0:00 / 0:00
Pesachim 117a - Who Composed Hallel? Who Wrote Tehilim? - Arvei Pesachim
189 views
This class was presented on Wednesday & Thursday Parshas Emor, 10&11 Iyar, 5779, May 15&16, 2019 at the Ohr Chaim Shul, Monsey, NY For Source Sheets: https://www.theyeshiva.net/jewish/6324
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
the yeshiva dotnet kufta Zion armored
Bayes the last line with a commoner high
oven the Gemara now moves off to a new
discussion a new suger the mission has
said that when we finished reading the
Haggadah the first section before the
meal and we drink the second cup of wine
right before we drink the second cup of
wine there is the beginning of how low
that we say either Tolima bonham smell
like be Shammai or Columbus lamine named
William like basil--oh and then we have
the blessing Lusaka national high of him
and the conclusion of Baraka Tasha Malik
Endemol hello ma chere Galano
regardless of a centimeter I am Reptar
ofin finishes it right there to be a
Kiva gives us a much longer text of the
blessing which also discusses the future
redemption through Messiah when we will
come back to bring the carbon pay stuff
in the carbon 4 Giga and we finished
with barakah Tasha I'm Gul you sir all
but the mission accorded that when we
thank Hashem at the end of the Haggadah
and we sail official connection of
heaven la jolla dice la jolla Lucia Bear
etc we finished off when we say the name
our love fun of how Lil Luca we we shall
say before him hallelu kha
which is of course the first word of
hallo the first word of howl is hallelu
hallelu Ave Hashem and that's in the
beat indeed what we do we begin to say
the hollow either the first chapter in
the first two chapters like basil--oh
which is the halacha that we do the
first two chapters of howl and then
later we finish the rest of Hollow after
the meal after benching with we begin
with Layla no or corn to be Shama we
would begin with bodacious Rama meets
Ryan when we do challah later in the
evening
so the Gomorrah says as follows amar Rab
is the Americana the priestess said in
the name of Revelation and here the
question is going to be addressed as how
do we explain the word ha
loo loo Co what is this word hallelu Co
the word hallelu co appears the first
time in tehilim
at the
of chapter Cove dalit Cove Dollard is
the chapter of Tulum that begins with
barfy nafsi we say it on Rosh Hodesh
right how does it end you remember Utah
makatea minarets will show you my denim
Barcena is a sham
hallo Luka that's the first time it
appears to Hill them 104 but after that
it's repeated numerous times in safer
tehilim the question is is hallelu qey
one word or is it two words is it
hallelu youth K praise Hashem and one of
the names of Hashem is you'd K so it's
towards one is the name of our Shem and
one is hallelu hallelu praise you Takei
or no that's a wrong understanding
hallelu cos actually one word hallelujah
it's one word which is basically praise
it just has a ute and hey at the end as
we will see to accentuate the meaning
for example we say in the morning Phil
Allah David he has the Haggadah alloy
the heat Sultan nafsi misha oil tax Tia
you have saved my soul from shila's the
abyss the Gehenna Musha Musha
also it's honest admission all cactus Oh
Michelle alpacas says Michelle Otaki yo
that's not Hashem's name it's just a
Hebrew way of accentuating the word like
the lowest abyss
maybe that's what hallelujah is and the
difference is do I say hallelu car or do
I say hallelujah right if it's two words
praise Hashem hallelu car if it's one
word just praise with a u-turn hey to
accentuate it then it's hallelujah
that's what it basically is that's the
question that's going to be addressed
now do you write it as one word do you
write it a towards if it's two words
it's like saying hallelu s Hashem
that's what it's like hallelu SRM and
it's one of Hashem names or the youth K
is not a holy name and therefore you can
erase it it has a very serious
consequence you a lot of race to you
decay of Allah Luka you know that a race
Hashem his name but a Hebrew word your
ladder a race hallelu car just means
praise and the urine there hey is not a
holy name rather the posix sometimes
adds you'd and hey which doesn't change
the meaning of the word like Ceylon now
Sri Michelle Castilla instead of taxes
which is until Allah David which is
capital pave of of tehilim in your high
school my mother if it says waha be Nia
or waha binya instead of waha Binion it
says if I have been you're just another
example that that the rash BAM brings so
the same is hallelujah is just like
saying hallelu praise or hallelu who
American American on a prison sending
every American on hallelujah the case
your via DDR aha sale hallelujah and
case your and you did er are basically
one complete word they are not two
separate words rip is this telling us
when it says hallelujah and tehilim
it's one word when it says case yeah
it's one word what is he referring to
the end of Paris mashaallah when the
Jewish people fight Amalek hashem tells
Moshe cured al Casey are milsim all a
sham bamileke me doridori you could say
case you Takei is towards the throne the
Keisei of hashem
that's one way of learning it like Rashi
says they're God's throne is incomplete
and God's name is incomplete until the
name of our mullick is blotted out so
cured i'll case you Takei my hand is
placed on the throne of Hashem and I'm
swearing
with my hands on my throne that the war
against a Moloch will continue for
generations so he says no Casey ah
there's not two words it's one word even
though in our safe at Toyota we write it
as two words but the quizzed in the name
of America none believe not that way
he believed that kasya has to be written
as one word the next one is you did yo
so basically yad al cassia is just
emphasizing the word throne that shear
the key say it's not a new word you did
yeah you did yeah is a story in small
base he calls the name of slow Maha Mela
Lovett son he says ye Karishma EDD ah is
it you did you Takei a friend of a sham
or is it no is the name is you did yeah
he did with a UA at the end so again the
blister holds it's one word the youth K
in all these three words case yeah you
did yeah and hallelujah are not a holy
name of Hashem they are the end of the
previous word even though she later was
called you Didier because he was a
friend of Hashem Hashem loved him Hashem
I avoid that's what he said that's why
he's calling him you did yeah that's
true but it becomes one name it was the
name was given because he is God's
friend but it becomes a name on its own
he did yeah it's not you did you Takei
and therefore I don't have to say he did
car I could say you did yeah yeah we
have Eliezer
why did my surname is son Eliezer Lak of
ibanez rewrite kala azar my God helped
me so we don't say Cayley Ezzor we say
Eliezer because even if the origin of
the name is to represent Hashem
salvation it becomes a mundane name
Eliezer the name is
roll is also Sark a lackey Suri similar
convey my notion you have different
names that it originates that way but it
becomes a regular name you Shia you Shia
right is again the Yeshua that comes
from you Takei you're me uh sorry Jose
sure you Takei so we don't say I'm not
going to say sky yeah I should say scar
car you don't do that right you've heard
a person say ginger kale
can I have ginger kale for soda right
okay so the piece that tells us cassia
you did yeah hallelujah are all akka
saying it's all one word there's no need
to divide it into two by us it's case
you decay two separate words yeah yeah
that's true
they say potato we have two words in
other words the Keisei of hashem case
you Takei and that so rashly explains it
and has I'll say that the word case is
written without an Olive case missing an
olive and the word you Takei is missing
both K because ain't ashamed solemn vain
hockey say solemn actually mawkish
masha'Allah Malak the cheer the throne
is incomplete and the name is incomplete
until I Malik has blotted out I'm Molly
compromises the integrity of the Keisei
and the name but if his do the name
direction and those are not learning
that he's learning that it's one word
case yeah another interesting thing is
does that McCleod cos between the ballet
I'm a scientist between those who
discuss how to write all the words in
the tamaak if the word case y and you
did you at the end do you have a point
in the hey do you have a little point in
a what we call mahpic hey like uh hal
leuco right it has that it's called a ma
PK and really it depends if it's one
word if it's two words if it's one word
there's no ma pick a case yeah if it's
two words case caught it has to have a
map okay
by hallelula everybody puts in a dot in
the hey whether you learn it as one word
or two words they always put an a dot in
the last day of our Luka so this is a
prison the name of rabbuna revoir
comes Robin says K Co America via
åkesson k CR and merica via Wisma Kavya
in Thailand in hallo
I mean her mates are coracii yo or Nani
by America via you could learn from
distress I called out Asha answer me by
America in expansive in his car he says
no Merc of yo is one word it's like
saying on Nani by America answer me from
a place of expansiveness we are just
accentuating the word by adding a youth
k like t yo or binya the same thing Merc
of yer but it's really one word it's not
Hashem's name just like case yo rubba or
my Abbas's mayor havea bill vod's only
marry Kavya is one word not the other
ones not Halle Luka not cassia not you
Didier only Merkava so we have three
views the praise in the name of
regulation on Hallelujah hates your you
did you Rev kasya and merica via rubber
only Marik of yours one word the other
ones are towards hallelu car case car
and you did come this is the opinion of
robber that all the other languages all
the other words that have the car really
represent two separate words Ebola who
they asked a question mass of your
little piece de Mai
what about Marik have your according to
the prisoner is it one word or towards
the pleased only mentioned hallelujah
cassia you did you rob added Marik of yo
robber greet America via what if what
does replace the whole by merica via he
doesn't say is it one or two are you al
are erased the UK you know
race to UK the Gemara says take ho let
this question stand because we don't
know what his opinion is okay it Boyle
that's another question you did yell
arrived my what does Arab hold about you
did yeah is it one word or two words in
other words is Arab arguing with
represent or is he just adding to the
prisoner release de said hallelujah case
you're you did you rob said Asia and
added Merc of young does he agree with
represented India and he's just adding
America via or no he's disagreeing with
them and he only holds Asia and Martha
via and would reject the notion that
hallelujah and you did yah one word it's
not clear what doesn't revolt is he
adding on a prisoner or is he
disagreeing with her pisda fundamentally
with appeased in the name of her be a
sinner
now on Rob but we don't have this
question cuz Rob said mayor havea bill
VAT only martha via so it's obvious that
the robber is disagreeing with the
former to view so that's not a question
the question is only on raft cause he
doesn't say case you're may have your
boulevard he just has case you're my
Kavya
so the Gomorrah says Tosh ma come and
hear and answer the on my Rav Rav once
said clearly you did your necklace and I
am you did you're indeed is to be
divided into two words you did call a
friend a beloved one of Hashem the
fickle you did coil and you're cockeyed
ish and that's why the he did part is
mundane you can erase it and the youth K
is holy and your knowledge a race it if
you did your was one word you can erase
the whole word we see clearly here that
Rav disagrees with replicas
means only case yeah only America via he
does not agree with the prisoner because
you did you're clearly he says is two
words you did car and the car is
clear he Baloo
they asked another question what about
hallelujah lira of my what would drive
hold about Alleluia we just proved that
when it comes to you did yo he disagrees
and he says it's indeed God not like her
pisda what about Halle Lucca does he
agree with the prison that you say
Alleluia and you can erase it or no does
he hold that hallelu and car two
separate words
now look higher you would think that
once the Gemara proved that by you did
car he's arguing so clearly he's arguing
with the prisoner so when he said Keysha
and mer kavya it means he rejects you
did you're so light it's clear that he
also rejects hallelu caride because when
he says case here Maccabi is not just
adding we just saw that he's disagreeing
so if he's disagreeing he's not adding
so then what's the question obviously
with Hello Luka he also he also
disagrees just think that it's a
different names nobody calls the polish
person X Y Rav would say you did cuss
two words I'll tell you what because the
same plastic finish as often says he was
called he called them you did yeah
because Hashem I havea cuz Hashem loved
him say foot maybe that's exactly how
you have to explain the word their name
Hashem I hate void you did of our shop
because the plastic explains it that way
or you could say that's as we said
that's the explanation of it but it
becomes something else
