Parshas Shemos: Where Was Moshe When Adam Ate From The Forbidden Fruit?

this Tower class is brought to you by torahanytime.com here in cougar Garden Hills New York safer shimais so there's a possuk that I was bothered by for quite some time plastic sounds like this pasta good Hashem I'm not a man of words you know what do you most uh people when you ask them to speak the most common Jewish refrain is I'm not a speaker now they would be served very well actually acting upon that and not speaking but people can help themselves you know you should know when somebody gets up to speak and they start off I'm not a speaker not yesterday not from the day before not even for the first time you spoke to your servant uh I'm heavy of mouth and heavy of tongue I know here I am and the question is Rabbi say what in the world is I'm not a speaker not now not yesterday not from the first time we spoke this is the first time they ever met this is their very first encounter this is the first time that rabanisham gives so I understand much of anyone wants to say I'm not a speaker but what does he mean I've haven't been a speaker from the first time we spoke this is the first time they spoke what's going on over here so um I mustered up the courage and I felt um the right person to ask this question was the penthouse the penthouse Friedman who's the Royce Bells so I actually mustered up the courage a number of years ago actually I'm looking here it was six years ago and I sent him an email I didn't know whether I'd get a response immediately I got the following response but Angeles I have the email over here I have written a beautiful member concerning all that you mentioned you could find it in likute for the year 771 I think you could get it at beagle eyes and bookstore 16th Avenue 44th Street 718-436-1165 okay so first of all big license gets free advertisement it's a good story agrada and the Republicans Friedman this was actually my first encounter with the srile pinchas and um I didn't have to go to Big Lots and I already had the safer but that's where this year started and that is what does my sharabino mean I was never a speaker not from the first time we spoke this was their first encounter question that's question number one question number two and here we have it on our sheet and number two where the Pinnacle asks this question Ayan alif and one of the reasons I couldn't find it is because actually it's on parashas vo era next question God I think he knows everything right so he knows what we're thinking he knows our abilities capabilities he knows what we're able to do and we're not able to do so if we banish some charge as much I've been with the mission of taking Claudius Adam it's rhyme devotion was aware that my shabin was not a speaker and even so he said you're the man for the job so what does mean I'm not a speaker God knows whether you're a speaker or not God knows whether he needs a speaker or not he told you to do something so say whatever you do you know if God tells you to do something why is my job you know trying to wiggle out of the job especially he's a speaker Kila what Good Morning America God doesn't know whether he's a speaker or not Hashem says me some hello Adam um who am I that I should go to that I should go to Parow and then I should take so we know when Hashem tells my Shabina to take class Adam is trying to say I'm not worthy for the job so listen to how Hashem persuades my shrabino to take them out of matraim don't worry when you take the people out of Egypt you'll be able to give them the Torah so much doesn't want to take the Jews out of mitzrayim but says if you take them Adam it's trium you'll give them the Torah oh give them the Torah fine I'll do it like so what exactly is the persuasion I'm saying I'll give you a two for one deal you see you're not only you don't only have to take down the Triumph but if you take the animal Triumph you're gonna get a free something a second item for 50 off so then maybe it's kadai to do it like how does Hashem persuade moisture to take that out of his time if he doesn't want to take them out of its rhyme he should say I don't care what free gimmicks I'm gonna get from taking them out of the time I don't want to take them out of matrium how is this a oh two for one says that a bargain I can't pass by and you would think you know if my shopping was claiming he's not a speaker and hashem's telling him you have two jobs to do which one of these two jobs would you think that Moshe should hesitate to accept because he's not a speaker leading them out of Egypt and splitting the Red Sea or giving them the Torah you would think if he has to teach them the Torah you know Hashem Hashem says take them at him and try him but she says I'm not a speaker Hashem says give them the Torah teach them Bible you shamis oh no problem you know why when it comes to taking them out of maths is um he doesn't want to take them Adam that's where I am thinks he's not worthy for the job and when it comes to giving the Torah moshabbin doesn't say that he's not a speaker you would think that to be able to teach the Toyota clown yourself for that you need to be a speaker why does my shabino refuse the mission to take