive are exactly the same when it comes to darvany makka - she's wrong and kiddush I agree with you Shabbos mikado sure Shabbos young turk Macario servoz mono this is rather sharing his conversation and argument with the elders of Pompidou sir one second but I'm not I mean and I will tell you time at the diva time I did who I will tell you my reason and I will tell you your reason your reason in other words rather is quoting himself he's saying I met them this is what they told me this is what I told them and I continue to tell them that I will tell you your reason and then I will tell you my reason so you should understand that I'm not coming from a place of not understanding your perspective I know your perspective so now let me tell you my perspective now I just in parentheses I find this interesting there's an expression that they say try to understand before being understood ah yes this is a big contemporary teaching in conversations with your spouse with your children with your employees with you anybody right try to understand before being understood good advice okay so look what Robert does here rubber should say to them you're wrong this is what I say and I'll tell you why it's not what he does Robert says let me discuss your reason and let me hear your feedback obviously and then I'll discuss my reason okay just so you see that this is 2/3 this is 1800 years ago yeah always I know a minute no you're right he says I will say my reason and I will say your reason and then paradoxically he starts with their reason it's fascinating he says I'm gonna tell you my reason I'll tell your reason but he starts with their reason not with his reason interesting in other words he understands before being understood and by the way it's very powerful method than communication it's also encouraged evolution Omaha yep do you have the right and lice every word like a coma it's pretty meaningful right so why does he say here you could have said in the earliest remember this I used to say this I found you I thought about it why does it ever say I found them he could have just said this is what I heard from them like we always say am I rather the people at home with this I found them Christina I think that I think that is a good deal and I don't know the answer he was looking for yeah the Gemara they rush bomb also says that there were two people that were known as sabe de palma this review hooda and of aina at the end of the first plane ignition of sanhedrin the first chapters and a few design review Hooda and revena were known as the elders of them of this and that's who he meant review hadera vain who were great sages this is who he was arguing with phenom in a time of the diva time added who time' did who let's begin with your reason fascinating reason shabbos stick via vac i'ma Shabbos is established and it stands from the beginning of creation Hashem is the one who established Shabbos via for bein bits lies sub n be conducive Tavern in and kiddush the right text is Baraka Taschen Mecca - ops urema tava Yom Tov the Cyril who decauville they it's the Jewish people who establish it what the common ABR say they are the ones who make months pregnant meaning they add a day to the month Vika Vela Shani and they are the ones who establish the length of a year because sometimes they may add a month of the year therefore the proper blessing is Mikado she strove AHA's mana Hashem sanctifies the Jewish people and the times Rover is explaining a beautiful reason of the people of Pompidou said that those who he disagrees with what's the reason because you can't compare Shabbos to yom tov what makes the seventh day holy who decided it's holy the answer is the reboiler Siloam when and the answer is the first sharpest of creation he set a cycle this six days of creation is a day of Shabbos and then he tells the Jewish people with sham Reuben a lesser Shabbos right oh you see Benny Oh bene I'm sure most remember SARS very much I was very enough for the first Shabbos was already the first day of holiness what do we say by Hawaiian words were called Salaam right fighting Kaddish I survived hallelu Kim smugly much everybody Kaddish or you say by a Voronoi say God conferred a sanctity and a tranquility on the seventh day not only on the first seventh day on every seventh day he sanctified every single Shabbos of history that's proud Shabbos the career vickima it's it's there it's cavora it's irrelevant if I know of it or I don't know of it if I observe it or I don't observe it if I don't know if I know what day it is or I don't know which day it is if I'm in the mood or I'm not in the mood if I'm passive or active the Sun sets you can also feel it almost the Sun sets Friday over the horizon and Shabbos is here you still have a thousand emails to answer the food is not ready you're running around like a chicken bike a porous but Shabbos arrived okay that's from a Jewish point of view who made Shabbos holy Hashem so what do you say Makka dishes shops young teeth has a very different mechanism Yom Tov is also holy the tenth day of Tishri is Yom Kippur it's a pretty holy day the holiest day the 15th day of pay of miss and his pacer it's a holy day I'm not a little work I'm not any comments but here's a question who decided that let's say this year the 15th day was Shabbos this said the sixteenth day was was was was Sunday so Friday I already know how to eat comets who decided that Hashem of course he says the 15th day of pay stuff you not gonna do Malacca and you have to eat not say you know let comets but wait there's another process here how does the fifteenth day come about based on day one who decides what's day one the Jewish people not God and they can even make mistakes they're human they make mistakes what if two witnesses come and said they saw the moon and it's a lie they will investigate for what happens if it happens the gomorian tells in reshawna that it's to come used to rent false witnesses I mean they caught them but the possibility of a mistake the possibility of astronomical errors etcetera and there was a choice if Rosh Chodesh is day 30 so the previous month has 29 days so let's say some day is Aleph some Monday is base right so showers will be Erev Pesach but whatever is Kurdish is Monday and the previous month has 30 days so then Komets extends a day later so if I eat comets a day later I have a nice Icarus I eat comets a day earlier I'm free I'm not guilty and who decided all of this bears them there's something else best in also decides years some years they made leap years they added a month that means pay sucks is pushed off by a month so if I'm celebrating Pesach on the 15th day of misson they say sorry it's underbase a month later I'm eating comments its ear no your mcli of chorus you did Malacca you mostly of Malchus why you decided that it's it's listen I know that it's either you made a leap e it's not my problem we say that's not the case you have to follow best then God confers holiness on the day based on who based on best in deshyla's how do they have this power I know God has the power the answer is Mikado she's royal the husband his effort MacArthur she sir Oliver has mana he can first kedusha on Israel so that they can sanctify the time if they wouldn't have that power there's no way that best in his decision can actually affect the quality of time the fabric of time it would be senseless it would be a superficial holiday with we don't mind thanks get you know Thanksgivings you can you can push off Memorial Day can push a threat that you can push love these things because they're artificial it's just days to take off work and go to your summer home on Long Island and if it's a good weather make a barbecue right but that's not Pesach there's an Easter chorus if I eat comets that's not artificial it's called the death penalty from heaven for eating chorus why because somebody decided this is Passover this means that the day has a unique energy who does that the Jew the cottage is straw Vaz madam Shabbos has nothing to do with the truth we didn't do anything seven thousand seven day that's rubbish explanation and more did the Kivar so Shabbos we say Makar - a Shabbos jumped if we say not makka - house madam he doesn't do what we do it Myka - she's royal who could then be MacArthur's mononym that's why it's two words so it's not Makati deserve as madam two separate things Makar - she's royal who are then Mikado's this Manon if there wouldn't be a condition you saw they couldn't even condors mana for stays dry barren you understand okay noop so Roth is explaining it so beautifully while you're arguing with this a beautiful explanation rubbish rubbish said it so beautifully so nicely the hillock of Shabbos and Yom Tov Shabbos Craiova Kaymer and yom tov is not clear the Kaymer we don't know when you're if is gonna be she it's not clear Vic I'm it's not a stir we know Shabbos for the next hundred thousand years if there's seven days in the week Shabbos is a seventh day irrelevant if you're lost in the desert and you don't know which day is Shabbos the Gemara says what you should do you count six days you keep Shabbos account Shaba secrets you the trapezes days you know the story with delusion air your beast all of religion was a child they were learning a Gomorrah and Shabbos on my tests if you're in a desert and you don't know when Shabbos is you count six days and you shabba so you do Shabbos you count six days so