Parshas Emor: Are Kohanim Today Legitimate?

this store class is brought to you by Tora anytime.com Hills New York we have a lot there's a lot to talk about we we have um I coming up black boimer coming up I've always said today we're going to talk about kohanam here today yes hopefully we'll still be friends Okay so so the um tells us in this week's parisha Isha is a woman who's a Zona now zyna here is not in the colloquial sense but rather a woman who has prohibited relations is rendered woman who has become disqualified to Kahuna cannot be married a woman who's divorced from her husband cannot be taken the Cayenne is Holy to God well both say what happens if in fact a kohane does marry a grusha does marry azina what's a halacha we force him to get divorce kaifen is we force him to get divorced the question is you can't do Force someone to get divorced The Garrison has to be baratsun right the answer is so we take a hammer and we smack him on the head and he you know and we say you want to get divorced no no we smack him again yeah yeah I want to get divorced so here's a woman she she was married and the husband died without children and what happened was so now she falls to even to the deceased brother in order to extricate herself from the zika she performs khalisa she takes off his shoe she spits she's called the khalusa Maria foreign what if a kahin marries a khalusa the answer is even though it's initial job we take our Hammer we smack him on the right side we smack him on the left side we keep on hitting him we take cattle prods and we yeah we do whatever we had to do until he divorces his wife right Sani well let me tell you a little story Once Upon a Time there was a man who is a coin and he was a well-established coin every time there was the first Dalia available yeah also fine and we give it to him Mondays Thursdays Shabbos morning by minha every time there's a a bar mitzvah who speaks first Yanko Ben Vero because he's a coin every time there's Amazon for 15 years the man is then he gets up he meets agrusha he likes her and then get married and they say he said what do you mean you're okay whoever said I'm a coin so the uncle you always got the first Aliyah someone's gotta get the first Ellie Bianca you always spoke first someone has to speak for your uncle you always benched but but you got called up as a Cayenne you know what I I just like the covet but I'm not a coin I I tricked everybody who says I'm a guy I'm not a coin it was a big scam so this is a Shyla brought in the pistol Avenue who are the ancestors and they say somebody who has established himself as a koyan for 15 years Canada all of a sudden turned his back on everything and say you know what I only did it no if you're an established he says on the fourth line boys the coin cannot argue and go against what he has been established for a long time because he says even 30 days isakazaka even to kill someone certainly hazaka 15 years but he's giving an excuse that a woman who says and then says just joking I never had relations if she gives an excuse that she was just uh having a fight with her husband and so forth we believe her excuse right so what if a woman says to her husband and then a few hours later than that I only said it because uh he didn't take out the garbage but uh I I'm not really Tommy so here also he's saying I only said I'm a Cayenne asked me so is this a valid says no this in this case you can't give a namasla first of all is it really a legitimate that he wanted the the covered and second of all you can't give in a namasla when you do a Misa and here he did a maisa he was he took the benching he took the first Aliyah when you when you do a miser you cannot give a um you cannot do given a mask yeah yeah right but if but if he did a mice of going to the Durkin and acting as a client you cannot give in Hamas so if I said this is just by way of introduction to the topic we're going to speak about today and that is Kahuna bismar is there real Kahuna so you say or what's the other option the other option is there's not real that's the other option the rambam says we don't really have the roundman rates are not really kohanim they're just presumptive it's just assumed it's just we'll let things continue but they can only eat did anyone here ever hear of inert Israel when your math is Juma you say oh truma I can't eat this I'll give it to a Cayenne you ever hear you know a woman big Salah so I have him and there's a whole Shiloh what do you do with the with the challah that your mafresh some people burn it others say if you burn it you could end up chafing up your oven so some recommend you know you put it away in the freezer you put it away in the back of the freezer and then you burn it with the humps and you throw it in the garbage you wrap it up anyone over here now come on you know you mind uh taking out um this this khala I want to go send it to the client anyone here ships UPS there I have Russia of course not nobody gives holla to a coin you know why because we don't really know that somebody is a kind foreign Mr Rappaport I know so many not so