Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
This Torah class is brought to you by
torahanytime.com.
Okay, good evening everyone.
Welcome to our sheer on parashas
Behaaloscha.
The sheerim on safer Bamidbar are
sponsored by our dear friend Rabbi Isaac
Soloveitchik l'il nishmas his father
Shabsai ben Yitzchak Isaac
whose yahrzeit was yesterday.
Shamash and Evan Aliya, the whole shul
family, I'll be a skold tzedek. Actually
yesterday I was in Montreal
and I remember toward the end of the day
so I figured
that the we're machavin that the sheer
today will
within the span.
The sheerim on sefer Bamidbar are once
again sponsored
by our dear friends Dr. Zachheim
umishpachta l'il nishmas of
Eliezer ben Rabbi Yaakov Zachheim
and l'il nishmas
Dr. Zachheim's mother Rivka bas Tuvia
Halevi. L'il nishmas Shavin Aliya. They
should be melitzei yosher for their
whole family. I'll be a skold tzedek.
Welcome everybody.
So you wanted to know whether you could
still participate in the campaign. I
thought you might want to know about
that. So the answer is yes. We're still
pushing toward
to be able to
bring the binyan to its desired goal. So
if anybody still wants to participate
with any of the building dedications, if
you want to put your name on the
building, you want to call it the
um
the Goldman family building where the
Goldman family Beis Hamedrash where the
Goldman family kiddush room
that's still available. If you want to
do all of them, it's also still
available.
Azriel on a first first name basis.
The Azriel the Azriel building. Okay.
Um
So now we finalize our plans. We're
going to be visiting the country of
Tzarfas in the summer from July 26th to
August 2nd. We're going to be going to
the grave of Rashi for the very first
time on his yard site on Chof Tes
Tammuz, as well as the Kvarim of other
Baalei HaTosfos, Rabbeinu Tam, the
Rashbam, the Ri HaZaken, the Raavid,
um in Ramerupt, in Provence, in Metz.
So, if you want to join our trip, you
could uh go to our site. There's
information there.
And um check out the information on the
email. It's uh being
a run by LaLechet, and there is an early
bird special. So, if you uh would like
to join us, you are more than welcome.
Parshas Beha'aloscha, we have a very
unusual subject today. The subject is
kamatz.
How are you going to make a shin out of
a kamatz?
Well, watch this. The Gemara, the Mishna
says, Mi she meyser Rebbi Akiva, batla
kavod haTorah. When Rebbi Akiva passed
away, the honor of the Torah ceased.
Why? What did Rebbi Akiva do that
brought honor to the Torah that ceased
when he passed away?
So, the the uh commentaries explain,
Rebbi Akiva darshan every koitz, every
thorn. We know that letters have shatnez
gais, certain letters have tagin.
Rebbi Akiva darshan the meaning of every
little crown on every letter of the
oisiyos. So, when you ascribe
significance to every detail of Torah,
that means you're saying every small
point is significance, you're honoring
the Torah.
So, there's no there's no greater honor
to the Torah than to say that every
little minute detail is laden with
tremendous significance. So, when Rebbi
Akiva died and nobody was able to
expound on the small minutia of the
Torah,
the honor of the Torah ceased. So, we're
going to speak about
the kamatz today.
And
a rule about the kamatz. The possuk says
in this week's parsha Vaya'asu
Okay, fill in the blank.
I went to my in-laws for
Pesach
I went Do you go for Pesach or do you go
for Pasach? I went to Orlando, right?
97% of the Jewish people a few months
ago went to Orlando for what?
Pesach
I'm not endorsing that custom. For
Pesach When do you say Pesach
and when do you say Pasach? Well,
there's a rule.
Whenever the word appears at the end of
a possuk, it's Pasach.
There's a rule that a nekuda becomes a
kamats at the end of a possuk.
It's transformed into a kamats at the
end of a possuk. For example,
What's your Hebrew name, sir?
Dovid
Good.
In the Bible, who is Dovid's father?
Yishai or Yishay?
Yishai
So, Oved gave birth to somebody named
Yishai and a different guy, Yishay, he
gave birth to Dovid?
Were Yishai and Yishay related?
Of course, they're related. They're the
same person.
So, why is he first called Yishai and
then he becomes Yishay?
