Pesach: Is it Permitted to Shave On Chol Hamoed? The Noda B'Yehuda's Understanding of Rabbeinu Tam

this tour class is brought to you by torahanytime.com okay welcome everyone Brooklyn usually in the weeks before pesach we like to speak about the under for pesach and the hagada and one other thing that gets overlooked is because you know the week or two before people want to hear about the umptive itself so now's a good time to speak about this subject it's a very interesting topic um somewhat of a London topic and that is is it permitted to shave on halamide or take a haircut while taking a haircut is not really a big deal you take a haircut before and usually you're good to go for a couple of weeks however uh yeah especially in our day and age where many people shave every single day that's part of their work routine they have to present themselves in a certain way so the question is what do they do on now sphere in a way is much more lenient than halamite it's not mentioned in the gemara that not to shave it's only a Minogue when I say only Minogue is not only Minogue is a very serious thing but still it's not an absolute uh halaka as we're gonna see shaving on halamada shaving Hamid is called Dina the gamara so let's begin somebody who comes from overseas in other words someone was out of town and did not have an opportunity to shave before yam Tiff so if he comes back on yamtuf is a ladder shave on um somebody was released from captivity so someone's taken hostage by ISIS if they were still kind as to let the let you out on which is doubtful but if they would let you out you'd be allowed to shave or someone who comes out of prison on yamdiff would be allowed to shave on or somebody who has been excommunicated so let's say somebody who was put in Hiram sonus is not allowed to shave if mattered his excommunication I'm not going to shave so if the nether was permitted on on yamtif so then he could shave on halamite so these are the exceptions to the rule these people are allowed to shave on khalamide so the question is what about everybody else siligamara asks ushar kolada my time why everybody else are not allowed to shave what's the reason why can't anybody else shave right so I would ask you that question what would you say why can anyone else shave I would have thought the reason you can't shave is because he can't do malachite halamite is the most abused uh the most abused days on the Jewish calendar everybody should know at least that it's not permitted to do malacha on halamite some reshining states and some say it's drabanon there are exceptions to the rule so for example um governor of it if someone's gonna lose the money not if somebody in other words most people if they don't go to work they won't be making money let's say every day you make a thousand dollars so if I don't go to work I lose a thousand dollars a day that's not called losing money that's called not making money that's not that would not allow a person to go to work it would be money that you have in your pocket you would lose so obviously part of that is if you're jeopardizing your career or your job but other than that you're not allowed to work on other exceptions are um some what rabbis don't work right uh the other exceptions are um let's say a miser hedger something which is not considered a skilled a craft a skilled laborer that would be permanent now hopefully uh people don't get too upset at me many halama chips that are very common do involve prohibitions that are very serious and these are things that are commonly done and so I'm not going to tell you not to do it I just tell you ask a Shyla apple picking how to pick apples off a tree on her mind straight it straight uh you know uh Pottery you know painting pottery you can't well you need that mug you don't have mugs at home why do you need to paint that mug so these are things that uh you should definitely ask Shyla before you do them but the bottom line is that you're not allowed to do malacha on and one would think that um shaving is a Malacca so why are you allowed to do it so the gamara says a completely different reason why one would not be allowed to shave on cholamide says the gemara my timers the men are the missile and the men are the maimed are not allowed to take a haircut and to do laundry so what's this talking about what's what's the answer so used to be they broke up the groups of kahanam into groups of 24 and they were broken up into various weeks so the kahanan would serve usually two weeks a year on the week of your mishmar akoyan was not allowed to shave also you had my mother is the same way the kohana would have to come and do time in the base of mikdash twice a year the Australian were also broken up into 24 groups and the Australian would stand by as representative of the rest of Cloudy Israel while the kohanim did the avoida the israelim whose turn it was that week to do the avoida to watch the avoida was not allowed to do laundry or shave during that week why but Lazar my timer so that they do not enter their missionar looking disgusting because if we're gonna allow a client or Israel to shave during the week that they do the Avada they're going to say to themselves you know I'm so busy packing and getting ready to go up to shalam I'll shave when I get there