fast what is if two witnesses testifying that this guy is a coin Ben planier the son of so-and-so upliney Ben Pliny and Pliny the son of so-and-so back to somebody who we have no questions about who is somebody that we have no questions about that we have two witnesses that could trace this guy back to somebody who did avoid the anonymous vet because once somebody did avoid down the Miss bayak then the best in hagodo never would have allowed any kind to avoidance unless we did a full-fledged drishavakira the fecock sayskin my name is we don't have to check any Cayenne who served on them we don't have to check any Cohen was who is a member of the Sanhedrin because anyone who served on the deck or anyone who was on the sanheden it's guaranteed that the best and hagalo did a research and they never would have admitted him to the Miss bayach or the sanheden unless he is a valid coin so the only person you could give chuma or khala to is we have Adam that could testify that he is oh we're going to talk about that okay so do we have a coin I don't know the who that's not good enough you need Aiden oh you need Aiden do we have that anymore I don't know it would be hard to say that we still have that David said they're gone no the going was was one person we need a dim yeah but he you you did the he did the we'll see we'll see okay so I've always said according to the rambam this man has that the whole the whole um institution of kahuna is based on kazaka you but we cannot use kaihanna for any DIN Dai Raisa unless we have a coin would seem like it would be very difficult to establish this let us start with the following we start with the chuva in the revash rivageas who was one of the S farad he was the Talman of the Run he lived from 1326 to 1408. they still say writes about the Rivage in the chuvas Afghan we know the basis then his rebbe who is the rebi of the basically safe the the maribe of Arab he would rely on the Rivas more than any okay is talking about the following Shayla in the uh in the art says foreign countries in the 14th century they would adopt any good custom that the Arabs were performing so in other words obviously they followed but if the society that they lived in had certain good uh Customs they would adopt such Customs one of the Arab Customs was that if anybody spoke badly about the rabbi or about the clergy or about the rashishiva or about the priest they would take them and they would beat them up so the Shiloh was somebody bad-mouthed okay somebody crossed the clan and if somebody would have done that in the Arab world they would have taken him and they would have taken a club with spikes on it and they would again one snack on the right side and one on the left side and one they would have really give it to him good and the Shiloh is since to adopt all good ERA practices should we beat up a guy who cursed the crane comes the revash in Sime look in the left-hand column on the third line don't touch anybody who curses a Cayenne why because we don't have them now so to say people have today 700 years when already 700 years ago they didn't have them is dubious so then why do we have koyanim no no the only reason we give a kind of first Aliyah even though we have no clue that is a kind it's just presumption status quo same thing for Libyan yeah I don't think the VMware but we're not talking about the VM yet we give a Cayenne even before a great God all but if you want to know do we really think they're kind of we why do we give them the first Aliyah it's only because of kazaka so if somebody curses you're gonna punish them we have no proof that this individual is a client says the revash writing in the 14th century 700 years ago before Spanish Inquisition before Jews were kicked out of every car country in Europe before kalmaniski programs before the Holocaust 700 years ago we didn't know who the kaihanna was let's move up about another 100 years damn who was a uh Thomas writes about the marriage Dam that Koma okay it's a play on words you know we we say hello so he play on what his name in other words we always pass and like him this is a paladica case here's a man oh here's the case you have a woman was captured she has a Huskies but the rabbanon said that you never know what the guy may have done to her if they inviolated her she would be a Zona and then therefore is okay so a woman was held captive and together with her it was another woman who was also held captive who reported to a third woman that the first woman was untouched and in other words so Sprinter was captured Spencer was captured with yenta yanta told a third woman that I ran out of Goodwill right um she she she um she told another woman that the first one was untouched it's Aid me paid Aid me paid so now the Shayla is can this woman who was captured but we have aidos Isha that she was untouched could she marry a Cayenne well the maharashtam weighs in on this is on this issue and he says you know Aid me pied we know Aid me paid we only have Araya bura from Shas that Aid me paid works that if Lady one tells lady two that somebody's husband died then the um