Parshas Chukas: Parah Aduma - The Mystery of History

this tour class is brought to you by torahanytime.com um of course we know that the most prominent aspect of is a part of the part the red cow the red hyper as they call it and of course we know it's a hike hike means it's a statute it's a Mitzvah that has uh no apparent logic and we're going to try to see investigate if there's no logic why would Ubuntu give us a missile like this but we're going to start from a very interesting angle and that is one of the commentaries on the shokhana and the magnet room quotes and the areas are right something very interesting that a the Jewish people should cry over the burning of the Torah what does that mean they should cry with the regular Torah in the year 12 42 as the market number reports 20 wagon loads of Shas of gemaras were burnt in Paris in in France was written by the marama Rosenberg and he writes how in the year 1242 they made formal accusations against the Shas a actually a Jewish apostate by the name of Nicholas danan made a formal accusation against uh the Shahs he claimed that the gemaras the Shahs contained heretical information apicarsus and because of that they gathered together 20 wagon fulls of shots now we're not talking about the gemars in our time the Mars in our time they're printed on the printing press like that in those days the shafts were hand written a handwritten shots may take years and years and years to write so you can imagine 20 wagon loads of shots we're talking about lifetimes of work we're talking about early manuscripts of the shots the original gersados the original text and this was a terrible tragedy and actually this tragedy happened okay it happened this week Arab Shabbos of the time and they're talking about the 13th century they wanted to try to understand why is this happening why is God allowing this to happen and they did something called you know don't try it in your own homes you are able to ask to be punish some certain questions in a dream you have to be a big Sadiq okay don't try this at home and you're able to maybe ask them Allah come ask God what's going on why are these gazeras why are these decrees happening okay and they made a Sheila Shalom and they got the following response response the response was three words from this week's parisha zos if you look at number four the response was those this is the law of the Torah and then in the dream they saw the targum right we know in every Hamish on the side of the Hamish we have the target monkeys the Aramaic translation and they saw the tagamoncos in the Stream and the tagamungus was Da gizerasa this is the decreditorah so they sort of put in a petition to God why is this happening and what was the answer this is God's decree don't ask any questions this is what Hashem wants and they saw the Tiger after they saw the twenty thousand yeah they wanted to try to understand why this was happening how did they do this how did they submit this question I can reveal the procedure in public no I don't know what I'm saying wow more than that I'm not at Liberty to discuss here many many Prodigy to the Jewish people why all of a sudden you need to make uh yeah this is not the only time they did Shameless Shalom there are other instances in history for example 1648 but let's I don't know when the last time writes that they did it in 1648. okay well now here's the question okay and they're for the mug and everyone rights that every Arab Shabbos parshas is a fast day okay this is not a fast day that we keep anymore but the ancient custom was the ancient customized Arab Shabbos they would fast they would fast okay this this fast has fallen into this this use but you look in the mug and have room Arif Shabbos precious cookouts with a fasting and the Morgan Abram wants to know he asked an obvious question okay in Judaism when we make holidays or we make fast days we never pick the day of the week right we pick the day of the month right Rosh Hashanah is the first day of tushway Yom Kippur is the tenth day of tishway sukis was the 15th day of tissue chanukkah is the 25th day of kissly poem is the 14th day of ADA pesach has the 15th day on this we don't pick a day of a week to establish a holiday and also fast days what's Tish above where we pick a Tuesday or a Friday or a Sunday we don't pick a day of the week we pick the day of the month and yet when it comes to this fast day of fasting for the burning of the shots in 1242 they did not pick the day of the month that it happened they picked the day of the week and they made it a fast day Arab Shabbos we have special food in your honor special Sudan okay wash okay okay [Laughter] um so they they made this fast day not the day of the month but the day of the week why why why did this fast they were talking about a special fast traditionally Arab child is passions is a fast day we're commemorating the burning of 20 wagon loads of shots that were burnt in the year 1242 and the question is why do they make this faster day of the week they should make it the day of the month says the mug and have rum that since how did they discover that this day how do they discover what the reason for the tragedy was remember they made a Sheila's