Preparing video...
0:00 / 0:00
Modern Masters: DeMystifying Lag B’Omer | Rabbi Sam Shor | April 30th 2026
34 views
www.ouisrael.org facebook.com/ouisrael #OUisrael #torah #judaism #torahlectures
Categories:Torah
Comments
Transcript
Auto-generated transcript. Not time-synced to the video.
Our entire full morning of learning
today
was sponsored, was dedicated for the
speedy and full recovery of Liam Yaakov
Nissan ben Ora. May he have a refuah
shleimah. Let's keep him in mind. Please
have a refuah shleimah.
We know that we are just a few days
before Lag BaOmer. So today I want to
look ahead and take a you know, a a
close look at Lag BaOmer. Of course, Lag
BaOmer, there are two great Tanaim that
we associate with Lag BaOmer. Of course,
Rabbi Akiva, who lost 24,000 students
during this period of the days of the
Omer period.
And of course, after those 24,000
students perished, that we are told that
there's a next generation
of a subsequent generation of a handful
of of of students of Rabbi Akiva who
helped to restore all the Torah that had
been lost, all the Torah that
disappeared with the loss of those
24,000 students. And of course, amongst
those, that second generation is Rabbi
Shimon bar Yochai. And Rabbi Shimon bar
Yochai, of course,
the day of Lag BaOmer is also known in
the annals of of Jewish tradition as the
Hilula of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, which
loosely translates as the Yahrtzeit or
the anniversary of the celebration of
his life, the anniversary of his
passing.
So today, I want to take a
a close look.
Or I'll take a as I I like to say, a
deep dive into the teachings and
legacies of each of these two great
sages and begin to, you know, Rabbi
Shimon bar Yochai, of course, is is is
is known, it's attributed that he's the
author of the Zohar Hakadosh. That we
often say that he's the the author of
the primary work of Jewish mysticism, of
the inner Torah, of Pnimiyus HaTorah. So
today, I want to take a deep dive and
clarify together, maybe demystify
together, the legacies of these two
great sages, Rabbi Akiva and Rabbi
Shimon bar Yochai. So,
just before we actually jump into our
sheets, Rabbi [snorts] Rabbi
Zalman Auerbach in his Moadei Moadei be
Halacha writes the following. This is in
um in the article that he has there
Moadei Moadei be Halacha about Lag
B'Omer. He he mentions we know that many
of us are familiar that there's a
long-standing minhag to visit Meron, to
visit the burial site of Rabbi Shimon
bar Yochai and his son Rabbi Elazar,
okay, on the day of Lag B'Omer and tens
of thousands of hundreds of thousands of
people make their way to Meron over Lag
B'Omer. And by the way, this is not a
new minhag, as we're going to learn from
this short ketubah that um
this short passage in the Moadei be
Halacha that Rabbi Zalman brings. So,
listen to his words. Minhag Eretz
Yisrael she nohagei me reisha al kivrei
Rashbi z"l v'Rabbi Elazar ben Rabbi
Yochai Lag B'Omer. Okay, we know that
there's a long-standing practice,
>> [cough]
>> custom, to go to the the the kever of
Rashbi, to Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai's
resting place, in the resting place he's
buried near near his son, in in Meron on
Lag B'Omer. And now
we in terms of where does this minhag
first come from? When does it first
appear?
V'eid Rabbi Rabbi Avraham Halevi, and
Rabbi Avraham Halevi, who was a 16th
century um he I guess he's an he's
either a late uh I guess you could say
he's a he's an early acharon. He's a
16th century, 1500s, okay? She haya
noheg tamid lomar birkat nachim b'birkat
tishkahn. He had a practice, a strange
custom, to always say the bra the the
sukum of nachim in the brachah of the
l'Yerushalayim birkat. We say that
tefillah only when on Tisha B'Av, okay?
That that uh that Yerushalayim should
not only be rebuilt, but we should
experience the comfort of that
rebuilding. So, traditionally, most of
us say that bracha, that add those words
to the bracha of the Jerusalem in our
Shemoneh Esrei on Tisha B'Av. But, says
this Reb Reb Avraham Levi, that he had
the practice to say it every single day,
okay? To So, he was so so pained by the
fact that we did not have a Beit
Hamikdash, that he would say the bra-
the the words of Nachim every single
day.
Okay, so now he says
so so now he says
that he went to to to to he went to
um to to Meron on on Lag B'Omer
to daven. Okay, so so now he says
and when he finished davening, Amar
LaRabi Yitzchak Luria, zal, the Ari,
zal, the Ari Hakadosh, came over there.
I guess the Ari, zal, was there at the
same time as this Reb Reb Avraham Levi
was, and Reb Avraham Levi davened
Shemoneh Esrei like he normally did and
included the bracha Nachim in his silent
silent Amidah. And
after he finished, the Ari, zal, walked
over to him, okay?
And he says
And he says to him Amar Li Isha Zeh, he
says he says Reb Shimon bar Yochai came
down in a vision, okay? And said to him
Amar Li Isha Zeh, say to this person,
Reb Avraham Levi, okay? Lama Hu Omer
Nachim B'Yom Simchati. Why is he say-
reciting the Nachim prayer, this prayer
of mourning and asking for comfort on
the day of my joy? And this This story,
by the way, is brought down in numerous
numerous sefarim, including many
chassidishe sefarim, as being the source
not only for the minhag of going to
Meron on Lag B'Omer, but specifically
that this day of Lag B'Omer is known as
the day not only when we recall the
story of Rebbe Rebbe Akiva and his
talmidim, but the day of the joy, the
hilula, the celebration
of Rebbe Shimon bar Yochai.
So, we're going to come back to this
whole idea of Lag B'Omer as the hilula
of Rebbe Shimon bar Yochai, and but
we're going to start, of course, with
the previous generation, his
What?
