Parshas Beshalach: The Profundities of Remembering Amalek

this Tower class is brought to you by torahanytime.com tonight is her yard side test testavat okay welcome everyone if you Brave the weather tonight so you get special scar halika tonight we're going to speak about um a topic which is certainly upcoming in the next couple of weeks we know Purim is coming and you know me I like to uh prepare for Pura many weeks in advance but the problem with that is that we sometimes Overlook so I'm not going to give up my policy of preparing for for many weeks in advance but what we're going to do is we're going to prepare for Pura many weeks in advance but before that we're going to learn about parisha zachar and aside from that this week's PowerShot the end of the parachute talks about Malik so what better week than to discuss the Indian and the Mitzvah of remembering amalek okay and we begin with the Apostle in safer is remember what amalek did to you on the road when you left let's try him remember by the way just to keep you on your toes and don't worry we probably won't see everything tonight but if you turn to number 44 the end of the three percent metamolic and kisses say it says when you have respite from the enemy and then at the end says eradicate the memory of a Malik don't forget okay so you need to remember and don't forget it like when your mother says remember don't forget right so it's actually a Myster it's an assay it's a command and it's a negative it's a licensing remember don't forget is this considered a Mitzvah direisa so if you look in these sifra now you know just it's important to know Italian is called the makhalta and safer Valley is called the sifra and I say foreign think about it do I have to contemplate it so the Safra says it's not enough just to think about it because it already says Shamar preserve it means think about it what does zachar means you have to speak about it you have to mention Shabbos and that's why we have a Mitzvah of right Kiddush Friday night on account of all the order we shine and agree because this Friday night is the Mitzvah racer it's a Biblical commandment that's why Friday night you have to drink more grape juice then shabba's day more wine than childish day it's a Biblical Mitzvah kiddish Friday night what about now the ramdam's opinion we just work with the rambam and peroxoftas holds that all you need to do amidaire Isa is talk about Shabbos you don't actually need a cup of wine midday right according to the rambam and according to other we shining tysus and schwa says midnight rice so you have to make it on wine you hear that according to tices it's a director to even drink wine when you make Kiddush and according to the mepharage of assess the Nazir you have to drink the wine even madarasa so you see this is what about amalek if you look two lines at the end remember what am I did to you you would think you could just think about it so that says the Safra when it says Lloyd tishka don't forget that itself means don't forget think about it what does it means you need to articulate it you need to verbalize it you need to speak about it and likewise this is free passions it says look at number three when it says don't forget that means think about it what does means you have to articulate it so so far we've established that both according to the Safra and the safri there's a Mitzvah in the Torah to verbalize what amalek did to us and not to forget it when do you fulfill this mitzvah when do you do it so if you look at the rambam the rambam is found in two places look at number four the round Mountain the rambam says it's a Mitzvah SASE to destroy the progeny of a Malik and says the ramam not only is in the midst of to destroy amalek um if the Mitzvah to remember always his bad actions so for the random I'd walk into the room right now first thing we do we'd all stand up for the Rama and we would ask rambam when do you fulfill the Mitzvah the ram mum says read my peace I said when Thomas ramam says ComEd always now what does always mean that's a big question what does always mean but we are are all familiar that the Shabbos before Purim all of a sudden the show fills up more than it usually does and especially around leaning time when we take out that second safetyra and the rabbi makes all these big announcements how everyone has to listen carefully to the reading of Pasha zachar and the balkari has to have everyone in mind and the listeners have to have in mind to be yodezi the Mitzvah and even though normally the balcory one he reads he reads it nobody could hear anything he's saying when it comes to zachar all of a sudden every word is carefully like he's saying the most important thing in the world it would seem from our practice that when do we fulfill the Mitzvah of zahira samalik once a year is once a year tamid I don't think so is once does once a year sound like what the ramam says tamid and if you look in the rambam in the safe from says the 189th Smith we are commanded to remember what amalek did for us that he Advanced to do bad to us and when should we talk about it a space all times at every time and time does that sound to you like once a year doesn't sound to me like once a year sounds like the rambam is saying it sure seems like the ramam holds that this mitsu is a Mitzvah that's incumbent upon us often very often we don't know exactly how to define often yet but it certainly doesn't sound like our practice of making a big deal about zachar once a year now we say well Rabbi let's see what the ram mom says when he tells us about parashas because we know that there's a special mix of Leaning for partials