so tackle area pista holes you did years
one word and laugh we just proved
holders two words the question is what
does rather hold about how a Luca so we
could infer that that I have argues with
the above statement because we saw that
by you did Leo he argues that means when
he says case chair America via
he's being very specific he's not adding
he's being specific because he rejected
you did you did you that means he's also
rejecting how a look if not he would
have put it in his list because he's not
continuing the conversation
he's excluding what Rob said what the
president said and
adding he's making his own list but the
Gemara still finds it always better if
there was an explicit source and it
doesn't have to be inferred so he bought
yellow hallelujah Ladislav my what's the
status of hallelu car Tosh ma come in
here the AMA Rav Rav said has a 'no key
lady baker Viva I have seen the till 'm
of my uncle the tell'em of my uncle
rapira rapira was an uncle of Roth which
we actually in the beginning of
sacrament of Dalit appear was Rob's
uncle so that's why Rav used to call him
ha VV Javie V means my beloved one my
cherished one but actually it comes from
two words och avi avi V is an
abbreviation the brother of my father
the relationship between nephews and
uncles apparently was one a very deep
affection sohe VV is actually a avi it
became a word in Hebrew already you say
you did the Javie v somebody I love but
really it's the brother of my father
avi V is the test act and VV my father
the brother of my father and actually
this case it was very accurate because
rupiah was his uncle so used to call
them Javie v the brother of my father /
even today we call an uncle died and
though it comes from which words like a
Neela died II video ideally like we just
had he did you Takei right Lloyd is also
a form of Brotherhood of love of
affection you did a close friend so
Aniela died even ideally I am to my
beloved my beloved is to me so in any
case he said I saw the tehilim of my
uncle Aviva my uncle area and in the
tehilim the symbol which says in the
tehilim
hallelu bahut geezer and Karb Asad Giza
on one side of the page meaning at the
end of the line that said hallelu and in
the beginning of the line of the next
line which means on the other side of
the page because you have a page of a
tailor so you're writing the you're
writing your your words at the end of
the line that said hallelu that's cod
geese
and then he started a new line with the
word youth K on the other side the new
line that means that Rav holds that
hallelu and car are two separate words
and that's why he's separated in two
lines
unlike Reb his de so we have a McCoy
kiss actually about hallelu Co you have
rip his de holds its hallelujah it's one
word and it's not a sham his name and
Robert and Rob hold that hallelu caught
two separate words hallelu caught it's
like hallelu SRM you should praise our
seminary another day race the youth K
cause it's kinda Sh
Oh plea get the W sharable AV this is an
argument with diminish or ban lavey
the view of Wrath that hallelu caught
our two separate words argue they were
so well David I'm gonna be sober maybe
be someone lady said my hallelujah what
does hallelujah mean hallelu be he loool
in high bay praise him extol him with
great many praises with numerous praises
in other words according to be sure ban
LaVey the youth k is just there that
you'd hey is just there to increase the
impact to increase the impact it
shouldn't just be hallelu you should
praise but hallelujah means the hallelu
should be with many he loool them with
many many praises that's what he says
for example we haven't Sharon there's a
puss sick at the end of Shara Shara
reshef a Harish Fay ish shalt have s
your shalt Hevesy our means not just a
shall have us a torched but shall ever
see 'as a strong torture you toward huge
sports are very powerful torch that's
how he learns the you'd hey hallelujah
is not two separate words like Ralph its
hallelujah it's a certain type of praise
with great strength and great intensity
that should be sharable Avery's opinion
and the Gomorrah says Oh pleaded a a
d-day and to be sure ballet V is so to
speak arguing with himself in other
words there's a paradox within his own
words
oh I'm gonna be shobun leave you be
Sherman levy once said Basara memorial
smash them
safer to hilum there are ten languages
of praise with which to hilum was said
meaning when you go through the chapters
of tehilim they open up with different
terms that represent the song the praise
that's going to be presented the first
is Mitsuwa many of the capital many of
the chapters of Psalms begin with the
word l'm not saya
I'm not say if we translate usually as
the choirmaster
l'm not say f is the first word Mitsuwa
this is the first language of praise
with which we open up a song a chapter
in Psalms the next one is Bennigan's the
word Nigam for example you'll have I'm
not saying be McGee noise Ben McGee
noises Nichkhun song
not yet no is the word you
have it capital valid you have it
capital love you ever tell them there
yeah it begins with Megan the next is by
Maskull you have capitalist that begin
with Maskull for example the Dovid math
skill that certain language that's
number three number four mismo you have
many capitals that begin mismo there you
have sheer like we're learning in the
morning and look at the term is more
sheer can Lukas hih by his load of it so
you have sheer so we have mitsuo niggard
masculine is Murr number five is sheer
we have ashtray in fact the first
capital of tehilim
ASHRAE her ish actually a lot but I will
show you we have tequila we know this
very well this is capital Coffman hey
tequila load of it I remember allah kiya
Melek we have Fela we have Fela right
like feel Allah on a Fiat I feel the
fear shemish position that's capital
cuff bays we really have in the
beginning capital you design three Lord
of it we have number nine hide or hide
or for example capital Kofi a test which
is part of Howell
Soph hi doula shanky tithe kiloohm Cosmo
and we finally have halle-loo
yah or hallelu car many capitals begin
with the word hallelu car
for example cava hallelujah hallelujah
how you do laden I ki Tov kill em cars
toy or hallelu cash riche
so these are the ten languages of praise
with which to hilum was said as the
opening up of the chapters Neetu arsenic
and masculine is ma chere a surety let's
fill like Donald God o me kulan said to
me Sherman lady the greatest is
hallelujah
shakeela shame bushwhack the basses
because this word hallelujah encompasses
in one shot simultaneously the name of a
sham and the praise of a sham hallelu
and youth k-car in one shot
in one word that's what that's what did
we show burn lady says
shame and smash Babis a closet comes
together what do we see form to be show
burn levy that even though he says
hallelu ha was written as one word
that's what he says shame would smash my
bass our cars simultaneously because if
it's two separate words it's not the
boss of us nonetheless it doesn't mean
many he Lula he said before hallelujah
just means praise in a strong way do
many praises but here he's telling us no
it's shameless maximum eye sockets so we
have a contradiction within to be sure
but lately both of you urban ladies are
telling us that it's one word but how
you explain that word is different first
I be sure when lady told us it just
means to praise many times or to praise
with much intensity
he'll Ullom higher bay and then he tells
us that it's shame of Abbas our sister
smacking a shame in one name the common
denominator though in both views will be
sharable av what he said is that it's
one word and it's not two separate words
as Raph taught us from the tehilim of
his uncle Ravi aware hallelu and car
were two separate words doctor Gemara
America Dharma Shmuel review Hooda said
in the name of Schmo
sheersha batata the song that's written
and tight which song is written and
tighter in patches mashaallah oz
Yoshimura chauvinist asistir as much
done by Emeril mo-mo Chevy's role I'm a
ruby shush alumina yeah this song moshe
and the jewish people said it and
composed it when they ascended from the
red sea after the sea split and they
passed it and they emerged on the other
side they came out of the sea as the
toyota clearly states ours then
Yoshimoto of nature all motion the
Jewish people composed and sang this
year that's what w-who the says in the
name of Shmona we don't need small to
teach this to us and says clearly and
how much but this is an introduction to
the next piece the Hallows there me I'm
all right the question is who said who
composed the challah we know who
composed the Shero that we know but
that's not what we have chosen to say on
every um tooth I mean special basic
let's the Curia cetera but every hump if
we say how that's how we choose to
praise our I'm a different song
the Shira Shira Siam is full of praise
to our Shem but it discusses the
splitting of the see what was chosen as
the verses of praise every single young
Tov pacer Lewis Lukas and then later
Chanukah what was chosen as the hollow
and we have her destroyed there's also a
half a hollow what was chosen
hallo Wiz hallo from Howell comes from
the safer to hilum Psalms chapter is
1:13 through chapter was 118 Cofield
Gitmo starts hallo
and it goes through Co few tests which
is the end of challah me Amari who is
the one who composed this hallo and why
does he have to give the introduction
because he's trying to contrast it to
when it comes to the first shooter which
we don't say on Yom Tov
we know exactly who said it we know when
it was said when it comes to hallow
it's mysterious its
it's a consist it's it's it's it's
concealed in obscurity it's shrouded in
obscurity where did it come from when
did it come from who composed it who
said why did it become so central
because the sukima tell them don't tell
us the background doesn't even give it
doesn't give it over time Alex name a
lot of capitalist until them it says Miz
Maryland of it rightful oleg of it here
it doesn't say double just says hallelu
hallelu of day Hashem a Lewis shameiess
let me say my Shama grandfather they'll
all the way till the end Kaylee activate
that killer kyon ki Tov kill em Casa Mia
Mara who said it says rob you who did
the name of Shmuel fascinatingly nazim
shabby nahan it was the prophets among
the Jewish people the prophets among the
Jewish people which Jewish people the
prophets who lived with the Jewish
people
tikkun olam lessor all instituted how
low for the Jewish people show you only
knows alko poked a panic they should say
it at every period of Howlett every
holiday Pater Kopernik means during
peyrac literally means a chapter but he
means every time that they celebrate our
young TIFF they should say hallo
and also I'll called tsarevets Irish
light over Alea if there's ever at Sarah
that should never come on them he's like
saying a prayer or light over and meet
sorry that never should never come on
them but if hospital them if it does
come on them the Gomorrah doesn't want
to say I'll call sort of it's Irish at a
violent because he doesn't want to speak
negatively he says I'll call turbid
searchlight of ala any sorry that should
never come on them but if God forbid it
does come on them so then it would look
shiny Golan when they are redeemed from
the Torah by Miriam I say al ghul
awesome
they say hallo when they are liberated
which is why we say hallo on Hanukkah
Hanukkah was a tremendous surah the
Jewish people were liberated we say
hallo
we see from here that there's two types
of hawa there's the howl of yom tov
called pericope eric that they
instituted every holiday no matter what
situation it is jus said hallo in the
Warsaw Ghetto on Pesach
juice a howl on yom tov whenever it is a
yump if you say howl for the yom tov and
then there's a separate hallo that was
instituted throughout history when they
are in a difficult situation and they're
liberated they say hallo so it's
actually too few of them of how the one
is the fee of to say hallo every younger
mile copay to compare it and then
there's hallo that you don't just read
every other if it's a sheer it's
appraised a song to Hashem for being
redeemed from from the Torah so that's
the navamsha be nahan who are these
prophets among them he doesn't say
clearly he says but the prophets the
prophets among them instituted this new
vm chevy naen he doesn't say when either
he asks me amara
so the RAM bond there on bond writes in
his commentary on the Rambam safer how
mitzvahs and as a saugus they're called
our saugus of the Rambam today rama say
for our mistress he says that what the
gomorrah means is the profits of that
generation the prophets who lived in the
generation that came out of egypt which
means miriam moisha and aaron and the
other prophets known as at sea labeneh
through all the prophets they were the
ones who composed the holo and
instituted it to say during Yom Tov and
during different situations in history
when Jews would be liberated from but
Sarah says the prophets of that
generation that's why he says in the vm
shall be naen because he says miyamura
who's who did it she's a vm should
intervene among them among who their
abundance is just among the Jewish
people
that's as obscure as anything else it
means from that generation came out of
Egypt
interesting question but the Gomorrah is