the first woman could remarry in other words there's a halacha that is if a woman comes in and says Spencer's husband died Spencer could remarry I inovation we basically say Isha daiko um we could rely on the testimony of one woman to allow another woman to remarry even Aid me paid but we don't necessarily know that if one woman tells another woman that a woman was untouched as a shuya that that woman could marry a cayenne and the basic says you know i f sure we could extend it to such a case but we don't have absolute uh Clarity in halacha that we could rely on Aid me paid under such circumstances relations we don't We're Not Gonna we can't check such a thing you don't do that you don't check for uh and it's not always okay so then then the marriage dance says like this even if this woman testifies that the first woman was untouched was she mamished holding her hand for the entire captivity she just says in general she doesn't think she was touched but was she there every second to know possibly what could have happened even though it's very weak to say that you could accept the testimony of one woman in the name of another woman that the first lady was untouched under these circumstances if a woman was captured she could marry Akai you know why says because ashfuya is only Oscar what major abanon bism anyway and therefore it's a suffix first of all the whole is and we don't know really that and therefore it's a suffix first he says why touched or you could flip it around the other way maybe she was untouched and even if she was touched maybe the guy's not a Kanye is clearly utilizing the possibility that kohanim is again this is in the beginning of the 16th century we move on 18th century he was lived during 1734 writes about God this is the author of The ioniaco the author of the Taurus listen to the following story Tales out of Italy a koyan from Italy any Italians there oh God and he likes spaghetti Okay so we have a coin from Italy and he is a well-known coyan ogenes he gets the first Aliyah and what happened he married an Amana and this woman is not a first-time Amana she's the second time Amana now she's already you know two guys she already killed two husbands and this guy marries her and it was forgotten it was putting under the rug then after the first husband died she died without children and she was a halusa so she wasn't just an Amana she was a halusa and now because he married her and now the Shayla is does he have to divorce this woman who's a vadai khalusa Tales out of Italy why what is well comes with and he says of course he would have to divorce her that Allah is that if you marry a khalusa because she should be awesome but lo and behold looking at the chuvas of the revash and looking at the chuvas of the maharashdam they say anime suffix um a little different than the mashdam said it maharashdam said that if a woman who's a shmuya has aidos that nobody touched her then the coin can marry her and here are the schwesiaka was quoting the maristam that a full-fledged because it's a suffix and therefore says the the schwas is okay and then he says what about the fact that there's a concept of Israel let's say I come into show and everyone they're serving peanut butter sandwiches after you walk out you grab a peanut butter sandwich and they hand me one I say I'm not eating that that's that's pork and then I say an hour later you know what I'm hungry am I allowed to eat it I can't eat it because I have considered it pork I made it pork whatever the Lum this is whether it's there's something called Surah so why don't we have the same thing over here this Cayenne he's been docking for you he's been getting the first Alia for years he's considered himself a coin he's re he's established that he will not marry a group so he will not marry khalusa so then maybe since we should force him to get rid of the khalusa no says the uh we're not going to deal with first of all he says only by dine direisa and second of all he's not really making himself a Cayenne he's not making himself more of a Cayenne than his father he's just doing what his father did and we would say the same way his father had no clue he was a claying he also has no clue he's a kind so he was never shavier he's making somebody into into an Israel he's he is what he didn't do it no no but he he had already established himself for 20 years that he would not marry halusa so now that he ended up fully ended up living with a woman and it turned out she's a khalusa we should say he can't live with her because ends off like this look in the last line on the page number page two the bottom right hand uh column here's the option if he wants to divorce his wife wonderful and we'll we'll Lord him and the rabbi will get up and show that this guy is a good guy he's a mahmir and he did the right thing and we would even force him maybe and convince him to divorce his wife and scream at him because at the end of the day he's pushing his children from Kahuna his wife no Garrison is a very difficult thing like the gemara says that they prefer to allowed he already maxed out on 18 wives