Pesachim 115a: The Secret of Hilel's Sandwich - Arvei Pesachim

the yeshiva dotnet I don't know how much time everybody has but it's kadai tu casa this is good monitoring the day before Pesach it's really the meat and potato or I should say matzah and hazaras behind to say then I know it's not meat and potato but the moths and the Hazaras behind they say there and the wine yeah we're holding a Marathi nahin see I'm a Raveena the line one two three four five six seven eight nine eight lines from the top Tov cocktail of Ahmad Aleph Omar Raveena Amalia of measure Shia you see around eight or nine lines from the topic of test move on but I love my sex tips off I don't know if we have a clear name for the compiler of the Haggadah much of the text of how God do we have in the Mozilla which is already from the times of the tunnel and then in the times of the we already have Amram goin and others we already have text of the huh goddess but but who is the manage the Masada Haggadah the official compiler of that God I'm not sure that we have a name major parts were round yeah major parts were round by the second base emitters and then after the second base I make a dish and I'm ready by the tannoy I'm after the second base under the mistletoe which is remember a higher of Achieva there's after the second base I mean if we have much of the text of the Haggadah that we use yeah we spoke about it yesterday bilasa herbalizer be assure are about kuvira - and it blows up in isaiah no just those well we have later on McCleod curse of Rabi Akiva Annabel Lee as in a BAC and Lily about the ten plagues if it was ten plagues yeah you'll have randomly alright I'm Leo said calm isolation voter man so we have a few time now you mentioned yeah yeah yeah after the horn but they're often after horn buy a shiny pill okay now say hello that we're gonna discuss today Hillel is already much earlier no they were right after they some were but some were born after the story in Bnei Brak has five people is my son Bobby Eleazar that's rebellious or how God litter bless him in her goodness and then you have the next one is Rubio yushua he was a lady he was also by the base I made it he's one of the vocalists to measure him it's one of the singers and the bass I Mukesh it was a Lavery show Martin Anya he was considered the greatest debater of the Jewish people in his day then the third one is your bilasa Ben Azaria became the nasi of the Sanhedrin after him Gamliel was dethroned amis after breakfast then your rib Akiva and then you have enough - they always wondered why the order why this order the lubavitcher rebbe is how God that he suggests interestingly he says rabbi Eleazar and Rubio issuer with the rebus of Rabbi Akiva nobody Akiva had them as teachers noble ossipon Azaria was the nasi he was the head of the Sanhedrin so first they put never lesser then they put revere schewe who were the older members then they put your blossom in Azaria because he was the nasi came from Ithaca Morris's from a great family mish Mahamaya fascist and then Rabbi Akiva and they ripped - repeat - was was also a Deb of Rabbi Akiva but he was also a cavalry rabbi akiva and since it was Bnei Brak and Rebecca was de Moura das Trimble neighbor looks they put trivia keep it before - but a blossom in Isaiah before I became in a pleasantry sure before everybody that's one interpretation of interpretation he brings is that the gomorrah says that when when they used to recline in beds when they used to eat so if you have a great man he's in the middle and the person who's second is on the right of him on top of him and the person who's third is on the on the bottom of him right and if there's two people who are greater so you'll have number two you'll have number three and then you'll have a number four he'll have a number five on his left she says her rebel ossipon Azaria was in the middle cause he was de nasi ya w schewe and her Billy as ur on the right Via Cavour enough - on the left that's my that's how they used to sit by the Seder everyone had their own couch in their own bed their own little table should have less have been outside should have a lesser degree shoe on the right table as up in Isaiah in the middle or became a photographer on the left but said his saber it worked that way that's how they used to recline the goggled the EMSA and the other golem on top of him and the katana on the bottom of him well very interesting interpretation why it's disorder because the order is a strain why this order back Eva was the Mardan of Bnei Brak Bnei Brak so he should have been first but he couldn't be first because you're Belleza was his Arriba and I'm gonna put your name before you Reb his name's a pasta we're sure was also dead it was have been as I wasn't as you know but he was the Nazi your paraffin was as it was also however and it's been a Brooks retired for when at the end that's Abbas interpretation in his Agartha and then there's the engine of the Seder of how they second interpretation it's brought and smaranam that Mossad did the denim of dough element on him it worked out that way because their bilasa was the nazis they gave him the the middle even though they're blessed sure were probably older were world they're not probably they were all members of Sanhedrin but they were in the leaders of the son had the son hadn't had a Nazi and I've bested the know she was gamma gamma leo from Gamliel was treating revere Scheuer very very harshly the gomorrah says he made him stand the whole time and they so they they took it away from him gamma leo and they gave it to a blossom in isaiah and then they brought back room gum leo and it was three weeks in one week really would give this year for three weeks and the blossom as I would give this year one Chavez and they both came back together but terrible as abanazar you who took over the minimally oh yeah they were very upset hard when I'm wheeled they felt that it was it was not I'm Leo was trying to maintain the authority of Halawa he wasn't doing it's Tom it wasn't an ego trip I mean I'm will was a big Sadiq but he felt this was the right way of dealing with him very sure and they felt that reassure it was wrong he passed indifferent Lee and I'm will you know he may I was arguing with him heavily which was an initial but he once the Adams standing the base med which the whole time him kipper was unkind summize he made him come with his money on Yom Kippur cuz I'm really really need to say so I'm not doing anything