Madame mitzrayim and not to give them the Torah these are not really questions that I'm letting you answer by the way but anyway yeah okay so then he should end there what's he telling them you don't have to do anything finished but Hashem seems to say if you take them Adam it's Ryan I'll let you give them the tire yeah presumably I mean why when you know when it comes to thinking that I'm trying that motionu and when it comes to giving the Torah Hashem Moshe just thought he's going to be handing them you know a gemara and that's it YouTube okay we'll see let's fast forward a little bit further um and we come to the episode of Miriam speaking lashinhara about moisha and Miriam and Aaron are talking and Miriam says who does this guy think he is to separate from his wife now that's something we have to look into we have to analyze why in fact in the history of Claudia so there's only one person who's given license to separate from their wife and that is authorized to separate from sipara in fact this is one of the three things that Hashem was agreed to it why was my shabano the only person who was allowed to separate from their spouse and if and in fact in fact um if his father wasn't supposed to do it and moshabbana was authorized to do it right so why was my shabano allowed to Hashem recommended Hashem endorsed my shabana's decision why is my chobano the only person who's allowed to do such a thing and in fact this was Allah of Miriam about Maisha no Miriam said Hashem speaks to me as well Aaron Hashem speaks to you as well Hashem never told us to separate from our spouse so who does my chavino think he is to separate from his spouse did God only speak to Maisha Allah he spoke to us as well listen so they have an accusation against you know the pasig actually says that they spoke about the Isha kushas now literally it means it seems to mean that they're criticizing motion for taking this woman who's in ishikuchus the facts are he never married Anisha kushas Rashi says it's uh darshan the same way if you look at acushas nobody kulayama like plagi that they're black so too no nobody would argue that the woman that moshabbin who married was beautiful right that's what it means that he took an ishakushas and the critique was not that he married her she says divorced sipara so they have an accusation against mosheim was acting arrogantly God speaks to me says Maryam God speaks to you Aaron you never separated from your husband from your wife I never separated from my husband who does moisha think he is so immediately the banishum comes down my chabano goes out Hashem speaks to Miriam and Aaron and he says no you know you're talking about how dare you speak to myself in my whole house he's trustworthy he's faithful right Hashem says um he's trustworthy he's not a thief how is the revolution addressing the taina of Miriam and Aaron they have a taina moisture the mosh is being about gaiva who is he to separate from his spouse should come along and say you know who Maisha is he's greater than you he has to be on call 24 hours a day to speak to me so therefore he has to separate from his wife why is evansham saying he's trustworthy he's faithful they didn't say my sharabino goes into the show when the pushka is full and he leaves and all of a sudden the push goes empty they didn't accuse me of stealing money from the pushka if they would have accused Marsha from stealing from the pushka then the Revenge them should come and say what are you talking about you're you're making up stories they're not accusing of dishonesty they're accusing him of who is he holier than us so the answer should be he's holier than us he's holier than you but they're not accusing of anything Unfaithful so why does foreign I think in your generation it's not a problem in the Young Generation come to shul you look carefully at people's mouths during davening they're sucking on candies they're chewing gum it's an absurdity you're not you know how to dive into something in your mouth came down with a candy in your mouth a gum in your mouth it's a bazaian for the Fila but people are addicted to eating people can't go even four minutes without eating and you know the gemara says the person can't go three days without eating a person couldn't survive without eating for even three days and we know that my chabano is the only person in history he goes up to harsinai was the one human being who so to speak Rose above the the human Frailty of requiring food why was that that moshabino had this ability how did he have this human uh the superiority that he did not need food how is that possible okay another interesting thing is and it was the sound of the sofa spoke we know that was different than all other navient yes they saw a vision they interpreted the vision and they were they spoke divinely inspired interpretation of the vision that they saw God did not say say this word say that word say it this way no they saw a vision and through their own personality they interpreted it through Nevada they were not given the precise words was not given an image to interpret God spoke straight out of his vocal cords that's why the Magid says from the God was heart of speech because in order for clauduso