Parshas Bo: Can Someone Please Reconcile The Chasam Sofer With Rebbe Akiva Eiger

this tour class is brought to you by torahanytime.com okay good morning everyone I'm gonna tell you two very brief debate Tyra that apparently contradict each other and I'll let you think about if you can reconcile the two okay so uh parisha's boy we have the parsham so it's very interesting when it comes to Penny not Ben that there are mostas and Simon shinhei that anyone here did opinionaben anyone here had opinion that's okay you're redeemed when I was in Yeshiva um we were learning so again kadushan and a guy woke up that he never had pity not Ben the guy was like uh he was from the former USSR they literally carried in a guy he's a big guy and they ended up putting a bet on him so anyway so the Ramos says that the father cannot use a schliach to do the mitzvah for him in other words he has to bring the kid himself to the Cayenne he can't appoint so the shark asks why can't he punishly we hold the tarakula that's for you right you could appoint a to do the briss for you why can't you appoint the schlier to do Pena is very interesting thought he says it's not that you're not allowed to use a schlier but it's better not to why is it better not to there's no Indian in kala terracula it's better not to use the schliac even though Mitzvah boy but still we don't say it's better not to use but but the so the some services like this that since the purpose of opinion event is to commemorate Marcus that the firstborn were Sanctified because he banished from himself jumped over their homes so therefore to commemorate that it was and We Know by Marcus so therefore in order to commemorate that Hashem did it himself you're supposed to do opinion Aben yourself okay that's the Samson first vatara so what's the contradiction what's the seeming contradiction the seeming contradiction comes from avart from his father-in-laweger has two questions we know that when it comes to pineappan who does opinion I've been who do you have to be played deaf firstborn of the father or firstborn of the mother first born of the mother first born of the mother only first born of the mother has kadusha if it's not the mother's firstborn for example let's say the mother previously had a miscarriage it's not the peltiracum you don't do pineappan even though it's the father's firstborn it's not the mother you don't do the firstborn of the father you do firstborn of the mother so the question is if the purpose opinion event is to commemorate um Marcus so which bucharim were killed in matrium both the firstborn of the father and the firstborn of the mother so which Jewish should have been Sanctified the firstborn of the father and the firstborn of the mother so why by opinion Aben do you only do firstborn of the mother and not the firstborn of the father and another question with Kevin asks is we know that the night of Marcus was no Jew was allowed to leave their home why because once the marshkas was given permission to destroy so he's not going to distinguish between the Sadiq and the Russia so everybody had to stay indoors and put the little red thing on their doorpost in order to indicate that it was a Jewish home so uh the question is what do you mean the match list there's no match list I thought it was Hashem what's the whole business of the Mask that's not being able to distinguish between the Jewish homes and the non-jewish homes so if kivago says like this so kivego says a beautiful idea the only thing is it seems to contradict the sun Cipher well kivago says it's brought down first of all in the safe which is the biography of kibeger it's also brought in Vegas does like this was not necessarily needed for Marcus because what do you need Hashem for a mouth could do it there was one thing you needed Hashem for to tell the difference between firstborn of the father and firstborn of a mother in other words let's say you have to determine who's the firstborn of a mother you don't need God for that any Angel could go to the hospital and see which kid came out first from the mother right that's like black and white so that you could use a malach for what's not so clear is who the firstborn of a father is right because you need to be able to distinguish which droplet of the father was the first one nobody can know that no human being No Angel that you needed God for so to determine firstborn of the mother every hospital knows that to the tourism first born of the father you know as the joke there's a very complicated day somewhere right Father's Day is a very difficult day in certain locations in New York you need God to determine the firstborn of the father only God knows who the firstborn of the father is so it's like this it says when it comes to the firstborn of the father who killed the Egyptian firstborn God therefore for God it's not a miracle and since Hashem is able to clearly determine who the firstborn is it wasn't really miraculous that the Jewish firstborns were saved because since Hashem is doing the Makkah he knows very clearly who's the firstborn of the who the Egyptian and is and who the Jew is so you didn't you didn't need God um you didn't need any kind of special Miracle to save the Jewish firstborn from the father because that was done by God himself the the malach though was was used and could be used for the firstborn of the mother ah now with Amala you need a special miracle for the malach to save the Jewish firstborn so Roku Baker says like this opinionaben is only for the firstborn of the mother because it was only a miracle that God saved the it was only a miracle that the angel did not kill the Jewish firstborn of the mother because that was done through the malach what the ribana Shalom did was he saved the Jewish firstborn that's not a miracle God could easily determine the difference between a Jewish firstborn and an Egyptian firstborn that's the reason why it's only firstborn of the mother because it wasn't a miracle by the father because that was God and that's the reason why you needed the blood the blood was not to save you from God the blood was to save you from the mashkas so the mashkas took care of the the firstborn of the mother and God took care of the firstborn of the Father the only problem with this is it's a direct contradiction to what we learned from Cipher says the reason why you should do opinion Aben yourself is because God himself was jumped over the Jewish homes yeah but you're not doing Pine on the homes that God jumped over because that's first born of the father you're not doing opinion I've been a firstborn of the father according to the Rebecca Vega according to Ricky Baker you're doing opinion Aben on the firstborn of the mother and that Revenge some didn't do so much didn't do that you should be able to use the shliach so the two things we said but they seem to argue on each other have a great day you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by torahanytime.com