Pesachim 101a-b - Arvei Pesachim #4

the yeshiva dotnet Sock'em dove cough Aleph Emet Aleph a few lines before the bottom of the page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 80 10 lines from the bottom Kavala foamer Aleph what did the Gomorrah tell us now the Gemara was teaching us that RAV holes that kids doesn't have to be malcolm sued so if you hickey the shul you can go home and start your meal even though you have to make a new bracha MacGuffin why because you changed your place you went from one house to another house you went from shul home but you don't have to make a new kiddush you could make you could start your meal and do I might see and eat because kiddush doesn't have to be but Malcolm stood there but small disagreed and small said not only do you have to make a new brush on wine when you get home you have to make a new kiddush and the reason is because small holds painkillers Ella from crime so the kiddush has to be in the place of the meal and there are shabam gave the two reasons for that Vacarro saw los cabos Oneg and the savour that they established the cup of wine to make kiddush on Shabbos the wine batalha stood there the wine as part and parcel of a meal and the Gemara explained abundance said that he heard from Shmuel it's not only from the shul to the house even in the house itself if you make kiddush in the attic and the roof and the second floor you come down you have to make kiddush again that's what he heard from smokers small used to make sure to come down and make kiddush where the meal was he wouldn't make kiddush on the roof and the gomorrah says rabona agrees moon also holds ain't kiddush a little malcolm stood and that's why once when he made the kiddush and it was dark and he couldn't eat there he went in to the canopy of his son and that's where he ate and made kiddush and then the gomorrah said that grab a soul zenki Shalimar comes soda so we everybody's small and we have a moon and we have rubber and the camera brings a story that I buy you said that what when rabbi used to make kiddush afterwards he would tell our students before you go home eat something to email media I want you to eat something I want you to take something why because perhaps when you go to your hotel or the house you're staying the candles have already been extinguished and therefore there is no light and even if you decide that you're fine not eating and you're gonna go to sleep but the problem is you didn't fulfill the Mitzvah of kiddush because you didn't eat here and my kid this won't work for you you're gonna have to make kiddush again and over there you won't make kiddush again because you won't be able to eat so even if you make it this again over there it's not gonna work because you're not gonna eat this or therefore just eat your meal here so we have three sources even though Rav disagrees but we have small and rabona robber I buy according robbed of all hold and Kadesh Ella from comb Sudha says the Gemara a knee it's not so how could you tell me that Rob agreed with small vomer abaya by you said something fascinating call Millie the mayor have a ovid care of all the issues all the matters of my master abayas master was a rabble rabble was his uncle Robert was his mentor Robert was his Reba I buy it was an orphan and robber was his uncle and robber raised him so rabba both raised him as a father and he raised him also as a Rebbe as a teacher so when he says the master Maher is talking about robber so he says all the matters of my master used to follow Rav with var Mahon e-class the Ovid Krishna law besides three Halak I swear he followed Shmuel against Roth everything my teacher robber followed robbed besides three things what are the three things number one might eaten me beggared lebesgue 't Martin and Rebecca the beggin means I could take cities off one one garment and place it on another garment Rav holds that it's embarrassing for the first beggar that you're removing the citrus you now let it do that small halts you're not just removing it you're removing it in order to place it on another baguette let's say I have to sit sis and one of my fringes of senses becomes parcel of tears I takes it is from another garment I put it on Ralph says you now let it do that you have to make new ones small halts Mateen in me beggin lebesgue a doctor you are allowed a while because he holds since your take changing it to another baguette it's not embarrassing for the Mitzvah next mark like this very similar Matt lickin me nail in there can I take a hammock a candle that I already lit as a Hanukkah candle and light with it another Hanukkah candle Rav says you now Lau do why because it's busy Mitzvah this candle is a mitzvah thicker candle don't use it to light another candle it's embarrassing the Mitzvah small holds mudlick in Manila Nair Rav would say use a match use a sama SH you could use a sandwich that's fine but don't use the Chanukah candle itself to light the other candles Shmuel says not much look in my nail in there because you're using it you're not stop using it to light your stove you're not using it to light your pipe you're using it in order to light another Chanukah candles so it's fine yeah yeah yeah yeah right right yeah so this is only for the Saints take it you want to light the candles as what would revolt what would small hole about using Hanukkah candles for Shabbos candles yeah it's an interesting question I think it's fine I have to look it up but I think yeah he would hold it's fine I think I have to look next the halacha could have shimon Bonita the next thing he found what small was small used to say the halacha is like rip Shimon when it comes to greeters dragging the Tonya we had a price Shimon I'm Arab Sherman says Goro Tomita Kisa visage silver Shabbos a person may drag a bed or a chair or a bench on Shabbos on the ground or bill virtuous Cavanaugh sweets as long as you don't intentionally try to make a furrow a hole in the ground what is the idea the Martin Oh Liam have a McLucas are you allowed to do something on Shabbos which as a result of that so thing will happen which is a melaka not intentionally but as a result of what you're doing you what you're doing is permissible but as a result something may happen unintentionally which is a Milan example you're in a bungalow colony say in the country right and you're gonna eat in somebody else's house and there's not enough they need a bench do you have a bench in your house so you take your bench outside and you schlep your bench from your house to the other house on the ground on the earth it may make a furrow which is a malacca of plowing tyrese but it's not my intention it also may not happen but if we're slepping a heavy bench on the ground it may make a furrow on the ground it may not but it may yes if it does make it and I would have done that intentionally it's called ploughing am I allowed to do it this is called dover shana miss Gavin he's doing something it may result in a melaka but that's not his purpose that's not his intention so this is the example of dragging a bet on the ground without the intention to create a furrow which would be a Malakhov ploughing if it's outside or malacca opinion of of construction of building if it's in a hall rip Shimon holds dovish animus Calvin is motor you just allowed it's fine your be hooded disagrees your buda holds that it's a sir so dip Shimon