0:00 / 0:00
Parshas Re'eh: Who Decided That An Hour Is 60 Minutes?
205 views
The Amazing Machlokes R' Yonasan Eibeshutz and the Chazon Ish Subscribe and hit the bell to see new videos!!! • Visit the Rav's site: https://www.rabbidg.com • Have a Question? Contact the Rav: https://www.rabbidg.com/contact • Order Rabbi Glatstein's Books: https://www.rabbidg.com/rabbi-glatstein-books Date This Shiur Was Given: 8/16/2017 #Torahstudy #Judaism #Jewish #Torah #Spiritual #Rabbi #Chumash #Parasha #Parsha #Gemara
Comments(0)
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
this torah class is brought to you by
torahanytime.com
okay uh good evening rabbi said pastors
ray
so the tarot tells us about the episode
of the mesis the mesis is somebody who
tries to
persuade and seduce his friend to be
oiveid abeduzara
and the pasik tells us about the
investigations that the besden has to do
in order to determine whether in fact
this individual qualifies to be a
message and the passage says vidarashta
you will seek out
you will investigate vishwa al-tahitev
and you will
question well
and behold
it is true the matter is correct
this abomination has been committed in
your midst okay so obviously you look at
the pasta can you see there are
extra phrases the dharashta one seeking
out the character investigation vishalta
questioning
and the gemara darshans based on this
passage and other psukim that speak
about the investigation of bezdin that
from these so can we learn out that
bezdin
goes through a full-fledged procedure of
cross-examination a very methodical very
thorough procedure and it's known as
seven khaki
so the way they cross examine the
witnesses they go through seven khakiras
the mishnah sanhedrin says
they would test
the witnesses with seven
investigations what are they
what shivua cycle what shemitah cycle
did you see it happen in other words
when do you claim it happened this seven
year period another seven year period
another seven year period so yeah they
have the aid them have to get their act
together and they both have to have the
same story of what shmita cycle the uh
the act transpired
how many
depends on the case depends on the
severity of the case it could be
anywhere between 71 and 3 it could be 71
it could be 23. the izana what year was
it
beijing what month was it
the kama bakadesh what day of the month
the azayom what day of the month
what day of the week
what hour
be
what's the place these are the seven
main questions that the desden uses to
cross-examine the witnesses the shemitah
cycle the year the month
the day of the month the day of the week
the hour of the day and the place
so from this
mishna
and gemara
it would imply that there is a concept
of a halachic hour now we're all
familiar with something called shasmani
ice where we break up the uh
there are definitely enough sheets for
everybody
so if anybody needs uh
that we know there's a concept of the
halachic hour where you break up the day
let's say from uh
from aloysia
until it says
or from natacama until
you break it up into 12 parts and in the
winter an hour could be a 12th of the
day could be as little as 45 minutes it
could be 40 minutes you know in some
place of the world for some place in the
world there's maybe an hour or two of
daylight and hours uh 10 minutes
on the other hand you have on the long
summer days or in some place in the
world where it's daylight you know
uh 22 hours a day so an hour could be
almost two hours
these are called shows manias the
question is the 60 minute hour
is there such a concept
say of course there's a concept i have a
watch and after the uh
the minutes hit
travel 60 times an hour transpires the
question is is that a real halacha
concept is there a halakhe concept of a
60 minute hour you say doesn't there
have to be this is one of the questions
we asked him what hour did it take place
and there's no way we're asking them
what shoz mani it took place because
nobody in their right mind is aware of
what shasmani it is maybe a face first
man krishna so you look at the chart on
the on the wall so you know what time
krishna nobody is aware during the
course of the day of the shasmani if
your watch is giving you shazmani
sorry you have issues you know if you're
aware of what the the halachic hour is
at every moment of the day you know you
get
you've got something going let me know
about that no more most normal people
have no clue what the shasmani is unless
for a specific halachic but
everybody follows the 60 minute hour so
the question is
is there such a thing is that a halacha
concept you say well doesn't it have to
be it's one of the questions we asked
the witnesses
well and what's the alternative is there
an alternative and if it's not
halachically recognized where did it
come from
so come to be honest in ibishits as only
he could do
in
maybe his magnum opus on mission
review
the fact that the day is broken up into
12 hours i like them are 12 parts
it's not a pasuk
and it's not a gemara there is no
pasaken promise that says they're 12
hours in the day
we know there are seven days in the week
we know god created the world in six
days he rested on the seventh day
there is no pasaken tanakh that says
that there are 12 hours a day
not only that there's no gemura in shas
that says they're 12 hours a day
not only that
science and nature does not dictate that
there has to be 12 hours in a day
science dictates that there are days
because there's sunrise and sunset so
the phenomenon of nature demonstrate
that there are days