here Pastor scholarships what does the ramam say over there so if you look at number seven the rambam in Hillcrest Fila where he brings the laws of kriya satara and he talks about how every Shabbos you have to read from the Tara the rambam says in Parachute that four times a year you have to read special readings says and the second one is zachar and the third one is para and the fourth one is does the rambam say by the way when you lean zahar you should have in mind to fulfill the biblical obligation of zahira samalik the ramam doesn't say anything he doesn't make any differentiation between scholm and zachar and between para and Zafar between it would sure seem like the rambam holds that the biblical obligation of zachar somehow we fulfill on a constant basis and when we lean parisha zakar listen carefully not only is it not a Mitzvah Dai Raisa not only is it not if it's not a Mr drop on parasha Zucker according to the rambam is not only not a Biblical myth it's not even a rabbinic Mitzvah in other words I'll tell you the following Naf Kamina when you come when you come to shul on a regular Shabbos right and they're laning pashas bashalach this week do you have to have in mind oh I have in mind now to be I'd say the Mitzvah of hearing parishes bashallah you ever hear anybody do that no there's no such thing when you go to Shoals you have to have in mind say the midsole Christopher no there's a regular procedure of Chris satura that the way it works is every week we land a new Powershell over the course of the year you finish the Torah on the yamantovan you Lane something relevant to that for example do you ever hear someone come to shul oh I'm coming to Schulte here today to hear the Korea Saturn of shavuas there's no such thing you're in Shoal you listen to the Tyro there's no special cavanos that the balcory has to have there's no special Cabanas that the listeners have to have the ram I'm sure seems like parasha zachar is no different than any other kriya satara over the course of the year and this is the dioc of the safer amec bracha was a tremendous Landing tremendous Bucky the godylam said about him that he he passed away at a very young age dumb said about him he had the kayak to be like and he was the town of the briskarov held of him very much and he wrote swaraman he'll slices his farm are very much nascarbel especially in uh the oilan habrisk together with the swarm of the Grizz and the base halavi and he's madayak from the rambam that the fact that the ram man when he talks about the mitza says and the fact that the ramam when he talks about he says it indicates that the rambam holds there's nothing special about pasha's author and in fact when the rambam talks about parisha zakar he doesn't make any differentiation at all between zachar and any other pasius which indicates the rambam holds parisha zachar is no different than pasius bashallah okay and so now listen carefully what does the rambam then mean when he says what does the rama mean that you fulfill the Mitzvah Thomas we have to try to understand that but the iMac bracha points out that the pastors of the gemara the pastures of Tom and babley is that there is an independent Mitzvah at least on some occasion to read the episode of amalek and that is funny Miguel adafius where the gamara wants to know what is the source right let's see the balcony gets up to the bhima and about Curry says we say very good but where's the megilla by now I know it by heart who doesn't know it by heart are you yes how do you know you can't read about the Miguel about that no it says it says by the Magilla news and it says just like I'm all like it has to be me so too by megillah so the MX Russell points out that would seem to indicate not like the Rama that there there is some type of obligation to read from a safer to read from the Torah at least on some occasion about the episode of amalek and certainly that's our practice once a year we make a big deal about the fact that we're opening up a new a safer just to read about the episode I'm like so where does our practice come from our practice comes from teysvis and Lafayette and it's like this you ready says you'll just say the introduction very briefly you don't even have to know the introduction says like this that according to reputation you could say Shaman in any language you could say it in English and French Swahili Portuguese whatever language you like says the gemara oh does rubby know that he learned it from Apostle for you says um review dinos you have to says the gemara from oh it says it should be say Shema the way it is kumara says well wait a second why do I need a plastic that you have to say Shema in don't you have to say everything in says he holds everything else every other Mitzvah you could say in any language and that's why I need a special toxic to say that you have to say Shema in what other Mitzvahs are there there are no missiles that you have to say in any they have to say at all besides Shema what midsults are there that you have to read sarashi and Magilla says well you have to read from the Torah so Tyson says yeah but that's not a mystery so when we land the Taran Shabbos is that a Biblical mitzvah it's a takana of Ezra so Tyson says Ah you know what think about is talking about there is a Mitzvah the direiser of reading from the Torah you know which Mitzvah that is reading that's what the gemara means that review Dynasty says you have to say but all other midst of reading could be in any language like what like zachar says reading from a safer Tyra Isa and that's what we do so if you want to know where does our custom come from that we make