for my honor I'm trying to do the right thing but they felt it was a wrong approach I'm Leo was very strong they felt it was a wrong cover husband as I was much more Hasidic gum will kept everybody out call Tom McCain terrific a body like honestly based on magic brothers of class tell me that his insight is not like his outside doesn't go in and he had a guard that Blas abanazar you took away the guards everybody goes into the best medicine the whole basement is filled up with people says 400 new chairs or 800 new trees who you meet toys for South Alabama draws hundreds of new chairs because people came in tastes worse absolutely mad rush I once saw speaker get up for a Russia and as he got up the whole place emptied out so he said now I understand what the Gemara means out who yummy taste versus Alabama in our show there were many new chairs Mike she has new people just because some people got up to speak and suddenly do a lot of chairs dice for South Slav be my dinner she says the Metallica rally huh he was making a joke here all that she is empty you got to speak everybody ran out Jesus it tastes worse off Scylla a cauldron Gamliel felt that if you're not perfect inside and outside you don't deserve to be in the basement Jim Campbell was looking for the highest caliber and a blah subpoenas are you said you can't you can't have he achieve it that way we need cross-pollination need different types of kids we in the big question is how can a guard determine if a town m''d inside how do you determine these things to what guards Isabella's are but as I took away the guard who was the sheriff he was about roja Kadesh huh-huh how can the show-me determine who your inside is like your outside stay in no but it says your bellossom and as I took away the Shimer he took away the guard and he let everybody come in and we'll also came in that day how can a guard determine inner character so apostasy was told Sara blows up in Isaiah I'm Leo told them this woman I once saw of art I think from the inner EMS or the farmers I think it's a Gary Vaart I saw it once he put a guard who didn't let anybody in and the person who fought and got in you knew that he really means it the guard didn't let anybody come in the boy who made it you knew he means my father took off he went to the southern mountains we was the first yeshiva came to him the next day over there with the Polish Engel if you wanna come come so your father went to klutz to the bar where barnico claw was in clutch skin that's how you ended up use the one they got in here the end oh yeah yeah so so saying so my brother's familar I don't know who dystrophy with my brother Jacques the hail King Amara Amara Vina Raveena said o Malley Live Mesh are shy about ad-lib knows mr. Shia the son of reminiscent old me hockey armor Hillel mesh made the Gemara this is what Hillel said in the name of the AMA Iranian who preceded him chimera is the term of learning the people who learned this is not Hillel the famous Hill Oh huzzah can the elder who was soon going to discuss who was a Tanner who lived a hundred years before the destruction of the second base a McNish this is actually a completely different Hillel this is the last Hillel in Jewish history he was a tenth generation of Hillel azúcar he was from the dynasty he was a descendant tenth generation of the original Hillel adulkin this is Hill o thou Maire so he lives a few hundred years after the original Villa so Raveena who's animator says I heard from Rebecca Shia that he's quoted Hillel that's how we know it's a later hill oh because Raveena this quoting you never miss our Shah he was quoting Hill o who said in the name of the AMA Iranian who preceded him this is what he said listen to this Lanisha I finish matzah murder Baha Theodore even a hoe a person should not make a sandwich of matzah and murder together and eat them do not bundle together nish Royce is like the word chorus sandwich right bundle together Krisha is a sandwich don't rap together matzah and martyr and eat them why miss from the severe alone because we hold Hillel said matzah bisman as a ricer matzah even nowadays when we eat it by the say there is a biblical commandment it's a mitzvah mandatory to eat matzah even today with no base on McNish even though we're not that we don't have a carbon Pesach we still have an obligation to eat matzah omorrow did a bond but Maurer nowadays is only a rabbinic commandment not a biblical commandment what's the shot the terrorist says about the carbon pacer in Paris biological by pacer Shanee and the partials boy by pacer accretion now Matsui so Miriam your clue you should eat the Passover offering with matzah and Mara that means the mitzvah to eat Mara came as what as an accompaniment to the Carbon pace I want you to eat the lamb chops or the goats whatever the proper basis is a lamb or a goat or a sheep or a goat together with matzah and martyr so the mitzvah of martyr is what only as an accompaniment to the cutting pace there's no cutting Pesach there's no mitzvahs murder the training never says the night of paces I want you to eat tomorrow turn is that one you need to carbon Pacers with mats and mortar so now there's no carbon pesos will never be some makers there's no myths from an eternity tomorrow but matzah there's a separate pasta can perishes boy but area of tulum axis on the night of pace that you should eat matzah independent so matzah remains a mitzvah dairy rice even today because the Toyota doesn't make it exclusively dependent on the carbon baser but more I mean hot area you have to have a carbon pacer to be Makai in the Mitzvah of Mara so why do we eat martyr today after the horn base I maybe there's the rabbi's instituted that zatia Allah mikdash a commemoration to the time of the base I make this when we ate murder with the mat with the carbon bases we shouldn't know today - so matzah today's day rice martyr today is only the Rabanne says hello don't make a sandwich and eat them together why because sins map says dad I said mother is there a bond on so therefore all see murdered Arab unknown Ummah Vitaly lamotte said a lie sir the taste of the murder which is rabbinic is going to nullify and obliterate the taste of the matzah which is the rice and you won't fulfill the mitzvot of matzah meaning when the trader says to eat matzah it means you have to eat matzah don't mix in other flavors other tastes don't put in sugar don't put it honey don't put in spices don't put in train I didn't ask you I