Parshas Toldos - Hakrovas Korban Pesach on Shabbos and its impact on the Seder after the Churban

in this week's par par told us we find the BR that gave Yakov asked asov to go bring him food Rifka benus knew about it and called in Yakov and said I have food for you to take to your father what should you prepare for your fathers go here to so Rashi quoting the med so the question ised by when he prepared three cuz to give each one of them a tongue but over here why why was two necessary you know why it was necessary to have two because it was P one for the carbon p and one for the Caron Rashi how Rashi brings it Rashi says is one for the carbon PES that he actually brought a on the side say that it's he didn't actually bring a carbon P many different reasons we're not going to go into it back upon him was a was and the same was also that's what we do also B MD we also do a where do we do a on the we have a aav even though we're going to be focusing today's she on this this medish that was car and the car P it's to note that in bringing the Min to have a an what's the M the source to have the Apple you dip the apple on R is this week's the says that said when he smelled when when walked in I didn't find that it's an app that this story happened with rash interesting that's a different M or or maybe it's I think the that speaks about this morning we're going to focus on that it was LE and and two two I would like Focus today being that this year fools out on Sunday these many to go through I want to focus today on the two carbas and what it makes for us and we'll begin very simple the mishna says that the carbona was not brought on a year like this year you should be should be built it's going to come P we're not going to bring a was not brought the of P there was two carbas who brought AR of p a carbon p and a carbon the carbona was not brought on ER it's not like thear explains there's no to bring comes out a number one at the end of in the we say the explains what's is referring to the car that's why he says the order should be because first you bring the carbon of and then afterwards you bring the carbon p r the Taz brings it the quotes this t r that a year like this year we should switch around to being like we just said the M says that you don't bring a car you don't bring a car so you shouldn't and because you didn't bring so you say but why don't you just take out you don't bring the ter is is referring to the carbus that you brought over y the first day PES was Sunday you brought carbon many different carbon we've learned over here in the brought referring to later and therefore there are those that hold the kessis holds not to switch it around because it's not it's not saying that now there for not we're not eating that we should be if that's the case this for next year and next year it's not going to be oh very good so that's maybe last year we should have been that next year we should be but the say technically it's that it's going to be once thees last that this year is going to be if no if if it's going to be a it will be we're not going to eat it's going to be however to say last year that this year we should eat because we're not going to bring it's that the when moves around we have we have a built-in calendar we know what's going to be for the next how many years but could always switch Yeah that's a good so the simple really is e that's the the other the other simple answer is is that even the carbon P you could eat enough of the carbon P that the last Gaz and that that's a really why did need two the whole was only that the says it's only brought which means it says if there's not enough meat you have a bunch of people on one car and you're only getting it say but if one person brings the whole car you don't need you have to figure out it should so the first as we said the first say and you switch you switch around and you say the next to speak about is a big if you don't bring a so what happens on the this if we're not going to be what happens on the what happens being that he's no we're doing we're putting on the for the car and the car and was that means you do not put a egg onto the this year you do not put egg because there was no another reason first of all ta says there's no reason to put it because you didn't bring but even more if you're going to put uh egg on the we might come to make a mistake and think that you brought so first says there's no reason there part no reason what are you making a you never BW on a you didn't bring a come out what would be the if this year we have a egg and when you look at the wait a second today wasab and so when the is going to be we're also going to bring when it's and it's not says we do not put on a the re argues and the re says no not to be and you keep on egg even a year like this year you keep it on ah he's going to be a like says that if he's going to be a a year like this year you might come to even at the let's say next year imagine next year is here sh area and you're going to say wait a second last year I had a egg on the to remember the it was shabas you come make the same mistake next year Al make a mistake in the come to bring and everyone else is not so you're going to realize right away you're not going to end bringing the car up it's not tell you can make a mistake in your backyard to take to some big every other you there is not bring you're not going to don't think the person is going to look around why am I the only one with two with with with two G or two two some every else only has one sheep and I have two he's realize something's wrong it's not nothing bringing it she you're saying it's even nicker so the msis is that you you mean a guy's walking with two so it's nicker maybe people are going to think he's helping somebody else bringing his Caron PES what say everybody make mistake everybody had a name but the should know going to be prepped okay so that says that says first I was trying to understand the m people yeah people