a big deal about reading that is the opinion of Texas now I don't have an answer for this maybe you could help me out and that is we're going to see this and not like the rambam which is very unusual you know the Macabre has a rule and whenever you have to send around them he always passes like the rambam but in this case for some reason he doesn't why maybe because of what we mentioned because the poshness of Shas is mashma like tysus that there's in a Mitzvah di Raisa to read but anyway this is the opinion of Tyson that it's not enough just to read it from your hummus you have to read it from a safe attire following issue there's a big mitzvah and that Mitzvah is davening with a minion right you ever hear that Mitzvah yeah good yeah you have to down with the minion right now even if you want to say like the rambam right we know the rambam holds davening is a Biblical Mitzvah at least once a day what about davening with a minion is davening with a minion a mitso die raiso or is it a misadravana Israel you should sanctify yourself among uh Israel and taith refers to 10 people like it says by and Ada is 10 like we learned from the miraculum but bottom line is dominating with the minion is you ready for a story this is one of the most interesting stories you ever heard at least today kumara brings down a story the story goes like this number 13. my son there's a story parabiellas are he couldn't find 10 people yeah you hear it the more things change the more they stay the same right he came into a show and he couldn't find a minion so what did he do he happened to have an avid Kanani a non-jewish slave and you know because if you free or non-jewish slave part of freeing him if he becomes Jewish he converts so he freed his slaves to make a center to make a test for the minion you like that story you hear it he had nine people he couldn't find the minion he texted everyone he knows but nobody listens to Rabbi anymore when he texts them everyone says no no whatever so right the same old story so what's he gonna do he has to be mashak versus Evan Kanani he has to freeze avakinani as to gamara you're not allowed to free Neva Kanani there's a Mitzvah SASE to work your Avid Kanani until the end of his life actually says enough you free your rabbit Kanani you're over and I said if you have a non-jewish slave you're not allowed to free them yeah tell them to Abraham Lincoln but that's the Halal if you have a non-jewish slave you're not allowed to free okay no now over here yeah says the gamara mitsubashani uh for the sake of a Mitzvah you're allowed to violate the assay de Raisa I'm not freeing an avid Kanani by the way if you look in the good morning get in line with custom and base the Gamora ends there mitzvahani for the sake of a midsole you'll add a free Arabic the Gomorrah and broccoli still continues the Kamara asks what do you mean it's a mystery to make a minion now rabbis listen carefully you hear what's going on I think Amara is saying that the mid smile of davening with a minion which is only durabanon is more important than a Mitzvah SASE so right you see from here the mission of Brewer points us out you see from here the importance of dabbling with a minion dominating with a minion is even greater than a Mitzvah Raisa because you know for amitsarisa you can't free your evidence because I was gonna say what do you mean you need to do a Mitzvah but you're doing the midset and at the expense of doing an Avera you're not afraid of Kanani says that seaboor is even more important than not violating the assay the Arisa freeing your slave so listen carefully here you have a slave the Torah warns you don't free him if you free him you violate and I said let's say you were stuck you didn't have a rule of an S rig and the only way you could get a lieu of an Easter egg is if somehow the evidence says if you free me I'll get you uh I'll get you a little of an asterisk would you be allowed to free the slave to get a little of an asterisk no let's say you didn't have to fill in and you're not feeling and this event will get you to fill in if you free him you cannot free the evid to get yourself a pair of filling but to make a minion you're allowed to free your Avid Kanani to make a minion Sesame yes Dominique with the minion is but it's a drop on that's all you're Isa think about that it's a mission mura diving with the minion yeah it's a drop on but Mitzvah the robots Okay Comes The Rush listen carefully comes the Raj and the rush says you see from here that a Mitzvah durabanon of the seaboor is even more important than an acedai rice not so fast you have no proof maybe that amitsarabanan is even more important than Amit right from this Camaro the rush wants to derive that a Mitzvah durabanon of itsyborg of davening with a minion is even more important than an acedai rice says the rush maybe not so fast maybe you know what they needed a Minion for you know why what Revolution needed a Minion for Parsha zachar says the rush maybe when rebelsa came into shul and he couldn't find him in he wasn't Towing that 915 marive he was talking he wasn't talking about seven o'clock chakras he was talking about he didn't have a minion and for zachar you need a minion die riser says the Russian I was talking about any case you see from The Rush that foreign not only do you need a minion you need a minion midday Raisa on a Biblical level you need a minion say What why in the world would I need a minion on a Biblical level I don't need a minion midday I don't need a minion die rise to damage from an essay it's only a drop on I need a minion but the rush who entertains the possibility that when rebelsar