holds that even if there is a Faro it's fine as long as this was not your intention and I should also add as long as it's not inevitable which is called secretion meaning if it's inevitable to happen then you're ready then it's you can't call it a dovish a animus Calvin because it was part part of action one is action - but if it's not inevitable so then even if it happens rip Sherman says it's fine and it's motor Shmuel held the halacha was like rip Shimon Rav held Allah who was like ruby hood Dava Shana miss Kavanagh sir robber followed Shmuel that lock is like rip shimon lover shana miss Calvin is mutter what do we see from here a buyer said my master did everything like you're out besides three things he would untied citrus and put another baguette he would lie to Fanuc account on others a candle or he felt it's permissible and he would drag something on Shabbos even if we could make a furrow because it's a dovish animus Calvin it's mutter those are the three things that my teacher did like Shmuel suddenly abayas contradicting himself he told us something new he told us that what that robber also held like share all that ain't kiddush Ella them come soon if he would hold like Ralph they wouldn't have to eat after kiddush they can make a dish and then go home and eat it's fine because kiddush doesn't have to be more come sooner so i buy is contradicting himself he told us a whole story that robber demanded they shouldn't have taken this because any kineceleran welcome soda in other words he agrees with small but I buy a told us that my teacher used to do everything like now besides three things and those three things don't include kiddush and here we have a fourth thing suck the Gemara you've misunderstood abaya whom today Ravi evolved it Kaku literally evolved it robber followed Rav in all of his stringencies besides three things where he was lenient like small but cooler the revolver but it doesn't mean that he always followed around when it came to leniency in other words in every area where Rav was stringent and Shmuel was lenient as a principal he always followed Rath when ralph was stringent and small was lenient he took Karev's position to be mock me for stringency besides three things were even though Rav was stringent and small was lenient he rejected their Avenue embraced more that sits us the candle dovish animus Calvin and all those three things Rav is stringent and small was lenient and that's the kiddush that in these three things he embraced you more but there could be things that he did like small when small was stringent so that's what happened it's not a contradiction he used to follow around when it came to stringencies besides three things but in Kadesh Alabama come sooner he followed small as astringency that is a leniency that's not a hidden the kiddush is then in three places he followed small as a leniency when he always used to follow Rav when he was to engine but in this case he followed small cost rules the stringent one there are things we didn't follow Ralph when following Roth meant being lenient and that's one of the examples a practical example the Halak is like yeah we accept a la collection wall in this area and that's why the vagina miss Calvin is mutter so if your child has a splinter you want to take it out on Shabbos right you want to take it out it's possible that you're going to prick it in the process and there's going to be the letting of blood which you're not let it do on Shabbos but it's not inevitable so you're allowed to take out you let it take a tweezer whatever and take out the splinter from the hand I'm not talking about if it's a medical figure if it's dangerous then of course you're allowed oh you'll let it take it out ah you could be there as a result of that you're gonna do a melaka that's fine your intention is not to make your child bleed your intention is just to take out the splinter that's a classic example of a dover Shaina miss Calvin right you may end up doing a melaka but that's not your intention and it's not inevitable so you're a lot of do it yeah on the ground yeah on the lawn yeah you know if you're for sure gonna make a Faro then it's a challenge then it's a problem we're talking about not for sure yeah if you for sure gonna make a Faro then it's a problem according to some yeah that's another Mac like this yeah yeah right exactly exactly yeah right I want you to look for a moment on the words of of a rabbit in the story that I buy a told about robber what did he tell the students he said just kihavah make a dish when we were by our master when he would make kiddush I Milani would say two EMU middie I want you to taste something to EMU media I want you to taste something these words to EMU midi can indicate a very interesting concept and that is that you don't have to eat a whole meal in order to fulfill the obligation of kid nashville maqam soda these two words become the source of a very important halakhah Rober didn't say stay here and eat robber said stay here to taste something so we learned from here that kid is my mom said it doesn't mean the whole meal has to be in the place of the kiddush it's enough if you eat something here and then the main meal you eat elsewhere that's what we learned from these two words to EMU me they taste something I don't need you to eat all meal because you might think kid this remark ensued the means you have to do condition the place of the whole meal but from here we learn no you could start eating something here as long as you started even though much of the meal or the main part of the meal you're gonna eat in another house you don't have to make another kid dish why cuz the main thing is that you started to suit in the place of the condition even though the primary part of the student was not in the place of the condition but since you started to I'm agin the place of a chorus on the Shabbos it is fine that's a give out the conditional ah-huh that even if you eat a little bit and you eat the most of the soda elsewhere you don't have to make a new kiddush oh very good very good another interesting thing you see in this story nothing evolved the good thing you see in this story is look at the story again and this is how we have to be medallion stories I'm a rabbi I'm gonna be Kiev inna Ben Meir when we were by the master key have him a Kaddish when he would make kiddush on my lawn he would say to Imam mean he tastes something when did he say this before he made kitty sure after he made kiddush look at the story when did he say it then he said before Kidder's to taste something and did he say it after kiddush how do you know was after kiddush excellent after kiddush right ki have a Makabe sh when he made kiddush all my long to him o midi what do we see from here he probably said this after he made kiddush this means that if you made kiddush even if during the kiddush you were not planning to eat anything but after the kiddush you ate you fulfill the obligation of Kadesh that's what we see from robber because rabbit didn't tell them before kid this make sure you're gonna eat something he told them after kids that means during Kadesh they may have thought we're going right home nonetheless it doesn't matter the ring kid is you may have thought you're going right on but if after kid is you eat some think even though you didn't have in mind to eat drink it is you still fulfill the obligation