and they're going to enter the base time on Camp then they're gonna look uh not they're not going to look presentable so in order to ensure and encourage people to take care of us and to shave and to do laundry before they're weak in the basement we say you have no alternative you don't shave now you're going to look like an even bigger uh during the week of your during the week of your avoida so in order to encourage people not to ask us on Camp we say you should know if you don't do it now this is your last chance you're not going to be able to do it when you go to the basement so says the gemara here also when it comes to holamoid why why is one not allowed to shave on kalamoid today because if you would be allowed to shave on then with all the things that you need to get ready before yam diff yeah you got your suit and you got your clothing you took your shower oh yeah I didn't shave don't worry it's only one or two days I'll shave after people are gonna come to shul looking like uh looking like a mess and therefore in order to make sure people come into the umptive looking nice and presentable we say reviewed if you don't shave now right you're not gonna be able to shave later okay can't shave on the second day events the first days are more important you know so you're not going to look that great the second days and anyway what are we talking about here we're talking about we don't want you to look disgusting you could have a guy who went the week or two weeks or three weeks so if he doesn't shave it's gonna look terrible for the beginning of yamta but if he shaves the first before the first days so by the time singing this comes he only has a couple days of stubble anyway it's it's in the the look is in right now so you know it's not a big deal okay except for these exceptions looking disgusting oh yeah don't be upset anyway no okay yeah you have to do everything you can to make sure not to upset them if you do that they won't they won't care about your beard okay so the chocolate says like this so it would seem like it would seem like an open and closed case why because if you look at him and Olive could you shave up halamide says so you know it's black and white so it seemed like there's nothing to talk about yeah and it's open and close once the north passkins there's nothing to talk about so why do we have a share tonight because there is quoted by the tour and the tour in archaim and simantovan aleph basically says the same thing as a shock that you can shave on kalamoid and the reason is so that you don't enter yamdiff looking unkempt because if you would be a lot of shavan people would just go into the Yum diff looking like a mess and they'll rely on the fact that they could shave on says the tour on the Fifth Line you know Rabino Thomas we cannot emphasize enough that for those of us who are ashkenazim as much as we grow up thinking the rambam the Riff the Messiah of ashkenazim is China they don't teach this I don't know the greatest says fantastically wealthy Ramen Utama had hundreds of avadim raveena Tam was wealthier than any nobleman of his time and he also had a mess what if you shaved there of yamtif and you didn't enter yamto for Mass so then it should come out it should be a ladder shave on Parliament the only reason is because we want to make sure you come into Young Thug looking good but if you shave there of yamtip and he came there I'm looking good why in the world would you not be allowed to shave on YouTube he says every day shave every three hours some people need it so there'll be no time if you shave aravient says the tour it's very hard to matter based on Robin it would be very difficult to be sunny why number one it's just very hard to be simultaneous number two says a tour the gumar is not mashma that way because the Gomorrah asks gamara says what about everybody else oh everybody else is not allowed to except for the mishnah that says the exceptions so somebody who got out of jail someone got out of captivity somebody whose nidoy was over somebody whose nether was hutar why didn't the Mishra say and someone who shaved Earth the fact that the mission does omits the most obvious exclusion means because it's not an exclusion then even if somebody shaves on ervyond if you're not allowed to shave on halamite otherwise if you'd be allowed to why didn't the missional list the obvious exclusive the mission listed the guy who got out of jail the guy got out of prison the guy who came from Medina the guy who mattered what about the guy who shaved on air yumptive like a normal human being so the fact that the mishnah did not list that exclusion means it's not an exclusion that taco if you even if you shave the Arabian you may not shave on halamoid and number two says the Torah another reason why you can't rely on Robina town imagine if a guy came in a halamite perfectly shaved what are people gonna say people are gonna say the guy said I know the guy is uh in in his powder room that he was he shaved air of I don't know what he shaved if it's marasayan so if somebody walks in on on halamayid shaved it's Maris to to walk in and shave on we don't know that he shaved on Arabian death for example did you ever lose the car keys I did and until you find them you can't do anything else especially if you