Pesachim 102b-103b - Arvei Pesachim #8

the yeshiva dotnet cook bass Amidala five vlogs from the bottom tolerable if you remembered of course I'm a table format BAE's we learnt about amok like us between a B hood and Ruby I see the Gomorrah is now going to return to that argument the argument was if you start a meal on a Friday even load of you hood this says that on Friday you shouldn't have a meal from approximately three o'clock p.m. from the before minute huh if sunrise is six but before minutes a katana you shouldn't have a meal whatever that time is in the afternoon but let's say you started earlier or quarter WC you can always have a meal Friday and now Shabbos comes in what do we do so we had a huge my latest review this says you have to stop Shabbos came in you cannot continue eating without kiddush are you started eating when you were allowed to that's fine but now sunset came you have to stop the meal and if you want to continue eating you first have to make it has to be there has to be condition mentioned you'll start a new meal the v.i.c argued that you could continue eating and bench and then you'll make you this and your kid ish will be after the meal and your kid this will connect to the meal before in other words it's an interesting case where a person makes kiddush after so the Shabbos but you don't have to interrupt and then the Gemara brought the third view of Shmuel who said pirates map on my cottage which is a view in the middle right that you interrupt a meal but not completely and off the bench you just cover the bread you make kiddush and you continue the myth review this says no you have to bench the meal is over you start a new meal if you want a B or C says you don't do anything after make addition of the bench need to just continue as is and Schmuel said pirates map on the Kaddish Niraj bomb said that shul is really following your BAC but just giving a new homra and the home res you could continue the meal but just do kiddush in the middle which ovulation doesn't mind you just as you don't have to so the Gemara now brings a price connected to this like Astana rabona Vinay kabura so I'm assuming you had a heavier kabura group and they were sitting and eating miss suman means they were reclining and eating that's how they used to eat and it was a Friday the Gemara doesn't say it clearly but it's obvious that it was a Friday because it says makida chalet in high yo him and the day became holy meaning Shabbos came in while they were in the meal the middle of the meal which means it was a Friday and let's say she is sunset was 6 o'clock p.m. just for argument's sake so at 6 o'clock p.m. and they're in middle of a meal Vivian likewise shall yayan the I'm Ariel of kedusha say I'm the kind of a Shaney I'm middle of versus a Muslim divya neighborhood the view this says what do you do you bring one of the people eating a cup of wine and he just kiddush on the color you want then you bring him mache me a second cup and he benches this is what tubular the hulls very interesting he doesn't say to first bench and then do a new kiddush I need a second meal a second cup of wine a second cup of one no no no a second cup of one yeah yes the bench after Kadisha right you can't continue the meal that's a view the the meal of oil has to get interrupted and if you want to have a new meal now or later that's fine you have to have a new million it's the Shabbos you can do it right now you can do it later I mean not much later because you ready-made kiddush but the bottom line is that you have to interrupt the first meal it has to come to an end meaning you have to bench and then you start to the Shabbos we're WIC completely disagrees he says you just continue your meal no Bute it doesn't just say you say conditioned middle of the meal and then you could continue eating no you can't continue the meal the meal must come to a complete completion through benching and then you start a new meal so the first cup you'll make a dish and the second cup you're gonna do because a Muslim dvw hood that this is the of Rabbi Yehuda why does he say you should make kid this before breakfast a Muslim why not bench and then make kiddush for the new you're benching for the old meal for the weekday meal why are you doing kiddush before benching buda hell you have to bench before you continue through the meal in other word you can't continue in the meal it has to be a new meal so the Shabbos has to be new it cannot continue cannot attach itself to the pseudo Friday it's two separate creatures right it becomes very practical for Puerto Miss Friday put them as Friday people have a meal they go sometimes till Shabbos they want to continue to be this says no you can't so the rice bum says like you said since the time of kiddush came because it's skier it's Shabbos you have to do it the effort is first do this thing you first have to do kiddush because that's the time of good if you still have to bench you're gonna bench after the kiddush but you have to first make you have to first make no no business Amazonas for the weekday yeah there's another advantage from afar some say of making kiddush before benching why when we make bet we do benching on a cup of wine when you finish bench and you make hug off and you drink the wine if you were do benching before kiddush you wouldn't be able to drink the cup of wine of benching because it's already Shabbos you now let a drink on Shabbos before kiddush so that's why you first make kiddush and you drink the cup of wine for kids then you bench for the meal and you drink a second cup of wine for the benching and now you could drink because you already made the kiddush you can't combine it to say anywho this says you make kiddush on a cup of wine drink it then you bring a second cup either he himself or somebody else and benches and now they could drink the second cup of wine also but if they would have benched before Kadesh then what would have happened you couldn't drink the cup of wine from benching why because it's already Shabbos and you now let a drink on shoppers when here comes I can just take a cup of wine even if I'm been cheating if I can take a cup of wine I'll have a drink anymore remember review this says everything gets interrupted so therefore you first make it there so now you could drink and then you could drink both cups of wine the kiddush wine and the bench and if there's one person you don't have to use a cup of wine if there's three there's different shitness but if this ten we use a kosher bra actually use a cup of wine yeah yeah ehem AWAC says you don't have to interrupt the meal at all a little volatile texture when danish Martius comes when skia comes you don't have to interrupt it at all just continue going even till it gets dark and even afterwards this point is when sunset comes you don't have to stop six o'clock stop you can go till seven if you want to go to line two but you can go even until it's completely dark meaning you don't have to change anything continue the meal ah its Shabbos the Sudha Scarl went into Shabbos and it becomes Sudha Sharma so you have to make a dish you'll make kiddush after the meal and that's gonna be the kid is Moroccan Sudha that condition after the meal is gonna attach itself to the meal even though the kid this year is after this so they're not before the Sudha so the BOAC time is you don't have to be mouth sick anything something about uh gum rules no oh the bedsheet accorded up you see the benching is gonna be with rich say according to wo you see the benching is gonna be oh so four so the Shabbos because he's doing benching only later at the end of the Shabbos meal so you're already gonna put in all so rich say because it's both for the source coil and for this of the Shabbos so maybe you'll have to do a Shabbos the convention or if it's Yom Tov IMed of the convention Galileo your right to knowledge in the middle of the military coup with Chavez or something no she says no conditions only at the end the kid dish is gonna be the chronology Changez yeah they continue the meal it'll be older so she kept you have to ban you should say we'd say no because you just say ah you're sure you can say with saying is that you don't have to say it's a bit for some Muslims completely for oil it's just you'll be able to drink the wine I doubt it you make it yeah I doubt it it's an interesting child you are not going to be hood that they have to make you it's a invention since the whole birth I wasn't is going on the soil meals but you're doing it after kidding you have to say that say because the point of choice is a hearing under Clio meal he started before such abuses just to the shoppers but AB you Dinesh crises also really it started before no according to be I see we don't make you be mouths it this should the skull could more finish at the sharpest contributor do we make you be mouth sucking to get Mario Gummer closer issue according to BOC they finish the meal gum who they finish the meal choice to assume a vertical a breakfast a Muslim they bring him a cup and he makes a breakfast a Muslim where Shane Lee I'm Leticia say yeah and the second cup he does kiddush on so the first course of breakfast Amazon is the end of the meal and therefore the BOC says just like you could continue the meal before kiddush you could also bench and drink the cup of wine before kiddush that's why he doesn't say you have to do kiddush before benching grab you who this said you have to do kid this before benching cuz if you do kiddush after benching you won't be able to drink the cup of wine of mention but every always see holds that what that you could continue the meal even on Shabbos even though you didn't make kiddush so he says you could bench and drink the cup like you did the mail and then afterwards they're gonna bring you a second cup and you're going to make kiddush at the end of the meal now of course the vo she doesn't mind if you make kiddush earlier if you AC doesn't care if six o'clock you say let's stop the meal I'm a kiddush and that's the of Lulu says Paris mapa or makan dish make a kiddush don't bench make kiddush and continue after guinness maybe like she doesn't care but it's a humorous and extra homra business you don't have to you don't have to do that you could finish the meal and make a kiddush after you finish the meal but of course if you cover the bread and middle of the meal and you make kiddush and you continue i'm i don't be good it really has no opposition to that he just says you don't have to and I was stuck in the din of school who was master made according to the Busey and upped it one notch and said you should make kiddush in the middle dragged the Gemara case you got say you would still make it say according to the Bureau you see when you bench you're always gonna mention the Shabbos invention because the benching is for the Sudha of oil but also for the soda of Shabbos remember you're benching at the end of the shop is the Kamil which could go for midnight he didn't say caduceus I am yet but he's benching for a shop is the Cameo it's it's considered so the Shabbos there's a mitzvah to have a sword on Shabbos he fulfill the mitzvot doesn't have to have a second to the Friday night he doesn't have to have an extra three meals that becomes us of the Shabbos and the kiddush afterwards is the Mach line so order of the suitor before condition when the Jews dance you have a guy well you have to make it a shot Chavez no but the iron you need wine to make Kadesh to use the wine for benching is one long iron but there's a special Mitzvah to make Kennish on Shabbos with a cup of wine but but you're right but you say he already said tradition say I'm invention you can every every Shabbos we say condition say I'm in my room and my room we also acknowledge Shabbos but there still are didn't there are born on that you have to say creo lii and we have to sanctify and welcome the Shabbos with the brothers of Casale gave us through a cup of wine that was an accomplished yet so a she says you do it afterwards and that kid ish is called the mahkum sooner because it's done in the place of the meal right after the meal was under the Gemara Am I why does WC say you need two separate cups the name riddle the traveler had the cost why don't you say both on one cup why did it Bo HC said you bring him a cause for benching and then you bring him a cause for kiddies why do you need two separate cases of wine why don't you fill up one cup of wine and at the same cup of wine you could do Sai kiddush i-i'm and cybercorps Somoza this is a question only according to Navy I see not according to review