the version that tells the teacher I don't understand the Gemara she explains and again I don't understand and he had a good hand a few times it's what don't you understand like what's so complicated he says how can a person not know when Shabbos sense does make it that cooking him all says you look up at the sky you see it's Shabbos was this was the hillock original when he was a child boots and boots and McAfee these out do you not know in show business maybe they come ice shop is my chemicai it's part of the fabric of the world it's part of the fabric of creation maybe you do it maybe you're holier than you think right yeah everybody this - I got him shaker yeah so that's Shabbos mashenka yom tov is completely dependent on on the human condition and we know that we know that we have a nourished hashanah a famous story it's a very interesting story randomly Oh established radish based on testimony of witnesses or every host schewe who was an astronomer a great astronomer disagreed and therefore he felt that diem Kippur is the wrong iam Kippur it's not really the tenth day it's the ninth day because rich trailer starts a day later and therefore Yom Kippur is a day later and her be her shoe I could not deal with the wrong iam Kippur basically everybody's gonna fast on the wrong day eat on the wrong day do melaka on the real yom kippur and not do malecon Erev Yom Kippur and eat eat on Yom Kippur and fast on air of Yom Kippur basically a mess Arab Gamliel told him I'm making a decree that on EURion Kippur you should come to me with your stick and with your bag and with your money and Rabbi Akiva saw rabbi Yeshua and he was very very downcast because he has here a choice to listen to him Gamliel to violate him Kippur what is he supposed to me I'm Lia was the leader of the Sanhedrin and abacavir then told them the famous extraordinary idea that it says a Lamia day Hashem micro eco - a Shetty crew are you samba my anthem we just learned in an Emer these are the holidays of God that you should designate in the right time you articulate some you have to designate the day in other words your book you mrs. Angley Maya dice Ayla Ayla the only holidays God recognizes are the holidays that you designate and then he adds in the Gemara that it says the word ice some three times in the parsha which can be read as autumn aishiteru autumn not thicker ice some of the days but you will designate it three times Adam a falou show you again even if you make a mistake Adam a Fela Mouton there was a complete error otama film is Eden even if you know that it's the wrong and for some calculation you decided to it's still related and Rubio schewe told them he come Tony you have comforted me and he violated his Yom Kippur what rebbi akiva was telling him was a Maitre D' cathain god's designation of yom kippur meaning astronomy's designation of Kippur is not Yom Kippur remem lil since he's the legitimate leader of the Sanhedrin we're not talking about an illegitimate leader an illegitimate leader who distorts Toyota doesn't have power we're talking about a real Bezdek that's a given it's a best in that is is trying to do what God wants obviously where it's not any Jew says this is Yom Kippur it's in Kippur it was him Gamliel was Sanhedrin they sanctified according to what they felt is the right thing of theater if there is Shalom it's not a best in anymore it's a joke it's it's a mockery I'm just parentheses but what we're saying is Yom Kippur is not an astronomical fact um Kippur is the day that the Jewish people said is him Kippur yes they have to based it on astronomy to the best of their ability you don't make him Kippur and middle of Hanukkah you kid with me in the tenth day which is based on the moon but it's about their designation not the astronomical objective facts and let me show accepted it so it's it's a it's a pelt it's a half load the cavorts one time over there was different when Schlemmer melis built the first base of mikdash the canoe Casa bias went for 14 days okay it started the eighth of Tishrei so he said the Sanhedrin passed condition ETM Kippur and they made a Calvo climber by the Mishkan then the sea and brought a carbon every day every day the twelve days sacrificing an animal is a violation of Shabbos Ephraim did it on Shabbos why cause it's dedicating the Mishkan the Mishkan is only temporary the temporary structure okay Ephraim is bringing the carbon only as a leader of one tribe yeah Hillel Shabbos miss Keela here that it's a base of mikdash and it's the whole Claudius you're all celebrating and it's only eating on Yom Kippur which is chorus you could for sure do it so that the Sun Hedren felt that the right thing is to override him Kippur they did they ate there is an unbelievable finish of the rocket Java gone okay travel gone in a letter to somebody we know that her shiny raba is considered like a semi Rosh Hashanah Yom Kippur we cuz they are good and committal you know like the end of the of the of the Martov so when Zoya does the whole thing about a shiny robber that M Kippur God seals and Hashanah robber he gives over the the papers to the you know to the court to those who have to execute it Pisgah tava getting acquittal opa-locka wiser Shanna Robert is all these putative and slickers and Fiddler's that we see as an Arab so the rocket Travis says this is a unique finish of his I don't think it was ever said before he says crazy unbelievable idea we have a concept in a locket called par Hallam devotional sibour it's a fascinating case in vehicular there's a homosexual akkada did her ears what happens if the Sanhedrin makes a mistake and issues a Hector to Jews to do something that is really a chorus penalty let's say they identify a certain liquid as permissible to drink and it's really blog a particular something like that or anything they permit something and it turns out that it was an Easter chorus and they realized they made a mistake and the Jewish people did it so the community they have to bring an ox it's called the power hell um Dover Schultz abhor you have to bring a carbon to forgive did this ever happen in history we never know of such a case in history look at reverse says it happened once sly Mahamaya he says they didn't it was a mistake and they realized there was a mistake and how shiny robber they brought the sacrifice of atonement and that's where hoshanah Rabbah comes from and the way he proves it is that there's a Gomorrah masaccio Summa that the fast on Yom Kippur was never overridden and he says it's not true it was so he proves from that Gomorrah that it was a mistake kaval Takeshi dish that hemella son had we made a mistake and they had to do trova and acquisition cuz he said it was it was they real like they they thought they thought it was a good logic but it was flawed a decision that was erroneous that they themselves regretted it she she's her shiny robber they brought the carbon hell no Jaden that's why your son Arab becomes a day of like chuhwa was the unique finish of his but in any case back to our discussion so Rebecca Vittorio schewe that it's all depends on besten so now we can understand why it's MacArthur she strove as mana with his best and have such a Korea from gum Neil is choosing the wrong day the answer is Easter all has a Cuyahoga Ducie and the Cuyahoga Ducie that the Jewish people have represented by best in it's invested in them it can translate into the calendar so when des des said this is a love Tishrei Yom Kippur now has the kedusha of his role that's what it is well there moisture de Bain was said to do it so wasn't a question he heard from God hear it from God something am i right time at the D let's finish this priest and what's my reason what's my why would I argue so rava says slicer davon ink is B Robin is it's done with the public it's done with the community so therefore the way that finish the brush is Shabbos on Yom Tov Mikado she's sure all he sanctifies the Jewish people what Rob is saying is a fascinating thing even though it's Shabbos or Yom Tov when are you dominate your dominant show what's the main experience in show the main experience is that you're together with other Druze that's the main experience and therefore that's what you have to say in the bracha barakaatuh avocadoes she saw he sanctifies the Jewish people cuz you have read it Sieber of the Jewish people that's the celebration so the main focus and the Brocker should be not Mikado Shabbos omekata jasminum but Mikado cheese straw you're giving tribute and you're celebrating cloudy straw that came together and shelter davon that there's a special kedusha in you sir all that's brought out and sure when Jews are governing together that's the focus even stronger than the condition of Shabbos as a day at this moment what are you celebrating the people that came to Dava this is quite the fascinating idea of his saying huh the health Mehcad it because but kiddush kiddush be honest we need oooka-deesh and your house is private it's me so therefore Bisharp is my condition Shabbos the youngters McCarty's almost now we focus on the day so Shabbos mikado says shoppers young Turkish man in show by Dominique what's the focus you sir all need not together and their holy Savior yeah yeah what matters is he strong it's not Shabbos it's not madam the main focus should be there that sip or do you saw the fascinating idea this is where he argues he first explains a beautiful reason it's hard to argue