need the car if you don't need your car but if you're missing something oh a bit better enough you lost your phone right imagine if you lost your phone ervington would you be able to do anything until you found your phone no the answer is no don't kid yourself so imagine a guy lost his phone and he couldn't achieve he's annoying us is he allowed to shave Uncle Mark discusses that not the phone but you know someone lost something and the gamara says no he cannot shame I but he was an honest that he couldn't shave everyone the answer is nobody knows that he lost his phone he couldn't he didn't have someone to tell anybody that he lost the phone so nobody knows that he lost his phone but the gamara says nobody knows it so it's Morris Hawaiian for him to shave on kalamai so by the same token says the Torah if somebody shaved aravyantif but nobody knows he shaved their vientif so for him to shave and therefore the Tor says we cannot rely on ravino tan even if someone shaved on aravyant if they cannot shave on halamite does anybody hold like robinotam no not the rambam not the Riff not the rush not the rajva not the ritzvah not Rashi nobody there is not a reason in the book that agrees to Rabino and in fact look back at number three the shogunaro writes black and white you cannot change even if you shaved on Arabian so it seemed pretty black and white as black and white as you'll ever get that even if you shaved on Arabian you cannot sit on color mine foreign you know in the olden days didn't have shavers so how would somebody shave with the cream right or the powder is like basically taking you know acid you open it like bit you open up a battery and you put on your face you know you take off the hair and sometimes you take off the face also but that's what he's a very powerful powder cream but it's the same Shyla it's not any more or less of an issue so at first another people was asked can you do this on halamite and he responded of course Matt only Rabbi no time matters it everybody else including asteret it would seem to be open and shot but then the night of Yehuda said to himself Rubino Tom was a big gun we know if a big man says something you have to try to understand why did he say it and says no idea you know what something hit me because it seems like everybody missed something in this again the gemara says why are you now to shave on because so you don't enter your a mess ask the noise of Yehuda the gemara should have said a much better answer you can't shave and holla because you're not allowed to do Malachi on whole life and according to many reasons why does it give us this like gazero we're worried you're going to enter yes the guys of Russia officials are coming because he's like Minnesota I'm doing Melaka says that's right it is a malacha but if a guy didn't shave an air of yamdiff so now comes the halamide the guy looks like uh he has a beard down to the floor you know he looks like uh a goat already I mean here's a nice beard if he didn't shave Arabian now it's the color mode so for him to shave on yantiff it's a Surah this is a serious we know you're allowed to do Malachi if you need to do them for example you're allowed to cook anything because it's you're allowed to drive your car to the store because this is so if a guy did not shave on aravyantif of course he could shave on halamite because there's a different reason he's not out of shape he's not a shame because but what if the guy did say there of Yom Tiff so if the guy did shiver of yamdev listen carefully then you don't have the Sara that you can't shave on kalamoid so you don't come into into a yamta as a mess because he didn't come into young to business because it's a malacha why because this guy since he shaved aravyantis he's basically shaven so he has a little stubble it looks good anyway it's not it's not a real need to shave that off so listen carefully so says tonight get this okay you got to think clearly did the guy either way you can't shame a holomite if you didn't shave on aravyantive so the guy has a big beard by the time halamoid comes so there's no malacha to shave it off because it's a real genuine need then you can shave for because of the isidra because we didn't want you to go into that state in the first place but if the guy did shave aravyantif so then we can't tell him not to shame on which is and don't say it's a Target because to shave off a little stubble is not a turkey so whether he shaved or whether he didn't shave you can shame foreign foreign why why do other shave but if you see the nervientev it's a Malachi to shave so now this is the Breakthrough you ready for this says if you shaved it's then you can shave because it's enough this is a breakthrough you know rabinota means that if you shaved on Arabian if you could shave on kalamide there is a halacha that even though you know let's say you have a guy who's poor and he needs to work to put food on the table he is allowed to work you know that it's another exception let's say a Shoemaker a tailor a barber who needs the hundred dollars he's gonna make that day to be able to pay the bills to put food on the table someone like that is allowed to do he could go to a Jewish Barber who's not doing well and that Jewish Barber could shave him because Apollo Ani is Allah Roberto