hood according to W hood because you have to interrupt the meal and move away the table and bench and then you can eat a separate suit of Shabbos so I understand that the kiddush relates to the second soda and the breakfast a Muslim relates to the first soda because the kiddush can't relate to the first suit because the first suit there was a student of weekday and the second so there's a student of Shabbos so therefore you can't make kiddush on the same cup of wine are you gonna do benching on because that Shia to the sudo of coil that either very she says don't mix the two suitors so don't mix the wine connected to the two cylinders this is wine of coil and this is wine of shoppers I understand that so this cup of wine I'm using for kiddush for Shabbos soda and this cup of wine I'm using for breakfast a Muslim for the Khalsa they're just like the boys he says he shouldn't mix the two meals so I understand you don't mix the two cups of wine I mean Hooda Buda don't mix the two cups of one so you make it on two separate crises but Lloyd review I see who says not that way the beard has some wasn't and the kiddush is both for the same meal right it's for the meal of Shabbos so why not kill two birds with one stone take one cup of wine and on this cup of wine you could bench you could make kiddush and drink the cup and I'll just get so you tell me because Shabbos in the hell now it's both it's both the sharpest the kid is just versus the Shabbos but you did before him because I was facilities which he didn't before so Mela you could use one cup of one if you say but we don't mix to fit what do you mean we don't mix just sooo this to the Shabbos so what so it's look so that's the Schuyler why you know they said you need a cup of wine you need a cup of water you need a cup of wine I had a cup of wine and a cup of wine for benching and a cup of wine for kiddush and then well should see when young turf is mature Shabbos yep why don't we make it a beaut it's too easy we bench it's called kosher bracha you say hashem and for the meal with a cup of wine oh yeah you thank you with a cup of one you bench and you make a guffin are you drinking at the end of one so do it together it's two different reasons it's two reasons but it's a cup of wine for benching you need a cup of wine for kiddush such as name Renu let's reveal how the council say both texts on one cause my armor abou nominative shasha's Buddhist and the name of appreciation is a fascinating idea in a mistake douches okay sound you don't say to graças on one cup of wine why not and he's calling here kedusha steak dishes is kiddush but Britta sorrows and those are called kedusha even though British a Muslim is not kiddush but the concept is it's a bracha it's like the holy brother you're thanking our chef so it's also called a form of kiddush so when you have two mitzvahs that both have to be done on a cup of wine like benching and kiddush rabona is teaching us in the name of reputation do not mix together both of them with one cup of one but why not what's the problem my time why not America is so criminal in the son of it's like explain with Li Shan ice and mitzvos Aviles havelis which means we don't bundled together Havilah means a package that bond that vines together many things like you take many twigs and you make a Cavill you make one package we don't bundle up together many mitzvos turning them into a package what's the problem the Raja bomber says kovaleski villas the Mexia like Hamas it appears like the heavy burden in other words I'm gonna use the expression you basically want to kill two birds with one stone what do I have to take two cups of wine one cup of wine and I'll do this I'll do this so it basically looks like it's a burden and you just want to because it's a heavy package you get the easy way out and you want to what you're looking for is just to get the cavillo off your off your chest off your shoulders so therefore because it looks like that the mitzvot are a Borden and a burden and he's just trying to hasten and get over it you know let's just get over it because it's too heavy it's too tedious so this for the hosel told us ain't no symmetries cover this Camilla story because she says use two separate cups of wine it's a very abraca lots more in other words a mitzvah has to be done with a dish mark with conscientiousness with concentration with mindfulness with dedication it's not just let's get it over with and if we could combine a few minutes versus one and bond occipital Omni putt around a sick that's the concept of a nice symmetrical discovery loose so yes a cup of wine would work you need one but you do one for benching and one for killers it's two separate mitzvahs one is thanking our son for the food and one is welcoming and sanctifying shops drag the Gemara separate couple yes after benching you make by your prayer dolphin and after and by kiddush you make boyfriend oh you sing why make Berta Priya guffin twice oh you don't have to do it often twice unless you made a broth crying after right if you made a broker cry now after the wine you'll have to make a new broker but you're right you won't have to do a second very end off like we learned before buy produce map or my condition member we learned that if it's Friday afternoon and you continue your meal of corn to Shmuel and you cover the bread and you make kiddush you don't make hug often on the kiddush because you already made hug often and the meal before so you're not gonna make a guffin on the kiddush so you're saying a similar idea whenever you may have covered before if you didn't divert your mind and the wine was there or you had in mind the new wine you'd have to make a logoff very good ara but you still have to make kiddush which is I should get a shot of a mid soy Soviet cetera McAllister shoppers drag the Gemara Hanoi you just threw this biggest soit we never combined mitzvos together and take the short cut really not the case well tiny we have a clear eye so that contradicts us a little Aslam Besame Mucho shoppers somebody enters his almond with so shoppers the system is moverá Hawaiian he makes a broth on wine with meaning hagatha while hamburger on the fire burn variation while up somnom on the incense vodka a mere half Dalek ice and then he says half dollar on the cup of wine our mouth will be additional coil when I let her finish her lime but in addition to half dollar you have to make a brach on the fire you have to make a broth on the summit and the reason is fire you make a broth with sorry Shabbos because fire was created my sorry Shabbos Summum you make a broth with sorry shop is because after the neshamah you say with extra summer of Shabbos leaves is a certain emptiness and a certain void in a certain anguish and that's why we smell the incense so really you don't have to make the Summum and the burner murmuration together with half dollar it's a separate broth you can make my side Shabbos but since we're anyway already making off though on a cup of wine so the minute is that we already bring in the summer member image cuz you're ready making broca's so you don't do it separately so he says you make yayan Moyer summit yeah I mean her coffin this is mature Shabbos you don't make inish with so Shabbos mr. Chavez you make a coffin buried amid a summit and then you say half-dollar right the e mainly alikoya huh what if he only has one cup of wine so if he makes elf dull and now when he drinks it he's gonna have a meal what we call my lava mouth he's gonna have a meal and he won't be able to have we I infer benching he only has one cup of wine and if he drinks this cup of wine he's not gonna have left over for benching so what do you do - Leila a car amahzing you leave the half-dollar till after the meal or Michele chillon cool and lock her off and then you you bring together all over the brothers after benching that's what you michelle gielan comes from the words shall shell us which is like a okay that Shane right in other words you connect everything like a chain you connect the breakfast of by remarriage summon yah in and half dollar all with better some awesome now here's an interesting thing because usually we don't eat before half dollar you know let it eat before half dollar but ty Swiss explains here in this case since if you make half dollar you won't have a place for breakfast or muslin so they allowed you to eat before half dollar and then together with bedding you'll have one cup of wine and with that cup of wine you'll bench and you'll do the half dollar you'll make a coffin you'll make half dollar you'll make some you'll make me some in-migration I've dollar what do we see here clearly you take one cup of wine and you use it for half dollar which is one mitzvah and breakfast a Muslim which is another myth so I'm both need a cup of wine ah you don't drink no is the cultural growth you don't drink he's combining the wine but we're not too much other sugars after sharpest after shopping yeah the knights of the round oh yeah bundle three instead of I'm going to see if she'll show this case you have Mazel Malka choice and you have another case will soon learn about relish of this course we'll see later this here the Bryce is telling us that you don't have to make half dollar right away and then go to your meal you could delay the half dollar till after the meal so I answered twice Chris asks the question and priceless answers toaster sensors yeah you could look my mission marker on mozz and take a look man if I wasn't he could have missed some Asiatic item Abdullah I'm riddle to come on also on them shoot them cool and clunk let me show you out of them right I made Marin ami my stomach a normal oh come on was also screaming about it but it is the haka my tea so toast was tasteless ultimately answer at the end of toys to see Ashley mark / Athena mainly like item of da la vache Malachi second moto local condom although the last Ursula class professor Muslim since he has only one cup of wine they let it meet the question is we see clearly from this Brice say that you're using one cup of wine for two ministers and for the Gemara a low signee when you don't have enough wine for two cups it's different and we can understand why it doesn't mean you're being stingy with mitzvahs and you know trying to get rid of it you push it don't have wine so since you don't have one you want to do the Mitzvah right you want to do I've dollar with wine you want to but it's a Muslim with wine so therefore we let you combine it but we're talking about a situation where you're sitting at a meal on this plenty of wine so to say to use the same cup for benching in the same cup for kiddush WIC said don't do that ready the Gemara that's not true volume 2 shakaal Leah Sakura Shabbos take yum tip that comes out after Shabbos meaning the first night of yom tov hizmet's our shoppers the east lay a person probably has wine for two cups enough wine for two cups of wine why because it's massage shops you're going into Yom Tov it's a time of simcha you probably prepared plenty of food and wine for the simcha vomitus so but mainly you probably have the Eastleigh amirev nonetheless Rav said that the brothers that we make mats are MTV's yack Naha Yakima is an acronym yayan kiddush nail and half dollar Mayan means you make a broca's hug offensively Madonna Maria prega then you make kiddush because it's the kiddush of yontiff shabak Abunimah colombia and monomi collection by theta monomer the masam curse yo him let's say suka saucer or whatever yump if it is hon - Luis Ortega mattes then because it's massage Shabbos you're gonna do nail which is birthday Maria H this candles on the table cuz you lit candles and then you have half dollar which is basically the Hamas till that you make barakah Tasha how Marvel being coy - Latoya - which is half dollar and then you're gonna drink the cup so you have two cups of wine and you're using the same cup of wine for the mitzvah and kiddush for your death and the midst of a $5 because Shabbos ended so clearly you taking two separate mitzvahs combining and making them have realized and even when you have two cups of wine why don't we say here who it looks like it's a burden he's just trying to get rid of it what do I have to do kid isn't enough though let me do kidneys go it together and bollocks triple drop and finding a murderer I'm Rhea answered middle oi on Mars man did you realize Ralph didn't put in a Zion he didn't put in chef yellow but the first night of yump if we make sure he oh why didn't he put in Zion we have to make sure he'll when Yom Tov comes you make sure he all okay kiddush why didn't