of kiddush why because the condition was welcomed Sudha even though during the kidneys you weren't thinking about the soda that's what you also learned from this story so you'll learn two major things from this story number one you don't have to eat a whole meal and number two you don't even have to have qivana by kiddush that you're gonna eat as long as you ate after kiddush ah now there's a third question what do you have to eat how much do you have to eat and what do you have to eat he says to email me the taste but don't say what taste what hiring matches herring stickell Mussina's snap what do you have to taste this - emu Mindi taste something obviously don't eat a whole meal taste something doesn't mean to eat a whole meal it means taste something but what are you tasting that he doesn't say clearly in this story another what did he need what did he wants for them to eat and naturally since it's ambiguous so there is a McLucas about this what else would you expect we are at we are Jewish the question is what type of food do you have to eat in order to be out the mahkum soda since this is quite a a practical question in life because people often make kiddush and a similar you go to a semca dish or ensure or whatever you visit somebody for a few minutes maybe even with your wife and family and then you go home and you ate something that the kid is right how do you know if you have to make a second condition when you get home to do malcomson so we learned that if you didn't eat your for sure off to make a second condition right but the question is if you did eat at the place of the kiddush do you have to make a second kiddush so yeah that's fine Shabbos day yeah it's just a bracha barrier prayer golfin that's fine yeah even a Shabbos day you could make kiddush many times because Shabbos day it's just a bracha barrier prayer Guffin that's the condition of Shabbos day right Shabbos day kiddush is only a blessing it's basically yeah but if I drink wine here and then I go home to drink wine and then I go to your house to drink one and then I go to your house to drink wine every time I make a golfer so it's fine so I could make kiddush for 20 people you understand what I'm saying Shabbos day it's fine but that's it no that's it that's that's the kiddush of shoppers day all the introductory remarks Shabbos day is not kiddush it's just so kind that we say before kiddush you understand it's okay no no no kiddush is only a blessing Shabbos night Friday night there's a serious kiddush you mention our shams name baroque guitar emilich animales I love my shaker Deshawn of him it's my summer at Saban / Shabbos country etc barakatuh Makeda Shabbos that's a serious brush of kiddush okay Shabbos day you don't have that job as day two is just verses of how much that we say before kiddush but that's not the kid is that you could say anytime you could say that a thousand times during the day that's not a problem that's not a Brock the only thing that we do Shabbos day is Baraka tamil komal embroidered prayer golfing as long as you went from house to house the house you can make that Braco many times so it's not a problem boys or other people to play you also don't have to eat you can make Kadisha not eat they make and they hear kiddush and they didn't eat then they'll have to make you this when they come home of course I can make killers for you I can't eat for you so this is a Shannara assimilation I in Gimelstob assimilation Gitmo so just I'm gonna read for you the conclusions in South America Roth when he says as follows kiddush has been welcomed so that that means if you made condition one house and you ate in another house whether you had in mind to eat in the other house or you had in mind to eat in this house but you ended up eating in the other house you did not fulfill your obligation with kiddush and you have to make a new kiddush in the new house before you start eating whether it's Friday night with Shabbos day because it says Vika rasa abbis Enoch Luka Russell ashab asana that have come and taught the place of an egg in the place of the delight oh so the Shabbos that's where it should be the Karussell of Shabbos will you declare Shabbos which is kiddush to the clear that it's jobless and goodness that should be where in the place of the I egg in the place of the pleasure in the place where you what you are eating certainly if you made kiddush and you didn't have a meal at all you didn't go anywhere you just don't want to eat you didn't fulfill the obligation of kiddush right oh so important you didn't fulfill that blade if you didn't eat after kid that you did just like if you go somewhere else gonna fulfill the obligation of kiddush if I stay here and surely I don't want to leave I didn't fulfill the obligation of kiddush even in one house if I'm going from one room to another room I made kiddush in one room and I decide I'm gonna eat in another room and then and I decide I'll go and then I go to another room or I go from the roof down to the first floor to the second floor second floor to the first floor you have to make a second time kiddush you have to make a second time kiddush it's a different room in the house you have to make a second I'm finished in other words let's say you make kiddush maybe if you make kid this upstate let's say here you mean we Davin up there you make addition then you come down here for a meal you have to make a new kiddush very interesting even one house that's what the Gemara said we learned from small they would come down from the roof to the first floor to make to make it to make English now here I want to introduce something very interesting we'll see a mom will see in a moment okay we'll see in a moment we'll see that in a moment the Kurosawa Shabbos Oneg literally it means you should call out right for Shabbos to be honest how come him said the Karussell a Shabbos should be in the place of Oneg in the location we have the oyneg means pleasure the location we have so the Shabbos that's where you have to have the vac rustle of Shabbos [Music] the normal ways for people to get away from you usually yet usually now here's an interesting thing there is showing him quote a statement from Tom and you rashon me in my sexist breakfast how many who saw me says that small who was the one who introduced this concept of Kadesh remark I'm stood there holds that if during kiddush you had in mind that you're gonna eat elsewhere it's fine even though you didn't make condition that place that's what the US Army says but it's obvious as they point out that our Gomorrah doesn't agree with that because if our Gomorrah would agree with that then why would small say you can't fulfill the kiddush that you made ensure make conditions show have in mind that you're gonna eat in the house and then you're good you have to make another kid is why would small argue with Ralph so we're from argumarium clearly that Shmuel holds that even if you have in mind it's not going to work the mindfulness having the intention I'm gonna eat elsewhere is not going to work so even though the your Xiaomi says it they say that there's a McLucas between the Bow Valley and the US Army when there was an argument between the two gamora's halakhah is like Bob Lee and therefore they say we have to embrace the view of the Gemara here that what that even if you had in mind to go elsewhere and eat when you made kiddush