Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Themes of Lag Ba’Omer | Rabbi Yitzhak Breitowitz | May 5 2026
3 views
www.ouisrael.org facebook.com/ouisrael #OUisrael #torah #judaism #torahlectures
Categories:Torah
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Omer sameach, if that's uh
what you say.
Uh today's sheer today's all days
mornings learning is dedicated as a
zechus for a successful surgery a refuah
shleimah for Pelech Shapsoi ben Chaviva
Oleyah. Again, may he have a refuah
shleimah b'soch sh'ar cholei Yisrael.
Uh again, with uh your permission and
with my apologies, I'm going to uh once
again digress from our assigned topic
because it is Lag BaOmer.
I wanted to talk a little bit about uh
Lag BaOmer, the significance of Lag
BaOmer
and uh why it's an important day.
Uh some of you might have participated
in bonfires. Uh perhaps uh
uh people are even going to Meron even
though the government uh officially
uh does not does not allow it.
Uh so, the first thing that's very very
interesting is that uh among the Kuntres
of Yosef Caro, there is no such thing as
Lag BaOmer. According to Yosef Caro, the
aveilus of Sefiras HaOmer
uh goes from the second day of Pesach
through
the 33rd day of the Omer and everything
is mutar after that point. So, there's
only Lag BaOmer b'eiluch. There is no
concept of Lag BaOmer bichlal ubichlal,
33 days of aveilus. But okay. But all
the other minhagim in various
configurations acknowledge Lag BaOmer as
a festive day
and a happy day and a day where you're
allowed to make weddings and listen to
music
and get haircuts. And then there are
different minhagim. Are you allowed to
do it after Lag BaOmer? Is Lag BaOmer
only a break? But according to all the
minhagim except the very first one, Lag
BaOmer is a free festive day. What is it
about Lag BaOmer that is festive? So, we
have to go back
to a story. I'm sure many of you are
familiar with most of the story, but
there's some details I want to go over
about the story of Rabbi Akiva because
it is a very, very inspiring story
and there are many lessons.
Akiva ben Yosef, as he was, was a
descendant of Geirim. He was not a Geir
himself, but he was a descendant of
Geirim.
And he was an Am Ha'aretz. He was an
ignorant person. He didn't know how to
read Hebrew.
And not only was he an Am Ha'aretz, but
in later years he described himself
as having a hatred
of Talmidei Chachamim.
Uh he he said, "If I would meet a Talmid
Chacham,
I would like to bite him and my bite
would not be the bite of a dog, it would
be the bite of a donkey which can break
bones. It's a much more powerful
powerful bite."
I've always thought, I don't have any
proof of this, maybe I I sometimes have
a tendency to psychoanalyze ancient
personalities,
but I often thought that perhaps Rabbi
Akiva had this sense that people were
looking down at him cuz he obviously
was a very brilliant person who had no
education and no chinuch.
And a person might feel, rightly or
wrongly, that all of these great
scholars
are looking down at him.
And
a person could feel a certain hatred and
a certain anger. I mean, even today this
can happen. You can have
a plumber or an air conditioner uh guy
and the lawyer or the doctor or the
accountant, you know, might look down at
the person even though it may it may
very well be that the plumber might be
acting very much smarter and more
intelligent
than the lawyer or the doctor. Right?
But we create these stratifications, we
create these hierarchies. So again,
maybe this is my amateur psychoanalysis,
but I think that might explain in part
Akiva, I'll call him Akiva till he
becomes Rabbi Akiva, Akiva's hatred for
the Talmid Chacham.
Be that as it may, he found himself as a
shepherd
in the employ of a very, very wealthy
person
who went by the nickname Kalba Savua.
Now, Kalba Savua was not his real name.
We actually don't know his real name,
but Kalba Savua is Aramaic for
a full or a stuffed or satiated dog.
And the Gemara in Gittin describes him
as one of the wealthiest people in the
Jerusalem area,
but he was so hospitable
and he gave people so he was so generous
with his resources that even a dog would
be stuffed at his table.
Again, the idea is that dogs are never
full, right? Dogs will always keep on
eating, but with his hospitality, even
the dog would be full.
And if you remember, the Gemara in
Gittin mentions Kalba Savua in a
non-Rabbi Akiva context
that during the Roman siege of
Jerusalem,
when the Romans cut off
food and water,
there were three wealthy people in
Yerushalayim
who had enough food and and oil and wood
to keep the city going for 21 years.
And one of those three people was Kalba
Savua. And then, if you remember, the
Gemara uh gives the very sad story that
the Zealots
uh in Jerusalem who wanted war with the
Romans burnt
all of those supplies, creating mass
starvation and many, many, many deaths,
right? That's the Gemara in Gittin that
many people learn on the 9th of Av,
which is the story of the Churban Bayit
Sheini. But be that as it may, Kalba
Savua was a very, very wealthy person,
and Rabbi Akiva was a shepherd.