the phenomenon of nature demonstrate
there are months the amount of time it
takes for the moon to go around the
earth the phenomenon of nature
demonstrates dictates that there's a
year the amount of time it takes for the
earth to
go around the sun
to revolve around the sun what
now by the way
we're having this eclipse coming up on
monday you know about the eclipse
a solar eclipse will always occur on
average
because that's the day where the
the
moon gets in the way of the earth's uh
vision of the sun so really a solar
eclipse can only happen on average
technically speaking it should happen
every single era of vegeta the only
thing is the moon is not in a direct
line of vision every single average
it happens to be for whatever reason the
orchestrated the world that this monday
ever
the moon is going to get in our line of
vision of the sun at what is it 2 44 and
maybe we'll talk about that over shabbos
but
the there's not a pausing in hamish that
says that they're 12 hours a day there's
no gemara that says they're 12 hours a
day and science does not nature does not
demonstrate the other 12 hours a day so
where does it come from says
son who has
it is merely convention of society
it's made up
well we'll talk about hot sauce because
you could say nature dictates there's
hot soils why when the sun is directly
overhead that's midday so that's a
scientific
uh platitude that's a scientific
demarcation but that the day is broken
up into 12 parts
maybe it's 20 parts maybe it's 10 parts
maybe it's 9 parts
there is no source that an hour is 60
minutes
and not by nature i every society in the
world they all have the same
building blocks of time those same
segments of time ravianusan says that's
only raku has
the scientists agreed to divide the day
into segments
they divided into twelve pieces the
karushais and they called it ours
but it has no legal significance it has
no hallock significance it has no basis
they could have said there are 10 hours
in the day anything if there are 10
hours in the day
then how long would an hour be
not more than an hour and a half
an hour 15 minutes or so an hour and 20
minutes so
more than a little bit more than an hour
right if there were 10 hours in the day
it would be a little bit more than an
hour
and says
we actually divide the hour
in other words what we're discussing now
is how do we know that an hour is a 12th
of the day meaning an hour 60 minutes
the fact is says will be honest and we
divide the hour
some people divide into 30 parts into 40
parts and in his time he said already 30
or um
30 or 40 khalakim
them kane
had to hirolano
so now the question is if an hour is
merely a societal convention so why does
the mishna say
that when we ask a question one of the
questions is what hour did it take place
that means the torah is saying
we need to ask the witnesses what hour
took place but an hour is not a halacha
concept the answer is like this
really what the torah means says son is
not what hour took place
hour in the mishnah means
the
general time of the day for example when
the sun is in the east
that's called the morning hours when the
sun is in the west that's the afternoon
hours and the sun is directly overhead
that's midday that's all shaw means in
the mishnah but once society has come
together and has agreed upon that
they're 12 hours a day and there's one
o'clock two o'clock three o'clock four
o'clock
in the
rice predictor
the more exacting you could be in your
cross-examination the better off you are
but it doesn't mean midday rice on a
directional level we need to ask the
adam what hour did it take place because
midori raisa there is no such thing as
an hour an hour is arbitrarily made up
unit of time they could have easily made
up an hour as 90 minutes could have been
30 minutes it could have been one minute
and la maisa i know people even today
their hour is much longer than an hour
because when they tell you they're gonna
do something in an hour
they still have the biblical definition
of the hour and it could be you know to
be done with capsules that they tackle
hold there's no such thing as an hour
and the truth is there isn't it's just
societal convention and once society
agreed upon a 60-minute hour when the
mishnah
means the hour
very interesting
something i was not aware of if you
would have asked me
uh before i research this topic where
does an hour i would say it's got to be
somewhere in the torah
and in fact we're going to see
how does ruby anderson deal with so many
gemaras and shaas that do mention the
concept of the hour but that's the ruby
sun that an hour is not a halachically
binding
unit of time comes our samayah
comes ramir simkov davinsk in his
commentary to the rambam and incredibly
in hilchoice edos
comes our sameach and he quotes
innovated a wondrous and true thing
so first of all
uh the arsenic says the kid is
second of all he says not only is it
incredible it's also true
sometimes you could hear this it's
incredible the only thing is
whether it's true you know who knows
sometimes you could hear a true but it's
you know it's pasha
so it's wonderous it's true that what
that when hazal say that one of the
khakiros that we ask the adam is what
hour it does not refer to the convention
of the societal hour because that is not
halachically binding that is not the
kawan of the torah says says
now look carefully how he paraphrases
12 hours is not a pasuk
and it's not halal
now that's not what reviewed said
the words of janus and i bishops were
it's
and it's not in a gemara