came in to free the other Kanani he wasn't doing it to make a Minion for marath he was doing it to make a Minion for bashes and therefore says a rush maybe you have no proof that a Mitzvah durability is more important than I said because maybe we're talking about a Minion for Paris obviously holds that for power you need a minion Minato you ever hear such a big fiddish you're gonna go home tonight and you say what do you learn in tarasamas you say you know what the rush says you need a minion on a Biblical level they can say what where were they saying over there right Isaac how would that be why would you need a Minion manhattara for anything why would you need 10 people I don't need 10 people to put on filling I don't need 10 people to put on such this I don't need 10 people midday right stuff for anything why do I need 10 people here do we pass and like the rush you better believe it in a very interesting place first of all the says like this says once the valkyrie starts to read the Torah you're now to talk even in learning even Ben gavril lagavra you don't think I have the governor when everyone meets the Misha back and all of a sudden everyone's right you're not even allowed to talk and divorita Bengal Agave now it could be the mission of Brewer I think is lenient that if you're speaking in Torah you're allowed to say it between alleles but what if you just want to ask somebody you know whoa is it snowing outside are you allowed to do that bengala gabra which place can say you're allowed to talk about it you let me know yeah you let me know none on the page yeah but then the mission Bruce talks about well maybe you could be lenient if you if you learn all day started learning before Chris had Torah then maybe you can learn Jokers but not power says he says not like the rambam not just like Tyson that biblically have to read from atarama that you need a minion midday Raisa preparations also in the name of a yes you see it's interesting he brings in the name of a yes says straight out parishes the Riser with 10 people and the million dollar question is why in the world would you need 10 people for parisha zachar why you want to see me drop on that no problem if you want to say it's like diving with a minion good but why do you need a minion midday Raisa comes along the Karen aura minkovisky music was the brother of the Michigan and he was a very smart man he never wanted to be a rabbi right so he used to learn with his brother who is the Rev of Colleen and then when his brother passed away he had no choice he had to become the Ruff of the city now he was a very compassionate Rob see if somebody would come to him benyani is there and say rabbis is kosher traif so if you realize the person was poor and if he realized it was Trey if he would say you know what it's trafe but here this piece of meat I have over here it's kosher you take this one so he wasn't just uh big time he was also of a great battle set so he is bothered by this question that we're asking and that is why should parasha Zafar need a minion you ever hear oh you have to make kidneys with a minion you ask so how come you're not making kidish I only have three people I'm waiting for a minion there's no Hollow Dominion right it would be ludicrous imagine a guy um what are you doing I'm waiting um I'm thinking about what Miriam did about her lashinhara but I'm waiting for another nine people to come over why in the world would you need a Minion from this is the big of the night and that is there are two minutes one is to remember what amalek did to us and the second Mitzvah is to destroy our Malik yeah but you know you have to understand their perspective I'm always perspective you know everybody has right like these liberal attitudes everybody has different viewpoints and understanding we have to respect all mankind and they probably had a very important point of view right nonsense the Torah says you got to take care of these guys yeah but Humanity God created Humanity a Malik attacked us we were unprovoked and they weren't coming only after us it was a war against Hashem it was war against God and we have to destroy them so we have two Mitzvahs one is to remember what amalek did and one is to destroy Allah says the karani do who is obligated to destroy amolink am I obligated as an individual no are you obligated as an individual no who's obligated that seabor the congregation says the character that if the Mitzvah of destroying amalek it devolves on the seaboars and comment on the seaboor on the congregation says again why do you have to remember what amalek did to us just to be well versed in ancient history it's not to remember what happened it's to remember so you know what you will need to do it's remember what they did so that you will destroy them in other words says the Karen Ira the Mitzvah remembering our Malik is contingent upon destroying amalek and therefore since destroying amalek is a mitzvahn that sibur remembering what amalek did is also incumbent and devolves on the seabor and that is the reason why the Mitzvah according to tysis is only to read it with 10 people because there's no independent mitzvah to remember what I'm elected it's remember what they did in order to destroy them and since the midst of destroying them is on the seabor the midst of remembering is also on that c bar and therefore you need 10 people it's an interesting by the way you look in the rambam at the end of it um when he lists all the 248 positive Commandments of the Torah he says by the way the rambam says some of these midsource are on the individual and some of them are on the seabor for example The Ramones says