0:00 / 0:00
Parshas Yisro: Kiddush - How We Can Testify About the Creation That We Didn't See
284 views
The Chasam Sofer Reveals Subscribe and hit the bell to see new videos!!! • Visit Rabbi Glatstein's site: https://www.rabbidg.com • Support & Sponsor: https://www.rabbidg.com/donate • Contact Rabbi Glatstein: https://www.rabbidg.com/contact • Order Rabbi Glatstein's Books: https://www.rabbidg.com/rabbi-glatstein-books Date This Shiur Was Given: 2/17/2017 #Rabbi #TorahClass #Shiur #LearnTorah #TorahStudy #Judaism #Jewish #Torah #RabbiDG #RabbiGlatstein #MachonMaggidHarakiah #Chumash #Parasha #Parsha #Parashat #Gemara #MishnaBerura #Mussar #Tefilla #Prayer
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
this tour class is brought to you by
torahanytime.com
okay a good
ride
the parisha of Martin Torah and sarsa
Deborah is and of course
one of the assassadores is the midst of
Shabbos and in the debris which chinaist
it says
well I'm sure we're all familiar with
the gemaram sakhem and we're also we're
so familiar with it and even bring a few
the last few words I figure you know by
heart it says
very good so those tours didn't make it
on the sheet but that's what the camera
says remember the day of Sabbath to
sanctify it become our darshans remember
it on wine this is a Makar for kidish
kiddish on Shabbos Isa now of course
Kumar says that's Friday night Shabbos
day is only durabanon
um that's what's called kidusharaba
kidusharabus
meaning the great Kiddush but it's
really very minor but the icker Kiddush
is Friday night and actually has
one of them is how much wine you have to
drink because we know
rice is much bigger than a drabanon so
you have to drink Roy previous so let's
say the rice is
4.34 ounces or so so you'd have to drink
uh
2.3 ounces but
further abundance is 3.3 ounces you only
have to drink 1.7 fine but Kiddush
Friday night is the rice
and we know that Kiddush Friday night
has two parts
one part is
and that part has about 35 words and
then before that you say
even though you've already said
after even though you've already said by
Hulu an inch minus right so it comes out
you're saying like Hulu three times and
there are reasons for that but
you should have a lot of Cabana during
Kadesh
and pihara Herbert
you should contemplate repentance
because the recitation
is testimonies
that God created heaven and earth the
Shabbos and restaurant Chavez so what
are you doing you're bearing testimony
but there's a problem because of
Russia's pastelitos so how could you
testify that God created the world if we
have a Vero Sarah and Sir Navarro's
render our personal Russia so our whole
testimony would be rendered invalid so
what do you do similar to if somebody is
given a kibo to be an aid at a condition
sometimes the Masada kadushan says
is not a real keyboard because you know
he's not doing anything he's not making
the marriage they eat them are making
the marriage so they really they really
do need to be mahara bachuva so so too
when I asked him to DNA that uh
one of my daughters went if he says I
will have to be safe so I have to go to
the medical people
no that ain't gonna help him if he's a
rusher the mixer ain't gonna help him no
he needs a lot more than the MC5
so but anyways
the rest is
therefore you should contemplate doing
chuma
this way you are fit to be our testimony
very interesting
that is very interesting now
the problem here is
well let's try to introduce in the
following way okay so you're saying
testimony
what are you saying testimony that that
God created the world
now the tour in our hayimakas
brings down a halacha the yes
standing now this is
you ever notice the minute gets to say
it's standing for what
happened
and the plastic says
they have to testify together
um
even though he's saying it's silence
is silent no it's not
comes first there's a toast in the
beginning of say fabricious parag base
hello
how do we know we say it's standing
lafisha who is
fine
well we'll see that soon
so certainly the evil that you're saying
at the end of davening is and that's how
we say it's standing
but the question is let's try to get
some
foreign
why does everybody say together
well so you only need two people so why
do you why does everyone say it together
so so just turn to your friend what's
the Indian of Singapore so the TA is
right something very interesting
because the the Taz the tour ended off
the tors say you say it together
okay
say it together well what if I dive in a
long essay and I'm left alone
and I have nobody to say it with
so it's the tour implies then you don't
say it so the town says
um that The Siege tour but
you could the Tor says you could say it
by yourself
ah
but says it has but if you're trying to
say edos
and you need more than one person to say
edos
says it has that if you're diving with
Adam minion you do not repeat
an individuals
and you need a whole it's not enough to
have two people you need a minion
you need a minion to save
color sparkle to test my guide to hainua
Sora
which is 10. so we'll have to see why
would you need a minion now the bottom
line is the mission Brook Haskins Friday
night you have to dab into an essay
quickly to finish to say with the whole
Seaboard you think somebody else no not
enough many people do I'm telling you
what you should do
is
I'm telling you what you should do that
