PARSHAS YISRO: THE MIZBEACH AND MY SHABBOS TABLE – WHAT’S THE CONNECTION?

in this week's par all the way at the end of the par second to last the says that it'ser to put metal on the you're G to make so the says build through metal even though the says how the ran explains is referring to any metal you make a a sword through metal but some any metal any metal the to make withal what's the reason why is iter to make a with metal so there's a few reasons reason number one the Mish already says the Mish says in mid that the was made a person is so really if a person sins he's supposed to get the sometimes to die but he could bring a carbon and and he could continue living so is created for a person to live longer and the medal the or so to speak any metal that's in the line of making a sword to kill somebody is is to put them together the metal that's together with that's that's reason number one why when you build a m the T says you not to use metal to chip the to cut the stones cuz you're not supposed to put together metal that's Mak with that's that's reason number one rash brings it right here Al Rashi brings another reason and Rashi says along these lines as well also that you can't put together an opposite like the says in it's opposite that the is here to make shom between CL the same idea CL a separation between when you bringus on it's makes between and sword is to fight is the opposite is the opposite of the sh to put them together so those are two reasons why the to put metal on the M whether to cut the M the stones you know put barel on the this we understand why because the is and also it comes out that it's only metal meaning to say is what's about let's say gold and silver that's not meant you don't make a sword out of gold and silver you could put on the MB or for the same matter any other way of cutting let's say you want to Chisel the stones of the through wood if that would be possible or let's say the shamber use the shmer you could it's only not metal because it's later there are other reasons in the thean Ezra says the reason why cut the stones of the M he says because what are you going to do with the leftover pieces of the M you're going to throw it out you can't have the stone going to the and then those little pieces those chips that are you not using from the stone are going to go into the garbage furthermore he says not only that not only it's going to go to the garbage it's actually going to go laar he says because try whatever they could to somehow use prove that their AAR works and they know good and well that the M the fire on the they knew good and well that the in the that's who all the happened so they figure they'll try they'll look after if there's any pieces left over from the they'll use that include in there says the Evan Ezra that you not let to use metal to cut because of the leftover pieces which is interesting it's not only metal says metal but you're right if you caught it a different way would also be the leftover pieces then what do they do with the leftover pieces what did you say what did they do with the leftover pieces go can't be thr out right so that's also the sh if that's the case anything you can't cut but T says you can't use metal to cut can't use metal to cut the r in says also along the lines of cutting not like what we said before mad metal but moread cutting because if you're going to cut the tus say pass ofus of having a stone you might come to to the stone so we don't want you to shape out a stone that's why it's user not M the metal putting metal on we don't want you shaping out a stone which is also you could shape it out also not with metal says this is with metal the first reasons we saw the m and Rashi says is because to put we saw some other reasons as well also D ran the ran says reason the reason why the T says is to put metal on the m and metal to say because metal represents asov what happened when asov lost the BR as told his father can you give me one and said as represents yeah there are those that don't make KES between six and seven because it's the Mas mad which is the masle of that's Ed that's which is so this it's also only a iser of of putting on metal clay clay you could put on only any metal says the same thing as well also he says that it's it's the of and that's why noal he brings a and represents and in the says says don't bring in into into the into the Mish bdash this is the why to put metal on the a little bit we're learning now in the morning where's unfortunately we don't have aash we don't have so it's not learning need to know that says these A Min it's a Min not to put to keep the knife on on the table during benching either you could take it off or you cover it like mentioned this morning today you find that they have such AA knife in a in a case you have to you you cover it you cover the knife why what's the reason why do you have to take off the knife cover the knife by benching so these two reasons the this is the who's the on his pish on the tour says two reasons reason number one is based off what we just said before we went through the reason why why put metal on the Miss we said before says these two the says right like we said before the there's a connection between a person's table to the if you do it right you eat say says that if you give food to poor people but says that there's a clear connection between a and a table a person eats on and a there's also another says I'm GNA go the says there a connection between table that eat on and that's why just like on the the says in this week's para you're not supposed to put metal on so too you're not supposed to put metal on not to put metal on so what's the shil should be the the whole time you now all to put metal on so the same the same the whole time only only metal I mean only only by benching says that this when is by benching just like the Shadows he brought carbonis and the carbonis was so too it's not just it's not the eating itself is giving F but says when you bench that's the connection benching giving that's the connection benching this is the first reason reason number one why the Min says the Min is to cover the knife is because and there is no metal this week's par so too on the as well a person's table also but like what we mentioned earlier it's only metal if somebody has dishes made out of silver wear made out of gold silver or for that matter wood or anything else you don't have to cover it remove it it's only metal ra points this out in a safer he speaks on he says that this reason only metal would be AER not anything else there's another reason in the that's also that's known there's another reason the says you know why you have to cover the knife brings from the quot it that there was once a person while benching and saying he was so bitar that he he took the knife and he poked himself in the stomach such a thing shouldn't happen again therefore you cover the knife it said from the hotka he asked that was then today is there anybody on such a Madre good that when he benches Al we should have even but M to M to poke himself so the K said the reason we have the btig is at least we should know that they used to be such a type of person the so when we bench during the week and we cover the knife and the reason why we cover the knife is because there used to be a person that was so bitar that he took the knife and he poked himself he stabbed himself we should know how we should know that there's such a concept how much a person should have on this is the second reason why a person should cover the knife says not to come to you cover a knife the this reason the this reason nothing to do with