Parshas Shelach: Prophecy of the BESHT

this torah class is brought to you by torahanytime.com one of the most interesting topics to my mind that we've discussed here in the shoe rim was the topic of trailers last week we last year we spent five shurim if you remember discussing the concepts mr cuddle fish over here which is a type of squid and uh remember the rosina reba was very successful um he wrote a treatise three treatise on this topic he wrote in 1887 1888 1889 he wrote three volumes on this topic where it really spread like wildfire radzina rebecca kept a precise record of who he sold trailers to to the point where you sold tests to more than twelve thousand jewish families in europe um later on rav yitzhak isaac herzog wrote his doctorate his thesis on the topic of trailers and he for all intents and purposes completely debunked the radina rebels trailers quite successfully um to the point and the upshot was that the radzina rebel was duped by an italian chemist who um the radina rev was not able to produce blue dye from the cuttlefish but this chemist tricked him and using a little bit of the the chemical contents of the cuttlefish he used that mixed with other chemicals to produce a blue dye the only thing was it had nothing to do with the cuttlefish it was just a little carbon taking from that fish because they tried doing it with a piece of roast beef and it produced the same blue wool so herzog and for the most part most of claudiuso rejected that trellis rev herzog suggested that the source of trelas first was the murex trunculus shell however rav herzog dismissed that because that shell produced purple color and instead referred to suggested that the trailers came from the giant thinnest snail the there were major problems with that the gentina says snail the dye that it produces is undurable it's unfast it doesn't stick to the wool and for the most part all of the questions that rev herzog had on the muric's trunculus have been answered today for instance um rev herzog's question on new york's trunculus was that it produces a purple color well if it's exposed to direct sunlight it produces a blue color and many of the other um questions uh that referstuck had on it for instance rehearsal gas well the new york's trunculus does not produce a chemical that holds fast to the wool well that's simply not true anymore actually the dye from the new york's trunculus is possibly the most fast dye and the most durable dye of anything known on this planet you could soak it in bleach it won't come off so there are many many tamil common today and many from jews and by the account of the trellis institute more than two hundred thousand observant jews are wearing i can't tell you if that's true or not maybe 200 000 people bought it but i don't know if it's necessarily true that they're wearing it um since the last year i've received many phone calls from literally all over the world from uh relatives of godot israel all the way to the head of the institute himself who actually did not agree with the conclusion of the shir however he did appreciate the research of this year and he asked that all five shiurim be included in his museum so if you go to the archives of the museum what i'm told is these five shurim appear now to appreciate today's shirt you don't have to know anything we said in the past about quelas so in case you don't remember every detail from last year it's okay but if you really want to get the maximized benefit from the sheer i suggest you know over the course of the next week or so or next couple of weeks go back listen to the five shurim again um and they are last year apart from we skipped balak we did a different topic last year and you'll see uh many of the fascinating uh explorations that we underwent last year and um just to give you the the conclusion the conclusion was very definitive and that is the conclusion was rebel yash of pentachuva where he definitively comes out for five reasons not to wear the trellis retirement koniewski goes so far as to say that even if you only have one pair of sitsis and you're stranded on a desert island if that sits is heschelas on it don't wear it yourself said not to wear it um and ravisher feinstein as reported by authoritative sources did not go for it and our conclusion was therefore this is an issue that affects the entire cloud israel to follow the gaddari israel but even though we came out with a definitive conclusion we have an entire new share today new sources new ideas new thought and let's see if over the past year anything has changed and what other information we could delve into okay we begin this evening with a safe air that i don't think we ever quoted before in the shurim the name of the safer is mayor enach written by one of the talmidim of ramirez the ice drove saraba who was an incredible figure really remarkable figure he was born in 1852 passed away in 1928 now the oyster of so was like a malacha like him literally like an angel first of all unlike other rebels he had no lineage his father was a bagel he baked bagels his father made bagels and they used to ask you know when the rebel when the rebbe says torah you have to say it from the tata you have to say over from the zeida so they asked the oyster of sanur that fresh bagels are better than stale bagels and then they say what else the tata said when the oven is shut tight the heat stays in better but he learned from there if the oven is when it when the oven is shut tight the heat stays in better keep your mouth closed that's what he learned from that anyway so the oyster was a very holy jew uh by the way in poland um even among the hasidim there were two great centers of of london of learning sakachav and the oyster up the ostrofsa had one of the most the prominent yeshivas in all of poland and for the last 40 to 50 years of his life he didn't eat ever eat he did not eat he fasted for approximately 40 to 50 years straight never eat it ate one thing during the day only at night he would eat some crackers and tea to the point where the end of his life he was literally skin and bones the family pleaded with him please eat he would not eat the emory ms plead with him please eat he said look your father is the space ms your