Parshas Terumah: Rav Asher Weiss Uncovers Two Dimensions of the Aron

this store class is brought to you by torahanytime.com as we prepare for parashas truma have already the plastic says she Tim she's making our own two and a half Amos one and a half almost wide yeah one and a half ammo is 12. says ramban why is the Torah saying via Su are they shall make an orange what do you mean they I mean they who made the all right should say viasu well says on the second line even though all the calim were made by an individual when it comes to the Orion all of klauso needs to participate in the making of the orange because it is the Supreme holy the shayesqueira the RN represents the Torah we won every year to have his name foreign foreign they all sat there chiseling at the Orange what does it mean they all should be busy she is either everyone should give some type of gold donation is but specifically one second so the Kasha is and this is my welcome number three secret maramaka I'm not telling you which man who says it it seems to be very difficult then why does it say that SI Pisa right in other words if everyone needs to have a Helicon either by an adava or helping with Salah a little bit or cavano then why is if in fact everyone needs to have a helic why is the Lush on Robin only by right now by the covering and not by the making of them okay let's let's see another item here in Paris when it talks about the badim it says something very interesting [Music] they put the bottom in the taboys outside to carry the all right now what's the purpose of the body say to carry Lauren right no the purpose of the bottom is to carry the orange but how could you say that you're now allowed to remove the badim even when you finish moving the Ari that means the purpose of the body we're not to carry the ri right though it's the only clue that um another one why but I don't need them that means the birds of the bottom are not to carry so Brazil has not to carry what's the thing in byakiel that they put the taboys in the arrow in to carry the arroy so again in number six we have a special hey is you weren't allowed to take the bottom out and to make matters worse day it says explicitly vayossum is now listen to this it says they put the bathroom in order and doesn't say the purpose of the bottom is to carry the all right another Kasha if in Paris look in carefully number four he put the bottom in the taboys that means batala put the the poles in the Orion foreign they put it in again who took them out that was whoever took them out was over and answer of Loya serum you can't I mean if it's in you can't put it in that means someone took it out you took it out no tomorrow [Music] they were they weren't said that either they helped but Salah or their mahaven but icker the child is the one who made it so I believe let's deal with the following question whoever gets this answer will get a prize what is the meaning of the Apostle boy and I will desire if he coveted it should save the Earth why in terms of the prophecy about the second base hamikdash does it say but it's missing a hey the answer is there are five differences between fun it's really seven the answer is Oro and capers and proven is one by the way who remembers the mnemonic we once made up to remember this I share with Three Olives remember that Asha with three olives [Music] okay so here's the prize whoever gets the answer I'm gonna give them money okay whoever gets Enzo get a dollar a dollar a dollar it's a color remember we said so so the um so the the which Navi said which Navi we learned that it's harder I had to say the answer quick before someone got it it's close you close whoever whoever um that the Muslim is going to allow you to build a second base a mcdush he'll desire it but I'm missing a hey there are five things that we're not in the second base of magnesium so the million dollar question is or the one dollar question is why was there no urine by the second base why don't they make a new Orion in the second base [Music] this is Akash of the rashash the mission of mission here why didn't they make another Orion in the second Mason yeah that's a big question why didn't they make an orange there was no now shrina you can't make you can't generate you know you can't make you can't make batteries this time we were applied to the company we're in the Tomb you need to know how to write the shame but why did they make an orange you can't make you're gonna have to you know put a fire there and say what kind of fire is this we made it no no that's but it is they were they weren't always yes okay good so good let's see the Manchester hold on to that hey right the 95th midst on the tower is used to say that when you remember 95 it's a reminisce to the Mitzvah making a mishkan because the mishkan is the 95th mitzvah okay the rambam in the third paragraph writes very explicitly how to make a menorah how to make us how to make a Kiara does not say a word how to make an orange foreign in other words we know the the Romans carried away all the Caleb excuse me the the Babylonians carried away the Calum so by guy and Cheney they did not have the kingdom of ice we shine they had to make new ones and the times again they had to make Nuance like it says they made a menorah varsal so they needed to know how to make it and says an amazing thing if they would have if the U.N would vote to allow the Jewish people to make a base on mcdosh we would make a base time make this