Maybe one of a thousand shepherds. How
many shepherds
did Kalba Savua have on his payroll?
And somehow, the boss's daughter, whose
name was Rachel,
somehow
saw in Rabbi Akiva
some greatness
that maybe Rabbi Akiva himself didn't
know that he had. And she fell in love
with him. There aren't that many
romantic stories in the Gamara. This is
maybe one of the few romantic stories.
She loved him. She had faith in him. She
believed in him.
And she wanted to marry him.
Her father
who was not only wealthy but very very
well regarded in Yerushalayim society
was so outraged.
And how could his daughter marry this
ignorant person?
That he made a neder, a neder, a vow.
That he would not give her a cent. He
disinherited her
from all of his property.
And she went ahead and married Rabbi
Akiva and she lived with him in abject
poverty.
The Gamara describes them living in a
barn, sleeping [snorts] in straw.
Her father did not give her a cent.
Whatever shekel, whatever the currency
was.
But she stayed with with Akiva ben
Yosef.
And then
she had this idea.
Hey Akiva, why don't you go to Yeshiva?
Why don't you go to Yerushalayim?
Apparently Kafr was outside of
Yerushalayim. Why don't you go to
Yerushalayim to learn Torah?
And you can And by the way, they had
children. Akiva had children. Akiva had
at least one son and one daughter.
Maybe more but we know from Chazal
he had a son and a daughter.
Uh and this is before he went to
Yeshiva.
So when she told him to go leave to go
to Yeshiva
she was also basically saying that not
only would she live by herself in
poverty but she would raise
the children fundamentally.
Uh and initially Rabbi Akiva was not
convinced. He didn't think it was right.
And he didn't even think it would be
useful. He's more than 40 years old.
But at one point, the Gemara says, one
time when he was shepherding,
he noticed water dripping on a rock. And
the water had been dripping a long time,
years and years and years and years.
And he saw
that the water
made a hole
in the rock after a while.
So, he said, "Ah,
the words of Torah are compared to
life-giving water.
And even if my brain is like a rock, you
know, I haven't learned anything. But if
water can penetrate the rock,
the Torah can penetrate me."
So, he went.
And the story goes, he went for 12 years
initially.
Now, this pashtus of the Gemara implies
that he did not see his wife for 12
years. I I don't I don't think you have
to learn that way. It could very well be
that maybe there were occasional visits,
you know, it's not like
they didn't see each other at all. I
mean, after all, he wasn't that far
away.
But basically, 12 years he was
essentially not at home, and and
certainly on a regular basis.
And after 12 years,
he comes back. He's already He's
Remember, he started with the cheder
kids. He started with the first graders.
A 40-year-old man
sitting
in first grade
learning how to read.
But 12 years of study obviously can
advance a person.
So, he comes home after 12 years.
And he overhears his wife having a
conversation with a neighbor.
Where a neighbor tells her, "What type
of husband do you have?
You're living in poverty, you're raising
the kids, you're all alone,
and your husband just goes off for 12
years."
So, she said to the neighbor, "I
wouldn't mind
if he'd go for another 12 years." This
is not a negative comment. This is
saying, you know, uh
halavai that he would learn even more.
So, the Gemara gives us the remarkable
story, which is really hard to believe,
that he overhears this conversation, so
he turns around and he goes back
without even saying
hello.
Now, there are two interpretations of
this story. One is you might call the
Litvisher interpretation,
and one might be the Hasidic
interpretation. I prefer the Hasidic
one, but I'll tell you both.
The Litvisher interpretation, because
everyone asks the question, "Okay, he's
going to go back for 12 more years, but
he can't say hello?
He can't have a cup of coffee? What's
going on?"
So, the Litvisher interpretation from a
Rav Aaron Cutler is that in Talmud
Torah, there's a great, great
significance to the notion of critical
mass. Meaning, there is a difference
between learning, let's say, 2 hours
straight
and learning an hour, taking a break,
and learning another hour. Even though 1
+ 1 = 2,
but 1 + 1 that's broken up
is not the same as 2 straight hours.
So, Rabbi Akiva didn't really want to
have an official break from his
learning, because that would have made
it a 12 and a 12,
as opposed to the cumulative effect
of 24. Although he did
make a trip, but but by not having a
coffee break, etc., there was the mile
of continuity. The Chazon Ish used to
give a mashal about this.
Uh let's say you have a big pot of
water,
and it would take 30 minutes
to bring the pot of water to a boil.
And every 29 and a half minutes, you
shut off the flame,
you wait till the water cools down,
and then you start it up again.
You could do 29 and a half, 29 and a
half, 29 and a half, 29 and a half. You
can do it a hundred times.