the way the art paraphrases it he says
it's not a passage
and we'll see that might be very
important well says our samaya based on
this reviews we can answer the question
of toy swiss in
rosh hashanah
on
that field
twice just asked the following question
the sheet of rabbi huda
is that tu edim can be off by a half
hour
normally the two of them have to get
their story straight they have to have
uh their story has to coincide but
ashita is
you know within a half hour
each aid could be off by a half hour so
the gemara says
that if one aide says that something
happened
in
the third hour
excuse me if one eighth says something
happened in the fifth hour and another
eighth says something happened in the
seventh hour
a dusan battalion
fracked isis
why is it but all
if one eight says it happened in the
fifth hour and the other eight says it
happened in the seventh hour maybe
really it happens at what time
at six o'clock
and the aid that says that it happened
in the
fifth hour it's the end of the fifth
hour
no no in other words
if
that's what
maybe it happened in the middle of the
sixth hour at what time
it happened let's say 6 30. let's say it
happened at 6 30. yeah and the eight
that says the fifth hour it's the end of
the fifth so it's come at six o'clock
and the eight that says the seventh it's
the beginning of the seven so it's seven
o'clock so each one is only off by a
half hour and their story would be
considered uh
um
you could you could reconcile the two
statements because each one is only off
by a half hour why does the gemara say
that if one eighth says five o'clock the
other eight says seven o'clock the story
is no good maybe it happened basically
the middle of the sixth hour and when
that one if what basically like this if
uh one eight says the fifth hour one
eight says the seventh hour maybe it
happened in the middle of the sixth the
guy who said the fifth hour he meant the
end of the fifth the guy who said the
seventh hour he meant the beginning of
the seventh and nobody is off by more
than a thirty minute segment
so it says our samaya according to or
beyond rabiani bishops
the two testimonies are not reconcilable
why
because an hour is only the additional
question that we asked to aid them
now that there's a concept of an hour
but the original question of isa shah
was not what hour was it the original
question was
what segment of the day was it when the
when the sun is in the east or is it the
sun is in the west and you can have two
adam contradicting each other regarding
whether the sun is in the eastern sun's
rest and if one eight says hour five and
the other is ours says hour seven they
don't yes in terms of the time segment
which is the added question that could
be reconciled but in terms of the basic
question what segment of the day did it
happen that they have different stories
and that cannot be reconciled but says
if one aide says the third hour and one
eight says the fifth hour that could be
reconciled and la maisa that would not
be a contradiction says
based on this
of ravianasan ibishuts okay by the way
so again shaw's mania
perhaps that would be on the dirichlet
level there might be a concept of a
halachic hour where you'll break up the
daylight into 12 parts
and depending on the season the hour
could be between a half hour and two
hours but the 60 minute hour
says if you understand irish says it has
no basis in aloha
and we know we do use the 60 minute hour
because when we ask the a the more time
it was the the carbon is to the what
hour that people agree upon okay by the
way the play yeshua
in massachusetts
also says this is
that the fact that they're 24 hours a
day
has absolutely no basis
there is no makar that they're 24 hours
a day
yeshua says again there could be 24
halachic hours 12 halakhah hours of the
day in
but the concept that you break up the
entire period into 24 equal hours says
if anything we're going to break up the
day into 12 halachic portions depending
on the season
and sometimes it could be less sometimes
it could be more but the concept that
there are 24 equal parts of a day
it's not even true it has no basis
no such thing
nobody's denying the fact that the watch
was uh invented what in the 18th century
that we got yeah the fact that people
invented watch does not now make it that
hour
is a halachic segment of time it's just
something that was invented
to the egyptians who developed the use
of sundials right around the same time
okay
so we took it from them or we didn't
take it
we just
you know everybody agrees that's a
convenient way to
okay that's the opinion of avenues and
ibishits
miracles happen you know
is the sheet of robinus and i bishops
and our samaya and the play yeshua that
24 hours in a day is a convention of
society here's the question
the question is like this there seems to
be sources in the sukim for hours for
example pasuk says that moshe tells the
people don't worry i'm going up for 40
days and i'm going to be back by the
sixth hour on the 40th day and the posix
says
the people saw the sixth hour came
so what happened at the end of 40 days
the saturn came he made the world very
cloudy so it looked like the sixth hour
came and uh the saturn said where's
moses
so they said he went upstairs yeah but
the for the sixth hour came they didn't
pay attention the sutton said he died
they didn't pay attention so he showed
them an image of misha lying in his
deathbed and then they said aaron you
know we gotta we gotta do something here
where in the world is my shabbino but
the lotion of the pasta