walking you think everyone's it's a it's a very hectic day could you imagine a PES with thousands of people with carbas you walking with two helping somebody else out says that and they're not going to make a mistake so when you come so they have to have what's this carbon for mistake we don't bring a today so we don't have to be that's number one number two going to be there going to are going to be there to make sure that we don't make mistakes says that and therefore you don't have to be concerned to BR to put on to put an egg on the is not going to come out it's need more meat whatever it show up two so that we have an excessive amount there that will get you out of the problem of I just in Cas some else needs one some else cover so I'm going to bring I'm going to bring an EXT you shouldn't do it person we find I hear he might be I we make it that person should they going to make sure to put outar earlier everyone's going learn know right now we only know what to do in if everyone needs toly show up with no one's going to know the procedure they're not going to to teach everybody says that says Thea do keep the egg on the and tsus is very interesting tysus has another two reasons why to keep it and not to change first of all that if you're going to take off the egg not put a egg this year it's going to look as if the Z and the are actually an actual carbon making it real it's little to understand but you make if not this year we don't bring the you don't put it it's only you can keep the even there's no if you're not going to put on an egg this year next year is going to come you're also not going to put on keep it on keep it on so we have over here if a year like this year should you put the bay on or keep it off particularly this year it's not mentioned anywhere this I'm talking of not putting it on that's CLA the minut is you don't change CLA however tus ends off and T says that if you want to T keep it off it's it's okay is it's it's fine it's okay you don't a person go on to take off he went through the Su and he wants to you know he's excited about but Pas you don't take it off these a third so we have over here the the that you don't take that you take it off the that you keep it on the rush says he brings from the the and that you have to keep the egg on what's why he says like this he says even though the Mish says that there is no brought on chabas it just means that you didn't bring it on shabas however you brought the shabas you brought shabas and this will be about shabas so let's let's take this apart was brought a of shabas and the that's why you keep it on the car was brought did bring it and you don't switch around you brought what does it mean you brought it an air of shabas so they bring based off the gar the gamar speaks about that the car P should be we're have to go into the whole but clearly the that you should be able to eat the car PES P the next morning and the next night for two nights and one day you should be able to eat the says that you can't but just like you can eat so too the carbon the carbon P you should be able to eat also for three o two nights and one day carbon because he's the says you should eat it that you don't have the DHA being that you don't have the DHA of eating it by night you have you eat it you have it shabas shabas and shabas by day for three day for three two days and one night so was brought shabas being that it was brought of course you keep it on the you keep the EG th the I don't understand good you could eat but what did you gain what do you gain by bringing a what's two days and one night ER p shabas shabas and shabas by day okay very nice so what does it have to do with the it's what they say but what do you gain you don't gain anything we want to bring to be able to eat itas together with the car PES you can no longer eat it you have to finish it already shabas afternoon and if you don't gain anything you can bring as many carbas whatever you want on air of shabas you can bring SCH there nothing to do with the you you don't gain anything so p that the won't be the be on up until we went through about the why what you P maybe even like last year yeah even follow you finish I don't know an hour after so you're tired of few hours is prob not going to be enough sa but you can fin why can't you finish your car eat eat the on sh afternoon you eat your car pza 3 hours later supp and make want to feel at end of the day you could eat it earlier only want CU you want it to get you at the end of no no you can eat the whole you have two days of water CU you're leaving it over till the end I don't know I I don't know you're not supposed to eat because you're you're not supposed to eat a of p i don't understand what's the what you you're supposed to eat before to eat I don't know if to eat it afternoon R what do you gain bring and then what so R says no out Bring so before continuing I just want to bring out did a year like this year did we bring the a sh was yes or no wasn't brought on chabas that's a the question is if it brought if it was brought Friday and he says like this that is that when you have you bring a that whenever you bring it no matter when you bring it it's that day you could can't bring a carbon by night you bring it by day doesn't make a difference if you bring it at 7:00 in the morning or 2 3 in the afternoon you have that day the night and the next day would be the same thing you're bringing the Friday a day before Friday Friday night and chabas however being that is the the the not the to bring the carbon p is a p in the afternoon and it's but speaks about also is to bring it in the afternoon so like this if that's the case the time is to bring a then you count hours whenever night day doesn't make a difference when you bring the carbon however if the's a time went to bring the carbon the carbon P the says to bring it to bring it in the afternoon and the has the same time is like this if you're GNA bring the carbon ER of shabas in the