Tom didn't mean anyone could shave him or he could shave himself he could shave the guy so listen carefully if the guy did not shave aravyant if he has no recourse because there's a Nissan but if the guy did shave and now the reason why he can't shave is because it's a legitimate malacha because his beard is not really that long now it's not really it's only been at sarak if he didn't shame it's really long but then that guy couldn't say because the regular but if the guy did shave and the only problem now is maloka you could go to a paell Ani you could go to a non-jewish worker and he could shave off your beard foreign it's my opinion that none of the reshinen understood Rabbi no time correctly they understand that you could just shave directly and therefore they argued on him but if all the resign them would have thought of mine they would have agreed to my shot and therefore says nobody argues on me no Thomas he could shave straight up if they would have realized what he meant is he could shave through a pilani they would have been masked him and therefore I feel that the following conclusion says he says therefore this individual who says this individual who has to go in front of Governors and officials and as a politician and his job requires him to be to to be presentable on a very high level he could go to a poor Jewish Barber on halamide who could shave his face without a problem I'll just read to you the conclusion of his chuva for deities so you could rely on the great Amor the iron Foundation of ravenotam and even though all the police came argumentam but my position is through a player on E they would all agree especially says another someone who has to go in front of princes and officers and politicians so for him it's a great Tsar to appear with um facial here and they're gonna mock him for somebody like this under the circumstances they would be allowed to shave ayode now you have to understand this is not really that great of a hectare for us because you know who exactly is this Polonia that we're gonna find you know the guy's gonna have a sign up he's you know a certified poor Barbara certified certified by the badats he's a certified payalani but it's already a little bit of an opening if you know somebody no you can't shave yourself that's what he's saying yeah some people bring the shaver to the barber so they know to be who this had to would not allow somebody to shave themselves or the only person who could do the malacha you can't shave yourself because it's a Malacca if you shave the Arabians if you can shave yourself no no big no because it's a malacha you can only do it through a payalani so Ken is a guy only only the end so how do you find someone else it's not really that practical I mean there are people you know who are Barbers who have a hard time making it if you could find someone that would be the hector of of uh again and not for anybody it has to be somebody who has a high ranking job in politics for him whatsoever why wouldn't you accuse a guy they allowed to play on why wouldn't okay so in the times so it could be you could use a guy just the reason why he says it happened to be in the times of Huda the did not know how to use the powder because they didn't they just use razors so it wasn't shy we'll see it's not really shy to use a guy today maybe it would be shank these a guy so that might be another option is a sack and the world was up in arms because for hundreds of years no yid shaved his beard and everybody was against tonight to the point where the hidayah brings down and it's quoted in the state found that you have it on your sheets and number nine the station brings down from Who quotes the hadat that the ikri had that says they were such a commotion and such a rush and people were so angry the rabbanim were so angry at the night that the noise that the hood at the end of his life changed his mind he was closer that is what's reported by the greyhadat however the statement says the night who never changed his mind because everybody knows there are many editions of the shout out the chuva that we just read is but posthumously it was published um by the sons of the many more and in Sim inside of Madura tinyana wrote another three chuvais endorsing his original plaque and says there is no doubt at the end of his life there's no way his kids would publish another three chubas after he died endorsing his his original sack so I want to share with you these three children which are some of the three most mysterious Chivas you will ever come across where they're not endorses this song and he says some pretty incredible things okay let us look in number seven so he got a letter and the questioner was really troubled that the noise would endorse the sack of Rabino time against all the poiskim how could you do such a thing oh the police can argue on Rubino Tom why would you uphold the second running time against all the reshine him especially the questioner asks you know in Our Generation all people need to do is hear that there's one Rabbi who once said you could do this oh and they'll be matter everything so it's not not even is this a good idea to let out of the you know let the cat out of the bag that you mattered even a a governor even somebody who works in politics to shavelani