you should try to damage from an essay
to finish with the seabor to say with a
minion
however and says it has and what if
yacht wants to say it he could say it
but you should realize he's not doing
anything all he's doing is took him an
attire
and then he gets somewhere next to them
just say if I pull it together
on Wednesday we give a anecdotal
evidence
if an individual wants to say it like
he should not behave in foreign
so one thing we see in the Taz is it
sounds like from the Taz
that you could say with another person
outside this but didn't it sound like
you should say with 10 people why would
that be
doesn't need 10 people okay right
yeah but you don't need an ADA you need
a does
so the Prima goddam says from this Taz
you see that he holds that it's somewhat
of
Sarah they need a minion to say it the
task holds you need a minion to say that
says
you should try to get a minion
like who should talk about this
amazing
like this we do the mission Brewer
brings it down Mr brings it down Mr
Brewer says look at number eight Mr Blue
says
and if you can't get a minion
at the very least
yeah
it's good
in other words the best thing right
correct not an absolute hip but if you
look in the beer Allah writes
that you should try to be the kindness
he says um you should make sure to dive
in quick to be able to finish with the
rest of the seabor to be able to stay
with the minion that's what says
um so you know yeah you're saying yeah
I'm making this up so I'll read it to
you
yeah sure Waits For You
be better
[Music]
[Applause]
um
foreign
[Laughter]
at the end and then the new Prince they
made it bold the Hamas Yamaha
look some people are not able to they
can't have him fast but you should try
to find
so here's the question
the question is that uh here
says that you should be mahara but why
because how could you say testimony if a
person's a Russia therefore you do chuva
before you give the testimony but here
we have this Taz that even in school you
should you need a minion and if you want
a minion at very least two people and if
you want to say it without two people
you should realize you're not doing
anything just kokori bataira so then
that's not like says that you're saying
you need two people at least
you need a Minion for kiddish or you
need two people for kids there's no such
maybe if you just talking about if you
didn't dive into my resin but so here
that he does telling you that he does
giving you advice he's saying you should
be my heart who's he talking to a guy
who doesn't have it with a minion but
everybody else doesn't have to he just
says you know he's just giving General
recommendation by the way the Prima
Gotham says according to this
let's take a poll who here sits through
the whole Kiddush
no I thought your father from radin yeah
no he stood through the whole Carriage
yeah anyone here sit at all during kids
no for the kiddies part sit oh everyone
here has what's going on
the Hello
nowadays everybody stand ah so the the
Prima God them says what kind of AE this
is it by yourself she never says I have
no idea why people are standing by hula
I stand for by Hulu and I sit for a
Kadesh that's what they do in yeshivas
but um
I'll pay that Rizal you stand up here
that reason you stand but Avada you know
that yamtif of course you have to sit
even even those who follow the Ariza you
have to sit for yantus
by night also remember
I can get involved that people can get
angry if you can get upset people are
very attached to what they do by killer
Schwab maybe if you stand for the
forfeit and then you sift the second
part is it a little bit of a visayan for
the second part that's beautiful it's
beautiful you know why it's beautiful
it's beautiful
it's also beautiful
so what we did was
we made our father switch we made our
grandfathers
but not everybody could do that
um but we'll talk about a different time
anyway whatever you do it's beautiful
it's all good but
um the based on what we're learning that
the reason to stand by Foreign
why would you stand
okay so that's a big question here the
hida implies that for Kiddush you should
um
for kiddos you should
because you can't convey this if you're
Russia what kind of ethos are you saying
so interesting ligamara says like this
even an individual who davins Arab
Shabbos needs to say
okay so here the gamara is saying that
if you dive in Arab Shabbos even by
yourself you need to save
um
so it's unclear which by Hulu he's
talking about but he says even if you
dive in on your own you need to say why
because if you say you become a partner
with God
he's from Massachusetts
so what's he talking about you need to
say how do you become a partner with God
imagine a guy he builds a skyscraper and
you afterwards you say some kind of a
little jingle and you say we're Partners
now you know I really appreciate your
partnership how do you become hear God
created the world and you said a three
second thing and you became God's
partner you know how do you get that how
do you work that out right what by
keeping Shabbos by not doing it but it
says all you need to do is say by Hulu
you can work that out that some guy he
does all the work and you say a jingle
and you become his partner you got
something going okay whatever level so
my chest is like this
it's not when God created the world it
also wasn't a big deal
Hashem