going to show now that it's not so
simple this is going to create a big
argument Tanya we have a brighter higher
that Miriam a used to say call to the
Bacchus ha Marie's be safer to hilum
coolant
mara all of the praises that are set
into them all of them were said by mm
Ella all the praises that you find them
to Hill him dove it said them and of it
said them Dheeraj bomb adds a few words
he says he says here said he says said
the - mom says David I'm Marlon it's
actually the Raj bomb here was printed
in the wrong place comforters and I'm at
base I just want to read a few three
lines Alamo roars Thiru dove it
basically said them for events that
transpired in life in his life it wasn't
just he set to hell and he wrote poetry
each mismo each saw each chapter of
Psalms is an event it's describing a
certain event and all of them were said
by Governor Miller this is what the
mayor teachers can Emma what's his
source it says in to Hill and Capitol
iron Bay's Carlos Fela is David Benicia
this Fela is the prayers of David the
son of you have been completed I'll take
your call ooh Ella Coelho says it may
don't only read it as we pronounce it
Khalu they finished that's how you
pronounce it but it can also be read as
call a low and abbreviation call a low
all these which means all the fillers
that you're gonna find there and tell
them come from David Benicia the Marsha
says that the reason that compelled
Ramaiya to say this is because this
posture should have been at the end of
tehilim not at the end of capital Lyon
base because we have prayers of Dove
anomalous later on so why the end of
Capet lion base suddenly colors feliz
novel by YCJA - something strange about
it so that's why the Marsha says Romero
was compelled to say that it's not Khalu
finished it's not finished yet you're
holding ayan gimble he's too hot a half
of the hilum to go it's not Colo
rather he's trying to indicate something
else call a loose Miller's double
Benicia
all these artfully Dalmatian 70 because
see 772 and they took the first in the
second combining one would be 71st
because he lives therapy I once saw that
remiz that Ovid lived for 70 years in
the first two capital of our combined
right Gomorrah so therefore at the end
of 70 it's colorful as David Benicia
every year you save the birthday yet
your year that's the slide involved a
good question how could a May us
everything was said by David amela
we see clearly we have Shem is Marla
Vinick Iraq for example and others Phil
Allah Masha Allah Kim exactly maskull
LaHaye Minh has Rafi I'm not saying live
in a quorum is my right we have Asif
Shem is myrrh what Asaf know we know we
have dove it we're not arguing but he's
saying how could it may say everything
is dove it so we have to say yeah so so
so the muff RM say the EU Yaakov says
here the FA and I am say that would have
Maher meant was that even though many
composed the poems but at the end they
went through the hands of David and he
was the editor-in-chief he was the final
editor who gave his stamp on all the
miss Myron in other words he was
basically he took them all and he he
compiled and he is the one who made the
created the final text of tehilim and
that's why he's called that's why it's
called of anomalous book we called of
anomalous and commissioned and tanaka in
the ins Mira's she saw the sweet the
sweet musician of the Jewish people the
sweet singer of the Jewish people
cuz David I'm Ella he is that name is
mister and that's why it has his name
the safer hasn't even though there's
many authors many composers that's what
your mayor meant he didn't mean that
initially he is the one who composed
every single one Holly Lou also shared
cuz it's it's disappointing they come
after Coelho seems to be indicative of
what okay
right but the problem is that call a loo
even at the end of iron Bay's would not
make so much sense because you have many
authors before to write so you can't say
all of them are only dove it you have
the MS Miriam I mentioned if as other
authors that's why he's saying that he
doesn't mean that he is the sole
composer rather he's the final editor
and you have dove it afterwards also
know anything besides in which one is
for which events no just like fix myself
though recover the original in that
safer
besides the demon he had also like to
use all that but I've been a lot of a
lot of MS mariatillema tests like for
example you have at the beginning of
Atilla ms marla dahveed before i'm in a
half-shell employ he sang this when he
ran away from a solemn right so it's
clearly that there was an event and this
inspired this poem l'm not say if MS
Miller dahveed be voy a love nurse and
an avocado almost over after he had this
connection with Bashara Nelson came to
him and dove it made a poem right kanae
Niall Acosta so many many MS merit
element clearly the linear clearly
specifies the event not always but many
of them Hilo's Hallam sir Hallows mi
Amara this is your mayor speaking who
said hallo
we told you who set to Ilham who said
hallo maybe I see I'm the Bryce is
continuing our mayor told us about the
hilum what about holo the BOC emitter
BOC
says Allah Sabini I meant my son Eleazar
says Moshe be solemn aruba shush Solomon
uyama Moshe and the Jewish people said
it when they came up from the seeds a
fascinating new interpretation before we
learned from Shmuel that didn't veeam of
that error which may also mean Moshe
Aaron and Miriam composed Allah but here
he says when they actually came up from
the sea the Paradis says they said Shira
but we have another thing that they said
they composed hallo I'm a ruby shush
alluminium which is interesting and
because it would explain it would
explain that there are spam puts the
rush mom says that this would explain
what's his source like why would he say
this when they came out of the yam so he
says well look at the second capital of
hallo
but say seesaw minute sir I am basic of
mam lawyers high co2 low country
hye-young raha Vienna is deceased son
fled her harem rock dukale and wise
given its iron Malachi aam ki so knows
why you running away
haha theater Agha maíam Columbus lamine
a Maya basically their Ribisi is saying
the name of Allah sir all this is an
indication that it was said to
commemorate Korea Sam self that's when
it happened they said it when they came
out of the sea and as the h-bomb puts it
Africa covered of it mr. fry and then
dove it took this composition that was
transmitted over the generations and he
put it into his book into the
compilation of Taylor but it originates
from the time of Korea Sam stuff when
they came up this is what Tbilisi says
about how look in I love have a roof but
the Friends of my son Allah sir argue
with him like my they say David amar I
dove it composed a hollow many many
generations later now that's a big
difference because from moisture a banal
coming out of the sea they were forty
years in the desert right and it's only
four hundred and eighty years later when
they commentates the straw that they
build them a stomach condition the times
of Schlemmer mela so you're dealing with
more than four centuries between mush
and of it so allah says motion that you
people said it when they came out of the
yam my his friends say no David said
this Dov it basically composed the hallo
to thank God for the miracles of all the
generations including three of Samson
patatas from him it's time it wasn't
said when they left Egypt it was said
hundreds of years later but it included
those miracles as well veneering devar
of madere Henry VI she says even though
he's my son let me tell you that his
words make much more sense than their
words why listen to his proof F sure is
it possible that all the years from
you'd see us much time to Dover
demolished there was no Holub that's
more than four hundred years you saw a
shock to us be sayin they shafted the
carbon pace of every year air pace
they're not to laveyan and they took
their little of him and their download
minimum Circus fillet I'm Lucia and they
did not say hallo
we know that tradition is that when they
were mark of the carbon paste saw the
hollow used to be said in the base
emitters when we shake the lulav circus
we hold the lulav in the dowload minim
and we say hallo with the Dollard minam
how can it be an a-hole hallo you
standing with the lulav and Estragon
your hands and you shake it during the
high dose and during on Ashima seon-ah
and during the last toyota during hallo
Rebbe I see says that if they were right
that he'll only came I'm sorry hallo
came around the time of mm Ellicott
means that for hundreds of years there
was the carbon Pesach and there was the
lulav without hallo and apparently WC
believes that the hallo is part of the
mitzvot then in these myths Rizal was
part of the Mitzvah and therefore we
would never have such a thing that a
Mitzvah was done missing a major part
and then suddenly a whole new part that
became an essential partner she can't do
that
you can add traditions around the
Mitzvah you know different people have
traditions around the Mitzvah they do it
this way they do it that way etc but how
low is considered an integral part of
the Mitzvah and if it's integral part of
the myths for that means it would have
been added later and that can't be that
is very very difficult to assume and
therefore he says my son is right that
the Halal was always there from the
beginning and therefore they can always
the lulav with the holo and do the
carbon pacing with the holo that's why
he embraces the view of his son but they
hold not so they hold apparently Howell
is not an essential part of the Mitzvah
for hundreds of years you could shake
the lulav without love it I'm Elvis made
howl and then they joined the two then
they combined it to when you're shaking
lulav you celebrate it together with
hallo
when you take a little of you do it with
our pizza not in the mid bar and also
because he because he's saying that even
if they didn't do it in the mid bar but
they did it in their to stall for
hundreds of years it says it says by
yahushua they went in they did the peso
here they had to circumcise themselves
remember that the circumcised I was in
Gilgal and you had the Mishkan urshela
at the Mishkan in novi at the Michigan
and give vine told over the mouth they
were doing the carbon Pesach yeah what
do you write they did it one but they
did it wunst anniversary the first in
mitzraim and then in the mid where they
did it once maybe not written but said
and composed the how long
that's what Allah saw his son holds
lover affair I have another proof to me
this is a fascinating proof piece Laurie
shall miss her or him it'd be Betty
visceral or MMS a hollow there was the
statue the the Minoan especial mica the
statue of Misha is standing in a place
called Betty that's the name of the
place where the statue stood and they
are and it's during the times of Dove it
and the Jews know about it and they
cherish it and they then say hallo
what does howell tell us about statues
and those who cherish statues in the
second section the third section while
on ooo we speak about
ox our Bayon kesav is of those who make
statues of silver and gold pala heaven
below you debater they have a mouth they
don't speak to have eyes they don't see
they have ears they don't hear they have
a know they don't smell they have hands
they don't
touch their feet they don't walk they
can't speak Khmer hem ye I say him coil
a sherbet is better those who make them
should be just like them and anybody who
trusts in them so he says to say that
the hollow was composed in the time of
David and embraced because the fact that
loveth composed that he composed many
things but this was embraced by Clouser
all he says it's illogical that they
would curse themselves and say Camellia
me or say him Carla schibetta bam the
hollow was composed by the Red Sea like
rebel Azhar says and then it remained
already part of Jewish traditions even
at a time of Dawa dermaluxe
even when they were worshiping the
statue of misha they were still saying
it if it was composed by Chris Young soo
there was no structure to me for them so
no one would be logical to say that was
by ages no no the pestle misha was then
the times of Dov it and many jews
apparently we see for mayor had some
affection to it right and it remained
there with them for many years but it
was also there in times of Dublin so the
Gemara is saying the hallow would have
never taken root in Jewish consciousness
at that time because there is an
explicit curse against those who cherish
these things but if you say that it was
an old tradition
so tradition continues you don't even
know what you're saying understand what
you say you do it because you know it
was a miracle
maybe so that he doesn't want in other
words he doesn't want to differentiate
and say part of halal this part of hallo
that it's more sense no the whole point
is that the chassis sama mitzrayim was
made by dove it by by motion emotion
this is loyal oh no says no for carrot
lalana was made by Moshe
because if it would have been made
during the time of David the Jews would
have not said it but but he's but he
says but the Jews wouldn't accept it
of the majority accepted curse
apparently that there was a huge number
that's what it looks like that's what it
looks like if it was just a few Jews
then why wouldn't others accept it yeah