father fasted for you i have to fast for myself the end of his life he was so cold he had to be under the pillow under the covers but he was a very holy jew and um he writes a certain prediction of the baal shamdas and he writes on this week's parachute number one venus people are going to search for trellis so the balsams have apparently made some kind of prediction or prophetic uh prediction that before mashiach comes we're going to search for this and in fact we see over the last century there has been great movements to look for authentic trailers be it be it of herzog be it today the various institutes now interestingly bashar did not say they're going to find treyless he just said they're going to look for it and the ice chest wants to know what is the meaning of this why daft before mashiach comes are they going to look for trellis we don't find they're going to look for the urine the only person that searches for the lost ark yeah is not uh not of jewish origin right the the the search for the lost ark we don't find any of the rabonum looking for the lost ark we don't find anyone looking for the mate of arroyo we don't find anyone looking for the mon did the balsham say they're going to look for the trellas well the oyster of says that ap habala that sadiq is referred to as a thread of trellas what does it have to do with the thread of trellis where he says the following he said we know us reminds us of the sea the sea reminds us of the sky and the sky reminds us of the kise why is the sky blue i mean look at the air in this room does it look blue to you no when you look down from the airplane you look down there's nothing blue in between you and the earth what exactly is blue about the air says the oyster the reason why the sky looks blue is because anything that seems endless takes on a blue you a blue color blue resembles and symbolizes insife insife that's how you look at the ocean and it seems like it's endless you can't see the end of it it looks blue the sky looks blue because it's inside that's why the sadiq is considered absurd because i'll say that you should seek torah from a rabbi who's doing hashem why should it be dharma to amalah just like everyone acknowledges we don't fathom the the depths and the what amalek means we cannot be massive we can't we can't even wrap our minds around what amalek is so you should seek out a rebbe who you can't even fathom their greatness that's why the sadiq is called and therefore before the end of days you know why people will search for us because as meshiach is coming it seems so far off it seems like it's never going to come it seems like it's inside that is resembled by the trailers the blue color it seems like the end of days is never going to happen we're waiting and waiting and it's just so elusive it's it's so not never-ending it's so ain't safe so that is symbolic of the search for it and that is why the bashamta predicts that before mashiach comes we're going to search for travis now you should know that it's not just a fad or it's not just something that people are into but you should be aware that there were many great gaduilam and poiskin who did wear trelas now i think we mentioned in uh the five parts that we learned last year one of the gdulim who legend has it had it war trailers was the marsham hashem was the place of khadr at the end of the 19th century beginning of the 20th century and in fact um i found this week right as i was preparing for this year in the ethical will of the marsham and the tsava of the marsham if you look at number two and he he wrote a say from homage called which by the way has nothing to do with us it's just coincidental that it's called that the marsham writes in his sabah that when he passes away they should take his talus without the atara and you should tie trellis on to the talus that he's buried in was the plastic and then he says some other interesting things he has some dirt from eretz israel he says please sprinkle it over my body especially and then he asked his family to earn mashinayas for him and especially a certain para park zynamic voice but amazingly we see that the marsham not only warts khala secretly he wanted and he asked to be buried in khelas in the safer the stipeler once told one of us tell me them that if not for the fact that people look at every little thing that he does he would do other things another stapler says like people look every single thing i do they think because i tie my shoe so now before you open up a gemara even if your shoe is still tied you tie it again because i tie my shoe this disciples says people don't leave me alone they they look at everything i do they think you know i'm about to learn and i blinked my eyes and that everyone everyone's blinking their eye but if not for the fact that everybody's watching everything i do i would do more things so they said like what like wearing razziner trellas he says now this is all anecdotal uh anecdotal evidence the stipler said he would have i don't understand what that means why would he have worn the trellis if he thinks maybe it's the real thing then he should wear and let everybody learn from him it's a little bit dubious exactly what this story is but one thing it is reported is the kazoynish did not go for it at all hazonis did not hold of it they said look you're right if it's not hairless so but it's not harmful it's not you're not hurting anybody you're not doing anything wrong so kazanus is fine so then what bring me a cow and i'll color my sentence with the blood of a cow or also it's not harming anybody just because it's not that has no downside it's not a reason to do something it also has no downside to spin around and flip and stand on your head for 30 minutes there's no downside it doesn't mean you should do it just because it has no downside kazonya said there was a guy in kosova who wore glasses with no lenses so they asked yeah were you crazy why are you wearing glasses no lenses the guy said well even though it doesn't help me it doesn't hurt me either so khazanu says the same thing about it's ridiculous to say that well it has no downside so you might as well do it there are a lot of things that have no doubt also there's no downside take your hat