column they asked God what the reason is and Hashem responded what with three words from the Parsha Zeiss so they realized that it wasn't the day of the month that caused this tragedy something about the Parsha something about Paris brought on this tragedy the fact that when they asked God what's the reason for this and God responded in other words Hashem is saying there is something about the para aduma which is in reference to those there's something about this red cow there's something about the midsole the red cow that it brought on this tragedy and therefore they understood we have to fast Arab Shabbos what does this red cow have to do with the tragedy of the burning of this arm and where do you get everything what does it have to do well you can't fast on Shabbos you can't pass on Shabbos right it's the closest fast the closest day so Arab shout is they realize there's something about the power Shah that brought on that brought on the right over here I saved you a special place let's have to sit from which hours they have a good point so they um there's something about the Parsha that is bringing on this tragedy and this is something we want to investigate how is an innocent red cow that says move gonna bring on a tragedy that 20 wagon loads of shots in the year 1242 are going to be burnt and by the way we have we have a nice uh diverse crowd tonight so we have to say that it wasn't just in the kilos ashkenaz that tragedy struck on Arab Shabbos was on the greatest he writes then the city of Izmir where's Izmir turkey turkey you would not leave your house it was such a like a dangerous time it was such a scary time even baladat and even working people would not leave the house era of Shabbos something about the Parsha that they understood brought tragedy in the past and by the way not only in the year 1242 the tragedy strike Morgan LeBron brings down in the year which is 1648 we know the many communities in Europe are wiped out in uh the xeros of grounds also tragedy happened that two kiilos two congregations were wiped out Arab Shabbos but we have to try to understand I don't know if we should be worried we don't have to worry but what does the parisha got to do with what does the paraduma have to do with tragedy we're going to change it well she told us about the paraduma something very interesting Rashi says if you look at number seven that this is not an ordinary Mitzvah this is a Mitzvah that the Jewish people get a lot of flack for we got we take a lot of heat for the paraduma why who do we take heat from two people the Satan and the guyan what do they say look at Rashi number seven Leticia hasatan for um the Satan the nations of the world you know what monin means they insult us like Ono Esteban they insult us they say what's the Smith what's the reason for it therefore the Torah writes this is a statute there's no logic to it God says this is my decree you have no permission to question it you have no permission to question it so let's think about what's going on here we get up in the morning when actually tells us we're walking to work and Jose screams out or uh or Jacks give that hey you Jew you know that red Cam that you do you know that procedure it's absurd it's ridiculous doesn't make any sense and they insult us so God says don't worry you're right there's no reason for it just tell them it's a hook this is my decree and there is no logic it's a little bit embarrassing though isn't it embarrassing to have a mits on the Torah that the goyam insult us make fun of us and we don't have a we don't have a response we don't have a logical response normally what does it say in parque audos know how to respond to an upper chorus the happy chorus asks you certain questions you're supposed to know how to answer him so what are we supposed to answer that because when he says you have a red cow and it's so illogical by the way what's illogical about this red cow let's just get it out what's illogical what's very what we call paradoxical meaning it's uh what's paradoxical about the paraduma is that what do we use the paraduma for Tahir somebody touched a dead body or somebody was in the same tent as a dead body he becomes Tommy for seven days he can't go into the basement so what do we do we take the ashes of the paraduma right we miss we burn it we mix the ashes in a special kind of water we sprinkle it on the guy now all of a sudden this guy who was Tommy mace he could go into every mix on the world he could go into the mixah and Stalin and breast love and and uh in satmer every minute Alexa in the world even in Flatbush and it's not going to work doesn't work ah but what do we do we take a red cow we burn it we sprinkle the ashes on him and poof he's tahar the only thing is the guy who sprinkles it on him becomes Tommy huh so it's uh it's very illogical on the one hand the ashes have such purifying powers that it could purify the most intense form of Tama and on the other hand the one who is sprinkling on him becomes tummy how do you see that in Hebrew um I don't know if I don't know if it works you know I don't know if that works I'm not sure so this is a very hard Mitzvah to understand why would God give us such a mitzvah so you say does Hashem