he put in a sign he said yakun aha MacLeod the wish we shall pay Skinner really it avid he wasn't talking about the first night he was talking about particularly the seventh night of pacer Shree shall pay sir you do not make a Chicano why don't you make a shelf er no because we shall pay sick is not a new young death it's a continuation from the first days of yom tov and once you made a Chevy on one yump if you don't make a second Shockley honor or just like when we like Kanaka candles the first night you make the show the second I make no because it's a continuation if the owner was always the first time it happens the first time the new season brings us silica so it's the first night of young teeth but he doesn't say smack that means it was a ready she shall pay so it can't be hello my call might you don't make kiddush so this is talking about obviously the night of Shri show Pesach when there's no Chevy on oh oh if I say we understand the coal miner have a little eh you've been already eating you've been eating already for six days so whatever you have you ate up you know some guests showed up the kids were hungry he ate up everything you drank up the Leslie you don't have enough wine for two cups you know you're asking me from this price from this of Rob that you see mistress that you could make it mr. some of those two villas it's not true because around particularly we're speaking about not the first night of the seventh night of young do the seven that on young did it make sense that the wine is gone there's very little wine the scarce one you have only enough for one cuff so mainly we say combined condition of dollar but according to this if you would if it would be the first night of Yom Tov Rav would never say yak Naha he would say a cup for kiddush and a cup five dollar two separate things Freddie tomorrow really really for her young to finish in the is like what about young to finish in the first night of um the view certainly have one because you've appeared if you don't have wine tonight when do you have wine but I'm gonna buy an abaya taught us that the order of the blessings is Roxanne ha yayan which is a Guffin kiddush which is a shabak abominably Kalama khadisha servoz mana Zion which is shacking y'all know the first night of Yom Tov nay which is buried in my liege and I've no rubber rubber disagrees and he says yeah can i Hoss yah in condition a half dollar Ozma and the Gomorrah under roof gimble the next page is going to discuss what's the logic of the debate between our buyer and robber why abaya put skittish put Saffiano right after kiddush and rather put Stephanie Arnold after half dull at the end that we're going to discuss in a moment but clearly they both talk about Chevy uh know if it's fer know it's the first night of youngnam at the seventh night of youngnam if it's the first night of you have you have enough wine for two cups nonetheless both abaya ever said you could combine both brokers both mitzvahs condition I've done with one cup of one place for says why doesn't the Gomorrah say that they're talking about schmitty at saris Shmi me at saris you make Saffiano because it's irregular from the apps money you make Chevy uh no so you could say I buy a Rover we're talking about not the first night yontiff but Romania Terrace so ready seven days of circus but some cuz mr. shaver with all the meals lemma dick and I love a bring in issue and the way they did in the times of that Miriam and the time I am certainly ah yeah and then you would have an answer choice who says why doesn't a camera say that it was from in yet Cyrus Romania Terrace will explain why this Shetty on Sri shall pay so hero make sure Fiona because the continuation of the first days of basil right unless you didn't make sure he under the first days of pace and then you have to make sure many answers I mean it's regional faceoff but many at service is considered are Lou young to Fred will be from a ops my the Gemara says in suka there's six dinner in which many at service is different than the other days it has a separate definition it's called the eighth day but it's still independent in many ways one of the independent qualities of Sweeney are services they have to make sure you know and yet you're really celebrated for seven days so we could say you didn't have enough wine and that's why they set the combined condition of dollar that's the question of tysonis soto swiss answers the reason is because he says the derrick was that for schmidt yet saris and silk Estella they still appear they used to prepare wine to the Shands morass of the shelter that has brilliant service well you could you the same question you're asking ruff laughs just said yom tov shakaal is a Carabas yakima so we have a student know so we have a big student between a B or C stock and wrath we're not gonna try to make a McCoy kiss and say that Ralph says yeah he's a mistress cover those cover those who don't like to do that right so we're gonna say Arab was talking about a specific young terrifically Sahara shoppers he was speaking on a specifically Sahara shoppers a by a rather also said what was their lotion yeah young to fruition so toaster says young definition is the first day but maybe it's many hats iris which is the first day so his time is that since it's a rebel buffet ABS my so they prepared the wine for it as well he didn't use it the day before that you didn't use it you prepare in other words a shiny rubber you prepared special warrant for the last day were the last days of young Toth last days of Yom Tov yeah so she says regular block in high bay they were they used to have a pair of lot huh so a buzz I it's not true in yet saris the fish mean at saris even if it is there was a lot of wine and still they say you could combine condition of dollar solenoid ain't isometric Aviles coverless so the Gemara answers a new answer ella half a dollar Cardinal say professor Mazar the kiddush dreamily Nino half-dollar and kiddush are considered one thing one would see us and therefore you could say them both on one cup so when I make kiddush myths re Shabbos which is also young dif whether it's the first day whether it's minuet said is when there is a stuffy unemotional irrelevant I could put the two together even though I have a lot enough one but Britt is a Muslim and conditions are two separate things what's this smarty here the brother of half-dollar that we may come at so Shabbos which is the night of yom tov is connected to kiddush because how do we say the half-dollar hamas dil mein koi desh McCoy dish in other words we're making enough dollar between the caduceus Shabbos and the disjunctive so therefore it's considered Cardinal see the - mom says true our value mission kedusha comm toy family no condition of dollar is both for the kedusha of young of the past as you say no half dollar is goodbye to Chavez and kiddush is welcome to empties so the Gemara is my heritage that really it's Cardinals and they're both connected into shows geometers Oba have dollar absolute Maastricht Lucius youngters and I've double itself you mentioned the caduceus of youngsters not only shabbos is gone her mouth still being coy - Lacroix - so the half dollars not only about the day that left them dull is also about the day that's coming half dollars not just bye-bye you're gone half dollar is a separation between the day that left in the day that came so Mela have null is connected to kiddush because kiddush is formative half dollars also for young to have it so give all the Kivar welcome even every Abdullah but sorry Shabbos is not just about shops it's about Sunday it in a way it's also welcoming Sunday it's creating a bow injury saying goodbye to Shabbos and welcoming something something has a different avoider than sharpest yeah it's trial it's not cottage there's now a void this Hashem of kiters I went to some of her I'm dull it's not just bye-bye I hate to see you and now we have nothing it's a way of welcoming new day - so there - box of the condition of Dulles called the mill say what if it's hotter Milson this is the previous day this is a new day how dull is also the new day I'm separating the old day to welcome the new day so it's a form of kiddush and we see it in the half-dollar itself that's when he and I mouth will be kinda SH McCoy - usually it's a condition as critical finders but mainly you could use the same cost the soft cool stuff it's one it's one the kuda what's the Nakula then you could there's welcoming young - well welcoming young turf one way you welcome it is through half dollar and one way you're welcome in this new condition so half dollar every week is not just saying that by the shop it's also welcoming the new week you're welcoming the new week through half dollar because without I've nobody can welcome the new week because it's a whole different it's a different genre it's a different identity and you're welcoming sharpest ortho submitter you make the stop kovaleski villas it's one that could it's one that could it's an Indian of kiddush my shank could bring us a Muzzin we talk about business and Muzzin and I've dollar because Amazon and kiddush I mean it's two separate things obviously precursor mazda weg says you're benching thanking our Shem for the meal that's a separate thing you make big someone's in a whole week you're taking a Shem for the food out there was about the reactor it's on Shabbos oh you're gonna say it's a if it's jumped if you're gonna say olive a avoid cuz you mentioned Shabbos you mentioned conditions chambers but it's something get their breakfast and Moses definition box Amazon is thanking a Shem for food the definition of kiddush is welcoming shoppers so it's two separate creatures two separate in yharnam the mela it's not called the milsat strain merely we mainly have to use two separate cups of wine that's why the BOC said it so it's completely not a sterile condition after all the works together that's what Rob said that's what I buy uses that's what Robert said even if you have plenty of wine it's not an issue of not having wine but my shake can have dollar a by shaking because I wasn't a kid - she need two cups of wine which put between your lips not as welcoming another one is separating yeah but I guess the separation that's really saying is a form of form of welcoming what about the bride's that we learned about that you could sometimes use the same cup for half-dollar and breakfast Amazon right well hiya how could you use over there you gonna say cuz he didn't have enough you didn't have enough wine that's why they said you could do I've dealt with before someone it says clearly he didn't have enough so that answers that question but in terms of sorry shabbos jumped if condition of dollar works together drinker some muslin and half dollar he's still gonna have to answer why cuz he didn't have more that he didn't have more than one cup and that answers I just want you to take a look we'll learn toys first let's loot Isis cuz he quotes it take a look enticing are my yak na you see the second-to-the-last Isis Oh Marsha a mask up summon hmm I know why he doesn't say some man you said he doesn't say his man consumers may be talking about shreya shall pass on but why doesn't he say summon penis rash bomb the Tom summon wish um it wouldn't show me a sailor the reason for summon is because you lost Oona show me a seder when with sir Shabbos comes the extra neshama so to speak goes out and therefore you smell the Summum to revive the person will be Optive nami it cannot show me you sailor there's mom says since on young to v o7o show me is saying it so one might say Shabbos falls on onion if you have to make boy - Maria H but not some him so that's what it says yeah and kiddush NER half-dollar no problem Wichita Co we don't do something with sorry Shabbos when it's jumped if we only do by the my tears for the - Baba says coz in a sham you say I didn't leave for this young boy Lamar you have to make us massage Shabbos but you don't have to make him summon the caution flag ties was the in cane from its arm to farm I like to kill Osama then everybody say octave we should make a bra camp something because we're losing the neshaminy assailant the cafeteria therefore toys vs. fascinating the beyond to flick in a shaman Seder biome truth is known as show me a seder and if we don't to make me mad scientist for haka a mask rip some so why Matsuri Shabbos that's Yom Tov you don't say summer resumed the synthesis Yom Tov are Lucia Malcolm summer since he going into young turf so the Simca VMT and the eating and drinking of young is effective as personam to