asked you to eat matzah matzah has to have integrity it has to be pure matzah same reason we don't cook matzo needed to forget the issue of Gabe rocks you don't eat my you know kinda me - it's not some of a shelves with cooked matzah you want pure matzah authentic the taste of mud if you sandwich it with Mario you put them in your mouth together the motor is going to be ma - the Tom hammock sir vasee loool Amanda or my mitzvah same avato Zuzu and even if you hold that mitzvahs are not my battle one the other two mitzvahs when they're being done together one will not nullify the other so therefore when you're eating mats and murder they shouldn't nullify each other and the Gemara soon is going to explain what this means on what this opinion is we're gonna get there in a moment but even according to that hanim merely the rice be the rice it's only if it's a toy there one day nicer with another day die sir are abundant did abana or it's a sandwich of one rabbinic person with another rabbinic Mitzvah Avel died I saw there a burner but when your sandwich thing together annoyed isanother a bun on Aussie their abominable bottle is very nice the rabbinic one is going to obliterate the biblical ones of the Mara which is rabbinic will obliterate the matzah and the Gemara explains what it means this opinion Montana - omelette lame it's the same of atheleisure a Sioux who is the tonneau who all that mitzvahs will not nullify each other even when you eat them together and they have two distinct taste hello this hello is the original Hill o hill over elder the Tana who was a nurse who was the leader of the Sanhedrin approximately one century before the destruction of Masonic - the mission mission was destroyed approximately in the year 70 after the Common Era and Hill Allah zarkan lived around a hundred years earlier and he was the nasi of the Sanhedrin his colleague was of course Shama Shama as aachen Hillel and Shammai and they developed two schools of thought base Hillel and base Shama we learned before the most like is about kiddush if you make first a brook on wine or a brach on Shabbos and yom tov schools of Shama and schools of Hillel who have a few hundred arguments and shots about different aspects of Halawa but this is the original hillier Hillel he its hillo the tanya we have a brace on where all of our Hill up they used to say about hello show your car horn Babar sokka's viola he used to make a sandwich what was it a sandwich the carbon pesach he lived a hundred years before the Corbin by Shanee the carbon pesach they did everything this is a second base i McNish hello lived a century before the destruction of the second base I see was the time to be some weakness used to make a sandwich or sandwich of what the meat of the carbon Pesach one second wait wait for your car honey and a sandwich she had in the sandwich the meat of the carbon pacer he had motsi at martyr baba sokka's and one shot together but oil and he ate them together shanem are the carbon says al matzah so my rhodium your clue the paw success in biological about Pesach Shanie that in the second month on the fourteenth day yeah so I saw you should make the carbon pacer our matzah so my rhodium your clue eat it owl doesn't mean on top it means with like it says by the Mishkan via via hashem al hahn awesome the men came on the wing the men came on top of the women didn't come on top of the women where they were sitting on their heads the women were carrying the man that means they came with our motto sandra me a clue means you eat it with mats and murder by pay secretion it also says o Maxis al medina me a clue and paste a parakeet based pasta cassia smiley seed based pasta class ever Hamish you might given me a homage am just hooked up oh good Shila good Shiloh good Schuyler good Schuyler why wouldn't he bring like a pillar deposit from pace solution why bring basic training because in the ocean and parishes boy is peyrac you'd base pass success the PASOK says for a clue as her boss Herbal ila has their /oh mattress al miriam your clue beautiful posture eat the meat on this night roasted on fire with Matz's and mortar you should eat it but he brings the pasta from from pace of shiny it's a very interesting order you're asking doesn't include bus maybe that's what because it wouldn't be a good analogy secretion uh maybe okay so oh one second one second it's a good harder right so that the armato samarium your clue is a passage from bajalia right but impatiens boy it says very similar it says o matzah is all miriam your clue which is almost similar in ad vocalist a possible i lhasa right in in ballet secret says bain are by Yasu i saw which refers to oyster the carbon basic our motto similar a miracle oh yeah it's it's a very good harder it's a very good order I'll address it but okay okay both good artists what is Hillel teaching us here hillo used to make a sandwich why he said that's what the plastic means eat the carbon pacer with matzah and murder together what does together mean together he took a bite and in that bite you had matzah yeah damar yet the carbon-based huh I'm it's miss Moffat Azu Azu the mower and the matzah is obliterating the carbon paste the carbon basically blitter ad the matzah tomorrow's obliterate the mots mitzvos aim of atlas or so why not okay oh oh all good questions all good question but that's let's first address what he's saying and then we'll get to the questions he's saying here I give all the cavort mitzva same of Atlas Rizzo we learned before feet mats and Maura today the murder is gonna be my battle the matzah I it's to mitzvos no this is the Rabanne Anderson Thai rice but it would be their dice in their eyes so would it be more vital each other what's the havona the Ivana here is the - bomb gives us one word Raj Varma fiddle amondawa is the third Raj mom a fiddle Amanda are the key Vonda C Haddad Lee Nino since you're eating them together Kulu kiya mitzvos Nino they're all a fulfillment of mitzvos Valeri motley Hadi and they're not my battle each other what is it as mom telling us what is bitl what is Bittle what does bittle mean when we speak in our luck about bitl it means two things come together they are essentially enemies meaning they contradict each other right so we speak about bittle be right the majority wins orbital position it's a ratio of 60 to 1 you win or will speak about Bittle in 100 orbital and 200 which basically means let's speak about this sociologically if you're a refugee and you come into