it's still insufficient and you have to make kiddush again even though your Xiaomi small holds otherwise however however many of the rishonim say that there's no need to create an argument between the two gamora's why they say that the US Xiaomi is talking about one house and the Bible is talking about two separate houses meaning if you go from schulter house then small would agree that your qivana doesn't matter and that's why he says you won't be here it's a kiddush but in the same house here small would agree that if you had in mind to eat in another room in the house then you could be Yosa kiddush you don't have to make another condition so the US Army would agree with the barely enough to make a mark like us so when the smaller says whatever you're thinking is enough if you haven't mind to eat somewhere else the kiddush can apply to that place it's only if it's the same house because since it's the same house it's already connected it's already integrated it's just you're not there you're in another room so if you had in mind that mind could connect you to the other place because it's really in one house it's not like you don't have to go leave the house and go to a new place if you have to leave the house and go to a new place in the fact that I have in mind wouldn't be enough because ultimately I'm leaving this place but because I'm in one house so then if your mother Shover is there so it's already connected because it's considered one house it has one gather it has one bias that would be a very very interesting interesting halakhah and as a result of this as a result of this hala column I sir this is accepted by many and that's why even though we see kids from welcome so that has to be even in one house but if you were upstairs and you made kiddush you made kiddush and you hadn't mind to eat downstairs right according to this many of the posts come so you would not have to make a dish again because it's one house although the ballot on you says it's better like a pillar not to do this because there was another of the over there on who holds that this is not true the bobbly holds that das is irrelevant even in the same house and if we says it's better not to rely on this it's better to do kiddush mom is from Malcolm's soda but there is a very strong smarter based on this you allow me to say that luckily my sir and he says you can do it it's just better not to that what if you had in mind to make to have the meal Elsa even though you may finish upstairs it's good but from one house to another house or from the house to the courtyard your thoughts don't help and you have to make kiddush a second time but there's one exception and that is if then this is your question if when I'm eating in a room I could see the place where I made kiddush for example a kitchen is open to the dining room so I make kiddush in the kitchen or in the dining room I eat in the kitchen and the place where I'm eating I could see the place that I made kiddush even through a window there's a window between the two and even if I can't see the whole room right let's say there's two adjoining rooms is an angle of a dining room in a living room you made conditioned the living room you go to you in the dining room you can't see from the dining room the whole living room but you could see part of it and maybe even through a window through an opening so so in such a case yes I am that it's called Kadesh from Arkansas because both of these places are called one place when it comes to kiddush this is the of the of the tour and my admission in the name of the Ghanim the shelter Nara and although again there are those who argue with it but he says you could rely on it certainly but Shah saqqaq you could rely on it you could see you could potentially see you might not be facing right if the place where you gonna eat from there you would be able to see the place where you made kiddush even part of that room and even through a window yes I am room there is a in a locker that it's fine yeah right right another important thing is if you have a huge room let's say a wedding hall you have a sever Broca's you make kiddush in one corner you could continue eating in another corner that's completely not a problem why because one room is considered one place it's called the same market so it's a huge buffet I'm doing kid and share and I eat there it's still called kids room welcome Sudha and but it's interesting the mugging of Rama says look I feel it's not a good thing to do this because again some people argue even with this some people argue even with this even in one room odka de Kock out can they yeah that that's the principle yeah that's the principle yeah yeah yeah yeah yeah finally we come to the point of what do you have to eat so the going them taught us that when we say ain't killers hello and welcome so that doesn't mean that you have to eat the whole meal as we just saw you just says taste the question is what do you have to eat even if you eat a Casillas okay so we're in there is a few different this here even if you eat a Casillas of bread you're good one cuz I said brandy good even according to many if you eat a Casillas of the other five minim meaning not a cos is of bread barley or wheat but even a cos iose of of other grains for example bergamini Amazonas right cake a Casillas would be good others say even a reviews of wine so if you either cuz I so bread you for sure good if you wash even if you a the cause is of MS anus you're just that cake cuz I similar is good some say even if you drank a reveals which is just like four ounces of wine besides the cup of kiddush they say it's good enough you did the sudha and you could continue eating somewhere else now or later and you don't have to make a new kiddush why because you already started you stood in the first place and the second sudha is just a continuation it's basically like this sooo delicious the third meal you don't have make kiddush you don't make hitters before what happens however if you only ate fruits at the kiddush you just ate fruits or you drank soda or you drank other stuff then you're not yet cicada to Malcolm soda why because wine is considered satiating and burger minimize anus is called ma sign so that's called sudha why Norma's anus is called Sudha but fruits or other liquids or shackles is not going to be called is not gonna be called Sudha great yeah yeah yeah so this is a very this is a very important idea that you don't mamas have to have to eat bread okay some same Amish bread but but many say even Mozilla's and and about what Tanya tine is even wine although some argue about wine but certainly you could rely on bread and Amazonas and according to many even wine but not anything else no Holland is not soda child is not so if I make kiddush and I eat herring and then I eat some sharland and then I eat some kishka and then I take an orange and then I take an apple right even though this I have to make another kid ish but if I eat a cos iose of bread or I eat ACCA's ice of cake or according to many even I drink four ounces of wine then I'm yet to the Suder the beginning of the center of to make another kiddush there is a schita that he brings that even if you drank the reviews of wine from the cup of kiddush your Yeats a kiddush from welcome soda you don't need sued only if you didn't drink a Revere's but if you drank a full reviews of your kiddush