Pesach Sheni: Similarities & Differences between Leil Haseder & Pesach Sheini

Today Wednesday's which is I would like to discuss some of the pesi and how is pesi different than the regular than pes of last month of the regular pes the par of pes sheni is a is a the par invol The says somebody was Tommy and he wasn't able to bring the carbon he wasn't close enough. He wasn't close enough to the B mig to be able to bring the carbon person should bring get he should he has another chance to bring a carbon which is in the ear the 14th day. So you have to bring the carbon pes and you should eat the carb pes together with matzah. That's the for of that a person has another chance and he can bring even if you couldn't bring the pes on the regular he can bring the pi the says what's the difference between the first and the second the first we all know the first a person has to clean out his house and make sure that is found. The second pes today when the person brings a car as well as at night when he eats the carbon he's allowed to have in the house together with he's allowed to have together with the says and then you have to roast the pes the pes that's brought today just like It's it's brought it's eaten together with so we see a very clear that between a person's allowed to eat allowed to have in his house as opposed to the regular. What is the the next step while the person's eating the carbon? Could you eat the kes with Of course you're allowed to have in your house. That's undisputable. It's clearly it's a Mishna that you're allowed to have. Are you allowed to eat it with In other words, you want to put it in a sandwich in a in a club sandwich in a lafa. Are you allowed to eat the meat of the pes together with why not? It's what? So technically I would I would think the pasturious really that you should be able to if the Tory says B there's no B raw bal so why should they be why should be it doesn't mean you can't good you have to eat it so you want doubles what if you want doubles you have doubles you have matzah and then you have it with a sandwich has to be anything one One second. You're going to tell me forget about never mind. You can't eat anything with these. It's whatever. Yeah. So, for that I'll tell you. One second. One second. I'll tell you why you can't eat. It's typical. Even if it's not even if it's a it's a it's a or something. It's of the of the thing you're eating with it. So are that the answer is that the of P is only a kaz and it's the last. So I'm not asking about that last that's for sure you can't eat anything with it because but how about all along you're eating a whole meal by night tonight while you're eating the meal all along you want to eat it with a sandwich you want to eat it with something else again the last which is the mitzvah to eat that you're going to eat without it's without anything because it's which means you're not let to eat it with anything Right? Just like pes even if you like to eat matzah with mayonnaise when it comes the kazayas matzah you allow to eat any with it anything because it's mitzvah. So the last of the that's for sure a person's not a person's not going to eat it with anything else. So it'll be what's about the whole meal. He's eating the meat. Could he eat it with Is there allowed you tell him about you can't eat or is there allowed? Oh, so it says it says is saying and that's what says you don't find anywhere these so why should it beer that's you don't find any you don't find anywhere you don't find anywhere that there should be an iser so it's not why should it So you can eat with he brings however says the rashi on the par we just says you allow to have it together there's no there is no only when when is there while you eating the eat now with it so says I'm showing you Rashi says that you now eat together with the car but he says why should it be says that you now eat so why can't eat together with the carbon pesh So we'll see what we'll see we'll see soon of something with however this rashi this rashi we'll get alhamdulill a little later the I want to first get also to the however this rashi that we see clearly that says which means It is I also hold that it's but I don't see where you see in that it's says you're allowed to eat it together with again which means you're allowed to eat it together. So says it says that you're allowed to eat it together. It sounds like a way to sing it. That's says weird how to word the hold. What? Says you're not allowed. No. The way he learns is that you are allowed. You're allowed to eat. So everybody ags it should be and says it should be the shila is how to learn a rashi how to understand if rashi is saying it's mut or it's I just want to say the so the shil is rashi says that it's and the question is where should it be pointed out you want to show me where thera says in the par we read of doesn't say anything about it just says that he's bring the which we read before the says what does the say the says you should bring up our you should eat the pes together with matzah and which means you should only eat it with matz and but not with says it's our rashi that we're speaking about here that it's and he learns that's the it's the says only together with matzah and not with he also brings a he brings a ride from a ta theft says no for seven days is only for one day. So the Dr. What's for seven days that is for one day is not for seven days that he's a for seven days that he's knowing one day that he's not eat together with together with you could say that just a second