Parshas Tetzaveh: "Flying Shuls" - The Sanctity of the Beis HaK'nesses

this Tower class is brought to you by torahanytime.com so the parish begins speaking about the shamanzai Zach that was needed for the menorah the Hadlock so the question is this would seem to be completely out of place Tasha's chuma of course talks about the construction of the mishkan you have the building of the Orion the menorah the various Calem the pillars the crush him the adonim the ureas it's talking about the osule mikdash the construction of the Mishka parishes talks about the big day Kahuna right talks about the mid snafest and the ill the sinus the aphide the haishan and so forth so you have passions tumor talks about the Binion Amish gun fashion talks about the big day Kahuna the Indian of vehicle is not something needed for the Binion and it's not something needed for the big day Kahuna what was it it was part of the avoida so you know where this little parisha should be should be in safer by yukra what's it doing smack in between pascist chuma and pasture it's at a place yeah this is the question of in mahadura Riviera in the fourth edition of the khidushima of I have not yet been able to get my hands on this safer but nevertheless because I'm sorry for in the fourth edition I have the first edition I have the Third Edition I don't even know what happened to the second edition and this is from the fourth edition of In addition the Holy Soul I don't know so that's the Casual you have to go back to parashas Truman in Paris is chuma it lists whereas she calls the 13 tools the 13 ingredients necessary to build the mishkan the gold the silver the copper the blue wool the purple wool and so forth and then it says the following shemen Lamar oil for illumination so tysus asks that that's the canyon Valley atosis Oil oil was not a a ingredient it was not a building block of the mishkan why is Shem and Lamar on the list of things needed to build the Mishka I mean it doesn't talk about flour for the left upon him it doesn't talk about animals for the carbon Thomas it's not talking about things necessary for the avoida so why does it talk about Lamar was needed to light the menorah it's not an ingredient in making the mishkan it's an ingredient in the day-to-day service of the Mishka the following you can take a look and pass this chuma in the that's the kingdomi baliatosis says Texas the whole pastor's tomb is talking about the building of the mishkan yeah except for this plastic this is what this was light needed for Hashem uh says yes right you know like Motel Six we'll leave the light on for you right so so uh success that it's when a king entered a house what he goes into a dark house the final step in building any house is what gotta flick the lights on you gotta turn what good is the house without lights so therefore toaster says you know what the mark of the patish was you know what the final step in building the mishkan was yeah you have beams you have pillars you have furniture but you got to turn on the lights Shaman Lamar we're not talking about the oil for the menorah that's something else but the Monaro also provided another element and that element was the final step in building a house is you got to turn on the lights so if someone says Hashem doesn't need it but still it's an honor to Hashem in other words why do we have a light in the shore so therefore what is turning on the lights for now we understand the beginning of this week's Harsha after talking about all the various steps in building the mishkan and building the menorah and building the Orion and building the Shogun and building the crush him and the Yuri ice but what's the final step needed before we go into the next Indian a big day Kahuna Este Israel that's what it's doing over here that's why it's not invite because we're not bringing it in because of the avoida we're bringing it in because this is the final blow the final step we turn the lights on for right we left the lights on for you this is the final step before you're able to enter the base time mixer I've always say today we're going to speak about a topic that I've been thinking about for a while and that is we know that our shoes are uh that our shoes are a mix so you want to speak today a little bit about kadushas basaknessas okay we're not talking about now today talking by davening we want to know are you allowed to talk in a show no obviously not by davening here talking about are you allowed to go over to your friend and say in the show how you doing how's everything how's the family or not well you know how to do that we want to know because we know you're looking safe you have to fear the base of the time says applies even to assure not only is he violating the love of Russian he's also violating a Mitzvah of um you want to know what what are the laws of kadusha space agnesis are you allowed to drink in the show are you allowed to do your taxes in a show are you allowed to go into the shul if it's snowing outside to protect you from the snow what are the halachos of the shul we're going to talk about Shores and Transit shows moving shows flying and that's what we're going to speak about today flying shoes Okay so let's start with the Commandments foreign okay [Applause] don't joke around ain't no equipment you can eat they enjoy some hand you know how to drink you can't you know enjoy it in there you can't take a suntan let's say you have a sunroof and you're gonna take out your hammock to get you know direct sunlight in the short you can't do that in the show I'm sorry it's another time when it's better we'll see we're just starting we're just starting okay