It's not going to boil. You have to have
30 minutes. Now, this is an important
cloud. Uh people
think
that, you know, learning times just add
up. So, I learned 2 hours, I did 2
hours, but 2 hours straight is different
than 1 + 1. So, that's the Litvish
interpretation in which Rabbi Akiva made
a calculation that if I have reshus not
to uh
interrupt, I'll go back.
There's a Hasidic interpretation that I
think is very moving.
And that [clears throat] is,
you know, people This whole story is
very hard to understand. I mean, you
leave your wife. What what what type of
I mean, what what is this is what you
do? I mean, let's imagine
a guy would go to his rosh yeshiva today
and say, "This is my plan.
I'm going to, you know, leave my wife
for 12 years or 24 years. I 24 years."
And, you know,
number one, it would be crazy. Number
two, it would be assur.
You can't abandon your family. You can't
just leave.
You have an achrayus.
The story is very difficult, and it has
to be
that this is because this is what she
truly wanted, because after all, this
was her idea in the first place.
Meaning to say, she is saying this is
her greatest dream, this is her greatest
desire.
So, Rabbi Akiva is accommodating his
wife rather than ignoring his wife.
But, one can imagine, and again, I'm
doing a little amateur psychoanalysis,
that Rabbi Akiva himself was tortured.
Rabbi Akiva himself agonized over this.
>> [snorts]
>> This is not a simple decision. Yes, she
wants me to do it, and yes, it may
produce great things in the future.
But, how can I let her suffer this way?
So, some say,
he didn't allow himself to have a cup of
coffee with her
because if he would have let his guard
down, he wouldn't have been able to go
back.
This is a very difficult decision in
life. Sometimes
people
have to make themselves cruel.
I mean, I'll give you another example in
a totally different context.
Totally different context, but it'll
give you a sense of maybe the dynamics
here.
Let's say, God forbid, there's a
9-year-old child
that has to have his leg amputated.
Because if his leg is not going to be
amputated,
the child will die.
And the parents
tell their child,
you know, you're going to have to lose
your leg cuz that's the only way you'll
stay alive.
And the child who doesn't fully
understand
the implications
is sobbing and begging his parents,
"Please, please, please don't cut off my
leg. Please let me keep my leg."
And there is no doubt that the parents
will be sobbing
and crying.
But they'll do what they have to do.
They'll do what they have to do.
Now, I understand you're going to say,
"Well, going to learn in Yeshiva is not
quite the same." I I I mean, I
understand. I'm not
fully explaining it.
But this was kind of an analogous
situation
where Rabbi Akiva had to be cruel.
And if he let his guard down
even for a minute,
he wouldn't have been able to go back.
So, he didn't allow himself.
So, I think that's a a powerful
interpretation of the dynamics here.
Meaning, I don't think you should read
the story
as just a casual decision
to leave his wife for 24 years.
This was a decision of great agony and
suffering, but it's only because his
wife wanted it.
And she saw something.
Be it as it may,
after the 24 years,
he comes back.
And at this point,
he is no longer a student.
He is the greatest
rabbi in Klal Yisrael.
He is Rabbi Akiva.
And he comes back. The number 24 is very
pronounced here, 24 years.
24,000 students.
24,000 students. Can you imagine? Uh the
largest Yeshiva in the world, some
machlokes,
is it Lakewood in New Jersey, or is it
Mir here in Eretz Yisrael?
Machlokes, how you count, who do you
count, but it's between 7,000 and 8,500.
It is certainly below 10,000. There is
no Yeshiva in the world
that has 10,000
talmidim.
Rabbi Akiva, 24,000
talmidim.
How did he even teach them? There were
no microphones. Exactly, how do you how
do you teach 24,000 talmidim? I have no
idea. But he comes back with 24,000
talmidim.
Now,
let's put ourselves, and again, please
forgive my my my amateur amateur
psychoanalysis yet again.
But let's put ourselves into Rachel's
mind.
24 years of loneliness,
of poverty,
of deprivation.
And now she sees
the fruit of her sacrifices.
Now she sees
the wonderful thing that was produced.
And now, as as Dovid Hamelech says in
Shir Hamalos, Hazore'im bedima
berina yiktzoru.
Those who plant in tears
harvest
in joyous song.
She sees the wonderful harvest
of all those years of sacrifice.
Can you imagine how much this meant to
her?
To see the beautiful beautiful
outcome, which unfortunately is not
going to last, but at least at that
moment. So, then there's an interesting
side part of the story.
Precisely at this point,
Kalba Savua, after 24 years,
finally feels sorry
that his daughter has been in poverty,
and he wants to get an annulment for the
vow.
He doesn't recognize Rabbi Akiva. He
doesn't know this is his son-in-law. So,
he's told, "A great rabbi has come to
town,
and he can annul your vow." Again, let
me explain this. This is Satres Nedarim.