is the sixth hour came
so doesn't that mean that the torah
recognizes ours
doesn't refer to shasmani when martial
said i'm coming in the sixth hour he
meant
the halachic hour he meant six hours
into the day
so there's a say for a new say from a
goddamn kadasham
he says that uh rabianis and ibishits
would have to say
that moshe never said the words i'm
coming the sixth hour what did he say
but now that society agreed that there's
something called ours and it happens to
be that khatsu is the sixth hour
because i'll stick it back into the
puzzle
i don't like that answer
or not
they're telling you what the tradition
is from harsinai as the meaning of the
pasta they're not telling you like a
cute thing that comes out really sweet
now that people got together and
invented something called time
so this is somewhat of a question on
ruby honest and ibishits the pastor is
acknowledging the concept of six hours
another question
says ten things were created on sunday
look number ten
um
says rashi what does it mean the
measurement of the day and the
measurement of night rashi says it was
created on the first day 24 hours a day
the concept of 24 hours a day was
created on yamiche seems to indicate
that the 24 segments of time was
a very
very old invention
so again the magadam khadashim says
an answer that i don't quite get he says
that rabbi and ibishits would have to
say
that once society created 24 hours
then all rashi means is that the 24
hours
is what it was referring to when the
segments of time were created not sure
exactly what that means so
if there was no such thing as 24 hours a
day
then it wasn't created on young region
what exactly was created on your recent
rashi says the 24 hours
so what does it even mean
rashi seems to say the length of the day
was created by our meshing again it
seems to indicate not like reviews
that the concept of 24 hours a day was
already created on the first day of
creation
here's another kasha
he did i don't have a good terrace for
it
i'm not going to tell you a bad
terrorist i don't understand what he's
saying sakasha on him
i'm sure he has uh i'm sure he'll be he
would be able to defend himself
lefiania's daity it's uh it's hard to
explain how would reverend snyder should
deal with that come on
takes out that gemara
oh okay i'm gonna i'm gonna i'm gonna
talk about that
yeah
because right there
okay we're going to a very good point
because our samak when he says over ryan
iverson says it's
not a passage
the way that arsenal says it over it's
not a pasuk and it's not halal
which probably the reason why he says
that is because there are gemaras that
talk about the hour
but what we're going to say is means is
gumara could sometimes mean gemara
gemara we have no ha tradition
gave us the torah he said and by the way
the day is 12 hours and an hour 60
minutes that's what we're going to see
in ambitiousness again because we see
the gemara does talk about hours
here's a very interesting one
if i were to ask you nobody knows this
i didn't say nobody
but almost nobody
what is the how do you say morning in
hebrew
how do you say
evening era and how do you say afternoon
saharayam right of course of course
where by the way where in humish does it
say saharayam
nowhere it doesn't appear
it does not appear in the comments
most people say it's alright is in the
afternoon right no
sarah has nothing to do with the
afternoon
what is saharayam
the first four hours of the day when the
sun is in the east is baker
the next two hours from boycare until
most people you know they're still
getting up in saharan you know 10 to 12
o'clock
is
not the afternoon sarayam is 10 to 12.
after the afternoon
but saharaim are the two hours from 10
to 12 the hour five an hour six of the
day says the ramban where does the word
saharayam come from it comes from the
word saihar tasalateva is like a window
why the sun is the brightest from 10 to
12.
now why is it called lashon rabbim
saharayam says ramban
since saharayam is two hours
so therefore it's called lashon robin
boykar
is one segment arab is but sarayam is
specifically two hours therefore it's
called not so hard
so what
you
definitely try to eat
you want to know uh when do you eat it
yeah
not only does it appear on homage it
also doesn't appear not in the vm next
to him and not even ishmael
say i guess you eat it after the
tsarayam you know
you want to let some macar for brunch
okay but what what do we see from the
ramen we see ramban
that if the torah is the tanakh word for
sarayam is saharayian because it's a
two-hour segment
that means the torah acknowledges
the concept of the hour otherwise we
wouldn't call it sahara if sarim is just
a modern convention then why would the
torah refer to that two-hour slot of
surround there is no such thing as a
two-hour slot
so again this is seems to be akasha on
ravionisin ibishits
now these are
when we said
these are
when the gemara says that the evangelion
created beyonce
that's saying what was created beyonce
the possibility of
but again there are many many gomorrahs
that seem to speak about the sequence of
ours the most prominent that we're going
to discuss tonight look at number 16 is
the gemaran sanhedrin that's
the gemara gives us an hour-by-hour
account of the way the first day of
creation took place which is really the
sixth day of creation when hashem made
other marishan so gemara says
very interesting
the first day the day is 12 hours shari
shaina hutzpah afari the first hour god
took the dirt and he made a mound shnia
nasa goylam the second hour hashem made