yeah yeah it was composed by moisture
that's his point and then it was already
continued by Dove it because it couldn't
make sense he says that the pestle
mission isn't Betty with prominence and
the Jews love it and they would allow
this poem to become part of their
literature because it's really cursing
themselves very interesting and I should
just say that there are AMA says Betty
either means a place or maybe it
actually means pestle Mischa I made by
Betty from the word pia and he says
really it's a euphemism the camera
doesn't want to say what it really wants
to say pestle but misha i made by simcha
it's standing with joy meaning they're
celebrating it so instead he says by
russian sanguine oh yeah it's standing
in tears in grief and mourning in other
words they're mourning it they're not
crying they're really celebrating that's
the second interpretation which is very
powerful in others the pestle mission is
being celebrated with simcha which we're
calling clear because we don't want to
say that every deserves being celebrated
and they're saying that whoever makes it
and trust in it is gonna is gonna become
is gonna be is gonna suffer they
wouldn't they would have never said so
yeah so you would have to say you would
have to say that that there's balm says
Bob al-alam never receive Lloyd pisaq
once it was part of the tradition you're
really not thinking about it so it
stayed in other words to compose a new
poem you have to actually be conscious
of what you're saying but part of the
tradition at once says cocksure mighty
that's what I heard or then he says
Billy Kenoi you like Michael I'm Raymond
boo simcha we weren't smart enough to
get rid of pestle Misha
it's hard for us to understand the
appeal of a Vedas order we don't
understand it the Gemara says inhuman a
tantric necessary dialect killed the XRF
avoiders our work it's hard for us to
understand why would people be so
excited about statues and deities hey
what's the we have our own avoid
disorders you know it was very very
heavy it was like it was the eighth
Sahara that was it was it was the
fashion of the day once it was already
composed on the sea it never stopped in
other words even when they worshiped
over this era they didn't have a problem
with that anymore
because it's already it's hundreds of
years old if it's a new poem it means
that dove had composed it to fight them
if he composed it to fight them he's
writing the contemporary situation they
would have rejected it but if it's
hundreds of years old it's not about us
you know how it is not about us it's
about to the old ones that's the point
that's the point that's the point that
just because David made the poem
wouldn't mean it's accepted and that's
why he's proving that Nava didn't make
it Oh same logic we did make know though
that the Kumari knew that hollow howl
became universal and it's thought they
started to say it so he wants he proves
he wants to prove that it wasn't said
during though it wasn't made during
those years because it would have never
it would have never taken root into
Jewish it says add your voice or 'it's
that the the statue of mitchell was
there add urine glow until they were
exiled from the from the land that means
it was been made of it also written exam
way yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah they were
exiled from the land and then till then
they had passed on Michael yeah yeah
wasn't a monovalent mal okay so in the
meantime we had three opinions we had
the opinion of small remuda mushball who
says the prophets in the time made how
well for every um different for every
sorry
goula he doesn't specify who but the
Ramban says the prophets in the time of
motion Rubino we had the opinion of
Eleazar the son of Aaron who says Moshe
and the Jewish people said it when they
came out of the sea so it's the same
people the same era but a different
period when after Korea Samson and we
have the Friends of Allah sir of rebel
aza who disagree and say it's part of
tehilim not only because Dov it put it
into Helen but because Dov it actually
is the one who who composed it and only
then was it initiated was was the whole
to him created time of mm Elana didn't
exist before the challah remai doesn't
speak about hallowed it may it only
speaks about tehilim mayor says that all
the praises of tehilim were said by Dov
it but as we said remai it doesn't
necessarily mean that Dov it made them
all cuz it can't it says other names so
from ma wouldn't be able to prove that
Howell was composed by David you could
say hallo was edited by Dov adore the
final touch-ups my dove it or dove it
put it into his book and so forth the
shock of the Gemara writer we learnt
that David hemella is the one who
composed the hilum Ramaiya told us that
in fact all of the poems of tehilim were
created and written or at least edited
and finalized by the vellum Allah so the
cameras
Tana rabona you see Turner abana by the
two dots the rabbi's taught Cole
Vistage Bacchus on my dove
would be safer to hilum all of the songs
and the praises that dove it recited in
the book of tehilim there is an argument
about them
rebel señora Maria blessedness connect
it acts Maya he wrote them because
of personal events we're sure emitter be
insurer says can negate Subura he
wrote them because of communal events of
the present the past or the future
prophecies of the future now this is a
very interesting Mike Lake is between a
B Eleazar and Rubio schewe and let's
understand there are many capitulation
to Hill him that say clearly wide of it
composed them let's take capital gimel
remember miss Marilla David before hi me
penne of Shalom binoy it's a song that
David composed when he fled a Shaolin
his son who created and staged a mutiny
against over lamella almost killed him
almost killed his father wanted to take
over the Empire at the end of Shaolin
was killed but this was a song but never
Neverland benaiah so here you can't
argue what event inspired it he says
what invent inspired him you'll have
capital non Aleph some people say it
every night in creation of schlomit l'm
not say Ms Miller David B voy a love
nurse and on our vacation Baba's mother
this is a song he sang when nothing the
Prophet came to him after he had his
relations with math Sheva and it's a
very very heart-wrenching mizmor that's
why it's said by many at night in
kilometer he asks for LAIV right he asks
for a new heart lave Taher Brawley le
Kim Rock knock on cottage but Kirby
creates from me a pure heart I'll touch
lucania mph or not or or kuch khatti
kuch my many yeah the caps a knee berets
avatar wash me out do laundry with with
the hyssop so I could be cleansed hyssop
was a cleansing agent
two cups a evades event that caps a knee
Michele a galvanize should become even
whiter than snow
- Gail MA at some ways the Kisa bring
joy to the bones that you have crushed
pretty heavy pretty hem in every capital
and tell them is pretty loaded people
don't realize because we say to Hill
them so much in the original Hebrew most
people don't understand it they don't
appreciate the beauty and the depth and
the eloquence and the sacredness of the
poems I once saw an article a Christian
clergyman wrote that the most inspiring
poem written in world history is Psalms
145 and I looked and I'm like I give out
that's ASHRAE Psalms 145 is - Hillel a
though now asked her regular drew says
Ashley three times a day what he thinks
about archery you know what I mean here
we go again
actually they say it Garcia Decker but
this man had so to speak the distance
from ASHRAE he doesn't say three times a
day and he says the most unbelievable
poem that was ever written Psalm 145 you
know what does it say absence makes the
heart grow fonder sometimes the
familiarity with something it dulls it
dulls your appreciation Muslim even
without that you say yeah you know a lot
of people say I sure yours are a few
times a day but they don't stop to think
what they're saying I show you as an
extraordinary blessing it really
describes the miracles of the digestive
system and many others the nine systems
of the body etc so a lot of capital
tehilim describe why they were written
you know the lesson to be sure I can't
argue about that but what are they
arguing about all the other capital all
the other capital here in bellezza says
it's like a personal diary basically
people sit down at night they open a
journal and they write down what
happened
dov'è hemella for his personal
experiences he had a poem for everything
something happened during the day
something happened there in the month
and there's a couple
chillin which is a fascinating study to
figure out what's the message of the cup
of the dome what is he addressing the
Malbin in his introduction to hilum
tehilim says he says many of the capital
Huff tehilim
you see that there's a lot going on but
you don't know the backdrop of it you
don't know what happened to inspire it
and that's what he tried he tries a lot
to do he doesn't know the events but he
tries to to bring out what is mm Ellis
trying to bring out so they're Belleza
says it's about himself it was basically
an individual story of life if you know
if you can understand to heal him you
have a biography of the Villa Mella it's
basically a diary of David amela
in terms of his emotional responses to
the experiences in his relationship to
himself to the world and to God and to
people yoshua says no David hemella is
representing that sibour he's addressing
the events of Claudius Rome
whether in the past or in the present or
even in the future that's what abuse
schewe tells us and the way the rash mom
puts it is the rush mom says that
there's rumors printed on kavkaza'
UNAMID base the center - mom says about
this what's his lot he says kanessa see
stroke miss snob a algo loose invis'ble
alayan it's the second to the last long
cuff design I'm at base he's
prophesizing about the future exile and
he's davon in for them so we see a lot
of miss Marie I'm talking about the
urban and the gulls in the pain governor
mother lived in the mother of United the
Jewish people they lived in their
homeland nobody was exiled
according to her be sure this is a
prophecy for the future he's speaking
about that zebra and he's praying for
them he's beseeching rebel Ezzor says no
he's talking about his own life he's
talking about his own personal life come
in moment him and her come him say yes
man connect it's impervious man connect
enhance my there are many chapters where
he speaks about the communal issues
kanessa see saw Claudia stroke and
others he speaks about himself
meaning Hamura is below shin Yahud can I
get out smile when he speaks in the
singular language I he's speaking about
his own experiences Hummer is blushing
Robin when he speaks in the plural
language can negate sibour this is an
idea visible as innovation which means
herbalizer holds that even when he
speaks in the plural he's speaking about
himself and her beer sure halt even when
he speaks in the singular he's speaking
about everybody that simpler and the how
come him say no when he speaks about
himself he speaks about AI he speaks in
terms of I when he speaks about that
simmer he speaks in terms of us very
interesting McLucas why would there be
letter B sure argue with this why
wouldn't they just say that like the
hominem sometimes he speaks about
himself sometimes he speaks about that
simmer beautiful so the EU Yaakov says
the Rambam tells us in hillcrist
Malakand lave hemella who lave Kulka
hollister all the heart of the king is
the heart of the Jewish people Rashi
says in Paris who cus Hanna see who ha
coil a real Massey is everybody and
everything so therefore even when he
speaks blush and sip or your bellezza
still maintains he's speaking about ATS
my because the true acts may have never
died Malik has not just an individual
insulated person living in a cocoon the
heartbeat of the king is the heartbeat
of the Jewish people the eye of the king
is not just a personal I an individual I
a real leader as I now see you are coil
encompasses the heartbeat of every Jew
rabbi Yeshua who says everything is
about that simmer not about himself says
that this is true even when mm alex is
speaking about Russian Yahud and the
reason is because all the Jewish people
are one body are kigu fahadh and
therefore since we're all one body could
speak about I and it's not just me but
it's also the entire Jewish people
because we're really all one that's a
very sure as you and the hum
say no we follow the literal
interpretation of the sukham and mickey
hm some he speaks about personal
experience somebody speaks about
Clausura so what are those who say oh so
you're saying according to this even
those Capitola would hear when he
clearly speaks about an individual thing
it's still connected to everybody that's
what you're touching
according to this you could say you
could say that they the marshal says
that all my leg is only about the other
miss Miriam where doesn't say but that's
going to the time you saying you could
say that they're speaking about all of
them in fact the lushness
kölsch it is with such buckles on my
double the safer tell them that even
those that are clearly individual Rubio
sure would say it's that similar and
even those that are clearly for that
symbol there Belleza would say that it's
the offset perhaps yet perhaps dr.