Now, a Satres Nedarim,
the annulment of vows,
can either be done by a Bet Din of
three,
or it can be done by one rabbi who's
exceptionally learned.
Bizman hazeh,
we don't rely on the one. We only do
three. In other words, even the Gadol
Hador does not matir Nedarim beyachid.
But, under the law of the Gemara, a
yachid mumcheh
can be matir Nedarim, and in the time of
the Mishna and the Gemara, that was
still practiced. So, he goes to Rabbi
Akiva, who recognizes him, but he
doesn't recognize Rabbi Akiva.
And he says,
"Rabbi, I made a vow. I I didn't allow
my daughter to have any any benefit from
my property, and now I she's been
suffering so much. Can you annul my
vow?"
So, you know, in a Satres Nedarim,
the way it works is you have I don't
mean the pro forma one, which is a
little different, but if you had an
individual nether,
you have to have what is called a petach
or petach.
>> [snorts]
>> Petach means an opening.
In other words, we identify a
circumstance, had you known a certain
thing,
would you have made the vow?
And if the answer is no, the vow could
be released based on the opening. In
fact, this could even be a trivial
thing. Let me give you a trivial
example. Let's say a person wants to be
on a diet,
but he lacks willpower not to eat
chocolate.
So, he makes a neder,
"I will not eat chocolate."
"I will not eat chocolate." It's a
neder.
Then, he comes home
and happens to be his birthday, and he
sees that his wife baked a beautiful,
beautiful chocolate cake. And if he
wouldn't eat the chocolate cake, she'd
be very hurt.
So, he hastily convenes a beit din
and says, "I made a neder not to eat
chocolate, but had I known that my wife
was making a chocolate cake, I never
would have made the neder. That's a
pesach." It may be trivial, but that is
a pesach.
And the neder could be released.
So, Rabbi Akiva asked Kalba Savua,
"Was there if you would have known that
your son-in-law would become a talmid
chacham,
would you have made the vow?"
So, he said, "A talmid chacham?
Had I known he would learn how to read,
I wouldn't have made the vow."
So, Rabbi Akiva said, "You're released.
The vow has
been has been released."
Now, in truth, by the way, I don't want
to get too technical.
Uh this type of pesach is actually
halachically very problematical
because this is called a nola. Let me
explain this. The normal idea of pesach
is it has to be a preexisting condition.
It has to be something that existed at
the time of the vow. So, if, for
example, Rabbi Akiva was a talmid
chacham and Kalba Savua didn't know it,
that would be a pesach. Had you known
that he was a talmid chacham.
But, you can't really say had you known
he would become because at the time of
the vow, he was ignorant.
In other words, a pesach has to be a
preexisting
ignorance
that existed at time of the vow.
So, Tosfos asked the question, how could
Rebbe Akiva not hear
uh annul the vow of Kol Nidre via the
Pesach that he became a talmid chacham?
That is what is called nolad. Nolad is a
later event that's born. And ain poschin
benolad, the Mishna says, we cannot use
nolad
as a petach.
So, Tosfos says a wonderful, wonderful
answer. Tosfos says, since at the time
of the vow Rebbe Akiva had begun to
learn, even before he went to yeshiva,
he had begun to learn,
if you commit yourself
to learning, it is so guaranteed that
you will have success
that it's treated as if it's a present
reality
and not a future reality. That's a very
important mussar that we can use even
today.
So, this part of the Rebbe Akiva story
is so inspirational.
Number one, he was 40 years old, he knew
nothing.
And he still became the great person
that he became.
This is something again in in Ohr
Sameach, where where where I teach,
you know, most of our students are
baalei teshuva
who came to Torah relatively later. Of
course, not as late as Rebbe Akiva, but
they come at 25, whatever it is.
And they sometimes feel
there's no way they'll ever really
achieve
success.
And of course, we can't promise they'll
become Rebbe Akivas, that's a little bit
false advertising.
But the story of Rebbe Akiva is there's
always potential.
Don't don't give up.
Uh and uh again, it's a beautiful and
then we have Tosfos that uh
if you commit yourself,
Hashem can act guarantees
that you will have that success. Okay.
So, so far, so good?
Wonderful. If the story would have ended
there.
It would have been joyous,
inspiring,
happy.
But the story doesn't end there.
We don't know exactly when because we
don't have a year-by-year diary,
but at some point
those 24,000 students died
in the period of time
between Pesach and Shavuos.
A lot of things are not clear.
Uh number one,
how did they die? The Talmud says they
died
through a plague.