The answer is he doesn't have a name
change. It depends where he appears.
When the name is at the end of a possuk,
it's kamats.
When it's the middle of the pasuk, it's
patah.
But, there are many exceptions. So,
really the the name of the holiday is
pesach.
So, then why in this week's parashah,
"Vaya'asu benei Yisrael es ha-pesach
be-mo'ado"? It's not the end of a pasuk.
Cuz there's a tipha on it.
Ah.
So, Azriel
of the Azriel building wants to say
that
that it's a tipha. Now, a tipha is
somewhat of a stop. In trop, there are
two kinds of stop. There's something
called melech
where you pause.
And there's something called meshareis
where it services the next word.
Now, normally a
a tipha is not like the end of a pasuk.
It's not a full pause like the end of a
pasuk. So, really it should be pesach.
In fact, the masoretic note indicates it
should not be a kamats. The masoretic
note says, "How pesach leslay kamats?
Should not have a pesach. It should not
have a kamats. Bechol esnahta de-soif
pasuk de-havasei."
Only at a esnahta or at the end of a
pasuk. Now, if it appears at the end of
a pasuk, it's a kamats. If it appears by
esnahta, you know what an esnahta is?
It's also
it's somewhat of a pause. It's a full
pause in the middle of a pasuk. It also
takes a kamats.
And yet in this pasuk, the word pesach
is not at a soif pasuk. It's not at an
esnahta. And yet it's still pasach.
What's going on over here?
Says Rav Yaakov Kamenetsky,
"This is an illustration of a great
principle.
The principle is love davka soif pasuk
makes it a kamats.
Love davka esnahta makes it a a kamats.
The biggest pause in the pasuk
will transform it into a kamats."
Now,
if there's no Asnakhta, again, you know
what the Asnakhta is? Asnakhta is the
main pause in the middle of the pasuk.
This pasuk happens to be unique. There
is no Asnakhta in the pasuk.
So, if there's no Asnakhta in the pasuk,
the tipcha,
which is the comma,
is promoted to the status of Asnakhta,
and therefore it's Pasach and not
Pesach.
You got that?
So, typically only the end of a pasuk or
Asnakhta would transform a Nekuda into a
Kamatz.
But, in this pasuk there is no Asnakhta,
there's just a tipcha,
and the tipcha is promoted, graduates to
the level of an Asnakhta. And therefore
it's Vaya'asu Bnei Yisrael et ha-Pesach
Now, you have to understand a tipcha is
very important.
My father would always say, "Many baalei
kriah have a disease that's called
Asnakhta itis."
What's Asnakhta itis? Vaya'asu Bnei
Yisrael et ha-Pesach b'mo'ado.
So, they ran through a tipcha.
According to the Mishna Berurah, you
have to stop him.
You know the Mishna Berurah says,
"B'vadai machzirin oso." Now, lots of
luck stopping the guy. You know, it's
hard enough you're stopping people from
doing other egregious activities in
during the services. They're not going
to stop a guy from running through a
tipcha. But, the Mishna Berurah says
that if you don't pause slightly by the
tipcha, b'vadai machzirin oso. Vaya'asu
Bnei Yisrael et ha-Pesach b'mo'ado.
So,
as ha-Pesach
b'mo'ado. In fact, tipcha is so
important, the Zohar says the world
stands on a tipcha.
How does it stand on a tipcha?
Because is Bet Din allowed to kill
somebody if they commit a capital
offense? Yeah. But, it says lo yisach,
you know how to kill.
So how could they kill someone who
commit The answer is lo
yi
sirtzach.
There's a tipcha after the lo yi, so you
read it don't kill. You can also read it
don't
pause kill. Sometimes you got to kill.
Is a person allowed to have normal
relations with a a wife when she's
mutaris? Of course. But it says lo yi
sinuf.
You have to read it, the Isaiah says lo
yi comma sinuf.
Uh right, it depends. So
uh if it's a tipcha, you're correct.
Then it's tinuf.
And that's The reason for that very
briefly is because
a beged kefet letter, you don't have to
know this part.
Beis gimmel dalet kuf pei tuf
are are six letters that could have a
tipcha that could have a dagish in it.
If they're preceded by a vowel
like an aleph or hei, they will drop
their dagish.