and put it on upside down there's no downside it's not a reason to do something khazanish did not go for it in fact if you look at number four in the dining it's well known khazanesh did not hold of any of the trailers not of brazil not of ref herzog's trailers not of the new york structuralist he did not go for the whole business ravencion abba one of the right if you remember last time we brought it on the opinion of ravitzrak yosef who said look you want to know what to do we had great sephardico in him we saw revezra atiyah we saw rabavadya hodaya we saw ravadas they don't wear trailers so what are you wearing trailers for well we didn't bring in yet the opinion over him said if your father did not wear trailers you're not allowed to wear a trailer why because he says in his commentary on the in the shouts of arlitzione park mandala he says it's like you're being miss owlzell the minute of your forefathers they didn't they didn't concern themselves with this so you're going to be better than them you can be more from than them it's a little bit uh disparaging their practice okay also he has uh other reasons the gemara says not to put on uh fake trailers and if this is not real real then you're violating what the gemara says not to put on kalaila okay now the the issue and we dealt with this also at length is look it's a mitsubishi it might be it it's a suffix and we know any matter of director which is a suffix we say a rule suffice so it's a it's a biblical uh issue why shouldn't we be machmer so we have over here number six shia listed look who do you want to put on the trailers regular people why should they wear trailers if the delume are not wearing it but the onus rests on the shoulders of the goddalem why didn't the gadolin put on the tailless and he says the following suffix do i rise to look does not apply over here listen carefully a very important safari you know when suffolk derice aloha applies the right home replies let's say the raman says yes the rambam says to do a mitzvah this way rameno time agrees the rift agrees and rabinoyano agrees and against all of them you have the rush so let's say we'll side with the majority so soviet would say look the rush was a force to be reckoned with he is a minority view but if you want to be mahmir be makhmere like the rush after all the rush is a well established authoritative figure who we consider important in all matters of allah so yes in this case he's a minority view but because we're dealing with the dairisa in deference to the rush there's an indian to be concerned with the russia's opinion but when it comes to trailers lived in the times of the razina rabbah he said none of the goddard agreed with him they all agree that zena rebel was a but did you ever hear that was this way because spectre hold that held that way and reviewed that way and the base jalebi and the rodzino held that way nobody ever brings in the name of the redzina rabba why not maybe he didn't ha gain that acceptability as the other poiskon so yes he's a great guy and he's a great sadiq but he's not he was never a recognized viewpoint in any other matter of halacha so therefore what are we going to do in one area all of a sudden we're going to say oh let's be concerned with radzina rabbah that's not the halachic process process not to be is only to be concerned with the main viewpoints which are prevalent in all matters of but just to take one isolated instance and say well in this isolated instance we have the viewpoint of radzina rabba as great as he was as big of a solid as he was as brilliant as he was it's not it's not a position that ever is considered in any other area which would now require us to reckon with it even in the area of sitsis okay now let us momentarily go take a look at number seven number seven is also safer that we never uh used before the name of the safer is the shout out now who wrote shout outs to he lived from 1866 to 1935 hungarian rabbi great scholar interesting man very interesting name he was a collector and a book salesman so he was born in 1866 five years later his parents skedaddle from hungary they go to ushalayam and he's very interesting it's interested in books collecting old manuscripts collecting old swarm so he decides to leave eretz israel and he moves to egypt he goes to egypt what does he what does he do in egypt he's fascinated with the cairo genizah he gets his hands on a lot of ancient manuscripts in the cairo geniza and he starts selling it off to london starts making money by selling everybody wonders you know in the uh museum in london in england um in cambridge university they have a tremendous collection from the cairo geniza how in the world does um cambridge university have such a large collection from the cairo geniza the answer is ripped shloima aaron verteimer was a very good businessman and he used to sell off different manuscripts to uh to the museums and university in england but anyway he did not agree with the radzina reba at all he said first of all if you remember from the uh last year one of the main questions on the radzina revan this was the primary reason why rabavadhi yosef and why refraimsky did not agree with any of the trailers because there's a madrish and there's an arizal that say the following trailers was hidden and nignaz means like it does throughout shas the orion was nignaz it ain't coming back until misha comes but there are many items the shema mishka was nignaz it's not coming back and it says the same thing about us so says he says if you believe in the words of the madrish then we can't have trellis until comes the razina rebel already addressed that and the razina rebels said oh yeah then why was it only mentioned in the medarish why isn't it mentioned in the gemaran saita that lists all the items that were nignaz it must be says the radzinareva that shasta beverly holds it wasn't nignaz to which rafale aaron verteimer says no that's not the reason why the shasta doesn't say it was nignaz the reason why shasta doesn't say it was nignaz is because in the time of shas it wasn't ignaz yet it didn't happen yet because if you look throughout shas for instance in the menaches of memphis had still had khalas one of the last some say he was even