very clearly where would be for Yes sir. I want to also just show you the I'm not going to go on to the case where the is but the is not says what does it mean? You can't eat it together right when you're done eating the the matzah and the pes right afterwards he can eat which would seem also rashi learns that these these to eat together with the first of all can mean that that there's a se to eat it but it doesn't say and also you could say means you have to fear doesn't have to be I just want to tell you there's no even the says you have to fear seven days of fear. Yeah, but he's not listening or or let's say or let's say eating matzah all together. The ging holes is a mitzvah whatever. Yeah, but he's also we're going to get to that as well. There's no there's no mitzvah to eat matzah. We'll get to that. We'll get to that. Look at me. The first part I want to elaborate a little more what you're handling on mats in room. Yeah. Along the same lines though we've been saying he learns a lot from the from the essay but when you compare the two of them this essay doesn't have any of the other essays that we see by so can't you say that the fact that he didn't say any of these things doesn't say yet doesn't say doesn't say anything when it comes to peni you compare it to pish has all these rules you learn out the love when you're comparing two things that are practicer right so everything else you have a point that everything else is no. You have a good point. However, if the Tyra says what you're supposed to eat it with, you're supposed to eat it with matzah and so that the Tyra is speaking about if the Tyra is speaking about the matzah, we could say it tells you to eat pes, it tells you to eat with matzar and also don't eat. So over here eat say you see that the doesn't see here a good point. I want to also share a different yet The say anything you can't eat with obviously you can't eat the second one either that's okay that's a good but you see it's not everything because there's things that are different also but okay good yeah going back to the you just said respectfully I have a question on that because Because is a one day holiday is a 7-day holiday. Okay. But is regarding the 14th? Yes. It's a one day holiday is a seven day holiday here for a while. So therefore you can't say well that's a seven day. It's not for you as what's the question? The last one you just said it said a seven day holiday. It's not. No pes is seven days and pes is one day is a seven day holiday. It's a different it's a different. Okay. Number three is okay. So you ate the together with the with the pes was it was what if eating so what did you eat first? You didn't drink today. What did you eat first? You ate a [Music] stama dinner. We're going to continue afterwards. I want to move over here. I'm thinks on the I took three things. We're going to continue afterwards. the asks on on this of which is a you're allowed to eat you're allowed to eat. So he says that's only like hill ate it all together. So on that that you're allowed to eat it. So here you could say and not anything else but not like hill when the says what does the means that part of the mitzvah of eating carbon pes means you should also eat mats let's say we don't have a carbon so there's no mitzvah of mats but it doesn't mean that you have to eat it together if it doesn't mean you have to eat it together then you can't tell me that only this has to be together and not You understand? You don't have to eat it together. If you don't have to eat it together, the Torah is not saying only eat this together and don't eat. The Torah is just saying that part of the the mitzvah of eating pes is also matzah. If you don't have the pes, you don't have matzah also. But it doesn't say you have to eat it together. You don't have to eat it together. Which means the is not saying you have to eat it together. You can't be mad only eat this together and not just to conclude in this topic about eating matzah together or you're allowed to have in your house that's for sure you're allowed to have in your house. So the the brings to me what's the why is today why not it's interesting it's you're right it's what does it have to mean 30 days later what's so he says since when they went out of besides that they ate matzah they took along matz those matzas lasted till for 30 days which means lasted till today and then there was a transition after they were they finished the matzah started the so he says to show that this day we had matzah and then we continued on to so that's why we have you're allowed to have with the matzah which is eaten with the pesa you have as well this doesn't this doesn't bring this doesn't bring this doesn't bring a a this doesn't bring one way or another if you're allowed to eat with the PES but at least it brings out why you allow it's a good question if it was the next day and says it only was three days later good but that's what he says why on that day it stopped you saying he came the next day or maybe even came three days later I don't know maybe it came the same day that they finished that's what he says he says the has happened to your dollar and the next day he himself says and then these so I guess we have matzah because we have matzah we still had matzah and then we also have to show because the next day started the truth is already we'll get we'll get to the minute in a minute about if we could were people naive back then to to make curb place even if they didn't have to like we do now with the mat. No, it was only