Gomorrah to be sure urban levy told us
that there are ten openings in tehilim
meaning the praises of tehilim are said
by saaremaa morrison ten languages let's
remember them l'm not say fwrite Nicoise
negan Maskull mismo Shearer ashrita Gila
Fela hi da and finally hallelujah ten
languages of the Camorra says now all
the capitals of tell'em that begin with
Mitsuwa Coveney gone they begin with
nice walk and and l'm not say I've
been guineas for example capital Dalit
houses capital dolls begin l'm not saya
Benjie noise and capital Volvo soca
begins with La Marseillaise been
Guinness all these capitalist law said
lover always refer to the future meaning
they are relating to
mushiya and I stood there a shabam
rights on this
he says wherever it says nice walk I'm
not saying begin it's it's about Lawson
lovely the lawyer Donna hasty Masha I
don't know how he knew this how how did
come on Aloha Ella how she have a Kim Lu
apparently it's a tradition that when it
says nice or Hannigan it's referring to
it's referring to referring to mushy
after Lawson lover
that's what
there are bombs says that it's just a
tradition however the Marsha says that
it actually makes sense also in the
words because the word neat swath is
associated with the word net sock which
means eternity the Gemara says in a
Riven where it says Nets Excel avoided
that means it's never interrupted it's a
something that never gets and the
Robinson says that's that's the
connection with the word lamb not saya
whenever you have a capital that begins
with the word Maskull for example
capital Ahmad base mass killer dove in
Azure in history Patrick's guitar etc
capital members write masculine Dovid
make a Isle Terrigal I think him I am I
think I should use it tell you by giving
this to me is just I think capital
members is also Maskull capital members
I'm not saying mass kill if Nicoya aisle
Tara gala Fatima him yet or capital la
midbass is also Maskull right I think
would of it
word of advice kill ashen asleep asha
i'll you date argument when it says
Maskull he basically it was a private
poem that he gave over to a to a person
who translated it and who explained it
to the people in other words maskull's
from the word say he'll Havana say he'll
Havana as rashly says who or americano
Farish he said it and somebody else
elaborated and explained it so he was
masculine with something that he gave
over to somebody and that person
explained it or musculars associated
with the word that it was silent he said
it quietly and that person said it
publicly either in person explained it
Moscow from the word say ho or mass
killed Ovid I'm Alex said it quiet
quietly and the other person the other
person said it loudly I'm sorry what do
you say lie fish litter diamond he says
musculus Lloyd fish litter common why he
did it that way and what would be the
occasion very needy the
was not killed it's not really it
translators it disseminator or the
cement disseminated somebody who says it
loud and somebody who explains it
some people occasions no doesn't meet
all whole class all was there I mean
could have been hacker but it just means
he's the one who gave it over
mm Allah gave it over privately and then
he disseminated it when it starts off
yeah very few very few yeah there was a
need for somebody to bring it out yet
the Dovid miss Maier whenever it says
load of admire for example capital Huff
Dalit with Ovid miss Milosh Emirates
employer table via Shiva Malamud sure
sell of Sheena
vaca-oom aashira it means first - Enid
well done dove it and then he said Shira
in other words Allah dove it first it
was dove it David was inspired
he had divine inspiration and then mismo
he broke out in song what about if it
says miss Marilla David right like we
say fry dead miss Miller David Havel R M
Binet Elam or capital gimel is mismaloya
VAR hey then
mallamma charm a sheet of a carousel of
Cena first he started to sing and then
the Sheena dwelled on him so you have
two different experiences miss Marilla
David means he started with a song and
his song itself caused the divine
presence to dwell on him the David miss
Marie means now first he was inspired
and thus he burst out and he expressed
it in song la lambdas but this teaches
you miss Belle Adama teaches you that
what Shane Ashley nasarah
that the Sheena does not dwell on a
person limitless Atlas not amidst
laziness voluntary HAP's was an Adam
it's depression or melancholy villa
meter hike and not amidst frivolous
laughter velu meter Carlos Arroyo not
amidst lightheadedness like mockery
cynicism cows Rajesh
vil imitative or imitate him and not
from idle chatter element advice sim
fishel Mitzvah Tichina dwells only
amidst one environment a place where
there's joy and the joy is mitzvah like
joy it's meaningful joy it's its sacred
joy is godly joy that's the difference
between psyche and simcha psyche is just
like you know laughter just frivolous
frivolous laughter some crucial Mitzvah
means a joy that's saturated with with
with spiritual meaning with a mitzvah
that's why when Dovid wasn't feeling
rule hakodesh what did he do he started
to sink and from mismo came to little
bit
there were times with Ovid mismo where
there was already a state of simcha
Shulman Spanish Lena dwelled on him and
then he started to sing but sometimes
there was no Chinna there so what did he
do he started the simile started the
mismo and he starts singing that itself
creates the skin the simcha brought the
shrimp into David's life miss Mayer and
then was load of it that's the gomorian
Broca's that Kinnard of it David's heart
the Kamara says abraca stuff kimmel da
fouled of its harps was hanging on top
of his bed in the middle of the night
rocks - northern wind came and started
to blow on the heart and it would play
and over time Alec would get up and he
would he would learn tighter till the
dawn so you say sometimes it was
actually the Keener started to play and
and of it woke up it says he would wake
up by cuts ice and he would learn to
avoid soccer till dawn break and that
don't break the hakama is through all
the sages the visit would come in to him
and they would say I'm called certain
part no sir the eylem means - and nobody
had money right so Davila MELAS would go
would say so go and support each other
who via Sparta Suzumiya
and they told them aina Komets must be a
sorry vena burma small
kasa you can't dig out a pit and then
fill it up with sand and expect it to be
full it's always gonna be missing
meaning an economy can't be sustained
from its own mechanisms so Dava died
Malik said what he need Milton Friedman
for so that when I Malik said look who
pitched to you they from big dude go to
war as I said good morning breakfast
however you understand this game already
happen every single day every single
morning but soon as in the morning they
would come Tim they said we need par no
sir and then they would go and ask to
erm vitamin and ask the Sun Hedren and
ask our case I fell three and then they
would decide what to do
I'll call upon them this is all part of
the experience so we have with Ovid
mismo and we have MS Millard of it
sometimes when you're feeling in a bad
mood and you don't feel in touch with
the shin and what's the aid sir they
just have to start singing you have to
start being joyous I say I don't have
what to be joyous for when you'll be
joyous you'll have what to be joyous for
that's what we see sometimes you're in
already in a state of rural ha'qodesh
and that creates the MS mer sometimes
you're not in a state of real hakodesh
you're not inspired so you have to start
with mismo you have to start with the
misery to start with the singing with
the simcha and that itself creates the
descent of the trimmer Trisha Shawn at
night Isla dovid mismo very good and
it's a lush Emirates employer yeah
Trask with words anger threat I guess
ah yeah you can understand it very much
and the first time it says MS Millett
Ovid Capital gimel because what is it
talking about Ms Millard of it before
Simon 1/2 shall employ he was running
away from his son who wanted to kill him
so what type of situation was he in it
was one of the lowest points of his life
maybe the lowest point of his life in
that situation there was no rule
Hakodesh so what did he do he started to
sink mr. Bullard Ovid he started to sing
and then he says through the mismo sure
celestina through the MS Matuschka came
to dwell on Shan Emma we have a source
for this in the pasta the pasta says in
Malakand base Kings 2 chapter 3 the
Attic who Lumina gain the higher Kannagi
diamond again but he a love yad hashem
what is this talking about this is the
story of Alicia Alicia was a great Navi
Alicia was a prophet and Alicia felt
that he's not in touch with Rorschach
either she doesn't have any divine
inspiration what was the reason for this
the background is the king of Yehuda the
king of Judea at the time was a man
named Yahoo Shafaat the king of Israel
the remedy was a split Kingdom right the
king of you hood there which was on the
south as name was Yasha fought the king
of the other 10 tribes name was your
Hiram they went to war against common
enemy called mauve which is in the
Transjordan near today's Jordan on the
east they went to war against Moyer and
they came to ask Alicia counsel and
advice about the future since he was the
prophet of the generation Alicia got
very very angry at yah Hiram because
you're Hiram the melody straw was an
over the Vedas Ora he was an idol
worshiper
because he got so angry and this was
justified anger
Tichina went away he couldn't have the
skin because he was angry and therefore
he
couldn't answer he couldn't give advice
cuz he was in a very very trapped state
so what happened so Alicia says Colima
noggin
bring me a singer Mahalia can Nagahama
noggin and when the manag and started to
seeing what the heel of yada sham the
hand of God dwelled on him so we see
that even Alicia who was in a state of
caste
not for a personal vendetta right
because he didn't invite me to do sin
the condition by in daughter's wedding
by his son's wedding so I have a
vendetta he was in Kosrae because a boy
disorder nonetheless you're not in a
state of enlightenment of openness of
transparency so therefore he asked them
to sing in front of him and this is
called sim crucial Mitzvah he needed the
sim crucial mitzvah and this is also
Mitzvah he wasn't doing a mitzvah but it
was a simply because he want to have a
connection with God I should just say
that there are dark interprets the
reason that Alicia was so upset was
because of the the passing of aliawan
avi Leo one of he went up in the flames
and Alicia didn't have his red band
anymore and that's what hurt him he was
in a state of sadness and that was the
issue and that's when he asked for the
man so it's different interpretations
why he was obvious for me
so that's right no cause he needed it so
he needed to be to be yeah for how you
can again I mean again but he loved the
other chef the Shin is only showing a
meter meter Simba yeah that's the source
and that's why you have MS Millett of it
but Eva how you can now gain hamon again
a beautiful interpretation of the market
of Miss rich since what's the higher can
again Hammond again it's like it's an
interesting imposter but after Kulemin
again well how you can again Hammond
again right you can say oh yeah right
cash any gain I mean obviously the one
who sings was distinct
he said take from me a singer right and
except when he's saying but overall you
can noggin humming not be when the
singers obviously was the singer it
wasn't some stranger he took him a
noggin so the maggot touches something
very deep
and he says for hire can nagahama Nagila
t lov addition the man Nagin has to be a
nagging the man again is the singer
Nagin is so we say when the singer sang
Nagin is the song itself
Nagaina for how your kid nagging him and
knocking when the singer loses his sense
of self-consciousness and he becomes the
in itself but the heel of yad
Hashem he could be a conduit for the