I mean if people get a hold of that then they're gonna take it to the nth degree and even if you hold that it's true why would you be Mafia Sim such a thing well says the night to be who though let me tell you something why should I not endorse I think robino town is correct says there's no favoritism over here there's no nepotism over here if I I'm a legitimate place like if I feel Robin is correct I will endorse the Sakura by no time I but and nobody agrees with him so here's where the Scottish comes in no wrong wrong the reason why nobody agrees with Robin is because nobody understood robinutan everybody you could shave straight out without a payolani and on that everybody disagrees that if you could shave straight out listen carefully if you could shave straight out then remember what the Taurus question was what was the tourist question are they no time the tourist question I mean the time is if you could shave straight out why didn't the mishna listed as one of the exceptions to the rule the guy who comes out of jail the guy who's let out of prison the guy who comes with Dino sayam says I'll answer that question because Robin didn't mean that if you shave on if you could shave a color mind he meant you could shave out your day of payalani and the mishnah didn't list that exception because the Mishra was only talking about cases that you could shave yourself but the mission wasn't talking about cases that you could shave ayude and the other question that they had in Albano town was it's Maris Hawaiian to shame on Coloma nobody knows you shaved Arabian well now it's not marathione because they're gonna see you're shaving through a Pieology and you're not shaving yourself so I answered all the questions on robinotan the only reason we shine the volume times they thought Robin that you could shave yourself if they would have known if they were as smart as me the courage to basically say that he got a better person than all the restrainers on the tour but he says that's what he meant he obviously meant that otherwise of course uh he never would have said that you could shave straight up otherwise the mission would have said it as an exception therefore says another people like this he makes this point a number of times he says if this is what abhinota means so then I agree to obey no time and all the reason I missed the boat and what channel Thomas And even if Rabino meant that you yourself could shave but wouldn't all the other we shine him agree that aliyade you could do it so even if that's not whereabino meant but it's a Heather that everybody should buy into I if I give my hetera then people are gonna take it and apply it to other cases look you know there's only so careful uh someone who teaches Torah has to be you can hide the truth out of fear that someone's gonna extrapolate it to in a ridiculous way well it says somebody who does something incredible okay get ready for this fasten your seatbelts the truth is let me tell you a story about 12 or 15 years ago someone came to me he worked in the government he dealt with officials and he needed a head there to shave a homemade I didn't want to tell him it's mutter because I now he doesn't say why so I just told him this year in your circumstances you could shave but just be aware you'll never be able to shave any other year and it doesn't apply to anyone else says I didn't want to tell him that I felt it was mother so I told him it was sha a one-time dispensation now don't make the mistake it says that I didn't tell him it was mother because I didn't want other people to hear about it and matter their cases I don't I'm not afraid it says if a rough feels something his mother he says it's mother and you know what's the expression that the chips fall where they May okay you see that's I need you guys fine however I had a secret reason why I didn't want to be my father say my Heather not because I was afraid people would extrapolate to other cases it's not that it was a food while the people hear that I said you could say people are going to shame on Shabbos no the reason why I listen to this the reason why I didn't want people to know you could shave alcohol is because many many you didn't shave every day with a razor but they're so backward how are they backward they shaved with a razor but they wouldn't shave them it's like Jews today they don't get married in the nine days but on the 10th day of Ave they'll marry a shiksa there's nothing wrong with marrying it seriously there's nothing wrong with mango good but not during the nine days we're not during the beginning of the month well not the end of the month I mean at the end of the month no people want to know I can't shave in the nine days that's not a problem people are backwards right people won't eat the Brooks but they'll steal from the government that's okay I it says they have a different Tyra they go by tyros lakshin and they're a tairo they have other money they have uh somebody else gave them a timer people have a warped sense of Allah and uh everything is a matter of uh you know culture and what they did in the Alta Haim and hi Mish sometimes not Hive sometimes it's bihaimish so people have to know what's Allah and what's says that you're a Ladish but I was afraid that if I would tell people they could