So it should be lo yi sinuf.
But the tipcha makes it that the lo yi
and the
tinuf are not connected. So in the tam
elyon, it's lo
yi
tinuf. In the tam tachtain, they're
connected, so it's lo yi sinuf. Okay.
The and Azriel
of the Azriel building was going to say
that. Okay. So another example
Another example, Azriel, is in next
week's parsha.
Because
um I know in Eretz Yisrael the Herman
mishpacha wants me to give shiurim on
parshas shlach cuz it's shlach in
Israel.
You know?
So we tell them to watch reruns, you
know? You don't have to watch
But
But in next week's parsha there's
There's exception. It goes like this.
Is um
Anyone here
name Ephraim?
Asriel, are you name Ephraim? No. Okay.
Is the name Ephraim or Ephraim?
Having Yarkhirli,
Yarkhirli.
Ephraim or Ephraim?
Ephraim.
And yet in next week's parsha, Lemateh
Ephraim Hoishea Ben Nun. Why?
Why Ephraim? It should be Ephraim. The
rule is that the name is Ephraim and if
the name appears at the end of a pasuk
or an asnakhta,
then it becomes Ephraim. But in this
pasuk, it's not the end of a pasuk and
it's not at an asnakhta. Says Rav Yaakov
Kamenetzky, this is another illustration
of the great principle that when there's
no asnakhta in the pasuk, the stop it
graduates to become like an asnakhta and
therefore it's Lemateh Ephraim Hoishea
Ben Nun, not Lemateh Ephraim. I put I
put your computer over here.
Okay. Okay. Lemateh Ephraim Hoishea Ben
Nun. So that's another exception to the
rule. Here's another exception. You know
in in Megillas Eichah,
we have how many prakim in Megillas
Eichah? Who knows?
Five prakim. Perek Aleph, 22 psukim.
Perek Bais, 22 psukim. Perek Daled, 22
psukim in the order of the aleph-bais,
okay? Perek Gimel is 66 psukim.
Right?
Perek Gimel begins Ani Haggever Asher
Ra'ah Oni B'Shivet Everati.
Yeah? Three psukim for each one of the
aleph-bais and the psukim in Perek Gimel
are very short.
Psukim in Aleph, Bais, and Daled are
long. Psukim in Gimel are very short. So
Maharal famously says, Perek Aleph,
Bais, and Daled correspond to
Eichah. Why is it called Eicha? Eicha is
gematria 36. The Jews violated the 36
chiyuvei krisos when? During Bayis
Rishon. Bayis Rishon they violated three
cardinal sins: avodah zarah, giluy
arayos, v'shifchus damim. So we have
three prakim for Bayis Rishon: alef,
beis, and dalid.
And since these are big sins, the
pesukim are very big. Bayis Sheini, what
aveirah did we commit?
Sin'as chinam. Sin'as chinam in and of
itself is small, but compounded again
and again and again, it's big. So
therefore perek gimmel does not begin
with the word Eicha because they didn't
violate the 36 chiyuvei krisos during
Bayis Sheini. Instead, they violated
sin'as chinam, and the pesukim are very
short. Since the pesukim in gimmel are
very short, there's almost never an
esnachta
in the middle of a pasuk. So if look at
number four in Eicha gimmel, chovav tavi
al chiyuv v'dumam, it should be v'dumam.
Why is it v'dumam? Because the zakef
katon
takes the place of an esnachta, and it
becomes a kamatz.
Who here
is named Mordechai?
Nobody.
Is the name Mordechai or Mordechoy?
Depends if you say it correctly or
incorrectly.
But
Is it Mordechai or Mordechoy? The answer
is it depends if it appears at the end
of a sentence,
at an esnachta, or in middle. Okay? So
whenever Mordechai is in middle of a
pasuk, it's Mordechoy.
Vayomer Mordechai la Hashevel Ester,
u'Mordechai lo yichra v'lo yishtachaveh.
Every single time the name appears in
middle of a pasuk, it's choy. Whenever
it appears at the end of a pasuk, it's
choy. Whenever it appears at an
asnakhta, it's choy.
And my whole life I was bothered by
perek dalid pasuk yud bais.
Violates the rule.
It troubled me.