with the first reason it's a really beautiful and then he said by daven a knot that goes out the window now it's Macalester all and we don't finish breakfast with different themes abraca is always one theme so you're not gonna say Makar the Shabbos and Mikado Easter all we don't do that MacArthur Slava's mononym is not two separate themes MacArthur she's sure to be MacArthur's mononym but when you want to focus on one thing that's either you stroll or Shabbos we semi-conscious from that's the issue you're celebrating Jewish togetherness the kedusha of kanessa cicero which comes together in stroll the daven which is much more powerful than when you're in your home because when you're home alone you're so holy but it doesn't individual here we're talking about the kaduche of Canasta the straw which comes out only when there's at zipper we don't know about let's see something a matter of Allah he they may have they may respond or maybe they did respond this is not true slice' be Akkad Melissa you can Davin on your own people sometimes dive in on their own and another question we could do shibba-dabba molester nobody ever makes conditioned public there was kid dish made in shoal there's a soda when you have our SEMRush ever broca's let's say a lot of people making Kidder's together it's also Mikado's is strong and you could have it in your home so the gomorrah says that's not a net and that's not a question of a rubber server as ill buzzer occur Robert says you go according to the primary functionality of the brach of course you can down Van in your home and you can make kiddush at a public feast but generally the place of domine isn't sure and the place of kiddush is it your house are there exceptions of course exceptions but you go according to the ICCA's so he's same across all these same a conditional shoppers so the Gomorrah tells a story all about noses committee rather bully the son of Rav noxious means he went down but in this case it means they used to have the standard for the thousand used to be low they still have it in some shoals it was it was you went down a step because it doesn't mean my Mac in Chris Akash I might call out from the depth so uh libera venosus when it says he went down at me that means he but he went down to be the thousand so he went down to the standard ruler Bhairav all of the son of nostrils committee rather he wanted his mother to have nacos nauseous he wanted his mother so he went down to davon in front of rava now let's remember of is the man who argued with the elders of medusa Omar he's davon Inc cassabi the pumper DISA like the elders implement this meaning when he does cause aerosol shots he doesn't say as Rover once he should say which is Mikado she's royal instead he says Mikado a Shabbos omekata to solve Osman on whether was Shabbos am de filet on my level I'm in de and Rover said absolutely nothing he did not protest Alma says the Gemara this would seem that huh debate over rather retracted from his position in other words rather did not protest because Rover perhaps disagreed and then later huh debate over he retracted from his positions to whether it was Shabbos or Yom Tov rather would have said McCallister all bulla said Mikado Charles Mackerras old man my rubber was fine with it he doesn't mean he doesn't mean necessarily protests it means if if if it's the wrong no sock it's a question were you sir not protestors to embarrass but we need so do you have to redo it robber was fine that means your ever felt that it's good huh debate over grab NASA Nevada rabona AB nos and the father of rabona who was be Raider of naasson he was the son of ribbon Austin ribbon Austin was the father of Ramona Ruben is the son of ribbon awesome nothis comedian of Papa he is the schlafzimmer in front of her papa amar casaba the pump Adisa Reb Nelson does it like didn't know suck of the elders Medusa the shop here if Papa and if Papa praises him again whether it was Shabbos a yump if we don't know but he either says my condition happens in conditions over as money he does not say my college is wrong amirev in so what do we see from here that riff Papa to embraced the sheet of pomp and is a mere veneer of innocence and nautical asura I once came to a city called Sura in Babylonia comida Miramar it was in front of me Rima Miramar was the Russia Shiva of the yeshiva of Sura the novice Commissioner hooded Subura and in his presence Ashley a zipper went down to Davin Veronica summer the pump Adisa and he followed the text of the elders were medusa for have a machete lay Kula alma and the whole world meaning the whole community tried to silence him they protested as dominique because they wanted he should davon like ruther so the Mushaf he lay means they were making a quiet they were saying sha sha sha you're not a good cousin I'm Milo who Miriam I spoke up and he said chef cool leave him alone he'll his circus avid the producer the halacha follows the elders of pomp Adisa knocked her over velour from a shot cool a and they listened to him and they stopped silencing him in other words they realized that it's fine and the no sack of pomp Adisa prevails and hence indeed today what do we do we do like the nurse turkleton producer we say in Davin a Mikado Shabbos and jumped if we say Makati to solve Osman ah and and the reason is because all of these people embraced it and even rather it seems like that robber himself rather himself perhaps retracted retracted the position so therefore maja waka we embraced this view to say Mikado Java has mana I saw that the Massif de Gemara in there this Kumari in their in their footnotes says that the mugging of ROM in in Sonora and cement of pays ayan he says that be evident fallow rather meaning if somebody said Mikado she's royal on Shabbos are yom tov by dominant you fulfill the obligation and you do not have to davon again so which is fascinating in other words by kiddush if you would send Mikado schuster all it's not good you have to do it again because if they Mikado Shabbos even according to Nova but de Morgan around postions Liholiho that despite this Gomorrah if you follow raava you're good but the evident how locals like Pompidou sir but if you followed Rover you're good that's what he dinars so the carbon asano and massages baits and the initial Mossad them say this small genome doesn't make sense the Gomorrah clearly says that the robber retracted his position robbery granted his position and he said you have to say macintosh' Shabbos so how in the world can can the Magan ever on task in this like the mission of Brewer for example says you weren't yet sir the Prima Gotham says you were you'd said with the effort you were you exhibit the effort why because that's what the mother my gonna have romp as kids but if the Gomorrah says that rather himself retracted it so there's no position anymore like that so look honey you shouldn't be it even be the avid to ways of learning it obviously the mugging of ROM learns that you rather wouldn't protest it but it doesn't mean he agreed that's the way to do it he felt that the ever did fall upon per distance so you don't have to you don't have to tell the guy do a new Schmoyer Astra then when the gomorrah says hard their barrier of it doesn't mean he retracted his position he retracted his position but the ever been out Mahakala he would try to his position meaning he gave room for Pompidou said that if you did it it's fine he position is not so strong that he will be legitimize your Davin Ely fallibilism but it's not that he retracted his position in the sense that he doesn't hold what he holds he still holds what he holds that the Chattanooga Mara that's why if you do like her over your Yeats it cuz that was rubbish it even though but the effort mother would agree whatever would agree with with pompe with competition why why does the mother never um say this because Roberts Vera was a very strong smaller you know that Robin knew their side and he still said say Mikado sister all because the Robin so it's hard to say that Robert just said now this is this is this is a mistake because Robert understood their position and then he said his position that means it was a fourth flu process if it's a little rather what did it why did he regret it suddenly so they were the monkey never learns that he didn't regret it he just regretted the fundamentalism of it meaning he regretted that even with the ever do not the ER itself he regretted the idea that his position is the only position but the everything remember this this farce Emma says in the Gomorrah in Osibisa that Bates enough in Zion that really Robert did retract from his position however the stories that the Gomera brings shows that the Gomorrah holds the Gomorrah holds that if somebody concludes the Dominic like rather you'd see a deja vu say that's the idea in other words Robert himself PACA regretted it but the fact that the Gomorrah brings a miser that that in surah they protested it yeah the Gomorrah brings it so interestingly the Gomorrah is saying that there is such a position and therefore them are gonna run past goons that Biddy Evan he could do it and he says that's why if popper praised Rab Nasim why did he praise him why did he praise him let me ask you a question if you get up on Baca sorcerer shots today yeah and you davon the regular Hazara shots yeah I'm gonna come over to you and say oh thank you for not dominant gamekeepers Dominic oh you did the