one of the rabban and savaroy he had trellis so the reason why the gemara doesn't say it was nignaz is not because the gemara argues on the madris and the gemara feels it was an ignac because of course it wasn't ignace but not yet not yet another issue that the radzina reba dealt with is that everybody knows that the zone does not make frequent appearances how often does the gilazone appear once every 70 years does anybody remember the scientific terminology for a once every 70-year appearance remember we learned last year the septuagenarian appearance right the once in every 70-year appearance the septuagenarian appearance well ra the and and the many asked on the radzina rabba this cuddle fish over here this guy over here if you go to the mediterranean sea off the coast of italy you could photograph thousands of them i mean they're they're like you know goldfish they're they're everywhere they don't appear once every 70 years to which rossino rebbe said it doesn't mean it appears once every seven years because the in the navi the navi says that nevus made the survivors of you shall i am he gave them a career and the career was there they became zoned catchers now what kind of career is it to catch a fish that appears once every 70 years imagine a father he he catches one and then he tells this kid you know kid you know i don't know how much longer i could do this i want to pass on my legacy to you so what's the kid supposed to do for the next 69 years exactly just to sit there by the seacoast twiddling his thumbs until the next septuagenarian appearance of this monster in the ocean obviously says razeen rebecca if niva's radhan made a gave people a career of catching the khila zone it must appear all the time every 70 years maybe he makes you know special appearances we know with spotlights and a whole he does a whole song and then but he's always around to which the the shayla said no no no no this the the killazone appears once every 70 years why wouldn't israel have given them the job of being uh uh a shiloh catcher well maybe because it just happened to be that in three months would be the next 70-year appearance but you can't prove from the fact that nova's raden gave them the job that it appears more often than every seven years okay i would like to bring to your attention the most recent chew voice written on this topic everything we did last year existed before last year but the two of us were about to learn tonight had not been written yet they just came out over the last couple of months one of the great points give now in arizona one of the up and coming uh recognized post game really by all strata of jewish observance is ravashah weiss bashar weiss has a mahoney narcissist very well acclaimed price sake on contemporary issues as well medical issues and ravashah rice in heilig bays of the shout out was very fascinated with this topic so he wrote out of the first five cubists in the safer four of them are about us so i want to share with you his opinion about us and he begins by uh dealing with the issue again not razino trelas not the gentina scale snail but rather the murex trunculus shell which is uh which the institutes and artistrol all are very much behind and ravage your wife starts off by saying in number eight this is khailek bayes simon bays on the third line ulla niyasti loi rajisi koraya there is no indication there is no proof there is no reason to assume that this is why not first of all says rebecca wise why should you wear it because maybe it is no no that doesn't make any sense maybe it is maybe it's not a reason to do something in judaism a reason to do something would be there is a source in the gemara some place can say like that just maybe that's not a suffix maybe maybe a rhinoceros is the hilaza you know it's not it also takes a bath how often do you see rhinoceros i know some people they say once every seventy years maybe it's the kilozone maybe a unicorn is a philosom i don't know just because maybe jews don't do do things because you know somebody thinks someone speculates maybe says russia wise vanessa needs suffix it's not a definitive something this is not a concept of suffix suffix has basis not mere speculation and then ramashawi says the second argument if you turn over your page onto page three third paragraph now we know in hebrew the new york trunculus is called parpura and the gemara says about the zone a few uh seem on him number one the gemara says that its body looks like the sea it looks like a fish it comes up once every seventy years and with its blood you die trailer says of these four characteristics how many of them are met by murex trunculus zero number one the muric's trunculus is not a fish it's a snail number two it doesn't look like the sea it's not blue it's sandy colored number three you don't use its blood it doesn't have blood it's a snail snails don't have blood they have liquid inside of them number four the rambam says it's found in the dead sea these are not found in the dead sea guess what's found in the dead sea today nothing now the truth is we addressed that last question last year and that is very possibly whenever the ramadan refers to yamamela who refers to a body of salt water as opposed to fresh water the ramen very likely refers to the mediterranean then reverse your wife says also it doesn't come up once every seven years so of the five characteristics mentioned by the mind around them none are met by the muric's trunculus then says rashford wise but these people who purport to that they have found the trailers they think like a heavenly voice came down like a bosco came out we're the blood of the muric's trunculus says rebashia wise i must have missed that bosco i knew i didn't hear the basketball these people think like god himself came down and said this is the this is the trellis and that everybody has to answer up every gemara and every mimer khazal in order to stuff it into the words of the gemara where does this premise come from what is it based on number three we know hazal say is similar to the sea which means hailes is blue scissor bashaway does anybody know what color the murax produces produces purple now did anyone here ever see the sea you saw the sea in your life is