to be miyahed with avishak instead of divorcing his wife caution Garrison and therefore since bismar we are not really sure that if a man ended up marrying a khalusa they stay happily married if they liked him Rabbi Sai we're only getting started here this is just the beginning comes of Yakov emden writes in the ivitz are you with me this is what can you do you know right that if a Korean wants to return the money of Ben he can however you cannot give the claying money otherwise maybe the Pina Ben is ineffective but if the coin wants to return the money afterwards he can the law yeah the coin should not get into the habit of keeping the money why because then the other Kahan am I going to lose out because then everyone's going to come to him right so the coin should not get him to the habit of giving back the money of of giving back the money exactly comes the rabiac of emden and the Shameless and shilohn hey to return the money the right thing foreign and so is appropriate always to do says that a coin should not get into the habit of doing that if you're a kind Erman so even though will be will be the cayenne and will have to be paid to steal money from other Jews that's for Sean how does the Queen have the right to keep the money he's a got him he's a gosling he's not gonna keep the money who says he's a coin he's only a selfie crying so means something he's gonna steal no Cayenne has to give the money back the client's not eating chuma and they call it how could the coin be over on gazella not only am I saying this is a good thing to do I would say that a coin is obligated to give the money back and at least a God-fearing kind should suspect on his own and return the Cayenne return the money and therefore to be I'd say every suffix every time a father you're gonna miss the best part every time a father sees a client he is obligated to redeem his son again because chances are the first Cayenne was not a kind and therefore God nearly shallots more than that anyone here a firstborn yes but your mother was a kyenas or Olivia so you didn't have a pig in that bed no no no well if you were then says of Yakov then you should do we know that a firstborn doesn't do opinion event if your mother was a kohenus I'm telling you you do need to do better man what makes your mother because she told you there so she told you that based on what how does that make her a coyannis because she told you cesariac of emden uh is obligated to redeem themselves no less than any other stuff with the Horizon because I'm here who are first born you mean not anymore no I mean before this one a coin who was the firstborn should also do pigeon of Ben Academia right but it's gonna lead to bad things because since La Mesa you have to be mahmer maybe you're a coin if you're going to do a opinion on Ben we're afraid the Clinton might go ahead and marry our grusha so in order to protect the humerus of kahuna the crying doesn't redeem himself but you want to know in the ideal world in the ideal world the Korean needs to do opinion [Music] don't make like you pointed out it's brought down that the villanue any time he saw a Cayenne his entire life he was always Pride himself because he was always concerned maybe uh maybe he did not meet a kind until they say he met a certain Rappaport who he felt was a kaime and then that put his heart at ease in Lakewood right now okay you know do we have edos then I don't know I don't know Rabbi Sai this is nothing oh more comes the I'm so Sly my and the answer someone says you know there's a concept of making haramim if you make who does it go to La coyan yeah says that we need to answer even if you say it should go to the Cayenne even if the coin already took it why is we have no genealogy commercial like we used to when they stood oh yeah or even after the hormone we had genealog back in the day is a certain type of hectares that you make that would go to the kohen nowadays you can't give it to the client we don't have we don't have um like they did in the times of the bias or even in times who they were still nizar and Shuma Centaurus and while your current they were still close to the town in the basement they still had the yes in their hands but in our because of our many sins because the goddess has been so long ogazeros vegeroshima's Babylon we've been chased out we've been Hackney we've been we've been attacked we've been persecuted we've been abused how and then he says a very frightening thing is you know keep don't talk too much halavai the Israel should be able to say definitively that he's Jewish so before you uh don't talk too much don't investigate too much that the the regular lineage of classical should be poor V levadation is almost a hundred percent that it's not for sure and in other words we don't have a lot of things you might not want to hear right and if not every Cayenne from this and he brings Ariah like back in the day and Elio I love him I love him and if not for sure hundreds of years ago 50 of kohana 600 therefore it could come to that and therefore it says unfortunately because of what we've had to withstand