a new community you you assimilate you become part of the larger majority it's very hard to retain your own identity right when everybody around you is doing something else that's what the concept of middlin it's also true physically you pour in a little milk into the cholent by mistake right or you put in a little soup into another soup it assimilates it loses its distinct identity because of the pressure of the majority class a case of bittle is yeah min but shame amina min be shame I mean it means two different species and therefore they come together and really they're competing against each other but since I'm the majority or at 60 to 1 so therefore you melt away and you lose your identity in the in the melting pot in the big pot one is a sir one is motor so if there's enough to be my bottle becomes bottle if not not here what's the bittle it's not to one thing is forbidden one thing is permissible you're eating mats and Mauro it's both a mitzvah study Dyson's did I bonnet but you say the model is my bottle des mots why is the modem of Atilla matzah because you supposed to eat matzah not mixed in with anything else so takes away from the matzah says hello that's all if the two things are not mitzvahs if the two things are mitzvos a move at leas who they can't be more vital each other you know why because if you go down to there it's really the same Nakota it's a mitzvah and because it's a mitzvah it's ultimately one so one mid server can take away and nullify an obliterating of the mitzvot which is fascinating physically it changes the taste of the matzah no question but because it's a mitzvah so ultimately at the core what is it what is matzah a mitzvah what is Mario I Mitzvah to mitches in other words if you want to use spiritual language what is the mats at its core godliness what is the morrow at its core godliness godliness can't destroy godliness hi this is matzah this is morrow that's just a manifestation of the godliness the manifestation of the mitzvah but then it could is mitzvah have been a goodness Mitzvah so you don't you're not my phatal me your Masek me you emboldened me it's like it's like when uh when a refugee comes and then his best friend comes from the same country they help each other they emboldened each other the midst is not move at all the other Mitzvah the Mitzvah brings out the other Mitzvah they're on the same team they're both connecting to a Shem hi this is bitter and this is matzah that's the physical manifestation but then a CUDA is you're connecting to God through this and through this swimming in Novato experience less good will soon see another will soon see another ah good it depends how you look at a mitzvah if you look at the Mitzvah from the external physical point of view then even mitzvot some of Atholl one the other this is Maura this is matzah sorry they it's two separate creatures but if you're looking at the Mitzvah from the premise of the Mitzvah the deeper core of the Mitzvah then the moths and the martyr is really one exome it's one entity each one is a mitzvah of Hashem so they can't contradict or even undermine or belittle each other it depends how you look at a mitzvah do you look at a mitzvah from the human perspective or do you look at a mitzvah from the divine perspective from the human perspective it's matzah and mortar from the physical perspective from the divine perspective you just did a mitzvah he just did a mitzvah he became one with God let my enough come in right now this is all if it's both a mitzvah but what if one is voluntary and one is a mitzvah it isn't a violent sins bhisma as a martyr is not biblical it's only rabbinic from a biblical perspective the murderer is not a mitzvah it's voluntary so today if you eat tomorrow with matzo what happens you move out allah tala matzah because from a very Raisa perspective the martyr is not a mitzvah what's the murder just horseradish just bitter horseradish ah they're abundant but from bats is very nice from the eraser level you're not doing a Mitsu with murder right you know doing a mixer with mother so the morrow is just regular food it's like eating an onion it's like taking matzo and putting on it borscht and onions and seven-layer cutting a piece of cake their abundance momentary rice and murder is not a mitzvah so on a dirty rice a level the time of the matzo got nullified but he didn't do a mitzvah through the murder this man of the base of McNish Hillel had a sandwich of paste matzah more the martyr was when I traitor mitzvah same of Ottawa Zuzu but bhisma Hazare the modern is the holy dear Obama so if it's a terrible man and Adira born on you good they won't be move out to each other if it's a very nice and a de-icer you're good there won't be a battle each other but if it's a very nice another a bomb on the dura banda will be Movado the dice the dice or a boner but it's not Islam with the TARDIS says to listen to their opponent that's true turtle is so I have to listen to their Abama but the thefts of the murderer right is not a heft of a mitzvah I have to listen to the Ramona but the thefts of the moor is not a heft of a mitzvah right right when they're a nice it looks at this tomorrow what type of martyr is it just a regular food it's not a bit it's not a commandment cuz it's abysmal ASSA so when I'm putting that murder into the mouth together with the matzo I obliterated the biblical matzah mitzvah conversely when I eat matzah together with martyr the matzah didn't obliterate the martyr because even by the rabbi's the mat says I mitzvot so the matzah doesn't nullify the murder but the morrow nullifies the matzah then matzah doesn't alter the murder but the murderer alters their matzah under erisa level that's why he'll hola Maria said today by taking away the taste i mitzvot same of applause urs Udina Cudas Ruxin Hashem no it's not rotten and smaller mats a motive is mana bias what's the new coudair Roxanna Sheng Matsumoto bhisma Hazare what's the new kuda it's modern it's not rocks Russia Oh a good question good question now you'll understand our whole say there now you'll understand I say there people don't realize what goes on and I say that what thoughts color you'll see in a minute when I finished what you'll soon see in a minute coz Mar is not nothing more is something it's taste will interrupt it will interfere the purity and the integrity of the mots experience the case is gonna multiply in the sandwich but at that point you already already grabbed on to not if I eat it