Parshas Beha'aloscha: The Identity of Eldad and Medad

this Torah class is brought to you by Torah anytime.com okay RAB we have a very interesting episode towards the end of the par we have two men we have two men who remain in the camp sh the name of the first guy is the spirit rested on them and they are in the Chronicles they did not go out to the tent they prophesied in the camp the lad ran and he spoke to and he said are prophesying now spoke [Music] up wipe them out destroy them lock them up said are you jealous for me if only God would allow all Jews to be prophets by placing his Spirit on them so the first thing we have to know is who in the world are El and Ma who are they what was wrong with prophecy what do they prophesies after all we know that AI who gets and he doesn't say it and this n say Wason and why does Yeshua want to lock him up either the how does m have what's going on who are these people who's elod who is this guy who is this person well the closest we have to El is in we have the one who was to his m the closest name we have to in the so you say Okay Rabbi it's close but no cigar El is not El yeah but it's pretty good no and in fact if you look in the you look in the med the medish in fact says who El benline that El was elad and who made Kimu Ben shiftan who's Kimu Ben shiftan well looking back in M the of was El Ben the the N of is so very interesting according to the m El is El and is Kim says yeah but El is not El one is El and one is one has an extra well says where did he get the from he was added because he prophesied and there are 10 types of there 10 what are they am so the B was explaining why he became known as El because he prophesied however the are not happy with this explanation of el who El he was Misha's brother yeah you you heard that you heard it Aron no not Aron could not be ar El elod was Mosa's brother huh yeah yeah you missed that day in Yesa you missed that day when the rebi said MOS had brother Aon maybe you were absent the next day he said he had another brother El and made said what I probably I just because I missed one day I would have heard it somewhere along the line listen to this says the when the T was given and they became prohibited to marry relatives everyone separated from their wives cuz almost everybody was married to a relative who wouldn't marry their aunt in fact according to the Torah it's a Mitzvah to marry your niece it's a mitvah the says if you marry your niece so people marri their aunts and everyone had to get divorced that every everyone was uh mat big everyone had to get divorced everyone had a separate from the heard the people crying regarding the families people had a break up from their wives including the God who is married to his aunt so am told it's been nice knowing you you know they had their 50th anniversary and and then they said they're goodbyes and that's it who yeah he got married to another wife and guess who they had what does el mean ELO instead of a instead of an uncle in other words my father used to be married to his aunt but now he switched and he had ELO that's me what Alo not the uncle made made M who's the uncle in other words in exchange of the uncle says I found a document from who brought the name shall marit is so now rabi amam is reporting what he heard from RAB Hill H I am H El I saw the grave of el now nowadays it's not one of the big tourist attractions it's not the Raj and Raba ra Balan and the ram El is now one of the big spots but Hill says I saw it but [Applause] the half brother ofon and then so that's another n the had a half brother that maybe we didn't know about and they were the ones prophesying now what is that for sure that they left their wi they didn't leave their wives am left his wife just and and the rest of that's what he says it's AAR yeah yeah now you want to know does everyone agree to that it's not so P some say there's who says that um that after mat they could stay with their wives why the says like this said you stay with me but everybody else go back to your tents including those married to relatives why cuz ah right and the says from here we see and in fact they did not separate from their wives and that's the opinion of says obviously forgot this can't argue on says they were all pish but that's a different we actually we once I don't know if we did it over here if you want to know more about it you could go to air it's called solving the lifelong mystery of the time from last year okay but this is the opinion of the tus then tus brings down the Mish that who el el who is M shi shi but then T says at the end according to the medish that this refers to El and Kimu they couldn't have Brothers of because was so say you have to say they don't they don't fit together these are two distinct one is they were El Ben and they were Beni and they were not M's brothers and in that case the person who saw their grave either saw someone else's grave or misread it or the person who wrote the inscription made a mistake it happens but the other shot is these were the brothers of M and by the way the rush the rush says the same shot as tus they were the brothers of M from the father and he reports the same tradition from in the name of then how could you say like the medish that they were El and he also concludes at what point in time were they not allowed to Mar um right away it's not going to help you because even if they inter married but even but you can't be a n of the shav if you don't come from that shav he married I'm going married somebody else he could have married somebody yeah but then they would be from amam sh Ley they couldn't have been couldn't ask him because he was a to what if you want to say oh therefore that solves the other question about yua yeah but um should say I can't pass again he just he says why you jealous okay now by the way there's a very interesting saer here us was written BYO Mr Caro you like that name okay good who's is the grandfather of it's the grandfather of the and he wrote and he says who are these guys the early prophets have a tradition the same thing the rash and the T says but he says this is a tradition dating back to times of the Early N comes the holy and the safer pav last week you thought we saw a lot of from from the this week we're going to see last from from the says in the was the father of mha he separated from his wife they had elod and Ma elod then he says like this in other words he is quoting a different version of tus no actually the same version that we have the same thing that we have in the that's is that what that mean this is what is that what he say yeah so that's yeah so the is also quoting the same thing that we saw in the now this this explanation is a little bit Troublesome to say that um Moshe and Aon had brothers from their father because if you look in it says why doesn't it say if they were in fact the