the sea purple see ain't purple some people here have shirts that are more similar to the sea than the purple color of the of the murex trunculus but says russia west it doesn't look like the sea so you say well it's pretty close it looks more like the sea than let's say yellow or red that's a reason that's a symmetra and that means it is and then ravage your wife says you know rashi shita rashishita and pasha's truma rashi shita in our parsha rasheem says that is similar to the color of green now there are seas in the world that have a greenish tinge to them right the muric's trunculus does not produce any color that has even a figment of a u of green then says of usher wise then how do they produce trellas today well the rambam explains how to produce he says you take the blood of the zone and you take the various chemicals and you boil it is that what they do today yeah they do that but they just do one more thing it's impossible to make trailers or muric structures until you do a very important thing you expose it to direct sunlight why would the rambam have left out the most important ingredient in making playlists so you say the rambam took it for granted obviously you're making it outdoors so the ram doesn't have to write that it has to be exposed to direct sunlight says reverse your eyes really what kind of ridiculous thing is that to say that of course the ram assumed you were making trailers outdoors who makes anything outdoors what it didn't rain in the in the times of the roundabout it didn't rain rain hadn't been invented it was it wasn't hot outside they only did things outdoors like the rambam took it for granted that it had to be done outdoors of course all manufacturers do things indoors so if the presumption is that it was manufactured indoors and the only way to make the murex is to expose it to direct sunlight why wouldn't the ramadan mention that and therefore ravashawi summarizes tamsu this is on page three third column top paragraph tab i haven't even caught a whiff of a semblance of an inkling of any kind of medic in other words what percent is it that this is zero percent or maybe a little bit higher point zero zero zero zero zero one would anybody do anything by the way tomorrow at one o'clock go to the bank why because they might give out money for free anyone going so yeah right no nobody does things based on that nobody does nobody runs their life that way you need you need basis not oh an idea and then let's stick it into every gemara and therefore and then says rebel shall rise well there are certain criteria that the muric's truncus does fit into for example the gemara magilla says it's found off the seacoast of zavulan and the gemara and megillah says that the passage it's one of the treasures of the sand yes this snail is found in the sand and one of the criteria the marine chamber says is that it's caught with nets and the gemara says when you crack it open it dies so says revolutionize well you know these four criteria are met by the murak strunkulus says rashford so is every other aquatic creature in the entire world yeah they're also found off the seacoast of zavulan they're also sometimes in the sand you also catch them with nets now all of a sudden i have to put i have to color my strings with this thing because it's caught we'll call it with a net so is a goldfish so is the tuna fish every fish is caught with a net and therefore says of ashwais well some want to say that but this is the only way to produce blue wool then what else is it that's a reason because otherwise what else is it imagine if a prosecutor came to court and said jury he's the murderer because if it's not him then who could have done it how long is that case going to last for because who else could have done it oh it must be this is trayless because otherwise how do you make it i don't know that's what we said we don't know how to make it that's why the khazal say when was it says russia wise from the beginning of time thousands of species have become extinct so if says became extinct what are you telling me well what else is it what is it what it is that's how you make it the only thing is we don't have it anymore now if you remember last year we discussed the mattress the mattress that says trellis was but we brought it out the following issue and the issue we brought out is yes the matter says but there's a concept in halacha that we don't ask in halacha it's from mid russian remember we brought many many sources that we don't pass in russian so even if the last was nignaz and he wasn't ignaz but you can't passkin based on that says ravashawise and this really explains you know i was i was very bothered regarding writes explicitly that since the matter says i was bothered why would rubric say that it is a madrish says radhasha wise anyone who wants to say that we can't follow the matters we don't pascal allah is making a very very big mistake you know why because of course we don't pass general russia we're not pass skinning from the madrish merely relying on the madrid for facts the madrid says that was we don't have it anymore so we're not following the matters for we want to know the messiah so we don't want to know the reality we want to know whether the hillary exists or not so the med verse says it doesn't exist anymore so he's saying oh we can't follow the meadows because we don't pass king like mid rush and we don't follow we're not following it for allah we're merely following it to know what the reality is and therefore says rasher wise it's a big avala to dismiss the madrish to say well we don't ask and like mid-russia now i'm not sure how big of an outlet is because it's not just we don't passing like mid-russian it's very hard to know what a mederis means when a matter says something it's very hard to know what it means in fact there are some refers to him that learned that when the matter says it was an ignaz it means it was forgotten so but rabasha wise seems to hold very strongly that if the matter says it was then there's nothing to deal with okay and this is the conclusion of ravashawis in chuva bays bays ain call mitzvah you want to know if you buy trailers are you doing a good deed says russia wise you are not doing a good deed