And I figured it must be I didn't know
the rule of Rebbe Yaakov Kamenetsky. I
figured it must be when there's no
asnakhta
the zakef katon is promoted to be like
an asnakhta. And Rebbe Yaakov does not
give this example, but this is a perfect
example of this principle.
Fine.
Here are some other examples of the
principle as they are simply. Vehi
eilata da'as
Paretz Peretz holedet es Yishai. Is his
name Paretz or Peretz?
His name is Peretz.
So what happened to his name by the
asnakhta? By the zakef katon?
What happened over there? This is
another raya to Rebbe Yaakov
Kamenetsky's rule that when there's no
asnakhta, the zakef katon takes the
place of asnakhta.
Or another example. Ve'oved
holedet es Yishai.
Ve'Yishai
holedet es David. Fine.
So so far everything is consistent.
When it appears at the end of the word,
it's kamatz. When it appears at an
asnakhta, it's kamatz. When it appears
in the middle of the pasuk, it's patach.
When there's no asnakhta,
if it's either a zakef katon or a
tipcha,
it graduates to asnakhta. Okay? So far
so good.
There's not one exception bechol haTorah
kulah.
And comes along a pasuk in Beshalach
and it throws the whole thing off.
Ready for this?
It's a a snachta. It should have been
vayivash.
You won't be able to sleep tonight.
Ah, so let's translate.
Yeah. They didn't listen to Moshe. How
do you translate Moshe?
Moshe. Vayoisiru anoshim mimenu ad
boiker. The men left it over till the
morning. Vayarum the mun. Vayarum
tolaim. It developed worms. Vayivash it
became
putrid.
Vayiksof aleihem Moshe. And Moshe like
vayivash hayaar, right? It became solid.
And Moshe got angry. I said I told you
not to leave it over. Why did you leave
it over?
Comes Rashi.
And Rashi And this So this is the kasha
of
Rav Mi Vilkmer.
Rav of Vilkmer.
A talmid of the Gaon.
Okay?
A talmid of the Gaon.
And he says, "You know who doesn't ask
this question but answers it?
Rashi.
How?
What The possuk says they left it over,
it became wormy and putrid. I have a
shaila. What comes first?
When it becoming putrid or developing
worms?
First.
What comes first? Worms or putridity?
Garbage then. Garbage then or garbage
then or worms.
First putrid and then worms.
Yeah, you agree? We'll take a vote. What
What comes first? Putrid or worms?
Putrid. So, it should say "Vayivash
vayorum tolayim." It says Rashi, look
later on. "Vayanichu b'ikay Moshe on
Shabbos." "V'lo yivish." It didn't
become putrid. "V'rimah lo yihyu." There
were worms. So, maybe it's in the right
order. In this possuk, it's in the wrong
order. Says Rashi, "Hare mikra hafuch."
The possuk's out of order.
"Sheb'tchilah yivish." First it becomes
putrid. "U'l'v'soif yis'ah." Then it
becomes wormy. "K'inyan she'ne'emar like
it says later, "V'lo yivish v'rimah lo
yis'ah vi."
"V'cheinda kol hamasim." That's how
things putrify.
Says Rav Volkomer, you know why
there's no kamatz? Because really it
should say "Vayivash vayorum tolayim."
So, to indicate that it's not in the
right place, it didn't have a kamatz. It
had a patach.
That's why there's no kamatz cuz it
doesn't belong there. Rashi's saying
it's a mikra hafuch. It's out of order.
Really should be earlier. It really
should It's as if it says "Vayivash
vayorum tolayim." If
the word "vayivash" was correctly placed
at the esnachta, it would be "vayivash."
But because it's not supposed to be
there, it says "vayivash." "Vayivash."
And what's the reason?
Ah, so David wants to know So, why is
the possuk out of order? Says Rav
Volkomer,
the next words are Moshe got angry.
What Moshe get angry about? That they
didn't listen to him. How did Moshe know
they didn't listen to him?
God came to Moshe in a prophecy.
"Moshe, Moshe, I want to tell you there
were two rishaim who left over the manna
and it got wormy."
God gave Moshe nevu'ah?
No, Moshe just it.
Did Moshe smell it or he saw the worms
from outside the tent? Did he smell it
or he saw the worms?