that's what we want to say straight out think about it doesn't qualify doesn't explain in Mattel Ibraham you can't uh you can't uh take a you know people they exercise every day what do you do in the winter they go to the mall right they go to these big mall and they walk if you have a big show you can walk up and down the aisle and the circle you cut but not in the show right when it's hot outside you can take refuge in the show um from the rain right you get off at a bus and now it's raining outside so now you want to go inside to keep dry now to do that you cannot eulogize an individual in a shawl avocado but you can learn and you're allowed you're allowed to uh you're allowed to learn and you're allowed to eulogize something that is relevant to the Tiba okay come on the the Bryce that continuese when are you're not allowed to do these things be Siobhan that's when the show is functioning but when the shul has fallen into this use and nobody diamonds there anymore and they're just you know waiting around until they sell the show now what do you do you leave it you let grass grow in the show don't uproot the grass you want to cause people pain you want to trouble people when they see weeds are growing in the show they're going to be very upset by that Sigma ask what are we talking about grass where did the grass come from what do you mean let grass grow like somebody planted grass in the shore what does it mean let grass grow who said anything about grass says the brat says the gemara the bride says missing some words and this is what it means to say You're supposed to sweep a shul The Sweep of shul you have to vacuum a shul you're supposed to sprinkle the Shoal with water right to keep the dust settled they have grass growing in the shore so it's a license when are you supposed to sweep a shul and sprinkle water on the shore so that grass doesn't grow but yeshuvan that's only when the shore is functioning but when a shul has fallen into this use don't sweep it don't water it let um we let grass grow in other words when a shawl when a shawl has fallen into this use we let grass grow in the show but if grass grows in ashore in a Shoal that has fallen into disease do not uproot the grass so that people will be troubled by it and Rashi says they'll put to their hearts to rebuild the show so basically bottom line you know how to use a show for any purpose other than to learn in tadavin you have to take care of the show but a show that's fallen into this use you sort of let it fall apart so that finally maybe the rich people will wake up and rebuild the shell that's the bottom line now here's the key ameravasi here's the key to the whole day you ready I'm ravasi so it's good to have a grass there yeah you're supposed to leave it in this use in other words you have an old school and now you know the window starts caving in don't fix it don't fix it you want the people to pay attention and rebuild the show okay the shuls in bovill are built with a stipulation now when we say bubble over here it doesn't just mean Babylonia it means Babylonia America South America North America South Dakota right everywhere in the world except for Arizona okay shulz and bubble are built out tonight now we have to understand what's the tonight they're built on tonight that probably that you could use the show for your own purposes but we have to see what this means no that's all iguana says they're built out of tonight what's the tonight doesn't say what the tonight is they're built on it tonight by the way let's look at Rashia number eight Rashi tells us what's the tonight shoes outside of Earth's Israel are built with a tonight that you could use them that you could eat in them that you could drink in them that you could go in them if it's raining you could use a show that's what Rashi says Schulz and barbell shulz and khusars are built with a tonight but after pecan mohen Carlos even though they're built with it tonight you can't be lightheaded in the show what's an example of being lightheaded who won last night what's an example of of being lightheaded oh my new EST in other words don't do your tax return no we're not talking about um we're not doing it who won last who won last night of course you know how to do in a show of course you now do that you're not even allowed to sit down and calculate your budget okay that you make calculations you need to leave dead bodies over on the shore because you did one thing wrong you have to do another thing wrong you think you have to leave over dead bodies it's not enough what you did by making is now you have to add insult to injury and do another thing wrong says Mitzvah in the end you're going to be punished that somebody never you're gonna have to use the shul as a place okay so this is the bottom line the gemara says you can't use a shul but in barbell you could use a show but make sure you're not noie Carlos okay that's what the gamara says now the question is why do they make a tonight on schulzenbauville and I don't know it's Israel what's the difference between a shul and Bob Eleanor to swallow the shores are sure what's the what's the difference what because it has kadusha Saras Israel you can't make it tonight it's it's not a different show because it's a narrative surround so look at Isis listen to this uh cestosis you know when a tonight helps because of using a shul only helps when a shul is no longer being used but so long as a shul is being used you can't eat you can't sleep you can't go in there you can't do anything in a show other than David and learn tonight doesn't help with the show as a regular show that's what she does the tonight