right thing this is why did you praise somebody when there's an alternative it's not what I'm saying you could have done otherwise it's a very interesting heart wrap up appraised them but there was an alternative cuz bid the ever do you could do like her over so I'm praising you because if not it was the only option I could thank you for doubting but it's not a special praise I don't go over to the ball carrier by the Megillah on Purim and say oh thank you for not reading you know the tissue of Korea cetera I mean in the stencil this Misamis says the failure of pop appraised them that's the proof that with the nvidia kabir it's like rava even though rover himself retracted retracted his position oh so Maury my told his people don't scream at Ashley excimer whose Davin II like pumpin DISA right he says chef COO leave him alone coaster sicker suffered upon padishah leave him alone ayahuasca like somebody will minister in other words he's telling them don't scream at the Schnee chipper it sounds like it sounds like what did they hold they hold mom they held mom much like rover and it's not that he said that you won't be Yoda Dominic you will be a chat Avenue but with the effort but the hollows like okay it's both you same hundred Savas monomer that's the if that rover retracted on Shabbos yup there was not such a hit that she right but there's still a difference even on Yom Tov because McConaughey servoz mononym is talking about best in Makati she starts talking about the Jews in show yeah so it's still a very big difference you're spoken about you straw you're right you're a hundred percent right yeah you're right gotta visit blessed to be in shows like you let it do but because we're Mikado's in other words it wasn't Bowie opening up an interesting question opening up an interesting question this was the argument between the do command the hakama who's fired him was them it mean Maharaja Shabbos they said means the day after Shabbos we're sorry Miriam always starts on a Sunday by hook or by crook the hazael said Maharaja Shabbos means Maharaj um it starts the second day of Pesach any day of the week it's a huge knife commander for them slammer always starts on a Sunday Lewis is always on a Sunday because the seven week starts Sunday they and Shabbos and show us is the fiftieth it's always gonna be on a Sunday in this three years calendar it happens to be that it works according to the DoCoMo song but cuz cuz it started Sunday the first day pacer horse was Shabbos my sorry Shabbos we start its various time I schmooze this year's gonna be Sunday and Monday this year but the Kazaa were vehemently against them there's also diem in office version of Anzac I had a whole debate and he said not Maher says Shabbos is Maher assumptive now according to traditional mickr they're right says sharpest doesn't say yom tov rashly says it can't be Shabbos cuz if it says Shabbos you have to tell me which sharpest just fifty fifty Shabazz in my year right you have to say maha receptive because we're talking about Pesach so today after I'm Shabbos is too ambiguous the Gomorra brings a whole proof a bunch of proves that Shabbos here doesn't mean sharpest yeah the Rambam concludes and we saw this cell has been done every single year by Jews and the carbon diamond was brought not on Sunday was born in the second day of Pesach and that's when you start to count what what was behind the argument so one of the explanations is a safer called clay femme de from the mayor Don Platz key remarried on plucks key was one of the great rabbis of Warsaw before the war before the Holocaust mayor done plots key was a huge gone hero to save a called clay femme de on Hamish on Tara in the introduction I think the clay hem that I saw he explains the argument based on this he says it's a gavel the convert that stuck him did not accept Irish ababa only terrier mix of why they said we have no problem with God giving us mitzvahs what we have a problem is that humans are capable of absorbing and analyzing and giving us a verdict of what God wants the process of terrible power which includes human analysis you'd give Moe mythos and arguments that has nothing do with God that's where Judaism ends Judaism ends after tears of itself didn't accept airavata they wouldn't accept son Hedren where does it come out most and the hillock of Shabbos injunctive Shabbos is holy it's divine Yom Tov is based on human subjective analysis it's not holy so there can't be a witch see is that the terror would call Yom Tov Shabbos never yom tov would never be called Shabbos why because it's a human creation so therefore they argue democracy Shabbos has to mean Shabbos because I understood the exact opposite no it says that you should make young turf but the fact that best and decided this is recited ish that's their thing and they therefore it's not it's it's not subject to the same level of holiness okay but I can also decide your decision has not ended with God it's your decision they didn't accept that concept that human beings can become channels for the gods will didn't accept it they often did their own thing yeah you see that used to they used to light torches on the mountains to deceive the crowd when risque dish was to make a different pace of all 2d legitimize the sanhedrin that's where they started to send out Slocum they wanted to keep yeah they didn't want to accept as they would they would deceive everybody cuz they held this whole best in as a fairytale the Christian this is one step further he says and where do you see the difference Yom Tov you're allotted cook for ISIL nefesh right Shabbos you're not what's the idea of ISIL nephesh that you should enjoy you should you should enjoy what's that idea that idea is that God is saying that holiness is not only when you don't eat the holiness of yom tov is expressed in the fact that you're doing something for the benefit of the jewish people to eat because that is also holy but that still can would not this accept that they said no no no no this is a completely different level etc so this was actually according to him the argument about a mockery so Shabbos no but Yom Kippur also needs to restore this the 10th of Tish it's not like Shabbos sharpest doesn't need to restrain the shop is just needs the seventh day right as long as we don't lose sight of the seventh day we know when Shabbos is the question is if during history that they ever lose sight know that if the world goes unconscious for a few days civilization and we don't we wake up we don't know when Shabbos so it's not the 7th anymore so then in other words did you ever can you ever imagine that all of humanity fell asleep and lost sight of the come we woke up it's Wednesday morning no it's actually Friday morning and then we're doing the wrong Shabbos since then right it's certainly possible right everybody smoked up one day and they lost consciousness for 24 hours you don't know where we're holding right so then again you wouldn't need people well we don't say that we say that Shabbos continued it's literally the seventh day and we're still this today is today is Wednesday to be without slavka we finished saying the Haggadah explaining Pesach matzah morrow thanking Hashem Lathika an aikidoka of him saying how low the first chapter two chapters of hallow making the final blessing Baraka Tarja Malik animal hello Meshuga la Nova Gullah service am Amit sir I am a corner of tyre for the quarterback Eve a hole longer blessing about the future redemption we finished by rocket our sham golly sir oh we made a guff for guffin we drank the second cup of wine so we are done with two cups of wine there is the meal of course and now the mission to continues to the Seder that follows the meal which we call after Magadh we have rocked so might see mats America oxygen IRA soften and now we're about to discuss the Seder after the meal mozgov like Ashley she they poured for him or diluted for him a third cup of wine I'm a very calm is ina and the person blesses Hashem for his food which we call burkas Hamas and the grace after meals the fencing is done on a cup of wine then reveal we finish mentioning they poured 1/4 cup Gomer a love s a hollow and on this cup you finish the hollow and we know why the word is glimmer because unlike other times where you say the whole hollow together here we already started to say hollow before the meal and we're only finishing the hallow we start today we start like may say hello from Loyola no Hashem la la no and we go to the end of hallo but we don't finish with hallo the amirul of business a shear on this fourth cup of wine you also say another blessing called the blessing of the song and the mission doesn't tell us what burkas our share is what's the blessing of the song some type of song and blessing that we're going to do after hallo which the Gemara is going to address what business are sheer is and the mission to concludes and says baina crisis hallo between the cups meaning between the first two and the last two numerate solicitors Ishta if you want to drink additional wine you can drink when you finish the second cup of wine there's a whole space in this say there till the third cup of wine there's going to be a whole meal you can drink as much wine as you wish they initially reveal Aisha but between number three and number four you should not drink any wine meaning once I bench and I drink a cup of wine now a middle of hollow I may want