but we because what we've had to endure throughout so many years of Galos he would like he would suggest that every last one of them is not a kind anyway and if not every last one of them definitely most of them half of them are not going to create a disturbance in the shoes it's um okay I know what do we say about the koi engine the only thing it shows is that they have some type of DNA of kahuna mixed into them but it doesn't show it's from the father doesn't necessarily show that uh it's from the father it could come from the mother it could come from whether that's enough of uh edos or it's admissible and uh in halacha to give somebody Raisa probably not but rapidly they say they do have anything and they prove about the court they claim they have that okay I hear him so so far we've brought many um of the most fundamental Place game Who seriously question the validity of kahanim this starting with revash going to the maharashtam coming going to the schwas AI one of the main questions that are raised um and this is brought up I Believe by the schwesiakos that the and the reverse himself mentioned this let's go back to number five for a moment and they say koshikan because [Applause] you're a client really where is it's like a guy comes into City Hall me citizen really where's your citizenship me lost it and where's your passport oh I'm not good question no and your green card oh yeah my green card I left it at home so you say you know have a nice day if you're a citizen you'd have documentation so it's the same thing we tell the guy Adam yeah really you're a Cayenne where's the star which that is really the beginning of the of the passatva for kohanim this and let us begin with Sam Cipher in number 12. some soifer in number 12 is addressing something else but in parentheses he comments on the words of Jacob then look at number 12 foreign narrowly I don't agree with him so the Sam Cipher says he does not agree with rabiac of emden that that parents should go around looking for kohanim to redeem their sons and that levium and levium should redeem themselves and if somebody's mother was a kyannis or Olivia they should redeem themselves says it would not seem to me to be the case grandson so far with Sherman Aaron Feld and he says even though the words of the zaydah ain't because Hashem Cypher nevertheless we have to try to explain why doesn't the samsifer agree with raviakov just dismisses with Yak of emden he says they know nearly it will not seem to me to be the case well we have over here the South which is really um the the same Shiloh that we brought up earlier in the piscay chuva in Simon vava is out the number three on the sheet where this question what came to him from Venice from Venezia and about who was the son of avram who acted as a kind for 15 years and then decided to marry a grusha he said no no no no he says because even kazaka is a very strong thing either the gemara tells us and I saw yosin all Jewish families have a certain presumption and we'll have to explain what this means because even though rabbis that we mentioned that the reverse says that if um somebody curses a Cayenne so we should not punish him because on the same token the revash foreign between the revash himself on the one hand the river says that if somebody curses a coin don't do anything to the guy because who says the kind is a kind on the other hand if a coin marries a Grisha and you have this other on your sheets the revashi is in number 18 where the reverse says that if someone marries a coyan so how do you reconcile this stira in the revash so the stage if you look at number 17 in [Applause] um I believe and he writes as follows he says that either to answer and to reconcile this contradiction in the revash he quotes the safer Yad Yamin this is in the left hand column of number 17 and the Yad Yamin says like this says acknowledges the fact that there's a presumption that kohana but that's only regarding them and not regarding other people we can't punish somebody because he curses a kind because this coins kazaka for us is not so strong that we should adopt the Arab Customs that if somebody curses a Kanye we're going to punish the person because the kind but Avada for the Korean himself he has to abide by his status Quoin his presumption that is a cayenne and therefore if he marries a gurusa we're going to be kaifeno it goes much more than that what's the reason why you could make the case have a nebulous the answers we say actually where's your stars is that really Italian when they when they kicked me out of Spain in 1492 and I couldn't even bring a shirt along you expect me to take a magillas and that I come from Ireland when the kamonesky programs came along and had a sneak in some sewer system you think I had time to take my style with me in the Holocaust I asked the legend in my family is that there's a yeast Breville where is it who knows where it is it didn't make its way over from Europe you have a time on a coin actually stock has only a China when every other kind in the world has a star and ukai and you're getting up for the first Aliyah