very clearly the Mitzvah of destroying amalek is a Mitzvah incumbent on the sibo if you look at number 18. the Rama says what are amidst and comment on the seabor he says building the base hammock Dodge making a king and destroying our Malik so so too says the caranura remembering amalek is also a Mitzvah that is incumbent on the sibor okay so everybody said I just want to emphasize this because I want to point out another four NASCAR Minas that come out according to this understanding that there is no independent Mitzvah to remember what amalek did the mitza is to remember what they did in order to emit says to remember what they did in order to by the way if you look back I skipped the ramban number six seems pretty clear to express this idea the ramban says number six in the left hand side the first line says it is correct in my eyes then what it means to say is don't forget what a molec did until you wipe out his name and to tell our children this is what I'm like dude and that's why we have to destroy him seems to enunciate this almost that the midst of to remember is remember in order to destroy them and you could even make the case that the rambam is seems to say that because around that I'm looking number five the random says we should think about it remember in order to fight against them so this is not so radical I believe it is based in the language of duration but I'm going to tell you another and after me and that is do women have to hear Pasha zachar well again don't judge by what people do yeah they make a big deal about it but do they need to come to airport right women are categorically exempt from the midst of fascism why because number 19. this myths has only come down males because they're the ones who have to fight the war but women it's like the gemara says in conditions women don't go to war s who cares if women don't go to war what is remembering the history of the Jewish people have to do with who's going to actually destroy our Malik but it's remember in order to destroy and if the women are practically speaking not going to be the ones fighting the war then says he feels they would be exempt from the mitzvah why should that be who told that remembering is in order to all of a sudden he is sticking in his own rationale into the Torah the Torah says remember why the Creed and therefore the safer says think about the following let's say when mashiach comes are you gonna put on Talus every day yeah you're gonna put on filling every day yeah is there going to be a mystery remember I'm Malik well if you already destroyed ammo Lake is there going to be a Mitzvah says I feel of course he'll be a Mitzvah no mitsos will become but according if the whole reason for the Mitzvah is remember in order to destroy that once you destroy them it would come out then there's no no reason to fulfill the mitza of remembering so basically what we have is um a fundamental difference in how to understand what this Mitzvah is is it an independent Mitzvah an inherent mitza remember what I'm like did why because Hashem said so that's why and in that case you shouldn't need a minion why why should you need a minion it's a Mitzvah every every person has to remember and in that case should women be mukhyavas yeah why not women also have to remember and will this Mitzvah apply when mashiach comes to remember nothing to do with whether you're going to destroy them or not but the head is that we are suggesting is that it's not an independent Visa it's a Mitzvah to remember in order to destroy them and destroying them is a comment on the congregation and therefore which is in order is also in comment on the congregation that's why you need a minion and perhaps that is why women like the server says would be exempt from because they have no connection to the war they're not they're not the ones fighting on the Battlefront and in that case would say that is then when mashiach comes and you've already destroyed our Malik there's no more Mitzvah to remember what they did I can tell you a side question a point of Interest this idea that women don't go to war I like the Quran kadushan says women don't go to war and they don't have to destroy our Malik they don't have to remember either that's a very interesting question what do you mean women don't go to war some foreign and all of a sudden the siren goes off and he runs out he picks his gun says the mishna she's right behind him saying that women don't have a midst of zahira because since they don't have a Mitzvah to destroy our Malik they don't have a missile to remember either is fighting against Mitzvah is yeah this is a very interesting question very contemporary issue the gamara tradition says women don't go to war the mishna says you ready for this one says the radvaz is on the page of the rambam the Ramon called submission that is she goes to war Lego Marvel says in condition women don't go to work you know you don't know what it means it means like this if the husband's going to war what's the woman going to do who's she gonna cook for so now she has to go and cook for him on the warfront till then she was cooking at home now she has to go cook for him by the warfront she's not fighting a war she's not fighting a woman is She Gotta feed her husband so where is he if he's home you like that one right yeah but that that's what that's what the Redbox says um now if you say like that would a woman be mcleavas to do that by Muhammad I don't know there's another very interesting carrots and that is foreign I guess and I guess after the death of was appointed by the oilama yeshivas as the saratara he was considered the preeminent Lambda