Some historians, and actually Rav Henkin
endorsed this as well,
suggest that the reference to plague is
a bit of a euphemism and a partial
cover-up
that the 24,000 students may have died
because they were participants in the
Bar Kochba revolt
against Rome. We know that Rabbi Akiva
himself
was very old, but he was a Bar Kochba
supporter. He thought Bar Kochba
was Mashiach,
and one could imagine
that his talmidim
perhaps took up arms
uh in support of Bar Kochba,
and when Bar Kochba was mercilessly
crushed
in the Beitar,
so the students of Rabbi Akiva who were
participating uh were killed as well. So
again,
it's a machlokes. The Gemara itself does
not say that at all. The Gemara itself
says it was a plague, but again, some do
learn that
the Gemara is notoriously obscure
uh when it comes to the details of the
Bar Kochba revolt. I mean, this is a
well-known idea that for various reasons
uh at least the Talmud Bavli
does not choose to discuss this revolt
in any great detail. So Rav Henkin
himself endorse- the reason I mention
Rav Henkin because I know if I would
just say it over in the name of
historians, a lot of type people say,
"Oh, the happy courses, it's connected
to Gomorrah."
Okay, some people get For some I don't
know why I don't I don't know why this
is an emotional issue. For some reason,
some people get angry. It shows that she
was doing that she goes to the army.
Yeah.
Yeah. Well, you you you may have a
point.
>> [laughter]
>> You may have a point. Uh but some people
get very upset over it. But but Reb
Penkin himself, uh the great Reb Penkin,
uh this is the grandfather of the Reb
Penkin as Hasham Yinkam Damav uh
he's a great old Reb Penkin.
Uh who died his son was Hasham Yinkam
Damav Reb Penkin himself
was just nifter. Uh okay. But be it as
it may, they died between the period of
Pesach and Shavuos.
Now,
again, forgive the amateur
psychoanalysis.
This was a great tragedy, of course.
But let's put ourselves in the mind of
Rachel for a moment.
The 24 years of suffering.
And she finally sees
that everything was worth it.
And then it's all taken away
and collapses into dust.
How does she view her life?
How does she view her struggle?
How does she view the worth of
everything that she did?
I [snorts] know that I'm moving in from
the tragedy of the 24,000 to the tragedy
of the one.
But there's a certain poignancy
in the tragedy of the one.
But there's another part of the story
that people often don't pay attention
to.
And that is
Rebbe Akiva started again.
Rebbe Akiva started
with five
talmidim.
One of whom was Rebbe Shimon
bar Yochai.
Let's think about this.
There's a pretty big difference
between 24,000
and just five.
And Rabbi Akiva is no longer so young.
And in fact, very shortly afterwards, he
himself is going to be tortured to
death.
Dying al Kiddush Hashem.
But we're not there yet.
And Rabbi Akiva
teaches Torah to the five talmidim.
Now, one would have understood if he
just would have been depressed, he would
have been in seclusion, he could have
said, "I did my part.
And Hashem determined I wouldn't be
matzliach, so that's it."
So, you learn something from that second
part of the story.
And that is even if you lose everything,
even if your world is destroyed,
you go on.
You rebuild.
You don't give up.
You never know
from where your ultimate contribution
is going to come from.
And you know,
from those five talmidim, Rabbi Meir,
Rabbi Yehuda, Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai,
all of the Torah that we have, the
Mishnah,
and the discussions of the Talmud, of
the Gemara,
and all of the halachas that come from
them,
are from those five talmidim.
So, Rabbi Akiva was not teaching five
people.
He was teaching the thousands and
hundred thousands, millions
of all of the Jews that would be
learning Torah
in all of the generations. Rabbi Akiva
is considered is considered to be the
main transmitter of the Torah Sheba'al
Peh.
And it's not via the 24,000.
It's via the five.
Via the five.
It reminds me very much also of a story
involving five, a much later story.
Reb Heiman
was a great Rosh Yeshiva in Vilna. He
was the Talmud Muvek.
He was the greatest disciple of Reb
Boruch Ber Leibowitz, great Rosh
Yeshiva.
And Reb Heiman came to the United
States
uh before the Holocaust in the 1930s.
And he became for a short while, he died
shortly thereafter, but he was Yeshiva
of Torah Vodaas.
And in those days,
1930s,
very few people were learning in
Yeshivas. There were very few Yeshivas
and there were very few people learning
in Yeshivas.
Who would even think of it?
And he was giving a shiur, an advanced
shiur to five talmidim,
like Rabbi Akiva.
Five talmidim.
And he was gesticulating, he was very
lebedik, very lively, very enthused.
And one of his chaveirim from Vilna
walked by and noticed the enthusiasm
with which he was giving the shiur.
And said to him afterwards,
"Reb I don't understand. When
you were in Vilna
teaching 500 talmidim, so I get I get
the enthusiasm.
You're teaching five guys.
What is there Why are you so What are
you so excited about exactly?"
It's not such a nice thing to say, but
he said, "What are you so excited
about?"
So Reb Heiman says,
said,
"I'm not teaching five people.
These five talmidim are going to have
families. And many of them are going to
become teachers. And they're going to
have talmidim, talmidei talmidei
talmidim.