cup you already did your kid dish and your soda so he says you should rely on this only in a time of need for example if there is yeah he said that you should rely on it but if you could drink another reviews of wine B drink another reviews of wine and then and then and then you're good okay a rave reviews somebody should taste a rave reviews so someone's in a place there's no food if there's no food then you just have wine and you drink reviews of wine and then you know if to make Kadosh a second time well you don't have like a mission I mean it's not a Sudha but it's it's a suit in the sense that it's called Kadesh from welcome soda yeah sue does that but it's still not welcome yet you examine here and you vote to kill ya person like me I cannot eat and telling you much go there go so am I better not to taste anything there who only and go over me why you could taste it's nothing wrong yeah you could taste you can either Stickle herring but you'll just make a second kid nothing wrong with making a second goodness no you don't have to you don't have to but if you don't eat you can't think that you will yo see with the skiddish you have to make a second kiddush if somebody made conditioned his house and his neighbor who lives next door hurt kiddush from him in his house and he has his table in front of him that neighbor fulfilled his obligation because he heard kiddush in the place of his soda so it's a funny thing you're saying kiddush in your house if you would eat with me you wouldn't be out to the kiddush but since I'm eating with me not you I just heard you as long as you had me in mind Hey Yankel just have me in mind then we're good why because I heard kiddush it's fine look I could be Oates of my neighbors with kiddush no you have to have a mind you have to have a mind dividend a VM and a VM is Shia Kabbalah it's called every Kabbalah right right something about a Veidt something tomorrow right three lines from the bottom could follow from an hour's rabbuna no more abuse and has a third opinion if you make conditioned soul a few day yah in nami Otsu the ocean and says wow not only a it's a conditioned soul and you have to do a new kid in your house you don't even have to do a new broker on wine in your house Rav said if you make conditioned soul you're good you know if to make a new condition your house but you have to make our Gulf in your house you they kiddush you it's about you there yeah small said you're not yeah it's a not wine and that kid this you have to make a new condition for sure you have to make a new brach on wine relational is the most lenient he says come home and you don't have to make a new kiddush you know have to make even a new graha you could sit down for your meal wash I might see and you're ready continue drinking wine in the house from the hug often that you made in shul and you drank and show by the kiddush apke dick huh in other words your buchanan halts that if i had in mind to drink wine in my house i had in mind when i make it as requiring a mouse so the drinking in the house is a continuation from the drinking in the show and i don't have to make a new broker in the house so he argues with ravaged floor they hold when you go home it's considered a new drink because it's done in a new place and the fact that you had in mind doesn't connect the two places it just means you wanted to continue drinking but lapel you physically interrupted this drinking and you started a new one you had in mind but geographically you're not in the same place so therefore it's called a half set you left this place you're going to new places considered a new drinking in reality even though your mind connected it to but your mind doesn't replace reality right x-rays don't replace the image reputation and says no your mind does define reality the fact that i was ensuring add and mine to drink the air yeah so it's like the about something what's that the muhkam shamash after shallow them so moon EMSA where your thoughts are that's where you are because my thoughts are I want to continue drinking in the house so the geographical separation dissolves in the mental connection between the two places and it's considered a continuation of the same drink even though I had to walk 10 minutes 20 minutes 30 minutes whatever it is over next door to get home so therefore regulation and says when I drank wine ensure it's fine I just have to say it even a question of Eurasian I'm if I heard hug uh finantial and I didn't drink it's not gonna work why cuz even in your own house it won't work right let's say I say boy your pre hug often yeah and then I start talking to you for ten minutes I have to make a new Brock on the wine so if I heard how guffin in Seoul and I didn't drink and then I go home you're gonna have to make a new huh guffin simply because of the have stick between the broker and the drinking you understand but if I drank control and then I make a half sick and I go to another house and off to make a new broker that's an important emphasis that Toys R Us makes let's say you didn't drink Hervey's let's he didn't drink Revere's if you'll take a look once they're gonna toast us rebuking a number a few day Yaya Tzu second-to-the-last Isis oh mighty shall say babe a sickness s a fog of the leaning kiddush yotsuba schmear for kid this you don't have to drink you just have to hear could the pre - delay Ling in the ioan look apparently in yeah in like pot - LEM cane salsa the other half sick the renovated cakes the reversing I'll be on my team who sits on a clown's Olivera but when it comes to the Brock of wine you have to drink right after you make the bracha so if I heard the Brooklyn shul and then I go home and I drink after make a new brother because of this interruption between the brush and the drinking but if I already drank control and then I go home and I says you have to make a new broker where Raph says you have to make sure mole says you have to make why because there was an interruption it's a new drinking regulation it says because I had in mind it's not the same for other ambition alotta made I'm reckonin by a buyer I've gone in the son of a buyer said I'm a rebel doesn't the name of ripped us a manipulation ever be excellent I thought she knew yayan the effort Chenier makam and sorrows lovara give out the kitchen dish if I drink wine and then I drink again in another place I'm sorry if I drink wine in one place and then I drink again a different type of wine that's called Sheila Lyon a different flavor a different caliber a different barrel a different type of wine I don't have to make a new boiler priya guffin on the second drink whether the second drink was from a different wine which is different than the first wine or she lahmacun it was in a different place the Buchanan holds a change of wine and a change of place doesn't cancel out the first broker you don't say it's a different type of wine and therefore I have to make a new broker no and you don't say I went to a different place and therefore have to make a new Braja whether it's genuine or Chenier mahkum you don't have to make another brush it's always considered the continuation of the first first first drink of course there are there are bomb points out famously when emulation and says she knew enough to make a new brush is talked about by the prior government but there's an uproar called hot toy waha motive which one