and after one of kaimizer passed away wrote a very long to say from and he says like this when the mishnah says in saita that akalo's mitzvah that's only a Muhammad to conquer eres Israel because our women why not say Shane has man grandma so therefore since she's like the Misha says in kubis she could force her husband to go upstairs well she is obligated in the midst of Israel so she would also be able to participate in Muhammad Mitzvah of kibosh however doesn't live in Arizona he's not part of the Zion armament and therefore that type of War a woman would not go out to even though it's but any event what I want to point out is the ramification of the hithers that we're making the hithers that we're saying is that the Mitzvahs the Kira is not an independent Mitzvah remember that it's remember what they did in order to destroy them that could be a reason why you need a minion because just like destroying them is on the seabor remembering is on the sibling that could be a reason to exempt women from zakira that could be a reason maybe while the mitzel won't be applicable once a Malik is destroyed I'll tell you another very interesting before I get to that cop you ready yeah everybody up everyone up everyone though yeah everyone good open the windows a little bit Yeah listen carefully divinian cyan there's a shot the vignancia in the shots that has been since written by the Arsenal of Yakov at linger and review reports from his revi where we have rum Bing who is the talmud of nothing Adler National he calls Cipher so again if nothing Adler's talmad was about from Bing Bing wrote that women and he says I have a Kabbalah for my Rabbi ramnathan Adler that women are Mercury would tell his Michelle recess in the house stop cleaning and come to hear and says and that is my custom I follow my Ruby rubber from being that women are but ner got a letter that maybe you could prove from The Rush that women are exempt from listening to Parsha zahar why listen carefully because the rush said gemara seems to indicate that amitsa durabanon of arabim is even greater than the midst of the rice and that's why making a minion would even push off not freeing your slave to which the rush said maybe you don't have a proof because maybe he freed his slave to make a Minion for Pasha zakar so they asked wait a second if women and we know in heaven ISO woman so if a woman is well if you have a Canadians why would he free his Avid Kanani to make a Minion for Basha zakar he is anyway so the fact that he had a free is AVID Kanani to make a Minion for Barrister that indicates about them are positive and thereby women would also be positive from parishes offer this is one of the famous kashas the Kasha brought inyan that it would seem from The Rush that women are exempt from parasha Zafar because otherwise why would he have to free the evid Kanani if the Avid Canadian let him make the minion says now what kind of question is that yes women are Michael yeah but you need a minion and if you're not a male adult uh non-evid you can't make a minion so just because he freed him he didn't free him because otherwise he wouldn't be obligated in the midst of he would have been obligated anyway women are obligated our Vladimir obligated but in order to create a minion you need Israel foreign the same way let's say a Israel brought a carbon just because it says it doesn't mean you don't need a clean to do the Avada carbon so too just because women are Maghrib and parishes but the minion has to consist of 10 male adults okay another naskamina of this pharah that we're saying the midst of remembering is only in order to eradicate them another very interesting enough Kamina is brought in the maganabra okay so if I were to ask you now following question if I could only make make it to show one time I can only make minion one time either zachar or magillas Esther what's more important to do with the minion zakar McGillis Esther only needs a minion my job needs a minion racer and therefore the Morgan Abram speaks out and simultaneous it's more important to hear pastor zachar with a minion than to hear mcgillisaster with Dominion no not because you do it two times because you could do it at home Esther you could do it at home you don't need a minion by reading books about the Holocaust because they come from you have to remember what I'm Malik did yeah so the mother says according to the letter of the law it's more important to hear zachar with a minion than thermagal assessed there with the minion but let me explain to you says the mug and avram why more people go to than they do for fashion you know why because if you go to shulam Purim you could kill two birds with one stone you could hear him because Esther with the minion and the queer Satora for Purim is from this week's parisha now we understand why we're talking about this week so you're gonna kill two birds with one stone you're gonna get uh Miguel assessed with a minute and you're gonna get right out of your Malik with a minion so you're right zachar with the minion is more important than Esther with the minion but empty your Esther you're gonna get Sakura comes the mission bura the mission Bruce says if you just read vayavaya Malik if you just read this week's passion you know what it says in this week's Parish now I'm all I came I'm all like attacked um Yeshua they held up his hands and we weakened them and Hashem said Kiana Malik there's no mention about your obligation of destroying I'm Alex as a mishna bura but if you re-patch this case say it doesn't say God says he's gonna destroy amalek it says in Crusade say you have to destroy amalek and since listen