only helps if the shoe nobody's diving in the show anymore okay so that's very strict that means you can't eat yourself shoot this in the show you can have your outside on the shore you can go into the Shoal if it's pouring outside that's okay all right this is it right how do I toaster says how do I know that a tonight doesn't help when it shows in use because the gemara says earlier that it was raining outside and the amarram did not want to enter the shul because it was raining only because learning needs a certain clarity says like this hear the amaran it's snowing outside they're learning gemara they don't want to go inside why not where do the amarram live they live in and you shall I am no they live they live in barbell and I thought shulz and Baba were built out tonight so why couldn't these amorim go into the shore to protect themselves the only Hector they could come up with was that they would not be able to learn as well outside says Titus why do I need that Heather why couldn't they use the Heather that schills and butter were built on tonight it must be that tonight only helps when the shul is no longer being used but so long as the shul is being used the tonight doesn't work that says shuls are built on tonight only helps when the shores destroyed so now the question is why does the tonight only help in Pavel and not in aretz Israel now you ready for this this is Whopper this is a Whopper is only helps will not have any kadusha anymore tonight that tonight doesn't help the caduce of shulz and narut Israel are eternal you hear what they're saying you ever hear such a big tradition in your life that is only as temporary kadusha so therefore play around with the kadusha you could say I stipulate that when nobody diamonds in the show anymore then I could enter because of the rain then I could eat in the show again yeah right number one that a tonight only helps when a shul is not being used when a show is being used tonight doesn't help and now Tyson supplies a reason for that what's the reason because the kadusha of Schulz and khudslarets are temporary are Eternal which has temporary caducea you could stipulate and say that when no one's diving in the show anymore then then uh the kadusha is I could use the show but now it's Israel where the show has Eternal kadusha then you cannot make anything on so I would ask antises where did Texas get this from who told Isis right like and Yeshiva Arabia used to say which birdie told Isis that when the Shia comes Schulz won't have kadusha anymore where does that come from why should that be I mean is there any Concept in kadusha at all that bigamar says right if you ever learned in suck the condition can't just dissipate ready get married after a month it's uh finished whoa how did it end no it just dissipated no such thing you if you thanked if you make something head fish you have to be pointed it doesn't just leave so where did toys just get that when mashiach comes scholes and won't have kadusha but we have to address that [Applause] good so then they will have katusha so we'll have to deal with that okay says then timer foreign ER said that Ravina wanted to plant in a Shoal even after it was destroyed and he didn't plant in the show he didn't why not but I thought tysus sushita is a SNY helps for shul and bavel for after it's destroyed says this does not help for something which is a bizayon and planting in a show is a bisaya now you ready for this you ready so if you would ask tices your initial you're unwrapping it's villain can you turn to the guy next to you and say oh how was yesterday how was the trip no it's an Israel says you can't even plant in a show Tyson says you can't even sit down and quietly write your budget so of course you can't talk to your friend what about after the show is destroyed could you answer you know you're going on one of these Jewish Heritage Tours and you're going into a show it hasn't been used in 500 years could you go over to a guy and say wow what a beautiful architecture maybe that you could say but could you say you know what are they serving in the hotel for supper of course not it's uh oh sure tonight does not help according to Tyson even when the Shoal is not being used I'm not sad it's not mine it's not my tire let's touch this yeah that's nice yeah it wasn't used in 50 years yeah yeah okay fine only helps when a shul is in disuse and even so it only helps for neutral purposes let's say it's snowing outside so according to Texas you know you could do if you have a shul that's not being used and it's snowing outside you could go into the show but make sure you don't ask your friend where he got his rubber from and I I would suggest that we're going to be extremely surprised as to what is the bottom line hello today I'm very surprised okay now let's deal with what rabbos was asking toaster says comes Schulz and Bubba will not have kadusha anymore so we asked where did toasters get this from so we can ask perhaps a bikinis question maybe a better question the gemara says on the next Elmo take a look at number three in the future the shoes the Bateman Russian in are going to be supplanted going to be uprooted and they're gonna fly to Earth Israel remember that that we all heard before right we've been hearing that since we're three years old that you got you have to be careful with the show because one day it's gonna fly up and all the shoes are gonna fly Terrace Israel fine what's the source of this we were all there but you know who else was there a lot of mountains came hard tavar came caramel came they all flew to harsinai at the time Hashem gave the Torah to Kalisa says if tavar and