to recognize that it wasn't moisha talking but rather the Revenge from talking this way heavy of speech so that when he spoke to you and I was shooting the breeze with you he couldn't really speak clearly and when he taught toyra it came out it flowed out this indicated that it wasn't much of speaking it was God speaking out of his voice box why was my sharabino the one who was like to this phenomenon that God spoke out of his vocal cords no other Navi was how do we understand this um in a deeper way why and finally um the final question for now is let's oh let's go back to the original sin the primordial sin so other Marisha needs from the tree foreign but here's the problem Hashem said you're gonna die but why does everybody else have to die because Adam ate the Fig or he ate the grape or he ate the asteroid or he ate the grain doesn't the Torah says that Hashem does not punish children for the sins of their father so why do we need to suffer why do we have to go to work why do we have to endure the curse of mankind because Adam sinned I thought were not responsible for the sins of our parents that's the question so just to review Rabbi Sai number one what does mean I was never a man of words not from the first time that I spoke to God this is their first encounter number two God knows whether he's a man of speech or not why is trying to avoid the job number three why when it comes to taking them Adam is trying to get out of it but to give them the Torah myself no when do we start why is that a job is more game for why does Ubuntu respond to Miriam and Aaron because they see them on who that's not the question we're not questioning what should have been with honesty we're questioning why he was allowed to separate from his wife how could my shabinu number five how come a chabino go 40 days without eating number six why did revansham speak out of the voice box of moisturabeno and number seven why do we suffer today for the sins of other Marisa if you came here today you're very lucky because we're going to learn something which is um oh yeah from the Torah of the ramami Pano Ramana Azaria of Pano um of Pano lived from the year 1548 to 1628 so he lived 80 years and um in your honor I want to in order to get a little flavor for hudarama was I once did this I'm going to present you with a portrait of the ramami Pano courtesy of machon schwadran of Hebrew University you take this picture you could look at it you know a little pachad from this is Kim I want to tell you a little bit about the ramami Pano rebiones writes about him in the um crazy uplacy he says Azaria writes about him and similar in the ivitz what we'll come to that is so he was a talmud of ravisraal saruk in turn was a talmud of the arizal the he was a very wealthy man the ramami Pano and he lived in a palace however he spent all of his learning in one room which was not decorated which was kept very um plain and simple that's where he spent his entire life now he lived in Italy and he was very involved in publishing so the reviews of karoi sent him the folios of the kesep mishnah to publish so the ramami panda was the publisher of the cast of mishnah and he was a supporter of the great macabo the ramak who's the ramak the Moshe cordavero and actually cordero's famous safer Paradise remind him the ramami panel wrote a parish on it called the palak harimain now the um the ramak road a 16 volume work a major work perhaps it's Magnum over something called oriakar aryakar and when there are Mac passed away the ramami panel very much wanted to gain ownership over the aryakar so he needed to send money to the Widow of the ramak to get ownership and to have rights to the aryakar so the hidayah in his entry in the aryakar writes a fascinating thing he says was a very wealthy man had to send money to the Widow of the of the ramak he says there are bonus accepted he had to send something like 250 coins and some say a thousand coins to be able to purchase the rights of the aryakar and the only thing is he needed somebody to speak on his behalf so we actually have a record of the amount of money that ramami Pano had to pay the godollam and slas to be able to pay the almana of the ramami panel so here it says he had to pay 20 coins to um he had to pay 20 coins to the base UI safe Harry says like this he had she had to get he had to give lfs to be able to borrow the aryakar to be able to publish it and besides that he had to pay 20 gold coins through Joseph karoi 20 gold coins to the matzraef LA casef 10 coins to the auschak the Australia charged last apparently and in order to for them to go and speak to the the Widow of the ramak to gain access to the aryakar so it's very interesting the ramami Pano as we mentioned was also a talmud and then ultimately he became a Talman of the ramach through the ramak's Forum and at the end of his life he became one of the primary Disciples of rabisraal saruk so interesting the the ramami panel says you know when a person gives to Dhaka the person sometimes feels you know they're losing out they're giving away they're being khasar she has a very beautiful remnants he says the word sadaka if you use the system of atbash hey the dalid is a cuff the cuff is a