What, nachum? Yes. That First of all,
the question why he says nachum every
day, that's a whole different story.
But the point being is that the Ariza
had a prophetic vision while he's
standing by at the kever of
Rebbe Shimon bar Yochai, and then Rebbe
Shimon bar Yochai appeared to him and
said, "Tell this guy he shouldn't be
saying nachum on a day of joy, that is
Lag B'Omer." Okay.
So, we're going to come back to Rebbe
Shimon bar Yochai in a few moments.
We're now going to go back to the
previous generation to learn about his
Rebbe, Rebbe Akiva. And we know that the
story of Rebbe Akiva is closely
associated with the [snorts] loss of his
24,000 students, but if we just just a
to before we look at that story, let's
contextualize who Rebbe Akiva was. Rebbe
Akiva, of course, was not an an educated
yeshiva education educated individual
till he turned 40 years old. At the age
of 40, Rebbe Akiva decides to go learn.
He spends 12 years in yeshiva. He comes
back and he hears his wife, as he's
about to return to the house, his wife
saying, "I wish, you know, I wish my my
my holy husband could could learn more."
And he turns around and goes back for
another 12 years, okay? So, two times 12
in the story of Rebbe Akiva's
trajectory to become who he When he
starts off as Akiva, in order for him to
become Rebbe Akiva, he goes twice for 12
years, two shifts of 12 years
to study in Yeshiva to become Rabbi
Akiva. All right?
Of course, Rabbi Akiva is most famous
from
teaching us from last week's parashah,
the parashah of last week's parashah,
"V'ahavta l'reacha kamocha" as text
number one on our sheet says, quoting
Rashi quoting the Medrash, okay? "Amar
Rabbi Akiva, zeh klal gadol baTorah."
That this is the most important
principle of the entire Torah. You can
either interpret this this this this
Rashi saying, "This is the most
important principle." Or at the very
least, this is an essential principle of
Torah, okay? But most people interpret
this as "zeh klal gadol baTorah." This
is the most important principle in the
entire Torah. Love your neighbor as
yourself. So of course, the question
we're going to ask is
if one of the most well-known accounts
of Rabbi Akiva is that he had an an a
this huge s- educational system of
24,000 students,
and they all died. And we're going to
talk about why they died in a moment,
okay? And we all know that we we say
they died because they weren't nice to
one another. They didn't treat each
other with respect.
So how could it be that the same Rabbi
Akiva who gave the world the mantra of
"V'ahavta l'reacha kamocha, zeh klal
gadol baTorah," how could he experience
the loss of 24,000 students who did not
respect one another? So in order for us
to begin to unpack all this and try to
make sense of all this,
>> [cough]
>> we're going to look at two different
versions
of the story of Rabbi Akiva and his
talmidim. We're going to start with the
more famous one, the one that most of us
are familiar with, and that's the Gemara
in Yevamot. This is text number two on
our sheets. The talmidim in Maseches
Yevamot, okay, tells us, okay? "Amru
shnei asar elef zugim talmidim." Okay,
so the it's
told to us that there were 12,000 zugim,
pairs. So why is that why is that
language of 12,000 pairs important?
What's the significance of a pair when
we're talking about students? Zoning.
They were Havrusas, okay? And we're
going to come back to this in a moment.
So, 12,000 pairs of students how you
learn in Akiva
and the price from Gabatha and the price
basically the entire length and breadth
of
the cooler made to
and they all died during one time period
because
they didn't treat each other with
respect. The world remained in the world
remained desolate of Torah.
>> [cough]
>> Until
Akiva came
to teach the next group of sages in the
south. He taught
who did he teach? Rabbi Meir, Rabbi
Yehuda, Rabbi Yossi, Rabbi Shimon, Rabbi
Shimon bar Yochai, Rabbi Elazar ben
Shamua
and they restored Torah once again to
the next generation. It's taught cooler
made to me Pesach
they all died from Pesach
and Shavuot. And
it's taught that what they all died a
very very difficult death. My here what
was it? I mean
I can say they died of diphtheria a
plague, okay? That's very interesting.
It's said here that they all died
between Pesach and Shavuot. So, the
one of the
the says
we have a tradition from the
from the the time of the
Shev Yomi Lag Baomer Pascal Mita that
they stopped dying
the plague ceased on the day of Lag
Baomer, okay? We talked no game slowly
turn about. So, why don't why is Lag
B'Omer a day of mini celebration?
According to the Meiri,
he
says this day of Lag B'Omer is a day of
mini celebration. Why? Because according
to the Meiri, it's on this day that the
plague that struck Rabbi Akiva's
students that took 12, you know, 12,000
pairs of Rabbi Akiva's students ceased
on Lag B'Omer. Okay. So, that's version
number one of the story.
We're now going to look at version
number two of the story, which appears
in the Medrash Rabbah.
Let's keep an eye out for the subtle
differences between the two versions of
the story, okay?
So, this is text number three on our
sheets.
Rabbi Akiva Amar, Rabbi Akiva said,
"Okay, so in the first one it said what?
It's other Tanna, it's other sages
speaking about the story of Rabbi Akiva.
But here it's Rabbi Akiva his personal
reflections, okay? Rabbi Akiva Amar,
Rabbi Akiva said, "Shneim asar alafim
talmidim hayu hayu li." Now, he says, "I
had 12,000 students." No There's no
nothing about pairs, okay? The 12,000
number remains,
okay? But nothing about pairs. In the
first thing In the first version of the
story, there's a clue that it's
something something about chavrusas,
right? But here it just says no, 12,000
students. But we'll come back to that
question. Hayu li mi Gvat ad Yavneh ad
Bnei Brak. So far, so good. They they I
have them all over I had an educational
system that spanned the entire Eretz
Yisrael. The kulam
Oh.
Now, here's a different wrinkle.