caramel how long did they come for for uh Kabal satara few hours they just made a guest appearance at harsinai they came to be macabo the Torah for a few hours and then what happened to them ultimately they were planted inert Israel soil base I can assess and a based on medrish that were Marvis Torah or the morsel cavachymer they're going to be uprooted and move to Earth Israel okay got the cover claimer it is caramel which only came to our C9 temporarily we're uprooted and one territory saw permanently so a shul and a base matters that you learned Tyra and certainly lost a lovely they're going to go on Earth as well by the way [Applause] foreign for anything just by the way we're gonna get to that person's cytosis that what is it whenever it says yeah and Lawrence is built out tonight you know what that's going to do for you that when nobody's using the Shoal and it's snowing outside you could go but you can't talk to your friend in it okay children off pastels like ptosis we'll have to see do we pass it like devices we'll see alternate side parking in the shore not in the show they made an announcement in the show okay and as people said it wasn't allowed it wasn't proper to say that however that should be the the worst thing that they say the discussion okay well so let's see so now to the market around anymore but the gamara says in Magilla the show is going to go there it's Israel so we see it's going to have kadusha take a look at number four he could this is a quote from the passengers that all the shores are going to fly the Earth Israel are you ready for this does the gemara say a Shaw's Gonna Fly to Otis Royal that's when the show is being used this is talking about when ashore is the qurbanon a shoe that is not being used is staying put it's not going to turn to Israel whatever needs an old show that nobody's using it's bad enough no one's using in America we have to schlep the turrets as well for now for numbers so therefore like this when when the gamara says Shores are going to fly to Earth Israel that's a show that's being used but toasters are talking about the qurbanon so since it's not going to go there it's Israel it's dark leimer the Hat toys is talking about shows that are in this used before Michelle comes they're not going to go there until very sad you know you drive down Coney Island Avenue and you see you know the base tifla that was once a based Fila yeah unfortunately it ain't going anywhere it's not when Michelle comes it's gonna stay that according to them again I'm wrong only a Shoal that's being used is going towards Israel That's the End Cinema then the Morgan Abram says let me tell you sir that what's the answer I don't like that may be like this you know what's going to go there it's Israel the building will go to aretz Israel but the real estate is gonna stay put so since the real estate is going to stay put when mashiach comes the ground that you're standing on won't have kadusha anymore what tices means that when Michelle comes Schulz won't have kadusha the Wolves will have kadusha the ceiling will have kadusha because that will fly to Earth's Israel but the ground won't have kadusha and therefore maybe that is why you can make a tonight says you know I don't like that answer because where do from where do we learn that shows are going to go to Earth as well what's the source it's a Cavachon caramel is real estate it's land if that land went Terrace Israel cavachon so therefore you can't say says that when the gemara says shuls are going to fly to Earth to Soul it's only the uh the bricks and not the land since we learned it out from heartaba okay on the rush and the Carmen asano says let's think for a moment what was the mugging of Rome's answer mug and everyone's answer is why are you allowed to make a smile on a shul because we're talking about a show that's not in use and a show that's not in use is it gonna go there it's Israel no it's not going strong says the cover in the sun now how could you say such a thing that means Texas holds that why are you allowed to go into a shoe that's not being used because that show eventually is not going to go to aretz Israel says the Covenant sign now how do you know don't isn't there halacha that if grass grows in a Shore that's not being used you shouldn't take it out why because you want to encourage people to rebuild it so how do you know when it's snowing outside that you could go into the shore that's not being used but aren't you hoping that it will be rebuilt and if it will be rebuilt it will go to aristotral so therefore says the Carmen Asana I don't accept the answer the magnav rum that toisius is saying that a Shoal that's not being used won't go to Earth Israel but you don't know that you don't know what's going to be you're hoping that some gear will pass by and say oh this was once a beautiful Shoal here here's a million dollars do over the show that's what you're hoping for so it says the carbon asano take a look on the fourth line after you close the mug and I've run the Carmen asano says the Kasha Shema yes why are we not concerned that maybe it will be built before mashiach comes like the gemara says that if Grass Grows don't uproot it because of agma snuffish says the Carmen asano I have a different shot entices you ready for this I feel that Shores will all go to Earth's Israel but you're not going to dive into them they're gonna go to Earth's Israel you but you think you're still going to dive in the same show that you dive in here you think yeah this is I'm writing my name on it and even mashiach comes you sit in my seat I'll kick you so hard right right and you'll have different