to drink another cup of wine or after benching I may want to trigger another cup of wine or a middle of Enosh MA so whatever it is he says not between the third and the fourth you should not drink any wine even though between one two and three four you could drink as much wine as you want the question is why not why not ah that's the question what about between one and two and what about after four right between one and two can you drink in others while I'm saying the Haggadah I already drank up one after kiddush I didn't drink up - can I drink the middle of that God the cup of wine to make it a little more exciting or after the fourth cup of wine which is at the end of the Seder can I drink more wine ah laughter Chi Minh was already eaten that the cover was eaten before been laughs the gun was it Deaton huh right but we did drink we did drink two cups of wine after that Fatima okay so that's the question that's the question cuz we did we didn't eat after that requirement but we did drink two cups of wine after that requirement so he's asking can you drink more after the for a cup of wine so we'll break it down the way the rash bomber understands it is if you take a look in the Raj bomb Ben gimel dalet la Ishta don't drink between three and four Mozza burger Mauricio shall me I found in your shall me meaning in tal Madeira shall me la mala leche de why not kadai shallow your sake so you shouldn't get drunk de su ly motsi LeMay Mahalo if after the third cup you say you know what I want another few cups of wine you'll probably get an e Bree ate it and you won't be able to say hallo anymore and we really want you to say howl it's a mitzvah to say how who para Qasim so the US Army asks a good question well like farmer Shakur who this guy by now should be drunk already sure chef Sycamore her baby so does say if you let him drink between he drank one he drank to between two and three you let him drink as much as you wanted the whole meal so he's probably drunk already if you're really afraid of him being drunks and then prohibit all extra wine you're saying you can't drink after cup three because he might get drunk and you won't do Hollow but by letting him drink a whole meal you already made him drunk oh very good tres OMA shamisen US Army says no no you got a not a drink yah in sherbert I saw muslin a name is Chaka Chaka I'm awesome a shocker when they drank a middle of the meal it did not get them drunk it was part of the meal it did not get them inebriated we're not worried about that we're worried about the drinking after you bench after the meal and now you're just drinking drinking alone that's where the great inebriation and toxication comes who are dena me the eye inshallah fineö Muzzin a name a chakra also wine before the meal as a preparation for the meal didn't get them drunk Rimrock solicitors been written with Shane a yeast dough Lyman Maya Tana Ella being gimel dalet which is why between 1:00 and 2:00 we don't care if you drink many cups of wine the time' only excluded to you three and four witches after the mail in other words the wine that you drink as a prelude to the meal opens up the system and you're good the wine that you drink a middle of the meal as part of the meal and you're good the wine that you drink after the meal this has the qualities of inebriation and intoxication and it's very likely if you drink extra you'll get drunk you won't be able to say howl this is how the Raja bomb understands the sugi of the Mishnah based on the Gemara shaman which is an interesting observation I don't understand this because I'm not a connoisseur and I don't know about drinking but that's what they say they say that when you drink the middle of the meal before the male it has a different quality huh deduce it enough amiss and what do you say aha decision in a jiffy they teach you feel up to your stuff use a lot of fat listen observe selfie yeah that's I mean left up and says if you drink oil before I never tried it myself but you Pig well it slows down the absorption when it hits you all at once that's the problem better and what does that do what is the fat though so you don't get drunk for example what did you the agents when they want to bet they pretend that they truly they're not drunk while they're eight before very well he says in the connect a GB with tweeters their age he grew up in Russia I grew up in the Soviet Union fascinating so when the KGB they would train their agents to get drunk they had to eat fat before right oil of fat so that would absorb the alcohol chicken soup that would absorb the alcohol and you don't get inebriated he would drink oil and that would absorb the so you could drink a lot with somebody the other guy gets smashed and tells you all the secrets and you're you're sober and that was the KGB's way yes exactly so that's what the US Army is teaching us that you could drink as much as you want as long as it's the middle of your meal in middle of your meal well once you benched and now you're on and to the Seder and you're in middle of this howling you want to drink now the your Sami says no I mean gimel adalat lowest and he says even between one and two is not a problem I can't you say close it's why you can't drink extra foxes otherwise it doesn't become who you should be doing the real are you drinking because that's always do it doesn't show that you're having it well that's a good question this is reason number one in the middle of the meal it's not a problem before the meal is not a problem and the read before the mill is not a problem is I guess because you're gonna eat in a few minutes and that will dilute it that will neutralize the impact but after you're eating and you're not gonna eat afterwards this is where we are afraid of impact so that is one perspective this is how - bomb - bomb learns Buster comes first right I should just add not everybody agrees with this rush bomb some say there are bomb is right about the middle of the meal that's what the Mishna says clearly that you could drink between the cups of one between one and two since it's before the meal so many posts can disagree with the rajah bomb and say you shouldn't drink even between one and two only between three and four and in fact the Shulchan Oracle has basic says that unless there's a great need you should try to avoid drinking between cup one and cup - but of course between two and three is not a problem however there's another way of looking at this earlier Dov Kavkaz Dheeraj bomb said the reason you're not at a drink between cup three and cup forests because of what you're saying cause near akamai cephalic Isis it looks like you're adding more to the number of four cups of wine since the hakama instituted to drink four cups of wine tonight so why are you adding adding another cup of wine looks like you're adding to the number of cups that they instituted and that would be the reason for the prohibition oh right the question is I bizarre I bizarre why would they allow you to add cups right but you you're pouring another cup of wine so that itself seems like you're adding you add it yet you're adding to the drink he says however according to this excuse me why would they allow you to drink earlier he says the reason they would allow you to drink earlier is because drinking will trigger the appetite to eat matza so therefore there's a value in it but after the first third cup of wine you already ate everything so there's no value in drinking the cup of wine to trigger the appetite in the dish mark and eating matzah so because of the opposite concern like you're adding to the four cups of wine therefore the Mishnah prohibited it the tie service brings another reason to prohibit it a third reason why you shouldn't drink after the third cup and the reason that toys just brings us so that the taste of matzah should linger in your mouth since you a Daffy climber and you drank a cup of wine don't drink so much wine to neutralize the taste of the matzah in the mouth this is based on a locker a mouth tyrion a Carmack's afikoman that we don't want to eat afterwards we want to linger so this is a completely different reason why we don't drink after the third cup even though earlier we could drink because this is after that requirements as you said we drink what we have to move we don't want to add and neutralize the taste of the matzah in our mouth that's that's that's that's later that's that's reveai mala god--all it's it's on a later it is on this page but it's later in the toy service we'll see but the toy service is on a later piece of Gemara now is also in this toy service yeah but this placeis is not on the mission at something amar the first reason we said because of intoxication would apply of course before the fourth cup why before the fourth cup because you didn't finish how well yet as long as you didn't finish how long they don't want you to drink another cup because you might get drunk once you finish the fourth cup according to the first reason in the Raj bomb you could drink as much as you want I don't care if you get drunk because you're ready finish to say there who cares so you could drink 20 cups of wine after you finished the fourth cup that's only according to the reason of the Raja bomb then you would be a lot of drinking allowed you to go home night but according to the second and third reason what was the second reason it shouldn't look like you're adding cups of wine and according