sons of they should have been listed in asks the said there's a third explanation who El and that's from the T which was not written by says but because the printers already had Ai and they had nothing else to name it they called it wrote but not on but anyway what does say two men remained in the camp they were the sons of el who's El we'll see gave birth to them B man when got rid of now when did get rid of the first time so he divorced her two times he divorced it so the first time he divorced her he parrow made a decree so said what's the point of having children he divorced everyone divorced their wife now the gamar says something contrary to what we think at that point in time mosa had already been conceived 3 months earlier we tend to think that no when he took her back then they could conceived Misha and then he was born after 6 months no the gar said he had already been conceived 3 months earlier and then he takes her back at that time he took her back she was already pregnant withu is a smart lady he's divorcing me I'll marry someone else no problem who does she marry El Ben par home second the first time the first time he divorces her she remarries who who's that look back at number two who's the says that when when divorc the first time she said no problem I got to continue on with my life he she marries Alit safan and they have two children El and made he takes her back three months later she was already conceived with Misha now how she could have had El and M when M was already in her stomach we don't have that question we're going to get to that okay but according to the gamar mha was conceived three months earlier she in the meantime marries who they give birth in three months to El and he takes her back and mha is born now then but how could he take her back that's ma you're not to remarry your wife if she marry someone in the inter room so that's also we have to deal with and there's only one person who could deal with that question okay and but that's the story according to so to me it's very interesting who El and made either when amam got remarried after he divorced her the second time he married a woman and they had El Ben Kline or Bui Ben yagi or when am divorced her the first time she married the of okay okay so these are three who either number one oh no or or they're the sons of amam from different wives son of or the sons of from a different husband now let's go for a moment what did they prophecy and we'll come back what did they say says rashim destroy them how do you destroy a rabbi you give him a big Stellar right everybody knows how do you destroy her kill give them a big and then they're gon to disappear on their own why because he can't learn a word right so give them lock him up is going to die yes and Yeshua is going to bring them in now this is what this is the second year right and that could be pretty uh pretty discouraging if clel hear his prophecy mosha is going to die and Yeshua is going to bring them in so Yeshua said lock him up says what's is a compound word is going to die so what they prophesied was the truth it wasn't oh okay good good question so what's wrong with what they said yob wants to know he said that it would be very disconcerning yeah but if you hear prophecy you got to say it they're not by the way is a compound word is is going to his soul will rest in the garden of God and Yeshua will bring him in I want to tell you one of the most amazing things you'll ever hear you ready listen to this why is yesu saying they're prising in the camp who cares where they was born he called there there are two extra words in this p n he it should say should say from the water what's there's an extra and an extra you got that doesn't mean from the water what's so special about that water ke from water he was drawn forth Comes The Rebel the rebel was the Reb of the sh he was the successor of the Malala Muk in CA when M Muk was very ill he said let's make like a sh who should be the next rebba of CRA out so they showed him the following P the he says is so needs to be the next Rabbi of C yeah brings down yeah so the re of H says you know why it doesn't say stands for it's not nice to say that as soon as he's born so it sticks in an extra non comes yes many years later 82 years later and he says means erasing you know what they're doing they're being Mo they're erasing n the non it should say and what they want to erase is the and make it and if it says it's that's the remes that Yeshua was telling mha mha guess what they're saying now they're removing the n and if you remove the N you're left with and says the re yeah you got that in other words erasing of the if you erase the you're left with yes okay A little Lum before we get to the mystical part okay now we can hear theis comes the of brisk rer and he once asked or if to speak because we know that so why does Yeshua want to kill them you can't kill a Nai who speaks na if he would withhold his he' how do you kill a with so why does yesu just want to lock him up they need to get in other words what are what's the problem with are they true they false they're true they got to talk and if they're false then you got to give them's me bris a nice thank you very much in per gather 70 men take them to let them stand there in other words said my job is too hard hasem said I'll give you assistance where do they need to prophecy so El were giving what was the and they needed to sa the because that's is but there was an added detail of the and that is the location of the and that is they need to prophecy in that's why yesu was running in they're in the wrong place so always had there was a detail one of the given to these that you need to speak the they were violating it they doing it so yes comes and says like this they're not because told them and they have to say it so we're not going to give them to be but they're violating a detail of and therefore if you're violating a detail to which responds why did God give them that detail it's only for my honor because he doesn't want people to hear that I'm going to die says it's only a matter of my covet now this was an added they have to say the because fine now you're saying they're violating a detail of that was only for my benefit and or excuse me we don't consider oh good Kasha they ask but was also a so how could be his covered so this might be a different kind of Mal this might be a different kind of so let's see this inside this was given them in an added detail that they have to say in the like it says and they didn't do that now say if going out to the was a in the that they could only speak the if they do then by violating the then they're violating the entire then they but it wasn't a just an added because they're and they're to say it but they're violating a detail and therefore comes running TOA and he says you need to lock them up for violating the