like an unfinished
golem an unfinished form shlisha's nimto
evarov the third hour hashem stretched
out the limbs of adam raviyas
the fourth hour hashem threw the soul
into man
love the fifth hour admiration stood on
his feet the sixth hour he called names
to the bahamas in the chaos the seventh
hour he got married the eighth hour he
had relations he went up to the meeta
two they came out of the meet up four it
was a very quick pregnancy and labor and
delivery in one hour it was all over
right ninth hour he was commanded not to
eat from the tree tenth hour he ate from
the tree
the eleventh hour he was judged and the
twelfth hour he was kicked out again
that's an hour by hour account of the
the first day of the creation of man
the tenth hour he was told not to eat
from the tree basically he could not
contain himself for more than an hour
but marvel
what's going on over here first of all
how do we know this hour by hour account
who told us
who where do we get it from
and number two if the gemara is saying
an hour by hour account that means hours
existed on the first day of creation
or there's another gemara navajzara
that's
the gemara talks about what does hashem
do all day
i'm sure you always wondered what does
hashem
that's what everybody says now let me
tell you what the gemara says
doesn't talk about that the gemara says
the day is 12 hours for the first three
hours hashem learns torah
the next three hours hashem judges the
world
the next then at the end of the judgment
hashem says oh i have to destroy the
world so he gets off the ki sedin and he
goes on to the kish
the next three hours
hashem feeds the world
and the final four hours hashem goes
fishing with olivia's son what
for the he sports he plays with the
laviasa that is the day that is the
hour-by-hour uh report of what the
evangelion does the first three the
first quarter of the day he learns next
quarter din next quarter fasted
and then then the last quarter of the
day
requires a whole discussion
and it's beyond the scope of this year
going fishing okay marvel said but we
see from this that the gemara says the
first three hours of the day doesn't
that mean that the gemara is
acknowledging the concept of the hour
again this may be why the arsameak when
he paraphrases and ibishits he doesn't
say
gemara but he understands the word
gomorrah means
meaning
that
all these gomorrahs may mean is that
hashem happened to do
this
in what we now call our one and hashem
happened to do that in what we now call
our two but really we have no source
that there's something called an hour
the shita ravionis and ibishuts and our
samaya and the pranayashua is that there
is no such thing as a 60 minute hour
yeah 12 meaning the day means the
daylight
though we have a tradition that when
hashem created the world he only did he
only only did bria during the the
daylight
okay
that's what some people say but the
gemara says it was 12 hours you know
even though the ramban says maybe
a day wasn't the same day
that's the sheet of ravioli
disagrees
you don't need anyone to agree 60
minutes what do you mean
there's no such thing as a minute
by the way we're going to see
even the khazanesh who says
that
they're 12 hours in a day
there's no such thing as a minute
there's no such thing as a minute and
halal there's no switching is a minute
18 minutes for mata
we don't
the concept of the 18 minutes the candle
lighting it's also
it's not it's a it's an american
invention
yeah okay so that's the that we
understand
says
that no the hour is very significant in
halacha we find that by the shriek of
the carbon tomit srita karmantomi is
determined by the hours it's shocked in
the eight and a half hour of the day
it's nikrav in the the
nine and a half hour of the day
says
so that already is not such a question
because these are shoeismanios
but then khazanesh goes further
says
since the torah itself divides the day
into 24 parts
and we call each part an hour
now the question is where did the torah
divide the day into 24 hours it says
the makhara is the gemara in rosh
hashanah the gemara rosh hashanah gives
us the exact
time frame of what is called the lunar
cycle so nasa spent something like a
billion dollars
to come up with this calculation
something that ghazal knew already for
almost 2 000 years
not until this century with a billion
dollars of nasa research did
scientists come up with this number the
gemara
intercalation of the month this lunar
cycle is not pusa me estimation
it's not less than 29 days
um
and a half
so so far we don't necessarily know that
it's ours ushneishlichesha
and two-thirds of an hour
the
and seventy-three
now by the way how many khalakkum are in
an hour
1080 okay and keep in mind that number
we're going to talk about that a lot
there are a thousand and eighty khalakim
in an hour so it sounds like a very
random number why in the world would you
divide an hour into a thousand and
eighty parts first of all it's a very
convenient number it's a number that is
there is no number in numbers that is
divisible by more numbers than the
number 1080.
obviously one two three four five six
eight nine and ten
a thousand and eighty is divisible by
more numbers than any other number
that's one reason why they picked it
we're going to learn today some of the
secrets of the number 1080. now if the
gemara says that the lunar cycle is 29
and a half and two thirds of an hour
now if an hour is a thousand and eighty
khalakim two thirds is
seven hundred and twenty khalakkum 360
360 360 is 1080.