before mashiach comes says like it says in the Mirage now the round mom happens to hold um I'll do it but it's not so clear the murderer says then the days will be sure they gave her shoes and they started to make a Mesa mcdosh and the capitals tomorrow right he wanted to be Mark of Cabanas and shall I am that means that you can make a way to make this as well so then why the avalhara intake of Kevin De nignus the Orion where the Lukas were hidden amen and the the the Lucas will not appear again like also Orange no other orange was ever made since the time Moses made it in the mid bar s ah says he's trying to give an answer he's giving an answer that the reason why they didn't make an iron is because there were no Lucas the Lucas will not appear until [Music] mashiach comes and therefore we will have no need to make an orange Ah that's what Roberto is mentioned before that the reason why the ramam doesn't tell us in other words why doesn't the ramam tell us how to make an r and the answer is we don't need to know him why because by his future on the head in our own because after bias we shine they didn't have Lucas so they didn't they didn't make an RI and we're not going to have the look until they stomach is rebuilt and therefore then at that time the ring will be revealed so we don't need to know how to make an orange but says I do not accept that answer why come back I'm talking because he says we know that our Torah does not rely on miracles in terms of relaying the hill and the midst of satara this is a very important principle in the ramban and safer by midvar that means really practically speaking it's a mitzvah for all generations to do what to make a an orange [Music] like the rambam says that one of the 613 mystery says when you carry the Orion carry it on your shoulders don't let it down the ramam writes one of the lavender the Terrors don't remove the baddam what do you mean we don't have an orange We're Not Gonna Be carrying our own we don't even have bad then we don't have an orange why is around them say one of the six thirteen mystery says don't remove the badim and carry the art on your shoulder the answer is the ramama's saying the ramam writes his Mitzvahs for a very practical um people who for whatever eventuality they need to make an iron they have to know they can't remove the bottom and they have to know they can't they they can't put it on the floor they have to carry on their shoulders so then why wouldn't the ramam say and describe how to make an orange he says I'm Cain yeah he says he says afterwards even though it's of no relevance not to remove badim and to carry the horn on your shoulders until mashiach comes because we don't have an arrow now the rambam rights what was what was relevant this man hamiktash and what will be Bismarck so why didn't the ramam right how to make an Orion that was uh relevant in the times of the first place for example in the times the first place something this what would have happened if the orange broke even though the iron was massive like him nevertheless we would have to make another one what would happen to Austin if the ring breaks you would have to make another one like in the times of Ali where the Arun was captured by the Philistines and it was there for seven months looking schmuel and if you look in the agodon schmuel that Shoal grabbed the Lucas from golias they must have made an Iron Man and in the times of Malachi mashiach what's going to happen if somebody Nick Sara you're gonna have to know how to build a new one so why doesn't the rambam write how to make an orange in fact the rambam Park Olive he describes how Moshe made the Shema Mishra even though never again was Shema Mishka ever made except for the ones that moisha made and that shown will exist forever like it says in Hungry Eyes like it says so why is the ramam telling me how to make it the answer is even though we have a half taka that the Shema will last forever we need to know what to do in the eventuality that we'll need to make it I but there will never be such an eventuality but the realman writes for a very practical situations even though we have a haftaha that will never need to do it the ramam still tells us how to do it so certainly the Orion where we don't have a haftah that the Arun will be around forever so then why wouldn't the rambam tell me how to make the Orion and he says don't say the Shema Mishra The Ramones telling me how to make because it's an afghamina because we're not allowed to make it in that image we can't make the RN in that image either and he's not concerned with the fact that that it's not going to be no idea because in in a practical World there might be no yes so now that tells it to me so tell them to the size of the word making noise tell me how to do he tells me how to make the menorah the VM the cafeteria what does he have against the orange okay [Music] all right yeah but even though by the minora do we buy some header show him an image of a fiery minora and ultimately moisture just threw the fire into Norman there was made the ramam still says how to make the menorah because are not limited by by Nissim well you should know that this why doesn't the rambam list had to make a an Orion the ramban himself asked this question the rambam the ramban in his hasagos on the rambam the ramban interestingly says why is a separate mitzvah Nations we're commanded to put bread on the table is and we're commanded to put the bread on the table