care how we are viewed by the goyan absolutely God says I have given you certain mitzvos the posix says he says I have given you certain mitzvos that you should look smart and wise in the eyes of the game specifically the Mitzvah of because uh all the astrological information that the gemara has Hashem says I've given it to you so that the goyum see what a wise Nation you are actually the sukims say that the are going to say that Hashem wants in the nations of the world to talk about how wonderful the Jewish people are how smart they are and how logical the midsos are so we see this is something God's interested in he wants us to appear Smart in front of the game he wants to go in to say oh what a logical religion what uh what a religion that makes sense and here if that's if it's so important to God that we look reasonable in the eyes of the Goliath why would he give us the Schnitzel of the paraduma even you okay the gun but even like the similar to the Jews they're gonna make it be even more fun yeah the self-hating guys yeah that's right you're right yeah so maybe you'll say maybe you'll say that the reason why now what do we want Hashem to do not to give us the Mitzvah he has to give us some it so it's part of the Torah we want God to tell us the reason why can't why can't ashant house the reason for paradoma so maybe you'll say there is no reason even was the wisest of all men right someone wrote all kinds of Michelin right is said he endeavored to get to the bottom of the paraduma to try to crack the code of the paraduma and says in kohalas I thought I would be wise I would Crack the Code but the hero called me many it's beyond me couldn't crack it so even shlo Muhammad the wisest of all man could not comprehend the reason for the paraduma on the other hand though Rabbi Sai the murder says you should take the part for yourself the matter says God told Moshe the reason for paraduma so Moshe understood it and by the way the archaima color says also understood it so Moshe understood it and I don't understood it why can't why can't I'm not sure why I shouldn't put emotions yeah well we're gonna have to see whether the eagle had a connection to the paraduma even though Rashi says it was a capara for the paraduma but it's not so simple because God commanded us about paraduma at Mara before the Torah was given even before the aegon so how could it be Kappa for the hero egal if the ego didn't even happen when when the Mitzi was given right it's like okay so Hashem tells Hashem tells mosheb they know the reason for paraduma why can't he tell us okay tell us I want to know so you say no we're not smart enough we can never understand it we can never understand it but actually the matter says the time will come when God will tell us the reason for paradigma level in the future the day will come when God will tell us the reason for paraduma now why how it's making somebody feel we want to understand how does it work you know how does it work how does it work how does it work so if God is going to tell us the reason for para aduma why can't he tell us now why can you tell us now why can't he tell something though even for hundreds of years we were tame mace and we were doing the paraduma and God hid the reason for us so do we need to know it or we don't need to know it if we need to know it I want to know right now and if we don't need to know what do we need to know and mashiach comes okay and finally we're going to address another question that we know who is supposed to do we don't need to know yeah what do we need to know for if we if we can't know now then what do we need to know when Michelle comes Michelle comes up maybe they'll be tomato what do we need to know for if we don't need to know then why is God going to tell us when Michelle comes if we need to know let's know right now okay maybe F sharp it's possible let's see let's let's try to develop this okay another thing we try to understand the procedure of the paraduma the procedure of paraduma is done only by who not a regular coin only by a coin Gaga there's one exception there's one time where the koenegade Aaron that coin was not allowed to do the paraduma who did it why why so if she says the reason because Aaron couldn't do it because we're going to give another reason this evening why Aaron was not was not needed and uh was not the one to be involved with the paraduma what so why are you not doing that okay so let's see let's see so what is it what exactly is so complicated what is so mysterious about the paraduma the paradoxical nature it's the tahara you have a guy whose tummy paraduma is you have a guy who's tahar who's pure paraduma makes him impure what in life does this symbolize there's something when you think about this idea there's something in this world that beer is a strong resemblance to this phenomenon of mataurus that's name um and that is the concept that probably the most difficult Concept in life and that is sometimes if you look around and we see bad things happen to good people and good things happen to bad people what we call sadik for Alloy rash of it you have it sadik and bad things happen you have a Russia and good things happen now don't make a mistake don't make a