with the murder okay well one second what the Gemara just said what will soon see we're not here talking about our Seder the Gomora said that he'll ovum iris said don't sandwich them together because the rice said their opponent cannot work together because the rabona will be Movado the rice even if you say mitzvos a mavala Zuzu which is why he'll Oh made a sandwich that's only the right sir I said they're abundant Ivana not adoration everyone that's what the Gomorrah said and therefore today he says don't sandwich matzah and moral even though Hillel did because by hello there was also the carbon pacer and the carbon pacer made it although rice was one big sandwich of the OI Raisa it's a different sandwich artists I by halo the sandwich was not so much slammed against the sandwich yes yes the lady Hillel said my grandfather's sandwich ate your sandwich man yeah yeah yeah yeah exactly exactly yeah what'd you say [Music] we're gonna to do in a moment we're gonna trust me in a moment we're gonna see what we do now I want to quote tousle Senora her ofsome and tough i na we discusses this gomorrah and he says bisman Shabbos HaMikdash Khayyam that de Moura was awesome in a Toyota Yahtzee de leyva smart savvy de hi were smarter Lovisa Mitzvah the shell Toyota a MAV Atlas zoo why the finish school in Haines caucus Shaku lon team it's voice of Shalaka - Baraka Wayne they're considered one they're all an implementation of a divine Mitzvah that's what they are so the murder in its pristine core is key mitzvah the Matteson at christine core is kia mitzvah they don't interfere with each other this is helping the could and their as mom says it but kids say he says Oh looky omits listening home well I'm avidly a daddy then Bala tiny elaborates a little but that's why you can make a sandwich now let's see let's see what happens now this drama is not over yet I'm gonna be elation at a Buchanan said coil can I love have a dove shall Hillel this was Hillier Hill else friends didn't agree they held different than Hillel the Tanya we have a Bryce the Bryce assess your Holy acre from Abbas our cosmos will good I really like what you might think you should make a sandwich between all three and eat them like Hillel together Talmud low morale matzah so my rhodium your clue who what's your who are matzah some room you should eat it I feel lose ever flats my visible a aunts my even each one independently as near as bomb explains by the first pay Circuit says Baraka Lewis a busser by Lila's ATS Liege are mattress or my rhodium your clue it should could have said our master so my ride him yes Lou you don't have to say your who we know what we're talking about eat the meat together with mats a mother right eat we know what we're talking about why does it say who you should eat it it seems superfluous both Zukerman by Ambala i end up with the word your slew who you should eat it you should eat it one of the passage would have just said a matzo so Miriam your halo or matzo Salman a miracle they should eat we know what to eat in the beginning of the positives as eat this meat right in English you to eat this meat together with mats and Mahler why they have to say your flu I can repeat you should eat it the Aqua submersible Lila's ATS liege Oh matzah Psalm I write him eat them me together with matzah sin the more you could say your halo you should eat your clue you should eat it because the posit is trying to say according to this Bryce sir I feel who's ever from the ants my visible from a smile that what you should eat only it what do we mean only it even independently carbon Pacers independently matzah independently your who who in other words you eat one after the other one in close proximity to each other but each one independently carbon pacer separate matzah separate more separate that's the price the cafe diem of hello argued with Hill Oh your clue who it's an individual eating eat them after the other our motto Samara means in the same meal proximity one after the other but not mixed together why mitzvot Sarma vassal says because they're looking at the physical experience weird obliterates it well soon see how he Baskin will soon Sally basket well the person is just quoting the calvarium of hill oh yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah no not yet not yet Mosca florida Bashi a hockey Maya fellow really if this is the of the Cohanim that you're not supposed to eat it together I'd say I feel as ever if not himself not somehow I feel means you could eat it independently but you don't have to I feel it means even independently el amor de bashing about she said you're wrong this Brice agrees with Hill oh that what that you should eat it together hi Tonia hockey Kotani this is what the Tana means your college eights a buoy that Havas ALM can come about Jacques welcome Derek shallow life long you would think you're not fulfilling the mitzvot only if you sandwich it together and eat it like Hillel used to eat it you would think that Hilo's way of doing it was like of it was indispensable and you're not fulfilling the mitzvot any other way Talmud loin Mar al matzah similarly Emir who I feel is ever from the arts may resemble ayaats mine so the Brice's says you could do it independently your Yeats in the Mitzvah even independently the Bryce is not arguing with hello the Bryce is just saying your clue says that if you didn't make a sandwich you still fulfill the Mitzvah it's not like you didn't fulfill the mid so if you didn't eat them simultaneously that's what the Bryce I mean that's not an argument with Hillier so the bi-xenon says the have a damn argued with Hill oh that's true but Habashi says this Bryce has not approved this Bryce actually works with Hill oh it's just telling you that be evident have to make a sandwich if you ate them separately you still young sir but if you ate them as a sandwich I've had the good as she is maintaining that from this Bryce and there's no proof to the kuvira move Hillier so the Gemara concludes hash to now delete my Hill Cicely Cahill over like a rabona the halacha was never there was no vote there was no Holocaust abla not like hillo and not like the Friends of Hill oh not like Hill aloo said that in the time of the basin make this you had to do a sandwich that's where the traitor wants and mitzvahs are not move out to one another and not like this I saw men who say that you have to eat them independently cause mitzvos I'm a battle one another we don't know what the halacha was never