console you for the new summer you say that was lost on Shabbos the yes time employing a high name there are other reasons that are incorrect bizarre Tom knocking wake this is the correct and primary reason why we don't make bare minimum somewhat sorry Shabbos because even though the neshamah leaves their harsh mom says we don't cause into summer doesn't leave but Titus doesn't make sense because then it's so young if you should make it because the neshamah doesn't leave that the high raya there's no neshama you say it so you're not worried will trample when you up defend enough to make a brush I'm at sorry sharpies you make a better Minnesota establish that what Summum accomplishes every mid-sized Shabbos symphysis Yom Tov and the food and the drinks of you have accomplished on my Shabbos that falls on Yom Tov America nothing well have a mouth is not enough cuz it's you need simple assumptive will see it compensate for the nizamiah seder right depends how you define of show me your sailor ya understand what's as follows on my likeness of russia bomb and isis goofer we learned before thank you so much Yom Tov shakaal ears are her Shabbos if Yom Tov falls out after Shabbos you see curved base on my base to launch from the bottom goofer and yom tov chicago Sakura Shabbos Yom Tov falls out after Shabbos meaning but sorry Shabbos is also Yom Tov so now we have to make kiddush we have to make a dish because it's Yom Tov but we also have to make half dollar because it's massage Shabbos and there's the brother of Boyer Maria ish because it's massage Shabbos we make a broth on the fire and is of course the bracha barrier Priya goofin so some interestingly we don't make mature Shabbos that falls on Yom Tov but we have to do kiddush kidness always includes two blessings which is wine hug often right how do we usually make kiddush we say Sabri Marana Baraka Tasha I'm the kinda mellow Ellenberger Priya golfer and then we say the Brock of Kadesh itself barakatuh shamrock animal hello Marshall edition woman's very severe arts a bond over Chavez Carter behave of rotten until on etc keep on over Carter barakatuh shameeka - a Shabbos so it's two brothers one is called Bertha Sian Brock on wine and Goffin cuz you're gonna drink wine that you would make a whole week whenever you drink wine but it since it's Shabbos you're not as drinking wine there's a special Mitzvah of kiddush you're sanctifying Shabbos you're welcoming Shabbos you're acknowledging job is on the wine and then you drink the wine so there's two blessings every Friday night granted what happens now when Friday night when shot and the same is true yom tov night every night of yom tov water we do we say burner priyanka fen and then kidneys bar katashi maluca mala Marcia Maha bandha me Colombian monomer Kalasha British on women choice of right but it alone are similar Cana Baba Maya the most similar Huckabee's bottomless Austin say SEM kakuzu Kasasa s Monson Casino Kevon over Herto Baraka Dharma khadisha servoz mana and then sometimes we'll say chef he all know the first night of Yom to the secondary level say Trujillo no as well here the problem is that you have two things coming together you have mid sorry Shabbos together with young tips that's what the young tips of soleus Acura shoppers what happens Rev oh my Rav says the order is yakin aha yackin aha would mean yayin kiddush Nair Abdullah who small amar Yong hak yayan near of dollar kiddush so Rav says the order of the blessings is yak maja yayan what's yawn the first blessing is hug often burry Priya Goffman right the next would be kiddush which is borrow akatosh mashallah mashallah car bonhomie column-free diamond monami Kailash and we could have shown of him it's voice of at10 lawn or the whole kiddush till macaque Bora Katara MacArthur she saw Osman and then you're gonna do Nair which is boy de Maria ash and then you're gonna do hey which is half dollar for a Qatari McKenna Malayalam hamara dil right bank additional home and our lockers when you Starla I'm him but you're a marsh realization same I said Ben caduceus Yom Tov but this is Shabbos ladouche assumptive Delta if Delta Vicki - this unsub recession Baraka tantrum Hamas dil mein koi - McCoy - that's how you do it yak na ha yayan Kadesh naira of dollar you see the logic in rev the logic right now basically is basically you first do the young TIF and then you get to deal with the sharpest first you do the kid attractive and then you go back to do the half dollar for Shabbos you do burning my rage and you do I've done it like you do every mr. Shabbos you don't have some him but you do bird emulation you do I've don't like every Shabbos that's Rob's small is you do ein you start with a gofer then you go to Burnham area age then you do have dollar and then you do kiddush completely different order what do we see it one of the two patterns you see immediately for SH mu L half-dollar precede skittish you first say goodbye to Shabbos and then you welcome young teeth for RAV kiddush precedes half-dollar first you welcome young teeth and then you say goodbye to Shabbos very interesting much like us according to Rav kiddush has to come before half-dollar and we remember half dollars - half dollars half dollar and this birthday Maria H is also part of our dollar but that would that's what we do mid sorry Shabbos after Shabbos was off why would the Rav wanna do kiddush before half dollar look sorry the Shabbos came first why don't you first say goodbye to Shabbos and then welcome so the answer is RAV feels number one kiddush is more important than abdullah because of dollars saying goodbye to what was kid dishes welcoming that which is so it has prominence of Roth dollar half dollars basically saying that by kiddush is welcoming a new day that's number one number two if you do have dollar first it may seem that Shabbos is a burden and that's why you want to know right away to have done as fast as possible let's get it over with and move on so that's why I've holds you first start with kiddush first of all it's more harsh of it's more prominent and because you want to delay the half dollar and then and then you'll do Abdullah so therefore drive system is very clear first you do hug offer then you do kiddush now you're done now you go to the next step which is burning my RIA H and have Dulla very good what a petitioner Keanu says the Gomora said before you have to say this includes also the night of speech I'll pay stuck the night of free shall pay sir right or after in shall pay sir you wouldn't make a shock he don't know cuz it's the last days of pay so can you may the first days Smule hold the opposite of Rav shmoo old you make first half dollar and then kiddush the Gemara soon can explain why Shmuel argues that you have to make up dollar first but that's what small halts you stress you know same thing yeah yeah this is what the kiddush looks like massage shop is when it's also empty what it looks like small holes that half dollar comes first so therefore small says what do you do first you do have dollar so what's half dollar McGuffin birthday my liege half dollar and then kiddush yah in nee have delegated so one says yeah kina ha and one says Yong hak Rav says yeah and kiddush native dollar small says yah in main abdullah knish seems very glad two different streams of how you got to do it kidneys comes first or half dollar comes first something invited robber robber tough cookie malama now live robber my rabbit says no yeah ha knock what see her knock ya in first hog often then half dollar then there's an kiddush which is interesting we see that rob beholds likes more what does he hold half dollar comes before kiddush that's clear in principle the all sexual comes before kids but he changes the regular order of abdullah and he does first half dollar then by the mirror eh we do for his birthday mediation and Abdullah which is what's called it small said you do yayan then you do NER half dollar which is the regular order that you do kiddush robber also says you do have dollar first so first but that name why wouldn't he put the barber in my age before after like we do every midsize shops he he needs to put something between half-dollar and kiddush you see Shmuel goes from half-dollar straining to kidís by small you do her mouth will be kurdish licorice and right away Berkut arch their mother came to my home action book abundant Kalam rabid doesn't like that robber wants I have sick between our dollar and kitties so you start with a coffin you're not gonna go bird emergency laughs dollar then you'll do Braden manage and then you'll do kiddush why does he want this because he feels there's a steering between the to Broca's the two brothers are contradicting each other in British half dollar what are we saying that caduceus young tiff is inferior to producer shoppers how Marvel being coy - licorice it's like a half dollar you need a half dollars like we're finished with the heavy kedusha and now we're now going into hell we're going into a lower kedusha so half dollar brings out the inferiority of young tougher GABA shoppers what does kiddies do kiddies brings out the give out the kedusha of young teeth so male the two brothers he says surpass Nations there has to be a separation it's two different worlds very interesting smarter nappa and that's why he says make a half sick what's the half sick you make make F sick of burden my liege so mayor you do hug often why do you do our guffin that he's not gonna push over push off later because her guffin is we always do first because it's Todd they're toddlers Shana tonic item is the most permanent for us because your whenever you drink wine you make a coffin right Boyd Emory a should do only once a week yeah and you could do every day theoretically you could do ten times a day I mean whenever you drink one so yeah I and we always do first which ravaged will also hold you do the iron first we always do a lion first when you have to make a broker you want to push away abruptly you want to push it off later which one are you gonna take me to take birthday Maria H and you'll insert it between half dull and kid is just to make a half circle that's the of rubber the way the large bomb explains all these smothers so yeah in half dollar nail and Kadesh robber next lady am i you thought was over lavr my kanea key this nee yah in Havdalah what do we see from Lavy lady holds a carafe he wants kiddush before abdullah right but instead of putting yayan and kiddush and native dollar which would have looked like RAV yack nah he does kiddush first and he puts Nair and yang before of dolla why he wants a separation between condition of dollar to be even more so start off with kiddush then he's gonna do Nair then he's gonna do AI in and then he's gonna do half dollar kiddush Narayan Abdullah what do we see from here let's get a little more specific with Lavy lady holds like Yadav kiddush has to come before half dollar but instead of doing her guffin in the beginning do her guffin in the beginning yeah I in condition eight half dollar would be very good right he says no don't do Yan in the beginning yeah and in fact is almost the last thing it's right before half dollar why is it the answer is because he wants that you should see that the hug often relates not only to the kiddush but also relates to the half dollar to the business of dollar if you would make how guffin in the beginning there would be a tremendous gulf between the hug orphan and the half dollar right it would be ayan kiddush nair have done like Rath so her governess in the beginning and of dollars at the end and therefore would look like that the hug guffin is only going on the kid is not on the half dollar but really that guffin is also going on the half dollar even if you'll do the wine right after kiddush for example you'll do kiddush and then hug often right not clear but kina right so the hurdle would be good you would still say that the Yaya now girlfriend goes on the kiddush and nine and a half dollar because every single but sorry Shabbos there's no kiddush so you could do hug often birthday murder age and then I've done because it's obvious that governor's going on the half double there's no other thing but here that there's also a kiddush so he says even doing the yin right after the kiddush would still indicate perhaps that the yayan is only going on the kid is not enough dollar therefore he says put the hug often as close as possible to the half dollar because the half dollar was made unwinding of the comma second to make British Abdullah unwind that's the Turkana in fact you even make it closer to all of them