mistake this is not the general rule the general rule is the general rule is Sadiq him have a good rosham had a bad that's the general rule but there is there are exceptions to the rule there's always exceptions to the rule like we say just look with your eyes you'll see the wicked get paid back you listen to the radio you shouldn't but if you want to waste your time listen to radio then you'll hear about you know some uh yeah mafia guy he got he got killed at age 30. right so yeah she's a Russia he's getting what he deserves the way this movie star right he uh committed suicide all you have to do is open your eyes you'll see the wicked get what they deserve but there are exceptions things aren't going well you have a Russia and life is wonderful this is one of the mysteries of life that no one was able to understand even even uh many navium if you look on the sheet number 13. this is something like says there is something in this world that is insanity he says can't understand you have it Sadiq and what happens to him it looks like he's getting what a Russia deserves the opposite sometimes you see Russia and he's wealthy he's Rich he has everything in the world but even so this is something that nobody was able to understand something you've tried under this whole safer eov what is it about it's almost like the paraduma is right here you have a guy who's tahar what is the paraduma you sprinkle the ashes he becomes right you have someone who's tummy the ashes make him to her the guy who sprinkles on him was Tara he becomes tummy why are they having so much trouble understanding uh good things happening to bad people bad things happening to people but even with Olam Haba even with Olam Haba is something not in all cases but in rare instances something that even slow my mouth cannot understand you couldn't come to terms with it what about it Sadiq who never did anything wrong what about and even when Moshe Rabino try to understand it God said I do good to who I choose I have mercy on he who I choose God did not respond to him God did not respond to him so there is a aspect of life that's very mysterious says it's safer it's one of the sparta kudolam he uh he was expelled from Spain in 1492 we've discussed him a number of times right he lived a very interesting life his children some of them were forcibly kidnapped from him and baptized never saw them again even his manuscript said even his firm that he wrote he had to bury and many of them he never saw again and he had to rewrite from memory Abram says looking at the para Duma it Bears a strong red resemblance to this idea of sadik faralloy rashavatota so now comes along the safe of Ariel safe last week we quoted from the very Joseph we're going to quote him again this week Joseph says [Music] Sabah so comes the Barrios Joseph and he says here we have a Mitzvah what's the midst of paraduma doesn't make any sense paradoxical it's illogical we can't make any sense out of it why does Hashem want us to perform this mitzvah it's training it's practice what is it practice for it's practice so that if something comes up in life that doesn't make any sense it's illogical we can't come to grips with we're able to say the same way we perform the Mitzvah paraduma even though we didn't understand it even though it didn't make sense even though it was paradoxical but what did we say this is God's decree and we fulfill the Mitzvah even though we don't understand it we accept God's will Hashem gave us a mitzvah to get into the Habit to practice to accustom ourselves that when Hashem says something when Hashem decrees something and we can't understand that we can't come to grips with it what's our reaction we accept the fact this is xeriformation this is God's decree so what we're doing is we're practicing we're getting into the habit of all coming to grips of those events in life that we don't understand God specifically designed a mitza for us that we don't understand so that the next time something happens in life sometimes even good things we don't understand you know why was uh why did this person win the lottery why did that person marry this person like some things they don't make any sense things happen in life that we can't understand and how do we come to grips with it the gemara says otherwise known as acher was once walking down the street and he sees a tongue in the street and he asks whose tongue is this and the gemara says this was the tongue of one of the great tanayam who would obey the metrogaman when the sheer was given in the basement was he served sort of as the loudspeaker and he spoke the share out loud and his mouth only spoke words of Torah who was a great town who was walking in the streets and he sees the tongue of this Sadiq rolling in the street among the pigs he could not understand how a mouth that only spoke words of Torah could suffer yeah okay well we'll look into it after he couldn't understand it right and what did he say he went off he went after that he lost it he became an Abbey chorus he saw three things he became right he saw this otherwise known as why it didn't make sense no it didn't make any sense to him how could this Sadiq whose tongue only spoke with of Tara suffer such a fate