does make when you bring out a second bottle of wine a different type of wine which is superior that's another brush type I made that it's not talking about when he says she no yawning so close he's talking about a new boiler Priya guffin the fact that the wine changed this ear is irrelevant why because your mind you didn't take your mind away from the first drink even though you left the house or you change the type of wine you got according to most post-game as long as it's not inferior assumptions it's better yeah but I'm saying is it did Fourier - the first one that's fine you make it's fine you could follow your bar yes as long as you're not debar yeah very good so when the Buchanan says that you don't have to make a new broccoli he's not only talking about wine he's talking about every food the patient knows if I start eating in one place and I continue to eat in another place and I'll have to make a second bracha as long as I did not take my mind off the eating which as we will see this is exclusively the view of rebuking on and it's not the halacha but this was the view of reparation involved I can finish enough to make a new brush even though you changed places you left the house he came to Newark as long as you did not interrupt it mentally you had in mind to continue yes he comes to be mental interruption these are also a time factor this is more than 72 minutes or something like that that cancels out no it doesn't seem it doesn't seem to be an issue says the Gemara mesa they asked the contradiction under Buchanan from a Bryson the Bryce it tells us clearly the tannoy important remark I'm sorry Oliveira if you change your location the middle of the drinking you have to make a new broker even if you had in mind to continue drinking she knew yayan if you change your wine ain't Sarris levar it to you third it'll be ocean and this is a refutation of regulation on who believes you don't have to make a new broker with SHINee Malcolm and the Gemara says indeed to youth to this is a ref you this is a refutation in other words regulation its position has been refuted it's true that if there's a new one you don't have to make a better PR golf it but if it's a new place if I left the house and I go to a new place even though I had in mind when I made conditions show that I want to continue drinking and hours I have to make a new burger Priya guffin unlike rabbuna the question is Ralph says kiddush work lunch moles as kidneys also didn't work but that's another argument but in terms of Shinri mahkum in terms of the brock our governor after make a new bra so the Gemara it says your savory of IDI by oven commander of wisdom revita the son of oven was sitting in front of the president the awesome her pisda andhra prince de was sitting with karma mich made arun and he was quoting Ramona so if Edie was sitting in front of her prisoner and replace de was quoting her phone and her Puna said hard the omelet she mimicked I'm sorry levar a whenever we say that if you change your place you have to make a broker like shun no LME by Islah bias this is only true from home to home I'll go me Malcolm lahmacun but from one place to another place in the same home lie it's not called a Shamir malcolm and you don't have to make a new bra that means if I start drinking wine in my house and then I go up to the second floor and I continue the drinking festivities according to the appears in the name of Ramona I wouldn't have to make a second broker brighter for young golfer rebuking an old even if I go from house to house but rabona said house to house you have to put place to place in the same house you don't have to make a a new Braja on my lady of edy bar oven sort of indie bar oven who heard this tells or is de hoc eaten in Alabama snis said the very Vinick in fact we learnt this already in a bracer that was taught in the Shiva the bay is the Shiva of ravinok of a man named of in it but I'm relaying some say the must miss said the bay Beranek it was no Brice of the shiva of the son of Hinnom either was the achieve of ravinok or the achieve of the son of Hinnom have a say and it supports you that Brice it clearly says that in one house it's not called a shinny Malcolm so ya habibi supported refused as words asked the Gemara valor of Horniman it's a commercial one so his opponent just telling us what it says in the price if a browser supports and why didn't have to say this is Merced abouna mustnít solution ela Ramona did not hear about this Bryson because the opponent was an admirer the fact was that I'm Iranian fluently they knew all the Mishnah is he couldn't be an admirer if he did not know Oh every mission of I heart word-for-word every I might add to not all the mission eyes because that was the structure the text that they worked with but the brightest they didn't always know so it's possible that rabona did not hear about this Bryson this Bryson ever heard about and that's why the burner felt that it's important I welcome to say because he didn't know that there's a bracer of the Shiva of ravinok or the son of rabbinic Beranek that tortoise so this is a new finish that shinra malcolm will only apply from house to house and not from place to place which would mean which would mean that what we learned before by kiddush by malcolm sudha and learning now is two different creatures because my kid is remarkable so do we learned small that even from place to place in the house from upstairs to downstairs you have to make kiddush again right that's why small came down to make kiddush because it's not cold makam soda but here we're learning that what that if I start drinking downstairs and I continue drinking upstairs not all skiddish but else brother I don't have to make a new bracha that means that kid is remark I'm soon there would be much more stringent than this halakha of changing your place and middle of drinking we're here we say that if you change your place if it's the same house you don't have to make a new brother why this is so important is because we have this text in the Gemara but many of the is showing him when we look in their commentary here they had a different version of the Gemara they saw in a bona he doesn't say Ivo me Malcolm lahmacun he says I will meet Pina latina from corner to corner that's what he Santa that's a completely different gear sir that means in one room if I'm sitting in a big dining room and I'm sitting here drinking wine and then I go there and I continue drinking I don't have to make a new broker but if I'm sitting here and I go upstairs I would have to make a new bra so these two versions and the Gemara are really very very different because let's say I start drinking here and then I go up there do I have to make a new broker according to the opponent no it's the same house but according to the second version no only in one room don't you have to make a broker which would mean that then kid is from welcome sudha and SHINee Malcolm are actually are actually identical they reflect each other because what did we say my kid is remark I'm soo de that two rooms in one house are considered two separate places and if you made condition one you can't eat in another one again unless you could see it as a window where butt shots are cough you can rely on it or or or it was or was one big room with two corners etc even though over there is also an argument but but according to the second