museums this was you know the old show this route used to be used to give shirim and maybe he'll have Taurus all the tourists will still be in business inherits Israel they'll take tours but you're not gonna dive in there he says he says they're not going to have the caduceus Israel maybe if you know if plants grow on the shoe then the shore if I even Truman nicer but it's not going to have right so that's so this means that when mashiach comes shuls won't go too excuse me the shows won't have kadusha they'll be uprooted they'll go to aretz Israel but they'll just be eres Israel they won't be a basic classes okay this comes along with some Cipher in the tubers and like some Cipher wants to say that the answer that the mugging of rum didn't like he does like what was the answer that the magnav rum didn't like well your mom said maybe maybe when the gemara says the shows will go to Earth Israel I mean but the cargo will stay where it was yeah so what was the mug and everyone's cash on that what do you mean but the source that shows real estate so here too the real estate should move so some services think of of the following where was it located it was somewhere and it got up and it moved to harsinai and then it was planted permanently narcissism so we learned from there that anything that gets up and moves to be part of a daughter will eventually go to eritsuam be planted there permanently so now take a look at a basic necess when you build a basic classes on carcass the Dead character get up and move to that location to be part of that basic and SS that karka never moved in Iota in its whole life the bricks moved the bricks used to be located in uh New Jersey near Paramus and you went there you picked it up in the truck and you brought it to Kew Garden Hills so the bricks uprooted themselves to be part of a Shoal covers Israel but 73rd Avenue never moved never moved it is not going to be permanently supplanted song says you have to think about the cavacher was that anything that is medald and natal anything that moves from its place to go for a double tusha will ultimately be moved Israel so therefore the bricks the stones the windows which move to be part of a shul they will go down to but the cat the cart the land that a show was built on it didn't move here to be the land it was always the land so since it didn't move to be the land therefore it will not go to eritusra okay and therefore Tyson says that since the land of oshul will not have eternal caducea because the mashiach comes the the edifice will move but the character will lose its kadusha therefore you can make it tonight in let me tell you one more answer and all these answers you could still ask let's say in the mug in Abram's answer the mug and Abram says that a shul that is in disuse a show that's in disuse will not go to Arts Israel so what happens to the kadusha so Tyson says it leaves who says Elizabeth is learning that the tsuna is I'm making a stipulation that the caduceus should be temporary but still hard to understand because we have a principle kadushu doesn't just dissipate you can't make it tonight I want my condition to last for 30 days I want my heck dish to last for 30 days even in the answer of the carbon Asana what was the answer to Carmen Asana it's gonna go to Arts Israel and and lose its kadusha why will it lose its kadusha so listen this answers to me is um I like the best and it explains from where tysus knew that when mashiach comes the kadusha of the show will be removed take a look at this number seven in the second answer he says like this yeah listen to what he says he says above he says well the show's not going to go to Earth Israel now if all the shows go to Etc where is anybody gonna live you can have you know skyscrapers of shoes the shoes aren't going towards as well the caducea of the shul is gonna pick up and go direct Israel the spiritual quality of the shul will be removed from the shul and it will travel Terrace Israel says the same way order will travel to Arizona just like cloudy soul will Gathering but the show is gonna stay here it's gonna stay here so it's in other words the cover crime is explaining you know how toasters knows comes shoes are not going to have kadusha you know where Tyson's got it from he got it from the next summer that says when Michelle comes the shoes are going to go to aretz Israel which toast this understood to mean the caducea of the shows the shows won't have any kids anymore so spiritual exactly spiritual spiritual the spiritual quality of the children of the the shul they will go to eritus these are three possible explanations for the opinion of Titus again let's just get twice to sushita tonight only helps when a Shoal has fallen into this use why does it only help for a shulen bobel because toaster says when mashiach comes Schulz and barbell won't have kadush anymore so we asked what do you mean the gemara says the shoes are going to go to Earth's Israel the cash of the mug and Abrams is kasha what was the answer we gave we gave three answers number one the answer the mug in Abram that a soul that falls into this use ain't going anywhere we have the answer to the carbon asano Carmen asano's answer was they will go to aretz Israel but they will not have conditions they will only have caduceus by the way the company adds because the whole Kaba Khan is from when it comes to arist Israel is only gonna have Israel so which means when you make a cabochemer you can't learn out from more than the source so therefore the show will also only have because we have the answer the truth is some Cipher answers that the cabocheimer only works for something