divine when the man noggin turns into
noggin
he becomes the in other words very
very powerful idea when I'm singing
there could be I'm singing I'm
performing right I'm performing through
a song it's not gonna get you anywhere
but he cannot gain how many body can a
get when the man noggin becomes the
he loses himself in the his
entire being is just a conduit for the
n-- Vitiello the others I think I
told you once I asked a pianist a great
pianist what success how do you know yet
a successful concert and he said if I am
not present if I'm not present I said
what happens he said my fingers are just
a conduit for the music if I'm playing
the piano and I'm impressing you you're
in a very limited place it's busy your
ego with their ego and I'm gonna and the
impact is a different impact you see it
it's it's it's your ego versus my ego
when you're not present consciously like
we learned earlier in the my name is
master Honoka some look at the tailor
right Shikha
well you're not the present so then you
are conduit for a much higher reality
that's beyond Yuri go Setzer says well
you can now gain hammer noggin the man
noggin
has to be the the hairs Jimmy was
stood sir he's a singer you understand
right singer sometimes you see their ego
and sometimes they're not there they
melt away in the music there's just
Dunnigan I'm just the conduit that's
when that's when the real energy comes
out cavaldi Kivar at the magnetism is
rich this is true with an artist it's
true with a writer it's true with a
teacher - with a communicator
ah
darvany yeah yeah always when you're
consciously present it's normal it's
human but it's a very limited experience
first taste I'm gonna Buda my travel to
the sender name of rava Shayne Lovera
halakhah this is not only true for the
chena it's also true for halakhah
meaning if you want to be able to
understand Tyra if you want to be able
to teach a law so you're always after
have Suleman this you know two hours
with simcha and before teacher teaches a
locker there has to be joy in the room
joy by the students I'm gonna block with
a maximun said with hallo hallo I'm Taif
it's also true for a good dream you want
to go to sleep and have good dreams you
gotta go to sleep with simcha show
mitzvah if you go to sleep angry
frustrated stressed - dreams are just
gonna be chaotic you want a good dream
you gotta go to sleep with simcha so
mitzvah tracked the Gemara how can have
you to teach in the name of wrath that
what that when you want to teach you
have to have some crucial mitzvah Amy
it's not true but I'm gonna begin to
love my rival I begin little quota to
the same grabs that cold comical my gosh
of live near a boy any tighter Scott
who's sitting in front of his master's
teacher the ancient source of noise for
smile and his drift his lips are not
dripping the Byron his lips are not
dripping with bitter dread meaning he's
not in a sense of awe of dread of year
of fear what happens to cavana those
lips shall be scorched was a scorched
justice to be singed in the fires of
Gehenna sinners in other words in other
words for the lips to fulfill their
their purpose their purpose which is to
absorb Toyota speak
teacher he's sitting in front of his
Reba those lips have to drip dread
meaning a sense of complete gyro or the
exact opposite of what Raph tells us you
need a joy of mitzvah that's not suffice
of nitrous Meyer and a good was quoting
grab and he's talking about sitting in
front of your ever and you just quoted a
blue the quadra-drive know you need and
he brings a position then when the
puzzle says in shoot him Chapter five
SIF size of shanem night was more over
his lips are made up of roses notice
they drip with my remote over is flowing
mirror which is a great incense an herb
or or or or a deer muskets it's a very
special beautiful aroma creates a
beautiful aroma suggestion describes his
lips which are flowing with this
beautiful fragrance Alta creature
Shannon Ellis hmm
there's no me goodness so instead of
reading show Shannon we could reach a
shining which means learning like vision
on Tom so basically sips noise of
showing him when they're learning their
lips have to be and I'll take remote
over a Lamar over not more which is
myrrh which is an incense but Mar which
is bitter like maurer Mary Rose that's
what it means basically the literal
interpretation is that the Jewish people
are speaking about their beloved on an
Illinois David ideally Hashem and
they're saying that his lips are have a
beautiful smell like a Carla says about
her Hassan that his lips have a
beautiful fragrance and a beautiful
aroma
notes were smart over the the smell over
it passes everywhere it goes everywhere
but but the how melodic communicant
imitation LP trash is that what that
when you're learning the suffice of
should be Moyer they should have a
certain bitterness a certain dread and a
certain it should flow with with with
all with yira where do we see from here
that it's gonna be singed so some say my
over is my herb Boyer maar buyer
now the result is boyer it's going to be
burnt it's gonna be it's going to be
singed that's what that's what some of
the some of the fire shrooms say in
other words you change the iron and
Bay's the order from over over to Boyer
that's what this read ah the feed uh
brings in a safer path setting I am so
we have here a contradiction what should
be the state when you're learning is it
one of tremendous Simms and Roy or one
of tremendous restraint and dread and
awe what did your classroom look like
Lenny which one I think your nose right
my class one qualifier okay you're
smiling all right very good
so the cash is not a contradiction
Hobbit told me the first statement ever
I was speaking about the Reber dilemma
has to be in a state of joy the second
statement is speaking about the students
the students have to be in a state of
war in order to be able to receive the
boys same another answer hubba-hubba
Rama
both are speaking about the river but
Lake Asha to look at is no contradiction
ha the first statement is Mikami the
pasta before the rabbit starts this year
for her the second statement of Ravis
Lamaze at the puzzle ashley starts to
share in other words before he started
after he has to create an environment of
joy not only for himself for the
students also there should be a sense of
joy once they start now the students
have to be completely attentive and
focused and they have to suspend any
type of joy is like an expansive
experience they have to suspend any type
of style joy and just tune in completely
with complete bitl complete self
nullification at all to this to the
tighter
kiha and we have an illustration for
this in a story Tihar the famous story
the robber the great sage
and I should just add Rebennack enamel
here says rava was just two glasses
whether it was rabbit or Robert Robert
was a student of Robert Kehoe the robber
may come with the pasta Lou albano
robber before he would start to shear
for the students for the sages are my
Mills of the dishes sir he used to
always say an anecdotal statement how do
they translate Muslim Buddhist sir
a humorous a humorous comment well I
think when you when you learn this
Gemara you you learn some things so
rabba would always say a humorous
comment this was a buddy who says like
something that brings like humor and joy
to people oh but horrible nun and the
rabbi's would laugh that I translated
correctly they cheered
oh but Korriban on their hearts opened
up from the cheering from the joy will
the Messiah then at the end afterwards
Yosef Eames
he would sit with or or pasta fresh
miter and he would begin the
presentation to Russia this year so
therefore the two statements of rava not
contradictory one answer is one was
talking about the rabbit he has to be in
a state of joy the students in a state
of war and the second is both about the
rabbit one is before the Shearer and one
is during this year before this year
simcha so mitzvah to create an
environment of openness and of joy the
hearts and the minds open up when there
is joy in the room but then for the
success of the Shearer itself they have
to tune in and focus and suspend in and
just be completely attempted without any
other outside experience but complete
attentiveness and self nullification to
the to the sheer now we don't have to
sit in the two answers in America
contradicting each other it could be
both are true that the Rav has to be the
DAF has to be driver has to be be simcha
and that before the sheared arrived
should be should also give simcha to
this
students or two different
interpretations of what rava rapper
what type of most of the Buddha's sister
what type of jokes he said I don't know
I don't know I don't know that it would
be a joke was just something that would
create humor but this is the source that
when you start a shear you started
Russia you first have to create an
atmosphere of openness then of warmth
and of joy that's why it's a good idea
to start with something that creates
curiosity it creates interest that
creates something more of a fun nature
which is what yours truly does very
often that's the reason for it I'm not
gonna say that it's the same most of the
system that Robbie used to say I don't
know what Robbie but you see the
difference you see the difference when
somebody gets up and their face is just
stone serious and everybody's a you know
what I mean it's like ah this looks like
a depression depressed state and when
somebody comes and just you know
connects it's it's a it's really bonding
it's really bonding with the people
ah it's really a form of bonding it
creates also it lets people remove the
fences humor ah right but also with
humor people like to remove their
defenses they're not so uptight the less
uptight they are the more open they are
the more you could communicate actually
effectively so this is not just because
people are weak it's actually essential
to the sheer it allows them to hear you
much more when they're more open and the
humor opens up people laughter opens up
people as you mulish like Peno right
laughter you fills your mouth I also
think they're welcoming everybody
it's very important yeah even somebody
who comes here once yeah
feels yeah yeah yeah I've asked myself
if I'm just being repetitive I already
said yesterday but then I realized that
it means a lot to people good morning
thank you for coming thank you for
gracing us I would owe sometimes our
thing like the same people I do it every
day like maybe come up with something
new but then I realized no it means
something I know that's a most of the
business uh but very good yep different
situations where this jutsu something
like that yeah
we're given in Yiddish I'm sure there
was a visiting but they're saying and it
was so stirred and so severe it was no
simpler I felt it yeah yeah yeah yeah
robber was considered the greatest one
of the greatest teachers of his
generation so he's teaching us something
very powerful
either to rob or robber but whether it's
robber robber
they were both they were from the
greatest of the generation robber was a
teacher of raava and older he was a
teacher of abaya and of raava
it shows the sweetness of this Indian
because it mentioned that myself right
right all right and the point here is
and this says in Tonya chapter seven
that the ballot Anya said is there most
of the businesses not Tyra if it's
tightest animals delicious it's actually
mundane but but he did it for the Tyra
so it became a part of Tyra the Muslims
itself becomes a part of holiness he
calls it Cletus Noida that's elevated to
kedusha
why because the Muslim is the
preparation for the Turner and this is
critical when somebody is teaching they
have to bond with their students
they have to create an atmosphere of
openness of joy
of bonding that people are comfortable
and they can open themselves up if not
it's the whole thing will not be as
successful it will be very unsuccessful
oh this is sir I don't know that I don't
know it's Aramaic Aramaic we have an