to which responded the whole reason for the of giving in the is only for my honor My Honor by the way I think the we've quoted many times was written by one of the I think the B by R by the way the of p is 208 of R is 208 and the of is 208 that's why he called say that why was yesu so bothered presumably he's asking their Nim the answer is all the N had a proph off in the and they asked permission from mosa and these guys didn't ask permission from M and they and they prophesied outside the to which M responded who as long as they're making my job easier okay rabai fasten your seat belts there happens to be a gamar in and if you don't remember this don't feel bad let me read to you gar we learned it a few months ago they were two mute people who were in the neighborhood of R either the children of the daughter of the son of the sister of they were mute if you're mute you can't talk whenever would come to they would come in and they would sit in front of RAB they would nod their heads everything RAB said they would nod their heads they would anate with their lips in other words they seem to know what's going on so rabie felt bad here they're so smart they the she they're so into it for them and they were healed and came out to have a they found they were well vered in all once upon a time there are two mute people and it turned out they were cure and they knew colle who were these two mute people says the in his commentary on in the name of say who wrote we had it on the sheet Wednesday ra aarya the Rami Pano and the Rami Pano had a tradition from saruk I think was a student of AR you know who two these two mute guys were El and Maid they were the gilo of look over there says let me tell you cute little RZ the word me is says for more on the story you need to look in my sa pav what's pav is um is one of the does on so Mr so a number of years ago when you got me the of included not only the but it included the now the said he looked in the and doesn't talk about it but if you look carefully does talk about it so wasn't able to find it he writes but it's not true if you look at the he does talk about it you ready for this say ends in a h ends in an Al ends in a Le ends in a y ill ill me 81 you got that says to Yeshua um take a look back at the AL hey 81 the why what's hasem begins with a y s begins in an Al begins 21 who cured the two with the it's 21 Reb is 212 so if you think this is all the says about it no has more to say about this he adds the name of says that El is true to says there's a perfect realas take the first two letters of el take the first two letters of what is that spell you're gonna have a lot of right now you have so much don't bump your head on the ceiling says what's and that was the letters could spell out lame like mute but you can never in life whenever you see things in you must look it up in the original source so even though the says he saw it in the you got to look up the luckily I happen to have the saero and the Rano adds a number of amazing details to the story now first now of the three explanations we said we said there three possibilities either they were the son of when he divorced the second time or they were the or they the sons of like the say so who does the ra side like look at number 22 two men remained in the camp when got rid of her one of the four people who never sinned how could take back after married is that the same problem that he married his we see [Music] that another big problem is at the time he divorced was already expecting three months when amam took her back how in the interim did she give birth to El what happened she said you hang out here a little bit longer in the meantime I'm going to live with and I'm going to produce two kids in 3 months you're going to stick around here and then you'll come out six months after what's going on so says the Rano first the two mut who are in the neighborhood neighborhood of re tell you the secret the secret is like this why did these two poor guys El have to come back as as mute people they came from the tears of that marriage they were the tears of the oppressed now what does that mean that means the following that when amam divorced he didn't divorce her wholeheartedly he was forced into it because of parro's decree so since he didn't really divorce her properly M when El married her it didn't produce children who were at full capacity so even though they were born the first time at full Capac they came back as a Gil they came back as why because and there's another reason why they were you know why say they had no right to say the there's a rule that's only if says to the to say it to others but if God doesn't tell the navi to speak it over to others they can now how to say itar right so this is a new answer to if they were they had say if they're not the answer is they were true but they shouldn't have said it CU hashm didn't tell them Lar and therefore because they spoke inappropriately when they came back to this world what was their they were they were mute which stands for and they needed to hide their until they got permission and that's why Yeshua was jealous for the rebi this is a new answer to the question they were true but they weren't supposed to to say it and even though they were from the that marriage but because they were they revealed naua inappropriately they had to come back to this world without the faculty of speech if not for rebi who was misp for them and they were cured in order to learn Tyra and that's why their souls were so steeped in Tyra because who are they they're none other than El and Maad now did am do by taking them back no cuz he never divorced the first time is only when you divorce someone but never divorced her wholeheartedly it's called he gave him on the get he divorced her but he made it known he's only doing it because of the decree didn't didn't do before the was given so how could take her back listen to this this idea how amam could take her back it's like doid who took mik back after mik lived with pal how could D take M back cuz David gave her a get he G gave him Mah that it's a bad get and when took her it wasn't a marriage so to he divorced but it was with a my that he's only doing it because of the Gaz and therefore he was allowed to take her back and therefore didn't do El didn't do and this is the Amazing Story of who so we have the says say it's none other than the sons of amam after he divorced after m and then you have the opinion of and and The Rao that these were the sons of after after divor the first time and then the Rano reveals to us the tremendous secret that the two mute in the were none other than El and stands for El of who cured El and of the says the of the words of mem is 81 and says and this is another who they later became the two and I wish you all you've just experienced another Torah class brought to you by Torah anytime.com