dalid and the hay is a taddy so basically it's backward to Dhaka which indicates you know like the vowel term says whatever you give to tadaka you know eventually ultimately comes right back at you so now uh the ramami Pano had a customer he would be Miss by date he would go into seclusion and he literally his nashama would soar the heavens and he would have agabai who have to come and you know knock on the door that he should snap out of it push it that he doesn't leave this world so the the tradition is it's brought the safer because of ram that the ramadav and uh every day the Shamus would come one time there was a fire the shamish didn't show up and in fact the the soul of the romanipano did not return back to Islam has that now you're looking at this picture and uh the question is is this an authentic picture is this a real picture is this an actual portrait of the ramami Pano and we mentioned that there's a lot of controversy whether in fact this is the the portrait of the ramami Pano we have over here a fascinating chuva just to speak out a sec let me see if I have an actual chuva here should have it here shallots and he writes that the ramami Pano did not have a beard the mommy panel did not have a beard in fact says the bear asek the Italian mikubalem did not have beards because they hold that even though the zoyah speaks about the kabbalistic importance of having a beard that somehow the yud gimmel's hairs of the of the beard represent nevertheless that's only appropriate in arts Israel however says one should not have a beard that is the opinion of the South a sec and based on that he says and all the other Italian michupalem did not have a beard based on this line of reasoning that in one should not have a beard and says very sick um you know I uh that's why the ramami Pano in fact did not have a beard so comes the shout outs is very important figure in Jewish history he lived from 1685 to 1730 he established Yeshiva in Italy when I was in Livorno a few years ago they took us to the cemetery in Livorno and we didn't know who was there and we were to be at the cover of reviews which is sort of a hakatama to Lima hakabala and raviosef ergos takes issue with this chuva of the different Asic by the way where is a very important character in Jewish history because he was the first one at age 25 to speak out against chapter 3. the rovious Vegas was the first opponent of shop taxi so he says that we live in very difficult times we live in times where people try to dabble in Kabbalah and they think they actually understand that they think they have a a clear and deep comprehension of it but really they're turning the world upside down because uh they have a very shallow and superficial understanding of Kabbalah and he uses this as an introduction to challenge the bear hey SEC so he says uh number one he says first of all I spoke to Robin koyan the rigio and he said you cannot rely on the bear hey ASAP that's that's first of all can rely on the spare Asic it's not a reliable source number two he says and this is a very interesting point this is a very interesting point he says that if the ramami Pano would have said except in other words if the bear Asic would have said that uh the the ramami Pano said you shouldn't have a beard then I would have responded I don't believe that the ramami Pano said it but he's not even saying that there are Mami Pano said that uh that you shouldn't have a beard he's just saying that he saw the ramami Pano shave is a very important Rule and that is we do not rely on stories a story is not really meaningful many people are under the misconception yeah so why do you do this I once saw a big God that'll be so I'll do this first of all you saw you sure you remember correctly one of the most um nebulous things in this world is memory memory plays tricks on you people think they remember things many things that people remember never ever happened they think they wanted it to have happen when you want something to have happened so badly in your mind it actually happened even though it's a Bubba mice that never happened but that's that's the best case scenario you do not rely on stories maisa is not Araya and he said first of all did the ramami panu ever get up and show and say you should not have a beard if he would have said that again I would have said uh I don't believe it but you're not even saying that romanipano said he shouldn't have a beard you're saying that you saw the ramami Pano shade shave good very nice maybe he had a rash on his face maybe his wife didn't want him to have a beard who knows what maybe he couldn't grow a bear you don't know what the situation was you can't bring a Raya from amazing the fact that you say that the ramami Pano shaved does not indicate that you do not bring Araya from Isis nicest have no by the way he says I want to tell you something that I was in Manitoba he says if um I saw a picture of mommy Pano doesn't look like he doesn't have a beard he has quite a heavy beard says the um the de rayoise of Airgas and therefore I don't accept I don't believe this tradition about the romanipano and he says further that when the bear asek doesn't say that shaved off his beard he says he was