the m so then has nothing to do with metal technically it's really anything sharp any type of knife it's not only a knife the first reason it's connected to the so let's take a look in this week's para like we went through in the beginning of the year the says and is referring to barsel to metal if it's not metal you don't have to cover it if the person has a silver knife you don't have to cover it the second Reason Not de marul the grandfather of the says the third reason and he says the following so this second reason it's very clear why benching the first reason was a little bit why we asked before should be not da by Ben but the second reason it's good why da because by Bening if a person the third reason why to cover the knife it is also connected to benching because by benching in benching we're giving thanks to the of all the gave us we being Mas like he says that during you being you should have a knife on the table that's that's a little bit like what we mentioned earlier but that's a third reason why to cover the knife during benching this third reason it's also only a knife of barsel of metal of mat not any other knife because is only metal sure these are two reasons why to cover the knife brings another minut says no again to cover the knife but then says right there that you don't have to be but you don't have to cover the knife even though during the week yeah shabas not so the asked the brings the that says my second reason that a person shouldn't be B then should be no also he asks the reason of a person shouldn't be so then shabas also you should have to cover the knife though some want to say that a person's more he's not going to get to such a level but there should be no difference but the asks first reason also reason just like you can't put metal so to on a so why should there be a difference between shabas and the week the says based off had brings two reasons but say shabas you don't have to cover the knife why don't you have to cover the knife why we not that a person will be just like during the week concludes that that's the Min and we stay with the minut that even that shabas you don't have to cover the knife what happen to the fact that he's chavas that that would be a good you don't have to cover it it's good that that fact others want to be the is why shabas don't we have to cover the knife we have two reasons or actually three reasons and all the reasons are applicable on chabas also so you're right that would be a to say that this that the person came it's less applicable on chabas but let's see the reason that why shouldn't it be applicable in also be same the same and the EM is that the says the says there's no the says that also you're supposed to cover a knife that why should be a difference what's says that the Min is not to cover the knife on shabas why so on the second the reason of so the to say thatas a person's more not but on the first says you know why shabas they don't have the minut to cover a knife because and the Torah says if you're making the you shouldn't put you shouldn't you shouldn't build the says the building the is notas you don't have to cover the knife says along the lines because you have to understand is AD it's only when you build a it's really later also you know want to put metal on though they ask the sh of of a knife the knife didn't go on the M but a knife is not called it's only says that it's not applicable it's not applicable on chambas because he can't build a the says a little bit and the says you know why we cover the knife says the says that's the mic but you know why it's Aur to remember that when we're going to rebuild we should remember you not to use metal we don't build we don't need that it means when you cover the knife we're covering it not just it's it's part of the to remember but what's the sh the is also says you don't have to cover the knife what's about By Night by night also you're not B you don't build a b m just like there's no you don't build it l is not a time to build a bdash it's possible you can't build a b mdash by night so if you eat supper by night you wash by night you also shouldn't have to cover so one teror is a different [Music] makes up until now this whole morning we're talking about the which is the out that's what you you need to cut the stones the inside wasn't made out of stone so it says that the he and he says just like the had these four types of and use forus so too our our table is eight what are the eight BR two BR before the four BR during the suit of benching four bras three the right and one and then the two afterwards it's but interesting connects where is the connected just a second I want to hear just where's it connected says that these you asked what's this good smell but say the connection shabas is to the connection to that's the not to put metal that's and that's during the week shabas is different that's why so it's another reason why not shabas not during the week and night will be different there's another between Lila and chabas but the it's a nice I'm just going to say it Mish quickly but it's not M the only reason I want to say it is because it's clear that the is the minut that we covered that's not applicable shabas but night yes and the reason why shabas not cuz shabas is is not a time of Bion and by night is also not a time of Bion thep says is a between the the of shabas and the LA of by night he says by night if you build it's a whole he says by night if you build the by night it's posel you have to rebuild it it's shab do you know if you somebody builds shabas it's Aion to build on he want I don't want to go into that the time doesn't allow but Al makes between By Night by night and shabas which really this Stiers it should be the opposite should be the opposite by night you don't have to cover because it's you should have to cover you gra the C build because you're not to build on chabas the answers what's the between shabas that you you don't cover the knife and by night you do cover the KN both says the says but building a B you allow to build a bomber by night so therefore we cover them as we cover the knife by night even though it's but of a you can't build a also and you don't have to cover the whole the first part of the sh we spoke about to explain why these is to cut a stone with metal we said different reasons then we spoke about the that says to cover the knife why do you have to cover the knife on your table and we explained also why different reasons one more nuda to speak about is it only on your table is it n anywhere else the Das kosim brings from the B not to use a mza holder made out of metal why just like on the M you're not supposed to put metal because is to be the theal is to of a person says so therefore not to put that's a holder that's to be Mak a metal that's Mak he speaks about he has some questions the RAF says in per when the mission speaks about the M speaks about the holder of a mza a k and the ra says what type of holder a holder of Matas so seemingly you could one last thing and with this I conclude somebody asked kki is there in a to refrain from using medal on a sa where's it let's say the GLE around the sa to close it now it's mostly velcro but some of them have like a clip a metal clip so could you use a metal clip together with the y a y the pointer on the could the pointer be metal so you answer that it's better not to it's odd of not to use metal not to use metal the yah the holders for most of the I mean a lot of them are nice holder a nice yah the pointers are made out of silver you know it's it's uh gold silver as opposed to just metal but he says a have a wonderful shabas