so it's 7 20 khalakkim and 73 khalakkim
basically the lunar cycle is 29 and a
half days
and 793
says
that the month is this long and they
give us a number and hours it has to be
that an hour is a halachic segment of
time so the question is where do we from
where do we know that they're 12 hours
in a day in an hour 60 minutes
just did not agree to that organization
said it's a modern convention
it's
and he brings araya from rabiosi shita
nida
we know that if a woman experiences a
flow
on a certain day so then it could
establish that she's accustomed to
seeing on that day a day of the month
um a certain number of days after the
last flow
rob yoshi says you go by the hour
says
he says you go by the hour he doesn't
mean shasmani he means a regular 60
minute hour
if rab yoshi is pascaning that an oina
midairsa is a segment of an hour it must
be on a biblical level there's a concept
of a 60 minute hour where did it come
from rabbi sai it must be
so it's very interesting we have
like a very wide mach like us who
decided an hour 60 minutes ravionis and
ibishop says who decided the ancient
incas and
the the navajo indians they had they
convened that they got together one day
and they all got together and they said
an hour is 60 minutes
and they're 12 hours in a day you know
one maybe one shave that said uh 14
hours once she was at 10 they took a
vote and they decided on 12 hours says
60 minute hours
let's go back for a moment to the first
day that admiration was created
and the gemara tells us the mama gave us
a day an hour by hour account of the
creation of other marishan
so first of all how do we know this how
do we know this information how do we
know what hashem did in our one hour two
hour three hour floor
if you look at number twenty five the
fei taya says
that there is no indication from the
sukim of what took place on each
respective hour
all of this information says
what took place on each hour
now the feta says something very
interesting says
wait a second
you know you know they're different kind
of schools
you have some shoes they could do kris
satyar in 15 minutes
some shoes it takes them 45 minutes so
what does it depend on depends on the
misha beyrocks depends on a lot of
things
you know so in some places you say come
on get your act together
you know you could you could finish it
in less time
what in the world took the rebound some
so long to make man
when we made the grasshopper he said by
he grasshopper grasshopper that's it why
first he made the mounds and then he
made the golem and then he stretched out
the wind the limbs and then he uh threw
in the soul and then
just know what what's the misha barak in
between each step
says the faith iris to teach
how much ribenson loves man
that he dedicated
so much time to his creation and he did
it so thoroughly and so methodically so
the man should realize how important he
is
says very interesting thing an amazing
thing
how many hours did it take hashem to
make man
well if i were to ask you
when is man complete
isha matsutov you know when you get
married then you're complaining
so how many hours did it take for adam
to be complete seven hours because he
got married in the seventh hour
in how many days did hashem create the
world in seven days
the seven hours of the creation of adam
correspond to the seven days of brialam
the same way on the first day god said
let there be light
but the light was not defined to any
specific area
so too the first day uh the first hour
of the creation of man hashem just
gathered together the material but
nothing was separated from the other
in the second hour hashem made a
unformed image and all he did was he
said the head will be here the feet will
be there but he didn't actually
press it into forum so to on the second
day of creation hashem sort of
determined the upper waters will be here
the lower waters will be there but he
didn't actually
bring it into
actuality
then in the third hour hashem made the
limbs of man so too in the third day of
creation made the rs came to be the sort
of the limbs of the world were apparent
in the fourth hour hashem gave the soul
the soul is the light of man on the
fourth day of creation hashem created
the lights
then on the fifth day
what happened on the fifth day
of the mauritians the fifth hour of the
region stood up
the fifth day of creation hashem created
the malachi hasharis
the sixth hour adam called names he used
his sechel that's why adam was created
on day six
and the seventh hour adam was misdavig
and that corresponds to shabbos kaidash
says
there is somewhat of a question on
ravenous and ibishits before we get to
the final section of the shira
and that is if you understand ibishops
himself besides writing the uran matum
also wrote a safer on jerush called the
arastovas
and in the arustavash rabianis and
ibishut seems to say like
that 12 hours of the day are not
societal convention but rather says
if you would look at the sun
you would see that every hour different
group of malachi ashares is in charge of
running the sun
and these malachi hashares are governed
by the twelve permutations of the uk
buffet
says rabbyongasan that's why they're 12
hours a day each hour is for a different
shift of the malachi
so that sure doesn't sound like an hour
is a societal convention that sounds
like there's something
inherent in the concept of an hour
but if you look carefully
at the words of the aristowash look at
number 27 the aristotle says
that because there are 12 permutations
of york gay and their 12 shifts of
malachi
the ancient civilizations therefore
agreed it would be convenient to name
segments of time based on the twelve
shifts of malachi
so in other words robinson is basically
reiterating his position that the
concept of an hour is a modern
convention even though it was agreed
upon based on
real uh real reasons
okay marvelous i fasten your seat belts
even ravionis and ivashitz who says
that the hour is modern convention
but on a deeper level we're going to
find that the concept of time
is rooted in the deepest secrets of
kabbalah we'll just give you a little
flavor so we know they're 12 hours a day
there's 24 hours in a an entire day and
how many khalakim are in a 20 in
an hour 1 000 and 80. so the question is
where in the world did a thousand and
eighty hawaikim come from
comes rabbenu
and very mysteriously rabbina bakayi
says on the passage in qadosham look at
number thirty
al tiffnu el hualilam
he is commenting on the pathway into
hilum look at number 28
in your hand is my times we say god in
your hand is my times says
30.