where's your star but nobody has a Stam anymore it's unheard of who has a star who has a Miguel Stark has only a it only creates if other people have their style but if nobody has a star anymore mirov and my wife had Saros that's not that does not make but here's the Iker nakuda of why bismar the Kahuna has to be taken seriously [Music] says look in the statement number 17 the left hand column Aria foreign they say that Kahuna bism hasika so for example right where we want to be might see Mama could you be Mighty moment with arrive could you be Mighty mama with a ripe now you don't follow if it's an established right you could even be might see my mind says the shame since it's been followed and been practiced for so many generations foreign [Applause] we obviously don't rely on it for truma the Messiah is based on the collective uh Messiah of of the Missouri attire of the rabbanim of the of the um magidim in other words the ramam says that the transmitters of the Torah have given this over but of a specific that just a specific shaved that they gave over that he's a Cayenne it's not a Raya it's not a riot it's says but says take a look in on page six the top right hand side [Applause] and I the impoverished one IM says who am I to argue on the going yakuzu going Yakov usually the guy is even wrote a safer I believe going yakuz but here it's referring to a vacuum then because he's very powerful refrain from writing what I have to say about his holy words and he says give back the money says I have a problem with Rebecca them then because Maran bet Yosef living in 16th century and he wrote that kohanim should not give back the money I have a question for you where the kohanimous no they should keep the money says excuse me says how could you make a bracha when you do a pill in haben if there's any suffix whatsoever in the Kahuna can make a bracha so you say no well uh 50 50. you can't make a broccoli 50 50. you can't even make a Brooklyn nine d10 I'll bring you Uriah foreign ER is a separate mixer every day and yet we pass in if you miss a day you blew it you can't make a bracha why who holds if you miss a day you blew it only the bahag nobody else holds that way so why are we so concerned with the bahag shita most people never even heard of the bahag the rambam the ramban the Riff the rush the rajva the ritva everybody says it's a separate Mitzvah so why will the Sun by Spirit the bahag says you miss the day you blew it big deal behind your answer is if there's any doubt at all if you can make a bracha you can't make a bracha so if there is any suffix in the Kahuna then why wouldn't the possum say you know what is but of course you can't make a bracha the answer is you're right maybe there's an element of Suffolk but khazaka comes along and says for all intensive purposes we pass in the Korean as a Cayenne do we know for sure maybe we don't know for sure a kid hits his father he draws blood he was warned not to do it what do you do to the kid kill the kid Michael obvious who says the father is the father was anyone who says who says because the father bought him an after you claiming present you kill the kid the mother you know you have you have on Earth yeah the mother of course he killed the kid but what if he only kills the father what happens with the mother of the same thing but that's for sure you have either said there's a mother but there's no there's no other son the father yeah yeah nowadays no because there's no warning there's no best then but I'm saying hello is how do you know a father is a father the answer is kazaka kazaka no it's kazaka he's acting like the father yeah so says the same thing for Kahuna whether we know for sure or not you're right we don't rely on it for truma Di rise and we don't rely on it for khala but ultimately since the crane his father was a cut and the grandfather was once came to the rabbi he said Rabbi I want to be a client say rabbit I'll make a big donation to The Sean he says uh can you know I have some backbone have some principles Rabbi give a million dollars to the show if you make me a client the rabbits there's nothing I could do nothing I could do but tell me why do you want to be a Connie just because my father is a kind right that's good enough the fact that his father was a kind is kazaka then why do we allow kohana to make a bracha on we should say look it's only 90 10 that they're going on him the answer is and for all intents and purposes the coin is allowed to Accord himself as a claim and then comes and perhaps this is the the main reason why the Sam Cipher did not agree with the chuvas of rabiac of amdin this is a fascinating issue writes an amazing he writes in the Dogma yard base an amazing foreign go to a cover of a guy is unclear how we pass again whether a guy is it's not clear definitely a guy is pretty much even though there are some Shooters but oh yeah it's a suffix a guy excuse me a Jew a Cohen could go to a guy why sex taker What's the sex taker listen to this the ride that holds says the uh that once you're ready Tommy mace you already maxed out on your tongue you