Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
this Torah class is brought to you by
Torah anytime.com
so the Mish for the question was why is
it when it comes to
she we do
say
or we
say And yet when it comes to we do not
say there
is I want to thank my friend
who brings out the answer to this
question
in
on deals with the question of the
parameters
of and
the it's only what
calls say what's the source of we learn
it out from sanin where you
need so for example if you have a bzen
of 23 and 13 say guilty and 10 say
innocent we follow the r because
it's but what if only 13 gather together
in the first place and they all say
guilty so do we say well even if another
10 would have come and all of them would
have said innocent it still would have
been guilty so the person's guilty no
you need to have everyone there and when
everyone is there
and you have Ro of that entity you
follow the RO and the is drawn after the
but it's not good enough to have a
majority by itself or let's say when it
comes to
minion you need 10 people so if seven
people didn't yet you could use another
three but if you just have seven people
who didn't DAV that would not be a
minion it has to be
rub of an entity that is present or for
example
the majority of theor sinned the
minority will also bring
the or if the majority of the is so that
will determine
the the of P or if you the majority of
theum the minority of the s that W ined
will be drawn along and are considered
as if it was so is establishing a rule a
parameter that the G of rub is not just
rub we would never say that oh as long
as you have
2666 in a mikah that's good enough it's
only when you have an entity that has to
be present and you have the majority of
that entity the rest of it gets drawn in
so let's see how this applies to
distinguish
between by and
K and the answer is explanation is
clear you need to drink a
a is a
Ras but once you have that Ras if you
drink Ro then the minority of that one
entity that is present will be drawn
along and it's
considered if you drink the majority of
the RAS that constitutes that is deemed
that you drank the
r of the from the entire entity that is
present because it has to be present in
one
entity but when it comes to
matah the Shir is a kazas that kazas
doesn't have to be in one entity you
could have a little piece here a little
piece there a little piece in another
place as long as in total you ate a
kazas so when you have a kazas in front
of you it's not there's no requirement
to have one entity of a kazas
present and
the requirement is to eat a kazas even
if it's a little piece in this room a
little piece that was in a different
room and a third piece in a different
room so since by the she Kaz there's no
established entity that the shear has to
be from as long as you have a she Kaz we
do not say rubba you see by a you can't
have one drop in this cup one drop in
that cup one drop in a third cup it has
to be in one entity once it has to be in
one entity that
entity is such that it creates this
phenomenon that if you have the majority
of it the minority gets pulled along
because it's part of that entity but
there's no
Hal requirement of one entity of kazas
kazas is the requisite sheer so you have
to eat and consume a kazas that's the
difference between Rus and kazas by Rus
is sufficient is because it's rub
it has to be in one
entity it's not eating an amount from
this entity that is the shear that has
to be consumed the din is learned out
from the way
the gives us the parameter of rub it's
not just rub it's
rub so if you have
2666 the Mikvah is p but if you have 40
one entity
then from that one entity that is
required
writes if the majority of it is not the
minority which is will be pulled along
and it would be aik wishing
everyone you've just experienced another
Torah class brought to you by Torah
anytime.com