I am teaching the thousands of people
that are going to be coming out of these
five.
So when I look in this room, I'm not
seeing five people.
I am seeing the generations of Am
Yisrael
that will come from this.
The fact that I don't they're not
physically in the room
is not that important to me.
Again, it seems to me
that that was in the mind of Rabbi Akiva
in the same way.
Okay.
So, this is the story
of Rabbi Akiva.
The story of Rabbi Akiva.
Of course, the end story is he himself
was tortured to death.
And remember his
talmidim surrounded him.
And they said, "Is this the reward you
get
for your devotion to Torah?"
And Rabbi Akiva said, "All of my life
I wanted to fulfill the pasuk
vi'ahavta et Hashem Elohecha, to love
Hashem
with all of your heart
and all of your soul, all of your soul,
your life.
And now I have the chance
to give my nefesh to Hashem.
Should I not rejoice?"
That's the story of Rabbi Akiva.
And I should mention to you going back I
I
I forgot to mention one detail out of
order
that when his wife approached him when
he came back with the 24,000 talmidim,
you know, earlier,
the talmidim didn't know who she was and
they didn't let her approach. They
thought she was a crazy woman.
And Rabbi Akiva said the famous words,
"Sheli v'shelachem,
my Torah and your Torah, everything we
are
shelo
is hers."
And Rabbi Akiva, as you know, is uh
you never know for sure, but the
official kever is in Tiberias.
>> [snorts]
>> And uh some of the story is there on the
matzeva and uh the line "Sheli
v'shelachem,
shelo is uh on the on the cover itself.
Rachel by the way died um
soon after the 24,000 students died,
perhaps out of heartbreak.
Rabbi Akiva had a second marriage.
So in many many ways Rachel didn't see
the rejuvenation
that Rabbi Akiva was able to
perpetrate. Yeah.
Maybe I'm a little bit tracked. Somebody
got left out of his children. And he's
away for 24 years.
>> Yeah.
>> They lost the opportunity of learning
from their father. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So
it's interesting that
there's one of the Tanaim in the Mishna
is Yehoshua ben Korcha.
And some say Yehoshua ben Korcha
was a Tana
was the son of Rabbi Akiva.
Ah, you'll ask me the obvious question.
Why is he called Yehoshua ben Korcha?
Should be Yehoshua ben Akiva. So Korcha
means bald
and apparently Rabbi Akiva was called
bald Baldi.
So they used the nick they used the
nickname.
Uh so it's it's hard it's hard again
it's very very hard to understand. I
mean all I can tell you is
we admire Rabbi Akiva well you know it's
similar to Moshe you know Moshe Rabbeinu
was celibate.
Now
are you is a man allowed to be celibate?
No. I mean if he you know
so there are things that the greatest
greatest greatest Sadiqim do
that are not necessarily complete role
models
for our lesser mortals. And I think
Rabbi Akiva is a very similar thing. I
mean basically
what Rabbi Akiva did was extreme
and if anybody else would want to do it
not in fact I'll I'll give you another
little thing. Um the one of there's a
great Tana
who is called ben Azai Shimon ben Azai.
And the Gamarra in Yevamot it is said
when the Gamora discusses the mitzvah to
get married and have children,
it actually says that Ben Azai says, "I
can't get married.
Nafshi chashka baTorah, my soul is so
desirous of learning Torah
that it's not shayach for me to get
married and take on a family."
We used to call them Yeshiva when we had
older bachelors.
We would call them members of the Ben
Azai club.
Now, Tosfos brings the following. Ben
Azai was married.
But he got divorced.
And who did he marry?
He married Rabbi Akiva's daughter.
So again, please forgive the amateur
psychoanalysis, but I I want to
focus on why I think that might have
happened. And I I I have a feeling it
might be correct, although I I don't
know.
Here you got Ben Azai.
Ben Azai is so attached to learning
that he feels he cannot take on domestic
responsibilities.
But there's a mitzvah to get married.
So what does a guy like Ben Azai figure?
I got to find a wife
who will let me kind of not be involved
in the family and just learn Torah.
So who better than Rabbi Akiva's
daughter?
She had a mother who did exactly that.
And that's why he married Rabbi Akiva's
daughter.
Why didn't it work?
Because she saw what her mother went
through, and that was not a life
she was able to accept. Right? So it was
a little bit of an experiment that that
backfired. Yeah.
Yes, yes. That's a story that the day
that she was going to get married, a
snake she stuck a hatpin or a pin
into the wall and it went through the
eye of the snake. Okay.
Now, here is the thing that I I want to
connect to to Lag B'Omer
uh briefly.