He smelled it. So, in order to juxtapose
Vayivash to Vayiktsaf al Moshe,
so it put it out of order so that we
know that Moshe got angry because of the
Vayivash. But, in terms of the
development of what happened, first was
Vayivash and then it was Tar'lem. But,
because Moshe got angry because of the
Vayivash, it puts it in that order.
It's unbelievable. So, you see every
little detail of the pasuk is accounted
for.
anything wrong?
Did I leave over one?
Yeah.
Moshe said, "Don't do it."
He said, "Don't do it."
Yeah, you can't leave it over till
morning.
consumed.
Yeah, right. But, because people wanted
to leave it over, right? Why do people
have a savings account? So, you don't
have to rely on God. You could rely on
your, you know, savings account. So,
people want to leave over money. They
Every day I have to hope that God's
going to help me out.
Yeah, I mean, they couldn't handle that.
They they wanted to feel certain
security by having the money in the
pantry. So, Moshe said, "Don't do it."
Okay. So, now we get to a major subject
that I'm going to give you a
watered-down version of cuz that was the
way until recently. I just got back.
Um
and I'm happy that at least we got out.
I would call this just getting a little
taste of the subject.
We come to a very interesting subject,
namely
in the second bracha of Shmoneh Esrei.
Ata gibor le'olam Hashem, mechaye meisim
ata, rav lehoshiya.
Mashiv haruach umorid
gashem or gasham?
What do they say here?
Gashem.
Whatever we Whatever I think is
Whatever you say.
Okay.
I said now if it's mighty fire it's safe
to say gashem.
There was rebellion
Sefaria. Yes, I'm aware of this.
Yeah?
So, I'm just going to give you in a
nutshell, okay?
What should it depend on?
Is it the end of a phrase
or the middle of a clause?
Really, what it should depend on is what
the trop is.
Is there a trop on Shma on Shmoneh
Esrei?
No.
Reb Yaakov Kamenetsky says, yes.
There's trop.
And the trop, I don't know
how what the
the ta'am
on the word
gesh gimmel shin mem
is revi'i.
Mashiv haruach umoreed hagashem.
And therefore, Reb Yaakov says it's
geshem.
Now, Reb Yaakov
his specialty was dikduk.
And he says there is no room to say
goshem. Why do people mistakenly say
goshem? Cuz on Shmini Atzeres
Who here is a gabbai?
So, there are no Ephraims, there are no
Mordechais, and there are no gabbaim.
Okay.
Um
The gabbai calls out mashiv haruach
umoreed ha goshem. Why? Cuz that's the
end of his clause. That's the end of the
statement. That's the end of the whole
show. Some people the whole The only
thing you ever hear from the whole year
is the clap. Mashiv haruach umoreed
hagashem.
But, now the answer is is it yishai or
yishay? Depends where. So, in Shmoneh
Esrei, it's geshem, but in the
hachra'aza, it's goshem.
Say mashiv haruach umoreed hagashem, but
don't say it.
Say geshem.
Since Reb Yaakov, since that's the end
of his sentence, that's how it's
pronounced in that sentence. And
furthermore,
when you davened geshem and you say the
piyut, "She'ata hu Hashem Elokeinu
mashiv haruach
umoreid
hagasham."
In the machzor, that's the end of the
piyut.
So there it is, gasham.
And when the chazzan announces it, he
gives it gasham. But when you say
"umashiv haruach umoreid hagasham", says
of Yaakov Kamenetsky, cuz the trope is
revi'i.
Furthermore, says of Yaakov,
is it "ata gibor le'olam Hashem"?
"Ata gibor le'olam Hashem mekhaye
meitim"?
"Ata" or "mekhaye meitim"?
"Ata".
"Mekhaye meitim ata" or "mekhaye meitim
ata"?
Says of Yaakov,
it depends if it's the rainy season
or the summer.
Why?
During the rainy season,
or if you don't say "moreid hatal",
it's "melel mekhaye meitim ata rav
yeshi'a mashiv haruach umoreid
hagasham".
But if you don't say "moreid hatal",
in the summer,
it's "mekhaye meitim ata rav yeshi'a".
Finished.
And this really deserves a shiur onto
itself.