to kid this it's like almost you're discriminating against kid this not only will you not do yah in kiddush Nate half dollar you won't even do kiddush yai in native dollar cause even then the eye it looks like it's still going to the kiddush you know kiddush Nate and then yah in Abdullah I there and you're gonna think the iron is only for half dollar and not for kiddush yeah so there's bomb explains because actually kiddush the Casal weren't my stock in the DEFCON one you could do it on bread too a person could make kid this on collar - you could be your executor she may come right see right the person doesn't have one you may get this on pass half dollars the Afghan wine so mainly LaVey hose that you daf could do the iron but in principle again well you don't make tube raucous we're not necessary and you're not you don't have to bring you don't have to use - I'm saying you'd have to make to our coffins and two cups of wine it's not necessary even though we said early even though a nice and mistress kovaleski villas Yutaka don't usually don't bundle up mitzvahs together but here we said condition of dollars really one theme it's one principle it's both celebrating the kedusha of holy days right the governor asked asked earlier ain't no sin mistress kovaleski villus tomorrow asked us you don't bundle together mitzvos because it just looks like you want to get rid of them you don't kill two birds with one stone but the gomorrah says it's not two birds because kiddush enough dull is really the same theme it celebrates holy days kid is she welcoming jumped if have Dudley is saying goodbye to Shabbos and even in the kid even in the half-dollar you mentioning douche assumptive hamas dubenko - licorice and the concept of half dollar is not only saying that buy but it's also preparing for the new day so condition of dollar very much interconnected half dollar is not just saying goodbye to the day that left half dollars oh so welcoming the new day have dollar is not just add in in Shabbos it's also add in and Kyle so therefore it's called the mill sitting Marcellus cotton mill so so maybe so you're not gonna tell a person make two separate hug ovens and use two separate cups of wine you could use one cup of wine and one bite of Prayer govern the question is just what's the most appropriate order so we had Rav said yakin aha Shmuel said Yong hak Robert said yeah hammock and lady said kunia we're not done yet when a banana Marie an abundance a key know they hold also like Ralph that what kiddush comes first but they do kiddush yah in nail half dollar what's this mother they hold kiddush Karma's before half dollar they also don't want the yin should be in the beginning because if it's in the beginning it's gonna look like it's only for kiddush and not for half dollar so that's why they put the I in after kiddush and they make it closer to half dollar but unlike lavey who puts the hug often right before half dollar they put it in the regular system of abdullah what's the regular system of abdullah hagafen birthday Maria Ash and I'm out cuz that's what you do we do kiddush and then you do the I in hug often and then in other words you go back to the regular system of half dollar okay and another svatah why their opponent would say this why they put the wine after kiddush and not me it's like Rav would be because they want to separate condition of dull as much as possible since the two are contradictory they're mutually exclusive they want to put not just one half second between but to have sacred symmetry in other words really they would do condition before they would do kiddush I hug often before kiddush just like Roth but they want between condition of dollar to make the greatest golf so what's the greatest golf to kiddush DUI in dune a lady is worried that the yayan should relate to half of Dulles he puts the iron right before of dollar they're abundant according to this explanation I'm not worried about that they wouldn't mind putting the I in first but they want a big Gulf so they put the iron right after kinder so it's kina kiddush yah in native dollar maybe we should because I'm in half dollar together you should have married the end well we never do neighbor at the end we always do have dollar every mid sorry Shabbos we do Nair before half dollar so we keep to that so tackle AV doesn't there before he Tucker doesn't there before he does condition area I know cuz he wants you should see that the yarn is coming from half dollar even though every mid sorry Shabbos lady agrees that the iron comes before Nair but every mid-south sharpest there's no room for error because it's only half dollar but now this room for error so therefore he takes the iron and he delays and he pushes it off as far as possible even though it's toddler it's the most permanent abraca it's still you don't do it first my bday did I born armor Meyer the son of rabona said Nakia Nakia what's Nakia nail kiddush yeah in half dollar here again in principle he holds like ralph remember all these shooters don't get confused it's two streams rev and small either kiddush before I've done or I've dollar after kiddush I mean I think it is before half dollar and that would be for killers there's just variations in those two streams how you do kiddies before I've know how you do have BB for killers so when we do my belated Urbana right away see kid that comes before of dolly holes like Ralph he also holds like LaVey that the wine gotta be right before the half dollar right Nakia the wine is right before the half dollar so if that's the case the wine is right before the half dollar so according to mark the son of Rob on this myth sorry Shabbos we're not doing the Brock on the fire on the nail in its regular place usually we do it between the iron and half dollar but now we're not because we're doing the iron right before the half dollar so he says since right now we cannot put the nail after the iron like we always do usually you do her guffin and then summon and then her ash and then I'm out of the water why doesn't govern come first the answer is toddler machine a toddler toddler condom it's the most permanent regular brush it comes first but we can't do that anyway because he holds like lady that what the yayan has to go right before half dollar so therefore the Nair is anyway going out of its regular space so then he says once you're moving around the furniture better to do the Nair the first thing even before kiddush why because it's the first thing you're enjoying the first thing you're enjoying the Nair is already burning some but sorry Shabbos and the Nayar is burning so the first thing you're having an off from when you get up to make it the neighbors there you're already enjoying the light especially then remember there was no electricity the candle burning was the only source of light so you're ready right away having an R so therefore make a bracket right away every mid-size Shabbos we do birthday marriage before half-dollar why because you're enjoying the candle right away but every mystery shoppers you first do hug often because it's thought of a shiny toilet on their coat but here you anyway delaying the hug often to be for half-dollar like lady said so he says if so take the nail and put it in the beginning so it becomes Nakia birthday me rearrange Kadesh yayan and half-dollar my Amish made Rubio schewe Marta said in the name of rabbi Yeshua me how do you have it knee hock knee hock Saudi Hawk would be Nair and then yah in and then half dollar and then kiddush twice was here is goddess a different gear sir and in the manuscripts of Gomorrah the gear sir is Nick which is nay have dollar yah and kiddush and it seems also like the gears of the rush bomb because he completely ignores this knee hack so apparently niak was a mistake at least according to most and the right gear sir was Nick which is nail half-dollar yayan kiddush this is Martin the name to be sure what's this money here we right away see he hold doll that comes before kiddush like small right however where does he put the iron instead of putting yah and a half dollar kiddush with as he put the iron he puts it between half-dollar and kiddush why because he wants that the hug oven should be relatable to both she puts it right in between half dull and kiddush because both were instituted on wine why doesn't he need a put the buried a maha ash near the burkas Heian that he doesn't care about because you don't have to do buy them a radiation wine even if you don't have wine you could still make a brush I'm Bernie Murray age where the measure has nothing do with the wine so therefore the name he doesn't need near the hug often but he wants kiddush enough doublet to be now guffin because i've dully supposed to make our wine kidding she's supposed to make her one Burnham radiation off to make with wine we happen to do everything with the wine some embroider marriage but even if you don't have wine you make Britta marry separate so therefore he says you do right away the nail then you'll do half-dollar then you'll do yayan that you'll do kitten so the iron connects both that's the of Libya and the Gomorrah concurs and says another another story which testifies to this last opinion Sola Slayer who it is smaller a be the father of small sent a message to rebbe reb Udonis yell bombed a new Rubino let our rabbit teachers say their half dollar say what's the right order of Abdullah when but sorry shoppers that's also Yom Tov so luckily Rebbe sent back a message to the father of small cos I'm gonna be small better be I see shall murmurs from Abu Salah mushroom to be sure mention Anya let me tell you what there be small the son of the BOAC set and they be small said this in the name of his father a beauty and a boa she said in the name of who rebel Shura Behnken Anya so this is going back many generations cuz they be who they are now sees the editor of the Mishnah the father of small is sending a message to the buda and he wants to know what's going on and what do we do to build on us he's going back to a bichon you have to realize there's a lady who's still one of the vocalists in the base--emitter of the musicians in the base--emitter is a measurement on Anya second base a McNish and he says to him Nick to say there isn't a hick which is nae half dollar yayan and kiddush again after dollar comes before kiddush the difference here is not like Shmuel himself and I'll remember this message was given to the father of small but small himself argued small held you do yaw in native delicate it's like every massage Shabbos kiddush at the end here we say no you do what nail have dollar and then the iron and then kiddush American a napkin and explain this will soon see what we do we'll soon see what we do well soon see the Gemara is gonna finish what we do I'm replica of cleanliness set Marshall W show back on Annie let me give you a metaphor a parable to explain to be show me come on what should we show mention on you see this year that half dollar comes before Kadesh the mela say I'd say a king a monarch leaves the city the partial stiffness and a ruler a governor comes into the city what do you do first we are now the citizens of this particular city we have two priorities the king is leaving we want to escort him the ruler is coming in we want to welcome him what do you do first Malhar Vanessa Mela the first thing is you escort the King the ARCIC athletes in the class are parkas and then you go out to welcome that it particles how do they translate a Paris the Duke first you say goodbye to the King you escort him out by the way that's why the meal mitts are Shabbos is called maleva Malka Lima lava Malka you're escorting the Mela you're escorting the Queen you're saying goodbye to the Kings like you don't just let the king leave Shabbos is leaving you make a whole meal to say goodbye you go together with the MELAS together with the Malka that's mature Shabbos but now you're bringing in the Duke the Duke is not like the King because the holiness of Yom Tov is not as intense as the holiness of Shabbos so therefore first you say goodbye to the Mela and then you welcome the Duke so be sure become Anya says first he may have well then you make it this I it's jumped if now you're right but first we have to escort the king that's half dollar our mouths will be additional coitus and then you're gonna welcome the Mela now it's interesting this is what the father of small herds from Remi small his son maintained the same but he just changed the order he said it's like every mid-sized Shabbos yeah and a half dollar kiddush we're gonna Sherman on himself made it a