maybe you're doing a good deed because the owner of the swarm store is a jew and it's very expensive and you're being methane sim so you're giving him a hundred bucks so you're right it's a good deed you're giving a jew more money but in terms of your observance of a mitzvah no you're not doing anything but whoever asked him the question in chuva bays was very persistent and very um steadfast in his opinion and he went right back out of oshawa since him and he asked him he says russia wise don't you know that in earth's israel many pits have been found many caves have been found full of thousands and thousands and thousands and thousands maybe millions of shells of the muric's trunculus and archaeologists date it back to the time in history when we had khilazone and don't you know reverse your wise that if you look in the greek historical books namely plino plino says that purpura is muric's trunculus and don't you know ravashaw wise there's no other way to make blue color says of us what in the world are you talking about i know that this type of reasoning holds importance and has value in the world of academia where there's a lot of guesswork and there's a lot of deductive reasoning and there's a lot of theory and there's a lot of suggestion in the world of science whoever has the best theory wins and we'll go with that but says russia wise doesn't work that way you don't you don't make out of theory you need evidence and just because you find a pit with shells and what else could it be other than that's not a halachic argument that's rational does not deal with hasharah does not deal with guesswork it does not deal with estimation deals with raya proofs and until you have araya to make herbera all over that situations remain the way they've been for a thousand years and well you say you say that how else are you gonna make blue wool i don't know i don't know how else i guess you won't make it just because there's no alternative that just means kilos and has gone extinct and there's no other way to make it but says rashford here's a very interesting point the proponents of the muric's trunculus say one simple question say you could make blue wool out of trellis but not out of color elon color elon is a fake imitation indigo as so the proponents of the muric chunkless ask if this is not also authoritative trailers if this is not authentic then why weren't hazal also afraid why didn't they also warn us don't make it out of indigo and don't make it out of the muric's trunculus if muric's trunculus is a fake why didn't hazal warn us about it oh they say it must be because it's not a fake it must be muric's trunculus is the real thing otherwise if it's a fake then hazard warned us against it says about your wise you know why they didn't warn us against it because it's so far off from treyless it's so the wrong color it's so does not resemble treyless in any way then no one would ever be duped into thinking that this is it because it's purple and we know taylor says be blue i but we know that the color of real trailers is the exact same color as indigo and the murex trunculus produces the same exact color as indigo do we showing them already say the color of trellis is indigo and the color of the mirror changes is indigo says rebashia wise who says that the indigo of a thousand years ago is the same indigo as today do we have like a masaira going back from the times of the rambam exactly what the ram gave us a yada kazakh and a benjamin moore booklet with all the colors in it where the random says ipasca and this is indigo we don't know what indigo is we don't know what they held in the ghost we don't we don't know what what indigo is today you can't you can't assume like that says um the ravashah rice but all the archaeologists say that all of these shells that they found in the pit date back to the exact time when we use kilazone says we do not believe one word that archaeologists say they have no credibility because if you're going to believe what archaeologists say you know how old they say the world is they're off by millions of years they say the world is millions of years old and we say it's only five thousand seven hundred and seventy five so that means they're 99 percent off so now they tell you that these shells date back to the times of the that has no bearing on reality won't believe a word they say but what do you mean everyone knows carbon dating the first thing you need to know is that carbon dating is the biggest scam in the history of the world you know that carbon dating is a farce because it's based on a pre presupposition that when the world began there was a certain amount of carbon in the earth which is we have no way to know that because we weren't there it's also based on the fact that as the radioactive waves from the cosmos uh react on the earth it cr it creates certain chemical reactions well everybody knows the ozone layers change heavily and and uh in recent history they've changed 65 percent so carbon dating is not reliable at all so now you're going to rely on archaeologists they date it back to that time and the obvious answer is the following anyone here wearing a blue shirt today almost everyone in this room has some blue in their shirt right are you wearing trailers did you get it from the line and nobody in this room sure it came from the gaza now guess where they got it from in ancient times they got it from the new york's trunculus it was a very strong die say oh it must be they used it for trailers what's i gotta do with trailers they have pits with thousands of these shells why because people like to wear blue shirts jews like to wear blue shirts that's it then now there's no bearing on trellis okay and therefore says rava show ice thank you for your letter it was very informative but as they say in yiddish nice try but no he says and then the person was added again in the third shiva and he didn't leave it alone and he says reverse your wise but everybody knows that the color of talus is indigo you can't argue on that that we showed him say that and we know muric's trunculus produces indigo which of asha white says i know it produces indigo it produces the indigo of today but who says it produces indigo of a thousand years