All you need to know now is Rav Moshe
Feinstein vehemently disputes with
Yaakov Kamenetsky. And I follow Rav
Moshe.
And he says it's "ata gibor le'olam
Hashem mekhaye meitim ata rav yeshi'a
mashiv haruach umoreid hagasham". Why,
says Rav Moshe? Because it's the end of
a phrase.
I, but the rule is only kamatz and
asnakhta is only asnakhta so pasuk. No,
the rule is the end of a phrase is
always
um kamatz, regardless of it's in the
Chumash or in the Siddur.
Now, says R' Moshe, where does it come
from?
That when a word appears at the end of a
uh
clause, the end of a sentence, the end
of a pasuk by an asnakhta, it's a
kamatz. Says R' Moshe, it's halakha
l'Moshe miSinai.
Where? It's the Gemara in Nedarim. The
Gemara in Nedarim says on daf mem zayin
amud aleph, Amar R' Yitzchak, mikra
soferim
The reading of the sofer, the crowns of
the sofer, kri and like ktiv, and ktiv
like kri, and kri ktiv. Halakha l'Moshe
miSinai.
What does it mean mikra soferim? The
Gemara says, eretz.
The Bach adds, eretz or etz.
It's halakha l'Moshe miSinai. Says the
Ran, when it's an asnakhta,
it's oretz. When it's the middle of a
pasuk, it's eretz. Where does that come
from? Halakha l'Moshe miSinai.
Tefillin are what color, Israel?
Black.
Black. What shape are they?
Square.
Very good.
Where does that come from? Why are
tefillin black?
Halakha l'Moshe miSinai. Why is it oretz
at the end of a pasuk? It's halakha
l'Moshe miSinai.
Interesting. So then it's really kamatz,
should we correct someone who doesn't
say it?
Doesn't change the meaning of the word,
but they're still
sort of not fulfilling a
biblical rule.
So it's very interesting. Says R' Moshe,
mashiv haruach umorid hagashem. What
does it depend on? Whether
whether it's part middle of a phrase or
the end of a phrase.
That's very interesting. In Parshas Lech
Lecha,
we find that
um
And Moshe and Avraham Avinu goes out
He went out to go to the land of Kenaan
and he came to the land of Kenaan.
So, unknowingly, you might say he was
going to Nebraska and he ended up in
California. He was going to Artza Kenaan
and he ended up in Artza Kenaan.
So, Chasam Sofer is bothered by this
question. Yaakov Avinu Avraham Avinu
went to one land and he ended up going
to a different land. We know it's the
same land. It's just in the middle of
the pasuk it's Kenaan at the end of the
pasuk it's Kenaan.
But the Chasam Sofer says, even though
it's a rule in dikduk,
there still must be significance in
that.
going to say, there's got to be a reason
for it.
Right? So, there's got to be a reason. I
I
Again, halacha l'Moshe miSinai, we don't
really know why it's spelled with an
aleph.
We have no idea.
And a name shouldn't determine it.
Shouldn't be a make a difference if it's
in the middle or the end. A name always
stays the same.
Okay, but it's a rule. It's halacha
l'Moshe miSinai.
A word, but not a name.
All the all the all the examples we gave
were names. Every single example we
gave, Ephraim, Mordechai, Peretz,
Yishai.
Kenaan.
So, Chasam Sofer says like this, God
told Avraham, go to Eretz Yisrael.
I'll make you a great nation.
What was Avraham Avinu going to do
there? He's going to bring people back
to the fold. He figured that when he
would get there, he would find that the
people were receptive to his message.
So, vayaitzei lelech el eretz Kenaan
Pesach. He went to go out to the land of
Kenaan. He thought that they would be
open to his message. He gets to vayavo
elav, he got there, eretz Kenaan, nobody
was interested in anything he had to
say.
Pesach indicates openness. Kamatz is the
fist is closed. Avraham Avinu thought
the people would be open, would be
receptive to his message. Turns out not
at all. They didn't want to hear
anything he had to say. He was totally
unsuccessful.
Now, according to that,
you would have to believe that there's
significance to the eilah toldos paratz.
Paratz hoyeled es Chetzron, or v'Oved
hoyeled es Yishai, the Yishai hoyeled es
Dovid.
It's still the same
I mean, he's Yishai himself. Once he's
Dovid, he becomes something else.