it's coming to elude
that the great name of hashem
that we darshan in it zash milla
this is my name forever le allam siv
it's spelled without above
koilel it includes bitsy roof choice and
the combinations of ours shaheen your
base beyond twelve during the day the
youth baseball is twelve in the night
and it includes in it all the seconds
and the simmon of the seconds are
epashaba
and if you turn around the first letter
onto four sides
you'll get all the seconds of the day
and therefore a person should be very
careful not to divert his mind from
hashem even for one second a day
so there's just one very simple question
and that is what in the world is he
talking about
what does he mean that's the secret of
the passage
what does this have to do with the past
exact shamila
what does this have to do with the pasta
epa
and what does he mean if you turn around
the first letter of the allah phase on
its four sides you'll get all the
seconds over there
so in the footnotes on rabbina bakaye
he sort of uncovers
his gleaning is is plucking the secret
of time from the sukkam of the torah
first we have a pasaken tehillah
24. that's the 24 hours a day
now the word eta is a very interesting
word
what does it say mean my times plural
what's another way of saying times
can i tell you a soy now
we know the aloe phase each letter has a
numerical value aleph is one kuff is a
hundred ratios two hundred chin is three
hundred tough is four
hundred well now what do you do how do
you get more than four hundred
so we once spoke out men at the end of
letters the final letters
the final half is 500 the final mem is
600 the final nun is 700 the final pay
is 800 the final sadhi is 900 and what's
a thousand aleph which is one is also lf
a thousand yeah
fine
so the word e tim i in is 70.
tough is 400.
uh it is 10
endomem
is 600.
i in a 70 top is 400 yod is 10 and the
amendment 600
1080. the word itim is numerical value
1080. this is the source for 1080
khalakim in an hour
okay
continue
says
this is the site of zeslam
the numerical value of shimmy
that's the way it's written shmee is
350.
what's
is
laminating is a hundred mem is six
hundred seven thirty three fifty and
seven thirty is
ten eighty zero twelve hours a day
shamila alam is 1080 1080
what's the secret the pasak and yashaya
apasha
aleph is lf a thousand pay is 80
shah 1000 1080 khalakkum in a second
but the question marv
is what does
mean at the end of his words
that if you take the first letter
and you turn it on its four sides
you'll get the number of seconds in an
hour
and the commentary on the bottom says
that one is really deep
but
you how can we stop here you're gonna
you're just gonna say ah that's very
deep what does
you mean
there are literally dozens of perushim
and the sephirah kabbalah what
i'm gonna tell you two perusian okay
two
royce in the name of hashem that they're
moments in an hour
here's the first one okay
if you take the rabbit says if you take
the first letter
and you roll it on four
you get the number of seconds so let's
do that what's the first letter of your
kevke
now let's spell you
lua
yud vav dalit
what's that
20.
now we're going to spell out the holy
quebed which is 20 we're going to times
it by the yud
20 times 20 is
400.
hey is he aleph
20 times 6 is
120.
love is
aleph
what is that
excuse me vote you'd love
what's above you above
22. what's your times above 20 times 22.
no
20 times 22.
440.
very good and then back to the hey
20 times hey olive six 120. 400 120 440
120 is 1080 1080 the seconds of the day
you got it
okay
that's 20 times good times hey times
love times hey is
1080 meaning
time is created by the particles of
god's name
so you have to use your time wisely
because hashem is doing you a favor he's
using his name to grant you time he's
giving you a thousand and eighty moments
in an hour it's created by the yurt
kevke
the shlo rejects this shot he said i
heard this chat when i was a young boy
but he rejects it i'm going to tell you
aside please remember this only for the
rest of your life
when you spell out the uk of k there are
two ways of doing it
you could use the aleph system or you
could use the youth system
you could make vav spelled v
and hey hey aleph you could use aleps so
hey could be hey aleph and v could be
or you could use the youth system hey
could be hey you'd
and love could be above you
but you can't pick and choose says
you can use a
aleph with the hay and a yud with the
vov either you got to use yud both ways
or aleph both ways now amazing thing
it's it's
um
if you use the youth system listen
carefully to this is unbelievable
if you use spell out yod kevakke bimi
luai with the yud system
so yo it is
hey is he yod
love is
and then the hay is hey and then a yud
using the youth system throughout you
add that up that's the 72 letter name of
hashem the youth system of 72 letter
name the aleph system is the 45 letter
name of hashem but says the show you
can't mix and match
so here therefore i'm going to throw out
to you what the schla offers as
his shot in the words of
i'll let you think about this as you go
to sleep tonight
and that is
if you take the aleph when the when the
brow benevokai says take the first
letter he means if you take the ois
aleph
and you would join it aleph with the
that's 11. then olive with the hay is
six and i'll lift with the vav at seven
and i'll put the that's six
now how many kudos are there
there are six nakudis there's heric
there's
shiva tsaring
now if you have
two letters
then how many different permutations of
nakudas could you have in two letters
36 each
right
each letter could have six different
akuda so in two letters you could have
36 different permutations
so if you if you put the aleph with the
yud
36 ways
and then the aleph with the hay 36 ways
and then the olive with above 36 blades
and then the olive or the hey 36 ways
you have 1080.