shave on so what is this doing you know what it's doing they're gonna end up saving another four days a year with a razor so let people think you're now to shave alcohol this way at least they'll go four days a year or less of shaving with a razor success I wasn't because I was afraid what people would extrapolate to I wasn't part of the answer because I don't want people shaving with razors and then he says one of the most mysterious things you'll ever hear so I took my chuva and I put into my briefcase and I hit it and I did not publish it and then years later when I looked again at the chuva I said just the opposite since people shave every day with a razor it's a Mitzvah to tell them you're allowed to shave on why none of your business he says only I know the reason I'm not gonna tell anybody um even if you press me I'm not gonna take it now it happens to human nature whenever anybody says I have a reason and I'm not telling anyone and even if you press me I'm not gonna say it I guarantee you I can get it out of him because if he gave you that whole speech you know he wants you to get out of him but you know we're doing tonight if he says he's not gonna say he ain't gonna say and then Noah was never a magala the reason why he he was the first thing you hear what happened at first and that you didn't want to tell people about the Kula why not because he wanted to prevent people from using a razor on yomtith but then he said I have a secret reason that because people are using razors foreign so the question is huh then the next tuba somebody asked tonight and everybody asks you will say here's my receipt I guess you know you need to put in your hair like a little sign you know super cut by Pieology yeah so the next two nights he says like this let's let's get we're getting to the end here he says look obviously the questioner started challenging that because you said I already answered all my questions all your questions I can't rehash everything I it says another very important thing no you don't agree with me so don't shave a hell of mine I'm not saying it's a mitsar I'm just telling you the truth you're allowed to I do not impose my view on anybody else I could just tell you the truth I oh so then the rabbi somebody asked wait a second imagine if a rabbi would get up and show and say it's motor to do X Y and Z and somebody says until the Grabber why is it mutter I have a secret reason the guy will be out of there so fast nobody will go for that secret reason with this reasons are there what kind of crazy thing is it that you're being methirous in this Heather and you say you have a secret reason this is not you know this is not some kind of uh religion from the from the the West Indies this is Judas and it has to make sense what do you mean you have a secret reason so now if you said no you misunderstood me I don't have a secret reason why it's mother I told you why it's mother because if you shave their Aviance then the only reason you're not allowed to is she'll come into the regular vote for that you got around elements so you do it through a pilani so I have an obvious reason I didn't want to tell people about it because I didn't want them to use a razor and I decided to say it anyway for a secret Reason Not that the Hector has a secret reason the head there is an open reason I personally decided to tell people about it for a personal reason that's not basing a cool on a personal reason and by the way if you want to know what that personal reason is I'm not gonna tell you and then they know got another letter from Amsterdam one of the good who wrote a whole letter and said you know you're the myth is the greatest in the Generation by the way now was the tallest man in the generation his hands were double the size of anybody else's hand in the dark some sorry for rights that explains why no dude has double the size Shear you know it's the pesach's coming because I was in kabear now if you had a double Shear some Surfers says because he was double the size of anybody else he was a very tall person he had huge hands and therefore this would explain why he entered all the barber shops in Prague and he said by the way do not use a razor and you see nowadays Rabbi says something well let's discuss it first no no you didn't tell us the guy's like seven and a half feet tall his hands were very big are you sure he said yeah right now take you to say for Torah that you will never use a razor he went to every barber shop in Prague and he made them he writes in shubakov he made them take a note that no Barbers would use a razor that main reason he didn't agree with him was that according to the hector of the night to be who the then it should come out that a coyan and the base who shaved era of his mishmar should be allowed to shave during his mishmar and this this idea is not found anywhere nobody says that if a coin shaped heir of the Mishra could shave during the mishma you don't have to agree with me I did not ride my safer for any other rap on him I do not impose my will in any rap on him I wrote my safer for my tell me them who don't have the kayak to be my end to my level so I wrote it for them to accept the opinion of the rebbe but no other Rabbi has to accept my opinion and then rupshali uh May Amsterdam said you know