to the third reason not to neutralize the taste of the matzah so then even after the fourth cup you now let a drink till the morning because you don't want to get rid of the taste of the matzah and you wanna make it appear that you're adding more to the four cups of wine so basically if you're a lot of drink at the end of the Seder or not depends on how you understand this mission of why you shouldn't drink between the third and fourth according to the third reason first first reason you would be a lot of drink because you're ready finish the Seder you're not sure we don't care if you get drunk and according to the last two reasons it shouldn't be my cephalic Isis or the matzah tasted remain in your mouth you don't want to drink even after you finished all say there until the morning another big difference would be according to the first reason the only problem is drinking wine or other inebriating beverages according to the second reason any beverage on which you could be mcian four cups of wine would be a problem right and according to the third reason any liquid would be problematic right besides water some say a lot of do water even though the minute we buy some it's not to do water but some say that water is not a problem so that's why we don't drink usually after the said Josh mom held you are allowed to drink well you don't eat after the same you don't drink after the said water some say it's fine although others have a custom not even to do water I mean if a person is hydrated then doctor Gemara Amalek another other of common said to ravish mommy not because I wasn't on the course from here we learn that benching requires a cup of wine why the Mishnah said clearly that the third cup of wine you drink after been Cinque so clearly burkas Amazon needs a cup of wine the question is the after mentioned a cup of wine like kiddush and Abdullah if they want a cup of wine you have to mention a cup of wine so he says clearly it seems that you have to have a cup of wine a male rava said now our ball cost CT Clara Bond and Eric Harris the rabbi's instituted that we drink Pesach night four cups of wine in order to behave in a manner of freedom and liberty people who are free people who are regal and roil I have accustomed to drink wine so drinking the wine is part of our re experience of liberty and freedom on this night hence call Harv Akkad Navin Ben Mitzvah because they anyway instituted four cups of wine instead of just drinking them consecutively they also instituted that each one of them should be joined with a mitzvah in other words drink each cup together with a mitzvah that's I guess the ultimate freedom ultimate freedom is doing a mitzvah English have been farinelli Misha is sick but IRA so therefore every cop join with a mitzvah that's why we chose to do the third cup together with bench in other words really you could say that bench ink doesn't require a cup of wine but the night of paces we try to join each cup with a mitzvah so the first cup we join with kiddush that's not our that's no-brainer we do it always the second cup we join with what do we do with the second cup the second cup we do the Haggadah and the blessing Tasha sham for gula we thank our Shem for Google the third cup of wine we join with which mitzvah bench in burkas a Muslim and the fourth cup of wine we join with the mitzvah of saying hallo that's the point so rava tells rakonin there's no proof from here and therefore as a result of this debate in the Gemara this question and answer the question is what's the conclusion those British I mustn't need a cup of wine or does it not need a cup of wine Rubicon and try to prove it rava said there's no proof so some say that breakfast a Muslim does require a cup of wine because Robert did it negate it Robert just said you don't have proof from the Mishnah but Robin never said that it's wrong so therefore some say because I'm Oz and needs a cup of one others say no robbers rejection was an absolute rejection it's two ways of learning how the driver rejected the driver reject the proof but rather maintained the idea he still believed in the idea or he said no the whole thing doesn't begin because a Muslim does not need a cup of wine and the Seder night is a different night according to this you wouldn't need a cup of wine so this is really two different this and pasta that are brought in chuckle not if they need a cup of wine or not a cup of wine some say you do need a cup of wine and others say you don't however everyone has made that it's a mitzvah man I'm her it's a great thing to have a cup of wine in other words it's always good to have a cup of wine the question is is it an obligation like you have to go look for a cup of wine or it's just a heater or hinder Mitzvah and that itself the question is is it when the one person is benching or only when three people are benching or ten people are benching then it becomes a mitzvah minim of her or it becomes an obligation and these are different views that I brought in our locker based on the interpretation of the Gemara okay so going to get more of it-- raviga middle of a sahal will buy me love breakfast a chef on the fourth cup you finish halal and you say Bertha such the question is my breakfast I share what's Bertha session we know what halel is what's breakfast are she repeated Amida Buddha says yeah lulu hashem elokenu called moussaka all the way to Baraka Tasha MELAS maluma - Bacchus it's basically the blessing with which we conclude hallo every restrain - and every umph if after we finish hallo with the words hi do lovscheim caterpillar LM Cosmo what do we do we have a special blessing right yeah Luca Sharmila Cana called moussaka kasi death cuts a dick in my series say nothing cabeza but in a yo-yo workshop too far with cetera maja - Floyd is Lachine Canal is a Macumba dial-o-matic el buro Qatar sham MELAS was that his business to share the view this says that's what the mission of means you don't just do hallo you finished the blessing after hallo and that's why it's called burkas a share because it's basically the blessing that's associated with the song which song the song of how well it's the bracha after the sheer after you finish you finish shower now what would be the finish every yump if we do the whole hallo but by the seder we split up the hollow so maybe when you do the second half you don't have to do the brush at the end so the Mishna says you have to do because because a the interesting question is do you have to do the bracha before hollow on the night of the seder usually before we say hallo we always make abraca I show you the channel no trace of its Eve oh no Lucretia challah and the interesting thing is that there's a mock likeness of the rishonim even though we don't make the brush but some of the restrain them hold there you have to make a bracha before you say hallo on the night of pace after the tournament is over Silvano look ah hollow and lemur or liquor i right we didn't either we made those who Davin and say hallo yeah yeah but the Ashkenazim don't say how little bastard Avenue right right right however many of the posts can hold that that Howell does not need a broker the night of pace of Howell doesn't need of a broker and if you say that halal needs abraca at the end you might say it needs a block in the beginning also others who say doesn't even Brock in the beginning it doesn't need a broker at the end and burkas sasheer is something that you add at the end but it's not that Howell essentially essentially needs a bra lapel a locker we don't make a brach on the Seder we don't make a brach on hollow before we start hollow we do not and the reason that most people say is because the Howell has not said as midst of of Korea sallal of reading Howell just a sheer it's like a song it's a praise it's a different genre of of saying hallo the hallo by daven eing those who say libido of course you make a Bronco that's the regular reading of how will we you know make a break in middle o hallo this is a different type of howl it's not the reading of the whole ha well it's just like calling from howl - praise God maybe I shoulda number knishmas call hi that's not what Bertha's are she means professor sheer is not the Hallelujah professor share is the prayer known as knishmas call hi which we say every charm is injunctive when we finish suka does Imre before you Starbuck and it starts off with the words knishmas call hi tovarisch as shem crush I'm Alec I know the soul the consciousness of every living organism blesses God and it finishes off of course with estaba simcha vas a estar buxom Khalid Baraka Tom Kayla and God l'm all about the schmucker's abortion Bashir is in Ramallah Jakob Kayla and wiser called birth azocheer because it's full of sheer it's full of sheer of song and praise to Hashem and that's why it's called big Hoss ha sheer so we have an argument at breakfast of shares yalla Luka hashem elokenu or cashier is knishmas call hi avala Luca as you know and our say that what we do we do both of them we finish hallo we say hallelujah and we also do the knishmas turn rabona the rabbi's taught raviga marialuisa hallo the fourth cup you should finish hallo on the fourth cup of I'm ER hallo hagatha and you also say on the fourth cup halel Haggadah which we're going to explain the great hallo you say on the fourth cup now give rate of paraffin these are the words of Reb - the ashram others say you also say Psalm 23 