so all he did was also he said you know
oh God said it was a few words so says
the martial like this
oh you're mad
you're testifying
so Hari NASA should open my color
sparkle why he built the a do so without
your testimony nobody would know that he
made it
just like his activity was only with
speech
like the plastic says
you're right this is awesome so you
become his partner
why because even an individual can't
testify by himself
now normally the a dose of one
individual is not worth anything but
over here
you say because you're Amira and God's
Amira they join together so you become
partners
so one thing we see from the martial
is that even if you say it by yourself
you're still saying edos
right
so according to the martial despite the
fact that oh you're a loner in your
apartment that nobody's with you
nevertheless you are reciting testimony
contrary to the task the task says no in
the shul you better say with somebody
else and if you want to say it by
yourself you're only saying it the
martial learns there is a concept of
edus all by yourself
so that sort of defends uh that means
the Marsha is explaining an approach how
you could be saying even though you're
by yourself
the Muggin of rum says
as a a very interesting thing
and that is so uh so I'll ask you a
question what kind of ethos is it by
yourself
saying where do you get this thing you
need two people to say this you always
need to weigh them we need them we learn
out
monetary law needs two witnesses Arias
need two witnesses
all you need is one witness when you are
testifying that a Shabbos it's to create
an Israel so legabe is Sir one witness
is good enough
also
why do you need a minion According to
some
well look at the Prima Gardens
foreign
could be you do need to Witnesses at the
same time yeah
and this is like
because someone who desecrates the
Shabbos is high of Misa so
there are elements of Shabbos where are
just a certain other words
but in terms of the punishments of
Shabbos it's Dinesh
so there is some discussion here which
allows for the possibility of ethos even
by by yourself
it's interesting the safer uh
he uh brings down
which would would greatly uh assist us
that there is a concept of testimony
given by kirish as well he says
my brothers and my friends
you should understand
the great rectification that occurs the
Amira's parisha
it's only if you have in mind when you
say it is
to testify in God's Unity peace
to testify and to remember the creation
of the world
and you should testify this
Sada
a person needs to testify this testimony
with joy USA daliba with the desire of
the heart
to testify before the Creator
the day is
AIA goes out of his way to explain how
much cavana you need to have but the
language of the zahar is
that when you say kidos Friday night you
are having in mind that you're
testifying that God created heaven and
earth meaning exactly what assumed that
recommends that when a person say kill
this Friday night their mahara bachuva
so we asked but the TA says that in shul
you don't say it by yourself and if you
want to say that's only kukara but well
apparently the Zaire disagrees on Isaiah
says when you are testifying when you
are saying Kiddush you are testifying
that God created heaven and earth
interesting
the rambam
about whether you stand for
the ram mom doesn't say his opinion in
the anaphazaka but that we shine him
quote
in the safer harmonic of
Rabbi the ravan
he says
we say by who's
Hashem
foreign
so here we have evidence that the rambam
stood for why
because of edos
but the task says you need you need uh
two people for apparently the
rambam who often says even though the
Rama did not see the Zohar but he says
that are very much in sync with desire
there are a number of places where he
does that the ramam is saying that
Kiddush Friday night is an ethos and
therefore you stand for
quotes this in the bedroom asks why in
the world would he have to stand for
you need to Aid them for uh you need to
Aid them to say edos
so therefore says you don't have to
stand but according to what we're
learning what do you say one aid for
issue well no it's not it's not is Sir
but according to what we're learning
that there is a gather of edos even in
kiddish so since there's a gather of
even in kedush that's why the ramam
would say you should stand for so what
do you do with the task so the Tas
argues on why would the Tas then say
that if you dive in along
and if you do you only say it to Curry
bataira
doesn't that isn't that straight up
against
the Rambo yeah because you would say
it's not hate this yeah but the rambam
says it is so you can't argue on how
does the tazagi on the ram has a Tas are
you on the Zion so apparently the safer
tries to uh defend
the Tas that the Tas all the Tas means
is as follows
in the basement the way they were masaki
by Hulu is there they were a masaki and
you need a full-fledged into
and if you don't have a full-fledged Azo
II that's the only type of way this
you're allowed to give in shawl you need
an atheist of a Minion or at the very
least two and if you don't have that you
don't say or you could just say it as as
Korea vatara in the home they were
masaki in a different type of edos and
shul and excuse me the Avis at home is
the ethos of
of even an eight and there are 10 people
and there it's permitted to say
even as an individual