Everybody grows in life.
Right.
Or
that when Oved gave birth to him, Yishai
was closed. He was not on the madreiga
that he could have produced a Dovid
HaMelech. And later on, he opened
himself up that he was able to produce
somebody like Dovid HaMelech.
Reb Shimshon Raphael Hirsch said
something very interesting.
He said, "Fundamentally, in the order of
nekudos, the first nekudah is kamatz,
followed by patach."
Why does kamatz
go before patach?
Says Reb Shimshon Raphael Hirsch,
"Kamatz means closed.
Refers to a closed mouth.
Patach is an open mouth.
That's also
say kamats.
Kamats.
Could you keep your mouth closed at the
end of the kamats?
Yeah, you could close your mouth. Patah.
Could you keep your mouth closed at the
patah? No, your mouth has to be open.
So, kamats, your mouth could be closed.
Patah, your mouth could be open. Stop
right there. Before we get to the his
limud, I would say very simply, that's
the reason why
when you're when you get to a soif pasuk
or an asnakhta,
the pronunciation is kats. Why?
Cuz you're ending with a
Because you don't have to keep your
mouth open. In fact, you're supposed to
keep your mouth closed. You need to
pause.
So, whenever there's a pause, the nekuda
will lend itself to keeping the mouth
closed, pausing. Whenever you're middle
of the pasuk, you got to keep your mouth
open. You got to flow. So, it's going to
be a patah.
You know, I think that's I wouldn't say
that's a big sisoid or not it's not it's
just practically there's a lot of the
rules of grammar are to help read just
pashuta help you navigate the reading of
the pasuk. So, when you're in middle of
a pasuk, the the nekuda patah indicates
keep your mouth open
and kamats indicates to close it. But
Rav Shamshon Raphael Hirsch sees
something deeper even than that.
And that is if kamats is the first
nekuda,
it's to teach a person that the default
position of the mouth should be kamats
and only be patah if you need to.
And that of course the Gemara says is
indicated by the fact that all the limbs
of the body are
vertical. The heart is vertical.
Cuz the heart always has to work and the
liver is vertical and the kidneys are
vertical and the lungs are vertical cuz
they always have to work. And everything
is vertical. There's only one limb that
its default position is
schlaf.
The
the tongue.
Why? The whole oral, right? The tongue.
Cuz it's like a gun. Just because you're
holding one doesn't mean you need to use
it, right? You have it just in case.
That's the purpose of the mouth. It's a
weapon. You have it just in case. And
even that's why it has a lot of
safeguards, safety features. You have
teeth. You Right? So, when the tongue
wants to come out, if you need to, you
bite you bite it. You have lips. And um
that's the the Gamara says the limud of
the mouth.
And of course we know
that
how many
teeth do we have on the top?
Oh, you're a shark or something? What?
16, 18, and and 17
16 on the top?
16 on the top
16 on the bottom?
Good guess.
Go back to dental school.
The Shulchan Aruch Hakadosh
Two psukim in Shir Hashirim talk about
the teeth of Klal Yisrael. Shinayich
ke'eder haktsuvot or shinayich ke'eder
harchelot.
We have two sets of teeth. 16 on the
top, 16 on the bottom. To indicate that
what's the mouth given for?
Torah and tefillah.
How much 16 Torah? We have three aliyos
Monday,
three on Thursday,
seven on Shabbos, and three Shabbos by
Mincha. Add it up.
Three
16. Very good, Azriel. 16 aliyos a week.
That's Torah. Tefillah
Right.
Maftir in a minyan But what about how
much tefillah do we have a week? We have
The answer is we're not we're we're
talking about carbon ice. So, you have
the time at your shahar and the time at
your by him. Is 14, right? Plus the two
musaf and my Shabbos is 16. This
indicates God gave us a mouth for Torah
and for tefillah. And this is the sheer
on the nakuda of kamats. Stay tuned for
future sheerum on other very
important shashela other
Two carbon ice and musaf.
You bring two animals.
But you you go to say both the hemis
with one musaf.
Yeah. Okay, everybody say have a
wonderful day not wonderful evening.
Call time.
Bok ti Rabbi Isaac, good night.
Just experienced another Torah class
brought to you by torahanytime.com.