so what are we going to do with that
okay you ready for this this is one of
the most unbelievable kinds i ever heard
you know why there are 1080 particles in
an hour
how many times does a human breed being
breathe in an hour
i checked it up today
it's
a healthy person an adult 15
to 20
an average of
1080 times an hour
each breath that you take is coming from
one of the a thousand and eighty
different cultures of your kfk
every time you breathe we vanish them is
like
mixing different letters to give you the
kayak of that breath
that's the shot says the
qadosh
think about how tolerant the evangelion
is
in an hour
1080 breaths an hour
the reason why they're a thousand and
eighty particles in an hour is because
they're a thousand and eighty breaths in
an hour
each particle and each breath is coming
from a unique kayak of the yurt cave fk
whether it's you know the yurt kev kevin
me luway times the utv or it's the 36
different nakuda
whatever it is says the
this is what it means god is a melech
look how suffering hashem is look how
tolerant he is he has to mix up his name
and zap you with strength for every
breath you take
think about how important it is to
utilize every breath of life for aveda's
hashem because every breath is a unique
gift from the rebounding club
and yet if we don't use our life for the
um look how tolerant he has to be look
how much he has to do for us
and yet he sort of tolerates the fact
that we don't use the gift for what we
need so let's end let's end in the
following way
this year will be a little among us i
got that so
that's right that's right bottom line is
if you understand bishop says that the
hour is a modern convention it's a
societal convention
however rabbi sai
what sort of seems to indicate more like
the khazanesh that units of time the 60
minute hour is something that is based
in the sort of building blocks of the
universe is the fact that in all the
svarim they speak at length about the
significance of the hours of certain
things i'll give you a few examples and
then we'll call it a night for example
the matters tells us that the arhagana
is the original light of creation
how long did it last for
we know it lasted for 36 hours 12 hours
friday afternoon and the 24 hours of
shabbos
what do you mean how long did it last
for there's no such thing as an hour
apparently there is a concept there's a
torah concept there is something called
the 60 minute hour
or i'll give you another example the
medara cites three instances of people
who cannot wait six hours one we already
mentioned claudio so cannot wait to six
hours until my sharabino came down
adam harishan within six hours of his
being born he was already you know
chased out of ganeden
and sisra sister also says
excuse me it says madua
came in the sixth hour
within six hours so she is an hour
two more examples
how long should a person prav shabbos
yeah i don't know you know
you start 18 minutes before shikiya and
you go at least
50 minutes
72 minutes
apida ariza writes many places shabbos
is 31 hours
now i'm not sure if he means mom is
shabbos but the kadusa of shabbos has to
be nimshak 31 hours and arizona explains
from
on friday you ready limit your
activities
is that six hours 24 hours on shabbos
and an hour of malava malka so what he
means is
the sanctified dimension of shah this
last 31 hours
and the rem is is that rizal says the
rem as a result says is kale malachi
and it comes to combat the 31 forces of
the malachan that yeshua bennu conquered
when he came into here
what's the reason talking about 31 hours
of out there's no such thing as an hour
the bay sauce car has so many drugstores
also says this i reason that the 31
hours on shabbos i found an incredible
ramez because if you look in the rambam
and they say for hamitz voice the
mitzvah of zakharov
is
31 of course
that's a raya to that reason all that
right we need 31 hours what are you
darkening hours an hour is a modern
convention
avraham because how many days of pesach
are there seven days seven days 24 hours
what's 24 times 7
168.
but you already have to stop stop um and
burn the comments
that's another six hours 174.
added a the eleventh hour an hour before
so there are
175 hours that it's awesome to have
comments
and that's how long abraham avenue lived
175 years that's why pesach is connected
out from aveeno what do you mean hours
there's no such thing as an hour
one last one
benedict says
are 40 days
how many hours a day
what's 40 times 24
nine hundred and sixty
the number of lugimun amika amikvah has
960 look the yume ello and the yaman
noiram are like a mikvah like ravikiva
says
name
um
that anybody who traverses through the
other naram is purified through the
mikvah yamnaram let's see darshaning the
hours i thought an hour according to
understanding ibishuts is just a modern
convention a societal convention
this would all seem to indicate that
there's something very deeply rooted in
the concept of a 60-minute hour
or maybe you could say no
we once said in ashira
that
and we used it to explain the veneer
salsa
we said the following concept it could
be ravenous and ibishits is absolutely
correct
and i'm sure he feels he is
that an hour is a complete invention of
society so what do we have all these
drushes on the number of animals
the answer is divarium gaddailam a
number
that even if it's an invention and even
it's something that society created but
if the
protest had it that the world created a
system of time called a 60 minute hour
even if it has no halachic significance
that means ribanus shalom orchestrated
that it should be agreed upon this unit
of time there must be meaning to it even
though maybe it's not rooted in sukhen
and it's not rooted in gemara and we
don't have allah
it is possible that nevertheless you
could ascribe significance to it
as there is this concept that if the
protest had it that this is what makes
up time and this is what mankind accepts
as a unit of time
we could then offer and try to delve
into well why did the hashtag
have it that this was the amount of time
that people agreed upon
rabbi
have a great night thanks for coming and
use your time wisely
you've just experienced another torah
class brought to you by torahanytime.com