Mustafa bid dignity he shaved in his beard which implies that he talked ahead of the earth he just trimmed it like many rabbanim do so be it as anime the opinion of the diverse for abusive ergas is the ramami Pano did have a beard and even if he didn't that doesn't have any indication halacha I will tell you that some Cipher chimed in on this Mac like this and she was in Italy none of the godylam had beards and they all hinged themselves on the Avi hamakobalam the ramami PanAm so it seems like the samsipher's opinion is that ramali Pano did not in fact have a beard in agreement with the Bear asek by the way the mirkha Salazar disagrees with but it's really a separate subject and very tangential maybe in the gemara but not anymore no but you can't rely on myself Lamesa if I were to ask you did the ramami panel have a beard it's not like a Sacrament whether he had a beard or not right so Sam soy first seems to say he did not rub your sever God seems to say he did the bear asex seems to say he did not I will tell you rights that if anybody says that a person is Kiefer why because the mishnah says that if you're messed upper you're now to be meghalayak with a razor which implies you are allowed to use a scissor so if anybody says says that one is obligated that if somebody shaves their beard they're over on baltaz says you're now to use a razor you are allowed to use a shaver maybe Le cabola kabbalistically there's an Indian but to say one is obligated to either Joseph clearly says that would be actually fira in the tarsh about disagrees with that sentiment as well okay but be a resume back to the ranch back to the ranch so that's just to give you a little flavor for who the ramami Pano was and let's come back to this year Cesar amami Pano based on the medus regarding how could it be that all the Marisha in did navera and everybody all the future Generations have to suffer what is the meaning of this so the murderer says something quite interesting the matter says the number 12.in was laying there as an unformed uh goylem God showed all the mauritian all the Sadiq and that were destined to come from him there is a concept a kabbalistic concept that inada Maria shine lay rested was hinged was hanging all future now some yeshuhut some of these Souls were on the head of other maricion somewhere on the forehead somewhere on his eyes some are on his nose some were on his mouth some were on his ears I know a few people who are in between the toes everybody had their specific location right as we say location location location all Future Souls hung on the Goof of other Marisa and therefore it comes out that when other mauritian ate the forbidden fruit the truth is you ate from the permanent fruit all the souls of mankind of claw Israel consumed from the fruit of other mauritian in fact when you wanted it yeah we have evidence you were there yeah all of mankind were Nana from the fruit of Allah they were all in the Gulf of honoration and when that fruit whether it was a fig or a grain or a grape or an essay went down the food pipe of the um esophagus of other Marie shine all those Souls were clamoring to get some shirayam from the from the eightsadas there was only one soul in one location who said I'm not taking part of this I'm not getting involved in this I don't want the fruit don't do it I don't want you to do it I'm gonna hide out in a very comfortable place and I'm not participating in the cinema the only person who didn't eat from the fruit was the soul of mushroom we are what part of the body the nose the toes the eyes he was in the corner he was in the windpipe of other Mauritius he took that you know um the epiglottis he covered it up and he said I'm gonna get out of here I don't have anything to do with this I'm going to hide out in this nice dark quiet place I do not want to be Nana from the sin of other reason I'm out of here I'm not participating and uh my shrabinu was the one nishama that did not consume and was not Nana from The Sinner therefore says Reuben Islam because you were nemon because you were faithful to me now the truth is Java was telling Adam the woman was telling him eat the fruit eat the fruit eat the fruit right like Ralph she says misery loves company and she was successful in persuading all the men to eat from the fruit of other reason there's only one man who was smart enough not to listen to her and that is therefore says every other man in the history of the world now abhibition says you listen to her the first time you got to listen to her for the rest of your life you cannot separate from your your wife because a punishment for the sin that of the Marie shine listen but because faithful to God and he didn't listen to khaba because he didn't listen to kava therefore says was licensed and authorized to be able to be parishment or Isha he's the only one who perished ariti the words of again I could never say this nor could anybody but these are the the holy words at the end of number 13 therefore it was permitted for him to separate from his wife that's the why where was in the Kane he was in the windpipe the Mayla when the Republic is looking to select who's Kane will I speak out of who has kept the Khan at pristine who