In the first version it said they all
died during one time period, okay?
Seemingly what?
All once. But Rabbi Akiva says in this
when Rabbi Akiva's telling the story, he
doesn't say that. He says they all died
b'chayai, during my lifetime ben Pesach
ad Shavuot. So, seemingly it's not that
they died in one plague in during, you
know, one year there was a plague that
decimated them. And by the way, in this
version of the story, there's no mention
of the plague of diphtheria, okay? Just
that they all died during his lifetime,
and it seemed to be something that
happened again and again and again
during his lifetime between these days,
between Pesach and and and Shavuot. When
myself, and at the end of it,
after I lost those 12,000 students, had
me to had me to leave Shiva. I was left
with seven, okay? Who were those seven
students? He says here's had me to leave
Shiva. In the Gemara, we're told there
were five. Here in this version, had me
to leave Shiva. I was left with seven.
Who were those seven? Okay, Rabbi
Yehuda, Rabbi Yehuda bar Ilai, Rabbi
Nehemiah, Rabbi Meir, Rabbi Meir bar
Ilai, Rabbi Yossi, Rabbi Shimon bar
Yochai,
So,
in this version we're we're told that
some of the names are the same, some of
them are different names, additional
names. And this is Rabbi Akiva's own
personal reflections. I'm going to have
He said to them, this next generation of
students, this next these seven new
students,
>> [clears throat]
>> I'm going to have I wish all of them
made to my first students didn't die and
let me measure I didn't name so Rabbi
Tarfon said to them, they didn't die for
any other reason except for what? That
their eyes were narrow towards one
another in Torah. We're going to discuss
what that means in a few moments, okay?
That's saying they didn't treat each
other with respect. He has a
And again, this is Rabbi Akiva's
personal reflections. He says what?
Their eyes were narrow towards one
another in Torah. I can't load to you
thing. You shouldn't be like them. Don't
do what they did. And me out and when
they heard this message, then they
immediately I'm doing you call out to
say all Torah. They went and filled out
to say all Torah. So, what's very
interesting, despite the subtle
differences in the two versions of the
story,
we have in both versions of the story we
have this idea of 12 or 12,000 12,000.
We have the 12,000 pairs or 12,000
students. And we mentioned earlier that
Rabbi Akiva also has two two two times
the number 12 in his life, right? And
Rabbi Akiva goes away initially to study
for 12 years. He comes back and he goes
back for another 12 years, okay? And
then if we look at the next generation,
his most famous student that we're going
to who we're going to look at in greater
depth this afternoon together is Rabbi
Shimon bar Yochai. In Rabbi Shimon bar
Yochai's story, he hides away in a cave
together with his son to hide from the
Romans for 12 years. He comes out of the
cave and they've been so immersed in
Torah and the secrets of Torah for those
12 years that they start to burn up
everything they look at. And they go
back into the cave for another 12 12 not
years, months.
So, the number 12 throughout this entire
this entire trajectory, starting with
Rabbi Akiva going to learn for 12 years
and again for 12 years, and then and
continuing to the 12,000 pairs or 12,000
students, and then continuing to Rabbi
Shimon bar Yochai the 12 years and the
12 months.
So, says says Rabbi [clears throat]
Pinchas Friedman, one of the great
teachers of Hasidut today that known as
the the Shvilei Pinchas. The Shvilei
Pinchas says that the number 12 appears
throughout the story over and over and
over again
to emphasize one important message.
What does the number 12 represents
represent in the annals of Jewish life
and teaching? The 12 shvatim, the 12
tribes of the Jewish people. And this is
meant to emphasize that Torah
is relevant and belongs to each of the
12 tribes. No one has a monopoly and
exclusive ownership or interpretation on
Torah. Torah belongs, and the
scholarship of our Torah Kadusha belongs
to all 12 tribes. And this says the
Shulchan Aruch
is the secret that's encrypted in the
each of the generations of the story
starting with Rabbi Akiva going to learn
for 12 years twice, and for and and the
story that of his talmidim that in both
versions the number 12 appears. And also
the story of Rabbi Shimon that's 12 and
12. The number 12 appears over and over
again to reiterate us this important
message, and we're going to come back to
this message that Torah is relevant
always
to every single member of Klal Yisrael.
Okay? Each of the 12 tribes. Okay, we're
going to come back to this idea. Now,
take a look at text number four on your
sheets, the famous Mishnah Pirkei Avot.
Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai kibbel
me-Hillel u-Shammai. Okay, Rabbi
Yochanan ben Zakkai received the mesorah
from Hillel and from Shammai. Hu aya
omer, he used to say, "Im lamadta Torah
harbeh, if I if you've learned a lot of
Torah, al tachazik tovah le-atzmecha,
don't take it as a credit for yourself."
Okay? But don't pat yourself on the
back. Why? Ki le-kach notzarta.
Because why? It's specifically for this
reason that you were created. Hakadosh
Baruchu put us in the world that we
should learn the Torah's wisdom
and share it with others and improve the
world.
And it's very fascinating
the Avodas Yisrael of Kozhnitz in his
commentary on our Mishnah. Okay, if you
turn your sheets to text number five,
the great Maggid of [clears throat]
Kozhnitz, the 19th-century Chassidic
master,
>> [snorts]
>> in his commentary on our Mishnah, he
quotes a
well-known pasuk, okay? A pasuk in Iyov.
And he says, "Al kavvana u-fi remez."