established let me tell you says the Gemara what to do today maverick Allah Hillis matzo vocal make sure you make a bra color Hillis mats and eat your causes matzah independently why if you'll sandwich it with Maru the Mitzvah is gonna be mavet on the matzah the moor is gonna be battle the months so eat matzah you mcian mats for harder maverick Allah Phyllis more Eva and then make a broccoli HeLa smaller Andy tomorrow why if you eat the matzah together with the moral the hakama mu argued with Hillel will say the matzah was my battle tomorrow the matzah was move on tomorrow if you ate mats independently and then you eat matzah together with martyr thus our common who argue with Hillel who say that more are you eat independently miss manna bias right now there's a mix with your opponent eat murder why are you public singing matzah Matt says Movado tomorrow eat matzah independently eat more independently for harder alchemax of a Haase body inaudi now eat matzah murder together in a sandwich below bracha safer lamech dish killer to commemorate what Hillel did in the time of the based on McNish basis matzah murderer so that means like this from Hills perspective right Hills perspective they ate then only with a sandwich today hello would also agree you can't do a sandwich you know why cuz Matz is very nice sir murder is their abundant if I make a sandwich the murder is my bottle the matzah so matzah everybody holds you gotta eat independently cause if not the murder will be more vital the matzah once I finish my matzah what do I do next Hillel would let me do a sandwich of mats and more why because modern is did a bonnet why is Marie Darabont on facial emitters how would they eat the more is a salami - whether a bond on well how would they eat the more essential how would they the morrow by the resubmitted together with matzah so hello says eat the murder together with the matzah now also mix with your opponent it's too durable nuns they're not my battle each other but they come argue with Hillel hold that wad that you're not supposed to eat the bar together with the matzo because believe me something stirs you also don't need the bar together with the matzo she have to eat the murder itself so if you tomorrow with the matzo the matzo it's gonna be move out of the mortar murder is a mitzvah there are born on mats is voluntary so that's why you have to eat more independently now you're done according to the Rabanne amazing even they held they held this mana buys you ate carbon paste separate matzah separate Morris separates so today the Mitzvah of martyr is to eat what separate martyr if you bring in matzah to the sandwich the matzah skills the morrow so their abundance adieu matzah separate do more is separate and now from that perspective you done but hillo says well why wait my murder wasn't done yet my mother wasn't done yet there's a mitzvah the--the Mario's a syllabic there's become a semi that's how you eat water together with matzah give me my sandwich you make a sandwich that's why we make our sandwich what do we say cane AUSA Hiller the rabbi's never did this the rabbi's Vinny you know why we're doing it K now say hello miss Manchu base I'm going to show you a I am oh you're cutting this past summer lacayo my master said Morano who now you did the midst of according to everybody if the halacha would have been like Hitler or like a common we wouldn't have to go through these three phases but since the ayahuasca was never established so we have to go through three phases matzah one more to kairos sandwich three and now you don't know call it everybody know modern state why because more is dependent on the carbon pay saw the toyota says eat the car basic with mother but with doesn't mean in a sandwich with just means in the same meal and the same meal eat it together doesn't mean to it's like you say by the Shabbos meal you make it this on wine and you make admission does mean you mix them together you just do them together you understand so the mitzvah of Mahler today you can't be metallian with matzah because if you mix the maps in the morrow the murderers that are born on the mats is not a mitzvah so the Matz is gonna nullify the morrow but according to he'll oh the mats and the Mara and I'm a battle each other why because they're both a queue mitzvah terrabona what's matzah I have on them what's modern and I bother great we're good your typhus Tomatsu today's day sir that's why you can't eat matzah with a sandwich in the time of the base I'm making this you can eat matzah with martyr because they were both very nice sir but now the monitors only they're not born on so if you can eat the matzah together with the moderate even according to hello the murderer will kill the matzah because the mother is only there are born on our sandwich is not like the ancient sandwich so that's what everybody says you have to eat matzah independent so now you did the mitzvot very rice of eating marks are done you ate good matzah now here comes a McCoy cos hello would say from matzo jumped to the sandwich to be fulfilled the fulfill the Mitzvah of Mara but if we do it that way according to the Friends of Hill Oh we didn't fulfill the Mitzvah of murder so we make a broccoli Phyllis martyr and we eat the murderer then for hillo sake we eat the sandwich and since we don't know who the halacha is like we're not gonna do another Brock Allah Phyllis murder even though according to Hill oh when are you fulfilling the mitzvah of murder by the career if not the first martyr but we're not sure so we make one Brock Allah heal us matzah one broccoli Sheila's murder we eat the matzah we make a Brucker murder we eat the martyr and then we eat the second matzah murder right and we don't make okay the second matzo according to Hillel is rabbinic why because Hillel says that today the rabbi said even though you don't ever be submitted on of a carbon pacer we want you to commemorate the base on McNish how did they do it in the time of the base--emitter tomorrow with the matzo so how do you do it today you do it as close as possible we can't have a carbon Pesach we can't but at least the murder and the matzo together so according to Hillel eating the martyr with the matzo is a rabbinic commandment so the matzo won't obliterated yes the whole kindness is rabbinic it's rabbinic matzah because Karthik is rabbinic so the rabbinic matzo won't obliterate the rabbinic murder on the contrary because they're both rabbinic back to mitzvos mitzvos a