little different basically Negev dollar yeah in kiddush look at the Gemara wow we have all these opinions how many opinions did we have we had the opinion of RAV which is what yakin aha we had the opinion of swirl which is what Yong hak that's opinion number two we had the opinion of Rob oohs yaha Mach number three we had the opinion of Lavy number four which is Kunia we have the opinion of the rabbi's which is kena right so that's what that's number five then we have Mar number six Nakia and then we have marked in the name of rabbi Yeshua which is nick such three four five seven opinions seven opinions what you do mr. Chavez's youngters seven different opinions play the Gemara my hahaha what's the Govardhan what are we supposed to do it do seven times seven Jews seven opinions what do we do right to be sure yes exactly exactly if not there would be eight if not there would be eight if you're going to Sneha you would have eight that's why I said that twice versus greatest in the heat and also woodworker says Martin Amish major of yahushua right and the next opinion is also to be sure about konami so that's why it's very nice it could be nick nick is marked in the name of rabbi Yeshua and later it becomes rabbi shmuel in the name of rabbi you seen the name is Rebecca Manya quoted by Rebbe sending a message travel with a small exactly exactly to bring it out no they're just guide is that Marta said the same thing Martin everybody schewe said the same thing we would have but then their album would have explained Neha because the Raj bomb explains the smarter everything I was telling you the smarter of each person was from the Rajesh bomb but me hockey ignores obviously didn't have it in the text cuz if not he would have explained it says the Gemara might have along what's the conclusion i buy your armor a buyer says yeah kazan ha which is basically yakin aha with a Saffiano in the middle so that's like Ravi I'm kiddush right name half dollar which is mama Schroth grabs at first kiddush than half dollar but in the middle after kid is put a Saffiano so pointed out what would what would it look like Sabri Murano my gosh I'm Barry Priya guffin then you make kiddush I should Bob on the McCullar McCullar servoz mana then you'll make sure Fionna then you'll make birdie Maria H and then you make up though then you'll drink the wine rather Mar yak Nahas lion kiddush nail half dollars man again following the principle of Roth Kinder's before half dollar but instead of putting Saffiano in middle you push a fee on all the way at the end so our buyer and rather both maintain the view of Roth interestingly it's against its against the father of small against small against Rebbe against a be show become on against all these Hanoian they hold that kiddush comes before half dollar and therefore if there's no Shafi ah no like special pacer everybody holds yakin aha no question where is the argument i buy a nova not really arguing when there's no Shetty ah no their argument is only when there is a Chevy or no for example the first night of Pesach or Lewis or circus where do you put the Chevy uh no so our buyer says where do you put the Chevy oh no you put it right after kiddush why because when we say Saffiano vickima no biggie analyst manager what is it on what switches Manas there Yom Tov you just made kidneys for Yom Tov so now make a Saffiano on Yom Tov we understand what I buy is saying that's what we do every young TIFF forget about my choice Shabbos oh how do you do every year you make kid it and then you make sure he or no after that half-dollar doesn't eat Saffiano have dollars for shoppers you don't make Saffiano after half-dollar every minute make sure siano you say Abdullah so therefore our bias is while you put into the Triano at the end chiana balloons after kiddush so therefore du ein kidneys mine and then go over top dollar rubber holds no no lover says that you do this Saffiano at the end why you're right that Saffiano has to do with kiddush but every regular kid is will you do Saffiano at the end so here you also do it at the end just like every kid is you do Saffiano at the end so here you also do it at the end at the end of all the process you're adding because since half dollars also for the futures of melody Saffiano is connected to a dollar and there's also another very powerful McCullough the - mom says the brush-off Saffiano doesn't have to do with the cup of wine when do women make sure he on young teeth but a candle light let's say I don't have a cup of wine I don't make kiddush yom tov comes yeah and without such person is in a situation of anything yeah they could be walking in the marketplace and making sure Fionna Fionna you're making on yom tov it happens to be that we do Saffiano together with kiddush but robbers arguing Shaheen Yan who essentially doesn't have to do anything with a cup of wine so Mahler you first finished everything that's connected a cup of wine and then you do chef Fionna at the end so you do it after MacGuffin after kiddush afternoon.a after half-dollar and the Gemara finishes up the whole suger the hill sister carava the locker is like rava following the principle of arrived that kiddush comes before half-dollar and following the principle of rava that Saffiano comes all the way at the end and that's what we do we do yayan kiddush may have dollar man yak Nahas we do our often will do kiddush again why this kid has come before i've dollar for two reasons number one because he holds that the prominent thing is welcoming Shabbos not saying goodbye the young welcoming young tiff not saying goodbye the Shabbos despite the marshal of the beer of a relative that he brought him to be sure welcome Anya in other words the Mitzvah sire and avoid that now is to welcome what is not to say goodbye to what was interesting lesson in life that's the main service number two you don't want to do I've dollar first it shouldn't look like you want to get rid of Shabbos as fast as possible and therefore kiddush comes first and we do it in the regular order how guffin first kid it's first then we go over to have Darwin arrived Allah there's no salmon when entering when you're coming in too young to the reason there's no up summon the rash bomb holds because there's a neshama you sailor even on Yom Tov so therefore you don't have to smell because the show-me state is not leaving twice was argued why because as we learned last time Tyler says if so we should make some of them it's all your tasters are used in a somebody's there it does leave my sari Shabbos but because of simcha some TIFF and all the food and drinks we learned today and look at the Turkish mini what it means to eat on Yom Tov so that weakens the anxiety of the neshamah Sara leaving a column there's no Summum see new Yankovic negative dollars mom Hills to secure the locker is like Rafa you want to know how Roth could go against the tunne huh the time there Debbie said that it'd be small and abuse information on you all set that I've dollar comes before kids all the way back to this monitor base-emitter SH and I've argued that it's all wrong you want to know how Ralph can argue with the timaya we do have a cloud char survive Tanner or Pollock Roth is considered intermediary between the generations of the Timonium and the generation of am i right because ralph was a Talmud of Rabi who was the last the end of the tunnel yym so Ralph is considered on the fence between phenomena members of the Morrises raft a Noah Pollak this Israeli so even yeah that's not a hidden I mean the talmidim argued with the rebels constantly so that's the halacha like rava doctor gomorrah am i sir the buna bar Yehuda kaalabhairava rabbuna the son of Yehuda came to the house of rava one was this this was a regular mr. Shabbos not um a regular Mitsuru Shabbos he comes to the house of rather I saw the Camellia more Europe summer they bring for they bring him fire Moyer and they bring him some incense what rather up some embarrassed about it I'm worried like we do rather makes a brothel burger mini-b summon and then he makes a brother buried a man is right what do we do we do hug often right by Abdullah coffin summon bird in mérida age and then her mom that's exactly what he did Oh male after he finishes of Darwin owner who came to visit him the bonus says Bob Danish on my who bane be still my bodacious rounded up someone both Bashar me and both they still even though they argue they all agree you first make murder marination then some where do you see this my heat what was your who know referring to the Tanami we have a mission in my sessions Broca's down on olive but Shama I mean by Shammai says the order of the blessings is nay uma sign some involved Allah base in aluminum nail oops ummat muslim half dollar the mission and brock is talking about a person who was eating on Shabbos Shabbos afternoon the meal continued till mid sorry Shabbos now you have two priorities you have to bench and yourself to make half dollar this person only has enough wine for one cup so what does he have to do he has to do all the brothers on one case of wine what's the right order of the brothers so be Shia and be civil argue what do they argue bashar me says first birthday Maria H then Berta some wasn't them some and then i've dolla they still aluminum no name should come first but then summon then breakfast a Muslim and then have Dulla but what do we see clearly the question is muslin when is muslin is muslin sack you know Muslim history but everybody says natives first on the other bus Ray so rather responded after him for many telephone long zoo deviated mayor you're quoting the text of remain in the Mishnah Ivo W annoying with the text of review there was the Buda totters Lane Ashley kubishime a said Allah Muslims will be cleaner well I'm Dollar Tree besides there was no argument between them about Missourian that it's in the beginning and I've dollars at the end everybody agrees you pick up your cup and first thing you bench that's no question because that's what you just finished you finished our shooters you bench everyone makes everyone says first muslin and then i've dolla that's not a question the question is what happens in the middle our monocle calamari vol up summer Bashar Miami more vodka some him basil--oh him summon vodka more for Amarillo in an argon caboose hello Val Liberty review hood bjergsen have said the nation followed Mason though according to the version of review hood that means first summon and then by Tamara - so don't tell me that I'm following my own not according to be sure I mean I'm according to basil--oh you're quoting the main I'm calling to be hood everyone holds breakfast are Muslim comes first why cuz when you finish your meal that's the first obligation ain't my fear another mitzvos the first Mitzvah that you're obligated and you should do first I ate I have to bench right even if I finished my meal later by night but when I already ate on sharpest I was already much slowly breathless on Muslim so the obligation because I'm wasn't started before the obligation for half dollar so therefore British a Muslim is always first half dollars always at the end like we always do the question is what comes first native summer suck the Gemara a blackened by a vehicle of a rava another story maybe a cover the son of AB becomes to the house of her over when is this this is on Shabbos as well soon see so the first story is a rabona came to the house of Robert Ivana by Yehuda and he watched a regular half-dollar which he was unhappy with and rava clarified his position next story is the back of this son of ABBA comes to the house of rava on Shabbos as we will see Rebbe Yaakov had a meal with Rafa on Shabbos and he was also there much sorry Shabbos and he was near by Abdullah when a vehicle was in the house of rather there's going to be three questions that come up on raava's behavior and the Gemara is going to bring the whole story of Rabbi Yaakov in the house of rava hacia Rebbe Yaakov saw fascinating the Voorhis body prior Governor Kasich Amma Robert makes a birdie Priya goofin on a regular cup of wine it's a regular cup of wine he makes Brady Priya go funny no the beginning the beginning the beginning he makes a birdie period often on wine the first case this this part of the story it happened there are bumps does it happen on Shabbos right it happened on Shabbos but it's not negated Shabbos the same issue would be OC of myself oil the - mom says that it happened it happened on Shabbos but it's not any Gaius sharpest it says equal basis sure / yeah the - mom says it was on Shabbos yeah but bothered by the