Okay, this Mishnah is to us an idea
that's alluded to in the
from
Adam a male you loud a person is
is is born in order to toil okay and he
says the word a male the word a male to
toil is Roche
is a an abbreviation right an acronym
for what little mode I'll be not little
I made a person is born to learn Torah
in order that what they should share
Torah with others learn Torah in order
that what you should be able to teach
Torah to others
okay should tell you I made a material
that is what that you should immerse
yourself in Torah how do you learn the
Torah
a person needs to what
to learn Torah in order that they're
able to share it with others
Rabbi Simon K one of the great Russia
Shiva in Yeshiva University today in his
beautiful foreign known as
if you take a look at text number six
and on our sheets the
takes begins to piece this all together
begins the trajectory everyone who who I
think everyone here
I think this is the first time maybe you
and I are learning together but I think
everyone else here we've learned
together in the past we know that when
my tend to be a a tapestry where we
weave together
similar themes from different from
different
and Rabbi Simon in his beautiful safer
he begins to help us
with our weaving it all together so take
a look at text number six all
the showing no mate too okay in the in
the version in the
the matter that we just learned together
okay he says them my first students
didn't die Ella for any other reason we
made a name Sarah but that was that okay
look to you came me out I'm doing me
look to sell tires they didn't have any
other reason except that their eyes were
narrow towards one another in Torah. You
shouldn't conduct yourself like them and
they immediately went out and were
inspired to begin to share Torah to the
entire Israel.
And we it's understood we can understand
from this
that the reason for the death of Rabbi
Akiva's students, okay? Low higher up
because of
it's not simply as the Gamara tells us
that they were disrespectful to one
towards one another that they didn't
have
honor treat each other with honor and
respect.
Okay? Hello, but rather be a car be
nation you shall you and sorry I am a
Torah. Below
the llama Torah hearing.
Will be glad that made to.
Okay? What was the reason? Wasn't just
they were rude to one another. It's
what? They did not want to share the
Torah that they learned with each other.
And since they refused to share the
Torah that they learned with each other,
they that's what caused their death.
The yesh let him learn therefore we have
to wonder and contemplate and ask What
was so terrible about what they did?
Okay, so they didn't they didn't share.
They didn't live up to their mandate.
Okay, that that that warranted it to
levy exert call you
that that warranted what? A death
sentence God forbid.
So now he's Rabbi Simon's going to
explain this.
Who is that tell me to Rabbi Akiva shall
I use a name Sarah Zaza the issue
low yours room below spill is a little
time. Since their eyes were narrow
towards one another in Torah and they
didn't show concern or that they wanted
to share the wisdom with their fellow to
help them and to influence their fellow,
okay?
Oto Tashke, therefore, whatever wisdom,
whatever Torah they had learned was
what?
Was Tashke, it was wasted. Okay? It had
no actualization.
No manifestation. It was just an
intellectual
intellectual exercise. Okay, it wasn't
manifested at all and actualized at all,
okay?
K English and Beria and we met it
because no other human being had any
other benefit from their wisdom. The
Kiva about Sarah Vana Nikareit. And
since they did not have therefore any
purpose, they didn't fulfill any purpose
and they really there was no need for
them, they didn't feel any need, okay?
And no one received any benefit for
them. Nikareit, they were spiritually,
okay, ostracized. They were Karis, they
received Karis. Vabame and they were
lost from the world. Vlakach Meitu.
And therefore they perished.
Vazel Kidvar Vazel Kidvareinu. And this
these words are are message for us. She
Eem Eina Adam Melamed Torah Laheren,
if a person doesn't share the Torah that
they've learned with others, Azai Huma
Abed Afik DeTorah Shel Atzmo. Then what
will happen? That even the Torah
knowledge they know, that they've
learned, will be lost. Ke Eem Mashbiin
Lo Milmala Hochma Uvina, because if
they're not constantly, okay, excited
about sharing the Torah they know, then
what's going to happen? Then that Shefa
that comes from above, that pipeline of
of wisdom and inspiration that comes
from above, is eventually going to be
closed off to them. Okay, Hashem gives
us that that Shefa, that pipeline of
wisdom and knowledge, in order that we
should share it with others. And the Bal
Shem Tov Rebbe famously
said and taught that even if a person
only knows the letter Aleph,
then they have an obligation to what?
To share that off with someone who does
not yet know the aleph-bet. Okay?
And that's the mussar skill that Rabbi
that Rabbi Simon sees in this story.
Rabbi Simon says, "How do we understand
that
the the such a terrible tragedy can
befall Rabbi Akiva's students, the these
great Torah scholars?" Because they
didn't understand what Torah learning
was all about. Torah learning is not
about achieving our own intellectual,
you know, accomplishments. It's about
transforming ourselves
and giving that wisdom over to others to
inspire and transform the world around
us. And if we don't do that, then all
the Torah we learned is what?
Is bal tashchis. It's completely wasted.
Okay.
So, with this as with this as our uh
new trajectory and understanding, our
backdrop to to beginning to understand
and weave together this tapestry of
understanding the story of Rabbi Akiva
and his students, we're now going to
look at a Gemara in Nedarim, another
Gemara in Nedarim.
And it also involves Rabbi Akiva and his
students. According to one of the
students who fell ill, again, we talked
about how there was this illness
that pervaded the entire community,
educational community and system of
Rabbi Akiva. So, this is the Gemara in
Nedarim, text number seven on our
sheets. Myaseh b'talmidei Rabbi Akiva
shechal alav. Okay, there's a story told
about one of the students of Rabbi Akiva
who became came ill.
Lo nichnesu chachamim l'vakro.
None of the other sages, again, 24,000
Torah scholars, none of the other sages
came to visit this sickly student, okay?
When he was ill. V'nichnas Rabbi Akiva,
but Rabbi Akiva came to visit, l'vakro,
to visit him. U'v'shaa she'kibdo v're'ah
ribtzol lifanav, and since he swept and
cleaned up and straightened up the
house, and showed concern for his fellow
chaya, the person made a miraculous
recovery, and he lived.
Amar lei Rabbi Rabbi Akiva Tani, the
student said to him, "Rabbi Rabbi Akiva,
you saved me. You restored my life."