carefully we're remembering what amalek did in order that we should destroy them you can't be you I'd say the Mitzvah by reading bashallah you need to hear kisses so again you see a very similar Mark like us the mug in avram seems to hold that the Mitzvah of zahira of remembering is an independent Mitzvah remember what amalek did why because Hashem said so but the mission Brewer says no it's not as simple as that it's more similar to what the Karan arrow is saying it's remember what they did in order to destroy them and therefore the only way to do that is to read kisetse where it says clearly remember and therefore you need to destroy them but in this week's Parish where you're not mentioning anything about your obligation to destroy them then foreign this is also offered as a suggestion why the bahag the Baja only lists list Royale Malik and he doesn't even list the myth so remember what amalek did you know why because there is no independent midst of remembering there is just a mitza of remembering them in order to destroy it so we spoke out sort of five ramifications of this idea that you remember what I'm always did in order to it's in order to destroy them okay now back to the rambam the rambam said when is the Mitzvah remember what amalek did tamid the ramam says sweet a second what does that mean how often is it how often what does it mean tamid how often is okay so for this we have to learn a very important principle and the principle goes like this if you look in uh number 31 we're gonna have to skip we'll try to wrap it up soon the uh the stipler the kilosiakov tells us a very interesting that if I ask you how often do you have to put on to fill in yeah here's a guy hey how come you never where it's filling your lazy bum why do you stay in bed yeah I put it on once a year he says to me you only read pastors okay I want to see you silently put on filling once here how often do you have to put on filling every day the tar doesn't say where it's fill in every day so how often do you have to dive in the random learns philos Amit they have to pray how often ramam says once a day look at number 32 the Roman says every day why every day why once a day why not once a month once a week once a year once an hour where does the time frame once a day come from the the stipler says the clown look at number 31 disciple and bracha says that if the Torah gives a mitzvah and the Torah does not say when the time frame is once a day it's a clown that's the Torah gives the Jewish people a mitzvah you got to do it at least once a day that is the reasonable time frame in other words the unit is yeah because I would say a unit is an hour uh 12 hours a month a week no the at the unit of time for the Thai resident so and this idea is is enunciated by the ramban also by the case of mishnah they both say well the rambam seems to indicate that davening is once a day says uh says around ban why why once a day because what are you gonna say once a year once a lifetime it is without any further indication without any guidance when the Tyra gives a Mitzvah the reasonable assumption is the Torah means to mandate it once a day you see that by te Fila that's what the rambam says you have to dive in once a day you see that by fill in by the way I'll tell you just very quickly remember the Gomorrah by Alicia balcony the Romans made a decree you're not aware of fill in and uh the the senator quota Alicia wearing fill in so he said what are you doing what's in your hands Alicia had ran away and he put the phone in his hands and he said what's in your hands so you know the gamma says yeah the oldest trick in the book he opened his hands and the bird flew out right so the cast of mishna asks why wasn't he moisture nephesh he should have given up his life we know that if the tried to stop you from doing a mitzvah you have to give up your life says they weren't stopping him from doing any Mitzvah he was ready Makai in the Mitzvah because the midst of villain is only once a day sure if you were in more you get put the increments those once a day well this idea that satara does not give a guideline as how often to perform a mitzlats once a day so presumably Rabbi Sai according to the rambam the Mitzvah to remember our Malik is how often it's very reasonable to assume it's no different than trila it's no different than felon no different than any myth so that the tower does not tell you when to fulfill it it's once a day when the ram them says tamid and the ramam says presumably it's once a day and in fact look at number 41 he brings down the opinion of tysus that we do it once a year but he says from the rambam it's mashma the midst is it once a day like we're saying so one simple question when according to the random when do we do this mitzvah yeah to fill in we do right we're good with filling we all put on the filling yeah it's Fila we diving at least midday rescue down once the damage down three times a day but once you do the mitzvahumalik so you say well that's why they print in the back of the sudurem The Sheiks the heroes and until they put that in the sitter when did they do it I mean it's a Mitzvah rice so according to the rambam when are you supposed to do the mitzvah doesn't say anywhere in the anywhere and the whole day anything about a Molly qantarama there's a mitzel once a day so you said we don't pass in like the rambam because like tysus okay fine but the RAM um what would he say when would the rambam recommend the Jew fulfill the midst of Malik so there's an amazing mug in Abram Logan everyone says look at number 42. and if you follow this mug in Abram you'll be uh adding to your repertoire at