ago we have no idea what indigo of a thousand years ago is and says russia wise my main problem with the new trailers is that it's based on principles that are not allowed entry in the halachic process it's based on presuppositions it's based on assumptions and in science things are based on assumptions in halacha we don't assume anything until you could prove it and then therefore says ravashawise i'm sorry if i have to speak so sharply i'm sorry if i've gone beyond my normal protocol i like to speak out to everybody but people come to me and they complain that the rabbis don't want to be moida ms when the truth is so blatant says rashawise just the opposite it's those who deal in the world of academia they don't want to question any of their presumptions and therefore says rashawise i must have missed the basketball that came down from heaven that this indeed is the zone and therefore but this is not and then rabasha wise got another letter it sounds like the next letter was a little nasty where the person had tightness on him taruma's on him that why he's fighting against the people who we are to which rabosha weiss explains that i don't fight with anybody i'm not against anybody i know all the people who wear trailers i love them they're all sharp mitzvahs and they're of course the only reason they're doing it is that of love for their mitzvahs but says russia wise as much as i love jews i love the truth even more as much as i love claudius i love the truth even more and therefore what can i tell you this is not it i pleno writes that the purpura is the mirex trunkless replenish shalom you're bringing from plano plino is a greek naturalist everybody knows even the words of the rishonim which they gave over every word to their talmudim beressas bizea basiiludin and nevertheless the words of the beshan have many gersais and plino who gave over his messiah to a right sayah who gave it over to a manife who gave it over to a mushroos who gave it over to al-mamzar who gave it over to another mushroos you're going to bring a raya to trailers from plano you says rasher weiss excuse me for saying it but anybody who thinks in these terms he obviously been taken over by some kind of uh foolish spirit but this is not how halacha works says all those who wear it certainly we understand why they want to do it it's out of their great love of the mitzvah but as important as it is to love mitsvice it's even more important to be truthful and if you want to be truthful then you got to wear authentic sitsis which remains white until mashiach comes ok what we said last year remains in full force that um there's no indian to wear that sits us and uh in my humble opinion it's probably better not to the deutscroll have not accepted it again rehearsal was a great man in fact i mentioned to you after world war ii my grandfather took her her dog around to all the dp camps and i'll tell you two stories about my grandfather of herzog rehearsal told him two very interesting things i don't think i ever said it before number one he said that during the war he went to the vatican to plead with the church to save jews the pope would not listen to him he would not give him audience after the holocaust rev herzog told my grandfather he went to the vatican that the pope should issue a decree that all the monasteries and all the homes that have jewish kinderlock in should release them the pope would not even listen to him so if shame hashem yurkov all of the all of the talmidim of the church and all the followers of the church they have their place you know where and and they'll be punished for and rav herzog was very active in the vat had salah but nevertheless as great as he was the same thing we said with razina rebba is not necessarily an opinion that we're familiar with in any other areas of halacha as great as he was and so to uh anyway by the way bottom line is today nobody's wearing red herzog's trellis the gentina snail is completely dismissed it doesn't hold it doesn't hold to the wool it's a it's a terrible dye it washes right off so it was never really nobody nobody uses rubber socks bottom line is rabbi so you say but isn't it depressing i'm looking at my titties and they're all white well i want to bring to your attention to chuva from the igor is my show with maisha feinstein in dallas mandala and this question was brought to ramosha by his very own son of david feinstein and ramosh is dealing with the issue of everybody knows that biblically you're not obligated to buy a four cornered garment to put sits on it and only biblically only if you happen to be wearing a for a corner garment then you must put such as on it however rav david says to his father that the minute of the jewish people is that every jew goes out and buys a four cornered garment to where it sits this every day and therefore abduv it says to masha i think now it would then be an obligation for every every jew to where it sits is why not because the torah says you have to wear a four corner garment but because it's minogue israel and we have to keep him in hug him like the pastor says initially right says you're very right that wearing sisters every day is mean of israel it's no less than any minute which every jew must abide by you can't say well it doesn't say in the torah afterwards it says so you know on a hot day in the summer i won't wear it since i said you can't do that it's a minogue like oh man okay so you have to wear it and rav masha says it's even stronger than a minute because other men hug him it's not a minogue to be makayama mitzvah this is a minogue to fulfill him it's a diarisa and says maisha there's so many important in yanum of wearing sitzis for example we know the myth of sitzus is equal to all 613 midsize says ramosha we know that someone who looks at it sits as he remembers all 6 thirteen right because the gamache of since this is six hundred and the and the eight knots excuse me and the five knots and the eight strings six thirteen so you remember the mitzvahs to do them says ramosha anyone who is careful and sits this will and we know someone who's careful and sets us and protects you from sin says with moisture is that only if you have trelas or is it even if you just have the love