can't become more tummy the rambam says you could keep on becoming Tommy and Tommy and Tommy and Tommy derive it says once your tummy you're not gonna become more tummy comes the noise and he says you want to go be matami yourself to Lenin to Stalin no problem why specs Faker maybe the rabbit is right then once your tummy miss you won't become tummy again and even if you could become tummy again maybe your guy is not in the tummy but I am says looks I'm sorry foreign 19 I was closer I retracted I I went I went off of my sock I retracted from my sock because I used to think that the riot held once your tummy you can become more tummy no maybe that's not what the Raven means what the Raven means is once your tummy if you become more Tommy we won't give you malcus but you will become more tummy the driver didn't mean you don't become more tummy derive adjustment we won't give you a malkus but it's still Usher [Applause] when I was a kid in the year tough cuff mem gimmel what year is tough cook 1783. some server was a young man I remember in the year 1783 and I was being used was not only a talmud of his great rebbe but he was mashamish his great Webby says I remember when I was a little kid and I was serving my review of nothing Adler and it was the year 18 1783 and we passed through Prague and my Ruby had a whole conversation with you about this issue whether a coyan could be matame himself to a guy tomasoya and they were methalpel in the words that arrived and my Rabbi ravnas and Adler said no and then he said yes like he writes in the darker above and of some Cyprus said no and uh no an amazing thing is I was a go-between there's nothing Adler would send me with letters would send me letters back to the remnants and Adler and there was a whole exchange of letters says so now when you read the Dogma revava at first the United writes that a coin could be matama himself but oil to a guy and then he says he says it says now we know why they know why wasn't it because of nothing Adler prevailed and he convinced him that the Rival doesn't mean you're allowed to be matame that once your tummy you don't become more tummy the rabbit just means once your tummy we won't give you malkus if you become more attention that's why they know I'm sorry I was there I was the one who who brought the letters back and forth and me myself says I'm sorry for 30 years later in the year 1813 I found in another state for the Raven and the tummy that the rabbit Avada says that once your tummy you can't become more Tommy it's just we won't give you mankas you can become with him you you can you can become more time but you're not in other words you're not allowed to be Madame yourself so there's this famous conversation between the noise sex maker maybe that looks like the Ravid once your tummy you don't become more tummy and even if that looks like the rambam but maybe a guy's name said no that's not what the Risen means what do you see from both ravnas and Adler and the night to behuda why didn't they both agree suspects Vega because of another suffix an Adler came along and said you know what that's not what the rabbit means so what if that's not what he means there's another very simple something over here maybe Adam must be you see aside from the night of insightful or nothing other than in terms of the suffix even though we don't know yet and this is very likely for his grandson gives one shot but I think we see he obviously he saw from his Arabian from the noise that we maintain are given a certain presumption and that presumption is strong enough to say to say that they're kahanim and you could you're they're they're they do pigeon and they make a bracha and they they're noises and he sort of dismisses the first 30 minutes of our share and he says like this look at number 21. roisi I saw who who did he see he doesn't want to say but we know who he's talking to Misha Casa this is that every coin has to be to be suspicious maybe he's not a coin but after Hamas and return the money and he's high even pidgin and he has to separate the money for his own Pena Ben o in my opinion is you're not allowed to listen to such things to diminish and undermine The Prestige of the kuna you're going to come to disparage and come to disgrace heaven forbid to say such a thing he says even when Ezra came up from bovill when all the Kayana and some of them did not so even those who didn't they were not disqualified certainly the kivan he says like this not only is there no doubt you can't throw it into halachic mix you know what maybe Korean could go to the hustle because maybe they're not real Cat in other words even if you have a valid Heather or something and you're just looking for a little sniff to throw into the mix says don't even throw into the mix and maybe it's not a suffix it's not a sex maker it's not a sniff bottom line is but for what they do and the reason is they don't have a kazaka for that but for what they do have a kazaka for that allows them to do it in the fullest sense they can make a broken opinion ah you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com