that's the point it doesn't have to make sense to us that's the point but it's very hard for the human mind to come to grips with something that's irrational so what what's going to tell him he's good but even so even so it's excellent why does he have to suffer in this world he gets a better seat up front so let him get a good seat in this world and a better suit in the world to come no but there's no emphasis okay we're gonna come through the Akiva we're gonna come through we keep in a moment but this is something that's very hard to understand with all the with you all the explanations and all the commentary and all these study and all the analysis in the Final End Result you see something like that it can make you lose it you can't understand it and therefore the Mitzvah of para aduma was God was training us to be able when we come to something we don't understand what do we say we don't understand why we don't know why God the Creed and we do and therefore so that when something happens that we don't understand we've already accustomed our minds and our hearts to the attitude that we don't have to understand everything that happens in this world because it's not our world we don't run it we don't control it we don't make the decisions we don't make this decision in fact all the time all the time no everyone was wrong well no because the person who became Tommy from the paraduma he doesn't become tame he becomes rishonda he could just go to the Mikvah okay so it's not this it's not Thomas mace yeah okay we have a very interesting okay tells us what are you doing what are you doing now look I'm uh I'm fixing the letters on the top of the safe return we know the letters in the Sabbath certain letters have crowns Gates certain letters have crownsome was you know fixing up the different crowns on the letters so Hashem says I want you to know there's going to be somebody well after you by the name of Akiva Ben Yosef who will be so great in Torah that he'll understand everything he'll understand even the reason for every little line that sticks up from every letter of the elephants not only that every line that sticks up from any letter of the Akiva could tell you mountains and mountains so Maisha says that's it I Quit why'd you choose me to give the Torah I'll let you know safe give the Torah Hashem said be quiet that was my decision I chose you okay then Hashem Moshe says let me see rabi Akiva Shir let me see what kind of sheer he gives sashem brings him into rabikiva Shir and Hashem you want to say no no you can't sit here samosha goes to the next row no that's not for you it's a third or no you sit in the eighth row all the way in the back that's where you belong in this year so Moshe is sitting in this year and Rabbi Kiva is giving share keeps giving share he can't believe you ever go to a class you don't understand you know sometimes you feel bad you think is it me and I am you know maybe I'm not that smart emotion felt bad motion felt bad you know he can't believe this someone was giving a sheer on the level that he you know it was above his level and until somebody asked me to be keep a question maybe Kevo what's the reason for this said there's no reason there's no reason for it God told motion someone should have calm down he felt better he felt better then then you showed me rabikiva's Torah show me his reward Hashem opens up the screen you know whatever I don't know what they had in Chennai and he shows him Akiva being raped with a metal comb they he showed the very terrible death Arabia Akiva so moshabino says this is Torah and this is the reward so Hashem said be quiet that's what I decided by the way the Schleich others rights we know it says Rashi says God wanted to create the world right but he still wasn't going to work out so he he joined together DIN and Rahman right what what words does Rashi use it was Allah to create the world so when Hashem says quiet what he meant was I am dealing with the way I meant to create the world the way it was Allah to create the world of middles for the rest of the world they couldn't handle it so okay that's a separate thing says God is setting up moshrabena he's he's array he arranged this whole charade almost how did he set him up first Hashem has the Tami Damascus what's the reason for this it was what we keep us say there's no reason this is what God decided so that when moshebenu sees rebe Akiva torturous death could come to grips with it why because the concept of the concept of there's certain Mythos we don't understand there's no reason for that and we just keep them because God told no sharabenu that allows us to deal with those events in life that there's no explanation they're inexplicable the only thing we could say is this is God's decree so the purpose of para aduma is what another cooking it's not there but specifically this cloak where nobody knows a reason other people are able to understand the reason but specifically the Mitzvah paraduma was given why so that we train ourselves that just because we don't understand the mitza and we can't comprehend the Mitzvah and it's beyond our comprehension we do it anyway and that trains ourselves to be able to deal with those things that are beyond