on says ramosa every single of sitsya supplies even if your tattoos are 100 white and therefore you don't worry not when you wear your regular titsus you are gaining all the spiritual power that you need to gain from that success that even though we don't really speak about this so much we always refer to the myths of wearing senses but the torah also says you should look at it it's number 13 that from the simple meaning of the passage it seems like the torah suggests that whenever you have a free moment look at your senses you're bored you're sitting at a chair you don't know what the guy's talking about okay at least look at your senses you're sitting in a class you're you're waiting till it's over take out your senses you're uh sitting on the train you have nothing better to do look at your titties especially says if you're about to get angry and you're about to do who knows what or you're about to have a bad thought then certainly look at your tutus and that is the way to counteract the atahara a few times a day that's a great question it has nothing to do with the topic that we're talking about but certainly you should try to look at it as much as possible i'm not going to discuss that tonight but it's a good topic for some time okay but i want to bring to your attention something very important and then i'm going to add with something really out there one of my favorites he writes in two places in the berkeley safe berkeley let's read inside number 14 of 15. he writes the following historical you should look at your senses as if it would have travis on it because even though it doesn't have trailers the spiritual light of trellis is still there so when you look at your tzitzis imagine that it has trellis on it because even though it doesn't actually have trellis the hara the light of trellis is there and the victorious of dalit brings this in the name of the ariza trailers when you put on sitsis you should have kavanagh the power the energy of trellis is still there and the baneshkai writes the exact same thing and number 16 parishes as if there's a blue string people are gonna look at you and you're staring at this say hey pal what are you looking at i'm looking at the trailers so what are you talking about you're one of those guys no no i don't i don't have any i don't wear it's kayla's but arizona says you should imagine as if you had it why because the spiritual power of qaeda still exists so everybody say after sikh shirim even though we've concluded that if you want real trailers you gotta wait until moshiach comes nevertheless on some dimension and some level on some behind we still have a certain light of trails even today but i want to end with the following in the early 1900s there was an astronomer named edwin hubble the inventor of the hubble telescope and he was the one who understood that our galaxy was only dropping the bucket of what's out there by the way if you ever look at a picture of um the uh the world i don't mean planet earth i don't mean our if you ever look at a pl um of the milky way there's one dot and there's an arrow by that dot it says this is our galaxy in other words if this was the universe you see this dot you can't even see the that that's our galaxy which means we can't even see to the end of our galaxy and in the scheme of things it's a dot okay that's what edwin hubble understood but he also came up with the following idea he realized there's a phenomena called red shift you know what redshift is what's redshift away from you you get red ship the same thing as isaac you told him well right so redshift is when a galaxy moves away from the earth it appears to have a certain red red u when the galaxy would move away from earth it would it would shift toward the red spectrum and as the galaxy approaches planet earth it shifts to the blue spectrum which means scientifically the color blue represents the shamayim coming closer to ours so that got me thinking today that maybe some of the symbolism of prelas we know trellis reminds you of the sea and the sea reminds you of the heaven and the heaven reminds you of so when your word sits this you're supposed to think about the kisaka what are you supposed to think that the kisekawai is 50 billion light years away it's good right i could do whatever i want and the kisaraka is all the way up there beyond the milky way now this is blue blue means shamayim coming close to ours the purpose of the trellis is to realize the kisayaka is right near you is looking over you is right next to you that's why protects you that's why it sits this protects you from sin because the purpose of this of the sith is blue shift to realize that shamayim is coming closer to ours if that's the case then maybe we understand why we don't have us today because everybody knows that when the visa middle stood we had the shrino with us we had the ki sayakawi it was because we could be reminded that rebounds from shrina is right next to us but with the destruction of the base amiktar says we don't have some covered with us anymore so maybe that's the reason why we can't have that supposed to remind us of their close relationship between shamayim and ours the close relationship of the ki sayakawid with us but we don't have that anymore the key say it unfortunately is shrinab and that's why comes the arizona and comes the and comes to banish and they say but don't make a mistake yes we don't have the keys and yes we don't have quelas but the aurora of hailas we still have we don't have gilo ishtina anymore we don't have reebokshalam's open presence with us but it's still with us so in the revealed sense we don't have quelas with us but blue shift we still have we still have the shrine and with claudius the galoosa golu israel gallus so even though we don't have revealed khelas perhaps we have the secret khalas which symbolizes that on the deepest level ibaneshlam is still with us kisakovi still knows of course what we do what we're thinking and that is the school of situations whether we actually have trailers the kedusha of trailers we do have to some extent and we still hope for the great day of the coming of mashiach you've just experienced another torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com