bismillah David Hashem ie lie after you finish the meal and you say this Psalm God is my shepherd I shall not want that's the yesh I'm ray asks the Gemara may - hallouwe god--all where does how well how God will begin we know that hallo Hagaddah Liz - hilum chapter kilometer of but where does it begin from she says Rav Yehudah Omer may who do at Nara suavo it starts with capital kilometer of which is how you do la sham ki Tov KLM Casa de hoy de lo que Ella Kim Killam cars dates basically 26 hyeju's we thank our Shem and we go through all of Jewish history moisten the floors does Lavar day in the creation of the world lie session my name is Fernando Collor tomorrow I said I'm gonna tell them the first part of it is the beginning of creation then we go to MIT ceramic emit Steinbach idea and we go to ETS mr. I am and we finish off chef chef flay knows our car long ago car through the cane it nice and left him with all bicycle alum has died howler monkey little macaws day that finishes capital kilometers of the next capital is cough llama time which begins our narrows bubble shamya shavano gamba she know we sat at the rivers of babylon babylon where we wept she says from how you do till Elmira's bubble and of course valet add the clown not elmyra's bubble so you finish off with Killa that's hallo legado rebuking annoy me mushiya malice add an iris bubble he started off from capital Kalama dalit Shira malice he neighbor who is Hashem call after Hashem I'm the member layla sue you day from Kadesh and then there's a whole other capital a Luka Lewis Sheamus Emmylou of their shell Shabbos morning we say all this right before the big high dose we do capital cough lawmen hey capital cough lama Dalit according to regulation and that is hallouwe godlet includes three chapters of tehilim unlike ruby hood the back of a Yaakov amar Miki aqueous buffer lawyer car Adam Aras bubble he's somewhere in the middle it's not all the way from cough Lama del but the middle of kilometres Apothic kia kaha like are he straw elias gula site all the way till Elmira's bubble which is column at Sian well I'm gonna crush my hollow had God though how did it get this name the great hollow the grand Hollow Amira be ocean attribution and says mie pene chakra - Miroku Yosh of Baloo Marshall I'll um because the theme of this howl is that Hashem sits in the height of the world in the height of the heavens and of the universe and nonetheless his Providence his care concerns and is directed towards the most humble tiniest creature on earth o Michalek mazzani's little barrier he orchestrates the plan and distributes food and nutrients to every every little creature the smallest ant has a plan the smallest mosquito the beetle and the Wow the wasp and the roach and the bug everyone the smallest barrier he sits in infinity and distributes food you know like a soup kitchen he distributes food to endless endless creatures but not hundreds not millions and not and not billions endless I mean not endless but astronomical amounts of creatures of each need their own source of food fungi yeast bacteria whatever it is under the water aquatic creatures whether it's under the water it's above the water where is this in this passage we say hi doula al hashamayim killer l'm car nice Inlet gamla kielbasa right the last ones move again nice and lessen the cold bathroom has a high delaila shamayim column has disease that's the hallelula girdle the contrast and the juxtaposition the God of heaven which is the God of infinity is busy running a soup kitchen and giving out bread to like a kidder she's in charge of the big kiddush and gives out bread and food to every single level that that juxtaposition inspired the sages to call it halal haggle that's the sign of greatness the sign of greatness is not that you're great the sign of greatness is that you distribute food to the tiniest of creatures I was on Asylum Kula the tuvo right on the end of the blessing as honest I Kolya under the bush people died from starvation but that's the guilt of the regime's that they're under because the planet Earth has the resources so here we come into the big question why does God allow people to do such terrible things to their own people that's a big question that goes beyond food right ah what Stalin did to Ukraine ah yeah and what the zealots did in Jerusalem at the end of the Second Temple Arab Jew Andrew they burnt they burnt the grain etc and what the Germans did to their subjects the way they starved them this was part of the torture of the Glee so when we say house own asylum cooler a bit too vibe a shame ahead and I say so many people are suffering from malnutrition God actually created our earth that has the resources to feed humanity especially with the advance of Medicine and science and biology and artificial artificial a fertilizer right artificial synthetic fertilizer created in the early 1900's by Fritz Haber our German Jew who created what we call bread from heaven he took nitrogen gas amino acid and he developed artificial fertilizer because they didn't have enough food Klee didn't have enough dung to fertilize the crop and Fritz Haber did this that's all parts of the resources that God invested in the planet to be able to develop and build on it and I believe mr. Hebert is responsible today for the lives of approximately two or three billion people speaking about Jews and their contributions to humanity I believe that close to a third of human of human civilization owes its life to a German Jew by the name of Fritz Fritz Haber whose wife was also Jewish received the first female to ever receive a PhD she translated his works to English and think about the Jewish contribution to the world third of the world is alive today because of Fritz Haber's artificial fertilizer but these are all part of the resources that God put into the world the fact that regimes and governments due to their corruption and sting genus deprived their children from food that's part of the evil that we have to fight against a Jewish German chemist that's what rabbi YY tells you I know I know okay so I'm telling you the truth I'm telling you the truth he died in 1934 in Basel on the way to Israel the Germans threw him out from his office and Heian Weitzman offered him to run the scientific Institute yes yes there's a dark side to him there's a darker side to his story as well yeah there's a darker side but that's that's another part of it yeah there's another side to historian from nitrogen gas right I'm just saying the world has tremendous resources if we don't utilize that people suffer yeah the food stamps we Kuwait Waco yeah chasm chasm the Congresswoman chasm a black congresswoman yeah huh Shirley chairs ah a black woman congresswoman right yeah may amazing story she said it publicly she was chosen to be a congresswoman here in the days when segregation between whites and blacks still was intact and her district was Crown Heights and Shay and her her colleagues and politics didn't respect her as a black woman and they basically didn't she didn't find any dignity and they gave her a job which is the worst job for congresswoman in Brooklyn to basically deal with agriculture and farming that has to do with Brooklyn yeah like like you're an expert on kangaroos in New Zealand and one day she was summoned by the lubavitcher rebbe he asked her to meet he wants to meet her and he asked her about her job it's a crazy story and she said how disappointed she is that they can't accept blacks Foreign Relations Committee she had experience there they put her with agriculture she's a Brooklyn woman her district was Crown Heights so the rebus said I actually see a tremendous opportunity what do they do with all the surplus of food that they have what's what's happening with all the extra wheat and grain and produce and I'm wondering because if I'm not mistaken a lot of that goes to waste and there are hungry children in America especially black hungry children in America we could take that and feed them look into it develop a program and she's like wow and she literally as a result developed an entire program that we know today as food stamps came from that she realized that is an extraordinary amount of surplus and she basically started to distribute it and not ten families hundreds thousands thousands of hundreds were saved from Amish being they were below the poverty level and malnutrition this is the 1960s so she shared this whole story how it developed and within a year or two it just Incredibles is within a decade people couldn't praise her enough in the level of prestige and prominence that she got was extraordinary not only because of the vision but because of the impact and the people that were helped so she said this whole story and she finished the speech and she said so some black kid in some black kid in there which is in Indiana some black kid in Mississippi doesn't go hungry today and he has milk and bread on his table in abundance he should know that he got to say thank you to Rabbi Menachem Mendel Schneerson acidic rabbi in Brooklyn that's Charlie Charlie it was the name shirley shirley chisholm look up the story black real black woman's huh I grew up with black black people I grew up in in a integrated community I grew up in an integrated community Lefferts Park of course of course we played with that we are yeah we also fought with them I mean we did everything with them I once had a boy come to