that uprooted itself to move to a show but the real estate of the show which was always there is not going gonna go there assistant and then you have the Cafe's explanation that only the Sparks of caduce are going to tell but bottom line is that a tonight only helps on the show is in this use when the show is being used you got to be very careful in the show so we're getting a little nervous because if we pass in like Texas we are in big trouble no big trouble yeah well is saying that tonight doesn't work while the show's been used you can't eat you can't drink you can't sleep what when your shoe is not in use it's a padlock on it nobody can get it no no no no no no no no no no no no no no no that's not the Quran you're not gonna say when when you lack the show at night if the show is it no no no means the show is not a functioning show anymore what's that then what do they do nothing nobody's here you know weddings no it's not being used nobody diamonds there no they can't even get a minion together whether it's locked or not it's they're no they're not the services everything's gone yeah it's gone yeah no why not because it's nothing there's nobody's having it there anymore so what you're mad let's see someone's married for 30 years but the husbands in one country the wife's in another country they're still married foreign what's the tonight is you could use a shawl you could sleep in a shovel if it's raining outside you could go in if it's snowing outside you could go in so the arzarua who agrees Tara she asks so why all these amaran they don't want to go into the show because of the snow [Music] they're only acting extra Pious they only want to date that was a certain zahiros they had but then you're allowed to go into a Shoal if it's raining outside so you know we're breathing a little easier now I understand now I could schmooze with my friends that's so Thai successful tonight only helps the qurbanon Rashi says even when it's being used we have a third cheetah the sheet of the ramban when ban says in a nutshell like Rashi that you're allowed to use the shul bishuban the tonight helps that you could use a sure when the show is being used but only under pressing circumstances for example you have aniam you want to feed Ghanaian nobody's house is big enough so where do you feed them in the shul I how are you allowed to use the shul because the shuls and Baba are built out tonight that if you really really really need to and you have no alternative and you have no choice you could use the shul for a neutral purpose to do your tax return you still can't do to schmooze with your friend you still can't do by the way even according to Rashi I just want to point out even according to Rashi who says that tonight helps when the show is being used you still can't do hashbrainers on the show and you certainly can't talk one second one second you certainly can't talk but the ramban agrees tarashi that you could use a show for eating only if it's a shazat pack take a look at the ramban Le FICA fashion band is good by the Iran in the guild adaptation days in Adelphia riff three versions if you need to feed the poor or you need a place you have homeless people they have nowhere to sleep mutter foreign foreign and even the corbanon you can't do whatever be Zion Rashi says the uh the most cool addict the tonight helps even when the show is being function is functioning but again not for a Dover be Zion not for asking your friend you know what happened last night and according to Tice and acquaintance around ban you're allowed to use a shul even when the show is functioning so now the question is who do we pass the mic to be passing like tysus so we pass in like ramban or do we pass them like Rashi foreign take a look look at number 11. in the Shopkins by to use it you're allowed to use the show when it's in this use is being used the tonight doesn't help no no are you allowed to do your tax return initial no are you allowed to go into a show because of the snow no yeah but if the show's not being used then you can yeah that can help me but this is a very that's how you passkins that's how you passkins tonight the show wants to do its finances in the show can't do it doesn't say anything so how old are we doing this today ah so what are we doing today it says it has says it has narrowly tourism the lady the Taz was the father-in-law yeah the the Taz was excuse me the son-in-laws so how's the sugar made so the back one set to the Taz I have a daughter who's as beautiful as the moon so the fastest I want to be in the college of levana fine I heard that from a Victor Miller okay so Taz says like this is nice um you're allowed to feed guests in the show who is that like this is like uh the Tas persons like ramban Spider-Man Hulu past the mic says there are many opinions tonight when the show is being used that tonight doesn't help and when the show has fallen into this use 89 helps that's shito one shita too wait I didn't have it on the sheet but the rush also agrees with Isis right okay so that's the first she's done number two Vegeta's Rashid mahani tonight Daddy tonight does not help even when the show is destroyed to use it if it's not a shout out right so says so we would say how could you go against the task is like those places it seems on the Tas in the beginning of semen we hold the Taz implies that in you could rely on the ramban that Yeshua mahani right and says that you could use that even according to rationality laughing the hito and joking why because even is who passes like the ramban that peshas you could eat in a shul why so that means if you have a hundred anium and nobody's