comprehension but why this why this is not exist for a long long time ah number 10. that there's an opinion that parasha zahar we know is Midori correct everybody knows the Shabbos before Purim you got to go to shul and you have to hear you have to hear about the episode of amalek attacking the Jewish people in the midst of the right to remember halamolik attacked the Jewish people says what does he say there is an opinion that passes that there's a Biblical Mitzvah to read about the Para aduma why in the world should there be a Biblical read about paraduma we don't have an oil mode we don't have a paraduma what do we need it for whoa why should the remit it to read about something that's irrelevant yeah yeah but still well we're gonna read it I'm gonna reward him the same thing is okay is that is that terrorist though that's a good reason but listen to this reason we're going to say yeah why this but what why this one why what because this Mitzvah has it's paradoxical no we don't understand why we can't wear we don't understand why we can we are wool and linen we don't understand other who can but this is the only Mitzvah that it has paradoxical it's the only one it's the only one why should there be a Biblical Mitzvah once a year to read about the paraduma we don't have tumantara anymore right everybody here is tame mace and there's nothing we could do about it so why should we read about the paraduma why we don't have an olamoid we don't have a mish gun we don't have why should there be a mitsa though Arisa to read about the paraduma the answer is because if we can't offer the paraduma at least we learn about it we read it publicly and the lesson to everybody is that there's a Mitzvah in the Torah we don't understand and that's why the missile was given Hashem specifically gave a Mitzvah that we can't understand why is impression God specifically gave a Mitzvah that nobody understands natural no Jew can understand the Smithson Ian and Aaron so I don't know so why was without not the one to perform the procedure of the paraduma because already understood this lesson what happens when arunach Cohen lost his two children what was ironic coin's reaction Aaron was silent he doesn't react he doesn't question hashem's ways he was matabel the usurimbi even though he couldn't understand it it was Troublesome it was bothersome he couldn't make sense out of it he couldn't come to groups within but he was Macabre someone like that doesn't need paraduma he already he got it already he understood it wasn't needed for him he doesn't need to perform the paraduma yeah over there sweetie it's a reference they was was saying that if I dumb our own because it came after motion abena said that because the first he was worried about he was like sound okay but but he was he was able to uh deal with it he was able to do the Cavalry that's true he explained it to him and that was enough for aarona coin that was enough ironic this weekend one second one second in the year 1242 in the year 1648 when these tragedies happened when the shots was burnt right when 20 wagon loads of shots actually the two versions one version is 20 wagon modes one version is 24 wagon loads of shots were burnt and the message from shamayam was those hookah Satora which means the tagum says this is the cree of God what is the paraduma gotta do with the Shas with the majority of the Shas in the country of of France being burnt what does it have to paraduma the answer is Para aduma is the Mitzvah that prepares you to deal with tragedy that you don't understand that you can't come to grips with especially something didn't understand why it was happening right very oftenham say the first place Amigo she was destroyed they could not explain why this tragedy was happening they didn't understand so what do you do when something happens that you really can't understand the answer is the Mitzvah given to explain these type of tragedies so what does a paradigm have to do with these situations that's why the paraduma was given it was given to be able to teach Claus Israel to cope with a situation like this and that's why they understood the those Generations understood that it was the power Shah that had a connection to these tragedies that's why when they established these fast days they didn't establish it the day of the month they established at the day of the week There's Something About parishes the lesson of hookahs and we're not only talking about bad things even sometimes good things you don't understand why they happen even a person's own life sometimes something good happens don't tell yourself yeah you know what I said I'm a big Sonic I deserve it no you don't understand why it's happening to you not everything we understand it's interesting says God wants everybody to recognize that we don't control the world the world you know we can't control the world and therefore God orchestrates two types of events sometimes something that we want to happen God does not allow it to happen why because he wants us to recognize we don't control the world but but sometimes God allows what we want to happen to happen but not in the way that we want it you know sometimes you're trying to accomplish a certain thing you