Priya a girl from maçussa , he made a bit of a governor in the first the first case typhus says in the on the bus a button on the words Baraka Kasich Amma shall kiddush it was kiddush she basically made kiddush and and he made he made by the Priya Guffin he made by the prior government Rashi says if you look at Rashi on the top column across a comic sham masculist eyes when he started to drink our Muslim sherbet Sheila when he started to drink yeah it could be there huh - right it could be - the older was by sooo delicious it was the third meal so there's no kiddush right so a male it was just a cup of wine for shall we show this and rather made Hobart appear governor on the cup of wine Torah says it was one of the meals of Shabbos when you make kiddush Rashi says it was a stop drinking so it could be it was the third meal there's no kid she was just drinking a cup of wine and he made a golfer why does Rashi hold it was so delicious because we'll see later that he was there till Havdalah so therefore it actually assumes he wasn't there from from Shabbos morning or from Friday night it was rather so delicious could be that's this one of Russian I'll cope on him but you'll see it's not so Nagaya here he makes her guffin on a cup of wine great harder Boris accosted the burqa sir then he benches Kosta the breakfast that means the cup of benching and he makes another hug often the ish tea and he drinks it you get it he sits down for a meal let's say Allah showed us he drinks a cup of wine a government he benches on a cup of wine he makes another hug often after benching and he drinks it on my lady Yaakov says la mala koola hi why all of this while making a second ago from herb article on marcado Ximena you already made one by the prea Goffman on the cup of wine and middle of the meal why are you making now a second ago friend on the second cup so that's the question in other words if I am drinking a cup of wine and then later you bring another cup of wine off to make a new one Goffman cuz I made a guff see I'm sitting at the same table I benched why do I have to make a new girlfriend when an atom might make I want them to drink the wine why am i making why are you making the newer government on my way so rava says Kiev in and made a Chicago's ha Kiev dinner when we used to have the meals by the ridiculous rules that means the head of the exile the Jewish leader of the Diaspora this is what we used to do on my way the Bayaka says wait Tina's Bailey is good Lucinda here I understand why you guys did this by the Neeraj Colusa the suffolk my salon suffolk my slay my salon you're a guest by somebody's house when you're a guest by somebody's house it's a doubt is he gonna bring more wine after the first cup or is he not gonna bring more wine after the first cup I'm sitting in your house you give me a cup of wine I make her guffin I don't know if I'm gonna get more wine by the meal but maila when I drank this cup of wine I made our guffin what was my mind on not at any future cup of wine because I don't even know if I'm gonna get it it was only on this cover one I know I'm getting this cup of wine I make a golfer therefore I didn't have in mind to drink any more wine so now if he brings me a new cup of wine even the middle of the meal it's considered a completely new drink and I have to make a new boy deeply ugh of fascinatingly let's say I'm sitting even at my own meal right and I drink one cup of wine I make a guff and I think this is my only cup of walking I'm drinking I do not want to drink more now I get a little thirsty ten minutes later and I drink a new couple wine I have to make a new girlfriend why because when I made the hug off and it was exclusively on this cup of wine I do not want to drink anymore here maybe they wanted a drink but there in somebody else's house she says that's why you have to make a brush on every cup of wine but half there but this is your house her Mama's kissa come on Medina me lawyer the second cup was there the wine was there and your - was on it when you made lady Priya golfing in the beginning of the meal didn't you know you're gonna manage of course you know you're gonna bench did you know that you're gonna use a cup of wine for benching of course you always use a cup of wine for benching so why are you making the newer girlfriend what are you competing this to the range Colusa by the native girl loose so you're at the mercy of a host you don't know has a good mood you don't know the maths if he has one it doesn't have one but it's your boss what's the issue I make McGuffin on my layer of his said I'm not of the Khatami did arrive I follow the students of Roth let me tell you on my cell then f Brunner venom Colonel Tommy didn't have a very austere be so docile this is a story a middle of a story a middle of a story RAF Bruin Arab karna no with the students of Rev and they were sitting at a meal two people roof Brunner and napkin on oh they're sitting at as Masuda and these are the students of Rahu inspired my way of doing things Korea liar a VA Versova standing above them is a behavior the elder what does it mean standing above them ah no it says by aroma vino right who who are you made al am he was serving oh you made that lame standing above that doesn't mean standing alone then it means standing and tending to their needs looking what they need who only medallion right Cory Liu - she says Mohammed alayhim or or or there's balm says vu who I'm a doll am at argument on voluma shamash the targa moon coolest and parses my areas with Amish Amish I'm rule a ref Brune a napkin on all the students of laugh turn to the Vav who is serving them the behavior the behavior sovereign behave of the elder and they tell them have Lanvin ever give us a cup of wine let's bench it's time to bench they basically finished eating so they turned to their behavior and they said hovel on give us give us what give us a course of wine yeah and so we could do Benjamin Masari I guess the conversation became very very interesting or engaging so at the end I'm rule a they have they regret you know what we don't want to bench we want to spend time together um delay they say to the behavior have Lanvin ich t not have alone ona Voris give us wine so we could drink in other words they regretted their original thought that they're ready to finish and bench and they wanted a cup of wine they decided they want a cup of wine not to bench but to drink on Milo who the behavior says hockey are my wrath let me tell you what Rob said Kevon damn resue have a Lanvin average eat acerola hula misty the moment you say give us a cup to bench your now let it drink anymore my timer does he sue that I who why because you had a cicadas you removed your das I see so means you removed you diverted your mind your attention from drinking you decided you don't want to eat anymore you said give me a cup to bench so therefore once you say give me a cup of wine to bench you removed your mind from we're from the meal and because you removed your wine from the meal you want a bench if you want a bench it means I'm done we're done we're going to bench give me a cup for benching now if you want a drink now if you want to drink you have to make a new broker a new birdie Priya guff and you have to make a new bracha soba Mela the behavior said I can't just give you wine to drink you have to make a new blessing on the wine because it's not included anymore in the original hagafen that you made in the beginning of the meal all the wine that you drank till now was included but now you decided to finish the meal so you interrupted it so now you interrupted it now you asking for one great but it's considered a new Sudha so you have to make an uber Dupre hug often this is what your behavior told the students of wrath this is how rather explain to the Bayaka what he was doing that basically even though he made a guffin in the meal and even though he had in mind to drink more wine and even though the wine was there but he benched Marr does when you asked Abed you have to make a newer girlfriend just for asking I didn't ask the bench I benched for sure of to make a knockoff that's what ralph was saying I follow Tommy the mama tell me them of Rob what do you learn from me that even if you ask the bench you just say give me a cup to bench after make a new broker for sure i benched i benched that is the greatest test about risk on us means I'm thanking our Shem for eating and drinking I'm done I'm benching so now when I drink the wine afterwards I need to make a new purchase hug often that's how Ravi explained to the beocca who was staying by him why he made a new hug off and after benching after benching a very interesting McCoy kiss of the rishonim comes up in this Gomorrah what did her behavior mean when he said once you said I want a bench we want a bench give us a cop you now that a drink anymore attached to the hula mr. what does it mean you now let it drink anymore what does it mean right apparently he's the words are you now let a drink it sounds like you're now let a drink even with a brush it sounds like you now let a drink right words that what he meant that he mean you now let a drink without abraca you just want a drink like just bring us more wine no no no you're gonna have to make her you're gonna have to make a new brother right so rashly and Maseca schoolin explains that that's what he meant he meant that you now let a drink without a bra he didn't mean you're not let a drink a lot a drink if you want just you can't drink the way you thought you could drink you can just drink stop you have to drink with a new broker in other words HESA hadass diverting your mind from the meal only necessitates abraca reshawna a new bracha you don't have to make abraca korenna on what you ate already even though it's two separate meals you could just drink wine make a new broker a shiner and then you'll bench and the benching will include everything and that's the of many many restrain him that what he didn't mean you have to make a new beer kasama in other words first bench you now let a drink and then we'll bring the wine that's not what he meant he just meant you're a lot of drink just you have to make a broker however raashi and they rush bomb here and that's the of many restrain him and that's the sack that them so Canora I am Simon Cove eientei's which is the simin dedicated to these helices very practical Alaka if somebody's sitting and eating and he turns to his wife or turns to his child or turns to the waiter and says please bring a cup it's time to bench right it's time to bench and then the person wants to drink afterwards you decide you don't want to bench you want to drink afterwards you would have to make a new bracha on the drinks fascinating halakhah ah if you wash my McCrone I'm for sure this is even the you don't wash my mouth writing him you just said bring me a cup for benching right bring me a cup for benching in other words you finish the meal so from for the drinking you would have to make a new broker a shiner even if it's wine a golfing or any other drink you have to make a new broker even though you're off to make a new broker you don't have to make a broker Crona first but Rashi and Irish bomb tied to Gomorrah differently literally the behavior said you're now at a drink he didn't just say you now in a drink without a new broker and what he meant was that they have to first bench they first have to bench on the old meal and then they could start drinking mom-ish in a new a new meal which this is this is a gevalt occasion dish that they would have to do breakfast a Muslim that's another usually but here they wanted a they finished the meal in other words once there was Hester hadass from the meal according to this day he says you have to bench and then you could if you didn't do a sad-ass yet you first eat and then bench but here they already did so it's too late understand oh very interesting so this is a huge mark like as nearest shiner what about eating this happens constantly in meals right let's bench bring the benches bring the benches bring the wine wring them out and then dessert comes out oh so he said only drink for drinks clearly he says some sanctum Ingemar every behavior said Rav said then if you ask for bench Inc right and you then you now let a drink without a broker according to assumption that you first have to bench but that welcomes us Anarkali off the bench but you have to make a new broker what about eating so this is almost like a series showing it some item said it's exactly the same thing what's the difference HESA cabassa cicadas so if they bring up cake even