motley zoo a zoo as long as they're both biblical or they're both rabbinic that's the key if one is rabbinical one is biblical you got an issue but if both the rabbinic your good so then the kuda of matzah is our abana then the kuda of modern is there a bonham so they're not move out to one another so Hillel says you can eat them together matzah Dearborne and according to hillo because you need it as a sandwich for the murder the matzah you need as a sandwich with the murderer because the reason we're eating Mario today is zatia lamictal the time of the base on victors you aid them together so today the rabbi said eat them together just like then why should you make a difference why should the rabbis today take the martyr away from the matzo if he'll Oh was here today he would he would eat a piece of matzah then he would make a sandwich say Allah heal us murderer and eat together the matzah no more because they're both rabona because you're already eights of the matzah because mats is de-icer he can't mix tomorrow with the matzah because the morrow will kill the matzah because motor today is that Ivana but the matzah he can eat together with the Mara because the matzah won't kill the Mara the Mara will kill them outside everybody since the halacha says low it's my illness and not like hilum not like you're a born on so I was say there the Gemara Baskins we include both to be lights according to everybody which is why it explains the Shulchan Aruch brings not to speak from when you make abraha a la Fela smarter he says yeah yeah all the way till the end of Korea what's the big deal why the answer is because according to Hillel your Yotes and murderer only with the 2nd martyr not the first martyr and you're not supposed to make you're not supposed to speak before a broker and doing the mitzvot so that's why it says you shouldn't speak between the bracha that you make on the murder and the the eating of the career why because like a pillar you're not supposed to make a half set between if you spoke you're still not gonna make a second broker because we're not sure that law is like hilla but according to hill you would have to make a new bracha because you're more a mitzvah you didn't do when you ate martyr that wasn't the Mitzvah you did it only later so it's very good mark why you're not why this remark says not to speak your typhus doctor ever says according to Hillel you're not yo some modern only if you do it together with Mart with matzo because that's how you did it as much to be some McNish Khayyam so that's why we do both yeah according to a Marxist daylights that's what you have to eat it in the beginning yeah that's we have to did in the beginning so that's why when we make a broccoli Hillis matzah we don't speak from the beginning of matzah till the end of coda because the broccoli Hillis motor has to go on the career if and the broccoli Phyllis matzah has to go on the mots of the career because that's also mix with the rabona so that's why we try not to speak from the first time I feel as matzah on the matzah till the end of the sandwich if you did speak you don't make another broker because we're not sure the halacha is like hello so we don't make but if that law would be like he'll you would have to make a second broker okay you got it you have to concert with the words in the price of the bracer says no the browser says you would think you have to make a sandwich like hello so it says you who you don't have to in other words the bryce is saying that even according to hell that's only like a pilling up with the effort you understand that's what I'm a chic splaine's it yeah now even he'll though holds pillow holds mitzvah same of Atlas Zuzu because that's why you can make a sandwich miss man by Semak - yeah lady Eisenberg ass he says maybe he ultimate says Novato Azores who's just the toyota says over they should eat it together right but no we could prove that Hillel holds mitzvot same of Atholl Isuzu because he'll oh says you also put matzah in the sandwich and Max is an independent mitzvah if you would say mr somavia Azu Azu right yet mats as an independent mr. berry of total Marxist not only with the sandwich and carbon basic is also an independent Mitzvah if you don't have Matt Serra Marius left eat the carbon paisa so the fact that you could make a sandwich is because mitzvah same Novato azul azul cause if yes if they would be movable you would have to eat matzah separate and crumpets are separate so Hillel holds mitzvahs never nullify each other so our sandwich is not like that sandwich is a different sandwich our sandwich according to Hillel is to rub enix according to the common it's one rabbinic and one voluntary the time of the base I make there's everything biblical according to hello so the structure of the say there encompasses both opinions the real McCoy cases if Mitzvah turning in of my friend Abba or my from the EEMA if mitzvahs are Maison de mer and others from the perspective of the of the yesh of the person so then Matt's and mahram of Atholl each other because it's different experiences this is the Hana of matzah and this is a time of MOR it's a different experience but if mitzvos emotion to ABBA so it's I in so it's wonder could there's it's iron so Mahler a Movado mine of cumin and Mata milah this time that Tom Santa gaya then it could is the Mitzvah but I'm sure it's connected to one another much like us a very interesting much like us it says when when the Hashem gave Toyota my table Rilakkuma Scott Varma Allah lamer lamer so what's the word lamer they were all there the usual elements to repeat but everybody was there so the mistletoe says lamer means that when a sham said the 10 commandments he wanted that the Jews should speak back they should give feedback lamer they should also speak they should say that they're interested so there's a microcosm if small says al hain hain via a lava lava river Kaveri morale heyn heyn viola vain wish small says on the positive commandments they said yes on the negative Commandments they said no so when Hashem said copy the service of SA matter respective him and they said yeah we'll do it when he said Leutze don't murder they said love we won't lie Sigma if we worked Elaine hain by lava lava rebbi akiva says al heyn heyn val lava hain they said yes on everything on the positive ones Shabbos cubed of aim and Moon are nicely said yeah on the negative ones I also said yeah meaning yeah will fulfill the mitzvot ly tsutsu of course yeah