and we're commanded to light the menorah in other words Raman is bothered why is there no mitzvah of making a why isn't that one of the 613 we're making the menorah making them as bayach and the rambam actually does not list making the menorah making the making the as a separate Mitzvah because the rambam in Mitzvah says they're all under the general umbrella of yasuli megdash in other words the rambam holds building the clay hammock Dash are part of the Mitzvah of building the mcdush itself the ramban says no they're not part the ramban says no they're not like menabayas but rather they're two Mitzvahs one is to build the mcdosh I wanted to build the calim technical you could be macro in a bias even though they're no Caleb but the rambam says that the reason why the Calum are not mentioned as a separate Mitzvah is because they're part of the midst of vasuli mikdash the rambando feels that the asias and the menorah is not a separate mitzvah for a different reason making the show Khan is necessary for the Mitzvah of and making the minoros necessary for the midst of Hadlock but says ramban my opinion is that making the Orange is a separamitza and don't say ramban says don't say like the Rama that through that it's not a separate Mitzvah and it's not ladai rice and it's only made for the lucris and then the bay there are no Luca is because the rambam himself counts the midst of carrying the the orange on your shoulder and the Mitzvah of not removing the baddam so just like the ram the rambam counts the midst of don't removing the bottom and carrying the Orion so too there should be a Mitzvah of making the RN and the ramban Really leaves it off as a Dava Kasha why does the rambam not mention the instructions of how to make the Orion it wasn't even there it wasn't even there in the Bible [Music] if he ever had to move it for whatever reason you couldn't put it on the floor on the rambam defends the rambam from the romance Kasha again they're on balance Kasha is why would a making an arrow and be a Mitzvah ladai rice so the Miguel assessor just points out that never in history was there ever need to make another Orange because the myth but salomade lasted forever it's hidden and when we return to the basement we'll have that all right so there's no Mitzvah to make an orange okay but now we're going to point out something very important something we already uh pointed out but we're just going to clarify yeah [Music] I don't know they're on Banfield that there are two independent missiles one is to build the Michigan and one is to to Clay avoida for some level it just means the same to the same extent that wasn't there I want to um draw your attention to the pasok by the oroin the nasato is that I will give you that's it fives took him later it says it already said that it's the exact same thing impossible that says basically you have the exact same admonition two times why do why do we need tube suck him guess who's bothered by this Rashi and Rashi says I don't know why the Torah repeats it is [Music] the Rashi says is coming to teach that when it's an aura and without a caporus you should put the edos in other words don't make the Orion cover it and then take off the cover and put in the uh the the lucrez but rather put in the look like and then put the cover on comes in my route he says I don't know why Rashi doesn't know I know repeat it there's a very important thing you can learn from here and you know why the Torah says it twice it's teaching you that without there's no Aaron shim like had the Torah not repeated it happened all right I would think it's still an orange without Lucas it says but nevertheless even though there's no room in between him there was a question so you would think by the Orion that even if they're not there's an orange so therefore the third repeats it a second time it's teaching me a second time they have to put the Lucas that if you don't have Lucas it's not an orange it's just a box and that's why says why didn't they make an orange because there's no point in making it all right because you're not making an R it's not an all right if you don't have Luca it's not an orange why does it say two times to teach that it's you don't have an orange yes it worked no it didn't light up but it was still a question it still had kadusha's big day Kahuna it's still no functionality yeah the functionality was that the coingada could do the avoida and he's not considering it may not fulfill the attacks but it still had kadusha's big dekuna that's the Mara marao says the reason why the Torah repeats two times put the aidos in the urine is to teach that without ethos it's not an orange says the same thing the same idea look at number 16. all the Calum they made in the mcdoshini except for the arrow and why is that is why the plastic says that it's not an orange until you put the Lucas and since there's no Aaron by the way the briskarov says the exact same thing that the reason why the Torah repeats the nasata is to teach not just it's a nice thing it's to tell me that without it's not an Orion no so the morale goes on to say Rashi knew that also so what's actually bother by Rashi is bothered by a different technical point in the pasok and Rashi adds it's adding something else besides the fact that that the market is adding the fact you can put the cover on then take it off and put in the Lucas you need to put the Lucas in immediately and then put the cover on right another one yeah Rashi