what neither it's gonna be very difficult for you to be Mafia same in your opinion said I don't want to be Matthias in my opinion I don't need anybody to follow it and you think you're misunderstood you don't know you're mistaken and how great I am and then the uh then who this says like this then then he says something wild one second then it says like this that will show my Amsterdam said but don't you know that you know who argues the marami Rosenberg who's considered the ready of older we shine him he argues on Rabino Tam it says even greater but you misunderstood me I never said I'm possuming like Rabino Tam I'm just saying that we showing a misunderstood and if they would have understood a big time like I'm saying they all would have agreed with him ah and then the noise that says the real Clincher okay get a load of this says [Applause] um says an amazing thing I didn't want to be my first name the hector originally because there's so many people use a razor and if they find out you're allowed to shaving they're going to use a razor however listen carefully I already went into prague's barber shops and I closed down all the barber shops how because I told them they are not allowed to use a razor and I made them take a schwa that they will never use a razor but here is the problem says the night to be Huda the problem was that in Prague all the barber shops were closed on kalamide so what happened if all the barbershops were closed on call mode here's what the the nephew writes in Simon cloth why were the barber shops closing hallway because all the rest items say you can use a pilani on a holomite so what so who did the Jews go to they went to the gallium have no idea how to use the cream all use razors so that was a big problem for the Jews in Prague so in order to save the Jews of Prague from having their face shaved by razors of I had to mat I had to be my passing the header there you ladder shaved through a piolani this way the Jews could open up their barber shops and shave people to Allah but everywhere else in the world where the Jews themselves shave with a razor this Hector is going to cause trouble to people so really I should hide the Hat there because of all the other communities besides Prague says another year that I decided to be my fire cement because people use razors they need to know your lady why none of your business says really for Prague he needed to say so that the Jews open up their barber shops and this way the Jews avoid going to goyam who are going to raise her off their face but everywhere else in the world where the Jews are using razors anyways really it shouldn't be good to tell about mykula but bottom line is that I did and I Can't Tell You Why so you know everybody is like itching to know what is this secret reason of the night of why dafka he wanted people to know that you could go to a player might and get your face shaved now this is even outside of Prague where the pione is going to use a razor think about it is publicizing his Heather so that Jews could go to a point and have their face shaved with a razor it says I am going to be the Bala shinhara to reveal the secret of the night get ready for this says everybody knows it's an extra director to use a razor on the face for a man to use a razor on his face but the hair has to be a certain length it's only in Israel if the hearer is long enough that you could take it and bend it back to the root and therefore at first the noise didn't want to tell people you're allowed to shave Uncle annoyed because they people shave with the razor and they're going to be shaving extra four or five days a year with a razor but then he realized just the opposite it's better if they shave with the razor every day of Calamine why because if you shave every day of color mine with the razor then you just have a little stubble and it's only Mr drabonon and then when when yamta is over you only have two days growth and you use a razor it's vital only is to drop on because the hair is not long enough yet so says if somebody basically shaves every day of the year except for Shabbos or two days of yamtif they'll never violate an insert the rise of using a razor on the face great because if they use a razor alcohol mine they'll never violate an extra di rise of shaving hair with a razor so even though I'm being martial people in Instagram it's better this way it avoids people violating Israel these people yeah was using a razor outside yeah yeah but again back then you know The Barbers were not uh yeah so the noises of some surface the reason the noise was the first and Heather is he didn't mind that people use the razor on calamide why this way they're never going to be violating um the Israelites of shaving with a razor but says it was incorrect because we hold that even if the hair is long enough that you could grab it with your fingernails to use a razor as an extra dirisa and therefore if they're going to do it on my they're going to be very Ernesto daisa and therefore he should not have been Mafia in the Hector by the way once we're on the subject this is something I wanted to mention a long time and hopefully this gets out not only to the people here there are many from people who know that you're now to use a razor and they will never use a razor but