has not impugned the Kane specifically sought after the and that's why is that so therefore again how why does everybody have to suffer because of the The Sinner doesn't is because everybody participated but Mike shabino did not there for Mojo Ben is authorized he didn't listen to khaba he does not have to listen to sipira so now the question is if anything he should be able to speak clearly says there's one little aveiro that he did and what's that if you look at number 15. now the the ramami panel wrote many's Forum he wrote asarama Roys he wrote he wrote Hashem he wrote he had many many swarim Jonas Elam he wrote a number of many many uh compositions wrote a parish on the riff and in the Asura mamaros ramami Pano osiotes in number 15 he says like this there's one thing he should have done meaning yes he was not Neneh from but if you're sitting there in the Shoal and the guy next to you you know during khazar sashats is on your eyes on his phone so what are you gonna do oh it's America mind my own business no you got to speak up you have an obligation to speak up and tell the guy you know what where are you you know wake up smell the coffee we're middle of davening because shout out and say call yourself what are you doing why are you eating funny should have spoken up he should have been the rest of mankind and we know what is the punishment what is the punishment of somebody who does not speak up when they say when they're supposed to speak up we know the Shabbos where um there's a conversation about the Romans and they're they're praising the Romans spoke up and see was Silence has to go in tagalas likewise we know we have a tradition you know 40 years he was in the Triumph 40 years he was in Kush and 40 years he was in the Midwest had to go into gallus for not speaking up and not protesting not protesting when all of these nishamas were being Neneh from the sin of the itsadas so despite the fact that Moshe was in the Kana and he was hiding out in the Quran he was not Nene from the aidsadas nevertheless he is somewhat indicted by the fact that he did not speak up now interestingly there's another thing that the Kana of other mauritians seemed to have done wrong and that is other mauritian said something that was slightly improper and that is when God came to Maisha came to Adam and he said why do you eat from the fruit so what did my chavino say the oldest trick in the book she told me to do it is ah Hashem said because you didn't value your wife you didn't honor her and you spoke badly about her therefore after Kabbalah Hashem tells moisha gota class Israel um one is used to blame his wife Hashem you're gonna blame her okay you're gonna make up for that you stick with me now you can't go back to her so that's also a tick on for what for the sin actually the ramami Pano does say that he was by saying oh look at number 16 this comes from the safer amodehouse Shiva actually um I was once with the srilai pinchhas in near beagle Eisen so I went in with him to the store he said you have to get the safer amodeo Shiva so we have it over here Shiva is an incredible safer of drushalo the darshan in the Kila kadosha slutsk and Lita and he says something very interesting if you look at number 16 he says Miriam and Aaron speak about myself why was moisha perished from his wife so Hashem says so we asked where they're not accusing him of stealing they're accused they want to know why does he have to be polish from his wife what do you mean he's nem on he's faithful so says was saying was because he was faithful to me and he didn't listen to Java therefore while the fate of the rest of mankind is they have the responsibility and so to speak the shibud to their spouse because he was Neman to me therefore I I did not put that upon him he is the only person so to speak who is freed from that okay let's continue on over here everybody saying so much he he's happy and he's willing to take the Jews out of mitzrayim in order to give them the Torah what happened to zanivas what happened to his humility what we learned from the romamy panel the moshrabenu being guilty even though he was not nenef from the AIDS had ass but at the very least he should have protested he should have been he should have corrected he should have said something he said don't eat the fruit God told you not to eat the fruit so when Hashem gives him the job to teach Toyota and the reason is he doesn't think it's it's a cover to give the target cloudy as well he figures rebunish him wants him to correct his uh his error here the first time around moisturabeno did not want to speak up my shrabino didn't say anything whenever when all the other Jews were you know were were dining and feasting on the on the Fig mashabena didn't speak up so now is the ticking for that when Hashem offers him the ability to give us the Torah says you know this is not a covet this is uh I need to do this for my personal shortcoming and my rectification so that moisture albino was willing to accept in fact we find there's a mattress in the beginning of devarim that before Maisha taught the Toyota class Israel he tackle was but once he taught the Toyota class Israel he we say he was able to speak clearly again so