get it done but in a that's exactly the way you thought you would get it done in a completely different way and this is all says Hashem is showing us not our world not everything we want is going to happen and not everything we want to happen is going to happen the way we want it to happen even if it will happen you got it and that's the part of the lesson of the paraduma is just because something is paradoxical illogical hard to make sense we don't throw it away from the cabinet we say it's a decree family that's why comes what God now is not one of course he's one what do you mean he will be won by um even now he's won okay right that's one side that's around she says right she says in another explanation another explanation nowadays in this world before Masha comes when something good happens what do we make when something bad happens what do we say Diana MS when something meaning when something good happens we bless Hashem Hashem thanks for making him happy when something bad happens we can't really understand it so what do we say God we thank you whatever you did was Diana you're was with Justice however when Michelle comes there's only one bracha foreign there won't be any bad news you won't have to say there will be nothing to say there everything will be good if that's the case the whole reason why why did God not tell us the reason for paraduma because he's training us how do we react to this throughout the oath how to react to something bad that we can't understand so God's training us we're metabolic we don't have to understand everything comes everything will be good there won't be any bad news it won't be any bad news we won't need paraduma we will need to learn how to cope with bad situations there won't be any to cope with there won't be any to cope with we're welcome to understand the reason for the paraduma the whole purpose of Hashem not telling us the reason for paraduma is he's training us how do we deal with things that we can't understand comes there won't be any of these situations that we'll need to deal with Hashem says I don't need to hide it from you anymore the whole purpose of hiding for you is irrelevant and that's what the Barry Joseph says yes are only supposed to view the concept that whatever occurs is for the good the problems correct but when you see something happen that you know it's you can come to grips with it you just can't make sense out of it you could explain to yourself you could you could tell things to yourself but ultimately how do you cope with it there's a certain attitude the same way there's a Mitzvah that we do that we have no comprehension of but we accept that this is the will of God it is in preparation for those things that happen that we don't understand and where macabo this is the will of Hashem and we'll add one more thing rights you remember when the brothers uh the brothers meet Yosef right and they don't know it seal safe and for the last many years the kinetic for the last little while they can make they can't come to grips with what's going on this King he's uh accusing us of being spies and he's a kid he's imprisoning Shimon and then and we're innocent and then he finds the Goblet in our in our package and we didn't steal it why is Hashem doing this to us they had so many questions they could not understand they right they asked what's God doing to us and two words answered everything you're you're safe oh oh understand now we know why the you framed us you wanted to get us come to the Triumph so that we should bow down to you to fulfill their dreams with two words all of their questions that they had all of the things that have been bothering them that have been nagging on their heart and their minds were answered the same thing when mashiach comes people are gonna have so many questions why did this happen why did that happen why did this happen to that person why did that happen to this person and we can we don't understand this right there are many things we don't understand and when mashiach comes God is going to say two words that are going to answer everything Ani Hashem question that will answer everything which means we'll understand all everything that happens throughout history will have a perspective of we'll understand why Hashem did it once we have that understanding of why Hashem did it we won't need the paraduma the whole reason for the paraduma is to train us that even if we can't understand what's going on we accept it as God's decree we won't have to be accepting things that this is God's agreement we can't understand that God will see the reason we'll understand all the things that happen throughout history and all the Millennia and all the centuries will have a clear understanding of why it happened we have a clear understanding why it happened being a mystery is not necessary anymore it's only a mystery for us to come to grips with with the mysterious when mashiach comes there's no more mystery of that life life will become very clear we'll understand history and the paraduma the lesson of the mystery of the paraduma well don't need to remain a mystery anymore thank you for coming thank you for listening again you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com