I don't know why people don't know that even a scissor you cannot cut the payus close what do I mean means are two things there's the face the face a man cannot use a razor on it anywhere don't say it over here yeah over here now we don't know what the there are five locations on the face you can't use a razor we don't know exactly where they are and therefore we do not use a razor on the face anywhere I don't care what the barber tells you he knows where it is nobody knows you know how to use razor on your face but there's another halacha that this area the minimum from the bone and up over here you cannot cut even with the scissors very close to the skin some people like to have a nice look to make The Sideburns very short that's a machlikis over here if it's not long enough that you could grab it possibly and pull it back to the root you can't even cut it with the scissors even people who don't have pears right regular Bene Yeshiva benetara we don't use a razor anywhere here but we still keep sideburns whether it's to the bottom of the uh ear canal or a more lenient opinion is till the end of the Boon but above the bone you cannot have very close sideburns it has to be a certain length whether it's whether it's uh usually we say it's that to be able to bend it back to the to the root so you just have to be very careful you know even if people have um what's it called uh you know not the shaver part but the trimmer and they want to have nice looking sideburns you know people like to make it short you have to be careful it has to be there is a minimum length and this ISO that we're dealing with so okay that's something that you should be aware of sometimes people like to have a very short haircut no problem on the top on the side it has to be a strong line okay finally so bottom line is very nice another view that has these at least likely this man is that the Feinstein a remote Feinstein completely revolutionizes the chuva the the sugya Cesar of my show what were the two clashes early in the time listen very carefully it's very quick very simple the two pounds of being a time is number one if a beta time is correct that if you shave an air of yumps if you're allowed to shave on Yom tip then why didn't the missional listed as one of the exceptions the other question is Marisa Ayan was only back in the day where people even if they didn't have a beard shaved once a month once every two weeks once a week but in the hiliger country of America where most people go to work or many Jews many Orthodox Jews go to work they shave every single day so what are you gonna say if they shave alcohol because people don't know they shave their vyamtif the guy shaves every single day of his life why wouldn't somebody know you shavedith everybody knows the guy shoots every single day so there's no matter science I but if you only have a little bit we said it's a malacha and it's not such a sorry to shave remember the name of Judah said that if you shaved Arabia it's a Malachi and it's not a turkey that's enough when it was when it wasn't to remove stubble but in the helicop country of America there are many people who even if they have a little bit of stubble they don't feel they look good and for them it is foreign but but now this is a very important site and the other two things whenever you have a cooler you have to know two things is it a legitimate cooler and do I have a legitimate need it's not enough that there's a legitimate cooler yeah the legitimate need as well you need two things you need it has to be real and it has to be a real need so says I only dispense this Kula to someone who needs it very much or is very distressed meaning like this let's say a guy says well you know it's mother so I'm gonna do it no very much I'm not giving you the Kula you have to have Sarah got all or you have to be sarboicer and then Relisha says you have to be very distressed either like this either you have to have a very big need or you have to be very distressed you're very uncomfortable but then ramosha says but let's say a guy just wants to shave because he wants to look nice don't protest you know don't throw tomatoes at him don't think he is a lesser of a Jew but still very much says I wouldn't give such an individual akula so the bottom line is like this I would not recommend that anybody said you could yeah but he says he doesn't dispense this cooler only to somebody who really needs some so as a as a matter of practice Dominican College Israel is however if let's say you have a very important meeting again what kind of meeting business meeting you're gonna why do you have a business being like how much you're going to lose money so again if it's a or you're an act you're a Jewish activist and you're meeting with the mayor you're meeting with the governor and you you feel very uncomfortable then remote says and it's a legitimate header but just for the sake of it it's better not to have to be summer on it but if you see someone who does do not castigate him do not uh think lower of him but in general the men of Israel is not to shame a kolamide but if somebody has a need it's a good idea to ask a Shiloh and now you'll be informed that there is what to rely on have a great evening you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com