least 2 000 Mitzvahs a year okay so if you need any extra mid slice you if you follow this mug in Abram 2 000 extra missiles a year the mug and bomb says like this and Sim and Sama can help us Krishna that there are Mitzvah to remember matzantaira every day Wendy fulfill that there's a mits that I remember maimon harcina every day there's a midso to remember what Miriam did when do you do that there's a mystery member Chavez every day when do you do that there's a myths to remember the eagle every day when do you do that says the Morgan of rum you can knock it off in one paragraph you ready for this when you say the words you chose us you should think about foreign and the mug enough room says when you say the kerav thanu you brought us clothes you have in mind to fulfill the Mitzvah remembering and when you say the words God you pray brought us close to Your Great Name you know what you have in mind because we know so long as a Malik isn't around God's name is incomplete so we say God you brought us close to Your Great Name That's the midst of remembering our Malik I do it once a year according to tices that's all you have to do apparently is saying if you want to fulfill the opinion of the rambam the designated time is when you say the words and when you saying you should have in mind remember Shabbos which is equal to all the mitzvahs and then when you say the word you should think that now God loves us but when we did the eagle he wasn't so happy with us so if you would like an extra 2 000 Mitzvahs a year then all you have to do is take the smug enough wrong just remember what to think by those words and it's an easy 2000 mistress here but if I would offer you two thousand dollars let's say I would offer you right now two thousand dollars first of all the line would be out the door no I wouldn't be able to go home tonight I'm just telling you I'm giving you more than that I'm giving you two thousand minutes and you don't have to say the shes the heroes everyone's busy after the diving right with all the different things Pitta Mac Taurus and heroes and all these things first thing you need to do by the way is come to Shalon time forget about all the extra things in the city first you got to say the things that you have to say but you don't even have to say that you could get everything in and I have a rabba okay so that's the sheet of the rambam okay you got it we you're right we don't pass it like the rambam necessarily and the icker is the heroes once a year but seabor but if you want to get in the sheet of the rambam which and we explain the ramama presumably holds its everyday the best way to do it every day but let's just end with this and we have a we have we had to leave out a lot but what can we do the opinion that we do pass and like is the opinion of Texas holds when do you fulfill the midst of their eyes remember I'm awake see you here what in the world is this Mitzvah remembering it once a year is there any there's no other midsole we do once a year yeah we're talking about matzo this is that yeah those are mixes that are governed by time the first night of pesach only comes once a year the first night I've took it only comes with fear but if it's a missile to remember then you always have to remember what is the logic what is what sense does it make to do a Mitzvah once a year and that's how we pass again why once a year ah you ready for this number 45. some services like this was to remember but then the Torah adds don't forget so what kind of remembering does it have to be a remembering of not forgetting well how long does it take not to forget something in other words at what point in time does one Burger begin to forget something someone passes away in James a close relative a person who passes away is only forgotten after 12 months in other words why is Avila's 12 months because after 12 months the memory begins to fade to some extent it's not as acute it's not as painful it fades a little bit then when 12 months pass when 12 months pass you begin to forget oh so if the midstought to remember I'm awake is remember and don't forget so you have to remember in a way that you don't forget how often once every 12 months after 12 months you're gonna begin to forget but if you remembered once and 12 months over the course of 12 months you'll still remember and then when 12 months pass you have to remind yourself again so some Services well what did they used to do when they lay in the tire every three years in the uh the trenewal cycle of reading the tire every three years right were they so maybe so he says well actually did the first year say the second the third year but ask you a question what are you doing in embryo if the reason for Paris is because it takes 12 months what are you doing a leap year comes along the maram shik the time and he writes he was in the presence of the Sam Cipher when someone asked the Samson for this question what do you do in a leap year with the midst of zakira samalik they're 13 months and some Cipher responded in a leap year you need to be makhaden that when they lay in parishes says I heard my Rabbi the samsifers say those words that in a leap year so Rabbi so we have two opinions the opinion of passions like his opinion of touchless is once a year and you need a minion midday right so why because it's a minion it's um and the opinion of the ramen submissive which is daily and if you want to fulfill it you could fulfill it when according to the mug in heaven when you get up to the words of the I wish you all a wonderful evening thank you for coming you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you byctoranytime.com