perhaps the Tyra in fact was his take on for being a cloud pair with shine and if I'm not mistaken the ramami Pano himself says that the reason why Maisha abena was a fat pair well showing is because he didn't speak up the first time and once he gave the Torah to be misaki in that he was able to speak clearly again but he didn't want to take a sentiments rhyme why didn't he want to take a sentiments right so it's just to capture this in a nutshell what was the purpose of naturalim we know that Novi refers to mitraim as actually a Cora barzal that's what it's referred to in safer devaram the iron furnace so what is it what does a furnace do a furnace purifies what did we need to be purified from what were we being purified from what was the impurity that we had that we needed to be purified from the filth what filth from what what did we do wrong so that reason says in the beginning of safe that uh the world still had not been cleansed from the center of adamarishine in fact the Ariza Allah learns that the various Generations that have progressed until mitzrayim were different attempts of purifying the world from the sin of Allah be it the door of anus be it the door of these were all attempts of purifying the world from the sin of the of the eight sadas which we know that Rizal says aside from eating from the eight sadas the Marisha and was perished from his wife by the way for 130 years and he was moiled Zara and as a and the the uh the DAR hamable continued in that sin and therefore therefore they had to be punished in boiling hot water and that's the reason why by the DAR hamable it says because they repeated the sin of Adama region be it as it may the various Wicked Generations throughout the vibrations were attempts to purify the world from the cinema which moistura binu indicted himself that he was responsible for the sin of automation because Maisha said to himself I should have spoke up I could have done something about I could have prevented it I could have stopped it so suggest this when it came to taking the Jews Adams you know felt he wasn't worthy to do that job he wasn't worthy for the task he felt he was responsible for them being there in the first place so that wasn't a job that he felt he was qualified to perform came to my shopping and he said give the Torah to claw Israel that much said oh you want me to rectify myself you want me to correct my own imperfections that was something that my Shabana was more willing and um willing to accept by the way one one of the one of the infractions he was right he didn't say he didn't acknowledge the gift that Hashem gave him that um said these words whose words are these shine and what's the right answer me right this is all part of the film why is mashabino the one who says as a correction he was the one who said so to be misak in that he's the one who says because was the only one who was not Nana from the eight sadas so Hashem says when it came to the eight sadas all of a sudden everyone was starving nobody could wait nobody could you know their color says that we were supposedly but he's supposed to wait until Shabbos came we would have been made Kiddush on the geffenada but we ate prematurely you know the people who they can't wait until the Kiddush comes out so they have to sneak into the kitchen to just wait a minute and at the right time it's right it's it's the it's had us again so the rest of the world could not wait a few minutes that's why we're always hungry Hashem said oh your taco you can't wait you're not gonna be able to wait moshabino is the only one who had the self-discipline not to be Nana from the eight sadas Hashem says you're the only guy who could come up to shamai in 40 days and 40 nights you won't be hung you won't be fetching no one's the Kiddush when's the kiddish Masha uh and now moshabbin was able to go up to shamayam injected the world with this was the only one who could go up to shamaim bring down the man the man is the pristine food there's no refuse right the reason why a person has to expel the soy less is because through the sin of the year the it injected a certain refuse into the food sort of is above and beyond that he could bring that from the man when the when Kalisa ate the man they were very frightened why because they didn't have to expel anything they thought they were going to be like a site that was going to blow up in their intestines but they didn't realize my shabin was able to access like pries food from because never was stumbled and they said us look these are all in your name but just to get you know the words and the basic idea it's something which is coming back to our first question so my Shabina was given the mission to take the Jews Adam it's Ryan moisha says me I'm not a speaker not today not yesterday and not the first time we spoke when you told me not to eat from the fruit and I kept my mouth closed and I wasn't a speaker to tell everyone else not to eat from it so I wasn't a speaker all the way back in the first day of history and I don't think I'm the man for the job now Rabbi Sai these are some of the nephlies to us through wishing everyone a great day yeah [Music] you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com