Indian we have what's called a bastion
comes from this word you know Barkin at
weddings about him
basically the Joker he makes rhymes and
song the word Botkin comes from the
dishes about I know who Trey battery
there were the two jokers right and Leo
and avi said they're going to Olam haba
that's who you mean a notary battery so
now she says some assumption Bonet Adam
Smith him I'm a Samson they were happy
themselves and they made other people
happy I know who Trey battery yeah this
gamar I think is maybe tynus I don't
remember huh I know Trey battery yeah he
says they blare them haba they would
Lily oh I know he said Binet Lamar they
trip people up that's the point
yeah was up it was something humorous I
once heard a bodkin say at a wedding
the reason rabbit did it is cuz he
wanted them to come on time so they
should have missed a joke that's what a
baton said at a wedding
that was his padishah everybody comes
late but they knew they come late they
missed a joke and it wasn't he didn't
allow anybody to video it so they
couldn't watch it later on what's up so
they had to come on time to this year so
the mela that was good
Samantha still hot it's my baby got a
flat out your inhibitions your each step
simplest already got blood upstairs let
go
very good yeah sometimes I've seen
teachers who'd Africa do the exact
opposite they get up and their darkest
turn they don't want to give any and the
impression of like even the slightest of
of lightheadedness and so they're very
very stern like they'll never crack a
smile even it's very very intense and
they do it with a they feel that
it's a much better way of learning
because because the intensity will be
greater for the students that's the
second stage that's a second stage yeah
but who they left they cheered they what
was the concept of laughing they
celebrated but Cubano okay on wash
tickle here
Turner de Bonham we go back to the big
question who composed hallo we're not
done
Thundra bun and the rabbi's taught
Hallows this hallow miyamura who said it
back to the question a new brace
rebellious a dreamer blesses his ma
cherie stroll Amaru Bassam duel ya how
are ya
Moshe and the Jewish people said how
long when they stood at the sea after it
split and they went through but say see
some Amit sir I am Ravi oh nice they
said hallo
they said hallo now what was the issue
here
so this Bryce is going to tell us
something very interesting when they
pass through the sea they didn't know
yet that Pharaoh and his troops are
going to drown they thought the sea
split maybe their enemies will also have
a free pass pun intended and will pass
through
and life will be as dreadful as before
so therefore the price that continues
hey mom aru they continue to Davin and
say loyal on new hashem loyal on lukela
she attained car without house column it
that car so how we have a whole move art
but say C supplements are a sacrament by
annoys they just saw this and they
composed it in prayer they rather we
said while on to watch them don't do it
for us do it for yourself because now
they're Davin in for the next stage for
the Egyptians not to be saved through
the korea-asean soft mushy broccoli dish
from rola Han and the Ruach ordered the
divine spirit responds and tells them a
verse from you Shia pay Rickman has
lomani lomani esse indeed I will do this
for myself you saying Loyola no lomani
LeMond es I will do this for myself as
the pasta continues ki8 yaho how can I
allow my name to be desecrated from the
word Hillel look very dealer after la
attain I will not give away my glory to
somebody else
this is what happens so rebel laser
teaches us a whole new idea hollow was
composed by the Jews and moisture right
after Korea Sampson's but before the
Shira the Shira happens when after
everything because they speak about the
drowning here it's in that very volatile
sensitive stage where they're still
diving they're still diving for a
Yahshua this is the view of Rabbi
Eliezer and now we have five
views about hallo w-who diameter Buda
sets
wrong yahushua vishal a marui bashar
shaundalyn mouth is not yahushua and the
Jews said hallo when the kings of Canaan
stood up on them in order to fight them
at that moment hey mama they said lalana
wash my Llano and again uma Shiva Andrew
Hakodesh answered with who Lila Manny
LeMond es sir I'm do it for myself
third opinion yeah bless I'm adorable
Azam adore eMeter bilasa Hamid I says
it's very Rivera
it was very the prophetess and Barak
banovina who said it
Beshara model am Sierra when Sierra who
was the commander-in-chief of the army
of Kanaan headed by the king oven and
sister was the arch enemy sister will
ultimately be killed by Al in the famous
story right with the peg in his forehead
so when sister stood up to fight them
they said Hal hey mom who they said
loyal oh no Hashem la la novia Hakodesh
Mishima various lemon hakodesh responds
lomani LeMond est ash IMM cast isaiah
40:8 i will do it from me the government
never laws have been Azaria minimalism
in Isaiah now we have the fourth opinion
rebel as the son of Messiah says
risk-averse ayaat I am aruba John
Williamson Calif riskier and the sages
of his generation said it when son Harry
of the Assyrian King stood up to fight
the Jewish people as we remember some
Herod ascended to your lion with a huge
huge army he wanted a conquered
Jerusalem he wanted to defeat the Jewish
people in fact there were Jews who
actually demanded that they surrender to
Sun tariffs that's why it says Hiskey of
a sea otter he had a group who didn't
agree and there was the famous plague
the night of Pesach the first night of
pacer a hundred and eighty thousand
troops of son Herod died and during this
siege Fiske Ian and his people said
hallo and what did they say hey mom rule
Elano uma Shiva Rahul Andrew ha kodesh
answers again Lamonica mani esta next
opinion Rabbi Akiva a fifth opinion yeah
the night of pacer they said how old
they prayed loyal or no that night in
the middle of the night to the troops
died 180,000 troops died in the morning
there was salvation the gomorrah says in
son head in our sham wanting to make
risky and mushiya but he didn't say
sheera afterwards here we're talking the
hollow during that surah we're talking
hollow during that Sarah got it okay
yes there was a plague the Tanakh says a
angel came and struck them all no no no
not yet
okay next labaki variable canvas says
anonymous of ours i emiru Bashar some of
them who had nets are Russia you see how
these opinions are revolving in Jewish
history the first opinion the opinion of
rebellious areas it's done by the sea
Rob you hood is Don forty years later
you sure been known in in in air too
strong
rebel azama da he is 200 years later
Barack and Vera write rebel ossipon
Azaria is Hiskey a hundreds of years
later this is when the ten tribes are
being exiled no buck even says after
Corbin by Hisham Kabbani mr. Boz I am
rubbish unlimited nets are Russia
Kanani Michelin Azaria said Halloween
Nabokov nets are Russia the Babylonian
Empire stood up and wanted to kill them
why because they refused to bow down to
the statue that Nebuchadnezzar put up as
the Navi as the book the kneel describes
her nanny Michelle Isaiah were cast in
to a furnace to be burned before that
day I said Halle hey mom rule I Londo Oh
Miss evil Emma knew her killer says
lomani lomani last opinion number six
really say ugly I admit it happens much
later it happens already at the end of
the Babylonian exile during the times of
Purim Mordechai Vesta Maroubra Shama
dilemma homina Russia Mordecai and
Esther say it when homina Russia stands
up Haim Amrullah la new
uma Shiva the holy rule ha kodesh
answers six opinions one Korea's yam
Soph - Yahshua be known 3d IRA for
riskier
five-can an immersive Azaria six
Mordecai and Esther so when was howl
composed a question of from Korea some
stuff all the way to the beginning of my
ashaming that means a quest
of almost a thousand years because the
Jews built the frisbee some actors 480
years 440 years after they came in Texas
strong it stood for 410 years and this
either happened all the way in the
beginning or in the middle all the way
at the end see dealing with a question
of between eight and nine hundred years
when Howell was composed from the Billy
as is opinion right in the beginning of
Jewish history trebuchet glue his
opinion all the way at the time of Purim
by Mordecai and Esther they are the ones
who said challah so we have six
different perspectives so altogether we
had one perspective of Allah saw earlier
that the Jews said it after Korea's
Samsung the perspective of his friend is
that David amela said it and now we have
all these six opinions of different
generations when Howell was composed and
who is the one who said it
yes good question and so how does it
come into the hello
if it was said by devoid make sense but
if it was said by his skier by
canon-ebersole Vaz I am are the Zionists
this is hundreds of years after mm Allah
give all the cash ila give all the cash
island for this this will be the last
piece let's see the Raja bomb moisture
so that's not a problem if mice just
said it and of it could put it in his
book if dove it didn't he could put it
in his book right if you're sure I did
it double could put it in his book and
if the virus said it you could put in
this book that's all before dove it but
riskier
is a king of you who do one of the last
kings hundreds of years after dove it
can be solvers acts after the Herman
Mordecai nest is after Corbin hundreds
of years after dove it dove it is before
the base on negatives this is at the end
of the base of makers you're dealing
with for five hundred year difference so
let's see the rush just take a look in
the rush bomb okay take a look before
the rash mom take a look at Rashi okay
three lines from the bottom of Rashi
rash she's on top of the riser on your
shoe of a shawl you stroll on my rule
you see you're sure of a hole you stroll
on Meru who you see that okay this is
the first opinion who said hallo you're
sure and the Jewish people said
Kalai my Rashi says I feel he showed us
all you stole Amaru he adds one word
when the Buddhist says yahushua said it
rashly adds one word off your issue of
this summer what is actually saying now
she's changing the whole idea w Hooda is
not argue if they're Belleza he's adding
moisture said it when they came out of
the young company business
yoshua also said it rebel oscillator oh
so Senate libel laws have been as I kiss
kiya also sanitary bhakti Mirchandani
also said basic the more the canister
also said earth in other words there's
no argument everyone agrees with Reb
Eliza that it was said by Moshe they
just say it was also said later that's
Russian so these were they repeated what
was said in an earlier generation right
right then it makes sense how its into
hilum because it was already around my
double but take a look in the rash bomb
same rash bomb Yahshua vitaly solomin
rule kill em are a few slowly and shoe
are my roots
oh so you're sure the same penis lobby
no this is how Rashi our rabbit what the
lonely he really this does not make
sense to me why why so now does take a
look back in the Gemara the last piece
the end of the Bryce what's the end of
the browser how come him aluminum
there's a seventh opinion what's how
come him and the VM shall be nay and
tickle em the assertion you everybody
sell Kalpana ko panic the profits among
the Thai in the time of moisture will
miss akan to say hallo and every young
TIFF file Colts are avatars from the
Soviet Laelius no any solder that comes
to the Jewish people SHINee : when they
redeem I mean in my cell goal awesome
that's the final seventh opinion the
Navi and made it to say it on Yom Tov
and they're saying by ever each other
when you redeem comes the - bomb and
says one second
if Raschi is right velena he released
shame cane but cool another circle fire
escape
if Rashi says it's about you're sure you
have to say bye
of them the in cane my BAE Nile so if so