house fits their name you can have them eat in the show huh could you do your tax return initial no could you could you talk to your friend about about nonsense no absolutely not absolutely no it was absolutely not so anything which is one second anything which is so that's not the reason the reason is because of Bashas you need to do something neutral okay then you're allowed to do it but according to the Tas of the mission Brewer are you allowed to eat shall shoot this initial absolutely not why you go home you go home and you go home why do you why do you all have to sit on this table what do you need there's no minion there's no Indian of a Minion for sure Feinstein according to the mission of bruh you cannot eat challenge of course not it's natural it's not for sure of course not what a tick on you know after for a yard sign to give to give you know schnapps his doors here when you cross the front yeah the sanctuary yeah the other part is just the you know whether the core weather the hallway of the show has it's a it's a different gloves okay we're talking about the actual show yeah eating foreign that someone who just learns an hour a day that's not considered uh again this is where we're up to right now according to the club when are you allowed to use a shul for something neutral so we're pretty much still in trouble right because you want to say that about now what happened foreign but not as much as you think says with mosha remotesha this question was raised um was asked to Amar shabai Hara finchas tights the river of Elizabeth New Jersey and the question was whether somebody like Elena he is blind and uh he can't go into show unless he has a seeing eye dog so as a seeing eye dog bringing a dog into a shul is that a bizarion for the show is that a neutral for sure is it permitted for somebody who cannot see without a door cannot function without a dog is he allowed to bring the dog into the show that's the question so Moshe says an amazing thing over here take a look at number 14. on the third he says Elizabeth he was trained the dog was trained to take him um the dog needs to be next to him or do we say it's to be Zion to bring the dog into the bay success if it would be obesion to bring the dog into the basement even Rashi would say you can't do it because Rashi says the tonight only helps for a neutral thing but not for a vision so says okay this is what about the boys are cleaning the show and they have a cross in his neck he's uh he's a you know that kind of bizarre tell him to uh put it in his shirt you know yeah maybe yeah yeah never say s with Maisha eating and drinking in the show does a tonight help to eat and drink in the show other amban and the round brings around ban that a tonight helps to eat in a shul if you need to feed anium and and put them to sleep over there says doesn't pass in like the ramban when I look on the top line and left hand side we have sugar honey tonight that's what we read at number 11. nevertheless since he brings the opinion of the hagoi sashri in the name of the ursarua that a tonight helps and the hagra brings Iran and then tonight helps for anybody well I fullheartedly endorse the sack of the time that we could even though the doesn't go like the ramban you could pass that that is foreign it seems to me that there are a lot of people that are being lenient even for saying that's a little bit of a mitzvah for example he says there's a big need to eat so make milk 10 minutes earlier but nevertheless so what do we see from here that the Minogue and quality throws to rely on the ramban that even when it's not mommy you're allowed to use a shul for a neutral purpose and we even make a Kiddush for enough or a bar mitzvah even though we will be very hard-pressed to find that it's actually a Mitzvah to make us such a Kiddush it's not clear there's a mitzo to make such a Kiddush now listen to this doesn't buy internet but Moshe says almost every shul makes a sudhas for a yard site a keyboard says there is no Mitzvah to make a keyboard by a yard site it's not it's completely sudas it's not an it's not an Indian it's not an Indian keyboard take on yard sides schnapps whatever you want to call it right whatever you want to call it says says emotion see them doing this don't tell me it's the Shah and don't tell me it's a mitzvah you know what the answer is that even though the rock Isis and the Taz is even more lenient like dramban but Mina Claudia thrall is to be even more lenient like Rashi wow but none of the earlier posts can pass in that way Cesar a very biggie sight that if you see that Claudius was a certain way that creates the psychology cake says it comes out that's the psychology is lenient like Rashi so what but maybe they're doing the wrong thing no if that's what Kalisto does if in every show in the world they make a Kiba they make a yard set they serve schnapped even though Cesar Moshe is that means they're naming on they're paskening Clarissa's past getting like people in my area just grow up oh no it's as well it's still in hot water yeah yeah that's right yeah and then when she goes on to prove that even by an Indian which is diarisa if cloudy sows a certain way that will create the halach and strongly by this Indian which is which is perhaps only my job oh we didn't get to that yet we didn't get today but yeah but there here's the thing Amina could only establish what the halacha is if there is such an opinion there is no opinion that there is no halachic opinion then there's Israel you're glad to do it so what they do um is irrelevant in other words minnow can't break the halacha Minogue in other words even though people