That is this story
is the source of the aveilus, the
mourning, not getting married, not
listening to music, uh not getting
haircuts. It's not in the Gemara. In
other words, the Gemara itself does not
indicate any mourning rituals during
Sefiras HaOmer. The hepech,
intrinsically, this should have been a
happy period. This should have been a
happy period. We're looking forward to
Matan Torah.
But in the teshuvos of the Gaonim, we
find
and it wasn't even universal, but they
said, "Yesh makomos.
There are places
where Klal Yisrael has a minhag not to
make weddings
and not to cut hair
between Pesach and Shavuos
to commemorate
the tragedy
of the deaths of the students of Rabbi
Akiva. And eventually that became
universal, although the exact dates
uh the exact minhagim differ.
So again, be sure you understand this.
The story of the deaths of Rabbi Akiva's
students is in the Gemara.
But using that story as the source of
aveilus restrictions is post-Talmudic.
Post-Talmudic. Now,
you can ask a very simple question.
Okay,
24,000 students,
very tragic, very sad.
But unfortunately, we've had worse.
I still have to mourn the talmidim of
Rabbi Akiva over and over and over and
over again every single year for several
weeks,
no weddings, no music.
Although the music itself is a shaila,
but the minhag is no music.
Why? Why am I choosing that tragedy out
of the many many many tragedies of Klal
Yisrael?
Why am I commemorating that tragedy
Over and over and over again.
And the answer is
it's not the tragedy per se.
It is the reason that is given for that
tragedy.
You see, even for the Holocaust, if
somebody were to ask you, you know, why
did I shame bring a Holocaust?
You could theorize and you can write
people have written books and you know,
both religiously secularly, but the but
the but the bottom line is we don't
fully we don't fully know.
We don't have prophets. We're not for
sale.
But for the deaths of the students of
Rabbi Akiva
for sale gave us
>> [snorts]
>> a reason.
They did not show
proper cover
to each other.
Honor, dignity,
respect.
They were taken for the from the world
because they did not show proper cover.
What does that mean?
They did not show
proper cover.
We can assume that if these were the
students of the great Rabbi Akiva
they were not pushing each other out of
line. They were not calling each other
names. They were not saying, you're an
idiot.
If we would have had a video, presumably
their behavior would have been totally
kosher.
But Rabbi Shimshon Raphael Hirsch
says the following idea.
The etymology, the origin of the word
cover
is connected to cover. Cover means
heavy,
weighty.
And heavy weighty is not only about
corpulence, but it refers to
significance.
When you talk about someone is a
heavyweight or someone is weighty
that means
their opinion carries significance. The
first says,
showing kavod to another person
is not about being polite.
It's not about etiquette.
It's not about, you know, Emily Post
behavior.
Kavod is I see the other person
as significant,
as valuable,
as worthy.
You could be very nice to a person even.
But you might be condescending.
You might be patronizing.
You might regard them as really an
insignificant person, but noblesse
oblige, whatever it would be, you treat
them nicely.
Now, we still don't fully understand why
was there a failure of that on the part
of the media ready Akiva, perhaps
because they were so connected to their
great rebbe
that they didn't feel they had anything
to learn from each other.
Perhaps.
But be it as it may, the first says,
laynagu kavod ze la zeh is the idea of
not seeing the inner significance
of the other person.
Not seeing their hashivus. Now, you may
ask me, so for that you die?
I mean, okay, it's not the highest level
of musar, but is that a type of aveira
that a person is taken from the world?
And the answer [snorts] is, normally
not.
But these 24,000 students
were supposed to be the transmitters of
Torah to the next generation.
They were supposed to be the gedolim,
they were supposed to be the leaders,
they were supposed to be the foundation
of Am Yisrael.
And yet,
when
your so-called leaders
do not see the inner worth
the inner beauty
of Klal Yisrael
every single person in Klal Yisrael
then yes
they are not worthy of being leaders.
God takes them from the world not so
much to punish them
but it's simply a question of replacing
the leaders
with those who are better suited.
Okay?
So I know he know me. Uh it's not that
it was the biggest of areas in the world
but it was an attitude that was fatal
to be a manhig Yisrael.
A manhig Yisrael
must look at every Jew
see the beauty
see the radiance, see the goodness
see the tzelem Elokim.
And that is what it means that he didn't
show kavod. So therefore
the reason why we mourn during the
period of the Omer
to commemorate the students of Rabbi
Akiva is not simply mourning a tragedy
but to remember the reason they died
and thereby
try in our own lives
in our own lives
to rectify
that reason
and transcend it.
So what is special about Lag BaOmer?
So according to some traditions
on the 33rd day of the Omer
there was a cessation of the plague.
The students of Rabbi Akiva did not die
on the 33rd day of the Omer.
Now why not? What would be special about
that day that poof they didn't die on
that day?
So it depends how you understand it. You
see no, no, it depends how you
understand it. If you assume the plague
continued afterwards,
then indeed there were told me them who
were left to die, but they didn't die of
that. So, it really would depend. You
you you are correct in that.