what's the argument between them if
everybody holds that it was said by
Moshe
so it sounds like there's an argument
here dude I am at this one I'm at this
one I'm they really all agree who
composed it so what's the real argument
about between them obeying what's the
problem you could say well they're
arguing of these people said it no mic
might be now you have been coming shall
I meet him the VM sure been A&M rule
what's the difference between the first
six opinion in the seventh opinion what
are the common say that the Navy him
among them were my second to say it
right we're Misaki to say it so Freck de
- bomb what does it sound like the ha
common are arguing with them why they're
I'm arguing with them cuz they're they
said that it was composed in all these
times there's a common are saying that
it was at economists naveen to say it by
every surah right that's exactly what
happened so it's very good so the common
fits in with all the opinions cuz they
have come and said intervenes and you
should say by every Soros that's what
happened but how many sounds like a new
opinion it's not a new opinion in a
firm's all the opinions together so
what's the difference between them and
the common for our sila maimie they've
come come and say the hall huh need a
moral ALM rule out Soros on share a
techno Naveen lekar then all of them
said it because of the Zara right but
they're all agreeing you understand the
point white Rasheed is a big fraud
because loiter ah she each one is just
adding to the other one yeah so what
does Ruby Akiva halt or abuse take a
look everybody did it plus Kananga
plus murder fantastic and what are the
Cobham say the Thummim say that then a
vm made it in time of moisture to say it
at every surah so they could come him
agree with ability and Lily and agree
with her bf Kiva and agree with their
Balazs it agree people of Talmud ie
they're all saying that they said it at
all these tourists and that's exactly
what the heck am I saying
so we is there an argument the column is
not a new opinion it's exactly what
everybody is saying that they said it
throughout every surah again
and again and again it was composed by
Moshe and it was sent throughout history
that's exactly what the Hamas say
exactly so the common there's no
argument so the rash bomb says on the
call Assad minute annoying hockey
Kimberly me Robbie I have a different
interpretation here's a seven-way
argument here every time that hurts from
his rubber this is when how law was made
for the first time according to the
first opinion rebel s was made by clear
Sam soft according to neighborhood that
was made by yahushua it was made at that
time and then comes the seventh opinion
the how come him who argue and give a
new opinion that the Newseum made in the
time of moisture and it was said on all
seven and all six times that's the final
opinion of the hakama
now it makes sense the Gemara but now we
have the problem of tehilim
if it was only made later we have the
problem of two hilum so the introduction
of the Maldon to tehilim the
introduction of the malbim - Tehillim
says as follows
he says that tehilim very interestingly
became the handbook of Jewish poetry and
emotional expression and therefore that
the hilum was not sealed and canonized
by Dove it it was still an open book and
according to these opinions that could
have been chapters added later and
hallow would have been one of those
chapters when they did it in the turn an
immersive Isaiah or Mordecai and Esther
or Hiskey hemella they then took the
hallow
and put it into the teller that's how
the malbim interprets this Gomorrah
according to the Raj bombs
interpretation which is a very
fascinating idea the hilum was not
sealed by the ramela it remained a
handbook for Jewish emotional expression
and poetry and therefore when this new
poem was created hallo the hummin felt
it belongs and tell them and I went in
to tell them because if not we have a
serious problem here
how it came in - Tehillim right
the only composed 1771 that means that
some of it was not composed by dove it
unlike Reb mayor who said earlier that
everything in tehilim came through dove
it but according to this interpretation
you have to say not that's what the
malbim says I see that the art scroll
Gemara says that you have to say that
dove it prophetically sought and he
already put it in a safer even though
wasn't made yet by these people that's
maybe another interpretation according
to Rashi it's not a problem because it
was already said by mush I don't know
could be but that's the mobs
interpretation that the hilum was not
canonized it wasn't certain times of the
Vimala okay everybody have a wonderful
day a wonderful Shabbos shlocker with
everything and remember if you get into
a bad mood today start singing yeah the
Gemara bah bah bah sir the last eight
sukham the last eight suka maybe a shoe
wrote or Marcia wrote them in tears how
could his mother who I'm more emotional
I serve Adama similar idea that moisture
wrote about the future or now you show
actually wrote it you say the same thing
with the hilum that the Hollow may have
been written later listen to say that
that the hilum was sealed by Dava ramela
not necessarily could be it was
available but the poil the time after
that it was sill just like we have in
machine eyes was a McLucas if clay
Hellas should be part of Tanakh you know
that if she has shittim should be part
of Tanakh these were all big arguments
they were available from Schlemmer but
who decided to go into the Tomas maybe
it shouldn't some books didn't go into
the Tomas right Ben Sira
etc so that recognizes our Delaware that
period the beginning of Maya Shamy
they decided what shall be the final
format of Tomas Corrales yeah even share
him even sure sure McGillis Esther
Esther had to fight for it
the Gomorrah says as to said Kosovo nila
Doris and they said you're creating
anti-semitism the harkaman said McGillis
Esther will create anti-semitism because
of what we did in Persia and then -
ravish and it sounds like you know
manipulation and and you know what
Esther said let's just said they all
know the story
I just want Jews to know the story Alex
Oh Barnabas if Rimouski mother but they
all know it already it's written
everywhere just drew the Jews at least
not the story why would she ever once
said over that time poor him and he said
Druze are afraid that if they're gonna
be proud know their story
and who they are and what they represent
I'll create anti-semitism Esther said
you don't understand the know
everything about the Jewish people the
Jews have to know about the Jewish
people know about that they know Jews
are they know exactly who Jews are you
don't even cut reason Jews after no Jews
are huh first taste hallo you say they
should have put it in though right no so
could be that there were more things
added also that's the point maybe more
things were Abbot could be more things
were added and also maybe they
reorganized ah I hear you saying
according to this it should have been
later yeah interesting inion very
interesting sugah first
alright the Gomora discusses that right
capital Oliphant base okay everybody
have a wonderful day and a lot of Arts
locker some crucial Mitzvah I was once
in a place to give a lecture
it was a very serious crowd very intense
crowd and it was just too uptight for me
I realized it's not gonna work but I
knew that if I say a joke it's gonna be
even worse because they're gonna feel
like I'm insulting them so I'm like
getting looking boy initial Ellen what
am i doing then I come I told them the
Gemara says so they all got excited
because tomorrow right sounded uptight I
said the Gemara says I'm soccent of
coffee and SIA that robber before he
gave her she said Muslim dishes so I
said even though I don't want to give a
Muslim disgusting and you don't want me
to give him most of the system but the
cameras says that's what you do so
that's what we're gonna do so then they
loosened up a little so what am I
supposed to do I don't wanna I don't
want to it's torture torture to laugh we
don't want to do that much better to be
depressed and angry and uptight but I
have no choice I have to follow rappers
example so I'm gonna say most of the
blue stuff
I don't remember was a good joke that
was already irrelevant the main joke was
the beginning yeah I still I'm not
saying how high yellows are shocked our
capital home phase says Esther said it
when she was going to her she Irish
Kayle Kayle llamas often a very good
question also is it sad that Esther was
repeating governor MELAS tehilim or that
she composed it that would be another
example yeah it says Esther said Athiya
Kayle Kayle llamas off Tommy
why'd you abandon me obviously there was
an editor of tehilim that nobody argues
because it says masculine Akira well I'm
not saying live in a Kyra muscular Haman
right miss Marilla Asif it's not all of
it there were authors they were cut
their work to fill all emotion so there
was an editor there was for sure an
editor who took the MS Miriam finished
them up put them in the right space
to have that it doesn't it's not one
book it's not what off huh so could be
dubbing himself that's where the mayor
says that Ovid is responsible for all or
could be somebody else that's my point
you see from tehilim that wasn't just
one hand from beginning to end
there were many hands over there so the
Dove it's a everything ultimately was he
like the last word the last editor
perhaps and according to these two mine
prophetically he had to even do the
other ones or no there were hands later
that touched her to Helen according to
the malbim only schleimann is a capital
for Schlemmer
lish Lima right Ella Kim mich pataskala
MELAS but said cos Caliban Mela capital
I am basis for Slimer so this was
apparently a poem that he wrote for
schleimann in honor of Schlemmer right
he's basically asking hashem to take
care of Schlemmer give him wisdom and
give him sense of justice or 12/12/12 no
mizmor though the practice means a song
to dove it meaning no it's not like yeah
yeah yeah I understand you saying this
men don't mean like attributed of it
like I'm singing a song for my my my
friend no so the camera says mismo
doesn't means like a song of dove it
like a song to dove it is basically it's
a song of dove it to himself
yeah yeah song that came to me or a song
I sang to myself or about myself yeah
yeah the camera clearly says miss melody
that the MS macaws - Rena so it it's
about him himself eeeh
Oh Sam is maillard of divorce him apnea
Shaolin Brunei and then he says Hashem
my Roberts alright his son runs away and
Hashem like saris are so big obviously
it's not a friend writing about him
cause yeah so they come up with the
Gemara is saying is that in those
situations where he didn't feel the
sheena he started singing and that
itself created the the vibe the holy
vibe
Oh so according to the Belleza the Shira
was said after the midstream were
defeated and hollow at least started to
be said before because they were Davin
annoyed Llano Hashem Londo don't do it
for us do it for you Lemuria game are
going at least part of Hollow it's hard
to imagine that they said the whole howl
in that period when maybe they had time
I don't know when they left to see
before the Egyptians came in it could be
also they'd arvind the kid sir and then
later they turned it into the hollow i
don't know if it means that the whole
Musa was managed then could be a love it
composed a hallelujah why didn't know
well he wanted to write other things
also Marsha flush I'm Celtic Malawi
hallucis uncle how you do
manometer or neshama Sheena he wanted to
write other things but he also pays
tribute to Caesar Simon crea Samsa and
many other miracles to other generations
it's one of the things but he didn't
just want to stick to the to the shooter
that's la Caramba
this class is brought to you by the
achieve Annette please help us continue
the classes make even a small
contribution at triple w dot they
ueshiba net / donate