say it's not true will do is if you have a viable reshine who holds a certain way so even though maybe the police can don't pass him that way if the Minogue is like that that's but if there is just Minogue that doesn't stand okay so in other words it's not what they do they do hopefully they do the right thing they do they do they eat and do everything in the show okay coming back to the sing Eye Dog is no different than eating and drinking and right it's not less than eating and drinking it's not a bisayon so since it's not a vision he says we we anyway hold like the ramban that it's nice we hold again we hold that they give us a good example exactly right this is a good student okay so Rabbi say bottom line is says Elisha bring the sing Eye dog into the Shoal is not any worse although I say it's not any worse than eating and drinking and sesame that if this if you don't let this person into the school the voices he'll never be able to sit down with the minion he'll never hear Chris satura we'll never hear Christian mcgillon certainly yum no Ram it's going to cause him tremendous agma snafes so therefore even like the coffee where we're only make electron band it would be mutter because it's no less than eating and drinking and even says you're allowed to eat and drink in a show okay but what about talking are you allowed to talk to your friend in a show based on everything we learned today it is absolutely really clear absolutely not you can't do it you can't do it so one minute one minute right so so Rabbi say if it comes out the the um said even that's how he concluded because the time said even according to Rashi a tonight doesn't help to sit down and write your budget so how could it so it doesn't help to sit and talk to your friend so what rationalization is there what harmless is there now before I give any rationalization I want to say something very important that this is for some reason not on our radar that there's a Mitzvah in the Tyra um you have to be afraid at the base stomachness now probably most people could understand if you go to the Kaiser probably many people could have the feeling you know what this is not a place to catch up and when you meet somebody this is you want to talk so you move you move you know I think people could have that hard gosh now and I think many people do have that high gotcha but for some reason in a shul it is something which is completely not on the radar that you can't just talk in the show it's clear this is I'm not telling you a Hummer over here according to uh it could be an Israel okay so right so this is something we should be aware of that there is something in the tire called the madashi tirau and it does not allow you to do certain things in the show so bottom line is is there any justification any rationalization so I saw something that's uh I think pretty reasonable by the way when he talks about he comes to the same conclusion that in uh that Frederica that um uh tonight does not help and he brings down here I have a safer on the safer time it's called he brings down over here that that the Prima Gotham says that even if you need to talk to somebody about parnosa right so this is not idle chatter you're looking for a job are you allowed to ask someone in a Shoal maybe have a job for me a lot of time says you can't do that you can't do that however so the Nissan says like this oh that a short conversation he says I'll read you the words a short conversation in other words good morning how are you hope you had a good day yesterday a short conversation is Mother he says that's considered the same way you're allowed to make a Mitzvah you're allowed to have a conversational mix in other words you want to have a short briefly you want to say good morning how are you hope all is good it's wonderful to see you that's mother and he says you could see even the racist who is a tremendously married about he ends off that if somebody who's an MRS comes to you and starts talking to you about their business you can answer them very briefly oh okay good uh you know business by me is also good what how you allowed to do that but so you're not a token or so the answer is something very brief just to keep the peace just to keep the you know the Friendship that's considered in Under the Umbrella of of uh Mitzvah and he says also you wanna you wanna show closeness to your friend you want to show friendship you want to ask and how's your family how the kids how their parents and so forth this you could sort of rationalize or or for real or reasonably explain that this is mitzvah Rabbi sang but it should cause a certain awareness that before you start talking in a short and I'm telling you this is not something that you're going to pick up after one one share because it's so far off the radar that it's hard it's hard to develop but this is something that a person really should try to develop and that is speaking in a show is not free reign there is there's a misconception oh there's a tonight in a show a tie in a shul only helps for eating and drinking it doesn't help for Taylor so you want to say but but this type of conversation is environment so wonderful that means you have to make when you when you talk in a show it should be it should be contemplated you want to show friendship it's not the place to start okay you know let's let's make a plan now how you know you have a partner in your work let's sit down now and we're going to talk about how we're going to get better business moving outside moving out okay so everybody said this is what we learned from uh the Indian of Joshua you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com