gear serve there is shine and it means that kid is rumor comes to then she might come out of the same halacha in both cases from house to house you have to do a new conditioning after doing Abraha even in one house from room to room do a new killer chef doing abraha the only way you're exempt is if it's in one room from corner to corner but let's remember we brought to you a shaman who said that small holes that hitted remarkably sudha in one house you can do even from room tumor if you had in mind right if you had in mind one house would help and therefore according to the opinions who hold that if you made kiddush in one room in the house and you had in mind to eat in another room that's going to be good because it makes the whole house like one place your mind could connect the house but your mind cannot connect two houses so by Shannon welcome that would be the same Holika Holika with me that if during the bracha i have in mind to continue eating in another room in the same house i will not have to make a new braja but if i have in mind to eat in another house i would have to make a new bra so that means I make a bra con coffee this happens here constantly people go to that room they start their coffee they make Chacal they come into this room do they have to make a new brach or not what do most people do they don't make but really really have to make a new broker right I can't see the room of the coffee here certainly if it's upstairs a hero's I can't see right there's no window unless you want to know her maybe wants to make a window no no if I made if I bring the coffee here and I make sure how beautiful but if I make sure how cool here and then I go upstairs with this coffee with another coffee doesn't matter or I made a coffee in that room and I make charcoal i smooth in the morning this they have the cigarette hour at 5 o'clock in the morning ok and I make sure how come then I come into this year and I sit and I continue drinking right people don't make another shot what would really the hello could be so according to the first gear Singham our rabbuna said right namikawa mahkum is fine if it's the same house but we just learned the gears of the Roisin em that what only one corner to another corner but my Makka Moo Makka would not be good you have to make a new bracha however however we learned okay a car the car is moving but you're in one place I mean you're on a boat right the boat may be moving you're in one place you're on an airplane you're not gonna make a brook 6.6 million times same thing people make a coffee here they make sure Jaco they go into the car okay and the car you drive the way that's already me bhai Aslam iose that's not my maka maka right here in upstairs is one bias yeah here to the tent yeah it's not I mean it's owned by one guy well a courtyard is yes that's not good by that's not called mean welcome welcome yeah yeah so the course what's the best you don't drink it here you just wait til you get into the car again and then you make a brush people buy potato chips they make on them and then they start walking around everywhere eating the potato chips right they have to make a new broker you went out of the room you went out of the building you can't continue eating the potatoes to make a new broker on potato chips you don't have to that's gonna be the next soldier when the after bench after potatoes you don't have to so this is something so the truth is that Liholiho according to most points come just like kid is from Arkansas if you make kid is in one room and you can't see the other room and you go out to the other room you have to make a new kiddush unless you had in mind right unless you had in mind during kid are you gonna eat in another room so this is by SHINee muhkam would be the same halacha no the car won't help that's my bias lobbyist that's my bias Luke Hudson but if I made if I took my coffee in that room in the four year what does that call the foyer huh fire okay mud room foyer I wanted to say for you say mud rooms as I mud room and you make a breakfast shikaka and when you're making you have in mind I'm going to a shear right and I'm gonna be there so then you don't have to make a new bracha because just like my kiddush if you have made kidneys upstairs and you had a mind to eat the meal downstairs according to many you're good but if you didn't have in mind this coffee grows when I need it probably twenty bravas when you came out of the car and you continue drinking when you came into the building and you continue drinking in that room and when you came into this room you continue drinking [Laughter] it's a problem you buy potato chips in this store you make Cod dama you start eating it and then people walk out of the store they go on to the car they continue eating it even as soon as you walk out you have to exactly exactly you went into the cut sir okay how local am i sir how this all applies practical is gonna be the next year we're gonna continue it tomorrow basil your das can help Makeda LaHaye doin one bias but you das can't help for another house just like kidneys Moroccan soda ah yeah the Mishna Brewer has a whole long Stickle here he says people walk around ya and they eat everywhere and Messiah so you're saying you have one one - that whenever I whenever I eat it's never for that place my whole life it's really where else I make a coffee don't think it's for here those you tell you my whenever I make a broth it's not for here it's for everywhere I go running you mean a middle of the marathon you decide to drink it's a good question in other words you're outdoors if you're in our house we said it helps but if you're outdoors so does the whole world outdoors become a house right that's a good question you're running you're running in a field or a park or whatever on a track and you have a bottle of water and you hold it yeah people they're biking they do it constantly and you take out the bottle so is that cool the house and you haven't that you have bad ass when you're drinking this water the first time you know that in five minutes you're gonna do it again in a half an hour again I mean that's your das you have a whole bottle you're not drinking at all now so you want to know if the outdoors becomes combined like a house right that's a good question so we'll explore that also tomorrow Bleen either maybe you should start no by kiddush the Vorta is that the kiddush and the sued after me in one place now without my two a separate thing not the kiddush in the soda a regular day I have a meal and I make a Brokaw on a piece of Mozilla's here and then I take it and I go up there and I continue it does but I really made a broke on the food yeah I'm drinking this coffee I'm not making a Lucia how cool I really made 20 minutes ago Jacques I take this cup and I go upstairs excellent you want to know my kid dish it has to be the place of the soda who cares about the place it's the same very good question the answer is the answer is that shinra mahkum makes up or half sick in the evening it's called unn just like a new coffee if I have a nuke or somebody brings me in our Luke off you have to make a Shaka why so to another cop what's the difference whose I'm you brought me a new coffee I made a block on this coffee so what do that the answer is the brush and the food have to connect the brussels was on this coffee now you bring me a new cup of coffee