Yatzah Rabbi Akiva, from this experience
Rabbi Akiva went forth and says,
"Vidrash and taught, Kol mi she'amar
acher cholem
k'ilu
shofech damim. Anyone who doesn't visit
their friend who is ill, it's as if
what?
They've shed their blood."
Okay? Now, with this Gemara,
okay, kind of setting the stage, okay,
that the other sages had such rivalry
with one another, okay, the other
students had such rivalry with one
another that they couldn't even bring
themselves to visit uh one of their
students when he was sick, and Rabbi
Akiva was so was so taken and so
devastated by the experience that he
came out and paskened what? Anyone who
doesn't visit If you If you're all going
to become ill, if there's going to be a
plague, and you're not going to visit
one another, it's as if what?
You've killed each other.
And with this understanding, I want to
now go back and reread the version of
the story This text number eight now in
our sheets. Reread the version of the
the second version of the story of Rabbi
Akiva and his talmidim, okay?
And maybe we're going to read it a
little bit differently now,
um having learned this Gemara together.
So, take a look at text number eight.
V'Rabbi Akiva omer, Rabbi Akiva said,
"Shnayim asar alfin talmidim hayu li
b'Galei Elul ad Pesach, v'chulam metzu
b'chayai bein Pesach l'Atzeret." Okay,
we learned this already, right? They all
died during my lifetime, not necessarily
during the same year, but during my
lifetime, but during this time between
Pesach and Shavuot, u'mishum eilu
shiv'ah, and I was left with seven.
V'eilu hein, Rabbi Yehudah, Rabbi
Nechemiah, Rabbi Meir, Rabbi Yosi, Rabbi
Shimon, Rabbi Elazar, Rabbi
Eliezer ben Hurkenus, Rabbi Yosi ben
Kisma, Rabbi Yochanan ben Zakkai.
Amar lahem, now this is the part I want
to really re-read and focus on. Amar
lahem, we read this before. Amar lahem
Harishonim meitu ela mimesha hayta einam
sar betorah ze lazeh. That the first
ones didn't die for any ela for any
other reason except what? That their
eyes were narrow and Torah wasn't one
another. But having learned this Gemara
in the daran, okay, of how their rivalry
not only existed in the Beit Midrash,
but spilled over to real life. That they
couldn't they had such animosity towards
one another that they couldn't bring
themselves to visit a chaver who was
sick. And Rabbi Akiva says, if that's
the case, what? It's as if you're
killing one another.
Listen to this. How I want I want to
suggest we an alternative reading of
this Midrash. Amar lahem Harishonim lo
meitu, hard stop.
Okay, this is the finish of the Rashash,
by the way. Everyone knows who the
Rashash is.
Rabbi Shmuel Aaron Shore, that's me,
okay?
The Rashash. This is the finish of the
Rashash. Okay, Amar lahem Harishonim lo
meitu. My first students didn't really
die.
Ela, rather, what happened to them?
Mimesha hayta einam sar betorah ze
lazeh. Okay, what was it? They their
eyes were narrow towards one another in
learning in Torah. Atem lo tiyu ken.
Okay, and therefore I'm giving you the
sacred charge. Okay, I'm starting over.
Okay? The my the system was so poisoned
that they couldn't visit one another and
it's as if they killed each other.
And therefore my students are to you
dead to me. I have to start from
scratch.
I have to start anew. And therefore I'm
saying to you, Harishonim lo meitu. It's
not that they all died. Ela, rather,
mimesha hayta einam sar betorah ze
lazeh. But since their eyes were narrow
and turned one towards the other, "I
tend low to you, hey." "You don't be
like them." And they were so inspired by
that by that message, okay, that I'm
starting from scratch and I'm trusting
you to restore the world with Torah
because the others had to so to speak
they're they're dead to me. They can't
they can't carry on my legacy, okay?
And they immediately went and restored
Torah to the entirety of Eretz Israel.
Now, again, this is not the only way to
learn this this measure. The first time
we through we learned that as as most
people read this measure. Why? And most
people read this measure the way that
that we read the first time. Why?
Because it's consistent with subtle
changes to the story as it appears in
the the more well-known version of the
story as it appears in the Gamara in
Yevamot, okay, which is the first
version of the story that we learned.
But let's just go with this
for the moment, okay, with this kodesh.
Let's stay Let's accept this limud for
for the moment for the time being that
this limud is correct. If that's true
and Rabbi Akiva's students didn't really
die
so what are we really mourning, okay?
Some of us have the the sefirah beards
on our face. So what is it that we're
really mourning during these days
between Pesach and Shavuot? So now we're
going to learn
a very interesting idea
from Rabbi Avraham Schorr. Rabbi Avraham
Schorr is a
great teacher of Hasidus living in
Brooklyn, New York today. He's the son
of the very very famous Rosh Yeshiva of
Yeshiva Torah VeDaas. Okay,
Rabbi Gedaliah Schorr the Ohr Gedalyahu
and Rabbi Avraham Schorr in his
beautiful sefer Halachah VeHalivuv says
the following in text number nine on our
sheets. And
we simply have to understand, okay,
plain and simple, what are we meant to
understand from all that from all this?
The concept of mourning
Rabbi Akiva who had to stop
may availus al korban Beis Mikdashainu.
Listen to his words. The mourning that
we have for the students of Rebbe Akiva
are in essence a continuation of the
mourning from what?
From korban Beis Hamikdash.