what would they say about nauseam if
Nash are alone they have a right
so but they're not Kosher later
so that they say by Hulu
um do women give
right or not so yeah do they say she's
saying
or is it just Corella Torah
yeah
they probably don't have the Civil War
maybe they leave the first spot out
so they according to the Taz is
[Music]
a field notion
but then it would come at that if
they're until Friday night they don't
say because there are 1080s of two that
they have they're not they're not um in
The Gather of either stuff too
so then it would come out they would
only say like Hulu and Kiddush and uh in
davening our adventures
[Music]
people who that would that if they do
say would that possible since they're
not exposure no because they're in a
different room
you don't know where the pastel
that's probably the least of our
problems about all the people giving the
but
um we have Crow from there also
okay
there's another gamara
the gamara says
Hulu
anyone who davins Friday night and says
the two Heavenly angels that accompany a
person
they put their hand on your head but I
remember they say Byram
your sins are removed
are atoned for
says the gamara if you say
everybody
so the question is
why do we need this
so the Elia rabbit says my uh
grandfather told me my high time um
we say that a demon again we tell them
to Mahaba chuva because of roshes
therefore the gemara says that it's not
the chat if you say that then the
malachim come and wipe off your sins
it's if you're about to save
and wipe away your sins so that you
should be caution
so this is very much in sync with
says you should be maharabachuva yeah
so I once heard from rev Miller and this
works very well whoever remember Miller
said wait a second over here yeah
he writes in his book sing you righteous
he says look how great the moment of
sing by Hulu is it's as great as Yom
Kippur it wipes away all your sin but
she says since we passed again only
wipes away your sins
could also only wipe away your sins if
you do chuva so he says you should take
before you say
so it comes out that before you say
and wipe away your sins and now your
cultural Edo so now you can give
testimony
why not yeah nothing was it's okay
what right
okay come and wipe away your sins and
then you say oh so you go then come and
wipers before that's what it sounds like
from uh yeah by the way the Marshall
also says
what I don't have that much time to do
that are you allowed to give either
Santa's yeah
okay yeah
he's crying by the way the Pharaoh
slimoy of radams he says on Patrick he
said say why did the malachem wipe away
your average
the same thing so if you didn't have era
and your pastors therefore you're
Michael all the Ave rice
so says
why does the gemara say they put their
hand on your head
what's your head got to do with that
well you know why they why they put your
their hands on their head so he says the
same idea that the thrashalama says
that since in order to do since in order
to say edos
um
and that's why the memory say you need
to be maharajuva so that you should be
all right and we know what how do you do
chuva the gemara says if a woman says
um if a man says to women I will marry
you on condition that I am now we know
this guy is a convicted felon we know
this guy is a wrote
in the world
maybe he did maybe the chuva we're
standing here we tied up his arms and
the guy you know the guy is saying you
know uh every hour every nibble in the
world maybe maybe the chuva shama here
maybe he thought doing Shiva so we see
to do chuva it's all in the head so
Malachi has put their hand on your head
on their head indicating that this
individual
is here so I once asked for Miller where
that where the heart is
the lathe when the tar says lathe it
means the brain yeah
the cardiac area is over here the tower
refers to the head as the heart
so he says
okay so here's the big question here's
the million dollar question
so I call you to testify say I want you
to testify that George Washington
chopped down the cherry tree so yeah I
hereby affirm that I saw George
Washington here hell there's one problem
you came for 250 years after George
Washington on the world he's supposed to
testify that he uh
what kind of testimony is that you can't
testify about uh about hearsay uh
information you can only test on
something you saw so here by when we say
we're supposed to be testifying that
what the Hashem created heaven and earth
one problem you want to say I believe it
you want to say I have evidence but you
know how do you testify that you saw it
foreign
ER okay very nice
Shabbos
I didn't say no
um them
Triumph when we left the timer
we saw with our eyes
that he's the Creator who
he's the one who could do what he wants
he has the ability
Through The Exodus of Egypt we became
witnesses to the creation of the world
you ever notice that in Kiddush we say
will make up your mind you know people
are so tired by the time they said they
forgot that three seconds ago they said
but which one it is it is
sometime so I want to bring to your
attention what it says in the asserts in
this week's as opposed to invest in this
week's passion it says keep Shabbos why
is
young man is
no it doesn't say that
it says what
he says
that's what it says in this week's
fashion keep Shabbos why because God
created heaven and earth and in the Luke