that didn't get a broker so i have to make a new shark ah only if I had in mind if I thought I'm gonna have no coffee or the coffee's in front of me then I don't have to make a new Brock but if you now bring me a new cup of coffee I wasn't planning different place oh I'm giving an example says the halacha when I change a place it's an interruption of the first year the first drinking got interrupted right so this is considered just like if you bring a new food this who didn't get abraca even though this is not a new food it was here for me but it's a new act of it's a new suit it's a new act of eating it's a new act of drinking because I change places it's not a Hampshire yeah we live in the McDonald's generation so places I don't matter eat in the car eat in the kitchen you damned a life negate we don't connect we don't in our minds we don't connect food with place but really food is connected to the place you sit you eat it's an act it's an activity it needs consciousness das so when I go to a new place it's not time I change places how lossless sees this is an it's a it's a new incident it's a new drink not it's a new drink B'gosh meais it's not a new drink regarded I was holding the cup but it's a new my Sofia that's disconnected from the previous mine sucia like a whole new Matthias the brothers not only it's on the eating and the drinking this is like a new drinking it's a new drinking read just like if I drink and then I come to your house and I start drinking yeah so with it attack a new water yeah so we say it's a whole new thing but I made a Brooke on water you made a Brock on that water even if it's the same water you made a Brock on the water in that place but now the water is in a new place it's a new blood comes to your house you stir in the house will give you well we'll see tomorrow depends what you eat us there's a different in a coffee and cake so cake and wine okay we'll see over there you mean missingness it's Messiah I said kishka no you're right if it's miserliness you're right I guess I was so much uh cook well the Kiska Kiska is chocol the Kiska flowers - you're right if the kishkes missingness and it's mahkum so they erect barley cholent is Right barley challans mazayas Onis if you eat a keziah submissiveness then you're good if it's Amazonas like ishka - you're right I stand crime mnsure hakufu yes shackled roland is not enough yeah yeah in other words so the Shinra mahkum so does p creates a Chinook after you say but it's the same cup of coffee now this cup of coffee was here that's like a new cup of coffee it's a new experience is it yeah but if the physical the same physical food the brothers not just on the same physical coffee because I changed place it's like a new act of eating the fact that I changed and the place changed the whole experience changes it's like I sit down for a new coffee drink a new meal i sat down for a new is the same food that they brought them downstairs they just brought it upstairs it's considered a no meal so it needs a new bracha in other words the brother of an hour ago can't apply to this food right now even though I made a brach on that food because since I changed locations it's considered a new my sake line it's like I'm starting new let me give an example okay an example let's say I'm eating the I'm drinking coffee yeah on the table it's late at night I go to sleep I wake up in the morning I come back you think I have to make a new bracha say please I'm a kitchen it's midnight I'm tired I go to sleep I wake up 7:00 in the morning I come back to the death table hi I made a Brooke on this coffee yesterday so what so you're saying the bracha was five hours ago it expired nah there's a shelf-life huh huh okay so another the brother expired I this coffee had a brush yeah five hours ago okay when I change places when I change places that's just like that I have second time I'm not a middle of this syndrome that's the point oh so few das is in the same house that connects the two we gotta fall asleep kind of super new except the chicken is like a new road cuz over there it's different then he went to sleep but I'm just saying just like in time you understand that the brush on this doesn't apply in the morning because of the half second time there's also something called a half second space when I take the food from this space to another space so the broccoli doesn't apply the broccoli here cuz it's a whole new experience now you made a brach on this coffee yeah but there was half said was that because I went to sleep where I went away yeah so here I took the food with me but it's now I have sick it doesn't continue yeah when you go to sleep it's a half seconds man mahkum das everything I'm just giving an example that even he's asking it's the same coffee upstairs and downstairs saying when you go to sleep it's also the same coffee but the brook on the coffee last night doesn't work for drinking the coffee today so the brook on the coffee that in this house doesn't work for the same coffee in another house or even in a must you know even if there was das or even in this house if there was no das why because they have sick mahkum they have sick Malcolm yeah it uproots it from the first brother just like a new coffee I need a new Brock and it's like if I come back tomorrow on the same coffee I need a new bra cuz the broken from yesterday doesn't apply to the coffee today it so to speak expired why because there was a tremendous interruption here also the fact that I changed location is not in the same room I went to a completely different that I don't see so it's considered so to speak like a new coffee it's not a new coffee but it's considered like a new coffee why because the place has an impact so when it comes to bread if when you washed for the bread and you made how much you had in mind to continue eating somewhere else then it's fine and you can bench them so we're gonna learn tomorrow there's a difference between different breakfasts in other words coffee is not cake coffee is not bread because this types this this thing that when you bench you have to bench in this place and there's things that you don't have to make a broker crown in that place so we need the halacha also changes in other words if the food if you leave it and it's if it's pulling you back okay we'll continue tomorrow McDonald's generation my wife's grandfather's 101 first time we have a new restaurant really on July 1 years old can i Inanna no no wait they don't know about it I know I'm thinking my grandparents they ever heard of a restaurant who know about a restaurant you ate in your house there's no such as that ah yeah you stopped in a shop you pick up a cake at this and that that's how we live we all live that way today we even have meals on trucks and this at a vomit of truck here you eat on trunks know that the concept of muckerman food is is today different generation of different marks are huh people don't associate food with it's on the go meals on the go like in war you know the soldiers are more what do they call the meals the rations of soldiers but there's a name for the food re ready army right ready ready made ready meals for the for the troops did I answer your question yeah okay slaughter this class is brought to you by the achieve Annette please help us continue the classes make even a small contribution at triple w dot they ueshiba net / donate