Kimi Yom, and I was going to explain
this thing to you. Kimi Yom
Beis Hamikdash Ailo Hakadosh Baruch Hu
Ela Dalet Amos Halacha Gedola. Okay, the
Hashem's presence dwelled within the
Beis Hamikdash. When the Beis Hamikdash
was lost, our Chazal teaches us where do
we find Hashem's presence? In the Dalet
Amos, the proverbial four Amos, four
handbreadths of Halacha, through
learning, through Limud Torah. That's
the only place that we can experience a
revelation of Hashem's presence, says
the Gemara Brachos. Dahainu She Sham
Be'eila Dalet Amos Yesh Hemshech
Hashra'as Hashchinah Shehaya BeBeis
Hamikdash. That when we immerse
ourselves in the in learning Torah,
that's when we can once again experience
a revelation of Hashem's presence in a
similar way that we were able to
experience when we had the Beis
Hamikdash. Oh, like that's now he
continues. Veshichachas Torah and the
Chashash Shalom, and if we forget Torah,
if Torah is forgotten, God forbid, Hu
Hemshech Shel Churban Beis Hamikdash.
Okay, therefore, if learning Torah is a
way to continue as if to the revelation
of Hashem's presence as if what? We
still had a Beis Hamikdash, then
therefore, if we forget Torah, God
forbid, if Torah is forgotten from us,
God forbid, then what is that? That's a
continuation of the mourning of
the destruction of the Beis Hamikdash.
Ki HaTorah Hu Hemshech Shel Kedushas
Hamikdash. Because the Torah
is the only thing we have left for us to
experience on some level the holiness
that we experienced when we had a Beis
Hamikdash. Uvishichachas
and by forgetting when Torah is God
forbid forgotten, Na'avad Me'itanu Od
Chelek Mikedushas Hamikdash. Then what's
lost us when we It's not just the Torah
knowledge that's forgotten and lost us,
but we're also simultaneously
metaphysically learning and losing
another portion of the holiness of the
base of migdash, okay?
So, now
Rebbe Nachman is going to explain this a
little more. Yom Lag B'Omer who has
a little shout out to me today Rebbe
Akiva. This day of Lag B'Omer represents
what? The the
interruption in the deaths of the
students of Rebbe Akiva that we said
supposedly died between Pesach and
Shavuot.
Why? Why do we say that they What What's
the significance specifically these
days? Ki Rashbi Rebbe Shimon bar Yochai
who shall mark What is Rebbe Shimon bar
Yochai? We talked about Rebbe Akiva's
famous mantra of
What's one of the famous teachings of
Rebbe Shimon bar Yochai? Has v'shalom
sh'tishkach Torah mi'Yisrael. That God
forbid what?
Torah should be forgotten amongst the
Jewish people. U'v'Yoma d'Hilula
d'Rashbi and therefore on this day which
we call the Hilula of Rashbi, the
yahrzeit of Rebbe Shimon bar Yochai,
yesh koach shel zicharon ha'Torah. There
is a koach There is a spiritual power of
what? Of remembering Torah. Okay, we're
[clears throat] reminded of the
greatness and the holiness and the
secrets of Torah that that Rebbe Shimon
bar Yochai represented. L'vatel
hashikchas ha'Torah sh'nigrama l'yedei
mitas talmidei Rebbe Akiva. And that
that restoration of memory of Torah,
okay? Okay, nullifies all and and
replaces all the Torah that was lost
with the disappearance [snorts]
of the students the first set of
students of Rebbe Akiva. U'v'chein hu
nechama al aveilus. And therefore this
day of Lag B'Omer is a the of nechama of
of consolation
for the mourning that we've been
experiencing during these days
since Pesach up till now. Okay.
Very, very chazak teaching from
um Rav Avraham Schorr. We're now going
to learn, speaking of his father, of
course, we said was the great Rosh
Yeshiva
of Yeshiva Torah Vodaas. So, the the the
person who who served alongside Rav
Gedaliah Schorr and then continued for
decades afterwards as the Mashgiach
Ruchani of Torah Vodaas is Rabbi Moshe
Wolfson, zecher tzaddik livracha,
zechuso yagein aleinu. Rav Moshe
Wolfson, of course, in addition to his
role as the Mashgiach Ruchani in Torah
Vodaas for five-plus decades,
Rav Moshe Wolfson also was a shtikel
Chassidishe Rebbe. He didn't call
himself an Admor, but he had
he had two two two major centers of
Chassidim, uh both in Borough Park,
Brooklyn, his community was called
Emunas Yisrael, and Borough Borough
Borough Park, Brooklyn, as well as here
in Beitar Illit here in Eretz Yisrael.
And Rabbi Wolfson's beautiful sefarim
are known as Emunas Yitzchak. Rabbi
Wolfson is actually buried in the in the
cemetery in Tiberia, where there are
many, many tzaddikim that are buried
there. He just passed away a few years
ago. And if you'll take a look at text
number 10, Rabbi Wolfson, again, we're
continuing to weave this all together.
Rabbi Wolfson is going to teach us a
little bit more about this day of Lag
BaOmer and the significance of Rabbi
Shimon bar Yochai in contrast to the
previous students of Rabbi Akiva. The
Zohar Gam Kein Inyan Shel Lag BaOmer.
Okay. All this
comes to teach us about the main the
main idea of Lag BaOmer. Ki Rabbi Shimon
bar Yochai, Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai
gilashi yesh pnimiyut haTorah. The
rising light. That's Rabbi Shimon bar
Yochai who revealed the inner Torah and
the secrets of the Torah.
Vi'al kol od divrei yesh talin talin
sodot haTorah. And that every letter has
many, many
deep messages, so many secrets within
the entire Torah. So, that's one idea
that
he taught that every letter of the Torah
contained the secrets. It's Shimon bar
Yochai who reveals the idea of the the
inner
messages and secrets of the Torah, okay?