also knew this the morale explains by the way they have the safer Avenue points brings Ariah to this idea that the whole purpose of the RN is for Lucha is looking number 18. there's a sector there's a safri this is in the world there's blessing in the world we find the same thing by the all right when the orange went to the house of he was blessed and the Safra makes the cavacher um which is that the whole world was made for the sadikim the world will be blessed so we see from this language that the only purpose of the RN is by the way the rashes explains that's why that's why they didn't make an origin he says maybe the reason I didn't make it is because it says you should put the edos and Aaron foreign and yet the private says there's no room I'm talking about shady and they made says the rashage may be because the Torah repeats it that teaches me that it's my agave in other words the same thing we're saying so I heard from rashiva of Besame they're based on this idea I just he just said it very briefly we're bringing out many sources of the Makar that the the morale and the rest of us they all point out that from the fact that the Torah repeats you have to put the Lucas and the array that means without luchos is not an orange right would anybody say [Music] that without left on my upon him it's not a shulkarn it's just you're not doing the avoidance no without the Christ it's not an all right so you could say like this remember regarding the first the second question look at number four it says in number four that is Allah and the purpose of the bottom was to carry the orange we asked no it's not purpose of the bottom not to carry because you couldn't take the bottom out even when when the orange didn't need to be carried and we also asked that they put the badim in the orange but if they didn't who took them out ah very good ready no pun intended oh they put the taboys in but they didn't put the Lucas in the maila it's not an orange it's not an orange what do you have about them for at that point in time the bottom are only to carry is only functional so Anne you could take them out because not an orange you can't take bathym out of an RI but without Lucas it's not an arrow so not know you could take them out foreign they put it in once they put in the Lukas they put in the bathroom now the purpose of the bottom is not to carry anymore it doesn't say to carry and that's how they got them out because they hadn't put in the Lucas because again based on this kadosh that an arrow and without look like it's not an orange look at number 20. what says to do to put it in so it's not it's not functional they're enigns they were hidden look at number 20. going from Jonas and sacks Suite that's why it's called was before they put them was like any other clean and there's no Easter to remove the bathroom the bad men were just functional day it was there's an Easter to remove the baddam thank you okay so let's just add one thing also that Rabbi Sax said over them of um ramasha wise that's why it's a prominent place that can hurt so strong he says a beautiful thing and with this will answer it's ramban says it says everyone should have a Helicon then why doesn't it say that sipoi should say why does it say pizza so it says like this two parts of the aura [Music] you have the outer and the inner golden box and the middle wooden box right now interestingly all the other km and make Dash were gold there's no wood the RN was the only one that had wood a wood box but it wasn't visible right it wasn't visible because it was a piece on both sides now you could really make the case they already had two purposes one was for the luchais and it could be that was the main purpose and without it it's not an all right but which boxes do you think was for the Tyra the gold or the wood the car the wood and the Raya is in parishes 8 Kevin number 21 when moshabino came down with the lucrez foreign the gold was that it was all besides the fact that the Orion was an orange it was also one of the clay hammocks and the climate just had to be gold so it says about your wise unbelievable which halak of the lucrez was for the Tyra the wood that's exactly why it says the word is for the Tyra the Tyra is we ASU everybody but now you have an inner box and an outer box that not everybody needs a helic in that that is just making it one of the Calum of the mixas so just like nobody had a helic in the menorah in the gold boxes on the inside on the outside so it comes out beautiful let's read number 22 and we'll call it a day is number one is [Music] so in other words one function of it was the function we've been harping on the whole Shearer that with Al Lucca is not all right it's one of the regular vessels So He suggests he passes the wooden box is in which housed and symbolized the Lucas and the Raya is impatius why didn't he make gold then Rabbi Sai down when he came down with the look like why didn't he make gold there's no Miss gun yet what do you need to be going for right there's no miscon right but I'm saying what's the line the shot is for the tarry only new way of it was what with a common denominator that had with the other Caleb it comes out it comes out beautiful [Music] everybody because everybody needs a look in the Torah but the other parts of the Orion were just what made it equal to all the other Calum and therefore by them it says that sipisa Yahoo you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by Tora anytime.com