So, here I have to be a little
cabalistic.
We know
that the seven weeks of the Omer
are linked
to the seven lower divine emanations
that are called Sefirot. There are
actually 10 Sefirot,
sources of divine energy, but the first
three are said to be God's brains, Kav
Yasha, Chochmah, Binah, Da'at, etc. But
the lower seven are behavioral
attributes. Chesed, [snorts] loving
kindness, Gevurah, inner strength,
Tiferet, beauty, Netzach,
eternity, Hod, uh glory, Yesod,
foundation,
Malchut, kingship.
Again,
we don't have time now, obviously, to go
over each of them, but each week
represents one of those dominant sources
of spiritual energy. That's also the
case of the Ushpizin.
That's also the case of the seven
Hakafot
of Hoshana Rabbah and Simchat Torah.
They're all connected to these Sefirot.
Now, because
there are seven days in a week,
each day
is also linked in microcosm
to a Sefirah. So, for example, the first
day of the Omer, which is of course the
second day of Pesach,
is the day of loving kindness,
situated in the week of loving kindness.
So, it's called Chesed
sheb'Chesed.
The second day of the first week
is Gevurah, inner strength, sheb'Chesed,
>> [snorts]
>> not to be confused with the first day of
the second week, which is
Hesed Shebe Gevurah.
So, the combinations are complex.
And in fact, there are books in Hebrew
and in English
that use these combinations of day and
week
to give you a specific spiritual
exercise
for every day of the Omer, how you
combine them and practical things that
you can do. It's a very interesting type
of thing.
Now, these Sefirot are also linked to
personalities.
Hesed is like the used piece. Hesed is
Avraham.
Gevurah is Yitzchak. Tiferet is Yaakov.
Netzach is Moshe.
Hod is Aharon. Yesod is Yosef. Who's
after that? And Malchut is David.
So now,
let's look at Lag BaOmer.
Lag BaOmer
is the fifth day
of the fifth week. Right? We said it's 4
weeks and 5 days. That means, a little
confusing, 4 weeks and 5 days actually
means you're in the fifth day
of the fifth week.
In Sefirah terminology,
Kabbalistic terminology,
Hod
Shebe Hod,
the day of glory
within
the week
of glory.
Who is the personality associated with
Hod?
It is Aharon.
Today
is Aharon's day
in Aharon's week.
What was the spiritual power of Aharon?
Ohev Shalom
V'rodef Shalom.
And Hod in particular, glory is said to
mean
the capacity
to see the goodness of the other.
So, based on this idea
you can understand why Lag B'Omer
where the spiritual emanation of Aaron
HaKohen
was extra powerful.
The Talmidei Rabbi Akiva could at least
momentarily be freed
from the thing that had dragged them
down.
Cuz they had failed because they didn't
see the kavod of the other.
But on the day of Hod Sheba Hod
you can become liberated.
You can achieve a greater capacity
to see that goodness.
And that applies
to us
as well.
We live, obviously
in a very polarized world. You know,
people worry about anti-Semitism, they
worry about Iran, they worry about uh
many, many, many things.
And yeah, okay, there are things to be
worried about.
But the thing that we really should be
worried about
is the division within Am Yisrael.
The hatred, the polarizations, the
indifference
the coldness
the rejection
the, you know
it's, you know, I versus you, whatever
whatever when whatever form
that takes.
Because that is kind of the root cause
of all the other problems we face.
In fact, Sefarim tell us that at least
one of the reasons for anti-Semitism
is to make Jews turn inward and realize
we have to connect to each other.
Because so many people hate us, we can't
find our salvation
in looking
to the favors, the goodwill of others.
Right? Trump is not Messiah, but again,
we were grateful for a lot of what he
did, etc.
So,
this is a real problem, and may maybe
maybe it's a bigger problem in Eretz
Yisrael even
than it is in Chutz La'aretz
because people feel more strongly here
about issues, and that can create a lot
of divisiveness.
But at least Lag Ba'omer is a smart
where we can tap into
the spiritual energy of Hochma and Binah
and try to understand other Jews, other
people.
Try to see the goodness in them.
And as HaMelech promises us in
the book of Mishlei,
K'mayim panim el panim, kein lev adam
l'adam.
As water reflects the face that you show
it,
you show the water a smiling face, you
get a smile back.
You show the water a frowning face, you
get a frown back.
So, the heart of a human being reflects
back
that
which it is shown.
And the more we see the and show the
kavod that we have
in the other, whoever the other is,
the more the other
will see the kavod that is in us, and in
reality, it'll no longer be the other.
Because there is no the other.
There is only us.
Right? I use the vocabulary the other,
but there is no other.
All of us are one.
And hopefully Lag Ba'omer can help us
try to achieve that much greatness.