And not only that, what else did he
teach us? And
he taught that every single
has a corresponding
letter in the Torah. Every single one of
us, our
are connected to a particular letter in
the Torah. And if that's true, if we if
we know that every letter has unending
significance and many, many secrets and
unending importance and significance and
every single one of our
every single Jew is connected to one of
those letters, then what does it mean
about the significance of every single
Jew? Listen to what he says. Okay? The
Cain God
of Israel is premium. If every letter
has hidden depth and secrets and
importance beyond just the letter itself
and every Jew, every
is connected to a letter, then that
means that every single Jew has hidden
inner significance, okay? The
soul is
every Jew has incredible, lofty
significance. Shishum Adam Malach Aino
may vino that no human being and not
even an angel, not even the
can begin to comprehend the depth and
importance and significance of every
single member of Israel. Okay?
Lag ba Omer who are taking shelter in
the Rebbe Akiva go cover cover
the other. And therefore, this day of
Lag ba Omer becomes the day of the
fixing for all that was lost, okay, by
this by the great transgression of the
first set of students of Rabbi Akiva.
Shalom now Google
every single one of those first 24,000
students thought what? That their that
their fellow was beneath them and wasn't
important. Okay, only they themselves
were important. No one else mattered but
they themselves. Of
Lag B'Omer but on Lag B'Omer
what's revealed? It's revealed that
every single one of us, okay, has what?
The
has an inner neshama, an inner depth, an
inner significance that is indeed very
very important. Okay.
Just to begin to bring this all
together, we have one more text on our
sheets and then two other short ideas I
want to show that are not on your
sheets. So, we mentioned in the
introduction Rebbe
Rebbe Pinchas Friedman in the Shvilei
Pinchas, he was the one who explained
the significance of the number 12
correlating to the 12 tribes, right? So,
now
he's going to help us begin to cobble
this all together. Text number 11. And
they immediately went forth and they
filled all the Eretz Yisrael with Torah.
He said
uh more meva'er Tziyon Tzion Tzaddek. He
says we it's taught in the it's
explained by the Tziyon Tzaddek, the
Bluzhever Rebbe, Zchuso Yagen Aleinu,
the great Tzaddek, the Bluzhever Rebbe,
Hava Gama Gadol Shel Talmidei Rabbi
Akiva. This is how he explained in his
sefer, the Tziyon Tzaddek, what was the
great deficiency of the students of
Rabbi Akiva.
Listen to the Tziyon Tzaddek's words.
V'einan hu this idea is she'atalmidim
harishonim lo hayu rotzim lanot zeh
lazeh baTorah machmas sin'ah. Okay, the
first set
>> They didn't want to what?
To to bring fulfillment, excitement,
okay? Pleasure to one another by sharing
Torah because why? Because
>> [snorts]
>> None of them wanted to share what they
have learned with each other, what they
have learned from Rabbi Akiva. None of
them, not a single one of those 24,000
students who had learned from Rabbi
Akiva
wanted to what? Share a single word that
they learned from their Rabbi with
anyone else
If that's true because of their hatred
towards one another.
If that's true, perhaps we can
understand the great impediment and
destruction that came as a result of it.
The whole idea of Torah
is what? It's this idea of sharing the
ideas
one through the other going all the way
back generation after generation going
all the way back to Moshe Rabbeinu the
idea of sharing the ideas we've learned
with one another. That's what Torah is
all about.
Okay? And if if we don't do that as the
okay
as the says in Mishlei
Okay, but the tells us that
the Torah is a sense of the words of
Torah are a sense of life to those who
share it share those words and speak
those words.
They have a life.
And
The opposite of this. The
measure
Therefore
they were punished measure for measure
the opposite life came
that's promised to those who promulgate
Torah. So, whether that life is literal
like a literal reading of the story or
whether that life is what?
Fulfilling our purpose in life like the
finish that I shared in the alternative
reading of the story, no matter how you
want to take it, either way we now
understand just how significant the
avera was. It wasn't just that they were
arrogant or they weren't nice each
other. It's they weren't fulfilling as
Rabbi Simon said so vividly, they
weren't fulfilling their purpose. Their
purpose was wasted. All the knowledge
they learned was wasted and was
forgotten and had to disappear and they
either either actually they disappeared
or proverbially what they represented
had to disappear from the world. And
now, just to bring this all together
Now we can understand the famous mantra
of Rabbi Akiva.
This is the essential message, love your
neighbor as yourself. This is the
essential message not of Jewish life but
specifically but Torah.
The specific language of the word Torah
To teach us that what when we learn
Torah It teaches us about intellectual
pursuit but learning Torah has to be a
vehicle through which we fulfill the
mandate of loving our neighbor like
ourselves.
And treating one another with cover with
honor and respect.
To learn
and share Torah with one another. Each
one to the other.
And not to conduct yourselves like the
students of Rebbe Akiva who eyes were
narrow and they did not share Torah's
wisdom with one another. I just want to
close with two two last ideas to bring
this together even further. We're first
going to hear from Rebbe Dovid
of Mikolayev who's one of the top first
generation of talmidim of the Baal Shem
Tov. And Rebbe Dovid of Mikolayev
reminds us that the end of the pasuk it
says "Ve'ahavta lere'acha kamocha."
Okay? That the pasuk ends with the words
"Ani Hashem." Love your neighbor like
yourself. "Ani Hashem." I am Hashem. So
listen to how
the Rebbe Dovid
of Mikolayev interprets that pasuk. "Im
oheiv atah es re'acha Yehudi vechosheiv
atah baleiv tameim ki hu kamocha." If
you love your fellow Jew and always
think in your heart that he is he is
pure just like you, "Omeditzcha
bemadreigah achas." He stands on the
same level as you.
"Lo she'atah gavoha mimenu ve'oleh al al
uma'aloso." Meaning not that you're
better than them or more accomplished in
learning or in or in your personal
achievements, "Ela shehu omed imcha
yachad." But rather he stands together
with you. "Be'ezel
al yad tzeiv beshurah achas." You're
standing together on the same level, in
the same row.