somebody who missed it. It was only if you missed it. We spoke about eating the car. I want to talk again to what everybody is speaking about about eating matzah. We spoke about sh afterwards now please. We spoke about not eating or yes eating together with the with the carbon pes is there to eat matzah pes let's even stay focused first to eat matzah is there to eat matzah or what the means is when you do the mitzvah you should also eat and matzah and just for understanding our there is no mitzvah of because just with the pes we eat we have a mitzvah we make a but the is only with the carbon pes so is matzah also a mitzvah only with the pes so let me let me share with you one or two nice things that show to be if there's a mitzvah typically the says a person shouldn't eat shouldn't eat matzah why shouldn't he eat because you should eat but what what's the problem why should you eat what's the oven that you should eat you have a mitzvah pes to eat matzah so you should eat that matzah and therefore a person of pes is not allowed to sit down to a meal He shouldn't be full. Tyus asks a question. The name of the is and the word the headline the first word in the mission is so tyus asks I understand they're both plural thes of the pes but what's the of pes what's the understanding says one ter and tyus says a ne second teri of both ar of the first pes and of the Second pes in other words and the is applicable for both pes that you shouldn't eat also a person shouldn't eat which means today this afternoon may not you shouldn't eat but to eat that's explains this asks over there on I don't understand pes of matzah. So therefore there's a to eat a mat. There's no mitzvah to eat matzah. There's no mitzvah to eat anything. There's a mitzvah which happens to be just the opposite. You eat you're supposed to eat. So why how do you understand the second you have to eat it? I mean I'm sorry you have to eat it. You have to be it should be there's no matzah. The same is also a there is a famous shila asked on by when we do we say the part we say to eat it together a sandwich the mat together the question is we're sitting now by the s the first p and why do we bring a p from pes al matl The is not not the so why we're bringing the of when we're sitting by eating we should bring the P. So one terret is brought from one of the bells that the reason why we say the reason why we say this is is a that mikdash and if the mdash will be built after be built we'll be able to bring the pes we're ding that we should have be able to bring the pesi and by peni it's tlu That's all being maspal. I'm going to leave it out for now, but it's a it's a it's a big schmoo if let's say most of couldn't bring a pes for whatever reason. So then wasn't said. So technically we wouldn't bring a pes a talk that if there was no migdash that's when the b mikdash was built maybe we would bring a pesi and maybe even not only bring a pen the whole pes would be no but that's that's one shot and he says that we're ding that there should be a pesi to bring to bring the to bring a carbon that's one shot theamer when theamer asked this question the says and there's a difference between the also says the terrorists but I want to just bring out from the idea that you know why the changes the between it says it says I'm sorry I'm sorry it says The in between says what's the difference? Why does a Torah change? We all because it's a separate mitzvah of eating matzah. So only the matzah inside the mor is only brought together with the pes doesn't have a mitzvah for itself to eat matzah there is no mitzvah to eat matzah there's a mitzvah to eat it with the pes but no mitzvah by itself he answers the question why we bring the to show that it's not we're going to leave that on the side for now. He answers the question why we say but he says there's no mitzvah of so it comes out from here that the mitzvah is only a mitzvah and there's no mitzvah on so you might all ask me so if that's the case why do we eat matzah we want to do some sort of obviously the the carbon pes we don't have. So the z is the matzah that we ate together the matzah that we ate together with the car but not not like a the mitzvah of matzah. Therefore, he's saying one of the commits. You say one second is the comp to you're saying therefore could be to the he's saying not only that we eat the we but just the these many most if not baby all eat the matzah today not tonight. Why do you eat the why do you eat the matzah today? Not tonight. Especially like saying that would be when did we eat the tonight? Not today. So it's brought that the reason many you know bring that's a reason in the pkim not to be toy that if we would eat matzah tonight people would be that we're eating matzah because he's a mitzvah matzah just like he's a mitzvah matzah therefore we move back to we move back to that's the reason some say that you don't eat it because of I heard last from one of the night said that because it'll be I didn't see it inside why it would be it's a different I mean it's later it's not together but this would be a reason even if we're to eat matzah whether if it's to that matzah carbon of the carbon we eat it today not tonight because not to be that that's for sure not there's no mitzvah and that's why we eat it today so to sum up we had First of all, carb pes for sure you can have in these if you like to eat it together with and we also spoke about that in the in the mitzvah there is no mitzvah may we still be to have and bring the pes can you eat today so could you eat