it says keep Shabbos why
it says
so in the second the voice that says
keep Shabbos to remember that Hashem
took his animatron so the rambam in the
morning
are bothered about this contradiction
what's the reason for Shabbos
so the morning says like this you have
it on your sheet
that Hashem says
why to remember that some created the
world in six days
to remember that we were servants
so how is Shabbos by the way how does
Shabbos remind us that we were servants
in matrium
that's right because
in mitzrayim we worked all day long and
we had no day of rest
so now that we have a day of rest we
remember that what are we resting from
were we resting from the malacha of
Shabbos
so again the rambam says
it remembers that God created the world
but it also reminds us that we have a
day of rest and we're no longer in
servitude
thank you
and the Ramba the ramban says as follows
the Ramadan says
this is still the realm I'm talking
Shabbos has two parts to it to believe
that Hashem created the world
and to remember that we're his servants
says ramban what's the realm I'm talking
about
when we rest and not do we don't do
malacha how does that remind us of
utisma Triumph
we were never imagined in what way does
resting on childish remind us of Italian
however says the ramban
when we rest from work we're reminded
that God created the world in six days
and he rested on the seventh day
the meaning is like this
is
when God took us out of assignment
demonstrated there was a God who
proceeded
the world
he innovated the world he has ability
vehicle
and he has power Al King America
therefore the tar says like this
if you have any doubts about Shabbos
which prove that God
has three abilities in other words
testimony that God created the world is
first of all testimony that the creation
acts in the hello that he innovated it
that he has desire and to do what he
wants and he has the ability
so if you have any questions about that
tisgarh
then you should remember that God took
you out of Egypt and that will serve as
proof that he created the world because
you'd see us with time demonstrated that
God stepped in
and was able to control all the forces
of nature the ramban writes at the end
of parsha's boy that the Midstream some
of them did not believe that that there
was a creation some of them believed
there was a creation and God doesn't
have yadiya some of them believe that
God has idea but he does not have
yahuilas
showed that if God could take all the
forces of nature and bring them back to
to Oblivion destroy them change them
override them supersede them that
demonstrates that demonstrates God's
therefore says that Shabbos is because
try and both demonstrate the same
phenomenon so Shabbos exactly it says
he must how was he able to do how could
God override the whole system
that's clear evidence he created the
system only somebody
who who has the ability to make such a
system could supersede it and override
it that's why
it says
interesting that's rahama writes
in patches for era
practice
and the morale speaks about this and the
previous
that parody did not believe in creation
of the world and more specifically the
Asura mama
what was the first member of creation
voracious
so God said says you don't believe I
control races
then all your firstborn are gonna die
you don't believe in the first Amira of
of creation Maca number 10 your
firstborn will die what's the second
Amira Maliki are you don't believe that
I create the light we'll turn the lights
off
number three and the malfarsham go
through that the 10 makkais were
basically a recreation of the world
demonstrating God's absolute control
over those 10 manifestations of his
abilities
so in effect testimony which our
ancestors did see and there's a concept
that we were all there
that is you have to say more than
circumstantial evidence that God created
the world but that's considered atem
where like the navi says you are my
Witnesses so says the ramban and this is
what means we are able to give testimony
on the creation of the world
based on the fact that um Shabbos is not
only serious but it's also we'd see us
this time so then it comes out that
there are two levels of testimony given
there's a level of testimony in the shul
which should be done with the minion at
the very least two people and according
to the Taz if you don't have two people
then you don't say it or you just say it
but there's another dimension of
testimony that we give in Kiddush which
even though not everybody agrees to the
abujaham questions it and the Prima
Gotham questions it but the um says one
should be Mahaba chuva even in
and the source of it is the zayar and
even the ramam says there's an immune to
stand for by who so apparently there's
another level of testimony that is given
a level
and by doing this first of all we get
the benefit
put their hands on our heads and uh if
we gave adus with a minion ensure yeah
and why do we have to give eight US 20
minutes later
the answer is sometimes you know I come
home much longer than 20 minutes later
until everybody you know finished it
takes an hour later who could remember
by the time you get home no but really
why do you need
sounds like there's ethos as uh one
gathers of the sibor and one is
apparently both are needed
her
you've just experienced another Torah
class brought to you by torahanytime.com