"As beshnei." Now see that he spoke in
Yiddish, okay? It's important to
understand he spoke in Yiddish. "As
beshnei Yidden." Meaning two Jews, okay?
That the word Yidden with a kind of a
Yiddish havarah could mean either two
Jews or also what? Two Yuds. Okay? The
word Yud, if you have a heavy Yiddish
accent you say not a Yud you say Yeed.
Okay? Well Yeed means either a Jew or
you could it could mean the letter Yud.
So he says, "If you have two Yidden
ke'eilu that are so aligned and unified
with one another, okay? Shahavat
v'
gam
that they have complete and complete
equity and equality and love for each
other. The love they have for each other
is completely the same one towards the
other. Surely
then what then they merit to have
amongst them Ami Hashem that Hashem is
there. Why? Because those
two Yidden
okay? Those two Yuds together form the
name of what? Two Yuds are what?
Hashem's name.
So the possuk itself
gives us the recipe says
of understanding what V'ahavta
L'Rei'acha Kamocha is really all about.
I just want to close with one last
beautiful teaching from the option of
Rebbi that really brings together
everything we learned about Rebbi Akiva
and his students and Rebbi Shimon bar
Yochai and everything that Rebbi Shimon
bar Yochai represents.
So just listen to these these few lines.
Yesh L'Havie Madua
Asech
me Rebbi Akiva. Yes on Lag B'Omer why do
we celebrate more Rebbi Shimon bar
Yochai not Rebbi Akiva? Okay? People
that maybe some people do make their way
that's to to Tiveria after going to
Meron to visit Rebbi Akiva's kever but
most people go to Meron. They don't they
go
on Lag B'Omer. How and he's asked the
question further he compounds the
question even further he says how low
Rebbi Akiva Rebbi Akiva was
Rebbi Shimon bar Yochai's Rebbi. And he
said Kibel Torah many when he received
his Torah from Rebbi Akiva. So Rebbi
Shimon's Torah is so great that we're
going to Rebbi Shimon then who else
should we be celebrating even more?
Rebbi Akiva.
Ulam
he says Itar de K'Sh'velo Moshe Rabbeinu
Sinai. Now he says we're going to learn
this from a Medrash about Moshe Rabbeinu
that when Moshe Rabbeinu came down from
Har Sinai, lamad kodem im Aharon. First
and he again, Moshe Rabbeinu learned
Torah from from Hakadosh Baruch Hu Pi
Gurah from Hashem himself. And who does
he learn with first? Who does he share
what he's learned with first? First with
Aharon. V'achar kach l'vanav and then to
his children. Who was the kehilla? And
then to the zekeinim, the elders.
V'achar kach achar kach l'chol Yisrael.
Then and only then, once he's kind of
had a chance to share it with his
trusted inner circle, then it's
disseminated to the rest of the Jewish
people.
That the Torah that Moshe Rabbeinu
learned in the heavens was too great.
Was beyond human comprehension.
And therefore was too much. It would be
beyond it would be be beyond the
capacity of the Jewish people to accept
and to learn. Okay? He first had to
what? Refine that message. And talk to
his inner circle. And by refining that
message, then and only then could the
lofty ideas that he learned in heaven,
Moshe Rabbeinu learned mi Pi Gurah, be
shared with the rest of the Jewish
people. In kein,
And so therefore first he had to do
exactly that. He learned first with
Aharon. And then he had to learn with
the zekeinim and his sons. And by
refining that message, then and only
then was it distilled in a way that the
Jewish people would be able to
comprehend and grasp. Okay?
And we can learn the same thing and say
the same things as the option of Rabbi
about the Torah of Rabbi Akiva. Hayah
gavoha yoter midai. It was on such a
high level. Okay? V'rak al yedei Shimon
bar Yochai.
And only because he passed it out
through Shimon bar Yochai, who by the
way, himself had to spend 12 years in a
cave. He comes out of the cave and he
starts and he's so immersed in continued
learning that he comes out and he's
burning up everything in the world that
he has to go back in the cave for
another 12 months in order to what?
Refine that messaging himself. Okay?
It's only because
he passed through Rabbi Akiva, passes on
through Rashbi
and Rashbi continues to work on it and
refine it.
Then and only then, because Rabbi Shimon
bar Yochai distills it and and refines
it, that that we're able to learn the
Torah of Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai in the
same way that
uh that Aaron and others were able to
what? To distill and refine the Torah
of Moshe Rabbeinu and therefore, even
though Rabbi Akiva is indeed
the master, okay? It's Rabbi Shimon bar
Yochai who refines those lofty messages,
those lofty heavenly ideas, those ideas
that might be beyond human simple human
comprehension and makes the secrets of
Torah, the inner messages of Torah
accessible to the Hamon Am. He distills
those messages that he learned from
Rabbi Akiva, he works on himself for 12
years and then another 12 months, for 13
years before he's able to finally refine
those messages and share those lofty
ideas with all of Klal Yisrael. So, as
we prepare for the awesome awesome day
of Lag BaOmer, now that we've got a
little bit of understanding, it's not
just a day, yes, it's fun to go have a
barbecue and whatever we do on Lag
BaOmer, but now that we have a little
bit more of a depth of understanding,
let's each of us, please be blessed to
merit to be mekayem the mitzvah of
v'ahavta l'rei'acha kamocha as we're
meant to, that the Torah that we've
learned together today and and every day
should inspire us to share that Torah
with others, even if we only know aleph,
as we learn from the Lubavitcher Rebbe,
may his merit be a shield upon us, that
we have an obligation to share aleph
with someone else, and so doing, we will
fulfill the mitzvah of "V'ahavta
l'reacha kamocha", "Zeh klal gadol
baTorah". We will continue to distill,
and refine, and share the legacy of
Rabbi Akiva with the entire world. Have
a great Shabbos.