if I already ate cake early I made my science have to make enormous owners bring out cholent ha ha ha cool whatever it is fascinating I love her but other is showing them say no this is only if you see another Gila only drinking not eating it's only drinking what would be that what would be the the hillock explanation would be there's something called yesh Kavala sudha that when somebody eats down sits down for a meal if they're sitting in one place even if they decide to stop eating they continue eating they often continue eating so malar it's not considered a cicadas but sia was considered a separate endeavor again it's a little hard for us to understand our customs sia was considered a separate endeavor when you decided you're not drinking anymore you're not drinking by a kilo is orphan that a person gets negro gets that anguish slab gets dragged in from one eating to another eating they argue that for eating you wouldn't have to make a new broker only for only for sucia so that's that that would be an interesting difference where other asurim say it's exactly the same thing HESA Hadassah's has cicadas and if they bring you new food you have to you have to bring and both are brought in choke on Arak and KO phi and test both sisters are brought the first that it's only with drinking and the second is that it's even with eating it's very very practical Allah come muds bench right and then somebody gives you an orange and you just say we're gonna bench soon you have to make her ate even if you made a AIT's already 20 minutes earlier on another fruit they have to make a new ice or they bring you new kugel you have to make Amazonas on the cocoa or not very interesting question on drinking yeah everybody holds though once you wash my Mirena or once you actually picked up the Kois for benching right then even eating even eating yet you would that you would have to make a new brocco that everyone agrees once you did my math right up but hits not you did my mum you just asked for a cup of this before my career lose no no no no no it's after Miami Craner so Zuma you do you do have to you do have to know you do have to know though now it could be this is what a place that once told me he said in today's day people are so not people are so are so into eating and drinking constantly non-stop that he doesn't even know this has had asked today from drinking and eating he says in other words when the guy says let's bench it's not even serious because he does it every Shabbos and five minutes later he's busy eating for another hour so he says if that's your routine so what does Venice on us another one they said give us a cup for benching it was a serious thing so his Titan is a cloud there's no such God as my you don't mean what you say let's bench yeah your nation it you know you're not such a responsible person that's been after something else we won't bench she says it could be this is not even a cigar it's an interesting a lock but but the way it says until tomorrow says if you say let's bench and then you want a drink you have to make a new bra eating is a McCoy cursor is shining glycosuria shine them McCleod cursor shine in the ballot initial America arrived says Suffolk Broca's lock so reckless welcoming since it's a Suffolk interior shine him so therefore it's local you don't make a new broker for eating so therefore if I take a piece of challah right I say let's bench and then the piece of Cal and I want to eat I wouldn't make a new one might see some say I'd have to make a normal very interesting question but this is the source of this discussion because the behavior said that you have to make a new bra doctor Gomorrah the humerus has three stories fascinating here is the story in the middle of the story in middle of the story in middle of the story I made my Mizzou Trivedi bhashya via Austria stood three people were sitting at a meal I'm a ma'am a Sutra NEBOSH McCrory alighted Ibaka balladeer of lab after the son of a rover was standing above them to serve them I made my bar I shall call Casa because I made my made birdie Priya golfing on every single cup of wine every cup of wine he made a government forget benching every cup of wine Marzu de boracay cost the camera vos Missoula made in the first cup of wine and the last cup of wine meaning after benching like rubber like rubber did boshy Boris hiked us a comma vassula boric marshy made our Guffin on the first couple one and he never made a broth again even after benching when he drank he never made a broth again i'm elora baka by Robert raka wherever was the waiter so he turns to these three I'm Iranian the great sages of the generation I made my Masucci Dabashi an uncommon Ovid who are we supposed to go he's supposed to do this like in other words you guys are completely contradicting each other our main Mart doesn't stop with his Broca's my suits red one and that one in the beginning one at the end a bashing one and that's it who are we supposed to behave like so they all explained to him what they were doing and basically what they were showing is that they were basically following their own experience I made my Rama I'm Amos says NIM lashonna this is just my personal thing and I drank every cup of wine the first cup of wine I decided I'm not drinking anymore and then nibbler nameless means I regretted it so after the first cup of wine I decided not to drink anymore and then I regretted it and I drank another cup and the same was true with every single cup I regretted it and I drank a new cup so therefore every cup is considered a whole new drink it's like a new meal so therefore it needs a broken that's a may MERS I'm a Mars position my mother says I know Daphne Khatami today Ralph unlike a may mark I did have in mind to drink and I'm following the students of Roth what did what do you remember what's the students of Wrath rather learned from the students of RAV that when you bench you have to make a new hug often not because he didn't have in mind but because it's considered a cicadas Habashi Amira baa she says Lisitsa committed enough I completely disagree with the students of around the halacha is not like the students of Wrath and I'll tell you why it doesn't make sense the ha we all remember the McCoy cos young touches all the Sakura Shabbos on my Rav yak na when young too falls out my saree shop is what did arrive say yayan kiddush nade half dollar you're making a guffin and then you're saying a block of kiddush a brother my age Abra $5 and then you're drinking what happened why is all these brushes not a half sick for your hug often is the Cariah that Rav says you can make one our Goffin and our Gulf and travels through kiddush and our Gulf and travels through half-dollar and then you could drink after in other words the fact that you made half dollar between the kiddush and the drinking between the hug orphan and the drinking is not absurd usually do our Guffin kiddush and drink or a guff enough darling here you did a gulf and kiddush and then you made a whole new brach abdullah and it's not considered to have sick soma MELAS RI you can make a broth and it's not a half sick so what's wrong with making breakfast I'm awesome I bench and it's not absurd and since Rob is the one who said this is the quraían that I've never said the other halakhah a behavior misunderstood raff I've never said that you have to make a new hug often if you ask people to bench because you see from here yeah Kandahar that Rob doesn't believe that a brother's a half sick and therefore a bar she says sorry I don't make a new hug often after benching I do bench ink and I drink without a government so I'm gonna Gomorrah of alloy he wrong you can't compare awesome by benching a card I Tama miss Tia you uprooted your mind from drinking haha like occurred item I miss Tia here you did not uproot your mind from drinking meaning the definition of breakfast a Mosin is I finished eating and drinking I'm thanking us sham why don't you think I should I'm in the beginning of the meal because you didn't finish you think after so the definition of benching is the meal is over no more eating no more drinking that's the definition of mentioning definition of benching is goodbye to the meal now after benching you want to drink a cup of wine great make a new bra when you're making condition of Dulla you're not only Korea das from C definition of Abdullah is not I ate and drank I've done with means you're saying goodbye the sharpest you sang that by the Shabbos and therefore rub Ashlee's distinction the gomora does not maintain and says the law he therefore robbers halwa has maintained that after benching you make a new boy - Priya guffin and that was his justification to Rabbi Yaakov so this is all part of the story that a Bianca was in his house and he saw maker guffin and he asked him why and he told me the range Colusa and he tried to question it and I've told him the story that happened with the students of Rav with Ruby haver right and then the camera goes off to another story about a main man mizuka Dabashi and I'm a man my Sutan are arguing about she is arguing and Lepanto we maintain that my sutra was right just like Ravi was right accepting the position of the behavior server in the name of Roth which all explains why rather made a new hug often after benching as he explained to Rabbi Yaakov so this answers the first question that Reb Yaakov had on rather why are you making an uber Dupree are offered and indeed that's the halacha that when we bench we make a new hug off and after the benching because it's called hester hadass even though you have a cup of wine and you know you want to drink it but because the definition of benching is asked of us not because you don't want to drink you actually do want a drink you have a cup of wine but the definition of benching is that the old meal is gone and whatever happens now is a new is a new experience and therefore you need a new body pre hug of on worry also according to this if I say let's bench legs bent you have to make a very good question if if you make a brach on food and there's more food in front of you even if you didn't have in mind to eat it unless you didn't have in mind not to eat it you'd have to make enough let's say I'm eating apples right because it's there but if the let's say I'm eating apples and there's an orange I finish the apple and I meet the origin I never had in mind to eat orange but I don't have to make a new her eights why cuz when I made a Brook on the Apple it applied also to the orange because it's her eights and it was in front of me okay unless I had in mind I don't want to eat the orange I don't want to eat the orange now I'm eating the orange after make a new bra but what happens if the orange was in the kitchen I'm eating the Apple and the orange was in the kitchen and then my wife brings out the orange after I made the broth and I didn't have in mind if when I ate the Apple I had in mind any fruits that are gonna be here I want to make up I want to include including when the kitchen that's fine then it doesn't have to be in other words if the fruit is a food is in front of you you don't have to have that's for it it's already nickel on the brush the food is not in front of you you need das and if there's no das then you have to make a new brush when they bring out the orange if the water is in the refrigerator I want to drink the carpet and that's it and you didn't have the sand you didn't have das to drink more water and then somebody brings more water but you didn't have das to drink more water you want to drink one cup yeah and then I said well they're yours have Shinri mahkum they also have a change of place are you saying in the same place you have to make a new bravia yeah unless listen very often we drink a cup of water we know that we want to drinks and then it's very often your das is not but if your mum --is-- our country entries i want one cup of water the truth is I have I have the question almost every day somebody brings me a cup of coffee before the first year I make a Scirocco obviously but the second she brings me a new cup of coffee but I make a new Scirocco because I never the coffee is not here so so no and the truth is when I make the first schakal I never think about the second coffee then I wouldn't if I'm having in mind that I'm still gonna have another cup of coffee and a half an hour now whenever I wouldn't make but I don't have in mind so I make every day I make at the end usually this class is brought to you by the yeshiva dotnet please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot they you Shiva net / donate you