afternoon even though the is a on shabas afternoon so that's when you're bringing it Friday that's not really Friday is just because the earliest you could but you're bringing it B I don't think because P that's when the time becomes shabas but the is is the next day so when you're bringing it Friday afternoon the is it's not that anytime during the day is's a time to bring it later in the afternoon if you you bring this carbon Friday afternoon so let's say you have three hours to that day then you have the whole night the whole day and then you still have another into the night R and were able to eat from that that you brought shabas you're able to eat it what say said days night it's not just three three three three not so much it's not really 100% comparison you bring an hour at the end of the day that's it's not a the still should give it just like two days in one night so he he should give it two nights in one day but this is this is like when the speaks about even though would be night day and night so we have over here so far from the two carbas that were brought we brought a and we brought a Caron so we said a year like this year the these no either there's no or like what we just said it was brought Friday but it's definitely a change either we didn't bring it or we brought it Friday we spoke about that could be not to put the B on the because we didn't bring and we also spoke about maybe changing the because he didn't bring just want to focus briefly there's not really a lot of time the carbon PES the carbon p p not pasas was clearly brought and was so was it business as usual regularly like a regular year or do was any changes the carbona was not brought the carbon P was was it brought like every other year or there were changes so the mishna says clearly there were changes anything that you needed you need to do on shabas was like the Mna says was on shabas however the to roast the carbon PES even though on a regular year the S was done on a p you could do it Le it'll delay a little bit they did it Le wasn't good so that's we could stop right here it's very clear whatever you needed to do on chabas he did on chabas and whatever you didn't need to do you didn't do Rashi says doesn't he be ready for the say so you could you'll prepare it so you say will start a little later and you're that prepared on shabas whatever you needed to do on chabas you did on chabas and whatever you didn't need to do on CHAS you didn't do was done on CHAS however the you could do it to Le Rashi says you know why the why can't you do by night so Rashi brings a POS a general by all that it has to be that it has to be has to be by day not by night so you can't bring up you can't it has to be by day the sh is the shagari among others ask why does Rashi have to go to the general PES of all that you can't do a by day by Night says clearly in that the car P was supposed to be brought so that's why what is rash saying because Kum in general the P the says you're supposed to bring the p so the shagas answers that rash is bringing could have yet been done by Night the only says what's about the could be could be could have been by Night the ter is in the General in bringing a carbon only by day not by night you couldn't have done as well you could not DOA however two things first of all it's not that considered that being right here on the mishna that says about that only butash says that it is considered but if it's considered Shas that's what Rashi brings why why it's because you can't do it by Night the Shila however is that tap the whole carbon P the T says you have to bring the Caron P when the Torah speaks sorry the Torah [Music] says but when the tah says bring a T says to bring the carbon PES when does the T say should bring the Caron PES but you doid bringing the carbon PES doesn't just mean means also so why do you have why does Rashi have to bring the general of allum that you can't do tapay that you have to bring the k p you have to bring the k p the whole car PES you have to bring by day you can't do Z by night so answers that being that the night afterwards continues from the day you would have a that you could you could you should be able to do Z by night that's why rash has to bring the P of the general Kum that you can't do you can't do a a z by night but the reflect rski on this very nice that you could still eat a it continues but it doesn't change the calendar day doesn't mean that it's still it's and the says you have to bring the car PES for your dollar but one thing he does say based off this he says like this the tour the tour brings that when do you make the mat for those that are know but the Torah says what do you do when it's you can't bake the mat on shabas so when do when you do it you do it was like that to make this when it's so the question is what do you gain by doing you know why we make because the is so was it was P now if you can't because it's it's shabas I don't know so do either don't do it or do it ER of shabas what's the Milo of Le based off this to bring a he still asks doesn't change it to make it but that's what he says the just to conclude what we said over here is like this this year clearly you don't bring it on chabas maybe it's brought a of chabas and then we saw m might make some changes for us if you take off the from the if you change the the carbon PES was definitely brought and the car PES that was brought had some changes anything that you didn't have to be was not just to conclude year on this that we see that brought either the this week's on the in the BR he says like what the says that it was LE says if you take a look in the BR the gave he says dog he says why dog dog is because and because drink that's why in the is based off p and the go says the go on his P he says by the what's he says that this that yov brought to that's that we got the and this week's para so we end off to say that that's all to say that what CL has the is all from the that gave have a wonderful shabas