well we won't kill yes as we will fulfill the mitzvot at the surface it seems like it's just an argument about semantics what's the difference if they said we won't do it or they said yes we'll do what you're saying and what's the difference but the truth is that it's a very deep McLucas nebbish mal says that the experience of the mitzvah had to be from the human perspective in other words the humans experience an understanding of it so the positive commandment is yeah of course yeah the negative is no it's horrible how am I gonna quiz I'm not gonna murder am I gonna steal for a bear keeper then I could of the mitzvahs the fulfillment of our shams will so it's not a difference what he says it's who says it's not what it's all hain yeah I'm gonna do the Mitzvah right it's a different word it's not what he says it's who said it it's not me gay if you tell me this you tell me that that's just the manifestation of how I'm doing your will but then it could days I want to connect to you whatever you want this this you want this it's all the same thing it's one decoder that's why Ruby Akiva repeats what seems superfluous Rabbi Shmuel says al heyn heyn the olive loved her be Akiva says Allah heyn heyn via a lava hane well hurry but Kiva agrees with it by Haney agrees with rubbish small so murky we should just say Allah vain or al haynesville la vain why does he repeat again I'll hang hang the answers cuz the hain of rubbish small and the hain of rebbi akiva even by the positive mitzvos is a different name but every small it's a hanging on the token of the mitzvah but a became its are hain on our shams roots and it's a different hain it's not the same hain yeah so Mossad al heyn heyn Val of lava mitzvahs movado Zuzu cuz every Mitzvah has its uniqueness here it's matzah here it's more but southerner khuda of al heyn heyn valois vain was sistema bottles were submitted this is marks its mother but it's the same in the couidn't schoolin schoolís and cold kiyomitsu like others were in Hawaii there's okanura harav says it's one could you fulfilling his will so what's the difference yes right right right but in the world of the eraser that are born is not a mitzvah in the world of Toyota it wasn't a mitzvah even though we're supposed to listen to it in this man of the base a mixer sure was a de-icer because it was a carbon Pesach but today when there's no carbon paste if it said that I Bonin so Meili can't eat the matzah with the markers the more is gonna be move out for the moths even according to hello because the murderer is their opponent much as they dice the dice won't be my battle did a bomb but a bond will be mottled a nice when I eat matza with more right when I eat matza with more area even if the murderer was added a Bonham and the matzo was a dairy riser it's not a problem for the motor the problem is for the matzo when they when he'll o thou mightest said don't make a sandwich it wasn't because of the morrow was because of the matzo because the Madson airy Raisa won't kill the mother did I Bonham cuz for the reborn on their eyes is also a mitzvah this for joyful Mitzvah the problem is gonna be for the matzah not for the morrow tomorrow would be good the mouth says the problem it does slip up tomorrow but the Moorish schlep is down the matzo whenever somebody schleps you up you schlep them down a little bit - it's like when you put when you put when you put an ice and ice in the coffee right thermodynamics seeks equilibrium so the ice cools off the heat of the coffee and the heat right also warms the ice and they found they find they find a place where they could be on equal footing today they didn't make yeah if today there would be a carbon-based and there are is acai Rambam there could be matter if the carbon even when there's nobody submitters so pacer could be there die sir and if Pacers because if no eve of that zipper is tumor you could still do it if we know the place of the miss Bayer even though there's no based on Mukesh right and Conan would sprinkle the blood on the MS Bella so the carbon pacer would be very nice then the mortar would be very nice Ithaca then Hillel would say you could do everything with her sandwich you don't eat matzo separate but since it's did I born today cuz we'll PO we don't have a carbon paste so if they would build them as baya according to their around they were talking about it here they were showing him who wanted to be mark of the carbon pay seconds Margolis do worry shine yeah it's according to us around mummy yeah everybody's coming peruse the caft of a fetish speaks about to the whole true of the some Soph Rebecca vague about it Rebecca vague asks a song world of some safer about it and nowadays there was discussion about it an interesting thing after the six-day war 1967 June 67 the next pay saw the Lubavitcher Deborah gave a whole Shir a whole talk and he felt Liholiho no no no that everybody should leave you shall I am Erev Pesach by hud sois who was according to many ways shown em now that the Jews have control over it it's not an honest and it's a shy love chorus if you don't bring the carbon pay so if you're not the Derek or Hika you gotta go tests above mill which was like fifteen kilometers away from yours shall I am ah and for many years Habad Hassidim would would leave Erev Pesach before cutters and Pesach Sheni also in the mid-seventies though he wrote a letter tips limits of his Evan that he feels that it's not relevant anymore why interesting cuz he says that Israel is in such a position that today even if they would want they can't they completely surrendered everything and therefore it's not it's completely not feasible so therefore there's nowhere it was a missed opportunity on many levels the leadership of Israel didn't have the backbone to embrace the gift and history was changed as a result of that it's one of the greatest missed opportunities of modern Jewish history the Muslim world was trembling they completely wanted to obliterate Israel so anything Israel would have done would have been justified and they were they were even hoping that Israel was they didn't even EE it really allowed to stay there right they were completely at their mercy but the Israel did exactly the opposite and and I was it showed them that it was a very very tragic missed opportunity yeah it was the inner on in an inner around this class is brought to you by the achieve Annette please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot they you Sheba net slash donate