yeshiva where I taught in Brooklyn and he was valedictorian and he was on the dean's list of one of the top graduates in NYU psychology and then he discovered Yiddish kites and he decided he's going to yeshiva and his parents freaked out okay and I still remember the day he was new she was learning Amara and he gets a call from his father and I see that he's broken so I call him over I said what does your father saying so he lets me hear his father's telling him basically that you were abducted by fundamentalist Orthodox people a cult they strip you from everything you had a bright future you were integrated into side it was a nice conservative Jewish family and now you're gonna become a member of a cult and a fundamentalist and they don't believe in the rights of women and they don't believe in integration and minorities and a suppressive culture you don't think anymore this is a and and you don't belong there and you should leave and come back to the regular secular culture etc so and the boys broke like nineteen years old a serious boy a final buckle and he was he was learning an intelligent person also he was much Lia he was doing well so I I said give me the phone I took the phone I play it as dumb as it gets and I said hi my name is rabbi YY Jacobsen and I'm privileged to be a teacher and I'm watching your son grow and I just want you to be proud of your son because I'll tell you what we do every single day now we have a huge break we go to Lefferts Park in Crown Heights and we're gonna play basketball baseball football with African Americans and I said that's something you guys don't get to do in Teaneck New Jersey in Teaneck you speak about integration and liberalism and open-mindedness but here we train the boys to experience it they play every day for hours with black young men they learn about each other's life they exchange ideas they become developed people they become open-minded people Jews living in New Rochelle and Westchester and Tina can Englewood write our vol very open-minded but we have the experience and the influence each other learn about each other's lives and we grow from them and they grow from us and this is the best education then you get in life in order to become a civilized human being who can bring the world together he's like really you believe in that that said we believe in it we do it you guys preach it we do it we're going right now to play to play basketball with them all right and we do it and when you play with somebody for two and a half hours there's a bonding that's very deep because you know sports sports bonds people I said this is a training we're giving your boy so your boy is gonna become an expert in Judaism he's also gonna become an expert in social relationships with different types of people and he's gonna learn how to create cross-pollination and this he says wow that's amazing I never realized I said now now speak to your son he said okay you could stay in the yeshiva it's fine it's perfect today's a Russia Shiva this boy he heads his own yeshiva I know and I'm not but he's a Russian sheep Attila so that's the idea of of Michalek Mozilla's Lahab area that the rebind shall oilmen his height thinks about how to distribute food to every creature which is basically the essence of the food stamp program in the Gemara I think before was food stamps it was called something else wick wick right WIC women infants children yeah there's always another side to it I hear ya I used to go with the kids with the boys that we would play we play soccer a lot baseball football basketball [Laughter] I would just go with the boys too yeah yeah yeah in the afternoon they needed I found that as a teacher my philosophy was that as a teacher I bonded with them more on the field than in the classroom I could lecture to them six hours a day but it wouldn't have an impact like when they tackled me in a football game because it creates a certain trust and camaraderie that he can't get in the classroom so I found that the profoundest influence I can have on my students was by spending the two hours in the field more than all the sheer that's what I found I told it to teachers they sometimes think I'm crazy but it's a fact when you have teenagers and you bond with them on the field they see you as a person they open up to you and over they also you see a different side of them when you become this the teacher of Gomorrha of learning then there's always that distance and you know the guy that it's altum Utley they're not always in the mood you could be the best teacher but you know there's an element of boredom for teenagers especially even for adults but the air days you know there is bond with you and they it because you become like a different type of figure for them the mentorship is much profound that's why I did it I wasn't very good at sports unfortunately yeah yeah yeah yeah so usually they just do it on their own but I find one there's a teacher there right I'm a good sure she's Shiva there it creates a very powerful bond between the the mentor the teacher and the students ah thank you we can have a game from our class also I could have been a little better I'm gonna be Ashura behavior be shobun lady said honey SME shisha hadouken egged me why this hallouwe goggle divided in 26 how use why 26 fascinatingly connect it s envisioned irish-american Eduardo homeboy Lamar villainous and Lempira vasana in bahasa there were 26 generations from Adam till Martin Tara who did not get Tyra but nonetheless God fed them and he sustained them in other words before you give somebody Tyra you have to feed them 26 generations he gave and gave and gave and there were not much expectations there was no tighter if he would have given tighter to Adam you would say you work for me I feed you you learn Tyra I feed you but for 76 generations it was Kela eylem cows there was pure kindness there was no terror yet they didn't deserve it so to speak but nonetheless he fed them so that's why it's 26 how you do is cause the real Hesed comes out in the first twenty six generations of creation and i think there's a profound lesson here if you want to teach somebody Tyra I was just wondering was this stupid that I got into this discussion of me playing football with my students in a good marriage here and then I realized this is what the Gemara is saying if you want to that it tight if you want to teach them Tyra feed them first if you say let's learn and you'll go find your own food it's not gonna work feed them first and then they'll absorb the Tyra so it was actually not so off topic ah that's true this that's true most there were individual people who had the Shiva's there were individual people who had you she was like shame and Ava and her knives and was a shallow yeah her was knowing but it wasn't a universal property there was no nation or or regime or community or tribe that embraced it there were individuals who held on to the monotheistic traditions but you know where they were they were in basements they had little sh t block they used to have shallow shoulders with old sponge cake no no I'm serious we call a rum of into the first monotheists he was not the first monotheists to mistake who was a have rum as the founder he wasn't the first monotheists no it was a man a theist shaima's a man a theist a ver with a man a theist mr. Sherlock was a monotheistic was a man a theist the difference was they all had basements in the Lower East Side where they had herring and Malave Malka private and essential Australis irrelevant was the man who made it public he's the one who made it popular he was the one who who went out to the world you understand he made press conferences he changed the consciousness of the world but it still remained in the family ultimately his students were gone we don't know what happened to all of his students there's no memory of them and it was only in Egypt that a nation developed so that's the idea that Toyota was there but it was not a property of the world his children from Hager from cateura went to these but I said van nefesh a sha tsui Bukharan of Rama and Sarah influenced many people the me II rewrites in intro to brick llaves that of ROM changed half of human civilization he converted them to monotheism what happened to all of them by hits hook we don't have anybody left rom Dodds one of the mysteries in Judaism of ROM dies and everybody is gone one way of looking at it is they look that he had suck and they said he's not a good successor because he was different than everyone was very charismatic and yet took was very verted stay left or whatever other explanations but no we count this one at 64 years lost then it comes out at tomography you know it came but my sphere my intersection was around 10 years meaning he was a child when everyone was camera bit but came from another hobby who was Nimrod who had the power wouldn't reduce tradition she saying the Hammurabi was influenced by Rama VII or Robbie's colonies by Nimrod to to take something from the tour I don't know what exactly that's distorted only works some say Buddhism Brahmin they have a mantra Brahmin welcome pleasure to have you very nice when I've run was physically not there the energy was gone Mitzvah also offers you a choice I use Acharya an aroma afraid like volume at everybody this class is brought to you by the yeshiva dotnet please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot they ueshiba net / donate